Instead of explaining the framework and logic behind transitivity and intransitivity, this instructor develves into a series of convoluted questions posed in the passive that reveals little on the framework of verb phrases and that barely explains the reason why some verb phrases require an object and why some do not.
For thoses interested in this topic of transitivity read 'Transformational Grammar' by Andrew Radford.
" I went running with my new shoes" Is this a transitive verb? Because shoes is receiving the action "running" Also the direct object of a verb does not have to be right after the verb right?
thanks this really helped me with my homework because i was absent and then i found this video an im glad you explained this lesson instead of my teacher. she just makes everything so confusing for me haha and some other people
@yuriamancio Thanks for your question! Some sentences have no direct objects. Some sentences have no indirect objects. The sentence in the video is "The soup tastes lousy." There is no direct object in the sentence. "Soup" is the subject, and "lousy" is something called a subjective complement. You can learn about this kind of sentence in the next video, "Copulative Verbs and Subjective Complements."
@mrthoth Can I ask why you say tastes is an intransitive verb? Isn't it a linking verb because it modifies soup and lousy which are the same thing, which would make it a linking verb correct?
@cGZynex Linking verbs (or copulative verbs) are a subset of intransitive verbs. (When you look up a copulative verb in the dictionary, the dictionary calls it intransitive, as I do here.)
I can't really comment on whether he is right or not as I don't properly understand this concept. Don't know if this helps or not though but he is not saying 'I am Wilson.' He is saying, 'I am a Welshman.'
Cool, thank you sir. Many blessings. Whoa, you call yourself Thoth ? As in the ancient Atlantean? Thoth, in that sense, is pronounced with a long "oh," many people say in with a short "o" and it sounds flimbsy, for the God of Knowledge. Read his Emerald Tablets. Become more than human in the process! The greatest alchemy created with words and beyond!
Thank you for helping a homeschooling Mom to explain this subject!!! I love English and I "get" it easily but sometimes can't explain it to my children so that they can understand it. This helped!
The question for sentence 2 should have been "What do I have?" instead of "What is had." The question for sentence 3 should have been "What am I?" instead of "What is been?" The fourth sentence is not a transitive verb but a linking verb because the verb taste is followed by an adjective which means the pattern for this sentence is Subject-Linking Verb-Complement or SLVC pattern.
thank you, you just assisted me in writing a sentence in my essay class i'm doing right now. I tried to look up how i could use null as a verb. I found my answer, and you assisted me in using it properly. Thanks a bunch a crunch.
At first I wondered why that last sentence was with those examples when in fact the topic is transitive verb and its object. But then, the teacher intelligently pronounced the flexibility of verbs in the english language; otherwise, I might have reacted violently over this video... hehe... lol
I suggest that you upload some more videos similar to this one. this is truly a good help for many.
Instead of explaining the framework and logic behind transitivity and intransitivity, this instructor develves into a series of convoluted questions posed in the passive that reveals little on the framework of verb phrases and that barely explains the reason why some verb phrases require an object and why some do not.
For thoses interested in this topic of transitivity read 'Transformational Grammar' by Andrew Radford.
Cienstin 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
" I went running with my new shoes" Is this a transitive verb? Because shoes is receiving the action "running" Also the direct object of a verb does not have to be right after the verb right?
maz0o1 3 months ago
This teacher is now a taxi driver in Rochester.
Kounelli33 5 months ago
This method is awesome!!!
I tried it here: writingcentre.uottawa.ca/hypergrammar/rvtrintr.html
and i got all answers correct !!!
mrthoth you rock!!!
moksshhh 7 months ago
Comment removed
moksshhh 7 months ago
can a transive be in a prepositional phrase?
awesomeZvidos 1 year ago
thanks this really helped me with my homework because i was absent and then i found this video an im glad you explained this lesson instead of my teacher. she just makes everything so confusing for me haha and some other people
LoverQT101 1 year ago
You explain in a way that is easily understood....Thank you..
corndancer 1 year ago
thanks a lot!!! :)
DJKEITH14 1 year ago
thank you so much i got a 100% because of you. i am really glad i found you on youtube.
gmanjack1 1 year ago
so, the soup is the object of the verb taste, then what is the indirect object? soup or lousy??
thanks
yuriamancio 1 year ago
@yuriamancio Thanks for your question! Some sentences have no direct objects. Some sentences have no indirect objects. The sentence in the video is "The soup tastes lousy." There is no direct object in the sentence. "Soup" is the subject, and "lousy" is something called a subjective complement. You can learn about this kind of sentence in the next video, "Copulative Verbs and Subjective Complements."
mrthoth 1 year ago
@mrthoth Thanks for the answer....often I have to watch your video more than once, because you have a great sense of humor and that makes me laugh....
e.g: What is tasted?? Lousy...that's what.....
Sandor thinking....what Sandor doing....Thinking...Sandor thinking...that is not English....
Congratulations.....Yuri from Brazil
yuriamancio 1 year ago
@mrthoth Can I ask why you say tastes is an intransitive verb? Isn't it a linking verb because it modifies soup and lousy which are the same thing, which would make it a linking verb correct?
cGZynex 1 year ago
@cGZynex Linking verbs (or copulative verbs) are a subset of intransitive verbs. (When you look up a copulative verb in the dictionary, the dictionary calls it intransitive, as I do here.)
mrthoth 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
YOU CONFUSE PEOPLE!
adamthelover10 2 years ago
@adamthelover10 wrong. he confuses the simple minded.
cGZynex 1 year ago
Thanks. :)
TheLarssan 2 years ago
I watch your videos everyday. Thank you for todays lessons, see you tomorrow : )))
kecakurdan101 2 years ago
I can't really comment on whether he is right or not as I don't properly understand this concept. Don't know if this helps or not though but he is not saying 'I am Wilson.' He is saying, 'I am a Welshman.'
honnor2008 2 years ago
Clarifications: (correct me if I'm wrong)
1. One of the characteristics of a TRANSITIVE VERB is that it is an ACTION VERB.
Thus, your example:
I have a cold.
I am Wilson.
The soup tastes lousy === are not considered transitive verbs.
Instead:
I am Wilson ==> AM is a copula/copular Verb.
The soup tastes lousy. ===> TASTES is a Perception Copula (or we commonly know linking verbs)
2. Copulas links nonverbal predicates.
sacarainn14 2 years ago 2
Comment removed
sacarainn14 2 years ago
amazingg videoo it helped me alot:P
ilse095 2 years ago
great video, it helps a lot.
marcellorenatto 2 years ago
Cool, thank you sir. Many blessings. Whoa, you call yourself Thoth ? As in the ancient Atlantean? Thoth, in that sense, is pronounced with a long "oh," many people say in with a short "o" and it sounds flimbsy, for the God of Knowledge. Read his Emerald Tablets. Become more than human in the process! The greatest alchemy created with words and beyond!
ThePastIsNothing 2 years ago
thanks! great videos.
mah927 2 years ago
Thanks. My sixth grade teacher explained this horribly. You did a much better job.
Jamesk899 2 years ago
on Yoda's behalf, he would neither say "The board was hit by me" nor "The board hit I" but "The board I hit."
proof:
"Agree with you the council does"
It is not a passive sentence:
he simply places the predicate in the beginning.
emerset 3 years ago
Thanks so much! I'm in a Pre-AP English class but grammar is my worst subject. After watching your videos I feel more comfortable with it.
CandyMomma14 3 years ago
thx so much
1234jnanzitoune 3 years ago
Thank you for helping a homeschooling Mom to explain this subject!!! I love English and I "get" it easily but sometimes can't explain it to my children so that they can understand it. This helped!
TheVisionOfHope 3 years ago
thanx for your help :)
HaRdYgUrL67 3 years ago
why???... tasted like soup??
hemhem17 3 years ago
thanks very much.
lineofhope123 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this sucks
nsoroma000 3 years ago
but why? you comment the same in all the videos. loser, get a life
carlosms83 3 years ago 2
thx for refreshing my memory in this stuff
facebookuser4life 3 years ago
The question for sentence 2 should have been "What do I have?" instead of "What is had." The question for sentence 3 should have been "What am I?" instead of "What is been?" The fourth sentence is not a transitive verb but a linking verb because the verb taste is followed by an adjective which means the pattern for this sentence is Subject-Linking Verb-Complement or SLVC pattern.
conniedc1965 3 years ago
Thanks, you really helped me with my homework. I never knew what transitive and intransitive meant. :D
GannonSlayer1437 3 years ago
thank you, you just assisted me in writing a sentence in my essay class i'm doing right now. I tried to look up how i could use null as a verb. I found my answer, and you assisted me in using it properly. Thanks a bunch a crunch.
niceace 3 years ago
At first I wondered why that last sentence was with those examples when in fact the topic is transitive verb and its object. But then, the teacher intelligently pronounced the flexibility of verbs in the english language; otherwise, I might have reacted violently over this video... hehe... lol
I suggest that you upload some more videos similar to this one. this is truly a good help for many.
bibliosensei 3 years ago
thank you,you really helped me please make more videos good job!
teddyluk22 3 years ago
Thanks so much for sharing this video, it has been a terrific aid to me and my students.
almagraza75 3 years ago
what school is this, or what level?
neverend7 3 years ago
duude im a sophomore and i have to do this crapp so gay.. for an honors class.
tennisbabe081 3 years ago
thank you for sharing your video
englishwithtony 3 years ago 2
This is good to learn
Thank you for creating this Video
DipologGirl 4 years ago 2
scrumptious I'd say. you're always standing in good stead!
fadfan 4 years ago 2
You so good i need complete lesson how can i get it
wwwmimicom 4 years ago 4