@KhylerNevra This show was recorded before some of the lyrics that actually ended up on the studio version were written, so it has some different lyrics, "prototype" lyrics maybe. The concept of the story is still the same.
@XxboVodxX Well yeah the story's the same. But even if these are "prototype" lyrics, a) more than half of them are missing and b) they don't make sense, half of the time. I was under the impression that he had just forgotten most of them. I've heard that this performance was done a bit prematurely.
This live version would be so epicccccccccccc if I was not has like 10 millions of kilometers of this perfect swedish metal band! I can't see any concert of pos in my whole life, it's my destiny...
@maddearth It was released BEFORE the studio version. The songs weren't finished yet. That's why you can hear different things, if you compare the Be Live with Be Studio Version, like guitar solos, lyrics, and a more other things. :P
Great perfomance! But I like the studio version more, because Daniel does some incredible singing in the instrumental part of this perfomance; from 2.17 to the end of the song.
He doesn't do that live, which is kinda really dissapointing, becuase the singing melodies and his voice in that part are incredibly crazy!
@masterzaabon Of course you can compare them, and the result of the comparison is: Pain Of Salvation is better. Only if two things are exactly the same is a comparison impossible.
@bjarnifreyr Nightwish is generally a different style. They focus more on the fantasical and symphonic style of metal, whereas Pain of Salvation has their own complex philosophical style in comparison. To judge one better than the other is not really possible. It'd be like comparing Dream Theater to Blind Guardian; they're just different in how they play, and what basis their songs/albums have.
@LukasVerdansky well said mate ;) if every metalhead was like you these seat of better or less better bands wouldn't exist.....but my opinion is that those guys that talk all those bollocks don't got the meaning of what metal is and what every different band wants to give to the world i do not believe that a band is better from an other cause every musician has different ideas built to his head and that's we we can't and we must not compare them...............
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Nightwish has a symphonic sound to it, as they are symphonic metal. and this album happens to be recorded with a symphony. So i definately see a connection there and hear it for that matter
well, insofar as they're both bands, there's a connection, that's where it stops...the fact that they both use 'kinda-violin-like-instruments' doesn't make it a very relevant connection, as the manner of composing and usage of 'orchestral' instruments differs entirely..
Holy Crap! That was amazing! I'm a believer now! I'm a song-writer/musician and that instrumental section had my jaw close to the floor. Amazing!!!! I'm getting this album tomorrow! =P
actually, i think this was a one time performance. :\ but i'm not quite sure. if that is the case, then that audience is a bunch of lucky bastards haha
i wonder why people have to take time to search for insignificant flaws in PoS' performances. its ridiculous and absurd. whats the point, and what r those people tryin to prove? no ones ever perfect..
Pain of Salvation, just the best lyrics, the most original music, one of the best voices in the world, ONLY awsome songs, on every point the best band in the world ever!
The lyrics are a bit different because this live act was recorded BEFORE they entered studio for the "Be" sessions, so as you can imagine, Gildenlow thought that it´s lyrics could be improved. They played this live set in their hometown, Skilstuna.
This is sooooo fucking amazing.. You know.. I'm a Dream theater fan for 3 years now.. I really never listened to Pain of Salvation.. But I think Pain of Salvation is climbing upwards, whilst dream theater is going down (see Systematic Chaos) ... I love it.. I really love pain of salvation. Their music is sooo melodic and original. Dan is great!
agree...the strange thing about this live DVD is...they released the live version first and then developed the studio version later, which i found lacked emotions from the live version
I'm afraid i got misunderstood..I'm the first saying that this version rules, simply it seemed to em that he forgot that part, it can happen during a concert, but this doesn't lowers at all the quality of the song, or of daniel's singing
Let's face the simple fact that this piece of music is some of the BEST SHIT ever written! As many of PoS's Songs are. Peace to all of you, and support the band, they deserve much more attention than they get!
In the audio comment of the dvd daniel explains that he still worked on some of the lyrics when they played the show, so this is kind of a pre-version, he has not forgotten anything, anyway, it all doesn't matter right? we dont't want to be the "music-police" who points out every little possible mistake (that's what I hate about prog-music, that the fans always have to argue "there was a mistake" "no it was right" etc.)
Why does he shouting "HEY!" & "NO!" have to mean he had forgotten some lyrics?! He shouts those words several times during the song. Maybe there were no lyrics to be forgotten? I think those screams ARE the lyrics.
at 0.26 he's a bit out of time, but maybe he does it on purpose. But he forgets the lyrics at 2 minutes, he doesn't say words but just screams. But I repeat, I'm the first loving this version, it can happen to forget lyrics..
This is simply OUTSTANDING. One of the best videos I have ever seen in many years. How incredible. THIS is what genius is about. Amazing, that is all I can say. Just watch this.
It kinda reduces the quality of the music when he gets his lyrics wrong... especially when the song is part of a story.
KhylerNevra 4 months ago
@KhylerNevra This show was recorded before some of the lyrics that actually ended up on the studio version were written, so it has some different lyrics, "prototype" lyrics maybe. The concept of the story is still the same.
XxboVodxX 4 months ago
@XxboVodxX Well yeah the story's the same. But even if these are "prototype" lyrics, a) more than half of them are missing and b) they don't make sense, half of the time. I was under the impression that he had just forgotten most of them. I've heard that this performance was done a bit prematurely.
KhylerNevra 4 months ago
Can't lie... man crush :)
maskounes 5 months ago
what the shiiiiiit. this song is crazy awesome.
martrex2 7 months ago
GILDENLÖW, I LOVE YOU!!! MARRY ME!
jmdb1994 8 months ago
4min04 bass taping wow! (john myung style)
freminick123 8 months ago in playlist pain of salvation
This live version would be so epicccccccccccc if I was not has like 10 millions of kilometers of this perfect swedish metal band! I can't see any concert of pos in my whole life, it's my destiny...
freminick123 9 months ago
2 person that saw this video where drunk or stoned to hit the right button and accidentally hit the "I don't like button".
Koootzer 9 months ago 3
Amazing!! I am a DT and Opeth fan from prog music,but they have such powerful music and vocals that I am out of my head!!!
AlterStein214 1 year ago
are these the alternate lyrics? he sings something different in the verces on the album =P
maddearth 1 year ago
@maddearth It was released BEFORE the studio version. The songs weren't finished yet. That's why you can hear different things, if you compare the Be Live with Be Studio Version, like guitar solos, lyrics, and a more other things. :P
osanan 1 year ago
@osanan ooh cool, thanks =D
maddearth 1 year ago
@maddearth Yes this is BEFORE they recorded the album and thus made some changes.
metallica2289 1 year ago
I don't have any words to describe what I feel when I hear this song, it's so perfect, amazing. I shudder...
SICse7en 1 year ago 2
Jesus, dude, can't you change the title to the proper one? It's moRARi, not "mohari". : )
Cordaleth 1 year ago 6
With this live version they just killed my brain
Musikdose 1 year ago 3
2 Justin Bieber fans missed the like button
roniemath 1 year ago 3
Amazing !
uKrease 1 year ago
I love the part that start at 2:17 ...
It's so... Perfect...
ignamax08 1 year ago
Great perfomance! But I like the studio version more, because Daniel does some incredible singing in the instrumental part of this perfomance; from 2.17 to the end of the song.
He doesn't do that live, which is kinda really dissapointing, becuase the singing melodies and his voice in that part are incredibly crazy!
Rattleguitar 1 year ago
the whole album is just mind bending stuff...
BenniMuzak 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Great song, thanks for the video
Visit my channel for a song of the new album.
MrLosskingdom 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Geat DVD.
Watch my channel for a song of the new album Road Salt.
kingdomloss 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
EPIC great song.
visit my channel to check a song of the new album
kingdomloss 1 year ago
meilleur chanson de ce groupe a mon avis
mon72689 1 year ago
The live versoin of this song has somthing to be desired.
ahigherstate 2 years ago 5
This live version is way better than the one in the studio..
GreekHellrider 2 years ago 4
Whatever !!! U suck!!
AchillesRageHoF 2 years ago
I wish he would have done the vocals, like he did in the studio version, but still good.
manydaysago 2 years ago
Comment removed
rlevanony 2 years ago 3
@rlevanony We all love Daniel
7SethMurrant7 2 years ago
I cant take this as a song sorry. Seems more like to have a soul itself. Epic..
topografer 2 years ago 33
This has been flagged as spam show
gives me chills...
kingofloss86 2 years ago
Best song ever ...
bulkaga 2 years ago 5
i saw pos n evergrey live in rio brazil best show ever!!!!!
bakkersyx 2 years ago
Comment removed
ahigherstate 2 years ago
lol they're nothing like Nightwish. Not even the slightest bit.
EternalDragon87 2 years ago
eeh... wtf are you talking about? You cant even compare nightwish with Pain of Salvation
masterzaabon 2 years ago 59
@masterzaabon Of course you can compare them, and the result of the comparison is: Pain Of Salvation is better. Only if two things are exactly the same is a comparison impossible.
Xoutravolta 6 months ago
You are right Pain of Salvation are by far greater than Nightwish
Significantmistake1 3 weeks ago 3
Holy shit... hahah thats coz nightwish is lightweight... Wont see them do anything like this..
bjarnifreyr 2 years ago 5
@bjarnifreyr Nightwish is generally a different style. They focus more on the fantasical and symphonic style of metal, whereas Pain of Salvation has their own complex philosophical style in comparison. To judge one better than the other is not really possible. It'd be like comparing Dream Theater to Blind Guardian; they're just different in how they play, and what basis their songs/albums have.
LukasVerdansky 8 months ago 2
@LukasVerdansky well said mate ;) if every metalhead was like you these seat of better or less better bands wouldn't exist.....but my opinion is that those guys that talk all those bollocks don't got the meaning of what metal is and what every different band wants to give to the world i do not believe that a band is better from an other cause every musician has different ideas built to his head and that's we we can't and we must not compare them...............
kaliopas1 6 months ago
Comment removed
MogHus 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Nightwish has a symphonic sound to it, as they are symphonic metal. and this album happens to be recorded with a symphony. So i definately see a connection there and hear it for that matter
so0o0o0 2 years ago
well, insofar as they're both bands, there's a connection, that's where it stops...the fact that they both use 'kinda-violin-like-instruments' doesn't make it a very relevant connection, as the manner of composing and usage of 'orchestral' instruments differs entirely..
ErSchTsp 2 years ago
So disappointed that they had to pull out of PN09. I was almost looking forward to POS more than DT.
gnargnargnar 2 years ago 3
me too. But from what i hear theyre working on theyre next album 2 cd set with 21 songs so thats a good thing to look foward too
KINGOFMETAL767 2 years ago
montreal Canada
fizzbin1 2 years ago
will see em opening for Dream Theater CANT WAIT
fizzbin1 2 years ago
omg, that is gonna be orgasmic. PoS + DT = God (if only i could add Ayreon to that equation ...)
LambdaDrS 2 years ago
Where mate?!
Saphiel 2 years ago
they're touring across North America along with Zappa Plays Zappa and Beardfish for the Prognation tour ..
I'll be there too :D
CobainFrusciante 2 years ago
bad news dude....there is a new lineup now. Pain of salvation and beardfish couldn't come for progressive tour because of their damn record label.
Ph0enix57 2 years ago
daniel the spiderman :p
absinthhhminded 2 years ago 3
A masterpiece..
JackTrab 2 years ago 7
the instrumental part is awesome. never stopped to think how it would sound without the lyrics. :)
rodritank 2 years ago
Holy Crap! That was amazing! I'm a believer now! I'm a song-writer/musician and that instrumental section had my jaw close to the floor. Amazing!!!! I'm getting this album tomorrow! =P
SoulCalligraphyMusic 2 years ago
one of the craziest instrumental parts ever and a truly great and beautiful song!
AndreEclipseHunter 2 years ago 3
I really love this song <3
Myownlittledeaddoll 3 years ago 4
I like the lyrics on the studio version better, but this performance is just so amazing. <3
Nenyatje 3 years ago 5
I agree!
This is my favorite PoS song. Hey. are you Nenya from the PoS forum?
DTRemcoG 3 years ago 2
I am, yes. Why do you ask?
Nenyatje 3 years ago 2
the site is growing :)
dreamfields72 3 years ago
Slowly, but steadily, yes =)
Nenyatje 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
lol, hi Nenya
-Sab
DirtyDoug669 2 years ago
Hi :p
Nenyatje 2 years ago
i can't find words in any language to describe this music!
vlassis19826661982 3 years ago 2
The orchestra adds so much to this song. One of my favorites on BE.
Shishkahuben 3 years ago 8
Genius.
Keyboardzrock 3 years ago 4
GOOD!!♥
lunaleslie92 3 years ago
but it's Morari, not Mohari
MilucyVampire 3 years ago 6
This album is one of the best music exemplum of all times
j4kc 3 years ago 3
Is there anyone who know if they play with the orchestra through the entire BE-tour?
Siifter 3 years ago
I mean "played" of course.
Siifter 3 years ago
actually, i think this was a one time performance. :\ but i'm not quite sure. if that is the case, then that audience is a bunch of lucky bastards haha
MrBlackBone82 3 years ago
Then you mean that I'm well favoured? :) I was actually in that audience.
Siifter 3 years ago 2
i wonder why people have to take time to search for insignificant flaws in PoS' performances. its ridiculous and absurd. whats the point, and what r those people tryin to prove? no ones ever perfect..
yaelitka 3 years ago 2
I think they played wrong at 4:00 live. They've edited it afterwards
steriliuz 3 years ago
este grupo la cago wn, el BE sin duda alguna es una obra maestra por donde se le analice,
grande POS!!!!
PonceHeavy 3 years ago 2
I can only imagine how awesome this would have been with the last verses...Either way, it gives me chills.
EnochMetatron 3 years ago
Pain of Salvation, just the best lyrics, the most original music, one of the best voices in the world, ONLY awsome songs, on every point the best band in the world ever!
Antalarion 3 years ago 7
Excellent
reverb2 3 years ago
I think the lyrics are a bit different than the album...wonder why he decided to change the lyrics?
jonased 3 years ago
The lyrics are a bit different because this live act was recorded BEFORE they entered studio for the "Be" sessions, so as you can imagine, Gildenlow thought that it´s lyrics could be improved. They played this live set in their hometown, Skilstuna.
insanebiochemist 3 years ago
Eskilstuna*, live 30 kilometers away from the place :p saw Be live at the Munktell Arena in Eskilstuna. Awesome band, awesome music, Divine vocals.
Keep rocking!
fredmajster 3 years ago
that mix with orchestra and guitars, drums, turn the music perfect...
GugaHoffmann 3 years ago
This is like my new favourtie tune from them. It's so impeccable, and the unison is so amazing.
JPMusicman 3 years ago
This is incredible! The mixture of orchestra and prog...
metabog 3 years ago 2
This is sooooo fucking amazing.. You know.. I'm a Dream theater fan for 3 years now.. I really never listened to Pain of Salvation.. But I think Pain of Salvation is climbing upwards, whilst dream theater is going down (see Systematic Chaos) ... I love it.. I really love pain of salvation. Their music is sooo melodic and original. Dan is great!
DTRemcoG 4 years ago
The concept of this album was so far ahead of its time. This song being an example.
Morrosujehabuji 4 years ago 3
I totally agree Mr King of Loss 86. LONG LIVE TO POS!
imjackswastedlife 4 years ago
Hi to all fans of POS, see Pluvius Aestivus from this same DVD. I hope you enjoy this beatiful song =).
POS rocks.
MRomeo777 4 years ago
touching..
i love this song... and this man!
esteretse 4 years ago 2
agree...the strange thing about this live DVD is...they released the live version first and then developed the studio version later, which i found lacked emotions from the live version
ryanpetrucci 4 years ago
I think of this DVD as a "beta" of the studio version, lyrics were improved a lot, and that's why I like the studio album best
TavitoX18 4 years ago
Isn't beta generally used to refer to the newest version? That doesn't make much sense considering the DVD was recorded before the studio album.
DeceptionOfTheState 3 years ago
Beta is more for a try of an unfinished version.
I think...
Well if it was recorded before... it was a beta before the album went out ^^
Gotferdom 3 years ago
Oh ok, sorry, my mistake :)
DeceptionOfTheState 3 years ago
I'm afraid i got misunderstood..I'm the first saying that this version rules, simply it seemed to em that he forgot that part, it can happen during a concert, but this doesn't lowers at all the quality of the song, or of daniel's singing
Elderanius 4 years ago
Let's face the simple fact that this piece of music is some of the BEST SHIT ever written! As many of PoS's Songs are. Peace to all of you, and support the band, they deserve much more attention than they get!
kingofloss86 4 years ago 3
In the audio comment of the dvd daniel explains that he still worked on some of the lyrics when they played the show, so this is kind of a pre-version, he has not forgotten anything, anyway, it all doesn't matter right? we dont't want to be the "music-police" who points out every little possible mistake (that's what I hate about prog-music, that the fans always have to argue "there was a mistake" "no it was right" etc.)
kingofloss86 4 years ago 2
Agreed. They're not machines
Greensmurf 4 years ago
He is not off time at 0:26.
Why does he shouting "HEY!" & "NO!" have to mean he had forgotten some lyrics?! He shouts those words several times during the song. Maybe there were no lyrics to be forgotten? I think those screams ARE the lyrics.
vaggpanelsklubben 4 years ago
seems like daniel doesn't know the first part of the songs..out oftime in a couple of occasions, and misses the lyrics..but this version still rulez
Elderanius 4 years ago
He didnt miss anything. Most of the DVD lyrics changed in the CD version.
As the DVD came first, i preffer the CD versions.
silentman2006 4 years ago
come on, he does.
at 0.26 he's a bit out of time, but maybe he does it on purpose. But he forgets the lyrics at 2 minutes, he doesn't say words but just screams. But I repeat, I'm the first loving this version, it can happen to forget lyrics..
Elderanius 4 years ago
There are magical little things called offbeats. Bands Occasional use them.
FailedEgo 3 years ago 3
GRIM
happysmellyfish 4 years ago
best son in BE dvd...
my fav phrase: "..nothing is left unstained"
5/5
Chileandude18 4 years ago
This song is one of my favourites from the album Be!
Thx for uploading this, always wanted to see this played live.
PoS Rule!!!
Etiainen 4 years ago
Thx man, can you upload more?
marcyeung 4 years ago
Amazing song. Amazing performance. Speechless. As always with PoS.
SilentShadows 4 years ago
POWER, POWER, POWER!!!
Tradaxa 4 years ago
This is simply OUTSTANDING. One of the best videos I have ever seen in many years. How incredible. THIS is what genius is about. Amazing, that is all I can say. Just watch this.
drumhead
zildjian50 5 years ago
Daniel's presence on the stage just blows me away every time. He has such energy!
lumigecko 5 years ago
I love this song ,
i wonder how they come up with those weird ritmes and stuff
\m/
MartiusNauticus 5 years ago
Nihil Morari Just Rulz!
PoS the best!
Alsophocuss 5 years ago
Finally someone listened to my preys :')
Thanks Man!
It's perfect!
Fuckaue 5 years ago
thanks for capturing. this song is one of my favourites from be. and i didnt know kristoffer like this. but its too late. :(
go on listening to Pain of Salvation
Dextertheokb 5 years ago