Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (111)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Nice job!

  • And the VOX! And I thought I was the gearslut. :)

  • I like that Ricky behind the Les Paul!

  • Geez.....this is AMAZING. Very, very good. I'm gonna go as far to say that it's perfect.

  • Johnny Marr actually used a Les Paul for most of his live shows with the Smiths.

    Rickenbacker 330 was only used to play in the early gigs before the release of Meat is Murder.

    This Charming Man wasn't even recorded with a ric, it was a Telecaster

  • thats a great job on the riffs but i want to improvise

  • Very nice cover m8

  • best cover version of this on here by far 10 out of 10!

  • WOOOOW! you're brilliant! :O

  • is that standard tuning.??

  • Marr tuned his it to match Morrissey in F# you nailed it.

  • awaesome tht man got it off to a tee :)

  • nice tone ... awesome performance :) did you changed your tuning a bit to fit with the original studio song ?? 

  • lucky bastard. with your rickys and your les paul customs and your fender deluxe reverbs! This is a nice tone though!

  • nicely done. To the guy asking how you stop the notes from ringing, finger muting is how Johnny Marr and this guy do it, but if you find that tricky, play it as if you're playing the individual notes in a more lead guitar way if that makes sense. (not holding a shape basically.) Works for me.

  • you rich cunt! Nice cover though pal (:

  • wy the gibson and not the rickenbacker :S

  • Immense mate. Well played.

  • Quite possibly one of the best guitar riffs ever written.

  • Really nice work....Johnny is a wizard of a guitar player...

  • oh dude, you have to write down the tabs! i think you got it perfectly! i figured out many songs of johnny, but never managed to do this one..

    by the way, that's not standard tuning, isn't it?

  • 2 words for you: woo- oow

  • nice vox & ric in the back... nice riffin' dude.

  • I think this is exactly how marr plays it, seriously good cover!

  • Great cover!!! I know how to play this song too, but it just sounds all wrong when I play it. Do I have to tune my guitar down or something?

  • This is awesome. Great to hear someone doing it justice.

  • brilliant

  • why the hell would you play the les paul when there is a rickenbacker right behind you?

  • @vansrok1 that is xactly what i was thinking

  • okay i looked up F# tuning. i haven't tried it but this is what i found: F# tuning is F♯-A♯-C♯-F♯-C♯-F♯. and i have no idea how you learn to play this w/o playing by ear going from standard tuning to F#. maybe you have to watch this video 1 million times oh well. anyway thanks nicknoh for explaining about F# like Johnny Marr.

  • don't understand how you are doing this without a capo but it sounds the same

  • @sabaqat ever heard of tuning up? It's just 2 frets - the strings ain't gonna snap :)

  • my fav guitar, on my fav riff, <3

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • foda!

  • Vaya material que tienes, Gibson, Rickenbacker, Vox y lo que no se ve y ademas tocas bien. Bonito cover.

  • What effects do you use?

  • Is it difficult to play? It's the same repeating melody, and I guess it won't be hard to remember.

  • Nice job, the best tone/playing I've seen on youtube of this song.

  • Nice playing of a great song.

    I've got the same LP custom black beauty, except mine has the tremolo. I bought mine in the early 80s, & if you love yours anywhere near as much as I love mine, then you're a happy guy too.

  • how much u buy your guitar for?

  • awesome! This riff is a real workout man....it just keeps going!

  • Why didn't you use the rickenbacker? its like exactly the same as johnny marr's!

  • @flowerpower168 marr actualy use a black les paulon recording

  • that was beautiful! im going to learn to play that song one day !

  • nice Les Paul !

  • I have a copy of this guitar with gibson magnets. It is great. I am eating my nails looking the ORIGINAL!

  • Wyy not play it with your ric? lol

  • Amazing!

  • i didnt know jonny marr had a youtube page

  • Recorded on a Tele but in the video he played a Ric. I think that Ric behind out would cop the sound a lot better than a Les Paul but nice playing regardless.

  • Dude u got the tab 4 this?

  • no i don't, i just figured it out by ear.

  • @Stevebarrettfilm It's really easy to play, just listen to the song carefully, try to catch the first note and you'll get it right through.

  • very well done.  Marr was amazing

  • little fast in places but good!

  • i dont think it should have been played on he ric :) they are lovely guitars but it sounds brilliant on the les paul + marr himself used a les paul a couple of times

    brilliant mate

  • The song was written on a Ric...

  • yea but thats not to say that it wouldn't sound good on any other guitars is it?

  • Actually, it was written on a Tele with a shitload of effects.

  • Think it was wrote on a Gibson ES actually man.

    Marr gave it Noel Gallagher...what an insanely ledg guitar that would be to own.

  • Timing is slightly off in places, accurate playing though! Nice!

  • Should have used the Ric !!

    It breaks my heart to see it just sat there xD

    Great playing.

  • Superb!

  • Good work. Most accurate version I have heard on YouTube. Most aren't using the open E when they play this song

  • Congrats !

  • Nice playin' there Xp

  • Very nice! Thanks for sharing!

  • I love that you're playing Johnny Marr on a Les Paul even though you have the Rickenbacker right behind you. Sounds good. (and Johnny did play Les Pauls sometimes, too)

  • good point!

  • @krettere The main line of this song was actually recorded with a '54 Telecaster, not a Rick.

  • @krettere wasn't it actually the ES he played? like on How Soon Is Now?

  • Great cover!

    I'm sorry to ask you this, but I've played guitar for a few years now and I don't use a guitar pick, just my fingers.

    I'm learning this song, but I was wondering, how do you stop the sound of each string after playing it with a guitar pick?

  • you have to palm mute it, or in this case.. finger mute it.

  • Each one right? Yeah, they've told me that, but it's kind of hard, it's like learning to play guitar all over again.

    I should try that.

    Thank you :)

  • 68 but with different volume and tone knobs?

  • Good show.....!

    Marr Mastered!

  • anybody who needs the track playing is bobbins

  • im guna go out on a limb and assume that youre not a manc so stop actin like one

  • tut neither were the smiths you fucking nonse

    and even if you class them as manc, that doesnt mean somebody from anywhere but manchester/salford cant like them or try to emulate them in any way

  • i think he was objecting to the use of the word 'bobbins'

  • hmmmmmm

    1 yes they were

    2 its "nonce" you thick twat!

    3 if you're not a manc don't act like one,

    theres nothing more pathetic than someone trying to imitate. apart from maybe the tit who tries to justify it for his own reassurance.

  • Awesome cover awesome song!!

    thE sMItHS fORever!!

  • nice dude.

  • Interesting that you didn't use a cappo. Great cover tho :)

  • Thanks, I didn't use the capo because the guitar is a bit more freed up w/out it and that's just how J.Marr played, so i figured he's onto something if he's tuned up to F#. It's easier that's for sure.

  • i would have used the rickenbacker.

    bang on tho fair play

  • I have to admit mate..that was a fucking good effort. The feeling of mastering a Marr riff is like no other.

  • fucking hell thats amazing.....marr is a fucking genius

  • a true smiths purist, no jam improv crap

  • This is EASILY the most accurate playing of this tune on YouTube outside of The Smiths vids. Absolutely spot on.

  • Seconded, absolutely superb!

  • Sounds nice on the Les Paul. It's a welcome change from hearing it on the Rickenbacker all the time. Not to say that the Rickenbacker is bad, but I've never heard it on any other type of guitar. And this one sounds pretty good.

  • Should have used the Ricky...lol

    nice work tho.

  • I like it :D

    For some reason i always have trouble getting to grips with any of Marr's guitar parts..

    I've always found this song a pain because i don't like to use capos or alternate tunings..

    I have no problem with things like Zeppelin or Hendrix though, i guess it's just a different approach & i should put more time & effort into it..

    Nice playing anyways! :D

  • lol just read the top nevermind

  • Comment removed

  • Les Paul

    lol

  • fucking amazing guitar..

  • What tuning are you in?, you seem to be playing two frets lower than you should be, but it sounds in the right key.

  • tuning is in F#. instead of E,A,D,G,B,E it's F#,B,E,A,C#,F#. Just make sure you're guitar neck can handle the tuning. Thin neck guitars tend to bow back. So use one w/ a hefty neck.

  • im gutted mate you have removed heaven knows vid whats the deal your is the best cover on ere of that track wack it back if you would not mind nice axe by the way

  • spot on! brilliant! Nice Rickenbacker aswell! Good reason not to use it aswell!

  • that's super!

  • Great job, I'm jealous. Is it me, or does the tempo speed up near the end?

  • I'm not sure, I just used one of their live performances.. so it is possible that they may have sped it up at the end.

  • I saw The smiths loads live in the 80's, if you close your eyes and listen to this it does sound remarkably like Marr live - beautiful.

  • I sometimes do play on the Rick, but i can't get that ringing on the bottom f# string as well as the les paul. Johnny uses various Gibson Les Pauls early and later on in the SMiths. Personally i'm just using the les paul because to get a clean sound out of it is somewhat unique when it's usually seen as a heavy metal or rock guitar w/ heavy distortion.

  • this is good but you should be playing it on the rickenbacker

  • Marr actually said it was recorded on a telecaster.

  • i know but i don't see a telecaster in the background

  • Marr used to play it live on his Les Paul Custom.

  • Great video.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more