Added: 1 month ago
From: straightupswede
Views: 51,392
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (143)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Naya has an unique voice and so does Amber. I really like time both! I think most people just want to have naya's voice to be noticed more, because Amber already has been noticed by many artist so yeah.

  • OH MY GOD I JUST DIED webugwieuvbkyjsfkbd,kj

    does anyone have whole video...

  • The trouble is it sounds funky because I'm used to hearing the recorded version where Amber is louder.

  • these 2 need to sing more i mean listening to Naya sing "We Found Love" and also Amber's songs they are amazing, i just wish it wasn't all about Rachel the majority of the time

  • I do not understand what the problem is both a way of singing is unique and different that makes them special and incredible singing has to choose

  • I love Amber's voice and it beats Naya a lot. She has no voice, she sings but not that good

  • Naya...although I love her...it's not versatile voice. I don't think you guys know what that means. She can't sing every style such as broadway. GTFOH. It's her tone you're in love with. It's distinctive. NOT her versatility. Amber's voice is versatile as she is able to sing "Favorite Things" & Songs such as this. But, as great as she is, her tone is one we've heard before. But they both are very incredible in what they do, which is why THESE argument SHOULD FUCKING END.

  • Where is the whole performance? Please does somebody have it?

  • WUT!!! i dint know this performance exist omg i need the full performance RIGHT NOW PLEASE

  • to me, the very beginning did not sound good at all because they were off from each other, but once they seperated out, they both sounded amazing :)

  • @jen7121993 that's exactly my opinion. (:

  • They are bot gorgeous and have amazing voices. <3

  • Not Amber's best. Naya plain incredible!!!!

  • Oh!!! And she has more Power too!

  • Why do people act like Naya is the only one singing??? Yes she's prettier, has a more commercial voice, and plays a lesbian. But!! Amber has a better voice!! She has way more range AND control! Gosh, let's give credit where credit is due! This preferential treatment just solidifies what I've been feeling about this generation's music: it's all about appearance, talent comes Last. ~rant over ~lol

  • Comment removed

  • @HyperAmygdala I can agree with you to some extent. Yes, Amber has an amazing voice and can probably reach higher notes than Naya, but there is no excitment to it; no mystery. It's a great voice, but Naya has this tone to her voice that drags you in and makes it interesting to listen to her. I'd rather listen to her because of the feeling of mystery her voice has compared to Ambers, even though Amber probably has more training and what you call a "better" voice.

  • @straightupswede well said. something about Naya's voice is far more interesting than Ambers. Don't get me wrong, i blast try a little tenderness and ain't no way in my car because i think amber is amazing and does an amazing job on gospel music, but at the end of the day i believe Naya has the most versatile voice of the female cast and the fact that she can sound good regardless of genre makes her my favorite.

  • @straightupswede i can understand what hyperamygdala is saying though, i love naya and ambers voice, but credit should be where credit is due...sometimes i will see a glee cast doing an interview and then the top comment will be like "naya is soo talented" but they are interviewing someone like Kevin Mchale heheh

  • Naya's voice makes me want to take off my clothes

  • its funny how no1 noticed naya until santana's storyline with Brittany... i loved her from the day she came out in the nurse's outfit in season 1 :)

  • @samirhym That was season 2 :)

  • Comment removed

  • Naya!!!!!!!

  • Naya <3

  • Naya has cute hair:)

    And an amazing voice.

  • Naya was gorgeous!

  • Guise, it's not about who is 'the better' singer. It's about preference.

    I love both of 'em. They're my twee favorites on glee. I feel like the rest shouldn't even be allowed to open their mouths.

    Still though, I enjoy Naya's voice more. It's like I hear something I've never heard before. A kind of secret ingredient maybe?

    Having said that, Amber probably has the "better" voice. She obviously has a wider range and more control. Music, however, isn't always about rules and techniques and crap.

  • I don't think Naya signs better than Amber, I just like her voice more, and I think that's what people mean when they say they like the way Naya sings better. Technically, I'm guessing Amber is the better singer because she seems to have better range, control, and power.

  • True story I get pregnant every time I hear Naya sing O.o

  • @randamir12 Holy crap! How many kids do u have already?

  • I like them both as singers. Amber has a more power house/gospel voice, but Naya has a more unique/versatile voice. Not at all to take away from Ms. Amber's versatility.

  • Nobody cares who is singing the melody or harmony. Nobody really cares who sings better. We all are just focused on how attractive naya really is

  • Well Adele heard them sing and thanked Amber and said that she'd buy her cd if she put out one. What did she say to/about Naya?

  • @curlskinksandcoils She probably asked Naya to marry her.

  • @straightupswede

    Adele actually heard Amber's version of "someone like you" that was posted early 2011 and commented that she would love to buy Amber's album bc she thought she sounded great. She made no mention of Naya cause that duet wasn't even recorded yet.

  • I'm in love with naya @_@

  • Both were amazing. But naya... Dang that girls voice just gives me the chills!

  • they're both amazing. but if you listen carefully, Amber is a little sharp in her pitch compared to Naya. oh well.

  • Everyone is saying that Naya is better than Amber, but did you all know that Amber is singing the melody (higher part) and Naya is singing the harmony (lower part)?

  • you guys just like naya more thats all

  • amber riley has a cover of someone like you alone, its spectacular! they should have let her sing the whole thing on glee, although nayas voice is beautiful, its not better than amber rileys

  • Naya is so attractive.

  • Naya has the best voice!

  • I think I'm not the only one who thinks that Naya's voice is definitely the best on Glee, right?

  • Naya is more Adele!!! she must do a solo :)

  • i love her hands while she's singing!

  • Naya is perfecttttttt

  • Naya needs to sing someone like you full version alone.. it will be the best thing ever

  • Naya! <3

  • i dont want to say one is better than the other. they are both amazing in such different ways. its like apples and oranges you cant compare them <3

  • @tvlover127 This. I think they're both amazing and it's all a matter of personal preference. I personally prefer Naya's voice because there's more light and shade in it.

  • Idk, they both are great. Though I prefer Naya's voice I think Amber's is more powerful.

  • amber is a way better singer than naya! and im throwin shade to those who think amber isn't

  • Omg..!! naya sounds really good live...

  • They both sang amazingly, but it just didn't sound that amazingly together. At least the first few seconds. When they weren't singing together, it was amazing. You can actually hear that Naya has more volume in her voice here. In River Deep Mountain High, Amber seemed to have the more powerful voice. I love this.

  • I hope they'll sing this song in the next Glee Live Tour

  • Amber has the better voice out of the two. But Naya still has a beautiful voice.

  • I love Naya. I'm watching this to watch her

  • Nothing more to say than "No One Can beat Naya"

    She is such the bets singer and actress EVER

  • Amber is definitely the "better" singer. Her voice is impeccable, and her range is amazing. Amber could outshine Naya in a competition of Vocal Runs any day! No Shade to Naya, her voice is... cute.

  • Being a vocal coach, I have to say. Naya was too flat. Amber is stunning

  • Naya is amazing!

  • They both sing in pitch, it's just that Naya sings it the way Adele sings it live too, a tad lower, and Amber is singing it as Adele sings it on the record... And together it doesn't sound good, I still love these ladies tho:)

  • amber sonds really pitchy in this :/...naya is the one stayin in key. love em both as singers dont get me wrong, but this isnt their best.

  • haha Ambers face when she watches Naya sing its like... oh no you didnt just sing better than me haha love it.. love Naya <3

  • where did this happen?

  • OMG!! where was that ??

  • full performance please please please!!!

  • I needo the full performance!!

  • They're both awesome let's leave it at that.

  • In what world Naya's a better singer than Amber talk to me when Naya can pull off Aretha Franklin or Whitney Houston.

  • @Zinga1991 it's about preference. amber could belt all her notes but i prefer naya's and her versatility.

  • @aazzar Amber Riley does more then belt notes she can sing beautifully in her lower register just like on Human Nature are powerhouse range she's very versatile.i also like Naya Rivera voice too.I guess some people don't know Amber sung Someone like you all by her self way before the song was ever thought to be on glee with belting either!

  • @Zinga1991 i did actually. i watched her cover, she's amazing but how she started the song and her technique throws me off. and i instantly missed naya's raspy voice.

    all props to amber though but yeah, agree to disagree i guess. :))

  • @aazzar The truth is if it wasn't for Amber Riley not singing this song on the internet it would've never been on Glee.Adele saw the video of Amber singing her song and then emailed Amber telling her that she wanted Amber to sing her song on the show,then Ryan Murphy agreed to let Amber and Naya sing the song.

  • @Zinga1991 But could Amber riley pull off Amy Winehouse as good, no because they have different types of voices and sounds. I'm not saying Amber riley isn't good, in fact when she sang Ain't no way on Glee, it was amazing, but I think you can't take it away from Naya Rivera that she has a great voice too. These two along with Lea Michele are definately the best singers on the show and I think Naya Rivera is one of the best actors on the show too.

  • @RdGean Amber can sing anything so I'm sure she could pull off Amy Winehouse and yes, Naya Rivera and Lea Michele are amazing vocalist as well. I do agree hands down Naya Rivera is the best actress on the show.

  • @Zinga1991 if you're going into argument on who can "sing anything", then it'll be Lea over Amber anyday. What we're pointing out to you is we love Naya's voice, her type of voice, not her range because we all know it's limited. What she can't do, she makes it up with her versatility and technique. I love her technique.

  • @aazzar Sorry I have seen Amber Riley sing many times truly an outstanding vocalist.This is no argument fact Amber can sing anything.

  • naya naya naya naya naya!!!!!!!!!oh god....im going crazy

  • so beautful

  • I think Naya is so much better... Naya and Lea are the best singers in Glee :)<3

  • Naya, be mine

  • I think Naya is a better singer than Amber....

  • @lanaspiler7 Oh honey, we all do :)

  • @straightupswede I love Amber bit I couldn't agree more with You. Naya has perfect voice :]

  • @straightupswede i dont think we should judge etheir because there both amazing

  • @straightupswede I think Amber is the BEST SINGER EVER so...

  • @straightupswede  INCORRECT !

  • @straightupswede I don't... I love Naya, but Amber's voice... DAMN.

  • @straightupswede

    Not all of us.

  • @lanaspiler7 I think you're smokin' crack...their both amazing singers, just in different ranges, why does everything always have to be a contest

  • @lanaspiler7 no that's amber the best :p

  • @lanaspiler7 That was funny. I think exactly the opposite and so many people.

  • @lanaspiler7 Are you deaf? No seriously are you Amber is about a million times better

  • they did the two versions of the song all in one

  • they so good

  • uhhhhh..what was that??

  • D: mercedes D:

  • @DPMINIW5 you're an idiot, over analyzing.. The harmonized..end of story. Lol u guys are nuking this so hardcore

  • oooooooohhhhhhh Nayaaaaaaaaaaa!!!! nooooooooooooooooo... plaase noooooooooo more..... noooooooooooooooo.... noooooooooooooooooo.NOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ..

    ....

    ....

    ....

    I'm dead

  • TE AMO NAYAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

  • She's the perfect alto!! So charming

  • @ParkerScene If your talking about Naya Rivera she is actually a Contralto,Amber Riley is a Mezzo Soprano.The Alto on Glee Dianna Agron.

  • @Zinga1991 either way, its like comparing apple to oranges, they each bring something different, and together they're amazing

  • @ParkerScene Agreed!

  • this is great!!im really looking for video that naya sings live..

  • AMAZING:)

  • omgomgomg <3

  • Where I can find full song?

  • love naya!

    

  • It's amazing! I needo the full performance!!

  • I love the faces they make when they sing lmao!

    Also, this better be on the tour this year man!

  • --- Why was Amber was harmonizing the Naya's solo part "Don't forget me, I beg" at the beggining? Naya part is so perfect. I know they both sound good together but their differences is what makes them sound so good. Please Amber leave Naya's part alone next time..love you still.

    ...Naya's look at :12 kind of says it all, Naya knows that Amber sounded off (imho)

  • @cofuggle Amber was singing Naya's part because Naya can't do it, obviously. Amber can.

  • @pasteliitaah LOL!! are you one of those fans with a super hero complex that needs to defend somebody? ughhhh, btw I love Amber but the beggining was off ,I checked the original mash off song and compared.Amber was singing Naya's part. If you pay attention Naya IS SINGING HER PART!! and doing a hell of a job!!

  • @cofuggle OF COURSE Amber was singing Naya's part. Don't you get it? They are bouth doing the same freaking part but with a different tone! If you really hear Naya you can tell that she was singing in a lower tone, and Amber was doing the higher. I don't know why they did it like this but don't say crap like ''are you one of those fans with a super hero complex that needs to defend somebody?'' xd

  • @pasteliitaah you sound angry Batman

  • @pasteliitaah @cofuggle Guys Naya was just singing it the way Adele sings it when she does this live. Naya wasn't singing Amber's part because there WAS no "Amber's part" during that line.

  • @pasteliitaah um the awkward moment when your wrong, naya is one of the best singers on that show sooo yeah

  • @Samiii15 Never said she wasn't. Sooo yeah.

  • @cofuggle number 1 naya couldnt do naya's part sometimes what yout do in studio is not what you can do live at all naya did that range the whole way through that part and naya was the same way when she sung valerie with darren her key was wayyyyy of but it's trying to get the harmonies right amber is the greatest singer on glee everybody said it already and if u wanna here perfection checkout amber singing the whole song on youtube she doesnt even have to try to hit the high range at all

  • @DOMINIW5 Tell' em they better go watch Amber Riley sing the whole song by herself way before the song was ever thought to be on Glee.

  • @DOMINIW5 in valerie with darren "her key was wayyyy of", i would just like to point out that instruments should always adjust to the singer's voice. i really love that acoustic version but darren singing the higher tone ruined it.

  • voglio l'intera prestazione T.T

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • OMG amazing!

  • i hope they'll sing it on the next tour <3

  • Love.

  • Amber is a goddess. A flawless goddess.

  • oh naya ... i know i am one of many but .... you are a dream :)

  • Naya why you so perfect?!

  • I love seeing them live!

  • aaww I really need to see the whole song! Naya is amazing!

  • I love how she moves her hand when she sings (:

  • ON REPEAT!

  • Dear Naya Rivera....I think I'm in love haha

  • wow, too bad you don't have the whole thing ... so awesome <3

  • I need the whole song to survive, haha :-D But thanks for this.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more