Added: 3 years ago
From: joydivisionrule
Views: 11,232
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (19)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • in you,..,............

    

  • domani sono 46...non credevo di arrivarci....nonostante tutto la fine e' solo rinviata...arrivederci Ian , Luca, Enny, Corrado, Lilly, e tutti voi che non ce l'avete fatta...

  • Listened to all the great power trios; rush cream etc...(know joy division is not really a 3 piece) and hooky, stephen and barney are up there with the best; they created some of the greatest music of the 20th century.

    IAN 's lyrics are universal and personal, in one simple sentence, that is equally devastatingly profound,uplifting, esoteric and understood.

    Simply.... there is no other poetry like it in the rock world.

    up there with the beatles stones and other recognized greats.

  • A legacy so far removed, one day will be improved...

  • hipster crap, i think people only like this band because the singer died very young which gave the band that dark, mysterious hype.

  • @thundertower its not crap but you might have a point about peoples morbid curiosity

  • @thedraizetrain

    im just trolling i like the band, i like that old song of theirs 'digital'

  • @thundertower i'm afraid not, we genuinely like the music and the band for many reasons, i'm no hipster. i wish he hadn't topped himself and gone on to make more music with the rest of the band

  • When I listen to The Idiot by Iggy Pop I'm overwhelmed by Ian's death =(

  • instant classic

  • JD were a live band first and foremost, in my opinion. They always sound better thrashing their tunes on a stage. That's not to take *anything* away from the studio work, of course.

  • @ProjectFlashlight612

    strange you say that, I was beginnning to think they were overproduced, but it was prob due to the quailty of what was recording them, this les baines douche stuff is top notch

  • i can't believe how much Jd sounds like a modern band even after 30 years

  • Can't agree more

  • Am I the only one who thinks Ian sounds like Iggy Pop in this version? Thanks for posting this!!!!!

  • No, you're not! He really does sound like Iggy Pop sometimes.

  • @Popdivision he does. curtis was an iggy fan so it's not surprising

  • I´m a great Curefan, but i lay down my hat for Joy Division...thx for uploading!

  • the cure are cool my fav song is burn, its such a great song i 1st heard it from the crow thank you

  • thanx i know yeah, ian is a genius , im uploading some more live songs from les bains maybe digital and shadowplay do you have any fave songs.

  • Great song, and it HAS to be listened to live. I really can't stand the studio version of this (on Closer) as all its energy and passion is missing. But on live versions such as this, the band deliver the song with such power and fury, it shakes me up.

    It makes me wonder, who is Ian referring to? This person who he "put his trust in" and who has obviously let him down and destroyed his trust? Is he on about Deborah, or Annik? Or perhaps his idea of God? Such a terribly sad, resigned song.

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more