Girls Aloud - The Promise (Live Lounge)

[andrayeiscastiel]

who took over nadine's part? its pretty good without nadine!

[wozniacki15]

yuck!!! GA i know you guys arent the best vocal group but they cud have done much better

[cutiepiepenny1]

wow they actually sounded really good!

Nadine always misses things..i don't think she was as commited as the other's!

[CherylColeAMAZING]

I love this, its alot better without nadine, nothing against her. I think its alot more relaxed, nicola and cheryl really sang well :)

[bibipassos10]

WHAT?? how can people say that Cheryl cant sing? This is stupid!!

[GA178VS]

i always love Sarah when GA sing this song coz she sounds powerful!

and i think this performance is really good even without Nadine who people think is the best singer.

[TheMrMarilyn]

Now that was FAB!!!!They pulled it off with aplomb and grace,from what must've been an extremely nerve wracking experience for them!!They should feel absoLUTely proud of themselves for having dealt with all the backstage dramas etc and still shone as they did!!If ah wore a hat ahd take it off to them for this!!Awesome...

[CollazoLloyd88]

Where is that daft Nadine>

[luceeey01]

team sats all the way....

[zoeisobel]

cheryl cannot sing. 

[norkis2696]

@zoeisobel You are right! Cheryl can't sing bad!

[MrBarneey]

I think Nadine gels the group together - they're fine separate but in an interview even Nadine said she recorded her parts separate because they were so big and prominent. I think the band isn't as good with any 1 of them missing.

[ksajcatb]

@MrBarneey what's this interview? nadine loves herself way too much..

[ldi321]

cheryl rocks thisss

nadine wasnt as missed as i thought shed be hahaha

but theyll never be the same unless its the five of them

[MrDenizen]

Good performance. Nadine wasn't missed, although I would give all her vocals to Cheryl, and let them split Cheryls vocals between the four of them.

[tourous4life]

@MrDenizen nicola really should have nadines vocals, only one that can really match her vocal and has a vocal range like nadines... cheyrls hot, but vocally shes not top girl in gl hq, however shes a top girl when it comes to overall performance!!!!

[MrDenizen]

@tourous4life - don't get me wrong, Nicola is actually my favourite in the group, but I believe Cheryl's voice is more suited to take over Nadine's. I actually think Cheryl's voice is the second weakest in the group (after Kimberley), but feel she has the same sound as Nadine, compared to the others. I can't quite put my finger on the reason why, but when I imagine all the girls singing Nadine's parts, Cheryl's vocals just seem right as a replacement.. in my head at least :)

[tourous4life]

@MrDenizen i guess we r going to have to agree to disagree, as it is split up into 3 of them singing in each verse, it wouldnt have have flowed with cheryl singing her own verse aswell as nadines verse... however still thing nicola has nadines vocal range,

[TommyGDub]

@MrDenizen Not me. Girls Aloud would suck without Cheryl. She adds so much to the performance, she's easily the best dancer.

[tyqaJ]

surprisingly, they sounded good!

[rossmartino8]

it does make a big difference that nadine is gone, you can hear it but they still sound good and it proves they dont NEED her to help them through

[96raindrop96]

they're so lovely and made me :) when they started so powerfully shouting ONE; TWO; THREE; FOUR hilarious

[bardotek66]

OMG! I love this track! They're awesome live! Can somebody send me a download link, PLEASE? I'll be thankful!!

[piratekiwi13]

kim did a great job with the extra vocals =D

[piratekiwi13]

where the hell is nadine???

[96raindrop96]

@piratekiwi13 I think she was ill, but I'm not sure. It feels like they're missing something without her :(

[hesterftw]

Surprisingly, Kim's cover of Nadine's part was pretty good, much better than I was expecting.

They don't sound right without Diney though :(

[takemethere219]

i fecking love them! ga 4ever ♥

[Somethingkindacole89]

nadine slept with one of the other girls fellas so it serves her self right!!! she wouldnt have had to fake it if that never happened!!

[MusicalVariety]

It sounds a bit rushed...

[lomaaz]

i agree, and it also makes them sound more nervous, but thats why they're probs rushing anyway. but still quite a good job minus nadine.

[aznbbi]

where's the best singer? Nadine without her its not not as good as it could be!

[Adonis19007]

Kimberley needs to learn to sing a bit louder because when she sings she sounds so quiet in compare to the rest

[hughlee218]

where was nadine

[MarkN233]

she was ill

[hughlee218]

aww rite cheers for telling me r u a big GA fan

[MarkN233]

yeah! i went to the out of control tour my first GA concert, they were boss :)

[aznbbi]

There's one person who voice sounds odd with the rest in the beginning and thats Cheryl!

[MGirlsAloudFan]

ill with the shingles so she had to stay in L.A :(

[Justinpg284]

I love that acoustic version of that song.

[theharper08]

I <3 girls aloud

[shazwalks]

WOW amazing!

[justkrub]

i like this song...

[theharper08]

nadine or no nadine...i LOVE nicola. she's my fave and her voice is not bad at all.

[Flippanisa]

shes missing cause she was suffering from shingles, it sed on the radio 1 website

[martinobrien87]

defo need a bit of Nadine! Good performance though!!

[laura151511]

can't wait till I go see them

[LukesJellybeans]

They sound better here then they did on the live x factor show.

[warrioroftheworld01]

I loved their performance on the X-Factor, but it wasn't their best. I think it was due to the fact that Cheryl was very nervous about performing it in front of Simon, Danni and Louis, after only being on the show for a couple of months. I've never really found anything wrong with anything they have done.

[laura151511]

yeah I thought that.,

it was sti;ll good I can't wait to go see them

[Joe777funnell]

defffffffinately need a bit of nadine in this

[roughboybaybee]

amazing !! love these girls :P

kimbers cheryl (yn) !! :P

[kahraba]

they sounded good! even if nadine wasnt there...

[girlsaloudfan121]

nicola and sarah were amazing cheryl was great too

this is a great performance but missing nadine lol

[olgalucia51]

Nadine suffered Herpes zoster so she couldnt attend

nicola this, nicola that, when will you just shut up about nicola , you know sarah ,kimberly, cheryl and nadine are also in the band in case you didnt know

[XxhannahxXdawnxX]

no nadine had shingles.

[girlsaloudfan121]

wtf read properly

i mentioned cheryl and sarah you idiot you dont half chat some bullshit

[olgalucia51]

hey , asshole your still missing the best member of the band , Kimberly

GO NADERLY

[girlsaloudfan121]

so i HAVE TO mention every member in every single video do i so what if i missed one does it really matter

[olgalucia51]

yeah actually it does make a big difference

[awale223]

a bit rude arn't you? nicola is a good singer.they all have their roles in the band but i guess i can't control you but remember,it wouldn't be GA if 1 of the girls had left. so i really don't think you should be so mean to nic but like i said before,everyone has their own opinions and i'm only expressing mine and just to tell you,Kimberley and Nadine are known as Kimbadine,not Naderly and it shouldn't really be Naderly anyway cause Kimberley's name ends with ley not ly as most people get wrong.

[Hantuchova777]

nicola has the best voice

[RozLaChimmer]

nicola and kimberley sound incredible. especially kimba doing nadine's bits.... nooo that sounds really wrong in my mind haha

point is, they all sound amazing :)

[Scion103]

solid voices,solo and group..maybe some singing classes and they could be great

[epsonmicrosoft]

Nicola's laughing everytime Sarah does "Here I am" makes me laugh.

Vocals are really good on this, love it.

[pierre00]

Amazing.

[houstey]

sounds gd..

[swishsamuk]

What a talentless bunch of slappers...

[beckyy3]

Cheryl and Sarah always sound awesome!! (:

[AliciaMayOlsen]

I like Nadine but why would she move to LA, she's in a British girlband?! Just asking for trouble really.

[xxGirlsxAloudxx]

they all sounded great on this - ga forever

[stoberto06]

a contender for the next cd definetly, dont think its on the last one, is it?

[weeeeyx3]

it's on out of control, the new album yeah :)

[0abz0]

cheryl and kimberly r my favourites! i thought it was much better than the xfactor performance... LOVED IT!

[domthebitch123]

is it kimberly and cheryl doing nadines bit

[weeeeyx3]

yeah it is :)

[QuornishxXx]

although Nadine is an amazing singer maybe they'd be better off without her? she does seem the one most affected by fame.. the others are all down to earth :)

[pinksmurf10]

nadine lives in L.A america so uno she cant always be ova here in u.k

[Leppicon77]

hahaha she had shingles...

[stoberto06]

lool

[Bstoke13]

cheryl cole is absolutely stunning! the best thing since sliced bread. and the singing's not bad either.

[aussieapril]

i think kimba did a good job of doing nadines vocals! good version girls!

[tookytookykakakaka69]

jo whiley is a fucking ugly dyke man

[selzz88]

nicola blends in well with the group. shes great. no one needed to be replaced..

[DespWivesFan]

Why does Nadine never turn up for any of these things?

[MrNottingham1989]

yer Nadine is kind of how mutya was in the sugababes, always missing shows...particularly before her departure. Maybe Nadine will follow suit

[runamok12]

nadine was sick with shingles when they did this....

although i do agree - she is missing in action a lot these days!

[WatchMeWatchYYou]

well for this one she had shingles..but as for never showing up for reality things and interview type thing..she said that she doesn't like taking part in things that aren't meant to promote girls aloud..

[gkel9]

wow!!! sara & nicola r gorgeous

[brianmillward]

cheryl is gorgeous oh yeah

[LilMissNickyP]

this is amazin seein that they dnt av nadine!

omg! cheryl is amazin!.. as usual!

x

[jennylvsshoes]

amazing loved thiis

well done girls

[WILKII]

wicked!!!!!!!! Cheryl is amazing!!!

[tanzlc]

it all sounds the same to me except in the chorus there is a man singing to doesn't really work lol

although very good

xxxx

[peterwillhab]

I think you'll find it's called harmony and it's Cheryl not a man.

[girlsaloudfan121]

I love Nic shes my fave and shes beuatiful so just shutup and get off her back and sounds great as usual

[brianmillward]

i think they should replace nicola roberts and add delta goodrem to the band she`s prettier than nicola(who isn`t)they wud do alot better

[rhyspanniers]

nicola is stunnin!!

[cheerbabe2324]

they are great! nicola omg i would she would just get kicked out of the group! she does not blend with the other 4 girls

[phototgenicposer]

they cover her part good though??

[xxsxichickxx]

luv it nicolas lefal x0x

[xxsiannshonaxx]

haha so funny wen nic laughs shes my fav bless her luv her x

[Lucienofficial]

who's not there?

[hellu882]

sarah <3

[Sam4God]

i love kim, she's so down to earth and funny

[guyaloud]

Kimberley's so great in this live ... I think that she's better now than in the beginnin'of the group

[Castiel08]

great

im sure there vocals have gotten so much better

or maybe this song shows there vocals more

idk

but theyre amazing live :)

[NJdm392x3]

amazingg ! love them.

xoxo

[him20000]

This sounds great =] i love girls aloud ^^

[happinessltd]

This is wicked! They all sound bloody well good, don't they?

And the video premiers tomorrow! Ah, I'm right chuffed, should be ace.

[brownertoxic]

love it

[thehotr0ck]

im almost glad nadine isnt there to over sing it as she usually does live (see call the shots live)

[Squirrelunderabus]

Sarah: "HERE IIII AMMMM"

Nicola: "Ahahaha"

TWICE!

xDDD Bless her!

[happinessltd]

I know! Feckin' hilarious. Love Cola! <3

[NJdm392x3]

lmfaoo love nicolaaa.

[CyPam]

Hahaha, yeah that was hilarious.

Wish there was a video of this, LOL.

[lavalamp77]

They actually sound better live than they did on the studio version.

[yazzy145]

Theyr amazin

xxxxx

[pinkypie33]

is this being released?

[SexiBack3825]

Yh, End of Oct!

[dan12bronsje]

i miss nadine in this song:P

[martin2419]

good live performance from the girls,almost didn't miss nadine at all.

[tebone02]

I really like this version & id be quite happy to buy this version if it ever got released, lovely song

[ga1fan]

love this song its amazing

[rjsuskin]

thanks so much for this? do you by any chance have their version/cover of "apologize" by onerepublic?

[sak868]

bahah have u heard it?

its horrible! i was embarraseed. but i guess everyone has their offdays

obviously this sounds amazing

[CyPam]

Hahaha...

"Embarrassing" is the perfect word to describe their cover of Apologize.

God knows what they were thinking when they did it.

[tomgafan]

omg i love it, sounds better than the original :D

[noartist01]

wooo I love it :)They are damn good <3

[lambribs]

Wow this was FANTASTIC! Well done girls!!!

[MISPLACED1990]

I love it :D