@LadyGriffinix i wish everyone had the balls to be as honest as Amanda when sings or dose anything...... than again lost of people dont know honesty. it is a lost art in this reality TV world we live....
She has a very deep and expressive voice and everyone could understand it after getting a bit used to it, and then the lyrics of this song are awesome.
some of my friend dont like amandas voice because its so rough and they think its weird. but i dont think that all. she sings with such a emotion and intensity. thats what makes a brilliant singer. i think she has a beautiful voice.
Also, I was at that show! Whoo! It was really great, and the meet and greet afterwards was laid back, despite a crushing crowd. These two are fabulous people to talk to, really friendly.
I'd just like to comment that YouTube needs to be more positive. It seems to me that 3/4 of comments on any given video are like junior high school bad-mouthing contests, and I don't see the point. If you don't like a band, don't go out of your way to find their videos and be an asshole in the comments. Grow up a little. Thank you.
That's deliberate. Amanda's choral director... or someone of the sort, was orchestrating the school musical... and Amanda, I suppose, was singing on stage during a dress rehearsal, and the director stopped the music, stopped everything, and stormed down the auditorium shouting, "AMANDA! YOU CAN'T SING!" That's why I believe this line is in there - it makes sense.
who the fuck are you talking about "they" what the fuck??? maybe i do sing coz i can and teachers dont tell me not to!!
amanda can sing...but i can totally understand a teacher telling her to shut the fuck up if she was singing for a school musical...it doesnt work. it just doesnt work.
Oh, please just shut the hell up. If all you ever do is listen to what your teachers tell you then you're going to have one fucking boring life, but just because your life is boring, dosn't mean this FAMOUS band has to listen to what some bitch teacher says.
i saw met them last year at the southside festival in germany. after their performance they were just standing around next to the stage a bit out of sight signing some shirts etc, and you could easily have a chat with them. really cool and down to earth these two!! n1
haha, i love how she says "you motherfuckers will sing some day" the first time, and someone's like "YEAH!"
hehe =)
i love this band. and this song. and everything about them. Amanda Palmer & Brian Viglione are freaking awesome. I would totally freak if i saw them one day.
if you want your eyebrows like amanda's, go for it! i did twice, once cos i felt like it for a few months and then for the release of yes, virginia..., just for a few weeks.
rofl the best part is a lot of kids i know were like "oh yeah, i think i'll do it too" and had no idea who amanda is.
The good thing about Amanda is that she doesn't need audio-enhancing tools like some of the bands do when they're making an album but suck singing live (Hawthorne Heights and Paris Hilton for example).
thank you sooo much!! i was at both performances last night and got some videos from the Backrow show, but i forgot that my camra doesn't have sound, lol.
It's just FUCKING! FUCKING! is no big deal! let her say itt!!
dyeyourhairblue 9 months ago 2
God I love Amanda Palmer.
dansemacarbe1 1 year ago 3
I don't see why people dislike her voice. I wish MY voice sounded like hers.
LadyGriffinix 2 years ago 6
@LadyGriffinix i wish everyone had the balls to be as honest as Amanda when sings or dose anything...... than again lost of people dont know honesty. it is a lost art in this reality TV world we live....
ThePresiousFuries 1 year ago
I love her voice , It's kinda rough :/ I wish she didn't do that to her eyebrows though :(
MrAlexDude 2 years ago
we're singing this in our choir, its so beautiful, especially when top sopranos sing "Ahh, ah ah ahh..." its wow!
lilmagicfingers 2 years ago 5
i like the "WOAH!" just after "you motherfuckers you'll sing someday"
lanesousacid 2 years ago
She has a very deep and expressive voice and everyone could understand it after getting a bit used to it, and then the lyrics of this song are awesome.
PoetessOfTragedies 2 years ago 4
some of my friend dont like amandas voice because its so rough and they think its weird. but i dont think that all. she sings with such a emotion and intensity. thats what makes a brilliant singer. i think she has a beautiful voice.
MissCullenxx 2 years ago 3
i agree my girlfreind doesnt like her voice i think its amazing and has alot more character then half the women singers these days
vicklikevick 2 years ago
The world needs more bands like this. They are pure genius. Such beautiful music.
GitarStu 2 years ago 16
I love this song. God, these two are so fucking talented! Love them! <3
MuSiClUvErS1411 2 years ago 2
AMAZING! I love them so fucking much.
<333
Riotramsey 3 years ago
They're both so fucking beautiful.
PunkCabaretFTW 3 years ago 13
You mother fuckers you SING SOMETHINg! LOVE IT!!!!!
madebutante 3 years ago
I just can't stop watching this video. I just wish that I could have seen them in concert. Missed that chance.
libgibby80 3 years ago
same
kleptomessiah 3 years ago
I wish I could have been there too. How good must it have been! So close and personal!
GitarStu 2 years ago
i'm getting goosebumps from this - lovely!
Hyouchuu 3 years ago
Beautiful...
Did anyone else notice how intense the song got towards the end right around "life is no cabaret"? Even the flippin camera was shaking.
Great job, guys.
You're forever my heros.
LittleMissLovett 3 years ago
i love her voice and her gorgeous eyes!
jamjamyuyu 3 years ago
the most beautifule song ever sung im going to go see them in May in Arizona im counting the days...............
BillysEvilCuzan 3 years ago
Beautiful!
LVB1770 3 years ago
This song makes me feel so much better when I sing it and put my heart in it... this song is beautiful.
lollipopoman 4 years ago
simply awesome band
disarmin 4 years ago
I was there!
Femelle 4 years ago
:-D
MlekoKofolaCaj 3 years ago
Love them!
lien0moonen 4 years ago
absolutely wonderful. this is my favorite song. amanda and brian and fucking amazing.... JUST SING!!
singfortheuniverse 4 years ago
mmmm...
still need to see them live. must see them live. sigh.
xfeverdreamsx 4 years ago
I love her..
Danielaway 4 years ago
That was soooo awesome i love that song... sing for the teachers that told you that you couldn't sing.<-- i love that line!
OutTonight84 4 years ago
I wish I would have been there. Shows like that never happen here.
locomodic 4 years ago
Haha. That fucking Who shirt..
CherubHands 4 years ago
I love these guys ^_^
OMFGitsDAN 4 years ago
fantastic. i can not wait i am seeing them in six days for the third time.
deardiary56789 4 years ago
Also, I was at that show! Whoo! It was really great, and the meet and greet afterwards was laid back, despite a crushing crowd. These two are fabulous people to talk to, really friendly.
Nrrti 4 years ago
I'd just like to comment that YouTube needs to be more positive. It seems to me that 3/4 of comments on any given video are like junior high school bad-mouthing contests, and I don't see the point. If you don't like a band, don't go out of your way to find their videos and be an asshole in the comments. Grow up a little. Thank you.
Nrrti 4 years ago 4
I love The Dresden Dolls!!!=)
PunkNeko19 4 years ago
this is so great! thx!!!
mirdoch2egal 4 years ago
there is this thing............
ziamac 4 years ago
She has such an amazing voice! Seriously.
Macobe2 4 years ago
wow. just wow. they are amazing. this song is amazing. FUCK YEAH the Dresden Dolls kick ass!
xfeverdreamsx 5 years ago
love it!
the sentence " sing for the teatcher that told that you couldn't sing" erminds me that a teacher told me so, and now i am in a band :)))
salmazen 5 years ago
That's deliberate. Amanda's choral director... or someone of the sort, was orchestrating the school musical... and Amanda, I suppose, was singing on stage during a dress rehearsal, and the director stopped the music, stopped everything, and stormed down the auditorium shouting, "AMANDA! YOU CAN'T SING!" That's why I believe this line is in there - it makes sense.
lavimdida 4 years ago
hmmmm listen to your teacher...maybe being a rebel isnt always the best thing
gavwoodhouse 4 years ago
They're not being rebels, they're just fucking singing. Maybe if you weren't such a stuck up, jealous, chicken ass conservative you would sing too.
whackowitch 4 years ago
"they're not being rebels" ????
who the fuck are you talking about "they" what the fuck??? maybe i do sing coz i can and teachers dont tell me not to!!
amanda can sing...but i can totally understand a teacher telling her to shut the fuck up if she was singing for a school musical...it doesnt work. it just doesnt work.
fuck off
gavwoodhouse 4 years ago
You must be retarded, I'm sorry.
fanfuckingtastic. I love it.
smellslikechildren1 4 years ago
Oh, please just shut the hell up. If all you ever do is listen to what your teachers tell you then you're going to have one fucking boring life, but just because your life is boring, dosn't mean this FAMOUS band has to listen to what some bitch teacher says.
smellslikechildren1 3 years ago 2
amazing.
clamoopsa 5 years ago
fuck YES! is there a better band in the world? - no!
disarmin 5 years ago
They are just plain awesome!!! You Mother Fuckers will sing one day!!!!
pergaperga 5 years ago
i saw met them last year at the southside festival in germany. after their performance they were just standing around next to the stage a bit out of sight signing some shirts etc, and you could easily have a chat with them. really cool and down to earth these two!! n1
1mose3 5 years ago
haha, i love how she says "you motherfuckers will sing some day" the first time, and someone's like "YEAH!"
hehe =)
i love this band. and this song. and everything about them. Amanda Palmer & Brian Viglione are freaking awesome. I would totally freak if i saw them one day.
i want my eyebrows like amanda's =)))
NotSoShazia 5 years ago
if you want your eyebrows like amanda's, go for it! i did twice, once cos i felt like it for a few months and then for the release of yes, virginia..., just for a few weeks.
rofl the best part is a lot of kids i know were like "oh yeah, i think i'll do it too" and had no idea who amanda is.
sheep amuse me.
copacetic27 5 years ago
If the kids who did their eyebrows like you are sheep, and you do your eyebrows like Amanda, doesn't that make you a sheep too?
porcupinekillas 4 years ago
doesn't that make you a sheep also?
porcupinekillas 4 years ago
I love how people hate "sheep"... like anything people do hasn't been done before.
latenitetippin 3 years ago
she is so gorgeous
i love this song!
i don't get why so many people didn't like it
its the truth
runningforamsterdam 5 years ago
the part where they all joined in gave me goosebumps<3
ihadsexwithyourmama 5 years ago 2
Flippin AMAZING.....I LOVE this band!!!!
pmcv 5 years ago
The good thing about Amanda is that she doesn't need audio-enhancing tools like some of the bands do when they're making an album but suck singing live (Hawthorne Heights and Paris Hilton for example).
MisterNarnia 5 years ago
thank you sooo much!! i was at both performances last night and got some videos from the Backrow show, but i forgot that my camra doesn't have sound, lol.
popped 5 years ago