Air Force v Navy Instant Replay

[MegaSexyCracker]

why are the two top comments the same?

[BMXerDYNOandDK]

COOL

[SupermanBeast27]

Wat kin of retard wuld tink dis is a catch? smh

[MacRaeWarrior]

That was a touchdown. I see bribed officials isn't just a WAC problem...

[Ziggy2344]

@MacRaeWarrior you haven't seen the big ten..

[MrHellobro]

Thats not a touchdown at all. He had no possession of the ball what so ever.

[GODofORCS]

GO NAVY

[superspazz61]

BS thats a TD

[MrPikaPWN]

@superspazz61 hell yeh

[samiojo]

am i the only person to see this? watch from 36 seconds, the ball clearly bounces out of his hands completely. they just cut away too soon every time before.

[555mrbucky]

Go Navy!!!!!

[nikka6666]

I think its a good call..

[hostile97]

Thanks spanky and DJO....i was a bout to say....lol

[warcraft72]

It should have been a touchdown the defensive never touched him when he went down so the guy that caught was necessarily never down

[Tdogstar]

@warcraft72 this is colege not NFl....

[xXxPJDxXx]

Kace842 you actually dont need to keep control all the way through you have to keep control when you enter the endzone and he did

[HeyKevSan]

I would say that it was a touchdown but I wonder what happened after that play.

[garra7888]

OOOOUUUUTTTTT of control

4th and Goal

[michael13374]

IT WAS IN -_________________-

[phil15892]

it wasnt

[Did7You7See7That]

who cares they wont go to the BCS

haha sorry im an ass

[shieldsrbeastly]

no it wasnt a touchdown . it came out of his hand .

[harman443]

he had control of the ball when he touched then the ball bounced off the ground if you watch carfully

[lauzer12]

negative spanky.... the catch that oakland had pulled on MNF was the same deal you have to have possession throughout the act of catching the ball....they over turned 3 during preseason that way too

[spanky1113]

After listening to the rule a couple times, it's been clarified that if in the act of catching the ball, the receiver is going to the ground, they must maintain possession throughout the catch, including after hitting the ground. So yes, my previous statement was wrong to an extent.

[216CLEVELANDBOI]

that was not a touchdown dammit

[spanky1113]

In college, you have to have control all the way through the catch, including after hitting the gound. In the NFL, you just have to break the plane.

[skooptwo]

And that's why College football is so much better.

[Ryabeisaacub]

I think he had possesion of the ball, so when he dropped it it was just a fumble. Therefore when he picked the ball up in the endzone I think it should have been a touchdown.

[therealradio2007]

I may be a Navy fan, but that was a touchdown. The reciever had control of the ball and broke the plane of the goal line before going down. Tell the refs to quit smoking crack.

[yaman258]

Have to have control of the ball after contacting the ground.. Incomplete pass

[DJOdefnsiveend90]

in college u have to have control all through the catch only in nfl do u only need to break the plane

[somethinrather]

you need control in the pros to

[imaaznnpill0w]

what the hell really? doesnt make sense to me i mean.. why would they make it easier in the nfl? -_-

[kace842]

no it happened in the Oakland game too.. You have to keep control all the way through the catch

[iLeBr0n]

that is not a touchdown.whatr you people blind?

[FosterFuel]

okay for all of you poeple who are saying this shouldve been a td, it makes up ofthe the other play by eron riley that was confirmed

[samechazwres9311]

ball came out of his hands ppl

[flargicaldemon]

his knee landed in the endzone. i killed my wife because of that call. I LOVE Air FORCE!

[IrishLd4]

TD. easy as that

[simoneventuri]

he didn't got the ball so the play reversed is right.. No possession. I made a catch like that during the season and I've put the knee down before the ball leave my hands just like that one and they called incomplete pass. It was a wonderful 30-yards pass! :(

[HYBRIDhater]

that was a touchdown and a horrible call by the official

[MLGrunescape]

he lost possession of the ball and it was just like sitting there

[TheVangbal]

touchdown, bad call

[justinlundgrenapollo]

thats a bad call by the ref he had it the whole time it never touched the griund

[Rickyj5]

i wanna say he did but he didnt there was no sign of possesion

[brycerone]

he had possesion and the ball never touched the ground so thats a touchdown

[Fatalxx1]

Touchdown.

[soccerbaseballwiz]

bad call ref, his nees were still up and he fumbled it then recovered it

[72BigTrain]

great kall...

the ball was bobbling around and fell out of his hands..

great kall

[Wittyswine]

call......c-a-l-l.....C.....no­t k

[vikdude366]

like the dude said he held against his body. he passed the goal line and his knees touched afterwards

[Haidoor1987]

Touchdown, he had crossed the goal line, scored and dropped it.

[ParkourBlog]

look at it, he never had it.

Only a silly fullback could think a thing like this :P

[Haidoor1987]

Typical defensive player, trying to ruin the glory of the offence. This is why no one likes Defence, especially not DB's. :P

[Haidoor1987]

Sorry. I'm English. Defence. We invented the language.

[jaredalexross]

Touche, good sir. And England rocks, I'll give you that.

[Monkeymshr20]

touchdown

[48linebacker48]

he never had possesion. no td

[legogun13]

it was bad pass

[nezol69]

he droped it when he fell

[WandahlSolders]

No touchdown on that play. Sorry guys. XD

[DhWareham]

he droped the ball no TD on that one

[Panther2696]

touchdowbn

[scifihunnybunny]

Touchdown

[faithonmine]

fuck noo..that aint no touchdown

[Commando678]

He had no control.

[bulldogs1msu]

he never had control. The ball spins slightly as he is turning and then it comes loose when he hits the ground. Incomplete pass. Navy wins again

[BackToPass]

either way they both suck

[gamer4life1019]

that was a touchdown

[Broncoluva]

Freaking Navy has to cheat again... LETS GO AIR FORCE!!!

[InsanePlaid]

funny video lets chat

great vid 2f

[kjsoldier]

clearly a touchdown

[BostonmAn08]

that was totally a touchdown!!!!

[amyleemarryme]

the ground can't cause a fumble

it can cause an incompletion

however, he caught the ball, and turned with it, which is considered a football move

it should have been ruled complete...

TOUCHDOWN

[ffbfny]

no touchdown... go navy!

[PrUnEJuIcEtHeThIrD]

I think he dropped it when he hit the ground.