The funny thing about these comments, is that Scofield is on stage, playing with Herbie Hancock, and you guys are sitting at a computer making fun? haha, i think he gets the last laugh.
With Herbie in the band why would you need " someone who phrases like a great keyboard.."? By the way he, can phrase like a horn indeed...Also Sco did record w/ Joe Henderson on 'So Near So Far ' (dig it), so If he was just another 'guitar-phrasing-guitarist' I don't think joe (or Miles for that matter) would've ever hired him. peace
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Sco is a great guitar player, but stepping into the ring with Herbie and Brecker is a suicide mission for any guitar player. Maybe Gambale or Holdsworth would have a chance...
That's the problem...he phrases like a guitar player. That musical situation requires someone who can phrase like a great keyboard, alto, or tenor player. There's a spot at 3:08 rises to the challenge...but not for long. Get yourself some Joe Henderson, Joe Farrell, Freddie Hubbard and Woody Shaw.
i listen to all of these guys, and what i meant with scofield is that at least he has a tone and personality in his playing . . . and actually his phrasing is unique - it's doesn't even sound like a guitar but more like a tenor. he beats holdsworth by miles!!! freddie and woody are some great master phrasers - i put SCO right up there with them.
look, i'm sorry to retaliate once again, but get the album John Scofield - That's What I Say: Plays The Music Of Ray Charles.
forget him phrasing like a guitarist or a saxophonist. he's a singer. his tone and phraseology is just mind-blowing - something neither holdsworth nor gambale posses.
I can't think of anyone other than Sco fitting this group. It's a Jazz take on contemporary tunes, Scofield is one of the few guitarists who clearly plays with the history of both Jazz and Contemporary Guitar in his music. Imagine substituting Metheny or Holdsworth or even Rosenwinkel and it would sound out of place or too dominant. Metheny probably isn't groovy enough, Kurt plays more like a pianist. And the fusion guys just don't swing, which is fine, but isn't what this group was about.
@invisiblekid14 Well put! I have equal respect for Holdsworth in his own right - very much the Coltrane of the guitar. Such a humble fellow as well. Not a fan of Gambale, watching Sco play makes you realise how much Frank is lacking! Saw him live last weekend for the second time and was really disappointed. Brainless "shred".
gambale can't even play swing or bop, let alone this specialised genre of contemporary jazz
holdsworth would die in this situation. his articulation and tone are totally unsuited to this. he's an 80's, outdated, metal guitarist.
scofield's articulation is so individual, modern and his melodic awareness is light years ahead of both of them put together. gambale is less than a schoolboy next to sco... and sco's harmonic awareness is undoubtedly ahead of brecker... eg the dissonance at 3:50
I'm the biggest Sco fan in the known universe , but although this is brilliant individual playing, as a group it ain't happenin' ...
Herbie ain't layin' down the right harmonic stuff for Sco , and John's goin' off on his own like it was Goldings or somebody more familiar comping ...
Holland is fine .. but you can't have two jazz legends like Sco & Herbie at odds harmonically & still get true synnergy and synchronicity.
No biggie. Jazz all-star congregations frequently miss the mark.
Who are the Metheny people? I have seen him over the last 20 years. He may have played with a few of these people with some all-star groups, but they are not Mmetheny people. And what instrument are you a world class player on that you can say this band is a failure?
You are misunderstanding my point. First, I said they are Metheny *and* Hancock people. Second, I indicated that Scofield as well as all the others are great musicians. There simply was no chemistry.
This group was a failure. An all star band for which Scofield was invited but he really had no place in it; it was all Hancock and Metheny people. A commercial endeavour resulting in a boring concert by some of the greatest musicians of the time.
None of these other people in the band are "Metheny people." I don't know where you get your info. And while you may not like Scofield he can play with any of these people anytime.
None of these other people in the band are "Metheny people." I don't know where you get your info. And while you may not like Scofield he can play with any of these people anytime.
Scofield COOOL jeah
UncleFester77 4 weeks ago
Comment removed
toomanypup 1 month ago
@2:27 Does the drummer use a Koss Porta Pro headset?! xD
LiberoMan 8 months ago
Great sound! Got to crank it a little on my speakers.
jrogers71 11 months ago
What a F great line up! (it goes without saying the carpets are beautiful too)
flatnine 1 year ago
John played his ass off on this record and is a super nice cat too. He was a joy to work with on The New Standard- Guy Eckstine
IconiqueRecordings 1 year ago
cant hear this.volume too low.
bradshawvincent 1 year ago
recorden de voloome too low. not se pergetralkop the moozik karaho!
boazmoss 1 year ago
This concert made my cock throb uncontrollably.
AnonymousWhitePerson 1 year ago 4
scofield, brecker, dehjonette, hancock, holland, my god, i wish a wuz there
dansaghin1 2 years ago 5
i saw scofield in concert once; took me to another planet far far away
boundtogetdown 2 years ago 6
@maxmychopstix i learned what that word means in music theory class
i can think now!
boundtogetdown 2 years ago
numero 1!!!!!!!!!!
steinberger95 2 years ago 3
Fantastic interplay. I'd love to hear the whole tune. The rugs on the stage are a great idea as well. I think I'll try it at my next gig.
limaktba 2 years ago
Masters at work!
thechallengeresponse 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
there is very little correlation between the guitar and the piano. This just sounds like a din to me.
rooflee 2 years ago
Comment removed
TheSouthernrockman 2 years ago
It seems that here on you tube the humor is not welcome....
Bassko 2 years ago
well put coreafan
ElectricCandleLight 2 years ago
Did anyone else have to turn the volume on their speakers up to hear this?
ThrashMetal 2 years ago 47
no, I turned it way down.
PeanutButterGorilla 2 years ago
way, way down
wichipedias 2 years ago
yup
whispsmith 2 years ago
@ThrashMetal I just love the irony of user name 'thrash metal' checking out some herbie n scof!
hankhannaford 1 year ago
@ThrashMetal yeah, audio sux, its supposed to be a music video, so, what is the deal with that crappy audio level?
elvinagrillo 1 year ago
@ThrashMetal Yes....
emgcarra 1 year ago
@ThrashMetal jea here also
tevredenman 1 month ago
The funny thing about these comments, is that Scofield is on stage, playing with Herbie Hancock, and you guys are sitting at a computer making fun? haha, i think he gets the last laugh.
Quikfingers 2 years ago 5
Criticizing Scofield simply shows what a phenomenal ignoramus you are.
funkydrumr51 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I didn't know Robert Duvall sucked so much dick at guitar
lordoftheharvest 2 years ago
pat is at least right there with sco, imho.
rillloudmother 2 years ago
John is the best guitar player now! Who is better?
velibor1234 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
everyone else that owns a guitar
lordoftheharvest 2 years ago
hahahahaha..... best response ever
TLPnega 2 years ago
no one is better than the other, you can hear sylvain luc, pat metheny or nguyen lé ... & taste each flavour of each player i think.
coreafan 2 years ago 2
pat metheny , nguyen lé , scofield ... three great masters !
HeMoVidz 2 years ago
Comment removed
velibor1234 2 years ago
WTF!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Mike Breckers solo?
lidesnowi 2 years ago
With Herbie in the band why would you need " someone who phrases like a great keyboard.."? By the way he, can phrase like a horn indeed...Also Sco did record w/ Joe Henderson on 'So Near So Far ' (dig it), so If he was just another 'guitar-phrasing-guitarist' I don't think joe (or Miles for that matter) would've ever hired him. peace
tiluriso 2 years ago 2
As usual Sco is doing a great job
MagnusLindblOOm 2 years ago 4
the sound sucks
Wando55 2 years ago
yeah a lack of decibels right!!!!!!!!!!!!!
yeahyeahyaha2 2 years ago 5
Wow Don Alias...haven't seen him in a vid for a while. Great conga player...RIP
viper914 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Sco is a great guitar player, but stepping into the ring with Herbie and Brecker is a suicide mission for any guitar player. Maybe Gambale or Holdsworth would have a chance...
Modes9 2 years ago
holdsworth?!?!?!?! that silly motherfucker? you have no class dude.
at least SCO actually sounds and phrases like a guitar player . . . allan holdsworth - hehehe
invisiblekid14 2 years ago
That's the problem...he phrases like a guitar player. That musical situation requires someone who can phrase like a great keyboard, alto, or tenor player. There's a spot at 3:08 rises to the challenge...but not for long. Get yourself some Joe Henderson, Joe Farrell, Freddie Hubbard and Woody Shaw.
Modes9 2 years ago
i listen to all of these guys, and what i meant with scofield is that at least he has a tone and personality in his playing . . . and actually his phrasing is unique - it's doesn't even sound like a guitar but more like a tenor. he beats holdsworth by miles!!! freddie and woody are some great master phrasers - i put SCO right up there with them.
invisiblekid14 2 years ago 3
look, i'm sorry to retaliate once again, but get the album John Scofield - That's What I Say: Plays The Music Of Ray Charles.
forget him phrasing like a guitarist or a saxophonist. he's a singer. his tone and phraseology is just mind-blowing - something neither holdsworth nor gambale posses.
SCO is the master!
invisiblekid14 2 years ago 16
I can't think of anyone other than Sco fitting this group. It's a Jazz take on contemporary tunes, Scofield is one of the few guitarists who clearly plays with the history of both Jazz and Contemporary Guitar in his music. Imagine substituting Metheny or Holdsworth or even Rosenwinkel and it would sound out of place or too dominant. Metheny probably isn't groovy enough, Kurt plays more like a pianist. And the fusion guys just don't swing, which is fine, but isn't what this group was about.
smoothjazzslowjams 2 years ago
@invisiblekid14 you can't be serious. shitty opinion is shitty. have you even listened to holdsworth?
rexasul 1 year ago
@invisiblekid14 Well put! I have equal respect for Holdsworth in his own right - very much the Coltrane of the guitar. Such a humble fellow as well. Not a fan of Gambale, watching Sco play makes you realise how much Frank is lacking! Saw him live last weekend for the second time and was really disappointed. Brainless "shred".
sthoma07 11 months ago
twat
gambale can't even play swing or bop, let alone this specialised genre of contemporary jazz
holdsworth would die in this situation. his articulation and tone are totally unsuited to this. he's an 80's, outdated, metal guitarist.
scofield's articulation is so individual, modern and his melodic awareness is light years ahead of both of them put together. gambale is less than a schoolboy next to sco... and sco's harmonic awareness is undoubtedly ahead of brecker... eg the dissonance at 3:50
mibifinalist 2 years ago
Comment removed
r0b1u3t 2 years ago
actually gambale can play swing or bop pretty well..
qead0828 2 years ago
where/when?
in elektric band? no. he played like a metalhead with chick.
with jaco? no. he played like a metalhead with him.
...
mibifinalist 2 years ago
you're crazy.
SaxMan7776518 2 years ago
These boys can really play. They just don't have off-days!
flashaaahaaah 2 years ago
I'm the biggest Sco fan in the known universe , but although this is brilliant individual playing, as a group it ain't happenin' ...
Herbie ain't layin' down the right harmonic stuff for Sco , and John's goin' off on his own like it was Goldings or somebody more familiar comping ...
Holland is fine .. but you can't have two jazz legends like Sco & Herbie at odds harmonically & still get true synnergy and synchronicity.
No biggie. Jazz all-star congregations frequently miss the mark.
baltostar1 2 years ago
wow Johnny is on fire!!! 5/5stars
earthga 3 years ago
scofield is the best guitar player I' ve ever heard!!!!! wonderful!
cusatogez 3 years ago 4
He probably afford to change his rhythm up a bit
largemoose 3 years ago
Who are the Metheny people? I have seen him over the last 20 years. He may have played with a few of these people with some all-star groups, but they are not Mmetheny people. And what instrument are you a world class player on that you can say this band is a failure?
JohnSllv2 3 years ago
No...You are a failure and a pompous ass!
JohnSllv2 3 years ago
You are misunderstanding my point. First, I said they are Metheny *and* Hancock people. Second, I indicated that Scofield as well as all the others are great musicians. There simply was no chemistry.
c0rn1ts 3 years ago
Wow Johnny is on fire!! I dont know what time he should be living in to be appreciated, but it certainly isn't this one
bobthwart 3 years ago 5
really great
qlm86ooe 3 years ago
This group was a failure. An all star band for which Scofield was invited but he really had no place in it; it was all Hancock and Metheny people. A commercial endeavour resulting in a boring concert by some of the greatest musicians of the time.
c0rn1ts 3 years ago
whatever... fucking great solo from Sco here though
blueskiwi 3 years ago
None of these other people in the band are "Metheny people." I don't know where you get your info. And while you may not like Scofield he can play with any of these people anytime.
JohnSllv2 3 years ago
None of these other people in the band are "Metheny people." I don't know where you get your info. And while you may not like Scofield he can play with any of these people anytime.
JohnSllv2 3 years ago
where can i get the dvd?
William102582 3 years ago
have you a video of dave liebman solo on sax ?
burchos 3 years ago
scofield en foooooooorme !!!
burchos 3 years ago
What do you expect? FRom Herbie and Sco?? I think zhey are really good musicians, perhaps u should listen to some blur-stuff ...
sziethen 3 years ago
that just crippled me
this is some heavy shit
DustinGuitar 3 years ago 3
...now that ain't MMW, so you best take out yer listenin' ears to hang here
raindep 3 years ago
Aw easy now.
ZachRhea 3 years ago
post moreeeeeeeeeee pleaseeeee
gouliwooz 4 years ago 2
thnx for the post!!!!
allstar band!!!
gouliwooz 4 years ago