Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (178)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Guys, guys...Haley is amazing ( my favorite idol ever) but Naima totally takes this cupcake. I wish she had stayed with this kind of feel during the live show.

  • i love haley<3 oh and Jennifer looks stunning ;D

  • Jacob Lusk = Sylvester

  • I love Haley. (: She's a great singer. I'm voting for her. LOL. (:

  • God. Damn. Gaaaaaaaaaaaaaaawd Daaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaayum.....­.That's all

  • haley's astounding vocals going unnoticed once again.

  • @dblubarry haley is really amzing and she shoud have won imo but on this song jacob was definitely the most outstanding

  • @nooneveryimportant err i disagree, his part was just longer. his voice is too melodramatic.

  • @dblubarry melodramatic? he's got the emotions in his voice and he can transmit them. the way Haley expresses emotions on stage is still very staged and fake, she must work on it, jacob's got it natural

  • @nooneveryimportant must explain why haley has a huge record deal and jacob doesnt.

  • @dblubarry because this is show business and jacob lusk is not very marketable, he's not what common people want, dont get me wrong, i really like haley too

  • @xSophiaxCeex you lucky son of a biscuit eating bulldog!

  • Almost Cried When I Heard This !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • I get chills everytime i listen to naima in this song

  • i dnt think naima gets enough credit! she was my fav idol contestant ever

  • @jtightrope14 She is entertaining and she is herself -- I like her too. Heard she has a record deal also, but don't know a lot about it... They were all good in this performance!

  • ALL <3

  • JACOB.

  • 0:47 omg, is just me? or steaven is so in love with haley's voice?

  • @karemgc I think its more than just her voice

  • Comment removed

  • lol dsteven look like he is going to rape haley at :48 , I love both of them !

  • Haley's lower register is really strong here!

    I think by the end of the show, her voice was starting to wear, and that's why the verses in "You Oughta Know" were weak in the lower register.

    I seriously think Haley is the best contestant to come out of Idol. Her chest register, upper register, and falsetto are out-of-this-world good. And her tone is like Adele, Joss Stone, and a little Janis Joplin all mixed together. She's very unique and very talented.

  • Haley's voice like Adele's has a retro feel to it, and that's why she's so amazing! After Rolling In the Deep and Someone Like You going #1 on top-40 radio I think Haley will be very successful. And she will help good music come back to mainstream!

  • Haley using vibratto here! I loved it.

  • they all did so good. especially haley.

  • 1:34 i hear haleys beautiful growl!!!!!! :)

    

  • I wish we got to hear more from Naima though. We got gipped.

  • Like Haley, Naima keeps a stiff upper lip and manages to smile no matter what. She's classy like Haley is.

    vote Naima on faxo wall vote Idol of the month

  • I hope it works out for Naima. Haley likes her too.

  • Comment removed

  • Naima has some Great energy!!

  • I hope Naima never scrubs another toilet. She was my favorite before she was eliminated. Very hard to dance and sing the way she tried...JLo probably lip syncs when she's dancing on stage (definitely on videos). Old movie trick...so that the face doesn't get all distorted...Haley's been criticized for making "faces" while she sings. Real and True.

  • Haley is all I saw and heard here.

  • She's from Illinois....so am I :D

  • When the part all three of them had to sing together, I can totally recognize HALEY'S GROWL. <3

  • HALEY!!!!! :D

  • HALEY AT 1:35

  • HALEYYYYY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! <3 <3 <3 <3

  • Wow, Haley sounds so sexy doing that voice 0:53.

  • I will marry Haley one day.

  • Naima is good too. Haley, Thia, Naima my top three.

    'Faxo wall vote' by goog le

    then click idol pic with heart

    then sign in with twitter to vote or by clicking the box that says I am human

    I changed my name. I was boundless.

  • HALEY<3 !!!! I LOVE U

  • Thanks for voting for Haley at faxo....wall vote. Haley should go over the 5000 mark today with your help. Thanks and keep voting for Haley at faxo wall vote. She needs all the votes she can get. NON US Haley fans....Finally here is your chance to vote for our girl.

  • @boundlessloans yuppers i am voting for her on faxo shes in 3rd right now YAY!!!

  • Haley n Naima r my favs from this season!!!!!!!!xD

  • Dayum! Theyre voices blend together sooooo well!

  • man haley is damn sexy

  • naima is good but in her latest performances she was not singing. almost DANCING

  • haley and naima should duet!! Dont get me wrong I love jacob lusk but have to admit his voice is a little bit too screechy when he sings the higher range

  • @LoLz01ful A Haley/Naima duet of a jazzy song would be EPIC!

  • I don't understand what happened to Jlo and Randy regarding Haley, they were so supportive of her... hmmmmm just don't get it.... regardless though, this young lady has presence and she can SING!!!! Good luck Haley!!!!

  • Haley is my favorite person in the entire world

  • they all gone. i think relax will make them better, away better,

  • "Jacob Lusk"

    Compton,CA

    Age: 23 SPA CONCIERGE

    LOL

  • He is from Compton not LA

  • they all made to top 12 haha

  • YAWN!!!! 

  • I want to hear Haley sing the whole song hehehehe

  • If Jacob follows Randy's advice to "always do you", he'll end up on a Sunday morning gospel music show - but he'll never be the next Luther Vandross. Jimmy I. was right to tell him not to "oversing". Jacob's vocal histrionics got boring - it was all about "how many notes can I throw in here" and not about the lyrics.

  • Naima is just so amazing. She would have gone farther had she kept with emotional songs that challenge her vocal skills like this one instead of the undemanding reggae version of "I'm Still Standing" when she was eliminated.

  • @popeye98765 Looking back, Naima's reggae was such a huge risk that just didn't pay off, but is sure as hell a lot more interesting than ANYTHING Scotty or Lauren have done all season.

  • Haley is my Idol1!!! I want an album from her!

  • listen to Haley now. can u believe how much growth she had when u luk back at this mediocre performance. she is truly a dark horse, and a genuine talent,

  • HOW is Lusk still in this competition. YUCK!!!

  • VOTE FOR HALEY TONIGHT! no more bottom 3 for all this talent :)

  • i knew Naima would let herself down on the show. She never consistantly sang as well as she did her and for her wildcard performance.

    Haley and Jacob both in top 6, but i think they'll be the next two to go :( Really love Haley though, thumbs up if you're a fan of her :)

  • @jtymkiw1 too bad haley wasn't the next 2 to go home.(;

  • @jtymkiw1 ahahah that didnt happen but she still should have won

  • Naima was so fukin shit.

  • Haley! <3

  • Why naima didn´t sing like that on the show?

  • @javixupeke Naima was incredibly inconsistent. Her wild card and Las Vegas performances were great, but everything else was pretty mediocre or so entertaining that you had to forgive her technical in-capabilities.

  • I actually like when Jacob keeps it tamed. I like his both duets with Naima. So well done.

  • Im not a big Naimi Adedapo fan, but her range in this song was utterly Amazing!

  • I love all of them (This was Haley's only performance i liked until Bennie and the Jets where she won me over again) and Naima was my fav so sad she left and JAcob well i either love or hate his performances but this was just wonderful

  • @mommasguy but... in her audition it says she's 18. :S

  • Jacob is the best, to many haters hating on true talent.

  • Jacob sounds like Anthony from Anthony and the Johnsons and I crazy love that guy!

  • @dragonicelv true!

  • WASN'T HALEY 18?

  • @AmandaMagg haley is 20 year old :)

  • jacob is.....grating....ew.

  • beautiful.

  • im glad naima got the boot!!!

  • CLICK ON MY USERNAME >>>>> TO LISTEN TO PIA TOSCANO ORIGINAL MUSIC! THAT RIGHT -- SHE HAS ORIGINAL SONGS BEFORE IDOL THAT ARE ALL UPTEMPO!!!

  • What's the name of this song?

  • @jaderrw the song is called 'the long and winding road'

  • @shadowrider3196 Thank you, I am loving this song and version.

  • I just don't like Jacob man...

  • Vote a GIRL THROUGH! PIAFANS.COM !!! JOIN US AY PIA'S ONLY AND LARGEST FANSITE ON THE NET. DOWNLOAD ALL OF PIA TOSCANO'S PRE-IDOL MUSIC FOR FREE! ALL UPTEMPO!! AT PIAFANS.COM !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • this is y all 3 of dem made top 13 lol

  • holy crap.

  • Jacob FTW! (thumbs up if you agree!)

  • this was fantastic, luv jacob

  • HALEY OMGOSH GOOSEBUMPS. the way she shifter her voice from gettin so high to so looowww is amazinng

  • wow haley is amazing

  • Haley FTW!

  • JACOB KILLED IT AS SOON AS HE OPEN HIS MOUTH

  • ok sorry but I can't understand haley!

  • i looooooove haley.

  • Naima's really not that good. Jacob and Haley are the best in the competition.

  • @lnic16 yes!... i looove haley voice sooo much.

  • haley outshines all.

  • Naima and Jocob can't hold a candle to Haley!!!

  • @nkjohnston80 Retard

  • if haley gets eliminated OR even in the bottom 3 tonight im gonna sue all of america

  • Hakey is really underrated.imo,shes has what it takes to be the ai.

  • THAT GUY IS AMAZING , IGNORE THAT STUPID MUSIC DIRECTOR! NAIMA GREAT, GO FOR AFRICA GIRL AND HALEY A-MAZ-ING

  • I've said it a million times, and I'll say it again, Haley has the most incredible tone to her voice, and it is unlike than anyone else, not only in the compeition but in music currently. I really hope she wins, she gives me chills when she sings.

  • LOVE THAT GUY!!

  • I LOVE THIS THEY ALL ARE GREAT.

  • love the new judges, randy is getting on my last nerve

  • LOVE HALEY OMG SHE IS AMAZING

  • I think J LO and S Tyler are excellent judges

    this performance is wonderful!

  • everyone at school says that i look like haley .... & im like o.O "Realllyyyy ?!!"

  • 0:56 I loved her from the beginning but this moment SOLD me

  • WTF is oversinging? Is that even possible? Is there under-singing? Can anybody oversing or just the talented ones? Can you over-dance?

  • @fullahbro

    hahaha

  • @fullahbro lmfao well said!!!

  • @fullahbro There is a such thing lol (just listen to Christina). But oversinging is basically doing to much, whether thats riffs, runs, belts, high notes or all the above. Some songs just work with less.

  • HALEY is my favorite in the whole competition!!!!!

  • I'm not sure if the director gave the right advice, this is a comp Jacob shoulda did his thang. Whitney Houston in her day over sang and she is famous for it, ova singing is what made Aretha & Patti who they r today as well.

  • @seventeenboi haha, true but it still sound freaking good....haley is my fave dou...god herself and that orgy voice of her's...

  • @seventeenboi I agree...and I think that will hurt him in this competition.

  • I don't like the way jacob sings its not sexy its not smooth enough for me theres only one luther vandross and no one can come close to him not dis dude anyway hes got a style of totally of his own which is more suited to gospel i think good luck jacob

  • Comment removed

  • jimmy complete tosser gets a gig with John as a engineer and thinks he is a genius. Jacob just nailed him with randy. and a nice randy responce.

  • jimmy complete tosser gets a gig with John as a engineer and thinks he a genius. Jacob just nailed him with randy. and a nice randy responce.

  • Haley Reinhart has the most distinct voice i ever heard, when I close my eyes and listen to her sing, I'd totally know its HER. I LOVE HER!!!!

  • I agree with Jimmy. More is not always good, but Jacob Lusk is an exception. One in a million exception.

  • I love the Lusk!

  • that was the best group performance

  • American Idol forgot to mention that Naima, inbetwixt scrubbing toilets, polished some poles in da club too hehe. Im surprised american Idol was ok with that!

  • GOOSE BUMPS

  • i wish jimmy the music director would give Christina Aguilera the same advice. She over sings EVERYTHING...Less really is MORE

  • @lucky90000 If you got , flaunt it .

  • @lucky90000 it works for christina... shes just that amazing

  • @lucky90000 yeah christina aguilera oversings, not as much as she did before though, the difference between christina and this jacob dude,is that most of the time, not always, but most of the time, she at least is technically good, whereas this guy is just all over the place! jejej

  • @awhallowmyth099 She oversings more now. And they both sound pretty bad a lot of the time. When she pulls back, she sounds amazing. However, even when she's good, she's not that technically good. She has terrible technique.

  • @Scanned Christina is very sloppy, but she can get away with it because very few people have an almost 4 octave vocal range with the power she has. Also, she's not a classical singer. She's not Sarah Brightman, she's a pop singer.

  • @Scanned Christina doesn't oversing as much as she did a few years ago and to me she's one of very few artists that can oversing songs without making it sound bad, i think Jacob sounds beautiful sometimes when he oversings though. Overall, there are very few contemporary artists sing with good techniques, most of pop artists are not classically trained. But think about Christina, Haley or other artists they growl so frequently but never damage their vocal chords, how many ppl can do that?

  • Comment removed

  • @chatterboxleah

    control? if you don't know things like resonance, strain etc. stfu

  • @lucky90000 THAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAANK YOUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU!!! I've been saying this for years

  • That was amazing!!! They all have good chemistry together when they sing. I luv Jacob his voice is just phenomenal!!!!!

  • WOW. Just WOW.

  • what's the title of the song?

  • Jacob ha s agreat greaat voice!

  • fantastic!

  • Great group!!! Especially the girls!

  • Loved it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • they should be a real music group

  • oh my god, 1:44 was horrid!!! My ears almost bled -.-

  • @technicz98

    I hope you were being facetious.