the playback of the cd was playing with her vocals and she just sang over it...some parts not outloud but some parts especially in heartbreaker/if you should ever be lonely she sang live ontop of the track...
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Of course it's lipped. The entire night featured playback, over which some of it she sang live. It's not like she tried hard to hide the fact, and when she actually did sing live she's singing several keys lower than the original recordings. It's VERY easy to pick out which parts are "old" Mariah, and which are current.
She didn't lipped the whole thing because some of it you can tell she sang live. She was just singing with the track not that it was playback. Janet Jackson did it onetime on a foreign show singing with the track. I do it sometimes when I sing.
People need to stupid being so damn ignorant to the facts. It was reported BEFORE she went on stage that she would be singing live AND lip-syncing to some songs. You can tell Mariah is lip-syncing in this performance because of THE WAY she performs. Her face is calm and relaxed, she distracted by the items she's throwing in the audience, the way she is holding her mic, and her body movements.
she looks good.. but it sounds like she is lip syncing... that really doesnt sound live at all... she said in on of her interview that with TIOM album she went back to her roots as far as singing... but honestly her voice on the TIOM album was not even half as good as her first 4 albums when she started...
but even with her voice not being as good as before... its still amazing...
are you tone deaf? lol obviously she's lipped songs before but i swear to god why does everyone call out mariah for lip syncing shit. she's not even on the same fucking tempo or key as the original. go take some music classes plz
I have seen performances of mariah..were she actually sings live..and it NEVER sounds like her original recording... YOU can't get mad at people for noticing fakeness... when mariah is really singing... her face has deep expressions on it and she has a certain movement. but during this performance you could see her face. and even body did not show that she was actually singing. You know when mariah is singing those high notes it looks like she is in pain
Apparently she faked most of the show.. this song can be found in the Remix album from Columbia Rec, she no longer has that deepness in her voice... sorry guys ain't nothing but the truth.
and btw check the Its Like That/Heartbreaker remix from that same day...there she sing some parts Totaly live! Her voice is good.... but totaly diferent from dreamlover you see here....why? she has now the ability to even change her voice back to 93 and forth to 2005-07 again?? you can compare them for yourself!! ROFL...
LOL Its not the same as the cd-version or Album...becuase it was live back then 1993-1994!!
An the raw of her voice its not because its live or/and non-edited to sound like cd but because its from a camera with an average quality..DAH! Im sure if i was there should be all magic...and i still can feel some of it...but that dosnt mean that it is LIVE!! Denial is the word for all of you that cannot see or Hear it!
Could not take off work to see this...arrrggggh! I hope she'll be back to London soon to do smthng similar. I have always loved her remixes, especially the David Morales ones, though they might have become somewhat formularic of late. Best one is Dreamlover, love Shep Pettibone's Someday, Dave Morales' "Honey", Full Intention's "Through The Rain" and Quale's "Don't Forget About Us"...I am still waiting for a Frankie Knuckles Remix!!
you guys are so funny. discussing whether is playback or not. well, it is playback. Are you deaf? its the same voice from 1993...there are some tiny parts that she is doing live but only mombling sounds.-
why th hell does this always come up...why wuld mariah lip, she has a voice why wuldnt she use it, in every fucking mariah perfomrance video this lipped shit always comes up, she always sings live!
I know haters always start trying to tear down her performances because they are amazing. Her vocals are amazing and they can not fathom that she can acutally sing. They are use to other singers not being able to deliver live..But Mz MIMI can SING and they are stupified by it, so they have to hate.
oh my gosh!! valleybuddy you're right!! Mariah carey is one of the best!! and since 1990, she has an amazing voice!! and haters blabla can say what they want 'cause Everybody knows that MC ain't fake!! She sings in real !! Oh please haters don't be so jealous it ain't good !!!
hey fren,Mariah did Fantastic Live Vocal Performances all these years.Since 1998 she Lipped many Live TV shows Or Charities in many European cities as well USA.However Mariah still till today does Fantastica Live Unique RnB Vocal singing.
I was there too, I work in disneyland paris. Yes she performed all the songs LIVE and over the tracks, under the rain, and she was absolutely fantastic! A great moment!
thats not live..not even 1% .....this voice is Mariah's Voice of 1993-94. i remember a "live" with the exact same vocals lol..but hey it was back to 94 :P
This was Mariah showing her appreciation to her gay fanbase for the loyalty over the years, and she was amazing !! She performed in the freakin' rain...and the performance was one climax after the other...it couldn't have been better...and if you would have been there you could have felt the magic.. She was sweet and funny
It is live. This sounds similar to the remix but it is not the same cuz she sang the original in a slightly higher key. There are also parts when she stops singing and you can hear her voice on a very quiet backtrack, proving that she sang over a track and not lipped.
Of course you can have the same vocals oh yeah!! it's her singing lol same voice, same person!! and baby listen hardly before and this one!!! but it doesn't matter what you think!! cause baby you weren't there!! in the crowd!!!
so sad u sodade21,this video of Mariah's vocal is Definitely Live not lipped,unless there is background prerecorded harmony BUT that doesnt mean Mariah Lipped on this song.Check yourself.
Who cares, it was just an amazing experience, and Mariah was just incredible!!! The atmosphere was electric in Paris when she was performing, one of the most magic moments in my life!! Thanks Mariah...the gay audience loves you!!!!
She adlibbed over the original, but she sounded amazing !! It was struly the best show I've seen in my life...she delivered !! And people who might say she's a diva...well she is, but in an truly fabulous way...she performed in the freakin' rain, and not just a bit of rain, it was pouring when she started performing but she came on stage and with amazing humour she started this amazing spectacle
you're wrong!!! because you know I was there in the crowd!! and I saw her, with all full songs!! and Baby I tell U it ain't playback!!! Get a grip!! she was performing in the rain!! and hello!!!I was there, it was so amazing!! Oh my!!!you cannot critisize her with a video!!lol a little bit of the song LOL and baby Everybody knows that Mariah is the one of the most singer who sings in live!!! LOL
definitely lipped. she might be singing some part but most of it is not live for sure. i can see her pulling away from the mic and the voice doesn't even change. i know she's in the process of recording her album so she probably wanted to rest her voice.
Sorry this isn't live. If you listen hard enough, you can kind of hear her singing along to the track. People who went said she sang over the backing track for It's Like That, My All, Heartbreaker/If You Should Ever Be Lonely Remix and Make It Happen for the most part and Fantasy, Dreamlover and We Belong Together were mostly the backing track but she adlibbed a lot and people said it was great.
Completely lipped. Anyone who knows Mariah's REAL live performances knows that (in her own words) she likes to "change things up." Draw your own conclusions.
It's lipped, but that's okay. We know it's her voice. Sometimes the producers of theses events want it lipped, and sometimes the artist wants to save their voice, or doesn't have good voice that day...she's human.
I'm an audiophile, remix collector, producer/editor, and I know this remix like the back of my hand: the way the vocals sound are idential to the Def Club Mix from 1993. Draw your own conclusions.
yes fantastic show
PHIL93330 2 years ago
:08-:29 sounds like she did from daydream era
XforeverlongingX 3 years ago
the playback of the cd was playing with her vocals and she just sang over it...some parts not outloud but some parts especially in heartbreaker/if you should ever be lonely she sang live ontop of the track...
1dreamlover1 4 years ago
i like that she though things out in the audience. fun! to watch.
R1089 4 years ago
french dancer!!!!
deep95 4 years ago 6
heyyyyy!!!!
where the end of this video im the french on the left mariah and she touch me on this part!!!!!!
deep95 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Of course it's lipped. The entire night featured playback, over which some of it she sang live. It's not like she tried hard to hide the fact, and when she actually did sing live she's singing several keys lower than the original recordings. It's VERY easy to pick out which parts are "old" Mariah, and which are current.
jaquen1977 4 years ago
She didn't lipped the whole thing because some of it you can tell she sang live. She was just singing with the track not that it was playback. Janet Jackson did it onetime on a foreign show singing with the track. I do it sometimes when I sing.
trn17 4 years ago
Which is exactly what I said.
jaquen1977 4 years ago
@jaquen1977 you are almsot right but when she was singing along it was on key
iiAmitx3 4 months ago in playlist More videos from PHIL93330
it s not a playback !
i was there !
roseandblack70 4 years ago 4
um sorry but this is live.
EmileeIsRad 4 years ago 2
it's not a live, it's a playback, sur a 100% !!!
levoyage2chihiro 4 years ago
this is definitley live like all of her performances! she's incredible!!
mcforeva 4 years ago
quand c'était ???
Meligirafe 4 years ago
This is NO PLAYBACK... is it live!!!
KaspyMat 4 years ago
People need to stupid being so damn ignorant to the facts. It was reported BEFORE she went on stage that she would be singing live AND lip-syncing to some songs. You can tell Mariah is lip-syncing in this performance because of THE WAY she performs. Her face is calm and relaxed, she distracted by the items she's throwing in the audience, the way she is holding her mic, and her body movements.
USDACertified 4 years ago
she looks good.. but it sounds like she is lip syncing... that really doesnt sound live at all... she said in on of her interview that with TIOM album she went back to her roots as far as singing... but honestly her voice on the TIOM album was not even half as good as her first 4 albums when she started...
but even with her voice not being as good as before... its still amazing...
totalalisa 4 years ago
are you tone deaf? lol obviously she's lipped songs before but i swear to god why does everyone call out mariah for lip syncing shit. she's not even on the same fucking tempo or key as the original. go take some music classes plz
sunb1ind 4 years ago
I have seen performances of mariah..were she actually sings live..and it NEVER sounds like her original recording... YOU can't get mad at people for noticing fakeness... when mariah is really singing... her face has deep expressions on it and she has a certain movement. but during this performance you could see her face. and even body did not show that she was actually singing. You know when mariah is singing those high notes it looks like she is in pain
totalalisa 4 years ago
Apparently she faked most of the show.. this song can be found in the Remix album from Columbia Rec, she no longer has that deepness in her voice... sorry guys ain't nothing but the truth.
dmoraks 4 years ago
do it baby girl!!!! luv the performance!!! the guys are cuties also.. thanks phil for the uploads, much luv to ya lamb!
sunflowers77 4 years ago
and btw check the Its Like That/Heartbreaker remix from that same day...there she sing some parts Totaly live! Her voice is good.... but totaly diferent from dreamlover you see here....why? she has now the ability to even change her voice back to 93 and forth to 2005-07 again?? you can compare them for yourself!! ROFL...
!!!!!!!!!!!!W-A-K-E U-P !!!!!!!!!!!!
sodade21 4 years ago
LOL Its not the same as the cd-version or Album...becuase it was live back then 1993-1994!!
An the raw of her voice its not because its live or/and non-edited to sound like cd but because its from a camera with an average quality..DAH! Im sure if i was there should be all magic...and i still can feel some of it...but that dosnt mean that it is LIVE!! Denial is the word for all of you that cannot see or Hear it!
sodade21 4 years ago
she is a cheap whore
jlol 4 years ago
hey now jlol don't come here talking trash now she hasn't done nothing to you.
trn17 4 years ago
i!ts clearly live lol...:s
mariahcarey1625 4 years ago
no dahling
nicevidbro 4 years ago
Mariah Carey is the suck... Fake.
Feanar0 4 years ago
You too Feanar0 don't come here talking trash now she hasn't done anything to you she is a great vocalist.
trn17 4 years ago
great vocalist but she's still fake.
Feanar0 4 years ago
free game online
jahjahtown.miniville*fr
( enlever *)
jjahjah 4 years ago
Could not take off work to see this...arrrggggh! I hope she'll be back to London soon to do smthng similar. I have always loved her remixes, especially the David Morales ones, though they might have become somewhat formularic of late. Best one is Dreamlover, love Shep Pettibone's Someday, Dave Morales' "Honey", Full Intention's "Through The Rain" and Quale's "Don't Forget About Us"...I am still waiting for a Frankie Knuckles Remix!!
originaldeftom 4 years ago
i love so much mimi
relacionador 4 years ago
It's live ! Just listen !
nt1 4 years ago
you guys are so funny. discussing whether is playback or not. well, it is playback. Are you deaf? its the same voice from 1993...there are some tiny parts that she is doing live but only mombling sounds.-
nicevidbro 4 years ago
why th hell does this always come up...why wuld mariah lip, she has a voice why wuldnt she use it, in every fucking mariah perfomrance video this lipped shit always comes up, she always sings live!
naddyluvsmariah 4 years ago
I know haters always start trying to tear down her performances because they are amazing. Her vocals are amazing and they can not fathom that she can acutally sing. They are use to other singers not being able to deliver live..But Mz MIMI can SING and they are stupified by it, so they have to hate.
valleybuddy 4 years ago
oh my gosh!! valleybuddy you're right!! Mariah carey is one of the best!! and since 1990, she has an amazing voice!! and haters blabla can say what they want 'cause Everybody knows that MC ain't fake!! She sings in real !! Oh please haters don't be so jealous it ain't good !!!
moreno2210 4 years ago
hey fren,Mariah did Fantastic Live Vocal Performances all these years.Since 1998 she Lipped many Live TV shows Or Charities in many European cities as well USA.However Mariah still till today does Fantastica Live Unique RnB Vocal singing.
transhurray 4 years ago
I was there too, I work in disneyland paris. Yes she performed all the songs LIVE and over the tracks, under the rain, and she was absolutely fantastic! A great moment!
whoopsinlondon 4 years ago
The diva.
trentnjones 4 years ago
it's a dance mix, Mariah sang OVER the track. That's how you do it.
HoneyGotMeHooked 4 years ago
thats not live..not even 1% .....this voice is Mariah's Voice of 1993-94. i remember a "live" with the exact same vocals lol..but hey it was back to 94 :P
sodade21 4 years ago
This was Mariah showing her appreciation to her gay fanbase for the loyalty over the years, and she was amazing !! She performed in the freakin' rain...and the performance was one climax after the other...it couldn't have been better...and if you would have been there you could have felt the magic.. She was sweet and funny
funkygaybeatz 4 years ago
It is live. This sounds similar to the remix but it is not the same cuz she sang the original in a slightly higher key. There are also parts when she stops singing and you can hear her voice on a very quiet backtrack, proving that she sang over a track and not lipped.
trentnjones 4 years ago
agree this vocal is Totally Live and very RAW.Not CD version or CD sounding material.
Mariah one and Only Unique Female POP Great RnB Vocalist till today,althou since 1998 her vocal changed but sounded more Raw and Naturally good.
transhurray 4 years ago
Of course you can have the same vocals oh yeah!! it's her singing lol same voice, same person!! and baby listen hardly before and this one!!! but it doesn't matter what you think!! cause baby you weren't there!! in the crowd!!!
moreno2210 4 years ago
so sad u sodade21,this video of Mariah's vocal is Definitely Live not lipped,unless there is background prerecorded harmony BUT that doesnt mean Mariah Lipped on this song.Check yourself.
transhurray 4 years ago
hey if anyone has anymore videos of the mariah disney gig please let me know, me and the other dancers would loooove to see them!!! thanks anth
fashionf4wardguy 4 years ago
Who cares, it was just an amazing experience, and Mariah was just incredible!!! The atmosphere was electric in Paris when she was performing, one of the most magic moments in my life!! Thanks Mariah...the gay audience loves you!!!!
funkygaybeatz 4 years ago
It's not playback, stop geeks !
Listen to the album song and the live it's so different!
nt1 4 years ago
OMGGGG! I love her!!!
latinmax 4 years ago
It's live, at about 00:28 when she starts the chorus she doesn't sing and you only hear a quiet backing track. It's live go Mimi!
watehuh 4 years ago
She adlibbed over the original, but she sounded amazing !! It was struly the best show I've seen in my life...she delivered !! And people who might say she's a diva...well she is, but in an truly fabulous way...she performed in the freakin' rain, and not just a bit of rain, it was pouring when she started performing but she came on stage and with amazing humour she started this amazing spectacle
funkygaybeatz 4 years ago
once again...playback
chran19 4 years ago
It's not a playback hello !!! I was there!! and baby you don't know how to recognize playback or live!! LOL anyway...
moreno2210 4 years ago
excuse me, but it's playblack! there is something live, but it's a bit
chran19 4 years ago
you're wrong!!! because you know I was there in the crowd!! and I saw her, with all full songs!! and Baby I tell U it ain't playback!!! Get a grip!! she was performing in the rain!! and hello!!!I was there, it was so amazing!! Oh my!!!you cannot critisize her with a video!!lol a little bit of the song LOL and baby Everybody knows that Mariah is the one of the most singer who sings in live!!! LOL
moreno2210 4 years ago
honey, I love Mariah, and I never critisized her. Only is a opinion of video
chran19 4 years ago
definitely lipped. she might be singing some part but most of it is not live for sure. i can see her pulling away from the mic and the voice doesn't even change. i know she's in the process of recording her album so she probably wanted to rest her voice.
ziyizhangfan 4 years ago
loves it!!!
HTISAM 4 years ago
☆ DreamMariah! ☆
wwwMariahLiveNET 4 years ago
I THINK THAT I S PLAYBACK . IT SOUNDS LIKE THE OROGINAL TRACK .
and she looks great
mdyolanda 4 years ago
i believe its live, our Mimi is almost back!!!
Joyride126 4 years ago
yes and cant wait for her album!!!!
melchewvin 4 years ago
Sorry this isn't live. If you listen hard enough, you can kind of hear her singing along to the track. People who went said she sang over the backing track for It's Like That, My All, Heartbreaker/If You Should Ever Be Lonely Remix and Make It Happen for the most part and Fantasy, Dreamlover and We Belong Together were mostly the backing track but she adlibbed a lot and people said it was great.
slave4supernewty 4 years ago
First, this is amazing! Second, it is live. Third, you haters really should get hobbies. Mariah is immaculate. Deal with it.
rksu747 4 years ago
Completely lipped. Anyone who knows Mariah's REAL live performances knows that (in her own words) she likes to "change things up." Draw your own conclusions.
xjjr 4 years ago
It's lipped, but that's okay. We know it's her voice. Sometimes the producers of theses events want it lipped, and sometimes the artist wants to save their voice, or doesn't have good voice that day...she's human.
Brizzmann 4 years ago
OMG... Mariah sooounds sooooo great!!!! I wish there was more to this video....
LauraLuvsMariah 4 years ago
anyway ,it does not matter,cuz we are her fan,haha
thiseop 4 years ago
It's live,you can compare the part of 1:12~1:13 to ur def club remix
thiseop 4 years ago
Oh yeah? What about parts 0:01~1:11 and 1:14~1:18?
xjjr 4 years ago
very similar
thiseop 4 years ago
I'm an audiophile, remix collector, producer/editor, and I know this remix like the back of my hand: the way the vocals sound are idential to the Def Club Mix from 1993. Draw your own conclusions.
DJMichaelAngelo 4 years ago
omg omg!!! lovin it
visionsofmariah 4 years ago
lipped.... :<
ravenfrak13 4 years ago
it's live
thiseop 4 years ago
Was she singing live? That sounded exactly like the album version of the remix. Oh, Mariah!
UrbanSophisticate1 4 years ago
Thank you so much! I was dying to see these performances, as it's rare to see all the remixes live!
PsychAmanda 4 years ago