Damn...this makes the crucifixion of Jesus Christ look mild..like in all honesty...being burned alive? it's hard to get much more barbaric than that...
@27citizensoldier Though, Jesus was beaten to a bloody mess before he was crucified. More-so Jesus had to carry the cross himself that we would be nailed to. Not just that, but as well as having been beaten, he took on the guilt of everyones sins. The guilt of billions of peoples sins, (that's a lot of guilt I know) and it was so much that it made his heart implode. So I think by that comparison, Jesus suffered MUCH more greatly!
@Woreyel And your religion had a good habit of setting people on fire. See what happenes when men control the world. You pig need to die. Fuck men and there desert god
@Lunabeam1 We're all allowed to have our own opinions over life >.>
Keep what you think to your heart and carry on.
*Ahem* Back to commenting on the actual film, Milla Jovovich is one of those rare actors who really puts 100% effort into films: She's really believable in most films I've seen her in (Even the Resident Evil films! D:)
I disagree with those here who say this is the only really good scene in the movie. Minus the unnecessary gore, this movie is highly integrated from beginning to end. I wonder how many people noticed how the same blessing that opens the movie, closes it or that the whole movie is a metaphor for love.
The catholic church has had a questionable past, but it recognizes this and is now condemning what it did. This was done during a time called the inquisition and the church realizes what they did was wrong. The church today is much better in doing God's will.
If you would brush up on your history, you would see that more wars, famines, ect. were caused by atheists or radicals. You only ever hear about the accidents of the church because that's what the news wants you to hear.
@speedyturtle2012 I really appreciated this comment. I am a Catholic, born and raised, and I'm sick to death of hearing my faith and church condemned because of the history (Joan of Arc, going up to King Henry VIII, and so on...). Also, when the church overturned Joan's sentence years later and canonized her as a saint, it was a whole new church, with a whole new understanding of God's will! In conclusion, thanks for wording my thoughts so well. =) God Bless.
@CatieCass I don't just condemn your church for the endless torture and murder it has brought throughout history, but also for its sheltering of child rapists, its homophobia and its misogyny.
Wow...I actually felt tears springing to my eyes... D: Even the stake scene in the Leelee Sobieski movie didn't make me cry (well, at least, not on the outside)--& that's my most favorite Joan Of Arc movie EVER!!!
I must say, in all honesty, that I am quite interested in seeing the full movie. From what I have seen & heard about it, it looks like a very good film...despite its "revisionist" view of our favorite historical heroine.
This movie was too Exaggerated. I don't even think half of things they showed in this movie was real. For example I don't think Joan had an older sister Catherine who was raped and killed. I read her lifestory over and over again it didn't mention anything about Catherine.
@EmmyRossumFan94 Actually, I've read from many sources that she really did have a sister named Catherine. As to whether she was raped & killed...*shrugs*
@Inf4m0us94 I don't think so. He was a Catholic priest who received Joan's confession, as she requested, because she was a very devout Catholic. Those in power who sentenced Joan to death, allowed her request for a confession, before she was burned alive. Joan is now a saint of the Roman Catholic Church, in addition to being a heroine of France.
@mooninquirer Dustin Hoffman played the part of Joan of Arc's conscience--not of a priest--in the film. It is a very powerful role, beautifully acted by Dustin Hoffman.
Milla Jovovavich did very well in this movie.The movie was very well done and there was good supporting actors. But i think everything in here was just to get to the Dustin Hoffman scenes where he just shits oscars out like he's ordering a pizza.
@EisigHollen Yes, I agree....though, when all's said & done, I have to say that Leelee Sobieski will always be my #1 favorite movie Joan. ^_^ Milla Jovovavich is my 2nd favorite movie Joan.
Makes you seriously wonder how they ever shot this scene in the first place! Cause acting or not, being surrounded in torrent of flames that are supposed to kill me is not cosher!!!
@BeeZee1992 I learned in school. If you ever got a whiff of the smoke after lighting a match and got a sore in your nostral and coughed, imagine it being hundred times more potent being burned like that. Once the fire is set, the victim does of carbon monoxide poisoning breathing in hot air and smoke. The fire just burns their corpses but isn't the actual cause of death.
@HelenaXVI Actually I took a lot of history classes at the university I was at and passed with flying colors. Christianity is bloody, murderous religion.
@tweethang1 Oh and let's not forget Germans! Heinous crimes have been committed in the name of the German nation. It should be abolished lest it happen again!
Saint Joan Of Arc The Greatest Christian Martyr Ever She Sacrificed Her Pious Life For Words Of GOD And For The Freedom of A Great Nation Called France.May Jesus Christ Son Of God Bless Her Soul.She Bravely Fought evil english.
@FreedomFighterReturn Your religion beats women, forces women to wear black from head to toe, murders gays, kills anyone *in the middle east* who rejects Islam, and not to mention!! Believe in honor death!!
@FreedomFighterReturn if thats the case most middle east countries wouldn't be the wealthiest like Arabian Emirates.If you are wealthy your hands are dirty.Scandals like that are being covered from the public.
Islam in almost all the islamic countries treat women like playthings.Disfiguring their genitals so they wont cheat their husbands,get abused and are being brought up to an opressive way of life thinking its just fine.
And your famous execution squares more than make up for the witch hunts
@FreedomFighterReturn sorry but islam is not the answer either.Its even more corrupt and abusive and continues to opress critical thinking and society all together.Besides islamic people had their share in religious mindless wars and jihads like the west did the crusades.
@FreedomFighterReturn all true.The corrupt church is surely bankrupt but i still hope there are christians out there that try to do some good in this world.I haven't lost entirely my faith to mankind.We can still do some good like Christ without those filthy clergymen.After all,they executed him.the hebrew ones in Jerusalem i mean.
t is easy to see how hate can start fermenting in a person after watching a scene like this. All those old bastards standing around watching a young girl die in the most horrific way one could ever imagine. Fuck any form of religion that thinks it's ok to kill anyone (and we still have it on all sides today). If your "god" is not one of love, I want no part of it. Love is the only legitimate religion.
It is easy to see how hate can start fermenting in a person after watching a scene like this. All those old bastards standing around watching a young girl die in the most horrific way one could ever imagine. Fuck any form of religion that thinks it's ok to kill anyone (and we still have it on all sides today). If your "god" is not one of love, I want no part of it. Love is the only legitimate religion.
this is how the catholics treated people who they consider unlike them, remember the inquisitions ??? they wore, they are and will always be heretics unless they come back to TRUTH
@Paulewog123 it was their call...they had hired people to do their job ,never imagine a catholic priest holding a torch to burn her...but they wore as guilty as it was their call to do it, they wore afraid of her doing something, but God helped her..have you seen the 1999 movie ? it was in my opinion more of spiritual than this one
@AnimeLuver70 yes so you are catholic....and you disgrace this....i understand you , but it makes no difference in what i said !!! catholics gave the order that she will be killed, and when i say catholics i mean the reverends who had the power to give the call , it is simply disgraceful what catholic popes done after the year 1054, i am so sorry
god bless st Joan of the catholic church, she died with honor for all Catholics and the pope in defiance of the disgusting English protestant vermin and i say that as a member of a devoutly irish catholic family, i live in sussex, england and will move away from england when i can and forget i was ever born here!!!!
@jopeon hell, the english have changed. They may have done a certain amount of awful things according to movies but what the MOVIES don't show is that in war, BOTH SIDES do terrible things. And history does little to that effect as well. In war, history is written by the victor, and they can write whatever they wish in the end. They can deny all the terrible things THEY did and nobody will argue. Such is the way of history. Remember that the French started the war.
@OKB74U You need to go back to reading and studying the English history ....You're wrong on all counts in your statement here....The english are known for wars and more wars..... to gain more and more land......of stealing countries that the French and others have developed etc....That's all the english know how to do well....Read who built their buildings in England...not the English...sorry....
@Osayannx I'm certainly not saying the Brits were saints. I'm no history scholar but I don't think I'm wrong when I say that history is written by whoever wins. You won't convince me that the French didn't commit atrocities in their wars. Doubtless the Brits got what they paid for, but still. And yes, the Brits did conquer and steal lands, but so did the French, the Spaniards, the Portuguese and the Dutch. The Brits were just better at it.
@jopeon LMFAO!! WOW!!! The catholic church burned her then they turn around and call her a saint!! You guys are the biggest bunch of dumb ass hypocrites I have ever witnessed in the history of man kind!! Your fuckin religion burned, tortured, drowned, hung, and boiled people in oil!! Your religion has more blood soaked into it's history the entire holocaust of ww2
@tweethang1 Why are you ranting and bitching to the Catholics today? Just in case you haven't noticed, the church has indeed changed, because people know better now. Not only have we changed, the entire world has. Catholics are smarter and more accepting of Protestants and other Christian faiths, and Jews. I am a Catholic, and I certainly don't condone this.
@CatieCass People rationalize for various reasons. Often it is to differentiate from the original deterministic explanation, of the behavior or feeling in question.Sometimes this occurs when we think we know ourselves better than we do. It is also an informal fallacy of reasoning. you are trying to fabricate an excuse.. the English or should i say house plantagenate..were the invadors of france not the burgundians the englsih have commited genocide in Eire and all over the world..they are evil
@CatieCass On the Jews and Their Lies (German: Von den Jüden und jren Lügen; in modern spelling Von den Juden und ihren Lügen) is a 65,000-word antisemitic treatise written in 1543 by the German Reformation leader Martin Luther.
@CatieCass n the treatise, Luther describes Jews as a "base, whoring people, that is, no people of God, and their boast of lineage, circumcision, and law must be accounted as filth."Luther wrote that they are "full of the devil's feces ... which they wallow in like swine," and the synagogue is an "incorrigible whore and an evil slut"
@CatieCass i am agnostic i hold almost all organized religion in contempt my family is about half protestant / half catholic, both religons do sneer at each other but protestants tend to be more hypocritical they will not acknoweledge that almost every charge they level at the catholic church they are also guilty of and also i would say protestants are deathly boring at least catholics let their hair down and have a good time now and then
@TheMouseAvenger my family came from right around where joan was born, so i always have identified with joan of arc very strong, the main difference betwen catholics and poroteatans, there were no such thing as portestants at this period and were none for 100 years btw, was catholic church burned withes and proteatants found that barbaric, SO THEY HUNG THEM, times have changed since then, but not enough i fear
@CatieCass lol good one. Last I checked, the Catholics molest children and then pretend it didn't happen. The only reason they don't burn anyone today is because the REST of the world has changed, they couldn't get away with it now if they tried. You may not condone this, but I'm certain Benny would loveeeee a barbecue if he could have one.
@ajatkinson2004 agnostic and i was raised methodist the family is about half protestant half catholic and i can see equal absurdity in both in fact almost all religion(gnostics and buddists aside)
so who is the judgmental ass now? possibly you?? eh? f*cking brit
@MrBillcale no actually I'm Anglican. And I like Catholics as a general rule, just thought I'd throw that out there to show how disingenuous it sounds to make assumptions based on someone's denomination.
@ajatkinson2004 how do you feel about methodists?? anglican?? anglican!? oh you are the devil, may the curse of cromwell be upon you! Tiocfaidh ár lá!
@MrBillcale I am a Methodist lol. But we did come from the Anglican church. Our theology is the same, however we Methodists are more conservative than true Anglicans
@fairgirl7 In psychology and logic, rationalization (or making excuses) is a defense mechanism in which perceived controversial behaviors or feelings are explained in a rational or logical manner to avoid the true explanation. It often involves ad hoc hypothesizing. This process ranges from fully conscious (e.g. to present an external defense against ridicule from others) to mostly subconscious (e.g. to create a block against internal feelings of guilt).
@fairgirl7 The House of Plantagenet (pronounced /plænˈtædʒɨnɨt/), a branch of the Angevins, was a royal house founded by Geoffrey V of Anjou, father of Henry II of England. Plantagenet kings first ruled the Kingdom of England in the 12th century. Their paternal ancestors originated in the French province of Gâtinais and gained the County of Anjou through marriage during the 11th century.
@fairgirl7 The dynasty accumulated several other holdings, building the Angevin Empire which at its peak stretched from the Pyrenees to Ireland and the border with Scotland.
In total, fifteen Plantagenet monarchs, including those belonging to cadet branches, ruled England from 1154 until 1485.
@fairgirl7 The senior branch ruled from Henry II of England until the deposition of Richard II of England in 1399. After that, a junior branch, the House of Lancaster, ruled for some fifty years, before clashing with another branch, the House of York, in a civil war known as the Wars of the Roses over control of England
"Joan was a being so uplifted from the ordinary run of mankind that she finds no equal in a thousand years."
Winston Churchill-Legendary British Prime Minister in WWII
"Consider this unique and imposing distinction. Since the writing of human history began, Joan of Arc is the only person, of either sex, who has ever held supreme command of the military forces of a nation at the age of seventeen."
Louis Kossuth-19th Century European Freedom Fighter
@Vort317545 like all things,it was never applied correctly,in the form it was given.same goes for politics.Man cares only about his interests,profit.Man doesnt care about God and his great gift.Money is man's god.
@Vort317545 what about Alexander the Great?he controlled his first army at age 17,in Chaironeia.At least a half of it.His father was still alive back then.
"Taking into account all the circumstances... her origin, youth, sex, illiteracy, early environment, and the obstructing conditions under which she exploitted her high gifts and mader conquestss in the field and before the courts that tried her for her life... She is easily and by far the most extraordinary person the human race has ever produced.." - Mark Twain.
I do not view her death as tragic event But a victory. Joan herself had a letter shot into Torelles outside of Orleans. Warning the English "That I will cause a clash of arms that will be remembered for centuries" We in 2012 all still known of Joan's story. We remember not her enemies such as Glasdale who died at Torrelles or even the names of her Inquisition rigged judges. But we remember Joan and we to this day draw inspiration, courage and strength from her story.
Jehanne la Purcell (Joan the Maid) last words as recorded by re-trial wittnesses were. She asked for a Priest to hold the cross before her eyes until she died. Later as fires began to reach her she told priest to back away for his safety and pray for her soul as she would enter pergitory. She let out a scream "Jesus! Jesus!! Jesus!!!" and surcomed to the flames.
@TheMarieromantic Well your right about last name I forgot the "e" yet there are several letters of her still in existence of course dictated for she could not read or write. yet she did sign them with Jehanne the Old French dialect. As she was led to pyre she did make a public address, in which she stated that she feared city would suffer greatly for her death there, secondly that all she had done was according to God's direction and that her voices and visitations were real and corporal.
Joan was always and forever will be my favorite historic figure. She remained loyal to the truth to the very end. Any woman who would go through so much just to save her people and country is a true hero. I could not imagine the horror and pain of being burned alive. RIP Joan of Arc
I havent seen this movie yet but in my opinion i think that the Joan of Arc version that was with Leelee Sobeiski was more intense just saying in my opinion cuz this scene looks good too .-.
Dustin Hoffman pissed me off in this movie poor Milla...the English raped and murdered her sister and destroyed her country and killed thousands of her countrymen and so yeah she got pissed and raised an army and had many victories...and then at the end of the movie Dustin Hoffman is busting her balls and giving her a hard time over it...she didn't do anything wrong she helped to liberate her country...I don't get it...damn Hollywood revisionist history...
Hundreds of people were burned at the stake during the 16th century in england due to religion, innocent people.. Call them selves people of god, more like animals!
@tweethang1 its not christians who did this man.fuckin priests,supposed men of the cloth,"men of God in earth".tch tch the only real Christian was her,a martyr,a savior and a heroine and thats the bottom line.
@tweethang1 Joan was a Christian.She was the only true one,the people here weren't they just used God's name to justify what they did to others.Please do not say 'YOU Christians' I'm not in the same category as these people.
@tweethang1 It's okay.Really I'm as disgusted as you are about this stuff so I get a little edgy when placed in the same category as these supposed 'Christians' who don't know God at all.
Beautiful movie...I just can't believe it ended like that...I just could not believe at how stupid and what monsters people are in the past. I feel like crying when I finished watching this.
And shortly after this, they realized they made an oops. Someone said "We've burned a saint". Whoops! Besides, burning doesn't kill witches. It said so in Harry Potter.
@tweethang1 I agree with you, but personally, I'm glad that she chose to die rather than deny God! Die with honor instead of living your whole life with nothing but shame.
@tweethang1 same here my stomach trusn seeing this, and i read that English raked back the coals to expose her charred body so that no one could claim she had escaped alive, then burned the body twice more to reduce it to ashes and prevent any collection of relics. They cast her remains into the Seine, such horrid
and lets also remeber what the protestant done to catholics also for protecting there beliefs we both did wrong it doesnt make it right thwe world is sick no matter what everyone will kill .
ok im disturbed now
Lunabeam1 5 days ago
Damn...this makes the crucifixion of Jesus Christ look mild..like in all honesty...being burned alive? it's hard to get much more barbaric than that...
27citizensoldier 2 months ago
@27citizensoldier Though, Jesus was beaten to a bloody mess before he was crucified. More-so Jesus had to carry the cross himself that we would be nailed to. Not just that, but as well as having been beaten, he took on the guilt of everyones sins. The guilt of billions of peoples sins, (that's a lot of guilt I know) and it was so much that it made his heart implode. So I think by that comparison, Jesus suffered MUCH more greatly!
Woreyel 1 month ago
@Woreyel
yeah, that's true...
27citizensoldier 1 month ago
@Woreyel Let's set you on fire and see shall we. Burning to death is WAAAY more painful then anything.
Lunabeam1 1 month ago
@Lunabeam1 OH so YOU have experienced the most painful death have you?
Woreyel 1 month ago
@Woreyel No. BUT I HAVE BEEN SET ON FIRE BEFORE!! GO SHOVE YOUR BIBLE UP YOUR CHRISTIAN ASS
Lunabeam1 1 month ago
@Lunabeam1 So if YOU don't know the most painful death there is to experience I suggest you keep quite hmm?
Woreyel 1 month ago
@Woreyel And your religion had a good habit of setting people on fire. See what happenes when men control the world. You pig need to die. Fuck men and there desert god
Lunabeam1 1 month ago
@Lunabeam1 Well you're most definitely one very passionate God hater aren't you!
Woreyel 1 month ago
@Lunabeam1 We're all allowed to have our own opinions over life >.>
Keep what you think to your heart and carry on.
*Ahem* Back to commenting on the actual film, Milla Jovovich is one of those rare actors who really puts 100% effort into films: She's really believable in most films I've seen her in (Even the Resident Evil films! D:)
Shadowfang3000 4 weeks ago
@darkzz009 carmina burana o fortuna by Carl orff
meatloaf928 2 months ago
@meatloaf928 Angelus in Medio Ignis by Eric Serra
Dannyrorro 2 months ago
I disagree with those here who say this is the only really good scene in the movie. Minus the unnecessary gore, this movie is highly integrated from beginning to end. I wonder how many people noticed how the same blessing that opens the movie, closes it or that the whole movie is a metaphor for love.
kameraklips 3 months ago
French fried cunt
Dimrain47ftw 3 months ago
Fried 19 year old cunt for the win! Errr I think they over do the frying that it turned to ashes...
Dimrain47ftw 3 months ago
The catholic church has had a questionable past, but it recognizes this and is now condemning what it did. This was done during a time called the inquisition and the church realizes what they did was wrong. The church today is much better in doing God's will.
If you would brush up on your history, you would see that more wars, famines, ect. were caused by atheists or radicals. You only ever hear about the accidents of the church because that's what the news wants you to hear.
speedyturtle2012 4 months ago
@speedyturtle2012 I really appreciated this comment. I am a Catholic, born and raised, and I'm sick to death of hearing my faith and church condemned because of the history (Joan of Arc, going up to King Henry VIII, and so on...). Also, when the church overturned Joan's sentence years later and canonized her as a saint, it was a whole new church, with a whole new understanding of God's will! In conclusion, thanks for wording my thoughts so well. =) God Bless.
CatieCass 2 weeks ago
@CatieCass I don't just condemn your church for the endless torture and murder it has brought throughout history, but also for its sheltering of child rapists, its homophobia and its misogyny.
WhiteRose226 2 days ago
And then that hypocritical trash they called a church had the nerve to dub her a saint years later! It makes me so mad.
ProvokingYoVillian 4 months ago
She died at nineteen? She was so young
nonamehasaname 4 months ago
can someone tell me what is the title of this choir music?? this is awesome.
darkzz009 4 months ago
I never get it... Dustin Hoffman was "god" or was he the "devil"? o.O btw, I love this movie, and I love Joan, she was a real martyr =(
gothicgrowler 5 months ago
I think he's suppose to be the consciousness of Joan
nonamehasaname 4 months ago
Wow...I actually felt tears springing to my eyes... D: Even the stake scene in the Leelee Sobieski movie didn't make me cry (well, at least, not on the outside)--& that's my most favorite Joan Of Arc movie EVER!!!
I must say, in all honesty, that I am quite interested in seeing the full movie. From what I have seen & heard about it, it looks like a very good film...despite its "revisionist" view of our favorite historical heroine.
TheMouseAvenger 5 months ago
She is the first Avenger =)
Taurus5190 6 months ago
This movie was too Exaggerated. I don't even think half of things they showed in this movie was real. For example I don't think Joan had an older sister Catherine who was raped and killed. I read her lifestory over and over again it didn't mention anything about Catherine.
EmmyRossumFan94 6 months ago
@EmmyRossumFan94 Actually, I've read from many sources that she really did have a sister named Catherine. As to whether she was raped & killed...*shrugs*
TheMouseAvenger 5 months ago
all of the greatest warriors ever are usually betrayed... xD
euan777 6 months ago
@Inf4m0us94 he's the priest
YTMize 7 months ago
damn in 1931 r u serious
YTMize 7 months ago
is the old man god?
Inf4m0us94 8 months ago
@Inf4m0us94 I don't think so. He was a Catholic priest who received Joan's confession, as she requested, because she was a very devout Catholic. Those in power who sentenced Joan to death, allowed her request for a confession, before she was burned alive. Joan is now a saint of the Roman Catholic Church, in addition to being a heroine of France.
mooninquirer 8 months ago 4
@mooninquirer
This guy was not a priest but her conscience.
Freez57fr 1 month ago
@mooninquirer Dustin Hoffman played the part of Joan of Arc's conscience--not of a priest--in the film. It is a very powerful role, beautifully acted by Dustin Hoffman.
KatiaTiutiunnik 1 week ago
@HughStirling My gosh...*shudders* Man, am I going to have nightmares! D:
TheMouseAvenger 8 months ago
Milla Jovovavich did very well in this movie.The movie was very well done and there was good supporting actors. But i think everything in here was just to get to the Dustin Hoffman scenes where he just shits oscars out like he's ordering a pizza.
What an acting powerhouse...
EisigHollen 8 months ago 16
@EisigHollen Yes, I agree....though, when all's said & done, I have to say that Leelee Sobieski will always be my #1 favorite movie Joan. ^_^ Milla Jovovavich is my 2nd favorite movie Joan.
TheMouseAvenger 8 months ago
Yup and.... fuck religion.
LeMightySabre 8 months ago
i saw this for the first time totally stoned and at the time i thought it was probably one of the most fucked up things ive ever scene
airball2832 9 months ago
@airball2832 I didn't like this version because it made Joan look bad. The Leelee Sobeiski version was better.
Elly3981 9 months ago
@Elly3981 I agree 100%. Didn't like this at all... it sort of made me hate Milla Jovovich. O_o
Chemicat 8 months ago
@Elly3981 Agreed. *nods* (I *love* that version, BTW!)
TheMouseAvenger 8 months ago
Makes you seriously wonder how they ever shot this scene in the first place! Cause acting or not, being surrounded in torrent of flames that are supposed to kill me is not cosher!!!
NeoDanomaru 9 months ago
burning is a nasty way to die
vampgirl092 9 months ago
@vampgirl092 Thats putting it mildy!!!
NeoDanomaru 9 months ago
@vampgirl092 The victim actually dies from smoke inhalation long before they burn so they actually don't feel the pain like you might think.
Elly3981 9 months ago
@Elly3981
Lets hope so, but i think you have to literally have to be burned alive to make that kind of an assumption.
BeeZee1992 8 months ago
@BeeZee1992 I learned in school. If you ever got a whiff of the smoke after lighting a match and got a sore in your nostral and coughed, imagine it being hundred times more potent being burned like that. Once the fire is set, the victim does of carbon monoxide poisoning breathing in hot air and smoke. The fire just burns their corpses but isn't the actual cause of death.
Elly3981 8 months ago
Christians are ass holes
tweethang1 10 months ago
@tweethang1 Jeanne d'Arc herself was a devoted Christian. I guess she is an asshole too.
HelenaXVI 10 months ago
@HelenaXVI If you all had it your burning people to death would still be going om today.
tweethang1 10 months ago
@tweethang1 You're so smart. You should be teaching history in a university. Go and try to get a job there.
HelenaXVI 10 months ago
@HelenaXVI Actually I took a lot of history classes at the university I was at and passed with flying colors. Christianity is bloody, murderous religion.
tweethang1 10 months ago
@tweethang1 Thank God the pagans and atheists have never been bloody and murderous.
HelenaXVI 10 months ago
@HelenaXVI throw them to the lions!
MrBillcale 10 months ago
@tweethang1 Oh and let's not forget Germans! Heinous crimes have been committed in the name of the German nation. It should be abolished lest it happen again!
HelenaXVI 10 months ago
@HelenaXVI Agreed
tweethang1 10 months ago
what a horrible way to die!!
luvbites23 10 months ago
I watched this movie and really wasted my time it's got to be the dumbest move I have ever seen.
bosswall 10 months ago
They say her heart never burned.
comowhite4 10 months ago
Stupid Religious fucktards
tweethang1 10 months ago
@tweethang1 LMAO!!
luvbites23 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Saint Joan Of Arc The Greatest Christian Martyr Ever She Sacrificed Her Pious Life For Words Of GOD And For The Freedom of A Great Nation Called France.May Jesus Christ Son Of God Bless Her Soul.She Bravely Fought evil english.
saccyind 11 months ago
I saw this when I was 8 years old. I was deeply, deeply disturbed by this scene and I may never recover.
BlackHoleSun1921 11 months ago
@BlackHoleSun1921 honey im 20 years old and Im deeply disturbed, I feel your pain.
luvbites23 10 months ago
she's a good actor
turquoisbones 11 months ago
I hope one day this criminal ideology will be banned worldwide.
Hobu123 11 months ago
@FreedomFighterReturn Your religion beats women, forces women to wear black from head to toe, murders gays, kills anyone *in the middle east* who rejects Islam, and not to mention!! Believe in honor death!!
tweethang1 11 months ago
Ah mankind, to take something as comforting and as protecting as fire-and turn it to such a use.
Hardrada88 11 months ago
that has got to be the worst way to die
twomells 11 months ago 2
thats pretty much the worst medeival times execution. i heard the still burn people at the stake in other countries.
DCSk8er529 11 months ago
For my next birthday, I want this to happen to my stepmom.
mikedrummonds 1 year ago
@FreedomFighterReturn if thats the case most middle east countries wouldn't be the wealthiest like Arabian Emirates.If you are wealthy your hands are dirty.Scandals like that are being covered from the public.
Islam in almost all the islamic countries treat women like playthings.Disfiguring their genitals so they wont cheat their husbands,get abused and are being brought up to an opressive way of life thinking its just fine.
And your famous execution squares more than make up for the witch hunts
Elspethknighterrant 1 year ago
@FreedomFighterReturn sorry but islam is not the answer either.Its even more corrupt and abusive and continues to opress critical thinking and society all together.Besides islamic people had their share in religious mindless wars and jihads like the west did the crusades.
Elspethknighterrant 1 year ago
@FreedomFighterReturn all true.The corrupt church is surely bankrupt but i still hope there are christians out there that try to do some good in this world.I haven't lost entirely my faith to mankind.We can still do some good like Christ without those filthy clergymen.After all,they executed him.the hebrew ones in Jerusalem i mean.
Elspethknighterrant 1 year ago
I like the one with Leelee Sobieski better
AngelCruzrulez1 1 year ago
Did she forget to bring her axes that day?
NejiKusa 1 year ago
Dark Medieval Times...
HelenaXVI 1 year ago
today i saw the movie for first time and the scene shocked me, is very strong
rostraman 1 year ago
Comment removed
AnimeLuver70 1 year ago
Jeanne of Arc is my idol.
HorrorMovieCollab 1 year ago 2
But this is a very good movie though
AnakinAhsokaGeek18 1 year ago
I have this movie on my iPod and my heart always starts racing uncontrollably and I even have ti hold on to it when seeing this.
AnakinAhsokaGeek18 1 year ago
One of the most dramatic scenes in cinematic history
tokemon1994 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
t is easy to see how hate can start fermenting in a person after watching a scene like this. All those old bastards standing around watching a young girl die in the most horrific way one could ever imagine. Fuck any form of religion that thinks it's ok to kill anyone (and we still have it on all sides today). If your "god" is not one of love, I want no part of it. Love is the only legitimate religion.
timkluc 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
It is easy to see how hate can start fermenting in a person after watching a scene like this. All those old bastards standing around watching a young girl die in the most horrific way one could ever imagine. Fuck any form of religion that thinks it's ok to kill anyone (and we still have it on all sides today). If your "god" is not one of love, I want no part of it. Love is the only legitimate religion.
timkluc 1 year ago
Comment removed
timkluc 1 year ago
this is how the catholics treated people who they consider unlike them, remember the inquisitions ??? they wore, they are and will always be heretics unless they come back to TRUTH
myyvaine 1 year ago
@myyvaine I'm sorry, but it wasn't exactly the Catholics that killed Joan of Arc.
Paulewog123 1 year ago
@Paulewog123 it was their call...they had hired people to do their job ,never imagine a catholic priest holding a torch to burn her...but they wore as guilty as it was their call to do it, they wore afraid of her doing something, but God helped her..have you seen the 1999 movie ? it was in my opinion more of spiritual than this one
myyvaine 1 year ago
@myyvaine i'm catholic and disgrace this crap!
AnimeLuver70 1 year ago
@AnimeLuver70 yes so you are catholic....and you disgrace this....i understand you , but it makes no difference in what i said !!! catholics gave the order that she will be killed, and when i say catholics i mean the reverends who had the power to give the call , it is simply disgraceful what catholic popes done after the year 1054, i am so sorry
myyvaine 1 year ago
wow, thank god we have evolved, at least in some ways...
pvkjell 1 year ago
@TheResidentevil4life that´s because english were afraid of loosing all the frech territory that they have by a "simple peasent girl"
vir8KUMBIERITA 1 year ago
the razzies are full of crap. she acted very well in this movie
castormccree 1 year ago
god bless st Joan of the catholic church, she died with honor for all Catholics and the pope in defiance of the disgusting English protestant vermin and i say that as a member of a devoutly irish catholic family, i live in sussex, england and will move away from england when i can and forget i was ever born here!!!!
jopeon 1 year ago
@jopeon wow ok common england isnt the only country that burned people
julie101rox 1 year ago
@jopeon hell, the english have changed. They may have done a certain amount of awful things according to movies but what the MOVIES don't show is that in war, BOTH SIDES do terrible things. And history does little to that effect as well. In war, history is written by the victor, and they can write whatever they wish in the end. They can deny all the terrible things THEY did and nobody will argue. Such is the way of history. Remember that the French started the war.
OKB74U 1 year ago
@OKB74U You need to go back to reading and studying the English history ....You're wrong on all counts in your statement here....The english are known for wars and more wars..... to gain more and more land......of stealing countries that the French and others have developed etc....That's all the english know how to do well....Read who built their buildings in England...not the English...sorry....
Osayannx 2 months ago
@Osayannx I'm certainly not saying the Brits were saints. I'm no history scholar but I don't think I'm wrong when I say that history is written by whoever wins. You won't convince me that the French didn't commit atrocities in their wars. Doubtless the Brits got what they paid for, but still. And yes, the Brits did conquer and steal lands, but so did the French, the Spaniards, the Portuguese and the Dutch. The Brits were just better at it.
OKB74U 2 months ago
@jopeon LMFAO!! WOW!!! The catholic church burned her then they turn around and call her a saint!! You guys are the biggest bunch of dumb ass hypocrites I have ever witnessed in the history of man kind!! Your fuckin religion burned, tortured, drowned, hung, and boiled people in oil!! Your religion has more blood soaked into it's history the entire holocaust of ww2
tweethang1 1 year ago
@tweethang1 Why are you ranting and bitching to the Catholics today? Just in case you haven't noticed, the church has indeed changed, because people know better now. Not only have we changed, the entire world has. Catholics are smarter and more accepting of Protestants and other Christian faiths, and Jews. I am a Catholic, and I certainly don't condone this.
CatieCass 1 year ago 10
@CatieCass People rationalize for various reasons. Often it is to differentiate from the original deterministic explanation, of the behavior or feeling in question.Sometimes this occurs when we think we know ourselves better than we do. It is also an informal fallacy of reasoning. you are trying to fabricate an excuse.. the English or should i say house plantagenate..were the invadors of france not the burgundians the englsih have commited genocide in Eire and all over the world..they are evil
MrBillcale 10 months ago
@CatieCass On the Jews and Their Lies (German: Von den Jüden und jren Lügen; in modern spelling Von den Juden und ihren Lügen) is a 65,000-word antisemitic treatise written in 1543 by the German Reformation leader Martin Luther.
I
MrBillcale 10 months ago
@CatieCass n the treatise, Luther describes Jews as a "base, whoring people, that is, no people of God, and their boast of lineage, circumcision, and law must be accounted as filth."Luther wrote that they are "full of the devil's feces ... which they wallow in like swine," and the synagogue is an "incorrigible whore and an evil slut"
MrBillcale 10 months ago
@CatieCass i am agnostic i hold almost all organized religion in contempt my family is about half protestant / half catholic, both religons do sneer at each other but protestants tend to be more hypocritical they will not acknoweledge that almost every charge they level at the catholic church they are also guilty of and also i would say protestants are deathly boring at least catholics let their hair down and have a good time now and then
MrBillcale 10 months ago
@MrBillcale Excuse me...*I* happen to be a Protestant. -_- (Methodist, to be precise.)
TheMouseAvenger 8 months ago
@TheMouseAvenger my family came from right around where joan was born, so i always have identified with joan of arc very strong, the main difference betwen catholics and poroteatans, there were no such thing as portestants at this period and were none for 100 years btw, was catholic church burned withes and proteatants found that barbaric, SO THEY HUNG THEM, times have changed since then, but not enough i fear
MrBillcale 8 months ago
@CatieCass You're exactly right! *nods in agreement*
TheMouseAvenger 8 months ago
@TheMouseAvenger Thank you very much! =)
CatieCass 8 months ago
@CatieCass lol good one. Last I checked, the Catholics molest children and then pretend it didn't happen. The only reason they don't burn anyone today is because the REST of the world has changed, they couldn't get away with it now if they tried. You may not condone this, but I'm certain Benny would loveeeee a barbecue if he could have one.
BrixtonRBarrett 5 months ago
@BrixtonRBarrett ...Are you through? How ridiculous. I sure wish I had the last thirty seconds of my life back.
CatieCass 5 months ago
the english are such bastards
MrBillcale 1 year ago 15
@MrBillcale lol but it was the french people themselves betrayed her and made sure she died
EvilYelowBanana 1 year ago
@EvilYelowBanana go eat a hot dog you illiterate american swine
your probably protestant
which means all you do is lie
MrBillcale 1 year ago
@MrBillcale and you are probably Catholic, which means all you do is judge others...Blanket statements are so fun!
ajatkinson2004 11 months ago
@ajatkinson2004 agnostic and i was raised methodist the family is about half protestant half catholic and i can see equal absurdity in both in fact almost all religion(gnostics and buddists aside)
so who is the judgmental ass now? possibly you?? eh? f*cking brit
MrBillcale 11 months ago
@ajatkinson2004 oops apologies to the brits
your evidentally some evangelical hillbilly
MrBillcale 11 months ago
@MrBillcale no actually I'm Anglican. And I like Catholics as a general rule, just thought I'd throw that out there to show how disingenuous it sounds to make assumptions based on someone's denomination.
ajatkinson2004 11 months ago
@ajatkinson2004 how do you feel about methodists?? anglican?? anglican!? oh you are the devil, may the curse of cromwell be upon you! Tiocfaidh ár lá!
MrBillcale 11 months ago
@MrBillcale I am a Methodist lol. But we did come from the Anglican church. Our theology is the same, however we Methodists are more conservative than true Anglicans
ajatkinson2004 11 months ago
@ajatkinson2004 perhaps in texas not the ones i knew and in canada its called the united church
MrBillcale 11 months ago
@MrBillcale 100 % Truth Today Only Ireland Defeated england In Cricket World Cup In India
saccyind 11 months ago
@MrBillcale Remember the Burgundians sold her off to the English; they were just as responsible for her murder.
fairgirl7 10 months ago
@fairgirl7 In psychology and logic, rationalization (or making excuses) is a defense mechanism in which perceived controversial behaviors or feelings are explained in a rational or logical manner to avoid the true explanation. It often involves ad hoc hypothesizing. This process ranges from fully conscious (e.g. to present an external defense against ridicule from others) to mostly subconscious (e.g. to create a block against internal feelings of guilt).
MrBillcale 10 months ago
@fairgirl7 The House of Plantagenet (pronounced /plænˈtædʒɨnɨt/), a branch of the Angevins, was a royal house founded by Geoffrey V of Anjou, father of Henry II of England. Plantagenet kings first ruled the Kingdom of England in the 12th century. Their paternal ancestors originated in the French province of Gâtinais and gained the County of Anjou through marriage during the 11th century.
MrBillcale 10 months ago
@fairgirl7 The dynasty accumulated several other holdings, building the Angevin Empire which at its peak stretched from the Pyrenees to Ireland and the border with Scotland.
In total, fifteen Plantagenet monarchs, including those belonging to cadet branches, ruled England from 1154 until 1485.
MrBillcale 10 months ago
@fairgirl7 The senior branch ruled from Henry II of England until the deposition of Richard II of England in 1399. After that, a junior branch, the House of Lancaster, ruled for some fifty years, before clashing with another branch, the House of York, in a civil war known as the Wars of the Roses over control of England
MrBillcale 10 months ago
@MrBillcale Yes we English are a right bunch of cunts MUWAHAHAHA.
JustThinkForYourself 9 months ago
"Joan was a being so uplifted from the ordinary run of mankind that she finds no equal in a thousand years."
Winston Churchill-Legendary British Prime Minister in WWII
"Consider this unique and imposing distinction. Since the writing of human history began, Joan of Arc is the only person, of either sex, who has ever held supreme command of the military forces of a nation at the age of seventeen."
Louis Kossuth-19th Century European Freedom Fighter
Vort317545 1 year ago
@Vort317545 like all things,it was never applied correctly,in the form it was given.same goes for politics.Man cares only about his interests,profit.Man doesnt care about God and his great gift.Money is man's god.
Elspethknighterrant 1 year ago
@Vort317545 what about Alexander the Great?he controlled his first army at age 17,in Chaironeia.At least a half of it.His father was still alive back then.
Elspethknighterrant 1 year ago
"Taking into account all the circumstances... her origin, youth, sex, illiteracy, early environment, and the obstructing conditions under which she exploitted her high gifts and mader conquestss in the field and before the courts that tried her for her life... She is easily and by far the most extraordinary person the human race has ever produced.." - Mark Twain.
Vort317545 1 year ago
I do not view her death as tragic event But a victory. Joan herself had a letter shot into Torelles outside of Orleans. Warning the English "That I will cause a clash of arms that will be remembered for centuries" We in 2012 all still known of Joan's story. We remember not her enemies such as Glasdale who died at Torrelles or even the names of her Inquisition rigged judges. But we remember Joan and we to this day draw inspiration, courage and strength from her story.
Vort317545 1 year ago
Jehanne la Purcell (Joan the Maid) last words as recorded by re-trial wittnesses were. She asked for a Priest to hold the cross before her eyes until she died. Later as fires began to reach her she told priest to back away for his safety and pray for her soul as she would enter pergitory. She let out a scream "Jesus! Jesus!! Jesus!!!" and surcomed to the flames.
Vort317545 1 year ago
@Vort317545 Sorry but she was Jeanne La Pucelle , to be exact but well done to know so much about our most famous female heroe.
TheMarieromantic 1 year ago
@TheMarieromantic Well your right about last name I forgot the "e" yet there are several letters of her still in existence of course dictated for she could not read or write. yet she did sign them with Jehanne the Old French dialect. As she was led to pyre she did make a public address, in which she stated that she feared city would suffer greatly for her death there, secondly that all she had done was according to God's direction and that her voices and visitations were real and corporal.
Vort317545 1 year ago
Joan was always and forever will be my favorite historic figure. She remained loyal to the truth to the very end. Any woman who would go through so much just to save her people and country is a true hero. I could not imagine the horror and pain of being burned alive. RIP Joan of Arc
EnvysGirl01 1 year ago
i think i would have rather been shot. that is just awful.
makailadycus 1 year ago
I havent seen this movie yet but in my opinion i think that the Joan of Arc version that was with Leelee Sobeiski was more intense just saying in my opinion cuz this scene looks good too .-.
DeathOn3rdStreet 1 year ago
Dustin Hoffman pissed me off in this movie poor Milla...the English raped and murdered her sister and destroyed her country and killed thousands of her countrymen and so yeah she got pissed and raised an army and had many victories...and then at the end of the movie Dustin Hoffman is busting her balls and giving her a hard time over it...she didn't do anything wrong she helped to liberate her country...I don't get it...damn Hollywood revisionist history...
XxowendanxX 1 year ago
horrible just horrible R.I.P Joan of Arc ;(
PookieBearDaisy 1 year ago
Hundreds of people were burned at the stake during the 16th century in england due to religion, innocent people.. Call them selves people of god, more like animals!
ihatechavsXD 1 year ago 3
@ihatechavsXD they also drownd them
vir8KUMBIERITA 1 year ago
I threw up after seeing this! I was so angry that I just couldnt take it
tweethang1 1 year ago
I hope you christians burn in hell for this. She was just a 19 year old girl.!!
tweethang1 1 year ago
@tweethang1 its not christians who did this man.fuckin priests,supposed men of the cloth,"men of God in earth".tch tch the only real Christian was her,a martyr,a savior and a heroine and thats the bottom line.
You think you are now???
YES
GOOD
Gotta love her just for that...
Elspethknighterrant 1 year ago
@tweethang1 Joan was a Christian.She was the only true one,the people here weren't they just used God's name to justify what they did to others.Please do not say 'YOU Christians' I'm not in the same category as these people.
Though you're right it is sick.
eviltree99 1 year ago
Comment removed
tweethang1 1 year ago
@tweethang1 It's okay.Really I'm as disgusted as you are about this stuff so I get a little edgy when placed in the same category as these supposed 'Christians' who don't know God at all.
eviltree99 1 year ago
Thats the catholic church for you.
fsxlover 1 year ago
What a way to finish a movie! Brilliant job by the cast and the filmmakers. Rest in Peace Joan of Arc.
Sanderus 1 year ago
Comment removed
tweethang1 1 year ago
Beautiful movie...I just can't believe it ended like that...I just could not believe at how stupid and what monsters people are in the past. I feel like crying when I finished watching this.
SimlishSammy 1 year ago
And shortly after this, they realized they made an oops. Someone said "We've burned a saint". Whoops! Besides, burning doesn't kill witches. It said so in Harry Potter.
orlandogirl213 1 year ago
When I see Dustin Hoffman in that scene I expect him to say "Miss Joan, I think you are trying to seduce me!"
kingofmilwaukee 1 year ago
amazing movie
Delroc88 1 year ago
My god!! My body hurts after seeing this!! What a way to die. She probably died from the terror and fear alone.
tweethang1 1 year ago 22
@tweethang1 I agree with you, but personally, I'm glad that she chose to die rather than deny God! Die with honor instead of living your whole life with nothing but shame.
AnakinAhsokaGeek18 1 year ago 3
@tweethang1 same here my stomach trusn seeing this, and i read that English raked back the coals to expose her charred body so that no one could claim she had escaped alive, then burned the body twice more to reduce it to ashes and prevent any collection of relics. They cast her remains into the Seine, such horrid
AnimeLuver70 1 year ago
@tweethang1 The "good" part is that people who are burned often die from asphyxia due to all the smoke. But it's still a horrible way to die, yes.
HelenaXVI 10 months ago
the one with LeeLee Sobiesky is way slower and more dramatic at the burning scene...this one doesn't waste any time. it's horrible :(
TheWolfSings 1 year ago
Whats the song called in this video when shes getting burned??
EmoMad3line 1 year ago
lets just remeber what the catholics done to the reformers for telling the truth to the world
BestLoyalistMusic10 2 years ago
and lets also remeber what the protestant done to catholics also for protecting there beliefs we both did wrong it doesnt make it right thwe world is sick no matter what everyone will kill .
GodTowardSociety 1 year ago
yea ano man , everyone is sick
BestLoyalistMusic10 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
lol funny as fuck
SteveoMagician 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This movie was disgusting, particularly the last scene.
deslock1 2 years ago
Thank you ;0)
jessgregnmeg 2 years ago
What is this song called?
jessgregnmeg 2 years ago
The title of the song is "Angelus In Medio Ignis" composed by Eric Serra. It sounds like Carl Orff's O Fortuna
chitobass 2 years ago 2
The other song is "My Heart Calling" also composed by Eric Serra.
chitobass 2 years ago
How the hell do them made this scene? when she burning?
MrRambo4 2 years ago
WOW!!! is all I can say!
NeoDanomaru 2 years ago
Is it me or did you make this video go extra fast?..
ChristinaNL89 2 years ago
this last scene is amazing Oo