I actually like this version better than the rootsy version on 'Catch a Fire'. This version is a lot more intense and energetic. Sounds like a Caribbean version of the Impressions...
Relax all you reggae snobs. It was mis-created . . . slightly. Tosh was a member of The Wailers, but since Marley was the front man, this being credited to Marley is more shorthand than inaccurate. OK, hope I didn't interrupt your little superiority trip. Turn the egos back on, hommies.
Well, Stop THAT Train was of course on Catch a Fire, and although Tosh was the lead singer on this track, it is a Bob Marley album so many people, including me, just note it as 'Bob Marley - Stop That Train'. Just not sure if this story applies to this version, never heard it before.
Dear LORD people, this song was recorded by Bob Marley & the Wailing Wailers in their early days when Peter Tosh was playing bass for the Wailers. Tosh recorded another version years later, but this is the original. Quit griping about people knowing their facts when you don't do any research.
Another vídeo that says "Bob Marley", but isnt, you guys should take a time and find out about Bob Marley's songs, respect Bob and other artists too, thats not fair! What a ignorance!
bob marley is not over rated. just bc people for some reason give him credit for some stuff he didnt do, doesnt mean hes overrated. he is a LEGEND, hes got the title he deserves
I wouldn't call it 'overrated', just misunderstood. No, wait, Bob Marley isn't misunderstood, Reggae is. It's like thinking Eminem is the only rapper.
all those "doo doo doo doo doo" 's are Bob. and the mm mm mmhmmm's, too. the lead vocalist is Peter Tosh, with Bob & Bunny on backing. it's pretty easy to tell if you actually listen. All three very great and different musicians, and all three deserving of their due credit.
to the victims of the holocaust twont be long till the wicked are vanquished and the earth is unified and early land an oasis not one desert barren land.
Actually ya'll, it's not Peter Tosh. It's ALL of the Wailers, when they were just "The Wailers" (no Bob Marley and the...) with Tosh on lead vocals. Beautiful song, beautiful message, beautiful life tragically cut short by the ignorance of others.
*sigh* this song reminds me of the summers when I was 14 - 16 years old... peaceful days where I had a good time with my best friends smoking dope, having barbecues, swimming, making dreadlocks and rastas... sometimes I wish I could turn back time
Geez, yet another mistaken credit given to Bob Marley. Sigh... It's pathetic that so many Marley fans are ignorant. Marley didn't write, create and perform all reggae songs in existence. I'm a Marley fan, and as good as he is, he's overrated because, in part, because people give him credit for songs he didn't do.
Bob Marley did, in fact, create every reggae song ever written. In fact, every song you hear from the Caribbean is Bob Marley. (Sarcasm btw.) All kidding aside, it really does piss me off when people hear reggae and assume it's Bob.
Yes, he did. If I were an alien and came to learn about reggae through youtube, or talking to people at reggae shows in America, I would think that Bob Marley is behind all reggae songs. I'd honestly understand the miscredits if the singers actually sounded even somewhat similar to Marley, but most of them don't. I mean, come on, "Smoke Two Joints"?? Sounds NOTHING like Marley's voice. "Don't Worry, Be Happy"? What a joke!
well ... dont worry be happy was credited to bob cuz he made his own version of the song. his version became 20 times more popular so he got the credit, yes not his song ... but he sang it and he made it famous!
I hope you're joking, because Bob Marley neither wrote nor recorded such a song. It's Bobby McFerrin who did.
People are crediting Marley for all these songs he had nothing to do with because they've been brainwashed by Island Records, which did one heckuva job marketing Marley to "Western" audiences. So now suburbanites everywhere can listen to Marley while driving their SUVs, trucks and hybrids, while sipping Starbucks and cradling their iPhones.
@mykalroze actually marley is not overrated.... first off any one who is a true marley fan should be able to distinguish his voice even if its the first time hearing a new song by him......the artiste who sings this song is peter tosh.
@mykalroze - yes you are right, people do give him credit for songs that he didn't write but I'm not sure that that puts him in the overated catagory. He's not the biggest name in music (worldwide) because a few people haven't done their homework.
@mykalroze Relax, this came from Catch a Fire by The Wailers written by Tosh (one of two songs on the album by him). So since Marley was the headman of The Wailers, not so big a sin. And he's not overrated in the least.
@mykalroze Relax all you reggae snobs. It was mis-created . . . slightly. Tosh was a member of The Wailers, but since Marley was the front man, this being credited to Marley is more shorthand than inaccurate. OK, hope I didn't interrupt your little superiority trip. Turn the egos back on, hommies.
sounds like The wailerssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssss!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! toooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo meeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
yh tosh is singing but this came out really early back when it was bob marley, peter tosh and bunny wailer, i'm guessin lol this was out before my time
eh no no no, they were in the same band you know but peter tosh wrote this song so he sings in lead position. Bunny and Peter left because marley got all attention so you are wrong
my bad man i wasnt thinkin when i said that...it just bugs me so bad when people talk crap ove the internet...and i do agree with you he does deserve more respect, everyone has bob marley on song that peter tosh wrote and sang
we arabs aks almighty ALAAH evryday 2 stop the train cuz no one love us ,, we all gone reach zion & only HIM well tell ya'll that we loved ya'll ,, big ups 2 my RAS ppl & capleton z da new massinger
It's ashame peole forget it was Bob Marley and the Waliers, not just Bob Marley. I mean this song's listed as bob marley stop that train but Bob didn't even sing this song, it's Peter Tosh. I think Bob's doing some backing vocals though. Real good song though.
i cudn't give 2 f**ks what cds uve got at the end of the day a legend has spoken and this is not a reason to size up ur collections to one another, its a reason to respect the mans lyrics and comment on that. Sort urselfs out.
I think there are two or more Marley cd's with the name "Sun is Shining" and the one I have might be harder to find. There are 22 tracks on it and this version of "Stop that Train" is on it. I was trying to help mattwaad find a cd that had this version.
I actually like this version better than the rootsy version on 'Catch a Fire'. This version is a lot more intense and energetic. Sounds like a Caribbean version of the Impressions...
catboyzee 1 month ago
no roots but regea
yannickleusink 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Relax all you reggae snobs. It was mis-created . . . slightly. Tosh was a member of The Wailers, but since Marley was the front man, this being credited to Marley is more shorthand than inaccurate. OK, hope I didn't interrupt your little superiority trip. Turn the egos back on, hommies.
probrojeffro 2 months ago
Comment removed
probrojeffro 2 months ago
Well, Stop THAT Train was of course on Catch a Fire, and although Tosh was the lead singer on this track, it is a Bob Marley album so many people, including me, just note it as 'Bob Marley - Stop That Train'. Just not sure if this story applies to this version, never heard it before.
Renatar567 3 months ago
Dear LORD people, this song was recorded by Bob Marley & the Wailing Wailers in their early days when Peter Tosh was playing bass for the Wailers. Tosh recorded another version years later, but this is the original. Quit griping about people knowing their facts when you don't do any research.
Avenger325 3 months ago 4
Isn't Bob!
mink993 4 months ago
Another vídeo that says "Bob Marley", but isnt, you guys should take a time and find out about Bob Marley's songs, respect Bob and other artists too, thats not fair! What a ignorance!
Jhonatan5 4 months ago
how do so called marley fans not recognize that this is not his voice
I'm listening to this off of a playlist and was doing something else but immediately recognized it wasnt him.
I love marley, tosh, wailer and reggae so please people, give credit where its due
urasnitch69 4 months ago in playlist Bob Marley
bob marley is not over rated. just bc people for some reason give him credit for some stuff he didnt do, doesnt mean hes overrated. he is a LEGEND, hes got the title he deserves
crazybaldhead48 4 months ago
we should see if the uploader will change the name of it - at least put Peter Tosh (lead) and Bob Marley
SimplyCecileP 4 months ago
I wouldn't call it 'overrated', just misunderstood. No, wait, Bob Marley isn't misunderstood, Reggae is. It's like thinking Eminem is the only rapper.
DrsJacksonn 5 months ago
i hate that 3 people
bramknaller1 5 months ago
i love him <3 the best
miisz523 5 months ago
3 people are paralized
s0uf14n3 6 months ago
chillllllll........ just injoy the song who cares about doo doos and back in vocals. easy brothere.
rasta8292 7 months ago
all those "doo doo doo doo doo" 's are Bob. and the mm mm mmhmmm's, too. the lead vocalist is Peter Tosh, with Bob & Bunny on backing. it's pretty easy to tell if you actually listen. All three very great and different musicians, and all three deserving of their due credit.
marisadaniela6 7 months ago
This is my favorite version of this song. Thanks for posting.
19josh77 7 months ago
With all due respect you didnt know this was Peter not Bob? dude ease off the kind and do your homework son!
Edwah007 8 months ago
i love peter tosh!!!
UriahTheLeo 8 months ago
Bless in POLAND :))
Rafijozek 8 months ago
yet he did inspire each and every one
johanneck22 9 months ago
Why in the HELL would you dislike a Bob Marley song the three people that did must have gotten hit by the train.
Brandonbleb 10 months ago
One love <3
papprapp 11 months ago
Bob Marley is a Legend FOREVER ! <3<3
TheManonrock 11 months ago
If everyone listened to the Catch a Fire album once a day then we would have world peace.
YogiBear13 1 year ago
The singer is Peter Tosh, not Bob...
TheToporhead 1 year ago 6
@TheToporhead It's on Bob's greatest hits.
inedibleedible 4 months ago
@TheToporhead Bob marley does do some background voices
Pwnzor024 2 months ago
there are many different performances of this song, but dis be da best mon... jah bless peter tosh.. jah rastafari..
jessalynn2010 1 year ago
love bob marley
jessewalsh12 1 year ago
Well i had this music on a Bob Marley album,
mioloprode 1 year ago
@dussie08 peter Tosh, man.
CasualKarma 1 year ago
roots mee bredah
Benjoreally 1 year ago
No Problem
LorenzoNadia 1 year ago
to the victims of the holocaust twont be long till the wicked are vanquished and the earth is unified and early land an oasis not one desert barren land.
TheFriedLiverAttack 1 year ago
this is peter tosh :D
other legend of reggae
ScreggaeaficionBw 1 year ago
Esta é a versão do peter tosh ai o caralho
yowauno 1 year ago
goodbye nick!
Zoppolina 1 year ago
Actually ya'll, it's not Peter Tosh. It's ALL of the Wailers, when they were just "The Wailers" (no Bob Marley and the...) with Tosh on lead vocals. Beautiful song, beautiful message, beautiful life tragically cut short by the ignorance of others.
Bless up.
CasualKarma 1 year ago
@CasualKarma i thought he died of cancer not ignorance
dussie08 1 year ago
@dussie08 Murder. Shot twice in the head in his front yard during a robbery. Talking about Tosh, of course.
CasualKarma 1 year ago
I love this song. This version especially.
19josh77 1 year ago
peter tosh also does the vocals on many versions and his solo shit is fuckin great =D
devenbechtel1 1 year ago
the song is really good
I am from Germany and I understand the text Nich
but it sounds really well ;-)
Taddelgedaddel 1 year ago
No there is two differant songs..
This is bob who is singing this version..
rorytait123 1 year ago
i love bob and weeeeeeeeed,rest and smoke in pice my ganja man.
SuperBlueherb 1 year ago
yay^_^
Manschgi13 1 year ago
Hey anyone know the version that is heavy dub, and has sort of sheep sounds in the background???
PICLex 1 year ago
in order to sell a lot of records, I would still refer to marley if I'm looking for money
BeerB4ron 1 year ago
mutu fodaa peter tosh *--*
Danielrss 1 year ago
ahh been looking for this verson!<3
alixlovesretro 1 year ago
sing it peter one love
grunge0730 1 year ago
*sigh* this song reminds me of the summers when I was 14 - 16 years old... peaceful days where I had a good time with my best friends smoking dope, having barbecues, swimming, making dreadlocks and rastas... sometimes I wish I could turn back time
RocknRollSandra 2 years ago 3
it's written from bob marley but peter tosh had sung it
d1m1bitch 2 years ago 8
i have a disc floating around with this track on it, Tosh is not mentioned or credited on this track in any way. hmm, no wonder peter was pissed
kmare18 2 years ago
Do worry, be happy :D
Who is Bobby McFerrin?
Spasjan 2 years ago
this is my favorite version!!!!
RIP bob marley
cocksismyname 2 years ago 3
someone give me a list of songs that people think its bobs song.
i know like 2 - redredwine, and dont worry be happy.
you can tell this song is dont by him...his voice is soo much different wtf uh?
scastud1 2 years ago
This is peter tosh
HaitchP2008 2 years ago 2
I LOWE BOB MARLYS MUSIC
MrObretan 2 years ago
its Peter Tosh but everywhere i find this song its signed as Bob Marley song...
justbe24 2 years ago
Geez, yet another mistaken credit given to Bob Marley. Sigh... It's pathetic that so many Marley fans are ignorant. Marley didn't write, create and perform all reggae songs in existence. I'm a Marley fan, and as good as he is, he's overrated because, in part, because people give him credit for songs he didn't do.
mykalroze 2 years ago 8
Bob Marley did, in fact, create every reggae song ever written. In fact, every song you hear from the Caribbean is Bob Marley. (Sarcasm btw.) All kidding aside, it really does piss me off when people hear reggae and assume it's Bob.
1985MANAmericana 2 years ago
Yes, he did. If I were an alien and came to learn about reggae through youtube, or talking to people at reggae shows in America, I would think that Bob Marley is behind all reggae songs. I'd honestly understand the miscredits if the singers actually sounded even somewhat similar to Marley, but most of them don't. I mean, come on, "Smoke Two Joints"?? Sounds NOTHING like Marley's voice. "Don't Worry, Be Happy"? What a joke!
mykalroze 2 years ago
well ... dont worry be happy was credited to bob cuz he made his own version of the song. his version became 20 times more popular so he got the credit, yes not his song ... but he sang it and he made it famous!
Allmaster125 2 years ago
I hope you're joking, because Bob Marley neither wrote nor recorded such a song. It's Bobby McFerrin who did.
People are crediting Marley for all these songs he had nothing to do with because they've been brainwashed by Island Records, which did one heckuva job marketing Marley to "Western" audiences. So now suburbanites everywhere can listen to Marley while driving their SUVs, trucks and hybrids, while sipping Starbucks and cradling their iPhones.
mykalroze 2 years ago
@mykalroze - I ditto that!
Watson690 1 year ago
@mykalroze this is listed as Marley because this was on HIS album called Reggae Magic, which was done with Peter Tosh.
Gromper69 1 year ago
@mykalroze actually marley is not overrated.... first off any one who is a true marley fan should be able to distinguish his voice even if its the first time hearing a new song by him......the artiste who sings this song is peter tosh.
justasexygurl 1 year ago
@mykalroze - yes you are right, people do give him credit for songs that he didn't write but I'm not sure that that puts him in the overated catagory. He's not the biggest name in music (worldwide) because a few people haven't done their homework.
shellovski 7 months ago
@mykalroze Thank you! I was about to have an anuerysm. People do know there has been more than one reggae singer in history, correct? Nah, guess not.
KronosTheDeejay 4 months ago
@mykalroze Relax, this came from Catch a Fire by The Wailers written by Tosh (one of two songs on the album by him). So since Marley was the headman of The Wailers, not so big a sin. And he's not overrated in the least.
probrojeffro 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@mykalroze Relax all you reggae snobs. It was mis-created . . . slightly. Tosh was a member of The Wailers, but since Marley was the front man, this being credited to Marley is more shorthand than inaccurate. OK, hope I didn't interrupt your little superiority trip. Turn the egos back on, hommies.
probrojeffro 2 months ago
who's the vocals????? i doesnt sound like bob marley. backin vocals do tho
hazydaze83 2 years ago
petter tosh
schuindtmetal 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
not bob but peter!!!
flamedeck 2 years ago
u no ur music ha
TheKidperfection 2 years ago
sounds like The wailerssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssss!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! toooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo meeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
milanw 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
¤ø„¸Legend¸„ø¤º°¨~
¸„ø¤º°¨Bob Marley``°º¤ø„
¸„ø¤º``°º¤ø„¸„ø¤º¨°º¤ø
From Bosnia......he makes you smoke and enjoy!!! lol love him
dz1n2a 2 years ago
Excelente cancion me la puso mi novia colombiana cuando me iba de costa rica de regreso a mexico,
15321Klin 2 years ago
yh tosh is singing but this came out really early back when it was bob marley, peter tosh and bunny wailer, i'm guessin lol this was out before my time
robbob18 2 years ago
Bob Marley didn't sing this one. It was sung by Peter Tosh. It comes of The Best of The Wailers. Bob Marley's Version is on Catch a Fire.
iJay37 2 years ago 2
i like marley...
invernofrio 2 years ago
sounds like peter tosh
klockan77 2 years ago
Peter Tosh wrote this
nickyjam305 2 years ago
and this is singed by him
kfaraonk 2 years ago
¤ø„¸Legend¸„ø¤º°¨~
¸„ø¤º°¨Bob Marley``°º¤ø„
¸„ø¤º``°º¤ø„¸„ø¤º¨°º¤ø
From Utah, USA
kudafactor 2 years ago
ohh bob marley ...he is/was so good!!
compi1994 2 years ago
hell yeah this is the best version of the song. mah fav :D
deathkush 2 years ago 2
this is the version ive been looking for thank you so much for putting it up
whynotfish 2 years ago
bob marley sings background in this song to help peter tosh to get on his own feet in music buissnes
what a man
Nussschnaps 2 years ago 3
eh no no no, they were in the same band you know but peter tosh wrote this song so he sings in lead position. Bunny and Peter left because marley got all attention so you are wrong
Tomacco121 2 years ago
fuck you trying to correct people and shit just sit back and listen to the music who cars who is right or wrong
whynotfish 2 years ago 2
I wasnt being mean I just think it is important because peter tosh deserves more respect och recognition They all are great
Tomacco121 2 years ago
my bad man i wasnt thinkin when i said that...it just bugs me so bad when people talk crap ove the internet...and i do agree with you he does deserve more respect, everyone has bob marley on song that peter tosh wrote and sang
whynotfish 2 years ago 2
Thank you man, i totally agree.
TheKMK09 2 years ago
This is peter tosh but tis a good song.
lilpuppet1992 2 years ago 4
belive me i love you...
lucillau 2 years ago
we arabs aks almighty ALAAH evryday 2 stop the train cuz no one love us ,, we all gone reach zion & only HIM well tell ya'll that we loved ya'll ,, big ups 2 my RAS ppl & capleton z da new massinger
hainyluv 3 years ago
stuart buchanan, of beaty gardens, corby, gets bummed to this song nightly, also see YMCA
Rossmiles1 3 years ago
classic
MORCHEEBA77 3 years ago
stop that train! I'm leavin'!!
tomekgozdek 3 years ago 3
love it
Treadsoftly14 3 years ago
we should really love each other
Kackboon80 3 years ago
lively up yourself
federicotak 3 years ago
stop the fighting, one love.
frittheman 3 years ago 2
de best
hosselpiraat 3 years ago
It's ashame peole forget it was Bob Marley and the Waliers, not just Bob Marley. I mean this song's listed as bob marley stop that train but Bob didn't even sing this song, it's Peter Tosh. I think Bob's doing some backing vocals though. Real good song though.
youarenowreadingthis 3 years ago 27
actually it was just the wailers;) but yea a bautiful song who peter tosh is singing but marley gets all credit :(
merkurius45 3 years ago
thats funny, i thought it sounded like peter singing. peace
Treadsoftly14 2 years ago
@youarenowreadingthis your right, there was some legal issues with tosh and the wailers after the death of marley.
dussie08 1 year ago
i cudn't give 2 f**ks what cds uve got at the end of the day a legend has spoken and this is not a reason to size up ur collections to one another, its a reason to respect the mans lyrics and comment on that. Sort urselfs out.
fags
jakymcpot 3 years ago
Ya i gotta agree, who gives a shit which cd's you all got, just enjoy the blippin song
AlpinKirkonen 3 years ago
my favorite version...found it on a dual album set compiled and distributed by St. Clair Entertainment Group inc...:: [ely]
Elyenthia 3 years ago
its also on cosmopolitan records 3 disc set
swffmopshots 3 years ago
I think I have it in the sun is shining cd. Might not be the original Sun is Shining but it has 22 tracks and All in One is number two. 8)
dizzydolse 3 years ago
what do you mean?
Rastavibe13 3 years ago
I think there are two or more Marley cd's with the name "Sun is Shining" and the one I have might be harder to find. There are 22 tracks on it and this version of "Stop that Train" is on it. I was trying to help mattwaad find a cd that had this version.
dizzydolse 3 years ago
bob marley is god.
23breezyy 11 months ago
@23breezyy this isnt even bob marley XD its peter tosh and no he isnt a god hes an angel.
punkgabe 10 months ago
@Rastavibe13 probly trippin
cerpus 8 months ago
what cd is this version of this song on? cuz its much better than the other versions
mattwaad 3 years ago
i have this version on somthin called trojan records collection. 2 disc set. this song is insanaely good!
ninjamaican 3 years ago
woooohoooo!!!
dizzydolse 4 years ago