This song makes your really want to forgive others more because if God can forgive us for major things then why shouldn't we forgive others for small things. Grudges aren't worth it in the end.
In the summer of 2010 I lost my son. I had him stillborn @ 24 weeks exactly and I felt that God felt I wasn't worthy enough for him @ that time. During my complications I came across this song and it spoke volumes to my heart and I just broke down. Its been my favorite song since then, and it continues to take me back to that very time and my life and its a bittersweet feeling.
i'm not perfect but i'm trying when you needed me there's a few times i did not come running i'm not perfect but i'm working when you wanted more i would give you less and lord i'm sorry man this song touches me everytime i listen to it
FORGIVE ME LORD,I'LL GET BETTER.WHEN YOU WANTED MORE,I'D GIVE YOU LESS&LORD I'M SORRY.I<3 <3 <3,U JESUS&THANK U,FOR ALLOWING&BLESSING MR.J.MOSS FOR,THIS SONG!!!
God reaches down into the uttermost parts of the earth, and it goes the same for the heart of a person, in other words God reaches down into depths of one's heart & soul. He's so amazing, because he gives us just what we need, and this song was just what I needed at the time I heard it.
ATTENTION GOSPEL WORLD!! take a good look at the future of gospel music...(Darius Demetrice and Jayden) and also (Tiara Takyla and Trinity) encourage them while their young yall!! LEAVE COMMENTS OF ENCOURAGEMENT!! show em some love everybody!! :)
Jesus Comforts His Disciples 1 “Do not let your hearts be troubled. You believe in God[a]; believe also in me. 2 My Father’s house has many rooms; if that were not so, would I have told you that I am going there to prepare a place for you? 3 And if I go and prepare a place for you, I will come back and take you to be with me that you also may be where I am. 4 You know the way to the place where I am going.”
"When you wanted more I would give you less and LORD I'm sorry"......I LOVE THIS SONG and Anthony Hamilton just put the ICING on the cake. Thanks for posting!
This is the cry for all of humanity. When we were needed there was a few times we did not come running; and I know that when God ask for more we at times give Him less! Thanks J and Anthony for interceding for all of us.
if you're looking for something Fresh, check out Tye Tribbett's new album. it's got a really cool sound to it. he also has a really great story to his inspiration for the album title. youtube.com/watch?v=8UY-QPbb2kg
"Anybody ever been here...I'll be the first to admit I'm neglecting the relationship...Forgive me, I'll get better...I'm working...getting close...!" Amen.
Each time I stumble, I never fall because he is carrying me. Sometimes, I take advantage of your grace and mercy. I take off your robe of righteousness and pursue my own wants and desires. Thank you for never leaving me..protecting me and loving me through my trials and tribulations. Thank you for your mercy..thank your for restoration. Thank you for the smile and your loving arms that greeted me when I came running back home to you Lord. I LOVE YOU LORD WITH ALL THAT I AM!!!
as u listen to every word, u really realise u havent been there all d time for the Lord, cos after all u re not perfect. but then who is? it makes me understand and forgive others better, especially my husband.
♪~When u needed me there's a few times i did not come running!~I'm not perfect but i'm working~When u wanted more i would give u less&LORD i'm sorry!~♪~one of my faves♥
Very nice To the ears, soul, mind, body & the spirit. God works in mysterious ways. He doesn't hide all that He has in store for us. If you don't ask, you'll never receive. Priase is what I do. It's time people. Look at all the devastation that is going around in the world. It's affecting us all in one way or the other. If it hasn't, it will. Praises & blessings to all the people.
Love this song already. God knows we Christians and Non-Christians are not perfect. But, we are striving 4 perfection. Trying to live a better life like i'm trying to do.
wat have i done to recieve patience, kindness, and forgivness from god?
he sent his son to die for us and what do we do? cuss, lie, cheat, and steal and despite of who we are he still luvs us it sometimes brings me to tears
he sounds likee usher on this. i love this song its soo good and it speaks to everyonee, and tells you that no matterr how good you think you are. your not perfect. amenn ((:
This is one song that really speaks for me. Just when I thought I couldn't find the right words to say J Moss found them for me. This is an awesome song.
josiah3+1 I think JMoss and Anthony Hamilton did i beautiful job on a wonderful song. This song not only speaks to your heart it speaks to your soul. I Love It I Love It I Love It and I Love yall
amen this video,speaks to the truth.but the things that i dont understand is why do artistest feel like they have to confirm the things of this world to themselves.instead of abiding by GOds ways.
so is Anthony Hamilton a believer in Jesus or did he just want to jump on another track? I would love for him to use his gift full time for the reason he has it in the first place, to glorify God. Someone let me know please. Blessings
@FollowHim2Lyfe i dont know if anyone answered this for you yet but he originated from gospel then jumped into the RnB scene! so he does both but he definately glorifies god! i been a huge fan of him since always. just informing you! hope i helped
thats how i feel when GOD wanted more from me igave him less.When he blessed me seem like i'm not giving him like i should and what he deserves.Sorry LORD,forgive me Lord.
I listen to this at least once a day. It reminds me that I am not perfect though people continue to tell me I think I am. I know I am not and the only judge I need is God. He knows I don't mean to go about my day and not speak to him; though lately I call out to him and thank him more and more daily. I love him more than he knows, and he is God!
i love this song live and studio!!! This song speaks DIRECTLY to me!!! Lord, im trying, Im working, getting closer the more I know YOU!!! Im better than I was on yesterday!
Linda Cramb What music is this cum that only sound good but the Grim
Nasciblack21 2 days ago
j moss is the real deal
youngbowe100 2 days ago
i love this song...
TheRyanj1987 1 week ago
love this song
Sexymami245 1 week ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Luv this song
unclechiefou 1 week ago
This song got me through alot in my life.. God is good
tomboi3 2 weeks ago
Indeed!
MenOfHonor2011 2 weeks ago
i love , love this song!
MsAnointed777 2 weeks ago
This song is awsome!
it shows me that i can do better even i dont feel like it!!
StephenShowtown23 3 weeks ago 2
J moss is a bad man, I like all his songs and he knows who to put in his songs to make them stand out.
brownie2000lsh 1 month ago
Awesome song!
worsleyf 1 month ago
STILL LOVE THIS......SANG SANG ANTHONY HAMILTON.........YES!
ada627 1 month ago
Oldie but goodie!!
mturner81 1 month ago
This song makes your really want to forgive others more because if God can forgive us for major things then why shouldn't we forgive others for small things. Grudges aren't worth it in the end.
TheBeautifulladii 1 month ago
When i wanted more i would give u less LORD IM SORRY, true stuff right there
jasmine9378 1 month ago
In the summer of 2010 I lost my son. I had him stillborn @ 24 weeks exactly and I felt that God felt I wasn't worthy enough for him @ that time. During my complications I came across this song and it spoke volumes to my heart and I just broke down. Its been my favorite song since then, and it continues to take me back to that very time and my life and its a bittersweet feeling.
Reebaybeh86 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Im not perfect
MrBigdaddynic 2 months ago
i'm not perfect but i'm trying when you needed me there's a few times i did not come running i'm not perfect but i'm working when you wanted more i would give you less and lord i'm sorry man this song touches me everytime i listen to it
mk4167 2 months ago
im feelin this song... LORD forgive me.. Im not perfect please forgive me... give me another chance Im working on it :D)
trunatural1974 2 months ago
this song makes me cry
stepdaddy200 2 months ago
this sog makes me cry
stepdaddy200 2 months ago
J Moss always has a song that expresses exactly how I am feeling. I love this guy! he is my favorite artist.
LoveHappiness1521 2 months ago
My fav. gospel song <3
SDbaddasx 3 months ago
my theme sonq all the way
travisee2010 3 months ago
FORGIVE ME LORD,I'LL GET BETTER.WHEN YOU WANTED MORE,I'D GIVE YOU LESS&LORD I'M SORRY.I<3 <3 <3,U JESUS&THANK U,FOR ALLOWING&BLESSING MR.J.MOSS FOR,THIS SONG!!!
AhluvmesumHyM76 3 months ago
I know everyone has a right to have their own opinion, but how could you dislike this song???
amcmilette88 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I'm not perfect, but I'm tryin
1Dgriff 3 months ago
COGIC preaching Duilio brazil
MegaCogic 3 months ago in playlist j moss
FORGIVE ME LORD FOR MY SHORT COMINGS! I LOVE THIS SONG ! THANK YOU LORD FOR ANOTHER CHANCE.
cinnagee 1 year ago 2
I must say that I personally love this song! It speaks volumes! I am a perfect inprefect being but in God's eyes I am perfect!
tiffielovespink 1 year ago
love this song
DatCaribbeanQueen 1 year ago
God reaches down into the uttermost parts of the earth, and it goes the same for the heart of a person, in other words God reaches down into depths of one's heart & soul. He's so amazing, because he gives us just what we need, and this song was just what I needed at the time I heard it.
pepdogg513 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
ATTENTION GOSPEL WORLD!! take a good look at the future of gospel music...(Darius Demetrice and Jayden) and also (Tiara Takyla and Trinity) encourage them while their young yall!! LEAVE COMMENTS OF ENCOURAGEMENT!! show em some love everybody!! :)
wphilosopher1 1 year ago
this song is AMAZINGGGG!
endlesslovex811 1 year ago
love this song man !!
rleslie129 1 year ago
Its funny this song got added to my itunes by accident but yet its one of the most IMPORTANT songs i have in my music collection!!!
docbaddoc 1 year ago 2
This is me....I'm Not Perfect! But I'm working!
karmeldesire 1 year ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
John 14
Jesus Comforts His Disciples 1 “Do not let your hearts be troubled. You believe in God[a]; believe also in me. 2 My Father’s house has many rooms; if that were not so, would I have told you that I am going there to prepare a place for you? 3 And if I go and prepare a place for you, I will come back and take you to be with me that you also may be where I am. 4 You know the way to the place where I am going.”
PreachersOfChrist 1 year ago
MY joint. I had the young boys at church do a dance to this, it was tight.....
civman17 1 year ago
"When you wanted more I would give you less and LORD I'm sorry"......I LOVE THIS SONG and Anthony Hamilton just put the ICING on the cake. Thanks for posting!
mssquirrely 1 year ago 19
These lyrics are so true.
cuzimgd 1 year ago
all i can do is try and this song helps me when i began to fall short
nbattle1000 1 year ago 2
why would 9 ppl dislike this? SMH...
Denninasouras 1 year ago 13
@Denninasouras it's 10 now :(
MsDolphin101 3 months ago
This is the cry for all of humanity. When we were needed there was a few times we did not come running; and I know that when God ask for more we at times give Him less! Thanks J and Anthony for interceding for all of us.
bezaleel2009 1 year ago 6
this song is amazin' love it where do singerz cum up wit dis stuff :) very impressed!
MsMercy09 1 year ago 3
@MsMercy09 God! Divine creativity!
PrincessSaffie 1 year ago
this def me..rite now thts where i am.i heard this song a few yrs.ago and it helped me then i hope it help me now.
tyleraniyah 1 year ago
real beautiful song sumthn good to play and listen to in the car
nyniggagettinmoney 1 year ago
This songs speaks to my heart, and soul! Im not perfect...but im working!
ummmreese 1 year ago
this is me!!
tyleraniyah 1 year ago
if you're looking for something Fresh, check out Tye Tribbett's new album. it's got a really cool sound to it. he also has a really great story to his inspiration for the album title. youtube.com/watch?v=8UY-QPbb2kg
thisbcatastrophe 1 year ago
this is one of my favorites also.
eulajohnlouis 1 year ago 2
When you wanted more, I will give you less. Lord I'm sorry! Thats deep!
Toogood2007 1 year ago
wen u wanted more i wud giv u less and Lord im sorry.....my fav
kikinicole324 1 year ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
IM NOT PERFECT LORD!
whoisjo1 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
IM NOT PERFECT LORD!
whoisjo1 1 year ago
I know I need to treat woman better... forgive me lord
wufdog1 1 year ago
i just heard this song on my tv. i luv it!
jesusluva1296 1 year ago
I just started to devote my life to god and I need more inspirational songs like this XD god bless to those who approve of this wonderful masterpiece
Blackninja305 1 year ago 4
love this song
lmtkisha 1 year ago
this is like the bomb
demika456 1 year ago
I love the lyrics to this song....its so true.
MsSongbird32 1 year ago
This my JAm!! :D
KelliColeStudios 1 year ago
i needed to hear this right now!
mack1820 1 year ago
@mack1820 me to!!
nekole2009 1 year ago
i love this song!!!!!
tiesofresh 1 year ago
....
datrillz 1 year ago
love the song
shaneka1976 1 year ago
"Anybody ever been here...I'll be the first to admit I'm neglecting the relationship...Forgive me, I'll get better...I'm working...getting close...!" Amen.
iampsalmbody 1 year ago
I love how anthony just comes out of no where! this beat is too sick! ayyyyyeeeee!!!!
scabooty09 1 year ago 2
love it
boragrayson1997 1 year ago
i love this song,thanks for the post
boragrayson1997 1 year ago
Canção Linda , Poesia perfeita ....
MrOrigio 1 year ago
LAWD HAVE MERCY...I feel this one!!
rlpx4 1 year ago
beautiful and oh so true!
QueenBanded 1 year ago
Forgive me............Lord......On my knees singing thank you for loving me inspite of my faults because I'm not Perfect. Love this joint.
BLACTACULAR 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Have always liked J Moss
Also, check out EG Bradley on youtube singing Dear God. The performance is
AMAZING!!!!!
blessbeyondblessed 1 year ago
I Love This . Off the hook !!!!! A+ !!!
MsSaunders7 1 year ago 2
Each time I stumble, I never fall because he is carrying me. Sometimes, I take advantage of your grace and mercy. I take off your robe of righteousness and pursue my own wants and desires. Thank you for never leaving me..protecting me and loving me through my trials and tribulations. Thank you for your mercy..thank your for restoration. Thank you for the smile and your loving arms that greeted me when I came running back home to you Lord. I LOVE YOU LORD WITH ALL THAT I AM!!!
JaDivalicious 1 year ago 2
yo, this is my jam
nerlande667 1 year ago
LOVE IT!
takaishihikaru 1 year ago
"and you looked beyond my pride inside and blessed me anyway" YES!! Love this song so much!!!
jjay1127 1 year ago
this song is sooo true and speaks directly to me love it
levels365 1 year ago
i luv it 2
refresh311 1 year ago
i love this song
barbie12435 1 year ago
as u listen to every word, u really realise u havent been there all d time for the Lord, cos after all u re not perfect. but then who is? it makes me understand and forgive others better, especially my husband.
obunam 1 year ago
That piano solo was PHAT!!
anointed33 1 year ago
This is whats up i am so betta with GOD i am so trying THANK YOU J MOSS
michelleshaquonti 1 year ago
I'm not perfect but I'm getting close.
Yorubagurl 1 year ago
WHAT A SONG!HE LOVES US EVEN WHEN WE DON'T GIVE HIM OUR BEST.
kenneycar 1 year ago
♪~When u needed me there's a few times i did not come running!~I'm not perfect but i'm working~When u wanted more i would give u less&LORD i'm sorry!~♪~one of my faves♥
iAmANGELSONGZ 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
If you like artists such as Lecrae, Trip Lee and etc, please check out my Jesus Music and tell me what you think...GOD Bless!
Y.A.A.T.S
Yaats4Life87 1 year ago
j Moss just may be the one to help me on my way
Gemni1990 1 year ago
@Gemni1990 his voice does something to me!!!~IT reaches my spirit~i love him♥
iAmANGELSONGZ 1 year ago
Very nice To the ears, soul, mind, body & the spirit. God works in mysterious ways. He doesn't hide all that He has in store for us. If you don't ask, you'll never receive. Priase is what I do. It's time people. Look at all the devastation that is going around in the world. It's affecting us all in one way or the other. If it hasn't, it will. Praises & blessings to all the people.
myhappyness1 1 year ago
IM NOT PERFECT! but HE is!!!
shirekaA10 1 year ago
I Like How He Took His Own Style And ade This Song Because We All Are Not Perfect But We May Get Better Than Yesterday !
msayycee 1 year ago 3
love the words to this song this is me to a" T"....Feeling the conviction!!!!!!
TheSunshine19023 1 year ago
i love this song it explaines everything bout me...
c9ui8te 1 year ago
song is spiritual, anointed and cool!
SolarWaffles 1 year ago
the man can sing, and what hes singing about makes it that much better
kelsonboyer 1 year ago
This is my call back tone! I luv JMoss & A Ham! Yall did this!
voniimommie 1 year ago
My new favorite song!
Kaprecious 1 year ago
Love this song already. God knows we Christians and Non-Christians are not perfect. But, we are striving 4 perfection. Trying to live a better life like i'm trying to do.
tmac8505 1 year ago
So real...I'm not perfect...
lee19641 1 year ago
i love love this song...so true.
lollipop2992 1 year ago
I love this song !!!!
ruthemmanuel777 1 year ago 2
I luv this song, it makes me think
wat have i done to recieve patience, kindness, and forgivness from god?
he sent his son to die for us and what do we do? cuss, lie, cheat, and steal and despite of who we are he still luvs us it sometimes brings me to tears
ikeballer0717 1 year ago 2
I love the clark sisters and you!
Pinkglitterish 1 year ago 2
Smooth - and speakin straight 2 a boy
2june072007 1 year ago
please give me another chance.. ♥♥ that part.
trinigurl45 1 year ago
@trinigurl45
me too
lollipop2992 1 year ago
pa ti kriss (L)`pensando en ti
themrgangsta777 1 year ago
3:28- Jmoss.... oh em gee!!!
tadunn86 1 year ago
he sounds likee usher on this. i love this song its soo good and it speaks to everyonee, and tells you that no matterr how good you think you are. your not perfect. amenn ((:
leanora14 1 year ago 2
This is one song that really speaks for me. Just when I thought I couldn't find the right words to say J Moss found them for me. This is an awesome song.
bmatt1218 1 year ago 26
FORGIVE ME I'LL GET BETTER Love that part so much
cj06feb 1 year ago 40
@cj06feb who you telling, I second that!
Toogood2007 1 year ago
@cj06feb I Love this song!! We Don't care we just enjoy listening to the song. But nice Job putting it togather!!
SuperLaChar 1 year ago
josiah3+1 I think JMoss and Anthony Hamilton did i beautiful job on a wonderful song. This song not only speaks to your heart it speaks to your soul. I Love It I Love It I Love It and I Love yall
lincolnlova318 1 year ago 2
iI LOVE DISS SONG NICE SWEET SONG WIT A LESSON N NICE TUNE N MUSICAL LYRICS 2 IT. THANXXS JMOSS N ANTHONY.
ajhandestiny 1 year ago
amen this video,speaks to the truth.but the things that i dont understand is why do artistest feel like they have to confirm the things of this world to themselves.instead of abiding by GOds ways.
jicart07 1 year ago
THIS IS MY SONG!!!!!!! lol love it lol
lightbright1104 1 year ago
athony hamilton and j moss killed it
rlc91172 1 year ago
Right now, i feel and now that God will always continue to love and care for me.
Thank you Jesus
jasminesmith123 1 year ago
Halelujurrrr lol
SolarWaffles 1 year ago
I luv dis song. Praise the Lord. Halilujah
johnnie1234ful 1 year ago
love this song.........and so it songs so sweet and its so true
shanicevjackson 1 year ago
I love this song!
hayses7 1 year ago
My songgg....i love Anthony Hamilton n this song
spiffyzgrrl07 1 year ago 2
i'm sorry lord, forgive me lord
you know lord i am a saint..
i'm not perfect but i am do better and i work for that,
ILOVEYOULORD YOU THE ONE I LOVE THE MOST!!(l)
XGODBLESS.
ruby222312 1 year ago 3
I love this song ... praise him
captwendell 1 year ago
i need to give good more of my time
18Rocawear 1 year ago
so is Anthony Hamilton a believer in Jesus or did he just want to jump on another track? I would love for him to use his gift full time for the reason he has it in the first place, to glorify God. Someone let me know please. Blessings
FollowHim2Lyfe 1 year ago
@FollowHim2Lyfe i dont know if anyone answered this for you yet but he originated from gospel then jumped into the RnB scene! so he does both but he definately glorifies god! i been a huge fan of him since always. just informing you! hope i helped
ckell15 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
hey there, i live in South Africa. i cant seem to find any of J moss' albums in all our music stores. Any ideas??
MissSuggaBoo 1 year ago
i'm not perfect but i'm trying...work ur work in me..
emmylewisa 1 year ago
hey there, i live in South Africa. i cant seem to find any of J moss' albums in all our music stores. Any ideas??
MissSuggaBoo 1 year ago
@MissSuggaBoo itunes, amazon
FollowHim2Lyfe 1 year ago
@FollowHim2Lyfe Thanks a lot. God bless you.
MissSuggaBoo 1 year ago
@MissSuggaBoo AMAZON OR ITUNES
Hoffler22 1 year ago
Thanks. God bless you
MissSuggaBoo 1 year ago
God Thank you,
thank you for those people bles them more and more and too the people this this listening(L)
ruby222312 1 year ago
i love dis song fo real
franchise514 1 year ago 2
I LOVE that song I sing it all the time!!!!!!!!!
2103fan18 1 year ago
I love this song!
cloudofwitness 2 years ago 2
When you wanted more I gave you less and Lord I'm sorry.
Im not perfect but I'm getting close, the more I get to know you.
THIS IS REAL. I love this song. *tear
sexysweets1084 2 years ago 3
thats how i feel when GOD wanted more from me igave him less.When he blessed me seem like i'm not giving him like i should and what he deserves.Sorry LORD,forgive me Lord.
mattie1950 1 year ago
Beautifull
it's Realy Touching
god bless,
ruby222312 2 years ago
Comment removed
gregoryrobinson31267 2 years ago
please come by and check out my gospel videos, thanks.
kb26benson 2 years ago
everytime i hear this i break out in tears.
gullyboyz05 2 years ago 3
this is my song...i heard it at church during a performance....luv itttt!!!!!
plieswifey24 2 years ago 3
I Absolutely love this song...... Its so true.
SORRY GOD!!!
lexinicky1 2 years ago 3
Yeah...we're not perfect...but this song is excellent!!! Sing brothas!!!!
ladyrob4110 2 years ago
I'm not perfect...I'm better today than I was on yesterday...thank you Lord Jesus that I'm not what I used to be;
I'll tell ya what my professor would tell me: "Pobody's Nerfect!"
Memyai 2 years ago
I LOVE IT
caramel38flash 2 years ago
I heard this song for the first time when I was on my way to up a mens conference in Germany. Its smooth and still reppin God. His mercy is so great!
FollowHim2Lyfe 2 years ago
-I Loue It. <3
briannariecy 2 years ago
i didn't' know gospel is this cool!
ayattiubing 2 years ago 3
I love this song this man is BLESSED
dmasta200184595 2 years ago
Great as Usual and special Treat Anthony Hamilton!! Praise God ALL!!
timelesslyfavored 2 years ago
love the song
labreka88 2 years ago
I listen to this at least once a day. It reminds me that I am not perfect though people continue to tell me I think I am. I know I am not and the only judge I need is God. He knows I don't mean to go about my day and not speak to him; though lately I call out to him and thank him more and more daily. I love him more than he knows, and he is God!
swyeeteyes1 2 years ago 2
this is so great u can hardly tell its gospel
whitdrtythrty 2 years ago
1ST TIME HEARING IT AND I LOVE IT
stephaniegreen2007 2 years ago 3
This is such an amazing song. It has really ministered to me tonight in this season that I'm in.
crsmopc 2 years ago 19
WOW I'M FEELING THIS!!!
sweetallday2 2 years ago 24
Comment removed
nerlande667 1 year ago
linda voz que dios me de tu voz
Romytisati 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I love This Song .
ShaeShae54 2 years ago
I reaallly like this!!
HighlyFavored2009 2 years ago 2
Great song!!!!
laristi2 2 years ago 3
god bless you
stlman365 2 years ago 2
i love dis song
classylady16 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Most Annoying song ever
nocome2 2 years ago
their should be 100+ million views of this song then of some kid biting his little brothers finger.
bryandeezy 2 years ago 2
Oh yes nice groove!!!! I.m not perfect!!
amarvinwinansfan 2 years ago
i love this song live and studio!!! This song speaks DIRECTLY to me!!! Lord, im trying, Im working, getting closer the more I know YOU!!! Im better than I was on yesterday!
eal990 2 years ago 3
love it..
okonkwoobiageli 2 years ago