Added: 5 years ago
From: tobydomnick
Views: 546,040
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (1,518)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • great song and sad true story. i did a research paper on it for school. i learned y it accully sank when they found is with the same robot they did to find the titantic

  • White fish point the light house, were the great Edmund Fitzgerald and many other ship storyies are shown and things taken from them is very interesting to see, i go there every year and it is a breath takeing view and good memory, along with the falls and the sue locks are right near there!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Amazing story, amazing song. My uncle used to be the First Mate of one of these Lake Liners, now he's the captain of the Maid of the Mist at Niagara Falls. For some reason this song epitomizes the spirit of the Canadian North.

  • Beautiful tribute. my prayers and love are with the families

  • very haunting song but grate ten out of ten.

  • All I know is, my ship mates, are at the bottom of the sea. That is where true sailors wind up. Mama Seas, takes care of her own. She takes care of her men. An old Sailor here. Damn, those lakes Sailors have more guts, than I do. And I was a combat Sailor!!!

  • "Does anyone know where the love of God goes when the waves turn the minutes to hours." Great line. I've often thought about what goes through a person's mind when they are confronted with mortality in a tragedy such as this. Reminds me of The Rime of the Ancient Mariner: "Alone, alone, all all alone, Alone on a wide, wide sea! And never a saint took pity on my soul in agony. The many men, so beautiful! And they all dead did lie: And a thousand thousand slimy things lived on; and so did I."

  • Also turned into a great song by Iron Maiden.

  • I've been a Gordon Lightfoot fan for many years and I still believe he is very underrated as a singer/songwriter.This is one of his best songs and one day I hope to visit the Great Lakes area because of it.Our great lake in New Zealand is Lake Taupo but it's more like a great puddle!!

  • A good way to think of Lake Superior is that it's a small ocean. It is a big, beautiful, and yes, fearsome lake. Hope you get to see it!

  • This song is still awesome...34 years later. Gordy Lightfoot is the MAN...

  • This song is still haunting after all these years. I almost got my ass kicked for whistling this as a greenhorn on a longliner.

  • great song prolly one of my favorites

  • Oh, okay. Thanks

  • What is the last picture? I can't tell.

  • it's a sky view of the Great Lakes

  • its the ship

  • Gordon Lightfoot and his poetry songs,how beautiful..I have to remember this name :):):)

  • I love the electric guitar in this song.

  • First time I have heard this in years. It gave me goose bumps. Thanks for upload.

  • Gordon Lightfoot lost a relative when the Fitzgerald went down.

  • RIP. Great Lakes are great. Glad I lived near them a while.

  • Who sings this?

  • Gordon Lightfoot.

  • Such a great song RIP crew of the edmund fitzgerald .

  • Powerful story, great song writing, Gordon Lightfoot will be remembered for generations.

  • SeanLovesHisMusic ur so cool if you havn't noticed nobody likes you!

  • R.I.P.

  • Message to renau1g:

    On Nov.20, 1976, almost exactly one year after the Edmund Fitzgerald marine disaster, Gordon Lightfoot's single was #2 in the USA, and Rod Stewart's "Tonight's The Night" was #1

    on the Billboard Hot 100.

  • I know it wasn't on Lake Erie, of course it was Superior. That whole area of the country just has a similar vibe to me, especcially that I don't live in that area anymore. That's all I was saying.

  • this song rocks!!! give me thums up if im right!!

  • sean

    maybe you should spell your name "shawn"

    like a girl

    keep burping your worm

    this is a GREAT song

  • That seanloveshismusic is only 14 years old. The little bastard isnt even off his moms tit yet. Youtube is full of these young inbreed no life bastards that dont know anything about anything. Sad is what it is. Post when you gain some smarts ya little prick--->sean

  • go kill yourself at a my chemical romance concert you fucking fag

  • lol you got a few thumbs down!!!

    how do ya feel know

  • sean loves his music

    keep floggin the dolphin

    you sausage

  • i love this song. i love to listen to this one on a big stereo. it really sounds like a great sailor song with the airy guitar parts and folk singing. he is good.

  • Didn't sink in Lake Erie, it sank in Lake Superior.

  • I don't think he/she is saying that it sank in Lake Erie, he/she is just saying that he/she lived up there and it reminds him/her of his/her home on Lake Erie, which is close to Lake Superior

  • In 1976, Gordon Lightfoot's single, The Wreck of The Edmund Fitzgerald, hit #2 in America and became a classic because of the true story he was telling. I was 9 years old when this terrible marine disaster happened on Nov.10, 1975.

  • I wonder what was #1?

  • Great Song! It reminds me of home - Lake Erie.

  • Clairfication. It wasn't a freak, or freak set of waves that sunk her. It was the "holds" flooding. Lake Michigan can get tough but it's not the north Atlantic.

  • They can't actually be sure, so it's still just a theory.

  • How it happened? The "holds" were either improper;y secured or broke loose. More likely the former than the latter.

  • very sad song my dad died on this ship

  • Wow. This ship sank in 1975 and you list your age as 23. So your dad died about about 11 years before you were born. Amazing.

  • he's right

  • Brings back a lot of memories. Thanks!

  • gordon lightfoot: a true american poet/songwriter. Brilliant american

  • he's a Canadian...but yes...all the great Canadian songwriters seem to understand and embrace American music .Neil Young ect ect

  • are you being sarcastic? maybe im not catching the sarcasm, its sometimes tough online, but for sure gordon lightfoot isnt amaerican

  • dont get mad

  • Hey no arguing on this song, this is the most beautiful song so it doesnt need any arguments

  • lol not trying to argue, just asking

  • Nope. He's a passionate artistic Canadian

  • This is perhaps his best ballad. What a story teller. The slide show really drives home the song. Well done!

  • love this song!

  • I was aboard a US aircraft carrier when it went through TWO typhonns. NO ONE can imagine what it is like to ride a rollercoaster of water for days. Waves the size of a mountain and troughs as deep as the Grand Canyon. God bless the captain and crew of the Edmund Fitzgerald and all ships at sea in peril.

  • My God this song is still AWESOME...I challenge anyone to surpass this song lyrically!!!!!

  • Ballad of the Edmund Fitzgerald

  • Gordon Lightfoot sings this

  • The Fitz apparently sholed and had hull damage and was taking on water for about 3 hours through her damaged hull. Investigation of the wreck reveals damage to the forward cargo hatch covers, and if hit by the 2 or 3 35-40-foot plus waves that hit the Arthur M. Anderson that was about 10-miles aft of the Fitz these waves, the Three Sisters of lake legend, would have swamped the already damaged and listing Fitz. These wave were seen on the Andersen's radar heading toward the location of the Fitz.

  • How terrifying. They must have been so scared..

  • It's a great song, but I don't understand why the Edmund Fitzgerald stands out so much among shipwrecks, can someone fill me in please?

  • it was so special because it was one of the biggest frieghters in all of the great lakes at the time. so it was the biggest frieghters that sunk at the time

  • all 29 crews died in the storm.

  • no one knows what made Edmund Fitzgerald to sink

    or how is it possible to lose a a huge ship in a middle of a great lakes

  • 600feet deep lake.. big swell backing wind..rear hatch open..construction flaw in bulkhead midships..broke like a straw..been good to know ya..

  • I was reading a book on the Fitzgerald and apperantly it got hit by a three sisters wave. It's when three enormous waves in a row come at you. It says that the three waves came on the side of the ship and split her in two.

  • idk but i love the song

  • Beautifully done. Poetic. Very moving. Rest in peace to the Crew of the Fitzgerald and may your souls live on.

  • never forgotten...

  • When you play this song while sailing on Superior there is a eerie feeling that fall upons you

  • Rest In Peace brave sailors.

  • May the Waters of Superior Never Forget her Dead!!!!!!!! RIP to the Crew of the Fitzgerald and may your souls live on.

  • moving... very well done !

  • marry x-mas and RIP

  • very good song... love it.. RIP 29 sailors

  • Love this song RIP FOR ALL OF THOSE 29 SAILORS

  • May the Hand of God touch and comfort the families of these brave 29 people always. Rest in peace Brave Sailors.

  • This song has some ghostly feel when you listen to it, almost like the dead are coming back to talk to you. What a great song.

  • This is certainly a Cool Ballad, & this is a Cool tribute; it's just too bad that it centers around a total Tragedy!! Live on Big Fitz. in Your watery Grave...And My condolences for all the Crew (and Family Members) of Big Fitz.

  • dude my favorite song to listen to when im hi off my ass

  • Thank you for posting this video

  • Come on no hate comments for this memorial song

  • yup, I was listening to this song when I was young. He was big and beautiful (ship)

  • that's what she said;D. No, that was innapropriate

  • didn't even know there was something called the edmund fitzgerald

  • hand over your heart, stand for a moment of silence and respect the fallen sailors....then say FUCK YAH THIS SONG ROCKS!!!!

  • I actually had the 45,hahaha,cool...PEACE

  • I never tire of this song, and it always reminds me how unpredictable Lake Erie is. I have always wanted to see Gordon Lightfoot, but never have had the chance.If anyone gets to see the historical items in Vermillion please go and see them, it's a great tribute to the men that died on the Edmund.

  • It's not Erie. It's Superior.

  • This reminds me of my home (Michigan) :(

  • "Does any one know where the love of God goes

    When the waves turn the minutes to hours?"

    Wow, that's just incredible.

  • Yes, I was just thinking the same thing. Breath taking lyrics. This man is something else - what talent and inspiration.

  • my uncle was on that boat

  • So sorry, does this song bring any closure?

  • Why would you complain?

  • I asked a question about a play in remembrance of the people who died and you have to be an asshole. I won't insult you because I won't be dragged down past this level you illiterate little asshole.

  • I don't see how a question means I want to argue about your experience.

  • Don't worry Tubey69, he's an 8th grade cum rag who doesn't appreciate the magnitude and scope of either this song or the event it memorializes. So forget him and his fellow teenage angsty friends. Perhaps if they had ever known true hardship like this, they might appreciate it more. So to hell with him.

  • Oh Shut up Why dont you people mind your own Business

  • You started it when you went hating on a play about 29 people that died. You thought me asking a question was a debate and then you insulted more people. Get nice then come back.

  • Haha.. I Wasnt hating Its called being annoyed its my 2nd time doing the play so shut up like you know what im saying. Gawsh.

  • Sorry but after I ask a question and you respond like an ass how should I have responded? I never said I knew what you were saying but it sounded like you were being a young ass wipe.

  • Maybe I was But you shouldnt of responded to my comment. i can be annoyed all i want. so buzz off. By the way you dont know my age. so sdfu

  • You said you're in 8th so 13/14/15? And nice grammar. Besides, freedom of speech. It is the internet after all.

  • I Dontt care .? Everytime i post a comment on some video someone has to reply to it.! No Duh its internet

  • Alright English flunky I'll stop replying to your comments. And its the internet so I have freedom of speech which overrules you telling me to shut "d" fuck up.

  • Your Saying english are spanish? Are you calling me british? You Make sence what so ever. Yh So Do i. So Stop childish games.

  • I'm talking about the English language, that thing you're typing in...

  • Let me correct that sentence. *You Make NO sence what so ever. And Yh I HAVE Freedom speech too. And Your Saying your not english are you spanish asian? Seriously can you try to sence

  • I'm an American and by English flunky I mean your grammar is horrible. Ya know? English/grammar/language class...

  • Oh. What does that have to do with anything. My grammer is not horrible i'm just missinng words. like your grammer is perfect yeah right.

  • Bad spelling and punctuation. Mine is definitely better.

  • You think your perfect? Im not in school ok. What are you trying to be my teacher. I dont have to type correct at home ill type right at school. dumbass

  • Again with insulting me for no reason. You must be such a nice person when not sitting in front of a screen with anonymity. And no, I'm not perfect. No one is.

  • Are you kidding me. your acting like the innocent one i hate people like that. Your acting like your perfect "Bad spelling and punctuation. Mine is definitely better."

    You love to make people feel bad about there self? Your sad

  • You are the one insulting me. I am stating a fact that Spell Check or an old person can notice.

  • I dont need a lecture about "spelling" why does it matter? jeez. My spelling isnt right all the time, Dont hate.

  • I'm not hating, just applying education. And spelling matters because a mistake can give the wrong person the wrong thing.

  • Unfortunately im learning new things already and i am not in school. Really how so?

  • Wrong street names bring deliveries to the wrong home. How is learning new things unfortunate?

  • You wouldnt understand all you older people never do.

  • You would be surprised to find my age. And if education is bad then you should let a hobo and a well educated doctor perform a surgery and see which has better results.

  • Is that a trick qustion ?

    And i was thinking you were 30 but.. no comment.

  • There was no question. And hell no, I'm in the 8th grade.

  • lol.

    Oh Nvm it wasnt.

  • To tell you the truth i dont beleive your in 8th grade. I think your a liar, My point of view.

  • Then you are an idiot.

  • What the heck. I dont have to beleive your in 8th grade. i think 30 years old.

  • And I know for damn sure I'm in the 8th grade.

  • Well i dont believe that. Of corse your going to fake your grade. alot you do that on here.

  • Why would I say I'm younger than I am? You seem to be younger than you said. Much younger.

  • HaHa Very funny trying to steal my comeback? Well thats a lie im in 8th grade. You 30 year old man

  • It isn't a lie...I think you realize you lost or are just very insecure around other kids.

  • Lost is there supposed to be a prize?

    And i was being sarcastic. I bet you are in 8th grade?

  • Why is that a question? I already said I am. And I mean lost the argument you wanted a few weeks back.

  • I Said i bet i didnt say you where. =/ who cares about losing a stupid argument anyway?

  • You know all these messages will probably be spammed, right?

  • Yeah.. Of corse.

  • who sings this song?, my dad wants to know though

  • shut up you fukin fag

  • Whoaaa chill out napoleon...

  • Napoleon?? Haha Wow You Asshole

  • AHO!

  • WOOOO!

    go canada!

  • sad song

  • My uncle was a mariner for almost 50 yrs. He always said, he'd rather cross the north Atlantic, than sail Superior in the fall.

  • from mariner to mariner the sea is a cruel mistress and only mariners will ever understand that

  • You've put it very well. Unless you are a mariner, you will never understand the power of the ocean. Poseidon is a cruel master. Semper Paratus.

  • Well said, Coastie; Always ready!

  • When suppertime came the old cook came on deck

    Sayin "fella's it's too rough to feed 'ya"

    At 7pm a main hatchway gave in, he said

    "fella's it's been good ta know ya!!"

    God I love that lyric. Damn...

    .. Gordon Lightfoot - one of the best ever...

  • love this song!!

  • One of handful of songs that cause the hair on my arms to rise.

    It is the majesty of grief.

  • Ha. My arm hairs rose, too, just before I read your post.

  • amzing song.

  • One of the most memorable songs ever!  May God have mercy on the sailors of the Great Lakes!

  • Favorite song from the Legend.

  • This song makes me feel so cold. Hurricane force winds with frigid temperatures and freezing rain never sounds good. I live in Florida, when it gets to below 70 degrees, we cover up.

  • I was a cop in N.Ontario. It went to 35 below and daylight was only 4 hours. With the bitter winds off the lakes we smeared a coat of heavy lanolin or vaseline on our faces. I wore 4-5 pairs of my wife's spandex as well as thermals. The car tires would freeze flat on the bottom after sitting awile and would thump thump when you drove off. If a carlock was frozen, you got a man with the fullest bladder to thaw it free and not let the hose nozzle touch anything. It would weld instantly.

  • When it comes to braving tough weather, you guys are the best. I grew up in Wisconsin, so it's easy to ride out winter in florida (for now). The people must be easy on you guys, as I don't know who would go outside to cause trouble in that. I could imagine your biggest problems would be helping people affected by the snow and cold.

  • thi song gives me goosebums.. and it reminds me of my grandpa,.. random but hey... and this is a cool video

  • The lakes are one of the nastiest places on earth for weather... it can blow and build in a matter of hours..

  • i love this song my heart feels for all of the sailors

  • Great job on the video, and a great song! Gordon Lightfoot really nailed the essence of this tragedy with this song.

    <