Evanescence Cloud Nine Live @ Stgo Chile 13.04.07

[marquinhos982]

canta muito

[zombinagirl]

Wtf? She sounds awesome to me, wtf are u talking about? xD

[MayRPIK]

kiraFE100 Mentira!! Que en el concierto no suene muy bien no significa en absoluto que su voz esté deteriorada!

[kiraFE100]

que penca con los años se le esta llendo la vos... ahora son pocas las cantantes de metal que no desafinan en vivo

[evanescence9314]

she sounds tired, but I didn't hear her losing her voice. ..

[dellyally]

We ,all in turkiye, love u Amy Lee ...

[Kakarota14790]

she lost her voice during this song, that's why it sounds a little bit strange.

[alexel85]

@kakarota: Not just this song, she lost her voice during the entire concert in Santiago (Chile) (especially during Lithium and Good Enough)... That's probably why the live dvd is never released for "the open door tour", it's obvious that it was recorded with professional equipment, but never seen the light of the day... unfortunately...

[Kakarota14790]

yes, that's a shame :S

[b233]

su voz suena rara como am am raro jaja amo Evanescence mucho mas cuando suena raro jaja

[eacz12]

mmm it sounds perfect to me...

[TheBogossdu10]

J'aime cette chanson et j'aime Amy Lee <3

[euzkatroika]

ella es una artista. y esta cancion tiene mucho significado para las personas que aman. no le quedo bien , pero se le acerpta porque es una buena interprete

[dalm969]

yo estuve en este concierto y estuvo la raja!!!

[DeannaMASSACRE]

Dude, I love Amy to death but i felt so out of breath for her! It was hard to watch her sing. Even though I know she kicks ass she pulls through. I just hope that since her voice has strengthen so much over the years that when she sings it again, it won't be that bad.

[Zerolagg]

This song is voice killing... poor Amy, she managed to end the song still... that awesome she is!!!

[MissingAnywhere]

I'm a huge Evanescence fan!!! and despite this concert wasn't the best... this song rocks.

It's the best performance of the song, well she almost didn't reach the last tone but she did a great job because it's pretty hard to sing.

Even she improved a lot her voice in the last two concerts (NY & Brasil), she dind't reach the tone @ "change my mind"

pds. hey evanescence fans, don't punished me, u know I'm right

[evanescence9314]

@MissingAnywhere we know you're right. xD amy lee lost her voice during this song in this concert, that's why they stopped playing it live. D: but i still have TOD so it's fine by me. xD this song rocks!!

[jimbo222000]

OMG amy lee is beautiful

[axxz03]

i love thsi song its a shame its doesnt sounds so good as in the cd

and it seems very hard to sing

[AnaLetuka]

tssssssssss nononoon no :(

[imafanofamylee]

she so awesome!!

maybe she hardly sing when jumping and headbanging but i understand that! AMY U ROCK!!!

[Caos0828]

por esta cancion Amy se quedo con la voz estropeada por el resto del concieerto

es que esta cancion exige mucho

[petitanyell1]

According to The Evanescence Reference:

"During the Chile 2007 concert, Amy lost her voice doing Cloud Nine song, which is probably the reason they stopped playing this song so soon"

[KarolinaPacia]

I read it a few minutes ago too , but i watched a video and everything is ok...i don't know :)

[samigirl3211]

at the end her voice was strained and that probably what they mean especially during some of the high notes so after the concert she probably lost her voice and with the past she's had she would know what song did it to her voice

[haydeee31]

muy pronto ...evanescence en peru

[Caos0828]

ah?

[PurpleGothFreak]

AWESOME I love this song Live!...I love that outfit she's so awesome I wish she would do Like U live even though that song about her sister its just a beautiful Song!.i .love that song too bad she didnt do that one live.!

[cloudninequeen]

this is so awesome i love this song and ,it is hard i tried to sing it and i can't get passed "then let go off me"the first time ,i definitely understand amy loosing some off her voice its not easy ,but even if it sounds like she loses it ,it somehow come out preety awesome though ,so it dosen't matter if she dosen't sound the same because we see her live ,and not go to hear the album,Evanescence totally rocks

[Laine108]

Whoop! 0:46 - 0:50

[Laine108]

I absolutly love this video... I cant stop watching it. I love how she says high at 0.46-0.50

[Laine108]

Idc if she is sick in this video. She sounds amazing! It doesnt sound like she is even sick here. Nothing can take over that beautiful voice of hers

[vampiresneverforsake]

this was a great performance, even though she was sick ( literally) she didn't let that take over her beutiful voice. :)

[HollyTheFireNinja]

This is the performance where she almost lost her voice in. She really tried very hard and I agree that it paid off.

[quallilein]

Supernature06,i also would love her if she would be really fat,although she´s not!!! because she is a very funny and nice person and she had to go through so much pain like the death of her little sister and the problems with her ex-boyfriend....so shut your mouth and don´t look this videos of evanescence if you don´t like them.

[BandGeek824]

She tries hard and it really pays off:)

[semvitor]

muito bom!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[facu2929]

this is definitly the hardest song to perform of the open door

because all the park of the chorus are high and powerfull

IF IIIIIIIIIII FAAAAAAAAALLL AAANDDD ALL...

definitly the hardest song

followed by your star

AMY ROCKSSSS!!!

[headlesssinger]

This was the last time they performed "Cloud Nine" live.

It was too hard for Amy to perform regularly and she began to suffer throat issues because of it.

So they stopped performing it live after this concert.

[nathalievera]

wow really? no wonder i cudnt find many videos of this song live. I think Your Star is just as hard though, i dont understand... well i love evanescence but yea, her live perfomances of this song are not so great.

[killmetwiceplz]

:D so we got the last one?

amazing!

[proxyix]

whats this a song ?

[Supernature06]

She really needs vocal training that was horrible. Also shes so fat.

[Illusion483]

She is simply amazing *_*

[facu2929]

it's a shame they couldn't play this song in the quilmes rock (2 days after this)

anyway amy rocks!!!!!

[nickolasgoth]

She was sick in that concert...that's why her voice was cracking

[IanasAnd]

Grat love her and her music n1

[Evfan301]

I really love how the music sort of crashes in when she says they word "love" at 3:12.. Amazing.. :D

[SoopaDoopaSumo]

I admire the determination of her. Even though her voice is cracking and near enough gone, she carries on. She even looks as though she is pain. Thats what you call a true star...anyoneelse ould have given up. Keep Rockin Amy!

[smarcola]

She didn't breathe after "I" If she would have performed it as

"..is where I *BREATHE* Belong"

then she wouldn't have strained her voice.

[depaz019]

i really hate to say this but she really did flunked it but still she did not stop at all shes pretty awesome

[eilonamram14]

shes awesome

[Rozepoester]

LETS MAKE THIS CLEAR X3;

During the Chile 2007 concert, Amy lost her voice doing this song, which is probably the reason they stopped playing this song so soon.

~ Evanescence Reference.

Amy was not in her best at Chile, we all hear that, and especially on Good Enough she sings terrible. But hey, everybody has their darkest days. Even Amy Lee.

Amy is a goddess. She's amazing. But we all must respect she cant always sings so amazing.

[XxMyReflectionxX]

Wow!

That is the best performance of cloud 9!!

[DeathxByxLemons]

jeez amy wasn't that bad, it was a bit rough at the end but other than that i thought it was really good, her voice just sounds sore.

anyways the band played great as always, tim's bass is so awesome (and so is tim :P)

[ktluvaxx]

I'm pretty sure Amy would appreciate us being so kind to express our opinion. And I'm sure she appreciates the defending fans of hers, but she doesn't need you fighting her battles, and if she cared that much, she'd probably be posting a rant about her haters on EvThreads or something. The whole point is...it doesn't matter how much YOU hate on people who don't like her voice, she's still going to sound like that reguardless, and people are still going to dislike her, (as sad as that is)

[ktluvaxx]

Why are so many honest comments getting so many thumbs down?

First of all: it's just an opinion,

Second: They're actually kind of true.

But so what, Amy doesn't sound like she does on the album. Guess what...we have already established that; many, many times. Kay thanks.

[puli06]

Q recuerdos!!!

[Zym12]

fact of the matter: she doesn't have the breath capacity to sing this live.

and she probably didn't realize that when they recorded it seeing as vocals are recorded in clips.

this is one of her better performances of cloud nine, and if i'm not incorrect, i think they took that song out of the setlist altogether.

[LukeSWalker]

shut up cuz ur just a freakin hater! amy lee is awesome live but sometimes she can move around so much in the stage that she loses focus of her voice

[SunamiSoona]

I love Amy Lee! And I'm NOT a hater! It's just that her singing live and on the cds are kinda different in a way! That's all! (I said no offence...) *cries*

[amylee4e]

this song rocks live!!!! she is amazing with whatever she sings! and they rock at playing!

[chubsykins]

it sounds like shes dying, a slow tormenting death, from a soar throat or something :\

awful :(

[missingBra]

she has sick!

[BleedOnMeX]

maybe she was touring for a long, long time and after such a long time of singing almost all the time even her throat gets soar, yeah.. but even if she wasn't; it's not like she can never bring it, i've seen sooo many great preformances of her in which she was just.. amazing and her voice was perfect ^^ so..

[chubsykins]

me to but not THIS song :(

[cony87]

Me gusta! No le sale mal =) Nor regaló todo su esfuerzo para interpretarla a nosotros jejejeje. Buenísimaaa!! Es una de mis favoritas del disco.

[lithiumtearsxox]

she didd soooooooooo much better in this onee like noo lie<3

[chubsykins]

god this is AAAWFUL give her a drink or a strepsil or something :(

[lacunamaniac]

eu te amo AMY!

VEM PRA FORTALEZA - BRASIL!

POR FAVOR!

[il0veamylee]

dijo q era la mas dificil

pero a mi me enkanto este conierto!

amy te amo!

[anthony910107]

es impresionante, osea la cantidad de aire ke tiene esta mujer, en verdad canta super maximo, tambien me enkantan los conciertos en tokyo, y tambien los de nissan live sets estan buenoy aaa y los del dvd jeje es lo mejor ella si ke merece ser famosa la amo

[kmivale0410]

evanescence lo mejor !!!!!!! amy lo maximooooo yo kielo ser como ella cuando gande !!!!! :)

[evfan80]

Awesome performance.

[quierounyutu]

yo estuve aHi...igual la vi de cerca...

en el recital no se cacharon muchos la pifias quew salioeron de su voz...por

[smarcola]

Ouch! She's really having to proect her voice. She did great considering. :D

[jdnajes]

she said in several interviews that this is the hardest song for her to perform live. imo, she struggles too much just to sound 'ok'. I think they should drop this from the set and replace it with something where she sounds as awesomely as she can

[smarcola]

Earlier on in the tour she sounded amazing doing this song. She was even extending the notes and adding mellismas in but, I agree, after that long she couldn't keep doing this.

I think she should add this to their acoustic setlist coz they might be able to sit her down. XD

[PRINCEjuul]

What'cha talking about, this is one of the best live Cloud Nine's I've ever seen! Go Amy<3.

[missingBra]

she has sick!"

[chubsykins]

its still awful, she MIGHT be sick, if shes sick then she shouldnt do it in the set, ive not seen ONE good performance of this song :\ ever. if you find a good one PKEASE send me the link :)

[TonlliGirl]

por qué cantó así de feo? estaba enferma?

[egooh]

segun dijo estaba nerviosa, o sea no digamos que amy lee tiene la gran voz en estos tipos de conciertos donde se mueve tanto (por que cuando canta senatada en un piano canta hermoso) pero esa noche tenia la voz particularmente extraña, no alcanzaba las notas agudas bien. En fin, eso ni se noto en el concierto en vivo xD me vine a dar cuenta cuando lo vi en video.

[DaNaExReVeNgE]

por ahí escuché que amy había dicho (qué enredo xD) que cloud nine era una de las canciones más difíciles de cantar, debido que las notas eran muy altas y prolongadas, así que eso podría explicarlo xD

[HinjhotephIII]

@egooh CUANDO ERES CANTANTE LIRICO COMO LO ES AMY LEE ALCANZAR LOS AGUDOS EN ESE MENEO EN LA TARIMA ES MUY DIFICIL YA QUE LOS CANTANTES LIRICOS NECESITAN ESTAR EN REPOSO PARA ALCANZAR SU TONO COMPLETO MAS SI SON MEZZO SOPRANOS COMO ELLA, Y SI VEZ QUE EN ACUSTICA CANTA EXCELENTE LO CUAL LE DA A ELLA UN GRAN PUNTO A SU FAVOR PORQUE HAY ALGUNOS ARTISTAS QUE EN ACUSTICA NADA QUE VER

[anntsuy7]

@TonlliGirl si tmb estaba enfermaa

[papeleshigienicos]

@TonlliGirl según sé estaba con gripe justo en ese tour, además sus voz se escucha un poco agripada ... :(

pero igual tengo el DVD y el CD de este conciertoo *-*

[lapalomax]

pucha!! no pude ir :( pero igual todos los videos reviven lo que paso alla y ojala que evanescence venga de nuevo por que si es que viene de nuevo voy si o si...

saludos a fans de evanescence de chile y el mundo xD

[Kolnicky]

AMO ESTA CANCIÓN *-*

Es taaan sexy :$ xD

LA AMOOO

[Fyor3]

AMO EVANESCENCEEEEE !!! amo a amyyyyyy!!! yo estuve ahí ese día, lejos fué el día mas fantastico de toda mi vida!!! obvio qe quedará en mi (L) x mucho tiempo más, no me canso de ver y escuchar el concierto, aunque en lithium y good enough a Amy le salió un pokito desafinado, pero no importa.. valieron la pena los 6 años de espera x ver a Evanescence en vivo :)

[theonlyoneW600]

aber cuando sacan otro CD+DVD en vivo... espero que pronto

[Giodancing]

Great performance!But Amy can do better

[ktluvaxx]

that is Amy -.-

[renankunha]

cloud nine a música do cadomblé :~~

[sicpcis]

wenisimo!!!!

lo ame! grax por subirlo :)

sicpcis.