I seen the roses December 95 Glasgow barrowland. Albeit without reni. I feel very privileged! I also play and sing acoustic in pubs and no matter what age group I
Play too. Stone roses songs always make people sing along! Timeless!
This hurts to say but some of you still think there is a chance that the Stone Roses will reform. Although Ian Brown has performed with Mani and in on fairly good terms with Reni, he has not been in the same room with John Squire in almost 15 years much less spoken to him. The chances of all four of them being on the same stage again is ZERO. It breaks my heart; they would sell out everywhere they go.
Mr Brown is a very talented artist, his music got me through uni especially putting into perspective people who just annoy the hell out of you, and you have to see them every day for 3 yrs!!
'Thanks Mr Brown '! plus his dress sense is awesome.
I bumped into ian brown in starbucks in holland park ,london. Talk about star struck, i didn`t say a word. Been kicking myself ever since.. but you know what ! i still don`t know what i could have said.
Seen Ian live in 2005 at oxygen festival and was the best gig Ive ever seen bar none. Did a 10 minute bass line intro for I wanna be adored and then took the roof off the fucking tent!!! Unreal still get goosebumps thinking about it!!!
yeh but who cares ? liam does he own thing .. ian is a legend but his voice aint as good as liams, not live anyway .. even liam nowadays can still sound good
@spooner0770 Especially Reni, in fact Reni was better than Mani at bass. And any Roses fan would fan would know that Reni played drums, keyboard, backing vocals, wee bit guitar. He's like Jesus with a bucket hat.
@diamond1897 SHITE...Any TRUE Roses fan would love them to reform...i know i do.The present time is ideal for a Roses reunion ,what with all the bland manufactured pop shite that is the norm nowadays.In fact i would say a Stone Roses reunion is NECESSARY NOW...PLEASE MAKE IT HAPPEN
its The Stone Roses every day of the week for me, unfortunately im not old enough to have seen em live but ive seen Ian Brown live many times an although his voice aint the best its all about his songs for me an his presensce on stage..step forward Oasis who have produced the soundtrack to my growing up courtesy of the beatles an the roses, so Brown,Squire,Reni an Mani i salute you..!!
did i see cressa at some point in the background??
id love to know why ian took a john squire alike on tour with him around this era, the guy uses the same guitars (country classic here) amps, effects, flange, chorus.. everything.. damn fine set up, sounds like its lifted from blackpool live, but just dont get why he'd have his very own john squire clone on tour with him.
its because the lads he took on tour with him were a stone roses tribute band (fools gold)imagine being a tribute act then ian asks you to be his band on tour wen performing roses songs oh i cant imagine anything better
it just a matter of what you can get away with infront of the camera anyone can see that if ya see serious interviews with noel gallagher ya can see its all 4 the camera
im not joking right, they were different, a bit unique, and i like them, but theyre melodies arent amazing, which in turns makes their songs unamazing, theyre average, they really arent amazing as you mancs jump them up to be, and i like the roses, i really do.
It was never about hitting the notes he is a wordsmith a poet you fuckers!He is a one man musical revolution who learnt his craft on the streets not in some 10 000 a year drama school.He speaks clearly to the working classes because he is truly one of them,and you will never catch him sucking ass.The rest of the band lost any shread of decency for letting it all come undone.
And for anyone thinking the roses would have been better if Ian was a fantastic vocalist,I refer you to the sea horses, where John Squires tried exactly that by finding a good singer that looked like Ian.What happened-They now all work in Mcdonalds and Ian is still rocking.Increase the peace you fuckin peasants!!!!!
stop complaining about the vocals girls - this is about as good as your going to get as far as getting the Roses back together - they were shit live back in 89 and they'd still be shit live now - But don't get me wrong the roses changed my life forever and I love them so much!!!
They were shit live? Bollocks, they were fucking amazing live. And don't get me wrong, I hear what you're saying but for fuck sake, they were not about hitting the perfect notes vocally. This tune is brilliant, it is as close as we'll get to the Roses and it should be enjoyed. The Roses had a big impact on my life, I still listen to them and I will make sure my grandkids listen to them - fucking outstanding.
Right on, they were brilliant live... browny was all about the music and being the front man, sure his singing wasn't and still isn't great live but it's the music man!! fuckin' love it!
shit live??!!! Wash yo' mouth! Browny might occasionally have struggled to hold a tune but Mani and Reni were the BEST rhythm section I ever saw and Squire was (and still is) a genius. Pity he gave up playing
besides ian obiously. yeah this is shit. stones were good because of the musicans blending rock with dance music. ian was really really cool at the time, but is not the same now. just look at him. fucking dutch boy hair cut and a track suit. and just forget how he sounds. he doesnt have the talent to back up the attitude. love the stones... but just ian... eh...
do u think if everyone who wanted to see them reform for a few gigs and got vocal they would do it out of the goodness of there hearts? i know i would but then again i cut grass for a living
I'd give anything to have been there that night- It would have been the closest I'd ever get to seeing the roses live - But I'd give all my limbs to have been 15 in the 80s. I'm dying to see 'em reform. Even if it was just for one gig. Nothing commercially related in any form. No $2million produced single like GnR did. Just to re-live the legend that was Stone Roses.
nowhere near squire standard on guitar. charlatan. Not the Roses. THE SEAHORSES = HE HATES ROSES I fuckin love this song too... communism...waterfall.... grand!
nice one m8 allready got them though nice 1 please please can anyone name him he used to be in a roses tribute band thats how he nos most of squires moves
Actually, he sings quite good in this.
Rhidalgo789 2 months ago
Un poco desafinado el gran Ian... pero gran, gran canción.
elsebra 4 months ago
reni in the crowd at 4:45
Anotherrnumber 5 months ago
Genious!
wwwrampagewww 6 months ago
In today's homogenized musical climate we need the Roses more than ever.
croesrob 9 months ago 2
God Bless Thiss man
gunawanfahri 10 months ago
I seen the roses December 95 Glasgow barrowland. Albeit without reni. I feel very privileged! I also play and sing acoustic in pubs and no matter what age group I
Play too. Stone roses songs always make people sing along! Timeless!
j66hng 1 year ago
This hurts to say but some of you still think there is a chance that the Stone Roses will reform. Although Ian Brown has performed with Mani and in on fairly good terms with Reni, he has not been in the same room with John Squire in almost 15 years much less spoken to him. The chances of all four of them being on the same stage again is ZERO. It breaks my heart; they would sell out everywhere they go.
Dbusdriver71 1 year ago
@Dbusdriver71 Precisely. They would sell out big time. The roses burned brightly and then died. R.I.P.
10kamala 1 year ago
@Dbusdriver71 You were wrong.
Rhidalgo789 2 months ago
@Rhidalgo789 This is one time I gladly admit it.
Dbusdriver71 2 months ago
Mr Brown is a very talented artist, his music got me through uni especially putting into perspective people who just annoy the hell out of you, and you have to see them every day for 3 yrs!!
'Thanks Mr Brown '! plus his dress sense is awesome.
glitzerite 1 year ago
Great tune, off key singer.
gori1084 1 year ago
i wish i could see ian in live show
MrZivram 1 year ago
Epic man.
TyGreenTLB 1 year ago
I love Ian's face structure, like his cheekbones and nose shape and face shape. Might sound weird, lmao.
Ohh well, he's good looking :D
TheStoses 1 year ago
I bumped into ian brown in starbucks in holland park ,london. Talk about star struck, i didn`t say a word. Been kicking myself ever since.. but you know what ! i still don`t know what i could have said.
dimsummad 1 year ago
Best roses song ever seen em at Glasgow green 1990 still sound good
eddycelticbhoy66 1 year ago
ian brown defined my youth and i can`t get past it ! I have an erge to visit manchester and give it big style !!!!
dimsummad 1 year ago
@dimsummad dont get passed it.
sugarraygras 1 year ago
different level and class
jaspervj 1 year ago
my fave roses tune by a mile sorry but all we have no are memories and how we should all cherish... 20 years..
gburny 1 year ago
Comment removed
madferret27 1 year ago
Comment removed
madferret27 1 year ago
I don't want Noel Gallagher to join Stone Roses...I love Ian Brown&Stone Roses but Oasis is my life and i cant image that Noel is another band...
96Dano 1 year ago
King Monkey.
seanywarnywoo 1 year ago
Seen Ian live in 2005 at oxygen festival and was the best gig Ive ever seen bar none. Did a 10 minute bass line intro for I wanna be adored and then took the roof off the fucking tent!!! Unreal still get goosebumps thinking about it!!!
Renaldo1984 1 year ago
Sounds fucking amazin wen ur high
steveo9996 2 years ago 4
You dont have to be high to realise that this tune IS fucking amazing! but agree that with some weed it gives an extra dimension..
rapperzondernaam 1 year ago 5
Well said!!!
Renaldo1984 1 year ago 2
yeh but who cares ? liam does he own thing .. ian is a legend but his voice aint as good as liams, not live anyway .. even liam nowadays can still sound good
thacker123 2 years ago
@thacker123 Aye but Oasis are pish these days.
TheMariachi1996 1 year ago
Comment removed
pigpig1214 2 years ago
na jst pretty much The Stone Roses a perfect madchester super-group lol
spooner0770 2 years ago 2
@spooner0770 Especially Reni, in fact Reni was better than Mani at bass. And any Roses fan would fan would know that Reni played drums, keyboard, backing vocals, wee bit guitar. He's like Jesus with a bucket hat.
TheMariachi1996 1 year ago
clearly they are stone roses cover band professional
i don't blame him. they sound great! nearly perfect cover for his live stuff.!
lazyitus 2 years ago 2
XD!! <3 tHe StOnE RoSes.. <3 Ian!!
xxIII000ale000IIIxxx 2 years ago
omg I love this song! Is from that movie too "Green Gang Hooligans" which was so cool.
BarbieHerself 2 years ago
Please do not reform The Stone Roses.
They were beautiful man.
Don't tarnish the memories.
Any true Roses fan will agree.
diamond1897 2 years ago 67
I agree.
I'd love
Ian Brown, Noel Gallagher, Johnny Marr, Mani and Reni to form a band though.
DANNYM35 2 years ago 3
Johnny Marr!!! Now that would be fuckin' great with Noel and Ian. Hell yes!!!
swingersonian 2 years ago
@diamond1897 Great Post an very true...! Viva La Monkey
madferret27 1 year ago
@diamond1897 ian brown is the stone roses you nutter
grace51000 1 year ago
@grace51000 yea, im sure that reni and john had nothing to do with it
frodohair992 1 year ago
@grace51000 Amen
sugarraygras 1 year ago
@diamond1897 whatever
jonnytheoasisfan 1 year ago
@diamond1897 SHITE...Any TRUE Roses fan would love them to reform...i know i do.The present time is ideal for a Roses reunion ,what with all the bland manufactured pop shite that is the norm nowadays.In fact i would say a Stone Roses reunion is NECESSARY NOW...PLEASE MAKE IT HAPPEN
richiebhoy1888 1 year ago
@richiebhoy1888 BOLLOX.!!! That's not to say that I wouldn't queue for 9n hrs for a ticket BTW. :)
diamond1897 1 year ago
@diamond1897
Quite right.
donning 1 year ago
@diamond1897 They dont need to. Ians got the sounds without the roses. They have been replaced.
sugarraygras 7 months ago
Identico a LIAM!!!!
nitrogaia 2 years ago
Nearly but not quite.......Ian hasnt got the same "stance" tho eh?
alty567 2 years ago
well considering the stone roses were around b4 oasis who do you think is copying who?
sorry liam is a poor mans ian brown :)
skeptic9876 2 years ago
its just the scraffy manc look mate.
look it up.
dhb070 2 years ago
fucking amazing performance! I can't believe how good this guitarist plays Squires part. perfect.
Coldacre 2 years ago 3
Yes, yes, yes, yes. Stone Roses forever!
bonangusacdc 2 years ago 3
a thought tht wis a fukin good video likes
herewefukingo 2 years ago
tunnneeeeeeeeeeeeee , love this song ian brown legde ! bournemouth 3 december !
louisshukri 2 years ago
really omg im gettin ticket i didnt no
ubmilitant 2 years ago
ian brown IS a legend of that there is no doubt
apparently though, he DOESN'T play stone roses tunes anymore live because his solo stuff is better and he doesn't believe in nostalgia :-(
i was banned from the ian brown forum for suggesting he should
if you want to see roses tunes live, you now need to see a tribute band - howw gutting is that?!?!?!
dometick 2 years ago
imagine the roses reforming and playing at glastonbury
be fucking amazing
samnninty 2 years ago 5
its The Stone Roses every day of the week for me, unfortunately im not old enough to have seen em live but ive seen Ian Brown live many times an although his voice aint the best its all about his songs for me an his presensce on stage..step forward Oasis who have produced the soundtrack to my growing up courtesy of the beatles an the roses, so Brown,Squire,Reni an Mani i salute you..!!
madferret27 2 years ago 2
did i see cressa at some point in the background??
id love to know why ian took a john squire alike on tour with him around this era, the guy uses the same guitars (country classic here) amps, effects, flange, chorus.. everything.. damn fine set up, sounds like its lifted from blackpool live, but just dont get why he'd have his very own john squire clone on tour with him.
zoso11 2 years ago
its because the lads he took on tour with him were a stone roses tribute band (fools gold)imagine being a tribute act then ian asks you to be his band on tour wen performing roses songs oh i cant imagine anything better
i hpoe that answera tyour 2question
stretch0131 2 years ago
it just a matter of what you can get away with infront of the camera anyone can see that if ya see serious interviews with noel gallagher ya can see its all 4 the camera
TheMikelewin 2 years ago
A Stone Roses performance in Glastonbury would be so much better than this.
mahavishnu 2 years ago 10
im not joking right, they were different, a bit unique, and i like them, but theyre melodies arent amazing, which in turns makes their songs unamazing, theyre average, they really arent amazing as you mancs jump them up to be, and i like the roses, i really do.
kevlance 2 years ago
ye i get wat u mean mate but the roses are fkn ace [in my opinion]
thestonerosesj200 2 years ago
Stone Rose's all the way, such a shame they split. they might still be producing awesome music like this is they were still going!!
rugrat180680 2 years ago 3
classic manc song! love it!
Jamesofhull 2 years ago 3
ur all dickheads this man is part of a culture a movements fuckin god this music put mancs on the map bro trust one word legend
MrJoulo12 2 years ago 3
i've met ian a few times and was at a house party with him about 3 years ago. the mans a fucking knob. i do like his music though
jtt37 2 years ago 5
CORRECT
checkmiddy 2 years ago
i take it he's just all big ego etc.. a bit like the gallaghers?
i do like the gallaghers and ian brown, dont get me wrong, but they all sound far too cocky..
1wolfisloose1 2 years ago
notice how the drummer has absalutly no rythm compared to reni
LiamGill101 2 years ago
are you surprised? Reni was the best drummer britain has ever had
northcountrybhoy 2 years ago 10
nugget
ricocheung 2 years ago
the sound of manchester makes me proud to be a manc.
rocknotrave 2 years ago 3
The sound of manchester makes me wish I was a manc and not a yank.
Mozzer232 2 years ago 38
SO FUNNY..i am a manc and sometimes I wish I was a YANK lol
capuc71 2 years ago 3
Wud you dare wish you were a YANK hahahaha :L
I'm a geordie :L
WOOOOO
Well aye man :P
haha funny stereotype, i was actually in Manchester one time and these lads really wanted me to say it hahaha
In Burger King at departures :L
John16H 2 years ago
Im From Sheffieldddd :D
yay. :L
beaujobbb 2 years ago
whats that gotta do with anything? XD
John16H 2 years ago
arctic monkeys? :L xD
beaujobbb 2 years ago
I know haha, whats The Arctic Monkeys got to do with anything :L
John16H 2 years ago
Erm.... Indie music? :L
beaujobbb 2 years ago
How dare you even mention that shit band in a Ian brown video.
Ulmeyda08 2 years ago
@Mozzer232 shut the fuck up traitor
Fenderkicksass 1 year ago
@Mozzer232 livin the dream mate
ganjastep 1 year ago
@Mozzer232 We'd swap you for the Glazers if you want mate, lol.
ReDArMy06 1 year ago
@ReDArMy06 The Glazers are hated over here too!!! lol
Mozzer232 1 year ago
@Mozzer232 if you like ian brown you can call yourself a manc in my books.
GFisher111 8 months ago
hey does anyone know the brand/make of that jacket he is wearing is? ta
Humbdalas 2 years ago
if you weren,t there don,t comment. this music surpasses time. love it forever.
graypants1973 3 years ago
fuk off u penis if u weren there dnt comment thats jst a bit immature dnt u think
and all i can word it with is lol
kidslovetekno 2 years ago
tear in the eye watching this. the roses were fukin everything
tilly15773 3 years ago
It was never about hitting the notes he is a wordsmith a poet you fuckers!He is a one man musical revolution who learnt his craft on the streets not in some 10 000 a year drama school.He speaks clearly to the working classes because he is truly one of them,and you will never catch him sucking ass.The rest of the band lost any shread of decency for letting it all come undone.
sugarraygras 3 years ago 4
And for anyone thinking the roses would have been better if Ian was a fantastic vocalist,I refer you to the sea horses, where John Squires tried exactly that by finding a good singer that looked like Ian.What happened-They now all work in Mcdonalds and Ian is still rocking.Increase the peace you fuckin peasants!!!!!
sugarraygras 3 years ago 2
ahaha
The Seahorses were pretty shit like, apart from John's guitar of course
John Squire and Jonny Marr were both really good
John16H 2 years ago
stop complaining about the vocals girls - this is about as good as your going to get as far as getting the Roses back together - they were shit live back in 89 and they'd still be shit live now - But don't get me wrong the roses changed my life forever and I love them so much!!!
radioscotvoid 3 years ago
They were shit live? Bollocks, they were fucking amazing live. And don't get me wrong, I hear what you're saying but for fuck sake, they were not about hitting the perfect notes vocally. This tune is brilliant, it is as close as we'll get to the Roses and it should be enjoyed. The Roses had a big impact on my life, I still listen to them and I will make sure my grandkids listen to them - fucking outstanding.
YaaDafty 3 years ago
Right on, they were brilliant live... browny was all about the music and being the front man, sure his singing wasn't and still isn't great live but it's the music man!! fuckin' love it!
mikethompson1991 2 years ago
shit live??!!! Wash yo' mouth! Browny might occasionally have struggled to hold a tune but Mani and Reni were the BEST rhythm section I ever saw and Squire was (and still is) a genius. Pity he gave up playing
MCBhangramuffin 3 years ago 2
TRIBUTE BAND.
cavernbirch 3 years ago
ian brown vocals make most of his songs special. edge my dear boy - not the shite miming shit you have become used to. Ja bless x
DJStretchio 3 years ago
Great track, shite vocals though!
daw7777 3 years ago
is anyone from the original line up playing here?
cornpopsandacid 3 years ago
yeah man. browner!! woop woop
beaverking 3 years ago
besides ian obiously. yeah this is shit. stones were good because of the musicans blending rock with dance music. ian was really really cool at the time, but is not the same now. just look at him. fucking dutch boy hair cut and a track suit. and just forget how he sounds. he doesnt have the talent to back up the attitude. love the stones... but just ian... eh...
cornpopsandacid 3 years ago
browner was in the roses man, not the stones hahaha see what i did there?
beaverking 3 years ago
do u think if everyone who wanted to see them reform for a few gigs and got vocal they would do it out of the goodness of there hearts? i know i would but then again i cut grass for a living
cobinho310 3 years ago
agreeeed with comment beloww, i'd kill for the stone roses to get back togetherr ;(
xFlabbyBaby90sLovex 3 years ago
I'd give anything to have been there that night- It would have been the closest I'd ever get to seeing the roses live - But I'd give all my limbs to have been 15 in the 80s. I'm dying to see 'em reform. Even if it was just for one gig. Nothing commercially related in any form. No $2million produced single like GnR did. Just to re-live the legend that was Stone Roses.
MUrrrrD 3 years ago 2
rockin........
davidnavancavan 3 years ago
superbe !! je recherche ce son depuis que j'ai vu green street hooligans
usldboy 3 years ago
Fucking awsome Ian best thing since sliced bread!! Just as good at V 08 come on KING MONKEY
elcaffers 3 years ago
2 words - fuckin mint!
stewhe1979 3 years ago
Beautiful, absolutely beautiful
...This song gets me every time.
RoseMiyu 3 years ago 2
Top tune, top band, top attitude!
chippauly 3 years ago
Excellent stuff....a great tune of the Roses.
jasoncsh35 3 years ago
top tune ,and band
11thedogfather 3 years ago
why wouldnt he be enjoyin the cunt is smacked out of it lol
mcanner25 3 years ago
i want his tamberine!!!!
SirRudy93 3 years ago
You can tell Ian is enjoying this gig , classic
felly205 3 years ago
The album that changed my life.
bonangusacdc 3 years ago
Stone Roses Stone Roses changes everyone life best album EVER!!!
elcaffers 3 years ago 5
Ian Brown is my hero.
jmw02m 3 years ago 4
well said jogger..
nathanhanley 3 years ago
The King Monkey is there. If only John, Wreni and Mani were to. Still a beautiful, timeless masterpiece after nearly twenty years, though.
jogger1976 3 years ago
nowhere near squire standard on guitar. charlatan. Not the Roses. THE SEAHORSES = HE HATES ROSES I fuckin love this song too... communism...waterfall.... grand!
stripeysoul 3 years ago
i think ian brown songs must make up about half of the videos iv seen on youtube.
shes a waterfall...
kevingallacher69 3 years ago
ian brown cool as fuck wish the stone roses would get back 2gether x
billyscotland2006 3 years ago
any one name ians guitarist let me no lads n lasses
stoneroadster 3 years ago
i know them all except the guitarist xD sorry. if it helps tho ;
bass ; tim hutton
drums ; maxi [best drummer everr]
keyboard ; tim wills
^^
PowerRangerMegaTent 3 years ago
nice one m8 allready got them though nice 1 please please can anyone name him he used to be in a roses tribute band thats how he nos most of squires moves
stoneroadster 3 years ago
wait mate i'll ask maxi ^^
PowerRangerMegaTent 3 years ago
if u wud m8 be apreciated doin me bloody nut u must admit hes not bad at squires moves hes not squire but closish thanx 4 ya time bud respect
stoneroadster 3 years ago
no problemo , i sent him a message , just have 2 wait he's rehearsin ^^
yeah he is really good like , i saw him live a few weeks back , he's really somethin ^^
PowerRangerMegaTent 3 years ago
Stevie D ^^
PowerRangerMegaTent 3 years ago
nicly thanxs a million n yea he is shit hot
stoneroadster 3 years ago
Could you imagine anyone else singing it? Nope.
brady3249ers 3 years ago
this is a great song but I can't stand Ian Brown's voice.
fastrelief 3 years ago
people who say this dont make sense :S how can u like the song if u dont like the way its sung by the songwriter ????!?! weirdo.
DavieHam 3 years ago
wtf
PowerRangerMegaTent 3 years ago
stone rose's songs are the most beautiful ones created on earth.
babybritain90 3 years ago
this reminds me of college in the early 90's
doorspj24 4 years ago
It's not fair how good this man is!
RobAslan 4 years ago
good but damo dempsey is much better
mcanner25 4 years ago
wish I'd been there
mermaidylady 4 years ago
king monkey yaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaas
19danny 4 years ago 2
eat a few mushrooms and listen to this psychedelic song.....
Yoga1978 4 years ago
Monkey Magic !
moonboots69 4 years ago 2
sounds just like blackpool '89. fab
donlogan666 4 years ago 2
was at blackpool 89 full of the mushies probably the best night of my life. live with me forever
dirkpike 3 years ago
great
omgomg5475 4 years ago
mon the monkey!!
theeskimofriend 4 years ago
best song ever
JamieBlink 4 years ago
"if u can dance dont be affraid to shake the shoulder" ian brown wat a legend
jackyvamps 4 years ago
King Monkey rules!
Ptuutti 4 years ago 2
At least I can dance as well as IB...
beowulven 5 years ago 3