Selena Gomez & The Scene-A Year Without Rain-live@ Ellen(09/22/10)

[gracecatherine12]

amazing!



[precious020]

she always looks so pretty and we need to stop trying to choose her career and life for her she can do that for herself

[honmae25]

my question is...why would she record a song that's too high for her when she would'nt actually sing it that way?

[luv2dance1806]

i actually honestly dont think shes that bad, like okay, she sounds different on the cd, but she sounds DIFFERENT, not WORSE. I don't know what u guys are on about :)

[princeibz1]

Look ,,, she gave the high note at 2:34 ... you've really improved SEL :P

[princeibz1]

haters think that hating her can make them sing good , get real guyz ,,, she's way better than you so stop judjing her and give her a chance to improve :P

[princeibz1]

She isn't that bad :P

[ariana26yamile2]

I love you selena but you cant sing!

[imhaniz]

Beautiful. She can sing, haters. Why are you if you dont like her singing? Idiots -.-

[vdenisa96]

this song is harder then " I love you like a love song" but she sing this better then that. ( better is a vague term)

[CreatesGamer]

breath-breath-breath

thats it!

[1slashey]

love you selena <33333333

[flapjunk]

She hits one decent notes at 2:33... that's it...

[karinaalmarazalmaraz]

[Thumbs up!] if you think this to people on the, top comments' should just STFU and GTFO. ..this place is only for the people who love selena just the way she is<3

[hahapleasel97]

she sounds like shes scared to hit the high notes

[fluffy6775]

@hahapleasel97 lol i noticed she doesn't even sing the high notes sum times she'll use autotune or lip sync

[minou1206]

she's good, stop hating.

[MUFFINaddicted]

VERY GOOD JOB, BACKUP SINGERS.

[Justme91ification]

Thumps up if you agree that Selena is getting better in singing and if someone has a dream he or she should be allowed to live it. If she wants to sing let her sing and damn it stop saying she should stick up at acting thats not your problem. Have you ever heard Britney Spears singing live?? And Britney is just an example there are a lot of singers who cant sing and sound good in records and Selena can at least sing maybe her voice is not as strong as Christina Aguileras but she can still sing.

[TheMovieLoverz]

Thumbs up if you think the top comment should have the correct grammar.

[Welovewatermelon1]

she breath so loud 

[Jrr723]

@Nizinha7 or what ever your name is. Just because someone disagrees with you doesnt mean that you need to bash them. And i personally dont notice her breathing heavily, and if she then it is probably because she is nervous then her heart speeds up needing more oxygen anyway. Just please me kind and civil in your opinion.

[superstar12397]

she keeps breathe into the mic.

[mimziiexchu]

I really think she'd do a lot better if she had more power in her voice.

[peacelovesugersnap]

i love u selena

[90querico]

i hate that she goes flat when she is supposed to sing high notes!

[twilightnskittlez]

Oh please! You try to sing live in front of hundreds of people and she's only a young adult, give her a break. 2:35 was just great so how can she 'suck'? I wouldn't go to those extremes. Don't get me wrong I can admit that she's not a strong performer but she can still sing. And atleast her songs have meaning and depth unlike all these 'cool' songs about sex and what not. Even the best singers get nervous and sound absolutely awful so just chill.

[TheKiiks1]

@twilightnskittlez Yeah.. Good bless autotune XD

[imloverable]

Just let the girl live her dreams when she is singing her songs live it is good but other people's who have a powerful voice she needs to work on

[ChrrisSyY34]

Selena is a very talented person singing n acting wise, i dont kno why ppl say she cannot sing. Do research before sayin she cannot. Many singers out there that sound bad live, also it depends where she sings meaning outside inside weather techincal problems which makes it sound not good n bcuz she young she gets nervous to make it her best to impress US her FANS. She a wonderful amazing beautiful talented caring person. I -3 everything bout her

[valcool0499]

i love you selena gomez you are super!!!!! justin and you you are the cuttest couple in the world!!!! i love you both!!!! sorry for mistakes i'm a frech girl... :)<3

[canadagirl657]

i know why she doesn't sound good singing live, and everybody has it at one point, she gets nervous, don't picking on her for being nervous!

[rockprincess5595]

i dont know why everyone says she cant sing, i mean she's alright compared to most artists out there today so if you're gonna complain i say you start doing it to those artists too.

[smexxiboi55]

@rockprincess5595 no most artists are better, but she's still not that good.

[mounishachamarthy]

does she only sing in ellen shows ? does she have any concerts ?

[eliana8425]

AND a bit is to little for a STAR.

[eliana8425]

it´s unfair coz there are so many great singers in the world that aren´t famous bt if they really want they´re gonna make it ;) and the refrain wasn´t live. coz it was too good to be live and when she sings the refrain live it sounds more aweful.so i think therefrain wasn´t live but guys don´t take me wrong. i actually like her. her personality her DEEP laugh ^^ and her ACTING so i´m just saying . she can´t sing very well. maybe a bit but just a bit

[PetraGomezBiebs]

I think Selena should stick to acting. She does not have a strong voice like Miley & Demi. She sounds good on record bcuz she autotunes her songs. She acts better than Miley & Demi. & she should stick to her acting career. Her singing career gets her most of the hate. She can't sing life. No offense to big fans of her. :S

[Shockwave474]

@PetraGomezBiebs You are entitled to your own opinion, but "no offense" is a really tacky thing to say, so leave it out next time. Oh, yeah, and I LOVE her singing.

[bobo007regele]

I think the guitar player's backing vocals were better than selena

[FanRebaMcentire]

EVERY ARTIST IS BETTER THAN THIS CLOWN!!!!!

[xxcelinexx2]

@FanRebaMcentire that's not true justin bieber is worser

she's not so super good but she can sing!

demi lovato is still better :D

[JBluvsLindshei]

SELENA!!!!,,, you are great!!! great performance!!

[lulunumber111]

@JBluvsLindshei NO CUZ SHE CANT SING

[roliletea]

@lulunumber111 Agreed. :D

[JustPrima]

omg, she can't sing...

[Cvetelina95]

yeah i know..xDD

[MultiHazna]

can u feel me when i think about u.... my answer is not

[Valerie217]

@xdrumsticx2 I can also hear her breathing louder than her singing. :P

[xdrumsticx2]

She went off pitch a couple of times, enough said. She needs a hell lot of practice.

[tashbaybee100]

@candywandy100 shut up

[Fabulousdarling6]

I LOVE this song.. :D

[Cooketaa]

omygosh.. she can't sing in live :S

[loverforver111]

2:21 - 2:24 she sounded awfull.. No offense !

[star10197]

She sounds ok. But there are undiscovered people who sing WAY better thatn her. For example Christina Grimme. That girl can sing!!

[Syzelia]

She doesn't have the presence or the movement that makes her look comfortable on stage. And she's so quiet :$

[Lilacprincessette]

she has a good voice so shut up and don't comment if you have nothing good or nice to say! she's pretty and she has an amazing voice!!

[locaroncha17]

WAY better than before. Enough said....

[ImAnEviilGirl2469]

is it just me or at 1:58 when she suddenly breaks into a smile.. its er... very creepy .... O_o

[katherinevillumsen]

Thumbs up if you think selena should lurn to breath :-) <3

[coolgirly03]

@katherinevillumsen I think that you should learn typing at first XD

[katherinevillumsen]

@coolgirly03 I am from Denmark what do you expect? im not perfect... sorry for that :'(

[rustydevilll]

@katherinevillumsen

Thumbs up if you think this idiot should learn how to spell.

[katherinevillumsen]

@rustydevilll sorry :'( im from Denmark what do you expect?

[rustydevilll]

@katherinevillumsen thats okay :-) her breathing is okay she just needs to breathe away from her mic and not in it.

[katherinevillumsen]

@rustydevilll yes :-)

will you please go on my channel and watch my videos and let a comment below? thank you so much :D glad that you accept me :D

[AnetaBabii]

@katherinevillumsen She is breathin normally !!! dats how de song is ment to be sang .. she is brilliant live !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[katherinevillumsen]

@AnetaBabii everyone has different opinions so relax :-)

[AnetaBabii]

@katherinevillumsen Yah I was just telling you .. she breaths normally :)

[OoCrazzzyoO]

@katherinevillumsen bless her, she needs breathing lessons :/

[crazymiley98]

@katherinevillumsen thumbs up if you think @katherinevillumsen should learn english:)

agrree with you that she has to learn to breathe

[katherinevillumsen]

@crazymiley98 im so sorry? im from Denmark and im only 14. what do you expect?

sorry :'(

[crazymiley98]

@katherinevillumsen I', 14 too... xxx

sorry if it offended you :// xx

she actually needs to take breathing lessons xx

[katherinevillumsen]

@crazymiley98 thanks :) but im from Denmark and we are not talking english :)

she is breathing in the mic and that sounds wierd ;) please watch my cover :)

[mak97fury]

@crazymiley98 selena cant sing live... ;// she breathes in the mic, she cant hit the high notes and at certain parts its like shes talking rather than singing ;s

[fluffy6775]

@katherinevillumsen lol i don't get y she's famous . ohh yeah cuz of her show and ppl think she's funny but she didn't write the script . ugh i hate untalented ppl . hey i can't sing... why aren't i famous?

[katherinevillumsen]

@fluffy6775 what are you talking about??? it's because she is breathing so laud after every word hehe I lov selena? what are you talking about being famous??? wtf?

[xmademoisellle]

She's just another pretty face. She doesn't deserve half the fame she gets. She CAN sing, but not very good at all. The song is catchy, but she just sang it. Eh.

[Biebergurl2013]

ppl are stupid she has a gret voice live :)

[JOMO997]

@Biebergurl2013 it's not about the voice... she doesnt dance like others.... she stands there in ONE place... and when she sings "a year without raaaaiin" you can hear it's different which means it's thin... and she doesnt hold it for very long

[briskywithoutadoubt]

She's not bad but just needs practice and time

[Nizinhah7]

Everyone, we all must agree that Selena Gomez just sucks live. Come on she does ! And no this is not about Justin Bieber, its just i think she should stick up at acting because i think she is better. Without Disney she would be nothing. Im not hating i just think she should do that. Thumbs up if you agree, :-)

[x0xSaviix0x]

@Nizinhah7 It really depends on the video. if you listen to radio disneys live version of who says, it's actually really really good. it really really depends.

[Nizinhah7]

@x0xSaviix0x i know its just weird

[AnetaBabii]

@Nizinhah7 How does she suck ???? listen to her singing nd den listen to lyk britney spears that cant sing for her life .. cuz britney lip sings everytime she sings anythin not only live .. nd selena is not lip singin .. her voice is just perfect nd yhur just JEALUSE !!!!! .. nd if yhu think she sucks .. your de one who sucks .. :)

[Nizinhah7]

@AnetaBabii First of all who talked about britney spears? o.o Second go learn proper english then we can talk. Im not jealous hunny I said Im not hating ! Im saying the truth. Oh hun one more thing, you're probably a brained washed 9 year old girl. jfs.

[lauraleemathurin]

@Nizinhah7 i love her but really she sucks live no affence selena i love u

[1slashey]

@Nizinhah7 your just jelouss ;)

[lovebugg133]

fuk u alll that say that selena gomez is bad cuz i bet u guys cant do better and those who say they can are just saying that but really u cant so shut the fuk up u jerks

[xxxsykeeeeeexxx]

......and i thought Rebecca Black was bad.

[prettyxKittyx]

@xxxsykeeeeeexxx RB isn't even comparable. That's a whole new level of suck.

[kitkatsweetie15]

@xxxsykeeeeeexxx nice

[CYBORGJGL1]

I liked this performance, and the bass too i wanna play it xD

[leizelie]

Uh, I don't know. I actually like Selena's voice.

[Mziluv2sing]

y does she always big things in here ears thumbs up if u noticed:)

[anne54123]

hey dont say she stinks she is better than rebecca black !

[SuperAnrob]

i dont mind how sing¡¡¡¡ i love her

[SunnyGomez1]

she's out of breathe every line she sings : /

[amandaseyfried22]

I can see how much she loves singing<3

[angel7monster]

Selena can sing but she needs help with it. She sounds like she's out of breathe too quickly and her voice is too low or quiet. But she still sings okay though.

[amandaseyfried22]

@angel7monster the sound of her voice is so beautiful!

[Bittersweet21222]

@BrenSource duh. lol auto tune!

[videoaddic]

i love her but she cant cant hit the notes i think i can sing better

[georgialove64]

selena your really pretty and i love your music but tbh you can not sing live sorry<3 but i love you anyway x

[sharistripez]

She is gorgeous. This was actually one of het best performances so idk why ppl are saying she can't sing in this video???

[xxcandygirl84xx]

she can sing, but it is not perfect... But DAMN she's beautiful!!! And she is a good actress too! <3 I'm saying it as a girl ;P

[Tinkerrbel]

omg...she can't sing in tune ==

[TheLerosey]

lol, she has a lot of ahters, prob all jb fans...

[Cutziloank]

she should stick to acting

[GymDinky12]

She may nt be de best singer but lads she looks lyk shes havin a great tym up there singin Go selena

[jessieiscool97]

she can really sing but i think it sometimes sound less then she can because she is nervous which is normal. she is a great actrice and singer. she acts great in wizards of waferly place.

[4leafclover23]

shes a better acter then singer...but shes kinda good at singing tho

[MaddyHyams]

@candywandy UP TOP! That's what i say!

[candywandy100]

idk.. only time can tell.. btw demi lovato is also awesome.

[beautifulme1999]

honestly, whats ur point of saying she cant sing?maybe its just her passion at least she trys.. i WILL always idolize her forever... SELLY FOREVAH!!

[LeahKristi1994]

i think she's a better actress than a singer but i must admit i love this song x

[gagalover23]

She sings Good but she need to learn to control the nerves that get her

[fuerzaparsel]

♫ A tear's Pikachu is like a fear without pain.... ♫

[fuerzaparsel]

If you see minute 1:00 to 1:09 you can see that her voice is playback ¬¬

[bvt45e]

too all the haters... atleasts she actually sings live! hardly any artists nowadays sing live!

[ampikay]

she do have a good voice..... but her singing.... is not really good. yes she may sound good ... but you can still hear the difference of her singing here and the official mv of a year without rain

[BlueberriesAtDawn]

She's awesome at the chorus :D

[jennynguyenerrs12]

It's not like she can't COMPLETELY sing . shes trying her best and if she loves doing what she does then support her, why do you have to hate her ? You guys are so pathetic. Btw, selena doesnt get attention for her singing skills, its for her acting so idk why you people are calling her fake.

[missipire]

I Dont Hate Her But She Seemed Pretty Proud Of Herself When He Hit The 'High' Note :)

BTW: YOU PPLZ ARE SO IMMATURE 2 HATE HER JUST BECAUSE SHE PROBLY RUINED YOUR CHANCES OF BEING WIT JB :D

[ipodnano4eva]

@dontMarshmyMellow it's 'cause everyone hates her because she's with justin bieber! lol so immature

[dontMarshmyMellow]

i think she sounded good here, whats up with all the haters?

[1EmilyBelle]

i like her singing, but i think its to weak and scrony...............

[2537mai]

awesome!

[NukaCola15]

i love her and her music, but she really doesnt sound that well live

[karelybby]

wackkkkk!

[heyitslizzie4]

i love selena gomez SO SO SO much she is an amazing actresss and everything, but she struggles to sing, like she cant hit the high notes cos she doesnt know how to project her high notes yet, i think she should stick to acting ahah <33

[evtsandrasbveninde]

i dont understand why she's using her light voice in the high notes. the other half part of the song, she hits them like that! its not a prob i dont understand :D but she's amazing <3

[TheEmilySelena]

Man Shes Good She Can Hold Notes!!

[dimitar221]

i love selly gomez and i love her songs

[ThePrincessK25]

I like Selena but that doesnt sound like her voice at all :/

[SischVEVO]

THIS GIRL CANT SING.!

[THEMissHollyDolly]

0:38 awkward :\ but i love her anyway :D

[Joshye10]

@Candywandy100

Maybe if she actually did something beside sing in her room shed be somewhere but sadly shes a nobody and so are you

[candywandy100]

@Joshye10 mean much, but i wont stoop to your level and argue with you...

[Joshye10]

@candywandy100 lol im just saying, your the one who was calling selena fake!

[kta2100]

que fea ropa

[candywandy100]

Christina Grimmie sings SOOOO much better than her and she doent get half the attention selena gets! so everyone please support her instead of SELENA. she's so.. fake!

[kayeAlanis]

@candywandy100 why are you even saying that? Selena worked hard that's why she's so famous right now, Christina will have her time, you can't tell Selena that she's a fake because she's not copying anybody, you also can not force anybody to NOT support her, because we love her. My point is Christina will have her time and you can not compare them to one another.

[Joshye10]

@candywandy100

Christina doesnt get that much attention cause she doesnt have albums, tv show, movies, clothing line and she is uglyy!!!!!!! How would you even know if selenas fake? do you know her? i didnt think so, get over yourself.

[Famousfights]

@candywandy100 FUCK YOU

[shantilicous]

@candywandy100 shout the hell up

[TiiMM0TAY]

@candywandy100 dang stop hating

[candywandy100]

@TiiMM0TAY i'm not hating... just voicing out! leave me alowne for goodness' sake :@

[AnaCatarinaMP96]

@candywandy100 :o

OMG

Selena is so much better than christinna

[JOMO997]

@candywandy100 personally... i dont really think christina grimmie sings good... i really think miley has the best voice, i mean, she never lip syncs, she dances, and sings good live :D

[rustydevilll]

@candywandy100

how do you know she is fake? you don't know her.

[darjathekid]

sing louder for gods sakes!!

[HazzaWazza91]

shes fucking amazing and so beautiful, how can anyone hate her seriously?

[tooooooooooooota]

@HazzaWazza91 and she's so down to earth .. love her so much <3

[HazzaWazza91]

@tooooooooooooota

she is just amazing.. when i met her backstage in London last year, she stole my heart away.. shes just amazingly awesome <3

[ranifadhila]

her voice has improved a lot. she started to sing the rain part with the big notes

[bijoux15]

I love you Selena !!! <3

[StacyAllHeart43]

stop hating on her :P i think she has a lovely voice and is an amazing actress. she may need to work on her voice a bit, but i still love it :) LOVE YOU SELENA! <3

[simplymeyoo]

stop hating on her voice, shes not gonna stop singing just cause some people dont like how she sings, thats how she sings! BUILD A BRIDGE AND GET OVER IT!

Or instead you can just not watch her vids cause there are people who do appreciate her!

Love you selena <3

[KeatonWilson1]

A lot of kids can do better at that song than she can.

[flowerpower6111]

@KeatonWilson1 umm no offense but a lot of kids cant even get on stage.