He rarely wears shoes on stage. I believe he's putting 'm back on. You can see flashes of white at the end, when he's standing up, and during the interview, he's wearing dark shiny shoes.
And the uploader's proclaimation of "first hand permission" is laughable. I love that Timmy's become so famous that people treat him like a celebrity and revere his words. In most instances, it's the way it should be.
Pfft, some people. Tim doesn't give a shit which material of his goes on the net so long as it doesn't spoil new tours or take his work out of context. He never has. Technically the only people with the rights to publish/upload this footage are those representing the network who aired it, but unless someone else starts making money off it or it's a particularly pedantic network (or someone dobs you in), it really doesn't or won't matter.
@leecjoe Woah! Just because these people have happened to choose to reclaim the word as their own, it doesn't mean the rest of us have a right to its use.
What I'm trying to say is don't call him ginger unless you're ginger yourself.
FWIW, I'll defend JaackMaate/TimMinchinLive on this one. There has been discussion on Tim's forum including reliable evidence that Tim has given permission to this channel to upload (and not others excepting Tim's official channel of course).
@d4m4s74 - OOPS FAIL!! - as far as I understand, this is the only account (other than Tim's own) which is authorised to have the vids. Check out the channel homepage. Anyone else with the vids have stolen them or put them on-line without permission.
It really looks like you stole that video from "prozacbear" and you tried to hide some hard coded text with poor executed annotations. You should at least give some credit!
@tromboneux Actually, I have permission to upload this vide, Prozacbear didn't. He is in fact breaking the law and I do NOT need to credit him. Thanks.
@tromboneux Despite the fact I have spoken to Tim numerous times via email, despite the fact I made the official channel 'partner'. Despite the fact I made the background to both official and unofficial channels?
@tb240904 It's not a question of whether 'TimMinchinLive' has permission to upload this video from Tim Minchin or any representatives, it's a clip from the BBC and he ('Jaackmaate') is allowed to post it, so long as he doesn't "bring the BBC into disrespute".
@TimMinchinLive - Get over yourself. Prozacbear might be violating YourTube's Terms of Service but unless you know in what state/region/province/jurisdiction Prozacbear is living and are familiar with the Copyright laws applicable to that jurisdiction, you have no idea if he/she is 'breaking the law'. Don't talk shit. I DO credit Prozacbear because he/she uploaded first. I don't give a shit if they 'permission' to upload the video. I just care that I got to see it.
@zer0ne83 Regardless of whether they uploaded it first or not, they didn't get permission from the owner, therefore they don't have the rights to use the video. Even if he does have access to the video he didnt CREATE it.
@TheRealBarnez - Agreed 100%. No permission from owner means he didn't have the right to upload the content per YouTube's Term of Service Agreement. My point was that you can't call a breach of YouTube's SA 'breaking the law'. Because that's simply BS. Unless you know the precise terms of the Copyright legislation applicable to the poster in their home country, uploading the video could be anything to a full breach of the local Copyright Act to an act not amenable to any local legislation/law.
@zer0ne83 "I DO credit Prozacbear because he/she uploaded first."
The point that was being made was that he shouldnt be credited seeing as its not his video. The point is seeing as Tim didnt give him permission, being first to upload it doesn't make it his video.
@TheRealBarnez - Tim doesn't own the rights to a network television broadcast just because he's in it you fucking retard. The broadcast, as a Copyright 'original works', is owned by the network that produced it. So neither 'Prozacbear' or 'Tim Minchin Live' needed Tim's permission to upload it. Further, neither of them obtained permission to upload it from the true owner of the footage. 'The point' is that you are both drawing invisible legal/moral lines that don't exist.
@zer0ne83 As Tim performed the piece, it's his intellectual property. As it is, copyright law in its most literal state would say that it belongs to the people who filmed it yes, but that's like saying that all music belongs to the recording studios and not the artists who made them, because the studio filmed the video.
@TheRealBarnez I may be wrong here, but is it not a record label who owns copyright of a musical *recording*, not the studio or artist? The artist is the one who can sue for overly-derivitive (copying) songwriting, but any publication that breaches copyright of a recording is up to a record label (unless independently produced), or, in this instance, the network on which the footage was published.
@TheRealBarnez Yes, but Tim would have to get permission from the BBC, if the BBC is anything like the ABC. He had to do so to put various ABC clips on his DVDs.
@Equihan Mhmm, if the BBC gave Tim joint ownership of the clips then it's fine. If not, meh, this is only a fan channel. Its not like they're making money off it.
Comment removed
RonanaBass 2 days ago
he looks adorable when he hugs the photo awwww
PioneerOnSupercity 2 weeks ago
I miss the eyeliner...
EmmaPocketsize 3 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Minchin has genius and balls. Ross, in some contrast, is bloatedly talentless.
PaleSilverLight 4 weeks ago
that title is misleading.
noreasonforaccount 1 month ago 6
tim minchin is a genius.
QofLife69 2 months ago
3:25 - is he talking his shoes off/on?
LittleMissMiffy 3 months ago
@LittleMissMiffy
He rarely wears shoes on stage. I believe he's putting 'm back on. You can see flashes of white at the end, when he's standing up, and during the interview, he's wearing dark shiny shoes.
ChibiEii 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Its amusing listening to an audience of brain dead morons laugh at this unfunny cunt.
midcitygym 3 months ago
i like how tims voice completely changes when he says wife for the first time
jackoz18 3 months ago 3
I remember watching this on TV, he caught me by surprise when he said "to your wife" and I laughed so loud that all my neighbors definitely heard me
infinitydreamzz 4 months ago 4
Tim was a little far off-he weasaled his way back onto tv a year and a month after this. Damn itv.
TheProtoChimp 5 months ago
Not supposed to be a . Between piano and chords by the way!
simonmayson2513 5 months ago
Hey. Anyone handy with music able to send me the piano. Chords for this song. Really wanna learn it but haven't got a great ear to do that! Cheers
simonmayson2513 5 months ago
its really funny how jonathan its such a moody cu.......man that he gets pissed of with a joke
mcrappergstar 5 months ago
who cares who owns the videos, its youtube, 90% of the videos are bootleg in case you didnt know
dan11009 6 months ago
And the uploader's proclaimation of "first hand permission" is laughable. I love that Timmy's become so famous that people treat him like a celebrity and revere his words. In most instances, it's the way it should be.
Equihan 7 months ago
Pfft, some people. Tim doesn't give a shit which material of his goes on the net so long as it doesn't spoil new tours or take his work out of context. He never has. Technically the only people with the rights to publish/upload this footage are those representing the network who aired it, but unless someone else starts making money off it or it's a particularly pedantic network (or someone dobs you in), it really doesn't or won't matter.
Equihan 7 months ago
in the end is he putting his shoes on? im shocked
marije123456 8 months ago 2
0:46 epic face.
TheRealBarnez 8 months ago
OMG ROBIN WILLIAMS IS THERE! lol woot, you go Tim, id love to meet both of those dudes irl XD
mohomadali 9 months ago
love it haha
TheBlairRobb 9 months ago
sweet love to ya ... wife
RavenHouseProduction 9 months ago
johnathan doesn't look right without his moustache
bentheanimeguy 10 months ago
Actually made me cry with laughter a little bit
omgu8mynewt 11 months ago
"...in case I get hungry makin' sweet love to your wife."
This man has balls of steel.
foxkieran 11 months ago 39
@foxkieran Of diamond.
SteedDeMita 10 months ago
The guy makes a song about how he wants to make some sweet love to the show´s host and still gets few claps from him. That is brilliant.
intsu12 1 year ago
After robin Williams was like awww fuck lol XD
narutofan12234 1 year ago
FUCKING GENIUS XD
MattySP34Ks 1 year ago 2
for a ginger minger ,YOU ROCK MAN dont ever stop your AWESOME tim.
leecjoe 1 year ago
@leecjoe Woah! Just because these people have happened to choose to reclaim the word as their own, it doesn't mean the rest of us have a right to its use.
What I'm trying to say is don't call him ginger unless you're ginger yourself.
123456yum123456 11 months ago 3
@123456yum123456 joe king u p rik
leecjoe 11 months ago
@leecjoe It's a quote from his song.
I take no responsibility for your ignorance.
123456yum123456 11 months ago
@123456yum123456 eww arr fak off you ginger minger
leecjoe 11 months ago
Epic fucking backcombing.
EbonyFaery 1 year ago
i think thats the first time robin williams thought "holy shit, how the hell am i going to follow tha!?"
Raedan23 1 year ago 13
lol@that fake smug on wossy's face XD
DraMattIck 1 year ago
2 people obviously dont want to make sweet love to wossys wife!
lankybutsexy 1 year ago 6
Seems like Jonathan has watched this he's disliked it!
TheRealMuddydisco 1 year ago
dude you label all of your 360p vids as HD.. they are not....
Nolansykinsley 1 year ago 4
Cześć. Chce się to komuś przetłumaczyć na PL? :D
PaniczGeoffrey 1 year ago
got to admit, jane is pretty hot
ZigB95 1 year ago
Who cares about legal stuff? Illegal videos are put on youtube all the time and are kept on for ages before being taken down and put back up again.
Awesome song. I love Tim. <3
camisadokiller666 1 year ago 6
Wats this song actually called? Anyone know?
xlxsarah 1 year ago
@xlxsarah I have seen it also called "Song for Wossy"
wendighoul 1 year ago
@wendighoul thx cos then its easier 2 type into you tube if i know wat its called
xlxsarah 1 year ago
Love the start ...and the rest :D
MorbidlyObeseCat 1 year ago
im sooo glad i watched johnny ross on the night this was on best 15 mins of my life
robbierules81 1 year ago
awesome waistcoat
lordtwigg 1 year ago 2
5 poofs and 2 pianos was better
nhl4471 1 year ago
FWIW, I'll defend JaackMaate/TimMinchinLive on this one. There has been discussion on Tim's forum including reliable evidence that Tim has given permission to this channel to upload (and not others excepting Tim's official channel of course).
TheTwirlgrl 1 year ago
Comment removed
CrankyCrone 1 year ago
get dull after 30 seconds
jesuzizinmybedroom 1 year ago
Thats right, clap on the solo :P
urbanmonk95 1 year ago 3
Title of the video wrecks the joke completely.
Robomansk8 1 year ago
i'd make love to his wife :P
themegafool123 1 year ago
same video is on his official channels and in real hq
deadzior 1 year ago
LMFAO
PS3Unlocked 1 year ago
Amazing bloke, great pianist and superb song writer
hd53exw 1 year ago 3
Duude change the title it ruins the joke
ggaryy1 1 year ago 79
@ggaryy1 This.
iluvmuse 1 year ago
@ggaryy1 Totally agree!
tromboneux 1 year ago
@ggaryy1 agree'd
vpurev 1 year ago
@ggaryy1
Thumbs down are for the lying about being HQ. This is not high quality.
pacarter88 1 year ago
Turned on tv and just missed this and i was like AHHHHHHHHH FUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUck
BoxingMadLad 1 year ago 3
I saw this on Friday - Fkn adore Tim's humour - and to be honest I would happily have Jane too ;-)
TokerSmurf 1 year ago
All songs on TimMinchinLive are stolen (or "collected") from other accounts.
d4m4s74 1 year ago
@d4m4s74 - OOPS FAIL!! - as far as I understand, this is the only account (other than Tim's own) which is authorised to have the vids. Check out the channel homepage. Anyone else with the vids have stolen them or put them on-line without permission.
TokerSmurf 1 year ago
@d4m4s74 TIM MINCHIN STILL PAYS HIM SO LIKE HE GIVES A SHIT
PS3Unlocked 1 year ago
@d4m4s74 but TimMinchinLive is the OFFICIAL FAN account with permission to upload, all other uploaders are also criminals lmfao
ItsMeOrYouShitHead 1 year ago
Once I get past the hair, and I do, your brilliance still shines thru!
Great work!
CrankyCrone 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
It really looks like you stole that video from "prozacbear" and you tried to hide some hard coded text with poor executed annotations. You should at least give some credit!
tromboneux 1 year ago
@tromboneux
Yeah, remove the annotations and you see "Lenny Prozac part 2 of 2"
Nickondeweb 1 year ago
@tromboneux Actually, I have permission to upload this vide, Prozacbear didn't. He is in fact breaking the law and I do NOT need to credit him. Thanks.
TimMinchinLive 1 year ago 209
@TimMinchinLive Show me where it is written that you have permission please.
tromboneux 1 year ago
@tromboneux Despite the fact I have spoken to Tim numerous times via email, despite the fact I made the official channel 'partner'. Despite the fact I made the background to both official and unofficial channels?
JaackMaate 1 year ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
@TimMinchinLive please provide proof of the permission you claim to have or your videos will be deleted within 1 month of this comment being posted.
tb240904 1 year ago
@tb240904 stop preteding to be youtube you retard >.>
vpurev 1 year ago
@tb240904 It's not a question of whether 'TimMinchinLive' has permission to upload this video from Tim Minchin or any representatives, it's a clip from the BBC and he ('Jaackmaate') is allowed to post it, so long as he doesn't "bring the BBC into disrespute".
dave199234 1 year ago
@tb240904 grow up, you silly little child
ItsMeOrYouShitHead 1 year ago
@TimMinchinLive he's the real internet pirate!!! ;)
2sSHenky 1 year ago
@TimMinchinLive if you had permission to air it then you would have the original
sportchase 1 year ago
@TimMinchinLive - Get over yourself. Prozacbear might be violating YourTube's Terms of Service but unless you know in what state/region/province/jurisdiction Prozacbear is living and are familiar with the Copyright laws applicable to that jurisdiction, you have no idea if he/she is 'breaking the law'. Don't talk shit. I DO credit Prozacbear because he/she uploaded first. I don't give a shit if they 'permission' to upload the video. I just care that I got to see it.
zer0ne83 8 months ago
@zer0ne83 Regardless of whether they uploaded it first or not, they didn't get permission from the owner, therefore they don't have the rights to use the video. Even if he does have access to the video he didnt CREATE it.
TheRealBarnez 8 months ago
@TheRealBarnez - Agreed 100%. No permission from owner means he didn't have the right to upload the content per YouTube's Term of Service Agreement. My point was that you can't call a breach of YouTube's SA 'breaking the law'. Because that's simply BS. Unless you know the precise terms of the Copyright legislation applicable to the poster in their home country, uploading the video could be anything to a full breach of the local Copyright Act to an act not amenable to any local legislation/law.
zer0ne83 8 months ago
@zer0ne83 "I DO credit Prozacbear because he/she uploaded first."
The point that was being made was that he shouldnt be credited seeing as its not his video. The point is seeing as Tim didnt give him permission, being first to upload it doesn't make it his video.
TheRealBarnez 8 months ago
@TheRealBarnez - Tim doesn't own the rights to a network television broadcast just because he's in it you fucking retard. The broadcast, as a Copyright 'original works', is owned by the network that produced it. So neither 'Prozacbear' or 'Tim Minchin Live' needed Tim's permission to upload it. Further, neither of them obtained permission to upload it from the true owner of the footage. 'The point' is that you are both drawing invisible legal/moral lines that don't exist.
zer0ne83 8 months ago
@zer0ne83 As Tim performed the piece, it's his intellectual property. As it is, copyright law in its most literal state would say that it belongs to the people who filmed it yes, but that's like saying that all music belongs to the recording studios and not the artists who made them, because the studio filmed the video.
Its Tim's song, his property.
TheRealBarnez 8 months ago
@TheRealBarnez - Wow. I can tell you are a qualified intellectual property solicitor. Just, wow.
zer0ne83 8 months ago
@TheRealBarnez I may be wrong here, but is it not a record label who owns copyright of a musical *recording*, not the studio or artist? The artist is the one who can sue for overly-derivitive (copying) songwriting, but any publication that breaches copyright of a recording is up to a record label (unless independently produced), or, in this instance, the network on which the footage was published.
Equihan 7 months ago
@Equihan Er it's kinda half and half, Tim has rights to use the song, as he made it.
the BBC also own it because they published it. But as the actual artist Tim is obviously allowed to use it.
TheRealBarnez 7 months ago
@TheRealBarnez Yes, but Tim would have to get permission from the BBC, if the BBC is anything like the ABC. He had to do so to put various ABC clips on his DVDs.
Equihan 7 months ago
@Equihan Mhmm, if the BBC gave Tim joint ownership of the clips then it's fine. If not, meh, this is only a fan channel. Its not like they're making money off it.
TheRealBarnez 7 months ago
@TheRealBarnez I know. It's no biggie unless an owner gets antsy. Was just sayin'. :)
Equihan 7 months ago
Tim overdid it with the hair this time. He looks like he put his hand in an electrical socket just before going on stage lol
LynxChan 1 year ago
woooohoooo!!! freaking awesome as usual
akatsukimaster666 1 year ago