@Sokra01 The feeling we got now is more the opposite of both anthems...we arent unite, we arent german anymore and we dont raise...we are going under. Our government reaches for international appreciation by granting everything to everyone while ignoring the own ppl.
Germany died long before...this is BRD..not Germany...
"Du bist Deutschland".....nein sind wir nicht.
In Gedenken an das Land meiner Väter...Ruhe in Frieden....
@alternatehistorypt Just to clarify: Kohl was Member of the CDU (the christ-democratic-union party). Speaking about right- and leftwing governments and partys is somewhat problematic in Germany. Thanks to the Nazi Regime and the fact that the german people even today always have to apologize for what their ancestors did, all major partys are talking about the same things. Theres no "left" or "right" anymore - no choice anymore. In Kolhs days, there may have been a difference but that is history.
@DerEchteGangsterFan Hey thanks for telling me what CDU is, but isn´t that what Angela Merkel is CDU?, and they are in with some other parties I cant remember, and thats make the german gov neo-liberals just as in Denmark? :-)
@SuperAcab666 Yes, Merkel is a CDU member. and they are in a coalition with the FDP (Liberals). CDU is not a right wing party as far as i can see it ;-) greetings to denmark
@DerEchteGangsterFan OK thanks for telling me, the only thing I know for sure is that german gov is very EU happy along with France and Great Britain, just like danish gov:-( Greetings to Germany:-)
@SuperAcab666 Chancellor Helmut Kohl was CDU, Christian Democrats, as is Angela Merkel (Germany's current chancellor). In fact, Angela Merkel was the protegé of Kohl when he was chancellor. CDU is a right wing party. Gerhard Schröder, the chancellor after Kohl and before Merkel, was SPD.
@Tarvoc Hey thanks for telling, as you see I´m not that strong in german politics, but I see CDU as a rightwing party too, eventhough they are christian. In Denmark there is a christian party too, and they are rightwing. but not extreme LOL:-)
@SuperAcab666 CDU means Christlich-Demokratische Union, Christian Democratic Union. It is a right-wing party, but more to the middle than the Republicans in the US. The German spectrum of political parties is more left compared to that of the US. For example, Barack Obama, who is considered left-wing in the USA, would be a politician of the political middle in Germany. Germans often compare his political views to those of the Seeheim circle, the right wing of the middle-to-left SPD.
@Tarvoc OK I see:-) but you´re right many try to compare with USA, but US politics is really hard to understand, because both rightwingers and democtrats gave Obama campaign money. The only 2 leftwing parties I know in Germany is SPD and Die Linke. And I dont know if Die Grünen still excist? :-) And rightwing I know CDU and NPD:-P
@SuperAcab666 Die Grünen (Green party) still do exist, and they still play an important role. The NPD is not really important except in some parts of east and south Germany, and it has no seats in the Bundestag. Another important party is the FDP, which was originally left-liberal (ordoliberal as we called it) but has turned into a party of radical market liberals and objectivists until now, so it is still sort of left from the CDU, but right-wing compared to most other relevant parties.
@Tarvoc Yes, because I remember Die Grünen as a leftwing party, and good you say FDP, I forgot those yesterday. In Denmark we have 2 socalled worker´s parties, but they are turned into market fascists just like FDP:-( It´s good NPD have no seats in the Bundestag, but for how long? In Denmark Danish Folk´s Party have grown large and they have strong power in our parliament:-(
@SuperAcab666 As far as I know, the NPD never had any seats in the Bundestag. In Bundestags elections, they usually get about 1 per cent of the voices, far below the 5 per cent they would need. In Germany, extremist right-wing parties are currently less dangerous than the growing right-wing populism in the established parties of the "political middle" themselves. A recent example would be Thilo Sarrazin, an SPD politician who wrote and published a VERY right-wing populist book about immigration.
@Tarvoc OK thats good they dont get popular in the Bundestag:-) Yes that tendency with leftwing middle parties going rightwing is sadly wellknown in Denmark. We have Socialdemocrats(S) and Socialistic Folk´s Party(SF) they are turned so much rightwing over the last 10 years:-( They aren´t worker´s best friend any more if you ask me:-( But there are still 1 party on the left side, and they are still far left:-) No to war and EU LOL:-)
@alternatehistorypt but how exactly? what i know is that Lothar De Mazière and some social democratic politics of the BRD proposed to use auferstanden aus ruinen as the anthem of the reunited germany :)
Auferstanden aus Ruinen is very beautiful but not as an anthem, because it's too much - the same to the Russians. It's a great melody but too much and too powerful and exaggerated for an anthem. The west german anthem is more down-to-earth and more noble, and I still think it's the best anthem in the world.
@Lintflas have you seen the all video and the description box? You could have both mellodies in your anthem... 2 melodies just like South Africa :) it was almost so only Helmut Khol didn't allowed... anyway this is fantasy and not pollitics :) and I respec all oppinions anyway, thank you for watching :)
@alternatehistorypt Yes, I read the description, but if I had to decide which one to choose, I would take the west german anthem, but I agree it would be a wonderful idea to sing both anthems, because both are beautiful. :)
@Lintflas I understand, besides both would be a reconciliation like the South African anthem (to which this video is an answer) :) by the way I visited your channel and subscribed because I liked the music :)
I agree with you: Auferstanden aud Ruinen is a beautiful song about hope for Germany's future. It has hardly anything to do with Communism. It's a shame the Bundeskanzler turned down that idea...
Very very nice. I guess with composers like Wagner and Bach Germany would have to have a great Anthem. It makes my 45% Germanic soul proud. Jim from the USA
@atzel62 I read somewhere that Becher's anthem lyrics originally where intended to the Lied der Deutschen melody, is it true the other way around too ? : ) interesting :)
See my video: Alternate History of the Iberian Peninsula . In that other alt history the Auferstanden aus Ruinen melody (not the lyrics) turn to be the anthem melody of an alternate socialist Portugal instead lol :) (but read the whole description box of that video to understand why :) )
@projectblackthunder
Hehe gut so :)
Wir haben das auch gar nicht nötig !!
Girrovv 3 months ago
The East-anthem was quite worthy to be the anthem of the united germany after 1990. The text is exact the feeling we have now.
Sokra01 4 months ago
@Sokra01 The feeling we got now is more the opposite of both anthems...we arent unite, we arent german anymore and we dont raise...we are going under. Our government reaches for international appreciation by granting everything to everyone while ignoring the own ppl.
Germany died long before...this is BRD..not Germany...
"Du bist Deutschland".....nein sind wir nicht.
In Gedenken an das Land meiner Väter...Ruhe in Frieden....
Rofocael218 3 weeks ago
Fuck you that is not the german anthem, yeah you want always the nazis, im gay yeahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhrosa winkel
Glamstar54 6 months ago
2 people hate music
TheSaboteur97 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
im german and this are both german anthems the last one is from the DDR and the first one is from the BRD
DerMannVomDach33 1 year ago
im german and this are both german anthems the last one is from the DDR and the first one is from the BRD
DerMannVomDach33 1 year ago
@DerMannVomDach33 I know, that why I think they shoud be combined like both musics in the South African anthem :)
alternatehistorypt 1 year ago
@alternatehistorypt I like that idea. though i also wish they do that to the Russian anthem
TVgeinus90sSim 6 months ago
@alternatehistorypt
no!!!!! i´m german i do not want a communist anthem to sing
mrwinning4ever 4 months ago
Die Füsse im Feuer - Balladen und Blues (2003)
1977de33HERBST2010 1 year ago
At first BRD and then DDR what a mix LOL:-)
SuperAcab666 1 year ago
@SuperAcab666 This could have happened but Helmut Khol did not let it.
alternatehistorypt 1 year ago
@alternatehistorypt I dont know much about german politics, but wasn´t Helmut Kohl SPD? Now they have a rightwing gov:-(
SuperAcab666 1 year ago
@SuperAcab666 I´m not sure... but he was just another bastard in my view
alternatehistorypt 1 year ago
@alternatehistorypt LOL:-) maybe you´re right, I cant discuss this subject, because I´m too ignorant on german politics:-( Sorry:-)
SuperAcab666 1 year ago
@alternatehistorypt
Helmut Kohl was in the CDU
KlausAltmannBarbie 1 year ago
@alternatehistorypt Just to clarify: Kohl was Member of the CDU (the christ-democratic-union party). Speaking about right- and leftwing governments and partys is somewhat problematic in Germany. Thanks to the Nazi Regime and the fact that the german people even today always have to apologize for what their ancestors did, all major partys are talking about the same things. Theres no "left" or "right" anymore - no choice anymore. In Kolhs days, there may have been a difference but that is history.
Jix92 1 year ago
@Jix92 thanks for watching anyway :)
alternatehistorypt 1 year ago
@SuperAcab666 CDU is not a right wing goverment, they are christian democrats. The NPD is the right-wing party.
DerEchteGangsterFan 1 year ago
@DerEchteGangsterFan Hey thanks for telling me what CDU is, but isn´t that what Angela Merkel is CDU?, and they are in with some other parties I cant remember, and thats make the german gov neo-liberals just as in Denmark? :-)
Yes NPD is like Danish Folks Party:-(
SuperAcab666 1 year ago
@SuperAcab666 Yes, Merkel is a CDU member. and they are in a coalition with the FDP (Liberals). CDU is not a right wing party as far as i can see it ;-) greetings to denmark
DerEchteGangsterFan 1 year ago
@DerEchteGangsterFan OK thanks for telling me, the only thing I know for sure is that german gov is very EU happy along with France and Great Britain, just like danish gov:-( Greetings to Germany:-)
SuperAcab666 1 year ago
@SuperAcab666 Chancellor Helmut Kohl was CDU, Christian Democrats, as is Angela Merkel (Germany's current chancellor). In fact, Angela Merkel was the protegé of Kohl when he was chancellor. CDU is a right wing party. Gerhard Schröder, the chancellor after Kohl and before Merkel, was SPD.
Tarvoc 1 year ago
@Tarvoc Hey thanks for telling, as you see I´m not that strong in german politics, but I see CDU as a rightwing party too, eventhough they are christian. In Denmark there is a christian party too, and they are rightwing. but not extreme LOL:-)
SuperAcab666 1 year ago
@SuperAcab666 CDU means Christlich-Demokratische Union, Christian Democratic Union. It is a right-wing party, but more to the middle than the Republicans in the US. The German spectrum of political parties is more left compared to that of the US. For example, Barack Obama, who is considered left-wing in the USA, would be a politician of the political middle in Germany. Germans often compare his political views to those of the Seeheim circle, the right wing of the middle-to-left SPD.
Tarvoc 1 year ago
@Tarvoc OK I see:-) but you´re right many try to compare with USA, but US politics is really hard to understand, because both rightwingers and democtrats gave Obama campaign money. The only 2 leftwing parties I know in Germany is SPD and Die Linke. And I dont know if Die Grünen still excist? :-) And rightwing I know CDU and NPD:-P
SuperAcab666 1 year ago
@SuperAcab666 Die Grünen (Green party) still do exist, and they still play an important role. The NPD is not really important except in some parts of east and south Germany, and it has no seats in the Bundestag. Another important party is the FDP, which was originally left-liberal (ordoliberal as we called it) but has turned into a party of radical market liberals and objectivists until now, so it is still sort of left from the CDU, but right-wing compared to most other relevant parties.
Tarvoc 1 year ago
@Tarvoc Yes, because I remember Die Grünen as a leftwing party, and good you say FDP, I forgot those yesterday. In Denmark we have 2 socalled worker´s parties, but they are turned into market fascists just like FDP:-( It´s good NPD have no seats in the Bundestag, but for how long? In Denmark Danish Folk´s Party have grown large and they have strong power in our parliament:-(
SuperAcab666 1 year ago
@SuperAcab666 As far as I know, the NPD never had any seats in the Bundestag. In Bundestags elections, they usually get about 1 per cent of the voices, far below the 5 per cent they would need. In Germany, extremist right-wing parties are currently less dangerous than the growing right-wing populism in the established parties of the "political middle" themselves. A recent example would be Thilo Sarrazin, an SPD politician who wrote and published a VERY right-wing populist book about immigration.
Tarvoc 1 year ago
@Tarvoc OK thats good they dont get popular in the Bundestag:-) Yes that tendency with leftwing middle parties going rightwing is sadly wellknown in Denmark. We have Socialdemocrats(S) and Socialistic Folk´s Party(SF) they are turned so much rightwing over the last 10 years:-( They aren´t worker´s best friend any more if you ask me:-( But there are still 1 party on the left side, and they are still far left:-) No to war and EU LOL:-)
SuperAcab666 1 year ago
@alternatehistorypt but how exactly? what i know is that Lothar De Mazière and some social democratic politics of the BRD proposed to use auferstanden aus ruinen as the anthem of the reunited germany :)
breizhcatalonia1993 1 year ago
@breizhcatalonia1993 it's true see on wikipedia... if not for Kohl this might be true ...
alternatehistorypt 1 year ago
@breizhcatalonia1993 see the description box of this video :)
alternatehistorypt 1 year ago
Auferstanden aus Ruinen is very beautiful but not as an anthem, because it's too much - the same to the Russians. It's a great melody but too much and too powerful and exaggerated for an anthem. The west german anthem is more down-to-earth and more noble, and I still think it's the best anthem in the world.
Lintflas 1 year ago
@Lintflas have you seen the all video and the description box? You could have both mellodies in your anthem... 2 melodies just like South Africa :) it was almost so only Helmut Khol didn't allowed... anyway this is fantasy and not pollitics :) and I respec all oppinions anyway, thank you for watching :)
alternatehistorypt 1 year ago
@alternatehistorypt Yes, I read the description, but if I had to decide which one to choose, I would take the west german anthem, but I agree it would be a wonderful idea to sing both anthems, because both are beautiful. :)
Lintflas 1 year ago
@Lintflas I understand, besides both would be a reconciliation like the South African anthem (to which this video is an answer) :) by the way I visited your channel and subscribed because I liked the music :)
alternatehistorypt 1 year ago
I agree with you: Auferstanden aud Ruinen is a beautiful song about hope for Germany's future. It has hardly anything to do with Communism. It's a shame the Bundeskanzler turned down that idea...
Bismarck11139 1 year ago
@Bismarck11139 I agree with you, thank you for watching :)
alternatehistorypt 1 year ago
Very very nice. I guess with composers like Wagner and Bach Germany would have to have a great Anthem. It makes my 45% Germanic soul proud. Jim from the USA
JamesEStephenson 1 year ago
@JamesEStephenson thank you for watching and commenting :) consider to see my channel and my other videos too :)
alternatehistorypt 1 year ago
i like my anthem now, this version is coorler but the there are cooler German anthems like
Die Wacht am Rhein, Was ist des deutschen Vaterland or the Prinz Eugen Lied
RESTAURIERTdasDKR 2 years ago
@RESTAURIERTdasDKR I'll search them, thank you :)
alternatehistorypt 2 years ago
@atzel62 I read somewhere that Becher's anthem lyrics originally where intended to the Lied der Deutschen melody, is it true the other way around too ? : ) interesting :)
See my video: Alternate History of the Iberian Peninsula . In that other alt history the Auferstanden aus Ruinen melody (not the lyrics) turn to be the anthem melody of an alternate socialist Portugal instead lol :) (but read the whole description box of that video to understand why :) )
alternatehistorypt 2 years ago