Celia, this is an amazing performance for your age, excellent! You must be 15 or 16 years old now and I bet you are a great pianist now. Thanks for sharing.
great playing...this is a REALLY nice nterpretation for a girl your age!!
BUT, as some people questioned before, this girl does not attend regular schooling, so she does have more time to practice, answering the questions about a "normal" little girl's life. therefore it is very difficult to attain this level of playing at such a young age without an adjusted schedule, leaving some hope to people who just practice on the side! HOWEVER, very well done!!! bravo!!!
You're style of playing is a lot different from those of a lot of other pianists (myself included) First of all, I interpret the beginning slightly slower as a "slow walking pace" rather than a "jog." I also think you press the keys a bit too heavily. A piano is a medium through which one can express their emotions. This piece contains several. Take advantage of that. I also use the pedal to create a bit of a "dramatic" effect. Also, careful not to rush. Great Job overall!
you play too strong, this play must be played more piano PIANO! and, for you does the ligatures exist?. The technique is not too bad, but personally, i think you move too your hands up and down. But it's obvious that you've studied much for play it. Improve these small failures :) and it ll be perfect ;)
you play too strong, this play must be played more piano PIANO! and, for you does the ligatures exist?. The technique is not too bad, but personally, i thonk you move too your hands up and down. But it's obvious that you've studied much for play it. Improve these small failures :) and it ll be perfect ;)
Well done for learning this piece off by heart- however I feel you have put no feeling into this piece. Your hands are too heavy, it makes this piece sound angry instead of beautiful and heavenly. Good luck.
very nice for her age. barely any tecnique but thats not expected at 10 years old. very nice for how much progress she has made with her hand movement
@theEinsteinable Take it one measure at a time, one hand at a time. Play it as many times in a row so that it's really engraved in your brain. Then try hands together, very slowly. Go as slowly as you need so theres no mistakes. Then gradually speed it up!
This is partially decent compared to the amount of 9 year olds I have seen that are already in grade 10... quite decent overall. Try working on the accents and speed, as well as the deep/loud touch on the first notes of each phrase.
@smallblockdemon you're not giving a speech where you need to make eye contact. I'd love to see someone play this piece without looking at the keys. I've been playing for 15 years and there is only one piece I can play without looking at the keys and that's because I've been playing for nearly 10 years now (its a comfort piece that starts my practice with).
Wow you are amazing!!!!! Ignore all of the bad coments on this because if you put work into this you could have a future!!!!! Keep up the good work!!!!! = )
Boooożee... grasz przepięknie !!! pewnie i tak z tego nic nie zrozumiesz ale..
Pięknie grasz..ja rozumiem że jak się gra to się przeżywa to.. ale ja się Ciebie aż boje.. strasznie ponura i przygnębiona jesteś.. może jakiś uśmiech ? On zmienił by wszystko.. a grasz cudeńko ;**
Uuuurgh! I loathe, yet deeply admire kids like this. I'm 13 and am nothing compared to this. But what annoys me, is that, like here, the good people swing their arms and elbows all over the place. I get it if ur doing a long run or something, but when going from D to F, u don't really need to.
well it's good, but...I feel some kind of "too loud" on some parts and not enough emotion... well it's what I think anyway^^ I can play it too, and guess what? I didn't ever know this piece before my teacher gave it to us.
I'm not trying to be mean or anything, but try to put more volume change into it. Some part were louder than others, but mostly the whole piece had the same tone.
@Dpl8body LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOL especially at the last part when she looks at the camera.
Wow soooo I feel stupid now, I'm 14 and learning this and having difficulties even WITH the sheet music and then this kid comes along and steals the show. Good job! You're a very technically sound player, I would just put some more emotion into it. But other than that its absolutely amazing!
it's really good but i find it a little fast paced. The song should have alot more legato and also be a little bit slower but other then that it's really good
No sheet music? Who made you to memorise that hole piece? It's a crime ! Your mind should be clean. You need to read the sheets to avoid overcharging your mind !
I do have to agree with some of you. The fact that some kids this young can actually play these pieces very well, makes me wonder what kind of childhood and social life they have. I would assume almost none and that a majority of their free time is spent practicing which is very sad.
@pooh42682 Sorry, honey, I'm 15 and I've played all the Mozart Fantasias, go to a Performing Arts high school for piano, practice 2-4 hours a day, and have the biggest and best social life. You don't have to be weird to be phenomenal at an instrument...
i feel so bad for this kid, she's probably home schooled and has little of a social life, when i was ten i was playing those two page songs from the lesson book, i pity her although she is very very good, i pity her
@xDissonancex haha me too sometimes. I'm 12 and been playing for 3 years, some kids younger then me have been playing for about 4 and are so much better then me.
well done.:) don\t listen to others what they say here or too peoples that choose dislike. they are just haters, you can find them even in great pianists:) keep it up:)
@BlackCloud21509 Yea i feel like a looser but not cause she a kid cause i cant play period she can shurly read and right sheets and well i basically cant so thats pretty much it and i cant move up and down so fast so what can i say pretty much looser alert here but forget me she is talented ill find something im good at someday right now i cant figure that out yet
The beginning is way to fast. In my book the beginning is Andante, 2nd is Adagio, and 3rd is Allegreto. The scales were great. 3:50 to 4:00 you should check your rhythm.
its ok to do that with your elbow in compositions where there is not manu notes. at 1:13 you play prokofiev... you should make some dinamic. for example you do chrescendo on that one repetition tone.
she had good playing ability, but she doesnt follow dynamics or tempo. its supposed to be much quieter and slower at the beginning. but other than that. and she is ten. so good job.
you dolts. the music was written with emotion; it should be played with emotion.
but i don't understand what you want out of this girl. she's very young and clearly hasn't been playing for long, simply judging by the piece chosen. i feel that she did in fact put a good bit of feeling into the music. she looked like she was trying with great fervor and concentration to focus on getting everything right simultaneously. it's difficult. everyone has room for improvement...
@helloslinkyfish i agree with you %10000 precent. young kids should not play such serious songs. it require much feeling and emotion that young kids dont understand at there age.
@hco4af Humm, I think we can blame the teacher on that though. The teacher could at least tell her not to pound and to play piano and forte at certain points. That does not need emotion, just direction. The emotion can come later.
@ykaiilah i went to school in russia it was requried to feel the music becuase that was the most important part. even if the song wasnt in direction. i remember i played a song for my professer once with no feeling and i failed the song even thou i perfected the direction. sooo im pretty sure music REQUIRES music no matter when or how you play it. (;
Wow, I'm speechless. I definitely wasn't expecting that from her. Perhaps our public schools would be a tad better if rap wasn't the music of choice, and this took it's place, hmm?
Ugh. She's was 10 when she did this for Christs sakes, what does it matter if she doesn't have the 'emotion' or put her heart into it. She still did the number beautifully, so who cares and if you have complaints then go watch someone who has more 'emotion' and 'feeling' while they're playing this piece. 10/10, this was lovely.
I'm with AndyJB2005, I almost thought it was bad due to no emotion. I really just wanted to stop listening. She is very very accurate on her notes and rhythms though. It was still boring, because of the accuracy. It's really obvious she practices hours upon hours on hitting every note perfectly, and she looks bored. If your hearts not in it, neither is the crowd.
Technically wonderful, spot on notes. However, entirely too fast and no emotion what-so-ever. Try to teach her that music is more than playing on the page, okay?
Excellent technique. I followed the thumbnail and noticed the piano has an intricate music desk. After a quick search, I discovered that it is a Vogel, probably the 177 judging by the nice sound, in the Royal style. Cool :)
I play this fantasie too and I don't find it easy. I have been playing piano for 9 years I think that for this age, it's verry good, it's just her touch that's too strong but it could be the registering material., she's verry talented. How long did she play? She should have begun verry young.
Wow, definitely better than the crappy version I have posted at the moment (still learning it). Actually, I like this more than many of the professional versions uploaded to youtube.
I could make a couple of minor observations but will restrict myself to saying that in the section beginning at 1:27 (and its subsequent appearance in g minor) you have to be careful not to give it an almost tango-like sound. (2DRYH's performance takes this to the extreme.) But well done indeed.
I'm learning this piece as well. She's better than me, and I'm sure she is certainly going to be better than I will ever be. I wish I were lucky enough to have started at her age. She can be WAY faster than I am, without stumbling.
Even though I think a bit more pedaling and releasing notes more slowly would make it better, this is awesome, and it does have feeling! The happy ending sounds flawless to me, though I haven't played it yet...
Well, most of you said that it needs more "feeling"... And this is considerably sad, right? Most probably, she hasn't felt real pain and sorrow yet... And that's how it should be.... Personally I believe that the "happy" parts are better played than the "sad" ones.... But for such a young girl it's just perfect... (what an amazing technique!)
I had to learn and memorize this song my senior year in high school and I loved to play it. It is such a beautiful piece and I love this performance of it. I know when I played it there were parts here and there that tended to play faster...so it is still a little odd to hear those parts slowed down.
wonderful, keep going and keep practicing. You do not have to show "emotion" to play piano. I can't stand all the rounding and flailing, it's so forced and irritating.
dude... at 37 years old, you have nothing better to do than criticize 10 yr old girls at their piano playing skills? wtf do u know about piano? go find something better to do with you time...
very good just slow down...act like its your last song you will ever play...i know your young so you cant relate it to losing a love.but play with a thought of the piano needing you ....
Impressive technique for someone so young. But I think a little less "Horowitz" in her playing might be advisable. A person with their emotions just ripening can interpret things with such charm and natural innocence, that to play things so techniquely controlled is not the best fruit of a child's playing, or any artist's playing. This girl still has an intuition that comes through despite her probably strict formal training. Brava!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
WTF !! thiis is fakee !! thiss bull; her finger arentt in the right place. the lady who did this film obviously fast forwarded it .. and changed the music.. i play the college level fantasy . ALL YOU PEOPELEE THAT BELEIVEE ALL THE SHITT ON THE INTERNET SHOULD KNOW THAT THE INTERNET IS 90 % FAKE. btw im not near jealouss. ive played for all the goverment of america, and the ladyy fixed thiss filmmm.
Are you blind? You're either commenting on the wrong video, your processor sucks, your ears suck, you're a bad troll, or you're trying to make a joke over the internet.
Well, considering the fact that she's playing the RIGHT NOTES and the audio is perfectly in sync anyone who even has the slightest amount of brain power could add two and two together to see that she obviously is playing this.
You should seriously listen to MathGenius888, I studied piano for 3 years and I'm a fucking noob compared to him. Very good, but be careful when you're making huge transitions(octaves) across the keyboard.
Celia, this is an amazing performance for your age, excellent! You must be 15 or 16 years old now and I bet you are a great pianist now. Thanks for sharing.
sssatrunnn 1 week ago
She's really lucky to have a nice piano and lots of time to study! I have a keyboard, and I hardly get to use I piano during the week....
hermione624420 1 week ago
shows hours of studying but the performance is completely devoid of emotion
ternitamas 4 weeks ago
I played you for my baby when I was pregnant. She still likes you. :)
Lizardgod69 4 months ago
beautiful execution!!! go girl
jalentaylor24 4 months ago
She is really talented.
suraiaBD 4 months ago
So good!!!!
juan99160956 4 months ago
great playing...this is a REALLY nice nterpretation for a girl your age!!
BUT, as some people questioned before, this girl does not attend regular schooling, so she does have more time to practice, answering the questions about a "normal" little girl's life. therefore it is very difficult to attain this level of playing at such a young age without an adjusted schedule, leaving some hope to people who just practice on the side! HOWEVER, very well done!!! bravo!!!
greyoctopus 5 months ago
your thumbs in the beginning are too loud. anyone can play this piece but only some people can bring life and feeling into it
ustinkirock0610 6 months ago
put down your elbows plz ...can't phrasing correctly with that technique...
Spudboy41 6 months ago 5
You're style of playing is a lot different from those of a lot of other pianists (myself included) First of all, I interpret the beginning slightly slower as a "slow walking pace" rather than a "jog." I also think you press the keys a bit too heavily. A piano is a medium through which one can express their emotions. This piece contains several. Take advantage of that. I also use the pedal to create a bit of a "dramatic" effect. Also, careful not to rush. Great Job overall!
U2becommenter 6 months ago
I played this in 5th grade. It's really a great piece! Sounds harder than it is :)
gyurchev 6 months ago
@gyurchev Yes, it looks so daunting but it's actually not so daunting
chrisclr 6 months ago
Clap your hands everybody!
santias13 6 months ago
she's really suck.
MrAddress001 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
you play too strong, this play must be played more piano PIANO! and, for you does the ligatures exist?. The technique is not too bad, but personally, i think you move too your hands up and down. But it's obvious that you've studied much for play it. Improve these small failures :) and it ll be perfect ;)
elreydelpiano 7 months ago
you play too strong, this play must be played more piano PIANO! and, for you does the ligatures exist?. The technique is not too bad, but personally, i thonk you move too your hands up and down. But it's obvious that you've studied much for play it. Improve these small failures :) and it ll be perfect ;)
elreydelpiano 7 months ago
Well done for learning this piece off by heart- however I feel you have put no feeling into this piece. Your hands are too heavy, it makes this piece sound angry instead of beautiful and heavenly. Good luck.
anon0106 7 months ago 4
2:12 - 2:18
This, in contrast, just made my life look so insignificant... You have quite the future, Celia!
MegaLyricalGenius 7 months ago
very beautiful girl!
meronpan1128 7 months ago
she plays too aggressive and too quick
Johanna2206 7 months ago
very nice for her age. barely any tecnique but thats not expected at 10 years old. very nice for how much progress she has made with her hand movement
Xsabergandora 7 months ago
Hi im having a hard time playing this part: 0:43 any suggestions, so i Can improve myself
theEinsteinable 8 months ago
@theEinsteinable Take it one measure at a time, one hand at a time. Play it as many times in a row so that it's really engraved in your brain. Then try hands together, very slowly. Go as slowly as you need so theres no mistakes. Then gradually speed it up!
dancer8164 7 months ago
102 ppl are jealous
maitecorpsebride 8 months ago
ITS OK, WHEN YOU LOOK TEHNIQE, BUT ITS NOT WHAT IS SEARCHED IN THIS COMPOSITION
aApTiN 8 months ago
its incredible. its so beautiful
naattyvec015 8 months ago
best piano piece ever...luv Mozart, and this performance is just stunning
maitecorpsebride 9 months ago
BEAUTIFUL!!!!!!!
Arthro92 9 months ago
This is partially decent compared to the amount of 9 year olds I have seen that are already in grade 10... quite decent overall. Try working on the accents and speed, as well as the deep/loud touch on the first notes of each phrase.
WesPLOOP 9 months ago
Wowzah!! You ARE really good!!!
pockythin 9 months ago
I did subscribed! Good played and also recorded! =-)
underverser 9 months ago
Brava honey. That was beautiful. Very clear and crisp at the end. Its always nice to see a child learning and appreciating music.
epiplp6 10 months ago
VERY well played. Should put music in front of you just to keep your eyes off the keys. That was awsome!!!
smallblockdemon 10 months ago
@smallblockdemon you're not giving a speech where you need to make eye contact. I'd love to see someone play this piece without looking at the keys. I've been playing for 15 years and there is only one piece I can play without looking at the keys and that's because I've been playing for nearly 10 years now (its a comfort piece that starts my practice with).
epiplp6 10 months ago
Wow you are amazing!!!!! Ignore all of the bad coments on this because if you put work into this you could have a future!!!!! Keep up the good work!!!!! = )
buckyandtheoedork 10 months ago
isn't lines 1-11 supposed to be andante? or am i at fault D:
rachelp147 10 months ago
nicely done
ChaosNMK 10 months ago
I love your videos ^^ good job :) continue :D
tiffadorra 10 months ago
where i can find the score??
IlidaCullen 10 months ago
@IlidaCullen imslp.org/wiki/Fantasia_in_D_minor,_K.397/385g_(Mozart,_Wolfgang_Amadeus)
Politan182 10 months ago
@Politan182 Oh... Thank you very much..!!!
IlidaCullen 10 months ago
amazing how she can memorize all this!
how long has she been playing?
michiru123456789 11 months ago
where is the f or p the voice is too big in some parts
LoveGirl0829 11 months ago
Its wonderful!
custard50146 11 months ago
this girl is amazing she plays really well, especially becasue she's 10 years old !! i like playing the fantasy, even though im not as good as her :)
but little emotion cannot hurt anybody
Elijis1 11 months ago
I really like the fantasy, it has a beautiful introduction in the minor key, and then a faster 2nd part.You play it really well, congratulations!
raylegea 11 months ago
what grade is this piece?
lovechocolatefish 11 months ago
@2:09 watch her hands! WOW!!!!!
LELsings 1 year ago
its really beautiful :)
xivaavengeance 1 year ago
Brava suoni bene davvero
TheDandy0825 1 year ago
Boooożee... grasz przepięknie !!! pewnie i tak z tego nic nie zrozumiesz ale..
Pięknie grasz..ja rozumiem że jak się gra to się przeżywa to.. ale ja się Ciebie aż boje.. strasznie ponura i przygnębiona jesteś.. może jakiś uśmiech ? On zmienił by wszystko.. a grasz cudeńko ;**
Blanka162 1 year ago
Everyone: please note that the title of this video includes the word "Practice." Not "Performance."
armedbro 1 year ago
she has a feel for classical music
malmsteen80 1 year ago
Comment removed
nmsll 1 year ago
Now she's 14 years old. They grow up fast. (I'M 9 THOUGH AND SAYING THAT)
lolgirl9513 1 year ago
Uuuurgh! I loathe, yet deeply admire kids like this. I'm 13 and am nothing compared to this. But what annoys me, is that, like here, the good people swing their arms and elbows all over the place. I get it if ur doing a long run or something, but when going from D to F, u don't really need to.
Pyfacefornever 1 year ago
Wunderschone Musik! She has much talent.
poptartcows 1 year ago
Eres un robot jajaja!! muy bueno
xXVenezuelaXx 1 year ago
well it's good, but...I feel some kind of "too loud" on some parts and not enough emotion... well it's what I think anyway^^ I can play it too, and guess what? I didn't ever know this piece before my teacher gave it to us.
Pureinlife 1 year ago
I'm not trying to be mean or anything, but try to put more volume change into it. Some part were louder than others, but mostly the whole piece had the same tone.
Just my advice.
PianicFanatic 1 year ago
just a slight mistake i think...
on the second part, i think u played just a bit too fast?
lccansmd 1 year ago
@lccansmd I agree. It's supposed to be fast but not so fast that you can't tell the notes apart.
PianicFanatic 1 year ago
lawl FAKE :P she doesnt looks like a girl look in her face ! shes looking like an ill woman ..
Dpl8body 1 year ago
@Dpl8body LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOL especially at the last part when she looks at the camera.
lccansmd 1 year ago
fuck meeeee youre so good
roxyhappi 1 year ago
how old are you ??
MyKristenStewart 1 year ago
:O and this is just PRACTICE...i wanna grow up to be like her lol =] but no really
rachelp147 1 year ago
Very nice playing Celia!!! An Amazing Artist you already are :) Hope the brightest future for you, god bless your gifts and soul .
eddiemperor 1 year ago
Wow soooo I feel stupid now, I'm 14 and learning this and having difficulties even WITH the sheet music and then this kid comes along and steals the show. Good job! You're a very technically sound player, I would just put some more emotion into it. But other than that its absolutely amazing!
WithLove4896 1 year ago 2
omg she is like (looks) six-eight that is so damn amazing to memorize this piece and play it! and this is like pretty difficult piece
ADevilsSnare 1 year ago
Superlativa eccezionale sto studiando anch'io questo meraviglioso pezzo non vedo l'ora di finirlo
pinachi29 1 year ago
it's really good but i find it a little fast paced. The song should have alot more legato and also be a little bit slower but other then that it's really good
jasperc121 1 year ago
Very good, she just needs to put a lot more emotion into it. The dynamics are all wrong.
pbryld 1 year ago 2
You are so talanted! Well done!!!
desi0359 1 year ago 10
No sheet music? Who made you to memorise that hole piece? It's a crime ! Your mind should be clean. You need to read the sheets to avoid overcharging your mind !
RappaBoy1 1 year ago
Lol I'm learning this song and I'm 15 I feel so outsmarted loool cute kid she's REALLLLYYYYY good :)
3mouskkeuteuses 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
imao if she pays a little more attention to forte, im sure she can play much better. ofc she is a very good pianist for her age, though.
yuta1010blog 1 year ago
Comment removed
yuta1010blog 1 year ago
I do have to agree with some of you. The fact that some kids this young can actually play these pieces very well, makes me wonder what kind of childhood and social life they have. I would assume almost none and that a majority of their free time is spent practicing which is very sad.
pooh42682 1 year ago
@pooh42682 Sorry, honey, I'm 15 and I've played all the Mozart Fantasias, go to a Performing Arts high school for piano, practice 2-4 hours a day, and have the biggest and best social life. You don't have to be weird to be phenomenal at an instrument...
lisagracewantsyou 1 year ago
i feel so bad for this kid, she's probably home schooled and has little of a social life, when i was ten i was playing those two page songs from the lesson book, i pity her although she is very very good, i pity her
rustyrobot20 1 year ago
@rustyrobot20 u cant just JUDGE some1 like that after listening to them play a piano piece thats really good- maybe she just has TALENT
raphaTHEmaskweeka 1 year ago
I dont really like the interpretation, it should be too much more sweet, leggato, piano, slow and the part in 1:29 faster
putoamodetodo 1 year ago
Very Impressive runs. And yes, I agree. Kids who can outplay me, constantly brings me down. Lol
xDissonancex 1 year ago
@xDissonancex haha me too sometimes. I'm 12 and been playing for 3 years, some kids younger then me have been playing for about 4 and are so much better then me.
ForEverLana 1 year ago
What´s wrong with the people that dislike this video?? I think it´s amazing...
Ariusa 1 year ago
Very talented! You will go far!
RetroRedJeans 1 year ago
well done.:) don\t listen to others what they say here or too peoples that choose dislike. they are just haters, you can find them even in great pianists:) keep it up:)
Skenderbej 1 year ago
Amazing! Cheer up! I through Horowitz to find you. Just find your music and fun.
yiyiking 1 year ago
don't like this interpretation. there should be more emotion!
PentaPic 1 year ago
A M A Z I N G ! loved it!
MyPianoAdiction 1 year ago
Fantástica¡¡¡¡
valerita1973 1 year ago
Hate watching little kids play pieces like this it makes me feel like a loser...
BlackCloud21509 1 year ago 116
Comment removed
intermender 10 months ago
@BlackCloud21509 Yet, I can't stay away.... :D
Hakurou3137 7 months ago
@BlackCloud21509 Yea i feel like a looser but not cause she a kid cause i cant play period she can shurly read and right sheets and well i basically cant so thats pretty much it and i cant move up and down so fast so what can i say pretty much looser alert here but forget me she is talented ill find something im good at someday right now i cant figure that out yet
Don21x 6 months ago
The beginning is way to fast. In my book the beginning is Andante, 2nd is Adagio, and 3rd is Allegreto. The scales were great. 3:50 to 4:00 you should check your rhythm.
pianomasterbrandon1 1 year ago
The beginning is way to fast. In my book the beginning is Andante, 2nd is Adagio, and 3rd is Allegreto. The scales were great.
pianomasterbrandon1 1 year ago
The beginning is way to fast. In my book the beginning is Andante, 2nd is Adagio, and 3rd is Allegreto.
pianomasterbrandon1 1 year ago
Mozart would be proud!
teazalamode 1 year ago
youtube makes people watching fun... this girl is sooo talented.
rohw0016 1 year ago 3
its ok to do that with your elbow in compositions where there is not manu notes. at 1:13 you play prokofiev... you should make some dinamic. for example you do chrescendo on that one repetition tone.
predoje 1 year ago
Beautiful girl, beautiful piece and beautiful piano. What anymore can we ask for?
RonaldCadiggioFlores 1 year ago 2
what kind of piano is the delightful pianist playing on?
pyroprince78 1 year ago
pretty good.
yrrehs0702 1 year ago
So admirable :) It's close to Mozart I hear few resemblances :)
You are great girl :)
Bramborail 1 year ago
WOW
dhqXxicee 1 year ago
I'm twice her age and I can't play this piece as well as she could. lol
you're a talented little girl. Well done :)
DADADOoOM 1 year ago
very nice! beautifully done.. bravo!
steinhammerr 1 year ago
forte where piano and piano where forte...but ok in all
ComedyFeine 1 year ago
she had good playing ability, but she doesnt follow dynamics or tempo. its supposed to be much quieter and slower at the beginning. but other than that. and she is ten. so good job.
pianoguy1120 1 year ago
Wow o_o That was amazing xD I'm just jealous at you're talent. You are great!
kimmynap 1 year ago
hello please tell me how long it took her to perfect and learn this song ?
hco4af 1 year ago
you dolts. the music was written with emotion; it should be played with emotion.
but i don't understand what you want out of this girl. she's very young and clearly hasn't been playing for long, simply judging by the piece chosen. i feel that she did in fact put a good bit of feeling into the music. she looked like she was trying with great fervor and concentration to focus on getting everything right simultaneously. it's difficult. everyone has room for improvement...
helloslinkyfish 1 year ago 27
@helloslinkyfish i agree with you %10000 precent. young kids should not play such serious songs. it require much feeling and emotion that young kids dont understand at there age.
hco4af 1 year ago
@hco4af Humm, I think we can blame the teacher on that though. The teacher could at least tell her not to pound and to play piano and forte at certain points. That does not need emotion, just direction. The emotion can come later.
ykaiilah 1 year ago
Comment removed
hco4af 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@ykaiilah i went to school in russia it was requried to feel the music becuase that was the most important part. even if the song wasnt in direction. i remember i played a song for my professer once with no feeling and i failed the song even thou i perfected the direction. sooo im pretty sure music REQUIRES music no matter when or how you play it. (;
hco4af 1 year ago
@helloslinkyfish Totally agree. And btw, shes only 10 years old!! Its amazing to play like this at the age of 10!!
1998ninni 1 year ago
@helloslinkyfish EXACTLY. She's done very well. No need to be critical, she's done a great job and is probably watching all this feedback here too.
surfsideintruders 11 months ago
i like your playing
wolfymozartinio 1 year ago
Wow, I'm speechless. I definitely wasn't expecting that from her. Perhaps our public schools would be a tad better if rap wasn't the music of choice, and this took it's place, hmm?
habagrachel 1 year ago
Ugh. She's was 10 when she did this for Christs sakes, what does it matter if she doesn't have the 'emotion' or put her heart into it. She still did the number beautifully, so who cares and if you have complaints then go watch someone who has more 'emotion' and 'feeling' while they're playing this piece. 10/10, this was lovely.
xXSnoozySnoopyXx 1 year ago
Why does she moves her arms so much. That's not economical.
einarabelc5 1 year ago
@einarabelc5 Because it's how SHE plays, not how you want her to play.
habagrachel 1 year ago
I'm with AndyJB2005, I almost thought it was bad due to no emotion. I really just wanted to stop listening. She is very very accurate on her notes and rhythms though. It was still boring, because of the accuracy. It's really obvious she practices hours upon hours on hitting every note perfectly, and she looks bored. If your hearts not in it, neither is the crowd.
boogala13 1 year ago
Technically wonderful, spot on notes. However, entirely too fast and no emotion what-so-ever. Try to teach her that music is more than playing on the page, okay?
AndyJB2005 1 year ago
I'm about to learn this...how long did it take her to learn? and how many years has she been playing?
ahhlehx 1 year ago
@ahhlehx My brother took 3 weeks after 9 months of playing.
einarabelc5 1 year ago
Incredible
TrentSav 1 year ago
Excellent technique. I followed the thumbnail and noticed the piano has an intricate music desk. After a quick search, I discovered that it is a Vogel, probably the 177 judging by the nice sound, in the Royal style. Cool :)
edisrafehtable 1 year ago 2
Thanks :)
The piano is a Grotrian 160 - Clara Schumann style
ailecec 1 year ago 2
Hahaa if you were ten back then Im taking that your around 14 now?
Great job regardless.
angelicbabii 1 year ago
Nice pedal /sarcasm
OhMyKoshi 1 year ago
Excellent! Thanks for the beautiful music.
RespectedEnt 1 year ago
she play well,
I play this fantasie too and I don't find it easy. I have been playing piano for 9 years I think that for this age, it's verry good, it's just her touch that's too strong but it could be the registering material., she's verry talented. How long did she play? She should have begun verry young.
PS- scuse my english, I'm french
orinym 1 year ago
Wow, definitely better than the crappy version I have posted at the moment (still learning it). Actually, I like this more than many of the professional versions uploaded to youtube.
I could make a couple of minor observations but will restrict myself to saying that in the section beginning at 1:27 (and its subsequent appearance in g minor) you have to be careful not to give it an almost tango-like sound. (2DRYH's performance takes this to the extreme.) But well done indeed.
MaestroTJS 1 year ago
I'm learning this piece as well. She's better than me, and I'm sure she is certainly going to be better than I will ever be. I wish I were lucky enough to have started at her age. She can be WAY faster than I am, without stumbling.
Even though I think a bit more pedaling and releasing notes more slowly would make it better, this is awesome, and it does have feeling! The happy ending sounds flawless to me, though I haven't played it yet...
Very talented. Keep it up!
tunglour 1 year ago
Well, most of you said that it needs more "feeling"... And this is considerably sad, right? Most probably, she hasn't felt real pain and sorrow yet... And that's how it should be.... Personally I believe that the "happy" parts are better played than the "sad" ones.... But for such a young girl it's just perfect... (what an amazing technique!)
Good luck!
PIANOukla 1 year ago
fantastic
Kimba1234 1 year ago
Amazing!
Evanescence2213Piano 1 year ago
Holy shiz... I didn't expect her to play the fast parts correctly. Very well done.
cheeseclo 1 year ago
correct breaks and generally temp and rhythm
And pure child feel to Mozart.
!!!!!!!!!!
lampovy 1 year ago
Yowsers. Whata machine!!! Phenom.
dbordegon 1 year ago
I had to learn and memorize this song my senior year in high school and I loved to play it. It is such a beautiful piece and I love this performance of it. I know when I played it there were parts here and there that tended to play faster...so it is still a little odd to hear those parts slowed down.
comedytonighttt 1 year ago
geez... this makes me sick... technically flawless... she plays alot more accurately then me and ive been learning for 10 years.
eemziezz 1 year ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
i wish fuck this girl!!!!!
clickthory91 1 year ago
lol What a look at the end
sampoirier 1 year ago
Let me just get this for you, keep at it
cingle2004jp 1 year ago
wonderful, keep going and keep practicing. You do not have to show "emotion" to play piano. I can't stand all the rounding and flailing, it's so forced and irritating.
thubtenwangmo 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Myleso
dude... at 37 years old, you have nothing better to do than criticize 10 yr old girls at their piano playing skills? wtf do u know about piano? go find something better to do with you time...
Actually a fairly awful attempt at life.
i thought it was awesome btw ^^ x
dannyxthexcat 2 years ago
awesome
Estee116 2 years ago 2
Actually a fairly awful rendition.
Myleso 2 years ago
Comment removed
dannyxthexcat 2 years ago
This comment made me lol so much. Thank you. xD
Cactus78 1 year ago
more emotion would have made this excellent. im learning this noww.
hiuhiuloopdedo 2 years ago
i know what you mean... how are you learning it, if you have sheets, could you send them to me
mrquintontheone 2 years ago
very good just slow down...act like its your last song you will ever play...i know your young so you cant relate it to losing a love.but play with a thought of the piano needing you ....
afatnickelrock 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
that is weaerd
perla7812 2 years ago
Impressive technique for someone so young. But I think a little less "Horowitz" in her playing might be advisable. A person with their emotions just ripening can interpret things with such charm and natural innocence, that to play things so techniquely controlled is not the best fruit of a child's playing, or any artist's playing. This girl still has an intuition that comes through despite her probably strict formal training. Brava!
genopal1020 2 years ago 2
im doing this peice for a uil solo
suchaBigKiddo 2 years ago
My God, she's amazing! Not perfect in dynamics and tempo, but still - look at her age!!!
moltoallegro19 2 years ago 4
you're just wonderfully talented! i play this piece right now myeslf but wow, not as nearly as good as you... yet :) !
caljokeepkeep 2 years ago
very good
salamalachala 2 years ago
wow!
thats so awesome.
I can't belive, that you could do the part on 2:10
Suchdla 2 years ago
looks very real to me
i didn't know people that age could play a song like that with little fingers
well done
very good
williamhodges1 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
WTF !! thiis is fakee !! thiss bull; her finger arentt in the right place. the lady who did this film obviously fast forwarded it .. and changed the music.. i play the college level fantasy . ALL YOU PEOPELEE THAT BELEIVEE ALL THE SHITT ON THE INTERNET SHOULD KNOW THAT THE INTERNET IS 90 % FAKE. btw im not near jealouss. ive played for all the goverment of america, and the ladyy fixed thiss filmmm.
hco4real 2 years ago
Are you blind? You're either commenting on the wrong video, your processor sucks, your ears suck, you're a bad troll, or you're trying to make a joke over the internet.
Either way, your comment was unfunny.
Un1234l 2 years ago 3
Doode, I play this piece. Her fingers ARE in the right place.
iShokora 2 years ago 21
Well, considering the fact that she's playing the RIGHT NOTES and the audio is perfectly in sync anyone who even has the slightest amount of brain power could add two and two together to see that she obviously is playing this.
Gr33nkiwi 2 years ago
Wow, great to see talented kids like this, nice! I like this piece very much
You guys should watch your language over here, have you no shame?
quinto34 2 years ago 17
watch your dynamics and not too fast.
ruskybalboa 2 years ago
You know they only put the age to boast. You don't see 40 year old people putting their age.
goodwood505 2 years ago 2
Wow! You're a very talented girl.
zadeh79 2 years ago
never mind what these people say
you have shared a very nice talent
thank you
bikingsage 2 years ago
You should seriously listen to MathGenius888, I studied piano for 3 years and I'm a fucking noob compared to him. Very good, but be careful when you're making huge transitions(octaves) across the keyboard.
mikevuong14 2 years ago
Beau, mais lui a besoin de plus de sentiment.
美しい、しかしそれより多くの感じを必要とする。
Красивейше, но мы нужно больше ощупывания.
Όμορφο, αλλά χρειάζεται περισσότερο συναίσθημα.
Schön, aber es benötigt mehr Gefühl.
Bello, ma esso ha bisogno di più sensibilità.
Mooi, maar het vergt meer gevoel.
美麗，但是它需要更多感覺。
Gladiustimid 2 years ago
Exactement !
Exactly !
de39 2 years ago
i bit smashy but pretty good :)
you have good "lift" for a 10 y/o
most over pedal it- especially when playing mo