This was a terrible film. I absolutely hated the camera work in the film. It had too many close ups, in fact the whole movie was basically a close up. Johnny Depp, who I generally like, pulls off being nothing more than a Johnny Depp character. The Christian Bale character, Pervis, is so bland that he escapes memory at this moment. I must say, however, that the greatest offender is the writer/director himself. A very poor film with cliches coming at us left and right. Watch "Bonnie and Clyde".
I've been wanting to see this one, but sadly missed out on it in the theatre. (other commitments got in the way) But I really want to check it out, because I'm a fan of Michael Mann and Collateral, Manhunter, and Heat are my top favorite films from the guy. Johnny Depp is such a great actor.
And I read that Mann says the Blu-ray version is the true visual/artistic representation he intended [the look of it], more so than on the big screen.
I'm really digging the digital camera style he's got going on. Which was one of the things I liked about Collateral. Almost looks as if he's making a home movie with a budget and known actors.
Hope the 'suicide' reference wasn't a spoiler...! I guess with a historical story, it's hard to spoil it. However I myself didn't know too much about the Dillinger story beforehand, other than the 'myth' elements; perhaps that's why I was expecting more! Anyway, the film does have some solid stuff going for it - I hope you enjoy it!
Public Enemies was actually the best movie I have ever seen. And it did get me very ingaged in the story even though I knew, by fact, that Dillinger will get shot at the end. Well, everybody has their own opinions, but I don't agree with the review in this video. I think the movie is worth going to see because of the amazing acting done by Johnny Depp. He played the character perfectly, and if you want to know how he did it, watch some of his interviews. Overall I give this movie an A++++.
Very insightful review - I think that a good film should be about more than how it looks. I felt no sense of who Dillinger was or why we should be watching his story. The writing was terrible, and with the exception of a few scenes, Depp wasn't given much to work with. The real Dillinger was larger-than-life and this film only made him a bland caricature of the the gangster genre.Billy Crudup was intriguing, but we saw very little of him. Bale was miscast. Missed its potential completely.
You know lately a lot of movies have been visually stunning with amazing special effects, but what I seeing more and more is a complete lack of decent writing and character development. I KNEW THAT WAS DIANA KRALL!!! Gab when are we going to the movies and do a review together?!?
This was a terrible film. I absolutely hated the camera work in the film. It had too many close ups, in fact the whole movie was basically a close up. Johnny Depp, who I generally like, pulls off being nothing more than a Johnny Depp character. The Christian Bale character, Pervis, is so bland that he escapes memory at this moment. I must say, however, that the greatest offender is the writer/director himself. A very poor film with cliches coming at us left and right. Watch "Bonnie and Clyde".
C4blewupmybaby 2 years ago
I've been wanting to see this one, but sadly missed out on it in the theatre. (other commitments got in the way) But I really want to check it out, because I'm a fan of Michael Mann and Collateral, Manhunter, and Heat are my top favorite films from the guy. Johnny Depp is such a great actor.
Awesome review as always Gab and Phil! :-)
christopherSmac 2 years ago
And I read that Mann says the Blu-ray version is the true visual/artistic representation he intended [the look of it], more so than on the big screen.
GabnDad 2 years ago
I'm really digging the digital camera style he's got going on. Which was one of the things I liked about Collateral. Almost looks as if he's making a home movie with a budget and known actors.
christopherSmac 2 years ago
Good review. 5 stars for hot milf!
Louistogies 2 years ago 6
I agree. She is a turbo MILF.
4Shadower 2 years ago 3
i thought this movie was fairly enjoyable. 8/10 for me.
McqueenKid5 2 years ago
One of the year's best films. GO SEE IT for those of you who haven't.
tragicallyhip4ever 2 years ago
Hope the 'suicide' reference wasn't a spoiler...! I guess with a historical story, it's hard to spoil it. However I myself didn't know too much about the Dillinger story beforehand, other than the 'myth' elements; perhaps that's why I was expecting more! Anyway, the film does have some solid stuff going for it - I hope you enjoy it!
GabnDad 2 years ago
I'll like to see this movie, thanks for such detailed and insightful review, without giving away any spoilers. You guys are awesome!
Jordmate 2 years ago
Public Enemies was actually the best movie I have ever seen. And it did get me very ingaged in the story even though I knew, by fact, that Dillinger will get shot at the end. Well, everybody has their own opinions, but I don't agree with the review in this video. I think the movie is worth going to see because of the amazing acting done by Johnny Depp. He played the character perfectly, and if you want to know how he did it, watch some of his interviews. Overall I give this movie an A++++.
gerasoras 2 years ago
Michael Mann did really well with this movie. For me it was an instant classic. Everything about it was just great :)
Noelg28 2 years ago
Filmmaker Gail Singer asked that we post this comment:"I LOVE this format you have developed. It is so contrary to the
teleprompter, moviespeak television/internet reportage. I feel like I
am in a real place, with real people. It's kind of addictive, just like movies are. I don't even care if I
have seen or will see the movie.
In fact, I guess it is partly your relationship that is intriguing.
Who is more relaxed? Who is more knowledgeable? It adds to the fun."
philipslayton 2 years ago
Very insightful review - I think that a good film should be about more than how it looks. I felt no sense of who Dillinger was or why we should be watching his story. The writing was terrible, and with the exception of a few scenes, Depp wasn't given much to work with. The real Dillinger was larger-than-life and this film only made him a bland caricature of the the gangster genre.Billy Crudup was intriguing, but we saw very little of him. Bale was miscast. Missed its potential completely.
RadioactiveReviewsTV 2 years ago
You know lately a lot of movies have been visually stunning with amazing special effects, but what I seeing more and more is a complete lack of decent writing and character development. I KNEW THAT WAS DIANA KRALL!!! Gab when are we going to the movies and do a review together?!?
MrHollick 2 years ago