pero la biblia nos dice ke hay ke desechar toda mentira en otras palabbras si sigo en un lugar lleno de idolatria no he nacido de nuevo hay algunos salen de la madre iglesia catolica dicen ellos para seguir la verdad ,pero siguen con los idolos ensus corazones y ke dice labiblia ke el senor todo lo conoce olo sabe se acuerda cuando fue tentado y reprendio a satanas con la s escrituras le dijo no tentaras al senor tu Dios solo al serviras
@kozmoLouie keep fighting the good fight. which is that of Our Lord Christ, our church was founded by Jesus Christ, and its ridiculous argument using the albigensians they were heretics. as others say, as long as john chapter 6 is in the bible ill remain Catholic. plus a lot of other things
@carriebrk really? so St. Paul is adressing totally independent churches? but wait they all have the same beliefs, and if they dont they are reproved and corrected right?
There are 34,000 separate Christian groups in the world today. Over half of them are independent churches not linked to large denominations. Differences among Protestants are so great that its best to view them as separate religions w/ different beliefs and practices, who share the name Christianity, text of the bible and not a great deal else.
@KozmoLouie - The churches in the NT were also independent churches not linked to large denominations. The 7 churches in Revelation were addressed independently, most were commended for their faithfulness, then rebuked for their error. Smyrna was not rebuked, neither was Philidelphia, which was very small but very faithful. They recieved a great promise because of it. Because of their faithfulness to the Lord. "hear what the Spirit says to the churches" hmmm. plural.
@KozmoLouie Rather than making blind statement. Be specific. HOW do S.B backslide? Also, you are mistaken, catholicism is not Christian. The nazi party ( pope pius' buddies ) were also large. Where they right?
@kiwichristian2009 .....Oh please.....its a well known fact that the (Southern) Baptist tend to back slide often.
and you must live under a rock if you don't know that Catholics are Christian. heck you probably don't even know the definition of Christianity or Christian. You fail to understand that Protestants do not own the word or title of Christian.
@kiwichristian2009 Why do you need to approve comments on your page? And why don't you accept that Protestants branched out of the Catholic church during the Protestant Reformation in the 1500's. Also why are Catholics in the forefront fight against abortions while you people just sit on your lazy azz allowing secular liberals to kill babies?
@KozmoLouie I assume you mean my profile page. Because there is a place for everything, my friend. I am not a protestant so i do not know what they believe. My faith is based on the teachings of Jesus Christ and the apostles of the first century, as found in the Bible. Roman Catholicism did not exist as such until the third or fourth centuries. re: abortions? really? what do you do about it? i see nothing.
@KozmoLouie January 31, 2000 | CNN KANSAS CITY, Missouri (AP) -- Roman Catholic priests in the United States are dying from AIDS-related illnesses at a rate four times higher than the general population and the cause is often concealed on their death certificates, The Kansas City Star reported in a series of stories that started Sunday.
@KozmoLouie In 2001, while he was a cardinal, the pope issued a secret Vatican edict to Catholic bishops all over the world, instructing them to put the Church's interests ahead of child safety. The document recommended that rather than reporting sexual abuse to the relevant legal authorities, bishops should encourage the victim, witnesses and perpetrator not to talk about it. And, to keep victims quiet, it threatened that if they repeat the allegations they would be excommunicated.
@kiwichristian2009 Catholicism has a 2,000 year history. The Orthodox Church branched out in the 1200's, while the Protestants branched out in the 1500's. Over the years though Protestants kept branching out until the thousands of sects and odd ball churches we have today. Each one saying they are the true Church of Christ. Its obvious to me you belong to one of these little church groups. How Sad.
@KozmoLouie More like 1500, my friend. No, i am not a "david koresh" type. Are you a Pope Innocent III type who in 1208 proclaimed a crusade that killed a million Waldenses and Albigenses? or are you a Pope Urban II type who cowed France into attacking the Muslim world, throwing the region into five hundred years of religious warfare ?
It is impossible to divide the human Jesus of the Jesus God, this is also heresy, so Mary is truly Mother and creature Deus.Se it were not for the redemption of Jesus would have no value. Learn not to say such nonsense.
.41 And when Elizabeth heard the salutation of Mary, the babe leaped in her womb, and Elizabeth was filled with the Holy Spirit. 42 And he cried aloud: Blessed art thou among women and blessed is the fruit of thy womb. 43 Whence comes this honor to come to me the mother of my Lord? 44 For as soon as the voice of your greeting reached my ears, the babe leaped in my womb for joy. 45 Blessed art thou who hast believed, because if things will be fulfilled by the Lord that you were told!
is all God and man, therefore, as the one who birthed Him, she is the Mother of God. To deny Mary is the Mother of God is to deny that Jesus is God, and that is nothing short of blasphemy.
@ieatbruins4bfast No one disputes the fact that Mary is the mother of the human Jesus even though she was not the “supplier” of His human soul. Nor is there any question that the man Christ Jesus was created human in body, soul and spirit. What is disputed is the extension of the title “mother” to a divine nature that eternally existed and was not created in the womb of the virgin. A mother is only the mother of what originates within her womb....
@ieatbruins4bfast ...The second person of the blessed trinity did not originate in Mary’s body. He is without beginning – has always existed – and has no mother.
@kiwichristian2009, yes Jesus did exist before time itself. But what is also true that he humbled himself to be born of woman and save the world through his death and resurrection. Jesus is full God and full man, part of the Most Holy Trinity which is one God in the beings. Jesus' humanity cannot be seperated from his Divinity. Mary gave birth to Jesus who
Well done., good questions that any good CTholic apologetics should be able to answer. Actually the two questions that you raise ate "softball" compared to some far tougher ones that separate the teachings of the RCC from other Christians. And to see the hatred and name calling from RCC defenders in the remarks here is just flabbergasting. Well done video, good questions.
Did you know that Roman Catholics call Mary the "Queen of Heaven"? Did you know that the Bible talks about THE queen of heaven ( not A )? It does. The queen of heaven is A PAGAN GODDESS, A DEVIL-- Jeremiah 7:18 The children gather wood, and the fathers kindle the fire, and the women knead their dough, to make cakes to the QUEEN OF HEAVEN, and to pour out drink offerings unto other gods, that they may provoke me to anger.
@kiwichristian2009 Sorry, but not the same Queen. The fact that a pagan deity was known as the queen of heaven doesn't mean this term can't rightfully be applied, in another sense altogether, to Mary. The pagan king of Babylon, Nebuchadnezzar, is called the king of kings by Daniel (Dn 2:37), yet this doesn't preclude Jesus from being called by the same title (Rv 17:14; 19:16).
@Wilyam23 Wrong, my friend. God does not mention _A_ queen of heaven, He mentions THE queen of heaven. The one you guys worship is a man-made queen of heaven.
@kiwichristian2009 Mary is the Ark of the New Covenant - the New Covenant being Jesus. If you don't think the mother of Christ, the Ark that carried Him and nursed, raised and suffered watching her Son go through His Passion and Death, is not worthy of a special honor, then I'll let you settle that with her Son on your judgment day. I like the way you put words in a Catholic's mouths, such as we worship her right after being told that we do not. I'll bet you honor sports heroes and TV more.
@Wilyam23 I quote what your cult teaches. "For to be right and good, worship of the Mother of God ought to spring from the heart; acts of the body have here neither utility nor value if the acts of the soul have no part in them" ENCYCLICAL OF POPE PIUS X ON THE IMMACULATE CONCEPTION Given at Rome in St. Peter's on the second day of February, 1904, in the first year of Our Pontificate.
@Wilyam23 Exactly. The "queen" you guys worship and pray to is the one crowned by MAN, not by GOD. If mary was so important, why is she hardly even mentioned in the NT?
@kiwichristian2009 We only argue these things with you guys with your constant attacks against Christ and His Church in hopes of your salvation. We are secure in our faith knowing that the Church of Christ guides us in all Truth. You make things up as you go and define your own truths according to what lifestyle is most comfortable for you. You take a mutilated Bible that our Church gave you and then try to use it against us. What irony. I pray you'll start listening to what you're told.
The Bible says pray to God only, Mary cannot hear us! She is no greater than you or I. Otherwise we would have some direct command from God/Jesus/Holy Spirit to pray/thank her. We do not have that command in the bible because she does NOT intercede, help or plead our case before God/Christ Submission to God is from God (grace) NOT Mary.
Hi you said it,Mary mother of God in the human form, but is divine at the same time.Mary mother of God son, no Mother of God the father ,but there is too the holy spirit .Explain that to me,becouse are three person in one???????the father , the son ,the holy spirit ?????I think we catholic are right. GOD bless
@001satelite No, catholics are wrong. the rcc says that evolution is in line with Christianity and catholics can believe in it. This is CONTRARY to the Bible. the rcc says mary was sinless. this is CONTRARY to the Bible. the rcc says confess your sins to a priest. this is CONTRARY to the Bible. the rcc says mary can save you. this is CONTRARY to the Bible. the rcc says peter was "the rock". this is CONTRARY to the Bible. The rcc murdered MILLIONS of Christians. This is CONTRARY to the Bible.
@JDZwiers19 Is that the best rebuke you can come up with? God tells us to study the Word of God, to "search the scriptures", to read them for ourselves.
@kiwichristian2009 "God tells us to study the Word of God, to "search the scriptures", to read them for ourselves."
The Catholic Church has been studying scripture for 2000 years. The commentaries by saints like Aquinas and scholars like our current holy father leave no doubt in my mind that we have the valid interpretation. It is not just a matter of authority. The truth speaks for itself. If you wish to have a debate on scripture feel free to pm me. Any topic you like.
@PikSokolit My dear friend, you do need to study and learn about the gospel, more then that, receive Jesus in yur heart to fell the reborn of yourself as a child of God.
From Bishop Liguoris' "The Glories of Mary", APPROVED by the vatican! "She (Mary) is . . . the only hope of sinners: (p. 69),"We will be heard and saved sooner by going to Mary, and invoking her holy name, than that of Jesus our Savior. We will find salvation sooner going to the mother than going to the Son" (p. 82),"Many things asked of God and not received are asked and received from Mary (p. 82). All obey the precepts of Mary, even God" (p. 115). ALL CATHOLIC LIES!
the rcc says that evolution is in line with Christianity and catholics can believe in it. This is CONTRARY to the Bible. the rcc says mary was sinless. this is CONTRARY to the Bible. the rcc says confess your sins to a priest. this is CONTRARY to the Bible. the rcc says mary can save you. this is CONTRARY to the Bible. the rcc says peter was "the rock". this is CONTRARY to the Bible. The rcc murdered MILLIONS of Christians. This is CONTRARY to the Bible.
Não interessa a marcar de igrejas como catolicas, evangelicas, prostetantes e várias...etc..A IGREJA É PARA ORAR E IMPORTANTE É AMAR O JESUS CRISTO ( É FILHO DE DEUS E VIVO) E TAMBÉM AMAR O PAI ( É DEUS VIVO).....PARA SEMPRE...ACABOU E PAZ PARA SEMPRE.
PURGATORY EXISTS!!! and for the last time when speaking to a catholic remember that for us Not everything is in the bible, we can have teachings that are not in the bible as long as they don't go against what's in the bible. Do you really think the apostles were walking around with bibles handing them out and telling the people to read? Most people couldn't even read, printing press wasn't invented.
@chivitajm Rubbish. To say that purgatory is a necessary purification is to deny that the grace of God is sufficient. 1 John 1:9 says, "If we confess our sins, he is faithful and just and will forgive us our sins and purify us from all unrighteousness." "there is no more condemnation when Jesus passed over our sins and paid the ultimate penalty for us."
You don't have to be Catholic in order to enter heaven. Hell, the Catholic Church doesn't even teach that anymore.
As for Mary, to deny her being the Mother of God would be to deny the very Godly essence of Jesus, which you and I both know is high blasphemy. The fact is she gave birth to Jesus who is full God and full man. Therefor she is the mother. She is NEVER to be elevated to the level of God, and the Catholic Church does no such thing to do that. She is only highly revered
The doctrine of the Trinitiy (which is accepted by both Catholics and Protestants) states that God is a triune God, 1 God in the beings (Father, Son and Holy Spirit). These three being are distinct yet one. Since the Virgin Mary gave birth to Jesus, the Son, she is the Mother of God.
@ieatbruins4bfast But it WAS in "infallible" statement. "We declare, say, define, and pronounce that it is absolutely necessary for the salvation of every human creature to be subject to the Roman Pontiff (Pope Boniface VIII, the Bull Unan Snactam, 1302). INFALLIBLE PAPAL STATEMENT
@ieatbruins4bfast Nowhere does the Bible says Mary was sinless or the exception to sin passed on from each generation. For such a miraculous event the Bible surely would have spoken to this issue. Catholics do not find this doctrine from the context of Scripture but from making a pretext out of the Scripture from their Church tradition (which happens to be written down). But again it is not apostolic tradition.
well say all you said with Catholic. because Jesus the Christ instituted the Catholic Church and holds oral and writing tradition.
wow just because Archangel Gabriel hailed her doesn't mean anything isnt he a messanger of God? and if you know that is in the New Testament. on she is the mother of God the Son the second part of the Holy Trinity. so she is the mother of God.
Who said that you will have to Catholic in order to be saved? I M CATHALIC AND I DO NOT AGREE WITH YOU...AND WHO ARE YOU TALKING TO? MARY IS THE MOTHER OF GOD!!! WE ARE NOT PUTTING MARY ABOVE GOD...YOU ARE REALLY CONFUSED....
Aproposito, no where in Scripture says that all I have to is to have faith in Christ to be saved, the faith of which the Bible mentions is not merely a simple act of saying a bealive in You Jesus, but is an active faith which is very diferent.
The assertion of the true Church that there is no salvation outside the Church does not refer to those who without fault do not know Christ and the Church he founded.
Well I think you're wrong, the Catholic church dose not teach that you have to be catholic to be save, (CCC 846-848; (ref.: Summa Theologiae III, q.68, a.2).
@jorgeramirez01 "We declare, say, define, and pronounce that it is absolutely necessary for the salvation of every human creature to be subject to the Roman Pontiff (Pope Boniface VIII, the Bull Unan Snactam, 1302). INFALLIBLE PAPAL STATEMENT
I wish you would see my church, not as a material thing, or just a physical thing. I rephrase, is not my church, I follow its principles. Lets try not to blame the church, church is human, lets instead see ourselves and critisize how we are following His teachings, by throwing rocks at eachother? or by Really make a connection with Him.God bless you all. God bless La Santa Iglesia Catolica. Deo Gratias.
Catholic answer to "must be a Catholic to be saved":
Catechism Catholic Church 169: Salvation comes from God alone; but because we receive the life of faith through the Church, she is our mother: We believe the Church as the mother of our new birth, but not in the Church as if she were the author of our salvation. Because she is our mother, she is also our teacher in the faith.
Q: If your mother teaches you wrongly, is it harder to be saved?
Why shouldn't we hail mary? Her argument here is false -- What does Elizabeth say to her when she meets Mary after Mary becomes pregnant with Jesus? In Luke: She [Elizabeth] gave a loud cry and said, 'Of all women you are the most blessed, and blessed is the fruit of your womb. Why should I be honored with a visit from the mother of my Lord?"
If you believe that Scripture is correct, and Jesus the Risen Lord is God, then Mary is indeed the mother of God. If not, she isn't. QED.
La chica del video ilustra el eterno problema de los protestantes: quieren interpretar la Palabra de Dios como ellos quieren, y no como Jesús quiere. Jesús estableció el criterio de autoridad para interpretar la Palabra cuando dijo SOLAMENTE a sus apóstoles "Quien a vosotros escucha, a Mí me escucha". Jesús fundó UNA sola Iglesia. La Iglesia de Jesucristo es la Católica, y los apóstoles son el Papa y sus Obispos.
WHO told you and where does it say is bad to repeat some word an angel sent by God himself said??
thats what doesnt make sence
catholic are not putting her above God with that is just a prayer to god through mary we ask for intercesion not miracles from mary thats something that has to be really clear
Mary IS the mother of God in heaven just like my mother will always be my mother no matter what in heaven my mother will be ask how she raised her children she will be considered my mother after dead so yes mary is the mother of God
@Alicia6387 "But when ye pray, use not vain repetitions, as the heathen do:" The Bible says pray to God only, Mary cannot hear us! She is no greater than you or I. Otherwise we would have some direct command from God/Jesus/Holy Spirit to pray/thank her. We do not have that command in the bible because she does NOT intercede, help or plead our case before God/Christ Submission to God is from God (grace) NOT Mary.
Matthew 18:18 - Jesus gives to the Apostles the power to legislate
Timothy 3:15 - Church is called the "pillar and foundation of truth"
John 20:23 - Jesus gives to the Apostles the power to forgive sins
Matthew 16:18 - the gates of Hell will never prevail_ against Christ's Church
St. Irenaeus (200AD) "For where the Church is, there is the Spirit of God; and where the Spirit of God is, there the Church and every grace is. The Spirit, however, is Truth." (Against Heresies 3, 24, 1)
@Alicia6387 Wrong. "you are petros ( a small pebble) and upon this petra ( a massive rock) I shall build My church....." Christ built His church upon Himself, upon the faith Peter had and upon our faith in Christ. Not Peter the person.
@Alicia6387 Wrong. Peter is not the rock, because the 12 disciples, knowing well the OT, recognised the Rock as a description or name for God. Duet32:4,Psalms18:2,Psalm18:31
@kiwichristian2009 please read Luke 6Ç48 - He is like a man which built an house, and digged deep, and laid the foundation on a rock: and when the flood arose, the stream beat vehemently upon that house, and could not shake it: for it was founded upon a rock.
@kiwichristian2009 please read Luke 6.48 - He is like a man which built an house, and digged deep, and laid the foundation on a rock: and when the flood arose, the stream beat vehemently upon that house, and could not shake it: for it was founded upon a rock.
Someone can correct me on this but i believe if someone is being taught false teachings and they are not aware of it and are truly seeking God that that person will be saved and the person that taught the false teachings will be punished more.
olha gente, eu sei que católicos e evangélicos tem suas diferenças, alguns creen que existam imagens milagrosas (coisa ke eu n acredito pq fala nos 10 mandamentos em exodos que n eh para crer em imagem ou escultura etc.), enfim, isto não é motivo de ofender uns aos outros, se eles creem nisso não culpe-os, eles podem ter crescido com esta religião e aostumaram, mas sem ofensas uns aos outros, respeitem as decisões uns dos outros que o mundo fica bem melhor para se vive ^^.
acaso no dice la biblia que reinaremos con Jesus pobe evangelicos ellos no mas maria va estar en el infienro son vivboras ustesdes dicen basarse en la biblia y no se dan cuenta que la iglesia catolica es la que junto los libros de la biblia aparte los del pentateuco Raza protestante de Viboras
Catholics believe that Protestant Churches are true to God's teaching so long as they follow the teaching of the Church that was given God' authority and blueprint(the Catholic Church). There are a lot of Protestant Churches that incorporate almost all of the Catholic blueprint, so they predictably lead their flock to Salvation, but since they are facsimiles of the True blueprint, they fall short. So Catholics believe many Protestants are more "Catholic" than most Catholics.
concordo com vc em partes a igreja catolica pode ser taxada de porca, com toda certeza oq eu fico adimirado e essa corja de crentes que é muito pior q os catolicos que nao passam de cria do catolicismo,uzam um livro que foi formatado pela catolica 'biblia',e ainda querem faalr merda vs fedem mt mais que os catolicos essa corja norte americana infelismente esta invadinado nosso brasil,fodase inglaterra e eua,e toda essa merda ke vem de la
you are crzy. Accually Jesus founded the CATHOLIC CHURCH, the others were founded by fools and false profets like Luther and Calvin. And their Bibles are also incomplete with all the good stuff their is to read in it. BUT your church doesnt save you. I only help because God wants you devoded in a COMMUNITY.
The Ecumenical Council of Ephesus in 431 AD declared that Mary was the Mother of God. This was a united Church who decided this, before any divisions and schisms took place, over 1000 years before protestants corrupted the faith of their fathers. Christians have said "Hail Mary" since the apostles walked the earth. Who do you think you are to condemn a doctrine founded by Christ through the fathers of the church?
@JDZwiers19 I am mearly asking you to substantiate your claims. If your claims are truthful, you will be able to supply evidence to support it. Again, you are diverting away rather than answering. Remember God teaches us to always have an answer for our faith. Do you have blind faith?
@JDZwiers19 The Bible declares that God and Christ had no creator or mother or father. Thanks, but i will stick with the Bible on this one, my friend. :)
Interesting. I wonder, who should I rely on, the councils and decrees of the Catholic Church going back 2,000 years, or a little girl on YouTube. I think the answer is clear!
@GodIprefermyDog Do not rely on your STUPIDITY. Stop making dumb videos, please, little girl. No one cares about what you think. Why don't you study harder to get good grades? why don't you help your mom cleaning your damn house? are you on your period?? Geez... fucking teenagers piss me off.
@elcamaras Whell, if you consider the Catholic church was created by a pagan, to save his Impery, Rome, I'm talking about Constatine, so is much better to rely on this young girl, becouse she is talking in accordance to the Word of God! Think, it still time to redemption. God Bless you!
Te falta muuuuuuuuuucho que interiorisar, estas leeeeeeeeejos , awaaaaaaaay from the heaven, cielo, te basas en puras pendejadas eres aun una adolecente que no entiende nada de la biblia.
creer en jesus es actuar y creer en lo que dijo, no basta con solo creer en su existencia, si no que creer y vivir respecto a lo que crees que es la verdad y esa verdad es actuar como dijo jesus, si haces mal y mucho mal y te arrepientes igual puedes ir al infierno.
Pero el infierno no es lo que crees
Protestantes son idiotas que no saben leer poesia los catolicos la leen un poco mejor y los evangelicos son unos analfabetos culeaos.
En todo caso los filosofos agnosticos son superiores.
yes and no....craddle catholics believe that and hail mary is being recited for when he is supposed to be born when we say that it is for the rosary which is the mysterys of what events occured you think we hold mary high cause you hold god to low if we thought she was the main squeeze then we would say she died for us..you try to say these words to over bear our faith i bet you cant tell me what the word catholic means...it means universal and us christians all are on the same team
no entendi ni el ingles ni el port¿uges...,,.............................pero ccreo q dijo q los catolicos son lo sverdaderos hijos de jesucristo,,jejeje,,no es cierto protesyantes,,,pero ps si,,nimodo estasn mal
i meant "Mary".... anyhow.... 1 Timothy tells you there is only one mediator between men and God. ....and one more point.... GOd existed before Mary..... he only CAME TO EARTH as a man (like a baby) through her..... your own bible proves that. so mother of GOD?... Fails...
and by the way... about the marry forgiving sins and other things...... since you like Timothy so much let me quote 1 Timothy 2:5 to you: "For there is one God, and one mediator between God and men, the man Christ Jesus" ....
Esa chica repite varias veces la misma cosa... en el catolicismo esta la verdad segun catolicos, en el protestantismo esta el camino, segun evangelicos, sabemos que la salvacion viene de jesus... pero que es la fe sin obras??? es la idea sin la accion
Cómo demuestro que tengo fe? solo hablando y alabando? y el amor al projimo o peor, el amor al enemigo? la caridad? eso es secundario acaso?, que Dios te bendiga y te tenga en su gracia hermano.
if you go by scripture you should know this verse because of the athority of the church. Mt 18: 17 "if he refuses to listen even to the church". what church? 1tim3: 15 pilar and foundation of truth. So if your church was not founed by Christ 2000 years ago, you are in a church that has no athority to preach. your fallowing a man and not Christ and his Catholic church. even the bible says the church has the truth. Hell can't prevail against it. Don't question scripture blessings
I'm not protestant, but who said the church mentioned in the bible is the catholic? WHO on earth said that Jesus of the bible founded catholic church? Sorry, the name "catholic " is not there so that the term church may refer to any church either protestant, mormon, JW etc. Another thing, this stupid catholic church started to exist about 300 after christ, the anciente Christianity was NOT catholic church.
Look dog....300 yrs after Christ the christian church was called universal. Greek word for uiversal is Catholic it's the same church with a name. Not a protestant church w/name.1tim3:15 the true church. if you r not protestant that means you r Catholic. u say the anciente Christianity was NOT catholic what was it? could it be one u mentoned? could one of those be the church that 1tim3:15 talks about? NO they can't. these names came 1500 yrs after Christ using a Catholic book the (BIBLE)
No, the ancient Christianity WAS NOT catholic, let alone Roman Catholic! No, I'm not neither protestant nor catholic, I'm free. Ancient christianity did not know catholic dogmas like the Trinity, the Roman Pope and hailing Mary as if she was a Godess.
Look dog first let talk freedom either you are free or slave. Either Catholic or protestant most people in the world are protestant. thats ok. The Bible says hot or cold. make your chioce not excuses. 2nd back up all u say if you don't, it leads me to think no credibility
All I say is a repetition of what christianity scholars have already said, but I don't expect christians to grasp their religion was invented in a certain place and time. Why HOT or COLD? There's mild too. Isn't it obvious that an atheist is neither a catholic nor a protestant?
if you protest any teaching of the catholic church you are protestant. it doesn't mean that you are christian if you are protestant. You can be muslim, all you have to be is a non Catholic. on another piont you made christian scholars ARE Catholics. did you mean protestant scholars. Well back to my original point. paul speaks about a church having the truth. Can you tell me the name of the that church? cuz thats the church that I must belong to, the one that holds the TRUTH!!!
I understand your point. You do not view 'Protestant' as a denomination of a religious group per se, but all those who are not catholic. So an atheist would be protestant? Well, I see protestant as all christians who separated from the catholic church which in fact was the first worldwide organized christian church. (cont)
We have a point: Paul wrote to many churches (EPISTLES)which were the 1st christian churches. But what similarities can you see in them and the current catholic church? More, this catholic church is Roman. Paul doesn't mention a lot of catholic thoughts. He doesn't mention Mary, he doesnt talk about the authority of the pope. He doesn't talk about the mass of saints of the Roman church. cont
He does not mention Vatrican OR the trinity. These are all catholic inventions different from the 1st church. Ok, Catholics came before protestants, JWs, Mormons. But waht is your base to say it's the real church? What similarities do you see between catholics and the ancient chritianity bearing in mind the points I exposed?
seven sacraments of the Catholic church I was brief with scpriture there's much more, thats only scratching the surface. now your church what does it offer?
google vatican and trinity for info, ave maria most of it is biblical it's in lukes gospel. what are you getting at w/ the vatican or trinity? and by free does that mean you are your own pope free to make infalible athoritative interpretations, or a non believer
Trinity is shown in the start of the bible when god says "we" when building the world. Also Jesus gave us Mary as a mother and called her woman, and the only time god calls someone woman.. is with eve. She is the new eve, and she is the mother of God in the human form, but Jesus was God and man, and not solely human..
This is entirely YOUR interpretation. No part in the bible says God is co-substancial with Christ as Atanasius invented. Biblically speaking, Jesus can't be eternal as God since he was His first born. To be a first born he had to be born someday and everythingthat is born did not exist some time in the past.
Ave Maria = Hail Mary and that is how Gabriel greated Mary so its biblical. Pope Jesus gave the Keys to Peter and passed down to protect against heresy
@kiwichristian2009 really? from what i read it says Peter. so Christ did not tell Peter to feed his sheep? the pillar of truth is the church or am i wrong? or that in Pentecost the Holy Spirit descended upon the Apostles and Christ promised to stay with them until the end of time. just one last question when was the gospel written down?
@14alonso88 No, it was the apostles. Yes, He did say that to Peter. What was Peter in charge of? What was Paul in charge of? I should not say "in charge of", but "mission entrusted with". Now you are starting to try an argument regarding the Word of God and scriptures, and i will not get into that at this moment, for i can see your motive is not for truth, but for arguing and ego. I could be wrong though.
(i will look into the other things later).... but 'priests: luke 10:16 ??? fail..... i think you should read that verse again.... and tell me where does Jesus mention any priests or authorizes anyone as 'the' person having the power to speak with his voice? i think you are twisting the text. let me quote it here for you>"He that heareth you heareth me; and he that despiseth you despiseth me; and he that despiseth me despiseth him that sent me" ... read chapter 10 from verse 1. be blsed
@GodIprefermyDog I don't think catholics have any idea what a "protestant" is. Technically, a "protestant" is a former member of the catholic cult that "protested" against its false teachings.
@1tim315carlos I need to know what the official catholic organisations definition of a "protestant" is, please. The point is that several catholics have given me different definitions, and i need to know the OFFICIAL definition.
@GodIprefermyDog The early church as described in the NT did the following: shared all things in common, relationships, support missionaries/ministers, teaching & preaching, praying, worshiping, reading of scripture, evangelism, fostering spiritual gifts. No where does the NT dictate fancy buildings, robes, repetitive prayer, a priesthood, Mary worship, sectarianism, or any order of service, etc.. all these are man made traditions added on.
you do nto have to be a chaltic to be saved.
TheBladecharge 4 months ago
pero la biblia nos dice ke hay ke desechar toda mentira en otras palabbras si sigo en un lugar lleno de idolatria no he nacido de nuevo hay algunos salen de la madre iglesia catolica dicen ellos para seguir la verdad ,pero siguen con los idolos ensus corazones y ke dice labiblia ke el senor todo lo conoce olo sabe se acuerda cuando fue tentado y reprendio a satanas con la s escrituras le dijo no tentaras al senor tu Dios solo al serviras
aparicio12fran 7 months ago
i am catholic....so?
TAQUEROCHIDO66 7 months ago
i liked the girl... but why she is on the ground ? whatever, i liked her.
bartreis 11 months ago
@kozmoLouie keep fighting the good fight. which is that of Our Lord Christ, our church was founded by Jesus Christ, and its ridiculous argument using the albigensians they were heretics. as others say, as long as john chapter 6 is in the bible ill remain Catholic. plus a lot of other things
14alonso88 11 months ago
@carriebrk really? so St. Paul is adressing totally independent churches? but wait they all have the same beliefs, and if they dont they are reproved and corrected right?
14alonso88 11 months ago
There are 34,000 separate Christian groups in the world today. Over half of them are independent churches not linked to large denominations. Differences among Protestants are so great that its best to view them as separate religions w/ different beliefs and practices, who share the name Christianity, text of the bible and not a great deal else.
KozmoLouie 11 months ago
@KozmoLouie - The churches in the NT were also independent churches not linked to large denominations. The 7 churches in Revelation were addressed independently, most were commended for their faithfulness, then rebuked for their error. Smyrna was not rebuked, neither was Philidelphia, which was very small but very faithful. They recieved a great promise because of it. Because of their faithfulness to the Lord. "hear what the Spirit says to the churches" hmmm. plural.
carriebrk 11 months ago
The Southern Baptist are famous for being back sliding Christians.
Also the Largest and leading Christian organization in the world is the Holy Catholic Church.
KozmoLouie 11 months ago
@KozmoLouie Rather than making blind statement. Be specific. HOW do S.B backslide? Also, you are mistaken, catholicism is not Christian. The nazi party ( pope pius' buddies ) were also large. Where they right?
kiwichristian2009 11 months ago
@kiwichristian2009 .....Oh please.....its a well known fact that the (Southern) Baptist tend to back slide often.
and you must live under a rock if you don't know that Catholics are Christian. heck you probably don't even know the definition of Christianity or Christian. You fail to understand that Protestants do not own the word or title of Christian.
KozmoLouie 11 months ago
@KozmoLouie Be specific. HOW do S.B backslide?
kiwichristian2009 11 months ago
@kiwichristian2009 Why do you need to approve comments on your page? And why don't you accept that Protestants branched out of the Catholic church during the Protestant Reformation in the 1500's. Also why are Catholics in the forefront fight against abortions while you people just sit on your lazy azz allowing secular liberals to kill babies?
KozmoLouie 11 months ago
@KozmoLouie I assume you mean my profile page. Because there is a place for everything, my friend. I am not a protestant so i do not know what they believe. My faith is based on the teachings of Jesus Christ and the apostles of the first century, as found in the Bible. Roman Catholicism did not exist as such until the third or fourth centuries. re: abortions? really? what do you do about it? i see nothing.
kiwichristian2009 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@KozmoLouie January 31, 2000 | CNN KANSAS CITY, Missouri (AP) -- Roman Catholic priests in the United States are dying from AIDS-related illnesses at a rate four times higher than the general population and the cause is often concealed on their death certificates, The Kansas City Star reported in a series of stories that started Sunday.
kiwichristian2009 11 months ago
@KozmoLouie In 2001, while he was a cardinal, the pope issued a secret Vatican edict to Catholic bishops all over the world, instructing them to put the Church's interests ahead of child safety. The document recommended that rather than reporting sexual abuse to the relevant legal authorities, bishops should encourage the victim, witnesses and perpetrator not to talk about it. And, to keep victims quiet, it threatened that if they repeat the allegations they would be excommunicated.
kiwichristian2009 11 months ago
@kiwichristian2009 Catholicism has a 2,000 year history. The Orthodox Church branched out in the 1200's, while the Protestants branched out in the 1500's. Over the years though Protestants kept branching out until the thousands of sects and odd ball churches we have today. Each one saying they are the true Church of Christ. Its obvious to me you belong to one of these little church groups. How Sad.
KozmoLouie 11 months ago
@KozmoLouie More like 1500, my friend. No, i am not a "david koresh" type. Are you a Pope Innocent III type who in 1208 proclaimed a crusade that killed a million Waldenses and Albigenses? or are you a Pope Urban II type who cowed France into attacking the Muslim world, throwing the region into five hundred years of religious warfare ?
kiwichristian2009 11 months ago
It is impossible to divide the human Jesus of the Jesus God, this is also heresy, so Mary is truly Mother and creature Deus.Se it were not for the redemption of Jesus would have no value. Learn not to say such nonsense.
dommarko42 11 months ago
.41 And when Elizabeth heard the salutation of Mary, the babe leaped in her womb, and Elizabeth was filled with the Holy Spirit. 42 And he cried aloud: Blessed art thou among women and blessed is the fruit of thy womb. 43 Whence comes this honor to come to me the mother of my Lord? 44 For as soon as the voice of your greeting reached my ears, the babe leaped in my womb for joy. 45 Blessed art thou who hast believed, because if things will be fulfilled by the Lord that you were told!
Ok!
dommarko42 11 months ago
is all God and man, therefore, as the one who birthed Him, she is the Mother of God. To deny Mary is the Mother of God is to deny that Jesus is God, and that is nothing short of blasphemy.
ieatbruins4bfast 11 months ago
@ieatbruins4bfast No one disputes the fact that Mary is the mother of the human Jesus even though she was not the “supplier” of His human soul. Nor is there any question that the man Christ Jesus was created human in body, soul and spirit. What is disputed is the extension of the title “mother” to a divine nature that eternally existed and was not created in the womb of the virgin. A mother is only the mother of what originates within her womb....
kiwichristian2009 11 months ago
@ieatbruins4bfast ...The second person of the blessed trinity did not originate in Mary’s body. He is without beginning – has always existed – and has no mother.
kiwichristian2009 11 months ago
@kiwichristian2009, yes Jesus did exist before time itself. But what is also true that he humbled himself to be born of woman and save the world through his death and resurrection. Jesus is full God and full man, part of the Most Holy Trinity which is one God in the beings. Jesus' humanity cannot be seperated from his Divinity. Mary gave birth to Jesus who
ieatbruins4bfast 11 months ago
@kiwichristian2009
ieatbruins4bfast 11 months ago
Well done., good questions that any good CTholic apologetics should be able to answer. Actually the two questions that you raise ate "softball" compared to some far tougher ones that separate the teachings of the RCC from other Christians. And to see the hatred and name calling from RCC defenders in the remarks here is just flabbergasting. Well done video, good questions.
agthorn 11 months ago
Did you know that Roman Catholics call Mary the "Queen of Heaven"? Did you know that the Bible talks about THE queen of heaven ( not A )? It does. The queen of heaven is A PAGAN GODDESS, A DEVIL-- Jeremiah 7:18 The children gather wood, and the fathers kindle the fire, and the women knead their dough, to make cakes to the QUEEN OF HEAVEN, and to pour out drink offerings unto other gods, that they may provoke me to anger.
kiwichristian2009 11 months ago
@kiwichristian2009 Sorry, but not the same Queen. The fact that a pagan deity was known as the queen of heaven doesn't mean this term can't rightfully be applied, in another sense altogether, to Mary. The pagan king of Babylon, Nebuchadnezzar, is called the king of kings by Daniel (Dn 2:37), yet this doesn't preclude Jesus from being called by the same title (Rv 17:14; 19:16).
Wilyam23 11 months ago
@Wilyam23 Wrong, my friend. God does not mention _A_ queen of heaven, He mentions THE queen of heaven. The one you guys worship is a man-made queen of heaven.
kiwichristian2009 11 months ago
@kiwichristian2009 Mary is the Ark of the New Covenant - the New Covenant being Jesus. If you don't think the mother of Christ, the Ark that carried Him and nursed, raised and suffered watching her Son go through His Passion and Death, is not worthy of a special honor, then I'll let you settle that with her Son on your judgment day. I like the way you put words in a Catholic's mouths, such as we worship her right after being told that we do not. I'll bet you honor sports heroes and TV more.
Wilyam23 11 months ago
@Wilyam23 I quote what your cult teaches. "For to be right and good, worship of the Mother of God ought to spring from the heart; acts of the body have here neither utility nor value if the acts of the soul have no part in them" ENCYCLICAL OF POPE PIUS X ON THE IMMACULATE CONCEPTION Given at Rome in St. Peter's on the second day of February, 1904, in the first year of Our Pontificate.
kiwichristian2009 11 months ago
@Wilyam23 Exactly. The "queen" you guys worship and pray to is the one crowned by MAN, not by GOD. If mary was so important, why is she hardly even mentioned in the NT?
kiwichristian2009 11 months ago
@kiwichristian2009 We only argue these things with you guys with your constant attacks against Christ and His Church in hopes of your salvation. We are secure in our faith knowing that the Church of Christ guides us in all Truth. You make things up as you go and define your own truths according to what lifestyle is most comfortable for you. You take a mutilated Bible that our Church gave you and then try to use it against us. What irony. I pray you'll start listening to what you're told.
Wilyam23 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The Bible says pray to God only, Mary cannot hear us! She is no greater than you or I. Otherwise we would have some direct command from God/Jesus/Holy Spirit to pray/thank her. We do not have that command in the bible because she does NOT intercede, help or plead our case before God/Christ Submission to God is from God (grace) NOT Mary.
kiwichristian2009 11 months ago
Hi you said it,Mary mother of God in the human form, but is divine at the same time.Mary mother of God son, no Mother of God the father ,but there is too the holy spirit .Explain that to me,becouse are three person in one???????the father , the son ,the holy spirit ?????I think we catholic are right. GOD bless
001satelite 11 months ago
@001satelite No, catholics are wrong. the rcc says that evolution is in line with Christianity and catholics can believe in it. This is CONTRARY to the Bible. the rcc says mary was sinless. this is CONTRARY to the Bible. the rcc says confess your sins to a priest. this is CONTRARY to the Bible. the rcc says mary can save you. this is CONTRARY to the Bible. the rcc says peter was "the rock". this is CONTRARY to the Bible. The rcc murdered MILLIONS of Christians. This is CONTRARY to the Bible.
kiwichristian2009 11 months ago
Comment removed
JDZwiers19 11 months ago
@kiwichristian2009
You have made yourself the authority by which scripture is to be interpreted. This is CONTRARY to the Bible.
JDZwiers19 11 months ago
@JDZwiers19 Is that the best rebuke you can come up with? God tells us to study the Word of God, to "search the scriptures", to read them for ourselves.
kiwichristian2009 11 months ago
@kiwichristian2009 "God tells us to study the Word of God, to "search the scriptures", to read them for ourselves."
The Catholic Church has been studying scripture for 2000 years. The commentaries by saints like Aquinas and scholars like our current holy father leave no doubt in my mind that we have the valid interpretation. It is not just a matter of authority. The truth speaks for itself. If you wish to have a debate on scripture feel free to pm me. Any topic you like.
JDZwiers19 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@kiwichristian2009 "God tells us to study the Word of God, to "search the scriptures", to read them for ourselves."
He also tells us to obey his church. You should read the bible more carefully. I'll be glad to help you, time permiting.
JDZwiers19 11 months ago
@PikSokolit My dear friend, you do need to study and learn about the gospel, more then that, receive Jesus in yur heart to fell the reborn of yourself as a child of God.
linotche13 11 months ago
Que se calle a la verga y que enseñe las tetas jajaja
Davidilktrance 11 months ago
From Bishop Liguoris' "The Glories of Mary", APPROVED by the vatican! "She (Mary) is . . . the only hope of sinners: (p. 69),"We will be heard and saved sooner by going to Mary, and invoking her holy name, than that of Jesus our Savior. We will find salvation sooner going to the mother than going to the Son" (p. 82),"Many things asked of God and not received are asked and received from Mary (p. 82). All obey the precepts of Mary, even God" (p. 115). ALL CATHOLIC LIES!
kiwichristian2009 1 year ago
the rcc says that evolution is in line with Christianity and catholics can believe in it. This is CONTRARY to the Bible. the rcc says mary was sinless. this is CONTRARY to the Bible. the rcc says confess your sins to a priest. this is CONTRARY to the Bible. the rcc says mary can save you. this is CONTRARY to the Bible. the rcc says peter was "the rock". this is CONTRARY to the Bible. The rcc murdered MILLIONS of Christians. This is CONTRARY to the Bible.
kiwichristian2009 1 year ago
Não interessa a marcar de igrejas como catolicas, evangelicas, prostetantes e várias...etc..A IGREJA É PARA ORAR E IMPORTANTE É AMAR O JESUS CRISTO ( É FILHO DE DEUS E VIVO) E TAMBÉM AMAR O PAI ( É DEUS VIVO).....PARA SEMPRE...ACABOU E PAZ PARA SEMPRE.
freguess 1 year ago
Ha cala sua boca! Sua ignorante vá estudar babaca
clarissass 1 year ago
PURGATORY EXISTS!!! and for the last time when speaking to a catholic remember that for us Not everything is in the bible, we can have teachings that are not in the bible as long as they don't go against what's in the bible. Do you really think the apostles were walking around with bibles handing them out and telling the people to read? Most people couldn't even read, printing press wasn't invented.
chivitajm 1 year ago
@chivitajm Rubbish. To say that purgatory is a necessary purification is to deny that the grace of God is sufficient. 1 John 1:9 says, "If we confess our sins, he is faithful and just and will forgive us our sins and purify us from all unrighteousness." "there is no more condemnation when Jesus passed over our sins and paid the ultimate penalty for us."
kiwichristian2009 1 year ago
You don't have to be Catholic in order to enter heaven. Hell, the Catholic Church doesn't even teach that anymore.
As for Mary, to deny her being the Mother of God would be to deny the very Godly essence of Jesus, which you and I both know is high blasphemy. The fact is she gave birth to Jesus who is full God and full man. Therefor she is the mother. She is NEVER to be elevated to the level of God, and the Catholic Church does no such thing to do that. She is only highly revered
ieatbruins4bfast 1 year ago
@ieatbruins4bfast
WHAT STUPID ARE YOU...
MARY IS THE MOTHER OF SON OF GOD,
FATHER=SON...?
JESHUA=JAVEH?...
I^M NOT BELIEVER AND I KNOW THAT...AND YOU DON´T KNOW???
MrTEMPLARIO1971 1 year ago
@MrTEMPLARIO1971
The doctrine of the Trinitiy (which is accepted by both Catholics and Protestants) states that God is a triune God, 1 God in the beings (Father, Son and Holy Spirit). These three being are distinct yet one. Since the Virgin Mary gave birth to Jesus, the Son, she is the Mother of God.
ieatbruins4bfast 1 year ago
@ieatbruins4bfast But it WAS in "infallible" statement. "We declare, say, define, and pronounce that it is absolutely necessary for the salvation of every human creature to be subject to the Roman Pontiff (Pope Boniface VIII, the Bull Unan Snactam, 1302). INFALLIBLE PAPAL STATEMENT
kiwichristian2009 1 year ago
@ieatbruins4bfast Nowhere does the Bible says Mary was sinless or the exception to sin passed on from each generation. For such a miraculous event the Bible surely would have spoken to this issue. Catholics do not find this doctrine from the context of Scripture but from making a pretext out of the Scripture from their Church tradition (which happens to be written down). But again it is not apostolic tradition.
kiwichristian2009 1 year ago
@ieatbruins4bfast But Jesus existed WAY before even marys PARENTS were born, so don't spring me this "mother of god" nonsense!
kiwichristian2009 11 months ago
well say all you said with Catholic. because Jesus the Christ instituted the Catholic Church and holds oral and writing tradition.
wow just because Archangel Gabriel hailed her doesn't mean anything isnt he a messanger of God? and if you know that is in the New Testament. on she is the mother of God the Son the second part of the Holy Trinity. so she is the mother of God.
14alonso88 2 years ago
mistake second person of the Holy Trinity.
God incarnated. exactly human form so Jesus the Christ not God?
14alonso88 1 year ago
Who said that you will have to Catholic in order to be saved? I M CATHALIC AND I DO NOT AGREE WITH YOU...AND WHO ARE YOU TALKING TO? MARY IS THE MOTHER OF GOD!!! WE ARE NOT PUTTING MARY ABOVE GOD...YOU ARE REALLY CONFUSED....
103lollipop 2 years ago
YOU ARE CONFUSED!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Eduardonueve 2 years ago
Amazing, now, ANY one thinks to understand God``s TRUTH just because of reading the Bible,,
This girl has a lot of "predjudiced" questions
No where in teh Bible said SHE is the ultimate "authority" to say what the Bible means`and what it doesn`t mean
"EGO" raises its voices every time I heard this protestants
Te problem with our Mother Mary with this protestans is their poor understanding of God they have
Also, it is seen in Genesis "You (satan) and this woman will hate each other"
mjmenjivar 2 years ago 2
Aproposito, no where in Scripture says that all I have to is to have faith in Christ to be saved, the faith of which the Bible mentions is not merely a simple act of saying a bealive in You Jesus, but is an active faith which is very diferent.
jorgeramirez01 2 years ago
The assertion of the true Church that there is no salvation outside the Church does not refer to those who without fault do not know Christ and the Church he founded.
jorgeramirez01 2 years ago
Well I think you're wrong, the Catholic church dose not teach that you have to be catholic to be save, (CCC 846-848; (ref.: Summa Theologiae III, q.68, a.2).
jorgeramirez01 2 years ago
@jorgeramirez01 "We declare, say, define, and pronounce that it is absolutely necessary for the salvation of every human creature to be subject to the Roman Pontiff (Pope Boniface VIII, the Bull Unan Snactam, 1302). INFALLIBLE PAPAL STATEMENT
kiwichristian2009 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I wish you would see my church, not as a material thing, or just a physical thing. I rephrase, is not my church, I follow its principles. Lets try not to blame the church, church is human, lets instead see ourselves and critisize how we are following His teachings, by throwing rocks at eachother? or by Really make a connection with Him.God bless you all. God bless La Santa Iglesia Catolica. Deo Gratias.
gc18gc 2 years ago
Catholic answer to "must be a Catholic to be saved":
Catechism Catholic Church 169: Salvation comes from God alone; but because we receive the life of faith through the Church, she is our mother: We believe the Church as the mother of our new birth, but not in the Church as if she were the author of our salvation. Because she is our mother, she is also our teacher in the faith.
Q: If your mother teaches you wrongly, is it harder to be saved?
There sits the confict in this child.
unclesmrgol 2 years ago
Why shouldn't we hail mary? Her argument here is false -- What does Elizabeth say to her when she meets Mary after Mary becomes pregnant with Jesus? In Luke: She [Elizabeth] gave a loud cry and said, 'Of all women you are the most blessed, and blessed is the fruit of your womb. Why should I be honored with a visit from the mother of my Lord?"
If you believe that Scripture is correct, and Jesus the Risen Lord is God, then Mary is indeed the mother of God. If not, she isn't. QED.
unclesmrgol 2 years ago
La chica del video ilustra el eterno problema de los protestantes: quieren interpretar la Palabra de Dios como ellos quieren, y no como Jesús quiere. Jesús estableció el criterio de autoridad para interpretar la Palabra cuando dijo SOLAMENTE a sus apóstoles "Quien a vosotros escucha, a Mí me escucha". Jesús fundó UNA sola Iglesia. La Iglesia de Jesucristo es la Católica, y los apóstoles son el Papa y sus Obispos.
Hector3112 2 years ago
catholic church sucks!
SargentoArmani 2 years ago
Jesus é a verdade o caminho e a vida!
Tudo posso naquele que me fortalece!
Olha Deus é o unico Salvador!
Pra quem não entende jesus é Deus são um so!
Jesus disse eu estou no pai e ele em mim!
Leiem joão 14-11!
Não existe nenhum Deus a mais existe apenas um!
Ele é o unico salvador Jesus cristo!
E jesus não tem mãe teve so na terra e nada mais ele é o unico salvador!
Amém!
Dayan1234567 2 years ago
WHO told you and where does it say is bad to repeat some word an angel sent by God himself said??
thats what doesnt make sence
catholic are not putting her above God with that is just a prayer to god through mary we ask for intercesion not miracles from mary thats something that has to be really clear
Alicia6387 2 years ago 3
Mary IS the mother of God in heaven just like my mother will always be my mother no matter what in heaven my mother will be ask how she raised her children she will be considered my mother after dead so yes mary is the mother of God
Alicia6387 2 years ago 4
@Alicia6387 Rubbish. God has no beginning or end, my friend.
kiwichristian2009 1 year ago
@Alicia6387 Mary as you are talking about my dear Alicia, is Semiramis, google it and learn!
linotche13 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Alicia6387 "But when ye pray, use not vain repetitions, as the heathen do:" The Bible says pray to God only, Mary cannot hear us! She is no greater than you or I. Otherwise we would have some direct command from God/Jesus/Holy Spirit to pray/thank her. We do not have that command in the bible because she does NOT intercede, help or plead our case before God/Christ Submission to God is from God (grace) NOT Mary.
kiwichristian2009 1 year ago
bottomline THO!
Matthew 16:18 - Upon this rock (Peter) I will build my_ Church. And the gates of Hell can never overpower it
Alicia6387 2 years ago
Matthew 18:18 - Jesus gives to the Apostles the power to legislate
Timothy 3:15 - Church is called the "pillar and foundation of truth"
John 20:23 - Jesus gives to the Apostles the power to forgive sins
Matthew 16:18 - the gates of Hell will never prevail_ against Christ's Church
St. Irenaeus (200AD) "For where the Church is, there is the Spirit of God; and where the Spirit of God is, there the Church and every grace is. The Spirit, however, is Truth." (Against Heresies 3, 24, 1)
Alicia6387 2 years ago
@Alicia6387 Wrong. "you are petros ( a small pebble) and upon this petra ( a massive rock) I shall build My church....." Christ built His church upon Himself, upon the faith Peter had and upon our faith in Christ. Not Peter the person.
kiwichristian2009 1 year ago
@kiwichristian2009 that's ur OWN personal opinion.. i'm sorry i Desagree!
Alicia6387 1 year ago
@Alicia6387 Wrong. Peter is not the rock, because the 12 disciples, knowing well the OT, recognised the Rock as a description or name for God. Duet32:4,Psalms18:2,Psalm18:31
kiwichristian2009 1 year ago
@kiwichristian2009 please read Luke 6Ç48 - He is like a man which built an house, and digged deep, and laid the foundation on a rock: and when the flood arose, the stream beat vehemently upon that house, and could not shake it: for it was founded upon a rock.
linotche13 11 months ago
@linotche13 I have read it. My statement still stands.
kiwichristian2009 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@kiwichristian2009 please read Luke 6.48 - He is like a man which built an house, and digged deep, and laid the foundation on a rock: and when the flood arose, the stream beat vehemently upon that house, and could not shake it: for it was founded upon a rock.
linotche13 11 months ago
Someone can correct me on this but i believe if someone is being taught false teachings and they are not aware of it and are truly seeking God that that person will be saved and the person that taught the false teachings will be punished more.
gilbert4321 2 years ago
olha gente, eu sei que católicos e evangélicos tem suas diferenças, alguns creen que existam imagens milagrosas (coisa ke eu n acredito pq fala nos 10 mandamentos em exodos que n eh para crer em imagem ou escultura etc.), enfim, isto não é motivo de ofender uns aos outros, se eles creem nisso não culpe-os, eles podem ter crescido com esta religião e aostumaram, mas sem ofensas uns aos outros, respeitem as decisões uns dos outros que o mundo fica bem melhor para se vive ^^.
jheynison 2 years ago
acaso no dice la biblia que reinaremos con Jesus pobe evangelicos ellos no mas maria va estar en el infienro son vivboras ustesdes dicen basarse en la biblia y no se dan cuenta que la iglesia catolica es la que junto los libros de la biblia aparte los del pentateuco Raza protestante de Viboras
Pipleex 2 years ago
Catholics believe that Protestant Churches are true to God's teaching so long as they follow the teaching of the Church that was given God' authority and blueprint(the Catholic Church). There are a lot of Protestant Churches that incorporate almost all of the Catholic blueprint, so they predictably lead their flock to Salvation, but since they are facsimiles of the True blueprint, they fall short. So Catholics believe many Protestants are more "Catholic" than most Catholics.
bill0756 2 years ago
you go girl, God bless!!
leonororozco 2 years ago
sinto pena dos catolicos
h1lk1a 2 years ago
logico q maria nao é mae de deus sua yanke ridicula ,,jesus nao é deus entao ela nao é mae de deus evangelicos dementes
malucocta 2 years ago
catolicos sao porcos
h1lk1a 2 years ago
concordo com vc em partes a igreja catolica pode ser taxada de porca, com toda certeza oq eu fico adimirado e essa corja de crentes que é muito pior q os catolicos que nao passam de cria do catolicismo,uzam um livro que foi formatado pela catolica 'biblia',e ainda querem faalr merda vs fedem mt mais que os catolicos essa corja norte americana infelismente esta invadinado nosso brasil,fodase inglaterra e eua,e toda essa merda ke vem de la
malucocta 2 years ago
you are crzy. Accually Jesus founded the CATHOLIC CHURCH, the others were founded by fools and false profets like Luther and Calvin. And their Bibles are also incomplete with all the good stuff their is to read in it. BUT your church doesnt save you. I only help because God wants you devoded in a COMMUNITY.
reyconcristo1 2 years ago
En ningun lado de la Biblia dice ke María es "la reina del cielo", como aducen los catolicos
nicelooking21 2 years ago
You should abandon your arrogance and repent. Search in your heart and ask yourself who's traditions you should put your faith in.
JDZwiers19 2 years ago
The Ecumenical Council of Ephesus in 431 AD declared that Mary was the Mother of God. This was a united Church who decided this, before any divisions and schisms took place, over 1000 years before protestants corrupted the faith of their fathers. Christians have said "Hail Mary" since the apostles walked the earth. Who do you think you are to condemn a doctrine founded by Christ through the fathers of the church?
JDZwiers19 2 years ago
@JDZwiers19 Show me ONE instance in the Bible of a MAN or WOMAN saying "hail mary", please
kiwichristian2009 11 months ago
@kiwichristian2009
I don't even understand how a question like this is relevent?
JDZwiers19 11 months ago
@JDZwiers19 I am mearly asking you to substantiate your claims. If your claims are truthful, you will be able to supply evidence to support it. Again, you are diverting away rather than answering. Remember God teaches us to always have an answer for our faith. Do you have blind faith?
kiwichristian2009 11 months ago
@JDZwiers19 The Bible declares that God and Christ had no creator or mother or father. Thanks, but i will stick with the Bible on this one, my friend. :)
kiwichristian2009 11 months ago
Interesting. I wonder, who should I rely on, the councils and decrees of the Catholic Church going back 2,000 years, or a little girl on YouTube. I think the answer is clear!
elcamaras 2 years ago
On any of them. Do not rely on religion!
GodIprefermyDog 2 years ago
@GodIprefermyDog Do not rely on your STUPIDITY. Stop making dumb videos, please, little girl. No one cares about what you think. Why don't you study harder to get good grades? why don't you help your mom cleaning your damn house? are you on your period?? Geez... fucking teenagers piss me off.
ChrisDaron 1 year ago
@ChrisDaron Wow, mature language. It doesnt impress anyone, my friend.
kiwichristian2009 11 months ago
@kiwichristian2009 I'm not your friend. I don't even know you. So don't come here all friendly with me. Don't be a hypocrite, Protestant.
ChrisDaron 11 months ago
@ChrisDaron Well, i am still yours even if you are not mine, my friend. So, what am i a hypocrite about/over? Also, i am not a protestant.
kiwichristian2009 11 months ago
@kiwichristian2009 You Protestant the Catholic faith, and you call yourself a "Christian". You're Protestant.
ChrisDaron 11 months ago
@elcamaras Whell, if you consider the Catholic church was created by a pagan, to save his Impery, Rome, I'm talking about Constatine, so is much better to rely on this young girl, becouse she is talking in accordance to the Word of God! Think, it still time to redemption. God Bless you!
linotche13 11 months ago
@elcamaras How about relying on the Word of God which condemns nearly ALL catholic teachings?
kiwichristian2009 11 months ago
Te falta muuuuuuuuuucho que interiorisar, estas leeeeeeeeejos , awaaaaaaaay from the heaven, cielo, te basas en puras pendejadas eres aun una adolecente que no entiende nada de la biblia.
tomaspepino 2 years ago
U2, mi friend.
jimmyjmv 2 years ago
creer en jesus es actuar y creer en lo que dijo, no basta con solo creer en su existencia, si no que creer y vivir respecto a lo que crees que es la verdad y esa verdad es actuar como dijo jesus, si haces mal y mucho mal y te arrepientes igual puedes ir al infierno.
Pero el infierno no es lo que crees
Protestantes son idiotas que no saben leer poesia los catolicos la leen un poco mejor y los evangelicos son unos analfabetos culeaos.
En todo caso los filosofos agnosticos son superiores.
tomaspepino 2 years ago
yo creo que te vas a ir al infierno.
tomaspepino 2 years ago
yes and no....craddle catholics believe that and hail mary is being recited for when he is supposed to be born when we say that it is for the rosary which is the mysterys of what events occured you think we hold mary high cause you hold god to low if we thought she was the main squeeze then we would say she died for us..you try to say these words to over bear our faith i bet you cant tell me what the word catholic means...it means universal and us christians all are on the same team
Babyboy0033 2 years ago
@Babyboy0033 There are TEN times more prayers to mary than to God. You are putting mary HIGHER! Shame on oyU!
kiwichristian2009 11 months ago
no entendi ni el ingles ni el port¿uges...,,.............................pero ccreo q dijo q los catolicos son lo sverdaderos hijos de jesucristo,,jejeje,,no es cierto protesyantes,,,pero ps si,,nimodo estasn mal
inundacions 2 years ago
No le entiendo al inglés, meeeeenos al portugués.
Catholica67 2 years ago
Go do more research! Faith alone cannot save you!
imundiath 2 years ago
And you too read more about faith and Jesus words an maybe you learn.
Grand inquisitor defender of the Pope lies!!
BrunoLuizdeMello 2 years ago
You dont have to be a catholic to be saved, you must follow Jesus in truth and absolution and then you are saved.
RockyBalboa211 2 years ago
My God
Dayanne1213 3 years ago
salvo es tener jesucristo en tu corazon
y arrepentirte del pecado
apatosaurio15 3 years ago
esta pendeja habla con una actitud intimidatoria, si quiere que se la responda, que hable con un sacerdote.
deagossttini 3 years ago
i meant "Mary".... anyhow.... 1 Timothy tells you there is only one mediator between men and God. ....and one more point.... GOd existed before Mary..... he only CAME TO EARTH as a man (like a baby) through her..... your own bible proves that. so mother of GOD?... Fails...
Bassics85 3 years ago
@Bassics85 Amen!
kiwichristian2009 11 months ago
and by the way... about the marry forgiving sins and other things...... since you like Timothy so much let me quote 1 Timothy 2:5 to you: "For there is one God, and one mediator between God and men, the man Christ Jesus" ....
Bassics85 3 years ago
você com certeza é evangelica! isso tudo q vc falou é tudo um monte de nada. é a mesma coisa de falar que catolico adora imagem, continua...
Conektar 3 years ago
Evangélica é a menina do vídeo, eu só tô mostrando a briga de católicos e evangélicos.
GodIprefermyDog 3 years ago
si maria tuviese pecado no podria contener a LA SEGUNDA PERSONA DE LA TRINIDAD.
deagossttini 3 years ago
hey girl just say 1 timothy 2:5 and bam no mary intercesor problems anymore.
xRac18x 3 years ago
no mamen no le entiendo nada
charlyel24 3 years ago
Esa chica repite varias veces la misma cosa... en el catolicismo esta la verdad segun catolicos, en el protestantismo esta el camino, segun evangelicos, sabemos que la salvacion viene de jesus... pero que es la fe sin obras??? es la idea sin la accion
Cómo demuestro que tengo fe? solo hablando y alabando? y el amor al projimo o peor, el amor al enemigo? la caridad? eso es secundario acaso?, que Dios te bendiga y te tenga en su gracia hermano.
deagossttini 3 years ago
Reasoning of this girl does not make sense. SHE IS EXPRESSING HER OWN OPINIONS but she does not convince anybody with three fingers of forehead.
mpulidge 3 years ago
if you go by scripture you should know this verse because of the athority of the church. Mt 18: 17 "if he refuses to listen even to the church". what church? 1tim3: 15 pilar and foundation of truth. So if your church was not founed by Christ 2000 years ago, you are in a church that has no athority to preach. your fallowing a man and not Christ and his Catholic church. even the bible says the church has the truth. Hell can't prevail against it. Don't question scripture blessings
1tim315carlos 3 years ago
I'm not protestant, but who said the church mentioned in the bible is the catholic? WHO on earth said that Jesus of the bible founded catholic church? Sorry, the name "catholic " is not there so that the term church may refer to any church either protestant, mormon, JW etc. Another thing, this stupid catholic church started to exist about 300 after christ, the anciente Christianity was NOT catholic church.
GodIprefermyDog 3 years ago
Look dog....300 yrs after Christ the christian church was called universal. Greek word for uiversal is Catholic it's the same church with a name. Not a protestant church w/name.1tim3:15 the true church. if you r not protestant that means you r Catholic. u say the anciente Christianity was NOT catholic what was it? could it be one u mentoned? could one of those be the church that 1tim3:15 talks about? NO they can't. these names came 1500 yrs after Christ using a Catholic book the (BIBLE)
1tim315carlos 3 years ago
No, the ancient Christianity WAS NOT catholic, let alone Roman Catholic! No, I'm not neither protestant nor catholic, I'm free. Ancient christianity did not know catholic dogmas like the Trinity, the Roman Pope and hailing Mary as if she was a Godess.
GodIprefermyDog 3 years ago
Look dog first let talk freedom either you are free or slave. Either Catholic or protestant most people in the world are protestant. thats ok. The Bible says hot or cold. make your chioce not excuses. 2nd back up all u say if you don't, it leads me to think no credibility
1tim315carlos 3 years ago
All I say is a repetition of what christianity scholars have already said, but I don't expect christians to grasp their religion was invented in a certain place and time. Why HOT or COLD? There's mild too. Isn't it obvious that an atheist is neither a catholic nor a protestant?
GodIprefermyDog 3 years ago
if you protest any teaching of the catholic church you are protestant. it doesn't mean that you are christian if you are protestant. You can be muslim, all you have to be is a non Catholic. on another piont you made christian scholars ARE Catholics. did you mean protestant scholars. Well back to my original point. paul speaks about a church having the truth. Can you tell me the name of the that church? cuz thats the church that I must belong to, the one that holds the TRUTH!!!
1tim315carlos 3 years ago
I understand your point. You do not view 'Protestant' as a denomination of a religious group per se, but all those who are not catholic. So an atheist would be protestant? Well, I see protestant as all christians who separated from the catholic church which in fact was the first worldwide organized christian church. (cont)
GodIprefermyDog 3 years ago
We have a point: Paul wrote to many churches (EPISTLES)which were the 1st christian churches. But what similarities can you see in them and the current catholic church? More, this catholic church is Roman. Paul doesn't mention a lot of catholic thoughts. He doesn't mention Mary, he doesnt talk about the authority of the pope. He doesn't talk about the mass of saints of the Roman church. cont
GodIprefermyDog 3 years ago
He does not mention Vatrican OR the trinity. These are all catholic inventions different from the 1st church. Ok, Catholics came before protestants, JWs, Mormons. But waht is your base to say it's the real church? What similarities do you see between catholics and the ancient chritianity bearing in mind the points I exposed?
GodIprefermyDog 3 years ago
Clergy 1tim 3:1 Bishops 1tim3:8 deacons Tit 1:5 priests, power to speak w/Crist's voice Lk 10:16
We baptise Act 8:12
We confirm Act 8:14-17
We aniont the sick Mk 6:12-13 James 5:14-15
Ministry of confession (reconciliation) 2Cor 5:17-20
We marry Mt 19:5-6, Heb 13:4
We participate in communion 1Cor 10:16
seven sacraments of the Catholic church I was brief with scpriture there's much more, thats only scratching the surface. now your church what does it offer?
1tim315carlos 3 years ago
Vatican, trinity? Ave Maria's prayer? I don't have any church, I'm free
GodIprefermyDog 3 years ago
google vatican and trinity for info, ave maria most of it is biblical it's in lukes gospel. what are you getting at w/ the vatican or trinity? and by free does that mean you are your own pope free to make infalible athoritative interpretations, or a non believer
1tim315carlos 3 years ago
I'm not religious (hence my nick), but Ave Maria, THE Pope and the Trinity are not biblical at all.
GodIprefermyDog 3 years ago
Trinity is shown in the start of the bible when god says "we" when building the world. Also Jesus gave us Mary as a mother and called her woman, and the only time god calls someone woman.. is with eve. She is the new eve, and she is the mother of God in the human form, but Jesus was God and man, and not solely human..
RockyBalboa211 2 years ago
This is entirely YOUR interpretation. No part in the bible says God is co-substancial with Christ as Atanasius invented. Biblically speaking, Jesus can't be eternal as God since he was His first born. To be a first born he had to be born someday and everythingthat is born did not exist some time in the past.
GodIprefermyDog 2 years ago
@GodIprefermyDog
wow so what does the gospel of John begin??
or how about what Thomas says " MY LORD, AND MY GOD"
or try reading Hebrews.
Jesus is God made Flesh.
14alonso88 1 year ago
@GodIprefermyDog
Ave Maria = Hail Mary and that is how Gabriel greated Mary so its biblical. Pope Jesus gave the Keys to Peter and passed down to protect against heresy
14alonso88 1 year ago
@14alonso88 He gave it to the Apostles. He did NOT give the authority for them to be passed down! The "keys" as such was the Gospel!
kiwichristian2009 11 months ago
@kiwichristian2009 really? from what i read it says Peter. so Christ did not tell Peter to feed his sheep? the pillar of truth is the church or am i wrong? or that in Pentecost the Holy Spirit descended upon the Apostles and Christ promised to stay with them until the end of time. just one last question when was the gospel written down?
14alonso88 11 months ago
@14alonso88 No, it was the apostles. Yes, He did say that to Peter. What was Peter in charge of? What was Paul in charge of? I should not say "in charge of", but "mission entrusted with". Now you are starting to try an argument regarding the Word of God and scriptures, and i will not get into that at this moment, for i can see your motive is not for truth, but for arguing and ego. I could be wrong though.
kiwichristian2009 11 months ago
(i will look into the other things later).... but 'priests: luke 10:16 ??? fail..... i think you should read that verse again.... and tell me where does Jesus mention any priests or authorizes anyone as 'the' person having the power to speak with his voice? i think you are twisting the text. let me quote it here for you>"He that heareth you heareth me; and he that despiseth you despiseth me; and he that despiseth me despiseth him that sent me" ... read chapter 10 from verse 1. be blsed
Bassics85 3 years ago
sorry no so clear
Tit 1:5 appoint presbyters
1tim 4:14 gift received thru laying on of hands of presbyterate
acts 14:22 they appointed presbyters in the church
acts 6:6 the apostles prayed and laid hands on them
acts 22:28 H.S. appointed you overseers, to tend church
blessings
1tim315carlos 2 years ago
@1tim315carlos Rubbish. These are not sacraments! Again, catholic man-made traditions, introduced at DIFFERENT times in history by different MEN.
kiwichristian2009 11 months ago
@GodIprefermyDog I don't think catholics have any idea what a "protestant" is. Technically, a "protestant" is a former member of the catholic cult that "protested" against its false teachings.
kiwichristian2009 11 months ago
@1tim315carlos Can you please show me this definition in official catholic source, please?
kiwichristian2009 11 months ago
@kiwichristian2009 Salutations from Stockton Ca WHAT DO YOU NEED DEFINED? WHAT DOES " SHOW ME THIS DEFINITION " MEAN?
I GUESS I DON'T UNDERSTAND WHAT POINT YOU ARE ASKING ABOUT.
Keep the love and peace
Your brother in Christ Carlos
1tim315carlos 11 months ago
@1tim315carlos I need to know what the official catholic organisations definition of a "protestant" is, please. The point is that several catholics have given me different definitions, and i need to know the OFFICIAL definition.
kiwichristian2009 11 months ago
@kiwichristian2009
Salutations Brother Dean peace be to you.
I'll look in to it, but why the HANG UP on the definition?
keep the love and peace
1tim315carlos 11 months ago
Comment removed
TheNonjudgemental 11 months ago
@GodIprefermyDog The early church as described in the NT did the following: shared all things in common, relationships, support missionaries/ministers, teaching & preaching, praying, worshiping, reading of scripture, evangelism, fostering spiritual gifts. No where does the NT dictate fancy buildings, robes, repetitive prayer, a priesthood, Mary worship, sectarianism, or any order of service, etc.. all these are man made traditions added on.
kiwichristian2009 11 months ago