American Idol - Brooke White - Hero

[ChariceBillboard]

Too fast

Wrong melody

good try

[SFFL1996]

Wow, she had NO business picking this song....she did it absolutely no justice whatsoever.

[HeyJimmyDeannn]

She butchered the song.

[FM897]

It wasn't that bad, all things considered. She just had a few pitch problems.

[XritaiscoolX]

its Ok MARIAH IS WAYY BETTER SORRY

[orionpk]

weak, this song its ridiculiously strong for her

[sallyteacher]

I don't think so! It was Boring and it was way tooo ordinary. Enough with the songwriter drama. Show some voice quality and prove to us that you have more than just the sweet, loving nanny image. YOU'RE NEXT!

[ctf20]

i loved it...i love the whole singer/songwriter version. she doesn't have the belt it out voice like mariah - but i LOVE Brooke's voice...and she had to do something like this - and i thought it was great.

[LAchickee]

flat -very flat

vote off jason castro NOW - that boy is nasty nasty nasty NASTY

[xiniav]

Bye bye brooke! It was ur worst performance!

[tinachipp]

I thought Jason and David had better performances, but Brooke was my favorite of the female singers tonight.

[GeeWindu]

GREAT, GREAT, PERFORMANCE!!!!!!! There are three songs that have been absolutley the best on Idol ever. Let It Be, Shout To The Lord, and now "Hero". It was very original and as Mariah said looking at it as a new song it was absolutely amazing!!! Go Brooke! Remember that she will only stay in the competition if we vote for her every week as much as we can.

[Jarodm13]

Wow! That was fast!