NIGHTWISH - Wish I Had An Angel - ArtMania Festival 2009 - Sibiu

[Rina19961]

Nu imi vine sa cred ce a facut din melodia asta :((......nu am nimic cu Anette, chiar imi place cum canta dar aici...:| a stricat totul...asculta-ti un clip unde canta Tarja (aceiasi melodie,live) si pe urma ascultati-o pe asta :|..

[ipodlover360]

Anette is really good singer but not for this band. knowing she came into a band that origanly had a famous opera singer in it. I miss Tarja soo bad. TARJA DOMINATED ANETTE!!!!!!!

[vladcjskate]

she pregnant or what?

[GloveMC]

LOL

[dikalam]

please do not sing Tarja's songs ...

[GloveMC]

This sounds horrible, for real, Nightwish sucks now.

Tarja WAS Nightwish.

[Escapist666]

@GloveMC oh yeah, Tarja WAS.

Long live Nightwish with Anette!!!)))

Anette rules!=))))

[Monrosefreak91094]

all the argues about tarja and anette are stupid, but there's one simple fact:

anette can't sing what tarja sang. she should stick to dpp until the new album is done.

[wfcandrewkit1999]

0:10 LOL :D

[Glady210]

They had thousands of girls to choose from. It's obvious they weren't forced to choose someone, but were able to choose exactly what type of voice they were looking for. They picked Anette. Now stop whining.

[Akoro88]

yeah really

[spidermangrip]

BLIMEY! She is SO out of tune! It sounds like she's taking the piss out of NW! 'I wish I have an angel to ni-i-i-i-i-ieeeeght!' Yodelling rubbish it sounds absolutely HIDEOUS!!

FLOOR JANSEN's available, hint, hint, wink, wink! She would a lot more suitable with a lot more body in the vocals! Better than puny Anette shouting, whiny, out of tune pop vocals any day!

[MrReason09]

Actually "I wish I had an angel toniiiight" is on tune. "tona-a-a-a" is called vibratto, dipshit, not yodelling. There's some serius difference between the 2. You certainly can't hear it though.

Floor Jansen is not what NW was looking for. They were looking for someone like Anette. so just STFU and deal with it, fucking twat.

[spidermangrip]

It's called VIBRATO MrDippy not vibratto you TWIT!

She is yodelling again lol; a VIBRATO is a regular pulsating pitch on the SAME note. Anette doesn't hold out the note on 'I wish I had an angel to-ni-i-i-i-i-ght' , so NO THICKO, it is NOT called vibrato it's her cheap attempt at a staccato which is pathetic since it doesn't work where she's put it but like YOU, she doesn't have the artistic judgement or sense to see that it's childish shitty rubbish! YOU are so DUMB it's beyond a joke! FOOL!

[MrReason09]

Yeah it's vibrato, sorry I typed it quickly.

You know...what I'm going to do is rare for me...but I'll have to stop this discussion. You're WAY too stupid. And I mean TOO stupid. I simply don't see a sense in doing this.

The "staccato" part was funny though. Please get some musical education first, and then let's argue again, ok?

[spidermangrip]

I'm not arguing with you MrDippy. I'm just enjoying taking all the opportunities you give me to point out a bit more what a rubbishy job Anette is doing for the long suffering NW... Don't worry lads, you only have to do a few more gigs with her then you can BOOT IT OUT!! Well done to NW for putting themselves through all the ear bashing Anette vocals to honour the bookings... I feel your pain... I certainly couldn't have done it... MrDippy, YOU simply need a BASIC education NIT WIT! :-)

[takneo]

hahaha!!! XD

Staccato, EPIC FAIL

XD

[spidermangrip]

Hahaha! YOURSELF IGNORANT FOOL! Staccato; short separate notes i.e. 'I wish I had an angel to-ni-i-i-i-i-ight' Your friend MrDippy thought that was vibrato, you guys suit each other. Actually it sounds more like a YODEL when Anette does it! YOU and your friend ARE BOTH EPIC FAILS! lol

[takneo]

actually a staccato is the opposite of Legato.

It's impossible for Anette to do a staccato in a legato form. Therefore Anette does a vibrato here, in a legato form.

If you don't really understand what a staccato is, you could hear Mozart's Queen of the night aria. It's quite a good example for you to understand how Staccato sounds.

[spidermangrip]

That's why I said '..it was her CHEAP ATTEMPT at a staccato..' it's impossible for her to sing staccato as you say, because her head voice is so under developed, weak and uncontrolled. That's also why I said it sounds more like YODELLING when Anette does it. She is not an artist, she is a clumsy fool who is ruining NW! She sounds like a soccer hooligan cheering for her team at a soccer match.

[spidermangrip]

You surprise me, you seem to have such good taste listening to Mazart, so how you can tolerate Anette's live vocal efforts, I have NO IDEA!

[takneo]

The thing is...I really like Nightwish. As a band.

But Anette actually is quite Ok. She is not the greatest singer ever, but neither was Tarja. They are both probably on a very similar technique level. So it's not a big change.

P.S: I'm not like YulieAna or MrReason; I'm not gonna start a fight because I like Anette and you don't. So please, respect my opinion as I respect yours.

[spidermangrip]

BLIMEY! Anette has obliterated this song to absolute ruins. Why she does that off pitch yodelling I have no idea AND even less idea how Tuomas and the rest of Nightwish can put up with her trashing their songs! Surely they will boot her out as soon as this tour has finished as she's dragging them all down to her poppy level performance.

[MrReason09]

Because they are musicians who have been in the business for fucking decades, and aren't tone deafs like you.

They can see the talent Anette has because they actually know something about music. Sadly, you can't even tell the difference between metal and pop. You're a complete fail.

[spidermangrip]

You're the fail Mr Muddlehead! I know Anette's voice is suitable for POP not Metal, I know that Anette sings FAR TOO MANY notes OFF PITCH and that she yodels like an RnB vocalist cause she's trying to disguise the fact that she cannot sing the songs properly. 'I wish I had an angel to-n-i-i-i-i-i-ight!' You're a twerp who knows nothing about Metal if you think she sounds good. She sounds like a childish karaoke singer down the pub!

[MrReason09]

Jesus...You just wrote a very long comment with NOT A SINGLE SUSTAINABLE ARGUMENT, just saying "Anette sucks she sucks she sucks buabuaaaa".

Guess what, voices are not classified into pop or rock, so in theory any voice is suitable for metal or pop. She uses chest voice, which has been used in Metal since the beginning. you're just making up pure shit.

You say she goes off key yet you can't point out any single proof.

Get lost, and get some music education.

[spidermangrip]

The more you write the more you portray yourself to be a FOOL! SOME VOICES ARE MORE SUITABLE FOR POP LIKE ANETTE'S!! So by your reasoning Mariah Carey can sing Metal? That would be hilarious like your arguments. Listening to Anette trying to sing for NW is all the proof I need that she's no good at pitching her voice to the backing music! She's useless for Metal and is dragging standards DOWN!

[MrReason09]

Mariah Carey could perfectly sing Metal if she really wanted to. Within Temptation's Sharon sings with chest voice and many songs can be classified as Metal. And Tarja Turunen now sings pop and she uses classical technique. Only braindead morons like you think that metal is a religion. It is just a fucking music genre.

And you still can't prove she goes off pitch. I could show you were she reaches notes perfectly.

You're a fucking ape.

[MrReason09]

You still can't give me even a single fucking argument. Please prove me it's worthy arguing with you, or go back to the whole were you came from, and STFU.

[spidermangrip]

You NITWIT Mariah Carey couldn't sing Metal!! You know nothing about the technicalities. She has to have so much compression on her mic, the Metal guitars would cause too much feedback you twerp! Mariah's voice isn't strong enough to do live performances with a Metal backline! Plus her vocal phrasing and styling would sound like a joke just like Anette's FOOL! Metal is a music genre that is METAL NOT RnB or POP! You've the brain of an APE!

[MrReason09]

Wake up, fucking twat. Mariah Carey is a world class singer. Metal wouldn't do anything to her, she just need a proper in ear system.

"Metal is a music genre that is METAL"

Wow that was brilliant, I feel smarter already...stop making a fool of yourself please.

You really don't know nothing about music in general.

Metal is not a science, MUSIC is a science, and when you get to understand it, you can pretty much sing anything with the proper training. It has NOTHING TO DO WITH VOICE.

[spidermangrip]

It has EVERYTHING to do with the voice THICKO, and the structure of the vocal chords. If you haven't got the basic make up no amount of training will make you hit notes you weren't designed to hit. There are limits to what training can do! YOU FEEL SMARTER BECAUSE YOU'RE DIM! An in ear system won't make Mariah Carey's voice stronger and heavier. She has a great range but her voice isn't strong and heavy enough for METAL, she'd be swallowed up by the backline!

[MrReason09]

You're talking like this was all some robot shit. Voices can be worked out, as ranges can be widen. Just like ANY singer in the world, you just turn the microphone volume up and there you go. We're not singing opera anymore dude.

Please, you have proved us enough of your stupidity, you talk like if Metal was some kind of religion.

You have neither arguments, nor music knowledge. so please don't bother answering this with your pathetic excuse of a response.

[spidermangrip]

There are LIMITS to what vocal training can do. To give you a simple illustration because you are SIMPLE, you can't make a baritone reach whistle register because his vocal chords are the wrong size and shape. There are LIMITS to how much you can turn up a mic in a live situation before it will feedback, HOWL and blast your eardrums out... FOOL! I repeat, the more you write, the more FOOLISH and IGNORANT you come across.

[Felinestance]

learn about music then talk

[spidermangrip]

Anette gets swallowed up by the backline when she performs live with NW coz her voice is too thin and dainty more suited to light POP music.... Good job coz it covers up her out of tune vocals and immature phrasing. She sounds better on these youtube videos than she does live because of the compression on the recording devices. When you're actually there in at the gig, it sounds even more shitty, thin and unbalanced!

[1AzureSky]

Tarja's voice sounds shitty, thin, and unbalanced nowadays too, and is only suitable for the light pop music she sings.

U C WUT I DID THAR?!

[gratbil]

Tarja´s voice is so thin that you can hear her even when the guitars play at full force. That´s something I couldn´t say about many other singers for example .... (drop in whatever name comes to your mind).

[YulieAna]

Tarja's voice is completely drowned out by Doro in their duets together. And please, don't say that her mic was lowered or some shit like that.

[1AzureSky]

You do realize that studio magic can mix a voice to be higher in the mix? Besides, there was barely any guitar in her solo stuff, and she still sounded rather thin over the light symphonics.

[Felinestance]

abosolutely true, plus she doesn't even compose her songs

[coilofdeath]

you're so right man! exellent explanation!

[wwwEMPTYDREAMSnet]

Sper sa primeasca si ea scrisoarea de adio dupa concertul din Helsinki :)

[BUCURGEORGE]

Oare cum ar canta Anette "Sleeping sun"?????

[badkidruxy]

cauta ca sunt concerte in care a cantat si Slepping Sun(suna ff tare :] )

[BUCURGEORGE]

penibil......foarte penibil...n'am nimic cu saraca fata....da' nu sa lipeste de melodia asta.....

[ErnoNFE]

bah retardatilor, puteti sa va opriti din a posta comm-uri de genu' : "Anette e varza" ? Daca nu era ea trupa nu venea in Romania. Plus ca ...daca nu iti place cum canta, nu te obliga nimeni sa o asculti. Asculta melodiile vechi si gata. Numai ca mentalitatea asta de oameni retardati se intalneste din ce in ce mai des cand vine vorba de noua solista. Asta e! M-ai mult nu puteti. Personal va inteleg, si tot ce pot sa spun e...Condoleante!

[alkadeyas]

e o parodie, sau?e gretzoasa tipa....dezamagire crunta:(

[LPforever1994]

Concertul a fost foarte frumos nu pot sa reprosez nimic\m/

[helgaWishmaster]

wow!

she makes a show!!

[nightwishalex]

nightwish ne'au fcut o surpriza foarte palcuta cantand melodii precum wishmaster ever dream si altele, eu ma asteptat sa cante numa melidii de pe "once" si "dark passion play"...da anette a stricat totu cu vocea ei pe melodiile vechi si miscarea ei scenica zici ca era o "capra in calduri"!

[Lorinion]

Mie mi s-a parut ca are voce de teen pop sensation. Am fost destul de dezamagit de prestatia ei, ca multi altii de altfel.

[atveus]

buna inregistrare..iar annete...:|...sub orice critica...imi venea sa plec...

[v4mpireheart]

si de ce nu ai plecat?

[atveus]

dc nu am plecat?...poate pentru ca am dat niste bani ca sa fiu acolo..sa aud o prestatie rock...si am auzit...o instrumentala rock..impecabila acompaniata de o pipitza parca cazuta de la cabaret...patetic...

[GalusHcaa]

nu simte deloc frumusetea melodiei. zici ca e o prestatie de pop music, nu symphonic.. Anette are voce, dar nu pentru melodiile vechi de la Nightwish..

[badkidruxy]

Nu cred ca trebuie sa fii sophrana ca sa ai voce de metal symphonic, chiar daca ar merge mai bine. A fost un concert super si Anette a fost ff funny cu rata aia xD!

[tzusch]

superba prestatia,si din partea trupei,si din partea vocalistei

[alkoolik1992]

Si cind piesa asta era una din preferatele mele...de ce trebuie k "asta" sa le distruga faima ce o aveau odata???? + ca cinta ca o gaina ragusita...

[NWphreek]

sa te vedem pe tine, ok? canta superb. orice om care ar sti cate ceva despre muzica ar sti asta. daca tie nu iti place, asta e pentru ca esti un prost cu mintea ingusta care nu poate accepta o schimbare. end of story.

[kristicuk]

Atat timp cat sunt baietii in trupa, nu am treaba cu Anette,  a fost un concert bestial, de vis, mi-a placut fiecare secunda din el!!! I LOVE NIGHTWISH!!!

[morrighan02]

corect! a fost super!!!!

[lostinthedark2008]

OMG...I can believe how.s anette´s dressed :)) she is like a ...