Stop Jewish agenda in USA.Free America from those Ashkenazi criminals.
Jewish satanist.No wonder the Bible call them,The Synagogue of satan(Revelation 2:9,,3:9).Read this important book for free to see what those jews have prepare for you America.
Who Is Esau-Edom. Who Is Esau-Edom.
We have exterminated the property owners in Russia. We are going to do the same thing in Europe and America.
Both sides are to blame. When Bush Jr was in office, his administration passed many things that screwed us up like the Bush Doctrine. Now, under Obama and his administration, we have the stimulus, which wasted billions, healthcare bill, which caused higher unemployment, and both caused the national debt to skyrocket.
To think this problem was caused by poor/middle class or most democrats is asinine. Commodity Futures Modernization Act of 2000,Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act, are the main problem(all legislation passed by REPUBLICANS)
Most economists state that the 1999 legislation spearheaded by Gramm-- the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act — was significantly to blame for the 2007 subprime mortgage crisis and 2008 global economic crisis
have you had a chance to look at this animation yet? a 14-year-old's animation with humor and clarity explains the crash of 2008 in 60 seconds!!!!!!!!
for a quick, 60-second informative and funny tour of why Mr. Barney Frank is in trouble electorally, take a look at (by googling these words:) "Barney Frank takes us for a ride" animation
I was wondering if you could help our cause to unseat Mr. Frank by post and insert or embedding of this animation
how McCains campaign manager belonged to the Home Ownership Alliance,which defended Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae against stricter regulations paying him over $2 Million. What did they get for their money? Access to John McCain.
Well it looks like Barney Frank got caught again. This time he's exposed trying con the former treasurer Paulson, into bailing out a local bank back in Mass. Liberal Dems, just never change. Scamin the TARP money, whats new?
republicans like myself are blaming Phil Gramm, Paulson and Bush for increasing governent through a TARP that the majority didn't want to have passed. The CRA blame was blown WAY out of proportion to protect criminal bankers. Don't worry both sides did this.
Yes you're "GOP" in Congress are getting sweetened offers to pass this thing. They're all corrupt. Get a day job and quit protecting them.
Funny how people like qarohc call something crap when it goes against what they believe or when they can't argue with facts. When they see the facts right in front of them the best defense they come up with is saying because it is on Fox News it is crap. An independent group did a study back during the 2008 elections and found that out of all of the networks, Fox News was the ONLY channel that gave equal positive coverage to BOTH Obama and McCain. All the other net works slanted to Obama.
McCain had a terrible campaign and fox news being the republican propaganda outlet had to make it seem passable. If you think McCain had a good campaign ask Palin, and if you still think it was a good campaign ask any independent voter what he/she thinks of Palin.
If you think fox "news" is balanced you may want to consider moving to a country with a dictatorship like Cuba for example so you can listen to propaganda all day long with little to no actual press coverage.
I would never say FOX is balanced, but what do you call the likes of [every other network] completely selling out to the Obama-Cons? We unearthed one of the greatest scams in recorded history - and, yes, I am referring to Climategate - but not one your liberal networks provided a minute of coverage?! Well, not until they were able to confer with the IPCC, the CRU, Al Gore and host of other panels before getting their stories straight!
I do agree, however, McCain/Palin ran a horrid campaign, ultimately leading to their own demise. Then again, Barney Frank holding public office greater than one of a local, municipal tax collector is also a grave injustice to the American people. This prick should be leveled at the knees and dropped into viral-ridden cesspool.
Btw- i wasn't trying to say that McCain ran a horrible campaign and therefore republicans are stupid (as you are implying).
I said that McCain ran a horrible campaign and the news sources reported on it(this is why McCain had negative coverage on all news sources). But Fox news is a propaganda outlet and had to prop him up regardless of how good or bad reality was surrounding him.
you need to turn off your Alex Jones or Limbaugh or whoever the hell is rotting your brain.
And like i said before "I cant believe how American citizens are willing to defend a propaganda outlet. This is America not soviet Russia. "
Fox news has forced the other news sources to go down the toilet.
And what is it with this motif of oh look my guy is a sick corporate shill but look at this other guy he is an asshole so ill keep propping up my preferred asshole?
I'll guess we'll just have to agree to disagree...
However, the fact of the matter is; the polls are reflecting that most Americans now see the man for his true colors - not literally, of course, 'cause I'm not so sure even he remembers his true origin - and I assure you they will not make the same mistake in 2012. As a matter of fact, the redemption will be taking place much, much sooner. Some of these Congressional Democratic "lifers" will be getting the boot and quite soon.
fox "news" picks and chooses only the pieces that make their people (republicans) look good and make the democrats look bad. Anything fox news spews out is in order to manipulate the gullible.
Giving any credibility to these dishonest assholes is to take part in the crumbling of the United States. They have had a huge part in the destruction of our free press.
I cant believe how American citizens are willing to defend a propaganda outlet. This is America not soviet Russia.
Cornswalled Their tactic didn't work for people who pay attention. It worked when it came to the liberals. That's why the idiots are still in Congress and Senate - because the lib-Dems continue to vote for them because they don't have the mental capability to pay attention or even understand.
please keep this vid circulating. the us government has taken this video down. it's now playing through canadian accounts. don't let them take down every vid. let everyone know!!!!!!!!!!
The Republicans had no real idea of the magnitude of this problem, and didn't work hard enough to fix it. Do I blame the Democrats? Yes. Is it all their fault...probably not. Honestly, though what's the difference between D & R? Pelosi, Frank and Schumer should be in jail...with Bush, Cheney and Rumsfeld. We have to start over in this country.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Cheney lied repeatedly about the intelligence leading to the war (that one I can prove). Rumsfeld was an incompetent boob who also manipulated data. Bush had to apologize and say "my bad" for the crappy intelligence, and lied numerous times about the connection between al qaida and Iraq. The war was started on lies. Funny you have no comment on the Democrats I mentioned. Partisan at all? Open your eyes
voting .. lol... you sheeple sill dont get it... ITS ALL RIGGED... Obama will win but before you all get excited about it... he is FRAUD and just another puppet for the elite rulers... you think hes gonna solve all the financial problems? LOL.... the whole system is a circus and your just watching pretending that your votes matter... when will u all learn.
The root of the problem is that both parties are polotitions and not suprisingly don't know how to run the goverment, country, or usualy themselves. Party dosn't matter beacuse both sides are corupt, ignorant, and disregard the consequences of their actions.
republicans MAY NOT be innocent. However, they are patriots and would not manipulate economy the way Franklin Raines, Jim Johnson, Jamie Gorelick, Cris Dodd and Barney Frank did(wow-all democrats!).There is something fishy happening and involves a lot of money going to Acorn-which I don't know why this "community organizer" group is involved with housing, much less the $700 billion bailout. This group has corrupted the election process, and for some reason gets $500 for EVERY failed mortgage?!?!
this is the democrats fault, there not making republicans as the "hero" How about you use your ears and listen up rather than listening to democrat scums.
The democrats do promote the unions that are destroying the businesses. Big Uninon, which is now corupt. The problem is not just Democrats. While the democrats commit more cimes to get into office, NITHER party can run the country because they both want to control all they can and only truly want big orgnizations that are usualy corupt due to their size. It is just statics for why there is courption. Having said thay the problim is the brainwashing that makes you tink in terms of GOP or DEM.
Drive-by voters will not care.. They will blame President Bush because he is in Power at the moment. Hopefully the majority of people in this Country will seek the Truth before they vote..
This crisis was caused by giving a house to people who CAN'T afford to pay for it. Who made this legislation? Republican administration, Clinton and Bush. So keep spending trillions in wars and bailouts, the US will not be a good place to be living in the next 5 to 20 years.
well the repub's could of stood up for the american's and voted against the bill like they did on tuesdaybut they got in line like the good phonies that they are , both sides are fraud's and this country need's people that will look out for the best intrest for the tax payers
I agree. But we saw after they did not vote for it, the stock market almost crashed... so we are caught in the socialist trap ALREADY. We had to do this to survive another day. So the options are nill. This vid clip is just to show that the one sided media coverage that the dems are rescuing rather than unscrewing the mess they helped create is bull%$#t.
i dont know about you, but markets crashing doesnt bother me at all. So melt down or not wont hurt me. I want the market to crash then it can be truly fixed. I know a simple way of getting that billion dollars back. Decrim marijuana and right there is a 700 a year billion business plus the 500 billion they spend would be saved on the truth commercials you watch. Be no different when the depression happened and they lifted alcohol prohibition to save the day. and it did.
There is a problem with that idea. Historicaly when drugs, and prostotution are legalized they are usualy run by orgnized crime. Even when they are legal that tends to remain true. Adationaly when alachol was taken form orgnized crime we got the 50s whith the sterotypes of gangseres orininating from there. If you try to take orgnized crimes income sorce away without being prepared to forcably crush the orgnization you get the rampent cruption and violence return.
I could see there being some organized crime taking over on some, but wouldnt the criminals now be business men and be growing it on farms to send off to distrubitors like say like marlboro or whatever. Plus people wouldnt have to buy it from companies they could just produce there own long as they bought a tax stamp that allowed them to have so much.
No the problems that existed in the gansters area would resurface because orginized crime would forcably prevent people form being able to make any drugs. This dosn't applay to marijuana as that drug is so easy to grow that it is harder to prevent. The drugs that i am talking about is drugs like cocane and heroine. The dugs that take some sophicated manufacutaring to make. Thoes will never leave orgnized crime's hands.
You obviously don't understand how politics work, or you wouldn't be blaming the Republicans, or would you. Back in 2004, Maxine Waters, Gregory Meeks, Arthur Davis, Lacy Clay and Barney Frnk did everything but call the regulator and Republicans "racist" so, we let you have your way, and now look at what the Democrats did, created this mess. You can sit there all day long and spin it the way you want, but the rest of American knows who is responsible. Stop being a moron!
I unfortunatly have more experience that you might expect form somone who is not a polotician since i was stuck in the middle of it form the age of 5. Nobody seems to realize just how much a kid can absorb. Polotics involves attacking a persons stands by making them appear immoral if you disagere with them. Because of that the only people who want to get into politics are people without morals or stances ont isues, just a desire for power. We turned politics into a race of courption.
Frank you damn FRAUD!!
ed2kou1 3 months ago
@RollingOnThrough
>CNN, MSNBC, NPR
>Tries being serious, but fails 1 second after.
I thought libtards didn't exist anymore. I guess I'm wrong.
gamefreak1000000 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Stop Jewish agenda in USA.Free America from those Ashkenazi criminals.
Jewish satanist.No wonder the Bible call them,The Synagogue of satan(Revelation 2:9,,3:9).Read this important book for free to see what those jews have prepare for you America.
Who Is Esau-Edom. Who Is Esau-Edom.
We have exterminated the property owners in Russia. We are going to do the same thing in Europe and America.
(The Jew,December 1925,Zinobit)
MsMihailescu 1 year ago
Both sides are to blame. When Bush Jr was in office, his administration passed many things that screwed us up like the Bush Doctrine. Now, under Obama and his administration, we have the stimulus, which wasted billions, healthcare bill, which caused higher unemployment, and both caused the national debt to skyrocket.
Soulstealer354 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
To think this problem was caused by poor/middle class or most democrats is asinine. Commodity Futures Modernization Act of 2000,Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act, are the main problem(all legislation passed by REPUBLICANS)
Most economists state that the 1999 legislation spearheaded by Gramm-- the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act — was significantly to blame for the 2007 subprime mortgage crisis and 2008 global economic crisis
MrBishopWalters 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Please vote for Sean Bielat!
john51880 1 year ago
have you had a chance to look at this animation yet? a 14-year-old's animation with humor and clarity explains the crash of 2008 in 60 seconds!!!!!!!!
for a quick, 60-second informative and funny tour of why Mr. Barney Frank is in trouble electorally, take a look at (by googling these words:) "Barney Frank takes us for a ride" animation
I was wondering if you could help our cause to unseat Mr. Frank by post and insert or embedding of this animation
Theanimatorman1 1 year ago
California, can't you do better than this guy?
mre2u2 1 year ago
INTERNET FREEDOM AS YOU KNOW IT WILL BE GONE!
I'd like you to meet the ACTA (Anti-Counterfeiting Trade Agreement):
ACTA internet-censorship will abolish any political website that the Government deems "unsuitable". WANNA HELP OR ASK US QUESTIONS?
THREE W DOT herp DOT in/i/
zerogod420 1 year ago
Barney Frank is a crook, why is he not in prison?
ZinnerNC 1 year ago
@ZinnerNC the same reason why the entire obama administration isn't.
They're re-writing the laws as they go along, and ruining this countries very fabric.
This next election won't come soon enough!
AzBirdDog 5 months ago
how McCains campaign manager belonged to the Home Ownership Alliance,which defended Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae against stricter regulations paying him over $2 Million. What did they get for their money? Access to John McCain.
beachnative420 1 year ago
Well it looks like Barney Frank got caught again. This time he's exposed trying con the former treasurer Paulson, into bailing out a local bank back in Mass. Liberal Dems, just never change. Scamin the TARP money, whats new?
signalcorp4 1 year ago
You guys should get back to listening to more prisonplanet, since you're all brainwashed and will believe anything the media tells you...
Quit supporting propaganda morons! This is AMERICA, NOT RUSSIA!
mindmymanors 2 years ago
Even when hearing Barney Frank in his own words, major media still blames Bush for the failure of the democrats.
tomandkelly 2 years ago
@tomandkelly
republicans like myself are blaming Phil Gramm, Paulson and Bush for increasing governent through a TARP that the majority didn't want to have passed. The CRA blame was blown WAY out of proportion to protect criminal bankers. Don't worry both sides did this.
Yes you're "GOP" in Congress are getting sweetened offers to pass this thing. They're all corrupt. Get a day job and quit protecting them.
therealcaptobvious 2 years ago 5
Funny how people like qarohc call something crap when it goes against what they believe or when they can't argue with facts. When they see the facts right in front of them the best defense they come up with is saying because it is on Fox News it is crap. An independent group did a study back during the 2008 elections and found that out of all of the networks, Fox News was the ONLY channel that gave equal positive coverage to BOTH Obama and McCain. All the other net works slanted to Obama.
hwd2244 2 years ago
@hwd2244
McCain had a terrible campaign and fox news being the republican propaganda outlet had to make it seem passable. If you think McCain had a good campaign ask Palin, and if you still think it was a good campaign ask any independent voter what he/she thinks of Palin.
If you think fox "news" is balanced you may want to consider moving to a country with a dictatorship like Cuba for example so you can listen to propaganda all day long with little to no actual press coverage.
qarohc 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
@qarohc
I would never say FOX is balanced, but what do you call the likes of [every other network] completely selling out to the Obama-Cons? We unearthed one of the greatest scams in recorded history - and, yes, I am referring to Climategate - but not one your liberal networks provided a minute of coverage?! Well, not until they were able to confer with the IPCC, the CRU, Al Gore and host of other panels before getting their stories straight!
Even this should disgust a devout liberal...
fred1671 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I do agree, however, McCain/Palin ran a horrid campaign, ultimately leading to their own demise. Then again, Barney Frank holding public office greater than one of a local, municipal tax collector is also a grave injustice to the American people. This prick should be leveled at the knees and dropped into viral-ridden cesspool.
fred1671 2 years ago
Btw- i wasn't trying to say that McCain ran a horrible campaign and therefore republicans are stupid (as you are implying).
I said that McCain ran a horrible campaign and the news sources reported on it(this is why McCain had negative coverage on all news sources). But Fox news is a propaganda outlet and had to prop him up regardless of how good or bad reality was surrounding him.
qarohc 2 years ago
"Climategate " lol
you need to turn off your Alex Jones or Limbaugh or whoever the hell is rotting your brain.
And like i said before "I cant believe how American citizens are willing to defend a propaganda outlet. This is America not soviet Russia. "
Fox news has forced the other news sources to go down the toilet.
And what is it with this motif of oh look my guy is a sick corporate shill but look at this other guy he is an asshole so ill keep propping up my preferred asshole?
qarohc 2 years ago 2
I'll guess we'll just have to agree to disagree...
However, the fact of the matter is; the polls are reflecting that most Americans now see the man for his true colors - not literally, of course, 'cause I'm not so sure even he remembers his true origin - and I assure you they will not make the same mistake in 2012. As a matter of fact, the redemption will be taking place much, much sooner. Some of these Congressional Democratic "lifers" will be getting the boot and quite soon.
Thank GOD!!
fred1671 2 years ago
Next time mention fox news so people dont have to bother clicking on this crap.
If i saw a man on fox news with a gun in his hand shooting people i wouldnt believe it till i saw it on a real news source.
qarohc 2 years ago
ok, you hate fox
it's ok for the democrats and reps to keep up the lies
continue giving us fake numbers about the economy
keep telling us everything is ok, while we watch our great country drown
it's ok if they take over oil companies and any other company they want
i quess you hate cspan also since that's where most of this info is coming from
5837654932 2 years ago
fox "news" picks and chooses only the pieces that make their people (republicans) look good and make the democrats look bad. Anything fox news spews out is in order to manipulate the gullible.
Giving any credibility to these dishonest assholes is to take part in the crumbling of the United States. They have had a huge part in the destruction of our free press.
I cant believe how American citizens are willing to defend a propaganda outlet. This is America not soviet Russia.
qarohc 2 years ago 2
what news source do you watch?
8thEastTexasBlues 2 years ago
Comment removed
macman237 1 year ago
@qarohc
Gee, and MSNBC is "balanced"? What a LAUGH--just like all LibCowards :)
macman237 1 year ago
Libtards? Lying???
What a shocker!
Cornswalled 2 years ago
Cornswalled Libs lie and point fingers to try to keep people from seeing what a bunch of brain-dead idiots they are.
ccgraphics20 2 years ago
Too bad for them the tactic doesn't work.
Cornswalled 2 years ago
Cornswalled Their tactic didn't work for people who pay attention. It worked when it came to the liberals. That's why the idiots are still in Congress and Senate - because the lib-Dems continue to vote for them because they don't have the mental capability to pay attention or even understand.
ccgraphics20 2 years ago
please keep this vid circulating. the us government has taken this video down. it's now playing through canadian accounts. don't let them take down every vid. let everyone know!!!!!!!!!!
fondue294 2 years ago
i like how mccain was working on this before obama was even in the senate.
amoore19911 2 years ago
wish we had somebody representing the people of this country...
PatricksTime 3 years ago
The Republicans had no real idea of the magnitude of this problem, and didn't work hard enough to fix it. Do I blame the Democrats? Yes. Is it all their fault...probably not. Honestly, though what's the difference between D & R? Pelosi, Frank and Schumer should be in jail...with Bush, Cheney and Rumsfeld. We have to start over in this country.
jakezone 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
yeah and get rid of people like you
KFDEx 3 years ago
Huh? Seriously.
jakezone 3 years ago 2
yeah why should bush, cheney ,and rumsfeld be in jail
KFDEx 3 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Cheney lied repeatedly about the intelligence leading to the war (that one I can prove). Rumsfeld was an incompetent boob who also manipulated data. Bush had to apologize and say "my bad" for the crappy intelligence, and lied numerous times about the connection between al qaida and Iraq. The war was started on lies. Funny you have no comment on the Democrats I mentioned. Partisan at all? Open your eyes
jakezone 3 years ago
voting .. lol... you sheeple sill dont get it... ITS ALL RIGGED... Obama will win but before you all get excited about it... he is FRAUD and just another puppet for the elite rulers... you think hes gonna solve all the financial problems? LOL.... the whole system is a circus and your just watching pretending that your votes matter... when will u all learn.
DC180 3 years ago
The ONLY one who actually SEES the truth. Congrats DC180!
Luvcreole 3 years ago 2
The root of the problem is that both parties are polotitions and not suprisingly don't know how to run the goverment, country, or usualy themselves. Party dosn't matter beacuse both sides are corupt, ignorant, and disregard the consequences of their actions.
wagoner011984 3 years ago
true..thats what im trying to prove to everyone, but people wont get it
rafael1alanis 3 years ago
im so sick of hearing about how innocent and heroic the fuckin republicans are
RiceTees 3 years ago
republicans MAY NOT be innocent. However, they are patriots and would not manipulate economy the way Franklin Raines, Jim Johnson, Jamie Gorelick, Cris Dodd and Barney Frank did(wow-all democrats!).There is something fishy happening and involves a lot of money going to Acorn-which I don't know why this "community organizer" group is involved with housing, much less the $700 billion bailout. This group has corrupted the election process, and for some reason gets $500 for EVERY failed mortgage?!?!
misterjesp 3 years ago
this is the democrats fault, there not making republicans as the "hero" How about you use your ears and listen up rather than listening to democrat scums.
CaUSAPolitics 3 years ago
The democrats do promote the unions that are destroying the businesses. Big Uninon, which is now corupt. The problem is not just Democrats. While the democrats commit more cimes to get into office, NITHER party can run the country because they both want to control all they can and only truly want big orgnizations that are usualy corupt due to their size. It is just statics for why there is courption. Having said thay the problim is the brainwashing that makes you tink in terms of GOP or DEM.
wagoner011984 3 years ago
Drive-by voters will not care.. They will blame President Bush because he is in Power at the moment. Hopefully the majority of people in this Country will seek the Truth before they vote..
DivineMoments 3 years ago
o my God!
this umpa-lumpa character...he could fool whole America being himself a fool
woodyaan 3 years ago
I guess now we know who is in charge of FOX news.
This crisis was caused by giving a house to people who CAN'T afford to pay for it. Who made this legislation? Republican administration, Clinton and Bush. So keep spending trillions in wars and bailouts, the US will not be a good place to be living in the next 5 to 20 years.
charliesoto 3 years ago
well the repub's could of stood up for the american's and voted against the bill like they did on tuesdaybut they got in line like the good phonies that they are , both sides are fraud's and this country need's people that will look out for the best intrest for the tax payers
bjjhater 3 years ago
I agree. But we saw after they did not vote for it, the stock market almost crashed... so we are caught in the socialist trap ALREADY. We had to do this to survive another day. So the options are nill. This vid clip is just to show that the one sided media coverage that the dems are rescuing rather than unscrewing the mess they helped create is bull%$#t.
XtremeRealityCheck 3 years ago
i dont know about you, but markets crashing doesnt bother me at all. So melt down or not wont hurt me. I want the market to crash then it can be truly fixed. I know a simple way of getting that billion dollars back. Decrim marijuana and right there is a 700 a year billion business plus the 500 billion they spend would be saved on the truth commercials you watch. Be no different when the depression happened and they lifted alcohol prohibition to save the day. and it did.
swishersweets2008 3 years ago
There is a problem with that idea. Historicaly when drugs, and prostotution are legalized they are usualy run by orgnized crime. Even when they are legal that tends to remain true. Adationaly when alachol was taken form orgnized crime we got the 50s whith the sterotypes of gangseres orininating from there. If you try to take orgnized crimes income sorce away without being prepared to forcably crush the orgnization you get the rampent cruption and violence return.
wagoner011984 3 years ago
I could see there being some organized crime taking over on some, but wouldnt the criminals now be business men and be growing it on farms to send off to distrubitors like say like marlboro or whatever. Plus people wouldnt have to buy it from companies they could just produce there own long as they bought a tax stamp that allowed them to have so much.
swishersweets2008 3 years ago
No the problems that existed in the gansters area would resurface because orginized crime would forcably prevent people form being able to make any drugs. This dosn't applay to marijuana as that drug is so easy to grow that it is harder to prevent. The drugs that i am talking about is drugs like cocane and heroine. The dugs that take some sophicated manufacutaring to make. Thoes will never leave orgnized crime's hands.
wagoner011984 3 years ago
You obviously don't understand how politics work, or you wouldn't be blaming the Republicans, or would you. Back in 2004, Maxine Waters, Gregory Meeks, Arthur Davis, Lacy Clay and Barney Frnk did everything but call the regulator and Republicans "racist" so, we let you have your way, and now look at what the Democrats did, created this mess. You can sit there all day long and spin it the way you want, but the rest of American knows who is responsible. Stop being a moron!
claymaximus 3 years ago
I unfortunatly have more experience that you might expect form somone who is not a polotician since i was stuck in the middle of it form the age of 5. Nobody seems to realize just how much a kid can absorb. Polotics involves attacking a persons stands by making them appear immoral if you disagere with them. Because of that the only people who want to get into politics are people without morals or stances ont isues, just a desire for power. We turned politics into a race of courption.
wagoner011984 3 years ago