In my American opinion, there aught to be more WWI and II videos about Canada, I just think they didn't get all the credit they deserved. Same with Australia and New Zealand.
Anyways, EXCELLENT movie, ... it's one of my favorites!
you know this is fiction based off of non fiction. its true that very few canadians held the line of passchendaele by themselves waiting for rienforcements that came way to late. it may have not been a squad but a platoon yes. it is easy to defend a trench oppose to taking one, so few could hold off many. Oh, AND THERE CANADIAN!
Paul Gross is the epitome of Canadian nationalism in acting form. He played an RCMP officer in Due South, a Canada Corps. sargeant in Passchaendale, and an outlaw cowboy in Calgary in Gunless. His acting is really hammy with American levels of patriotic propaganda, but he is definetly a guilty pleasure of mine. I just love seeing a strong, handsome Alberta boy representing this country on the screen.
@Scouragerules Realistically, attacking forces are said to require 3:1 numbers, assuming troop quality is similar, to capture an entrenched enemy position, this was probably even more pronounced back in those days when 'run across thick mud (explaining why the Germans can't hold hand to hand either, they're knackered from the advance) as quickly as possible toward the machine guns' was the favoured tactic to taking a trench. If the Canadians had been attacking, they would have died in droves too
why can't they make a German "patriotic" WWI movie? there very no moraly "corect" side during WWI so why not make one where the germans are rock'n in the begining of the war? it's beond boring to watch all this "All Hail the US" movies. the Germans had the coolest uniforms
@TyphorT38 Thank you, for saying something.I really sopport that Idea of a film Not only patriotic, just neural. The biggest problem is, we learn in the school,a lie. (I'm not a conspiracy theorist) We learn after the WW2 only the perspectiv of the brit historian John Röhl.He say: "Germany have the full blame on the WW1" By the way,this is not historically tenable.But we learn such things.Thats the reason for such films.But now the chilean armyAND the swedish palace guards have the best uniform.
I think you only need this unite! Because this small unite of 5 soldiers kill whole german Divisions or what?! xD That movie, I think is british humor! xD The last scene are the graves of all Germans, who are killing by this 5 ersons unite, sorry but...
@Niambag you mean this scene are based on true battle? They killing all Germans and have no no losses? Sorry but, I don't say your soldiers are bad, or something. But this is a little unrealistic! This little Company kill the whole german army, or what? XD What battle of the western Front is this?
Don't check out this scene patriotic, check out this video objectively!
The German imerial army was the best army in europe...
@jaxxx1975 they have casualties, this why they end up to be about ten, and it is about the battle of Passchendaele, which is a true battle, and it is very realistic when you consider Canadians won where anyone else could have won. Ypres in 1915, we hold against the German gas and following assault without gas mask. Vimy in 1917, only the Canadians managed to take the hill, Passchendaele, Canada's Hundred days, where Canadian were the spear launch into Germany's defenses.
@Niambag We don't begun useing Gas. That was a british idea. Churchill quote: "I decided not understand this sensitivity because of the use of gas, I am sure to use poison gas against uncivilized tribes." sorry I translated the quote from German in english. you mean the Third Battle of Ypres. We won this battle Allied losses of 325,000, only about 260,000 soldiers from the Germans fallen. And the captured allied areas we conquered 1918 back! Senceless wars and battles..
@jaxxx1975 I said that Canadian hold against the Gas, it was the only part of the Ypres line who didn't fell during the second battle of Ypres. You should ask yourself why German command and soldier were scared every time they heard Canadian Corp, Germans soldiers gave to Canadian Soldier the name "Sturmtrooper"
@Niambag In Canadias schools this battle is importent. But in Germany.... sorry but you are conquered with two canadian divisons, under help from two british divisons, and under losses of 16.000 Canadian soldiers tree villages. Your divisons was a Substitute for New Zealanders. The Canadian force was under the control of british a command. On the 10 October started the battle and on the 10 nevember the british comman broke up the failed attack!
@jaxxx1975 NO sry on the 26 Oktober started the attack and on the 10 november the british command aborted the failed attack, because of the big losses...!
Sorry this attack was not so importent, and not really a attack like this scene. 10 Canadian killing all Germans... :-)
@jaxxx1975 There were a lot of Can. soldier casualtie/deaths portrayed in this movie. The German commander in this was very kind&cool.
As unimportant as this bitter victory was, it was actually the most significant victory for the allies that year of war. The Can. Commander knew the battle was worthless-the Germans were fortified on the high ground and it was muddy-but Brit. Gen. Haig forced the advance because the allies needed a symbolic victory. And they did won, but paid a heavy price.
@misharoyuki Thank you. Of course, that was a importent balltle for canada. I don't say you fight not good, bravely and hard. I only criticized this scene! That scene is to much patriotic. But I forgotten, that canadians are no US-americans who think: What I saw in a film, is reallity. I remember the US 10 part Series Band.of.Brother, they this company killed hundreds of Germans but in the end the company have... what?... 4 or 6 deaths? What the hell? That's what this film remembered me. Sry
Actually Band of Brothers is viewed from the stories of those that lived for the most part, if you actually watch it again you will see not only at the end of the episodes but half way through several of them (such as when Winters was promoted out of the company) that they were half strength several times (meaning at least 50 men were dead) and that replacements were killed alot too. Not 4-5, iirc it was closer to a hundred+ by the end in the originals and repleacements lost.
@jaxxx1975 Thank you for pointing out how unrealistic most of these patriotic war movies are. I'm not saying you're right in every point (germany a slave state?!), but it should be said that this wasn't reality.
@jaxxx1975 It was a campaign of several attack, and only the third and fourth made significant gain, taking the high grounds overlooking Ypres. The battle included Four Canadian division, pushing the german line at every assault and holding it, German troop retook it when it was passed to British troop, and not with Canadian defending it.
@Niambag It's ok, but I think europe is uniting in peace and friendship. I don't think canadian soldiers, do not must have to intervene again in a european war. What they, by he way, do not concern! :-D Now the glory of "queen Infantry" is meaningless,"her" time is over. Because the nuclear deterrence creates peace on earth. By the way: I love Canada, will you just do not like your neighbors in the south! Greetings from the European Union, greetings from a EU-Citizen!
@Niambag "economic power" the USA must go to China and say: please buy american products. And don't make our Interest higher. Because 25% of the US-debt belongs to China. The USA is in a Downfall. Don't go with them in the darkness of downfall like their slave state Germany. 90% of the German Gold reservs in New York, for example... I would find new partners like China, Russia or India. But Dr. Angela Merkel think the USA are the Superpower...
@demonlore1234 where the hell did this come from? the first world war had
-NOTHING- to do with jewish people or their faith. this war was mostly about the end of imperialism and old european rivalries. serbians and austria. germany and russia. this war ended the stupidity of anceant battle tactics and pointless slaughter of thousands of soldies. if we had THAT many losses today, america would impeach and or hang the president. it was later that the jews were scapegoated. go back to school.
The price of a mile,140000 dead to capture 5 miles,28000 dead to capture a mile,one dead to capture two inches,260000 German dead,300000 British Empire troops dead,36500 Australian dead,16000 Canadian dead,3596 New Zealand dead,for what...a few miles of mud.
In my American opinion, there aught to be more WWI and II videos about Canada, I just think they didn't get all the credit they deserved. Same with Australia and New Zealand.
Anyways, EXCELLENT movie, ... it's one of my favorites!
aabceacba 2 weeks ago
fuck german scum
qaz4306 3 weeks ago
Belgians FTW , viva the aliance.
Bixze 1 month ago
and french, british.....
pbdimitri 2 months ago
@Scouragerules
you know this is fiction based off of non fiction. its true that very few canadians held the line of passchendaele by themselves waiting for rienforcements that came way to late. it may have not been a squad but a platoon yes. it is easy to defend a trench oppose to taking one, so few could hold off many. Oh, AND THERE CANADIAN!
pbdimitri 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
you must they this GhostDog780430 version /watch?v=l2hpVBH8JOM . one of awesome MV of sabaton
tny0061 3 months ago
хабарное там должно быть местечко...
lubofff100 4 months ago
one of the best war movies i've seen, was shocked when i realized the main guy "Paul Gross" was the guy in Due South
healthenations 5 months ago
@healthenations
Paul Gross is the epitome of Canadian nationalism in acting form. He played an RCMP officer in Due South, a Canada Corps. sargeant in Passchaendale, and an outlaw cowboy in Calgary in Gunless. His acting is really hammy with American levels of patriotic propaganda, but he is definetly a guilty pleasure of mine. I just love seeing a strong, handsome Alberta boy representing this country on the screen.
Aetheilas 2 months ago
@Scouragerules Realistically, attacking forces are said to require 3:1 numbers, assuming troop quality is similar, to capture an entrenched enemy position, this was probably even more pronounced back in those days when 'run across thick mud (explaining why the Germans can't hold hand to hand either, they're knackered from the advance) as quickly as possible toward the machine guns' was the favoured tactic to taking a trench. If the Canadians had been attacking, they would have died in droves too
Soap032 5 months ago
@Soap032 When the Canadians took Passchendaele they did die in droves.
ssejr01 2 months ago
also I get what yall are say'n but to me it looks like alot more Canooks than just the squad shown.
Chimera262 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Ive never heard of this movie it looks awesome? is it Canadian? (is in America)
Chimera262 6 months ago
Great job on this. Best video for this song on youtube.
ez211322 8 months ago
5 soliders died at the wester-front :(
oroszka01 8 months ago
'I died in hell, they called it Passchendaele'
TheBonJovi100 9 months ago 4
Great! Added to favorites
Diablotion 1 year ago
what movie is that frome ?
JOBDDB 1 year ago
the vid fits the song perfectly
cr0wncat 1 year ago
why can't they make a German "patriotic" WWI movie? there very no moraly "corect" side during WWI so why not make one where the germans are rock'n in the begining of the war? it's beond boring to watch all this "All Hail the US" movies. the Germans had the coolest uniforms
TyphorT38 1 year ago
@TyphorT38 all's quite of the western front
and to note these are Canadians NOT Americans in this Video
and the movie was made in Canada not Hollywood
l33th0b0 1 year ago
@l33th0b0 so that makes the german win i take it?
TyphorT38 1 year ago
@TyphorT38 Thank you, for saying something.I really sopport that Idea of a film Not only patriotic, just neural. The biggest problem is, we learn in the school,a lie. (I'm not a conspiracy theorist) We learn after the WW2 only the perspectiv of the brit historian John Röhl.He say: "Germany have the full blame on the WW1" By the way,this is not historically tenable.But we learn such things.Thats the reason for such films.But now the chilean armyAND the swedish palace guards have the best uniform.
jaxxx1975 1 year ago
the video clip is a powerfool like as a music ^_^
mixerar 1 year ago
I think you only need this unite! Because this small unite of 5 soldiers kill whole german Divisions or what?! xD That movie, I think is british humor! xD The last scene are the graves of all Germans, who are killing by this 5 ersons unite, sorry but...
jaxxx1975 1 year ago
@jaxxx1975 It is British humour it is Canadian history, and they are not 5 they are about a half company of the best allied soldier of the time.
Niambag 1 year ago
@Niambag you mean this scene are based on true battle? They killing all Germans and have no no losses? Sorry but, I don't say your soldiers are bad, or something. But this is a little unrealistic! This little Company kill the whole german army, or what? XD What battle of the western Front is this?
Don't check out this scene patriotic, check out this video objectively!
The German imerial army was the best army in europe...
jaxxx1975 1 year ago
@jaxxx1975 they have casualties, this why they end up to be about ten, and it is about the battle of Passchendaele, which is a true battle, and it is very realistic when you consider Canadians won where anyone else could have won. Ypres in 1915, we hold against the German gas and following assault without gas mask. Vimy in 1917, only the Canadians managed to take the hill, Passchendaele, Canada's Hundred days, where Canadian were the spear launch into Germany's defenses.
Niambag 1 year ago
@Niambag We don't begun useing Gas. That was a british idea. Churchill quote: "I decided not understand this sensitivity because of the use of gas, I am sure to use poison gas against uncivilized tribes." sorry I translated the quote from German in english. you mean the Third Battle of Ypres. We won this battle Allied losses of 325,000, only about 260,000 soldiers from the Germans fallen. And the captured allied areas we conquered 1918 back! Senceless wars and battles..
jaxxx1975 1 year ago
@jaxxx1975 I said that Canadian hold against the Gas, it was the only part of the Ypres line who didn't fell during the second battle of Ypres. You should ask yourself why German command and soldier were scared every time they heard Canadian Corp, Germans soldiers gave to Canadian Soldier the name "Sturmtrooper"
Niambag 1 year ago
@Niambag In Canadias schools this battle is importent. But in Germany.... sorry but you are conquered with two canadian divisons, under help from two british divisons, and under losses of 16.000 Canadian soldiers tree villages. Your divisons was a Substitute for New Zealanders. The Canadian force was under the control of british a command. On the 10 October started the battle and on the 10 nevember the british comman broke up the failed attack!
jaxxx1975 1 year ago
@jaxxx1975 NO sry on the 26 Oktober started the attack and on the 10 november the british command aborted the failed attack, because of the big losses...!
Sorry this attack was not so importent, and not really a attack like this scene. 10 Canadian killing all Germans... :-)
jaxxx1975 1 year ago
@jaxxx1975 There were a lot of Can. soldier casualtie/deaths portrayed in this movie. The German commander in this was very kind&cool.
As unimportant as this bitter victory was, it was actually the most significant victory for the allies that year of war. The Can. Commander knew the battle was worthless-the Germans were fortified on the high ground and it was muddy-but Brit. Gen. Haig forced the advance because the allies needed a symbolic victory. And they did won, but paid a heavy price.
misharoyuki 1 year ago
@misharoyuki Thank you. Of course, that was a importent balltle for canada. I don't say you fight not good, bravely and hard. I only criticized this scene! That scene is to much patriotic. But I forgotten, that canadians are no US-americans who think: What I saw in a film, is reallity. I remember the US 10 part Series Band.of.Brother, they this company killed hundreds of Germans but in the end the company have... what?... 4 or 6 deaths? What the hell? That's what this film remembered me. Sry
jaxxx1975 1 year ago
@jaxxx1975
Actually Band of Brothers is viewed from the stories of those that lived for the most part, if you actually watch it again you will see not only at the end of the episodes but half way through several of them (such as when Winters was promoted out of the company) that they were half strength several times (meaning at least 50 men were dead) and that replacements were killed alot too. Not 4-5, iirc it was closer to a hundred+ by the end in the originals and repleacements lost.
MitchofSmeg 10 months ago
@jaxxx1975 Thank you for pointing out how unrealistic most of these patriotic war movies are. I'm not saying you're right in every point (germany a slave state?!), but it should be said that this wasn't reality.
silberstreif 6 months ago
@jaxxx1975 It was a campaign of several attack, and only the third and fourth made significant gain, taking the high grounds overlooking Ypres. The battle included Four Canadian division, pushing the german line at every assault and holding it, German troop retook it when it was passed to British troop, and not with Canadian defending it.
Niambag 1 year ago
@Niambag It's ok, but I think europe is uniting in peace and friendship. I don't think canadian soldiers, do not must have to intervene again in a european war. What they, by he way, do not concern! :-D Now the glory of "queen Infantry" is meaningless,"her" time is over. Because the nuclear deterrence creates peace on earth. By the way: I love Canada, will you just do not like your neighbors in the south! Greetings from the European Union, greetings from a EU-Citizen!
jaxxx1975 1 year ago
@jaxxx1975 I don't like my southern neighbors too, if it wasn't for their economic power.
Niambag 1 year ago
@Niambag "economic power" the USA must go to China and say: please buy american products. And don't make our Interest higher. Because 25% of the US-debt belongs to China. The USA is in a Downfall. Don't go with them in the darkness of downfall like their slave state Germany. 90% of the German Gold reservs in New York, for example... I would find new partners like China, Russia or India. But Dr. Angela Merkel think the USA are the Superpower...
jaxxx1975 1 year ago
Someone told me earlier today, "I don't like war, war is bad."
To which I replied, "Yeah, but some ass holes make it necessary."
John3Sobieski 1 year ago 3
RIP total war
UnkownSoldier117 1 year ago
Great vid man! :D I think you should add subtitles to this :)
Agge6991 1 year ago
poor Germans in WWI they dident deserve this WWII they had it comeing :/(Super work by the way :3 )
Rebs96 1 year ago
these men died so big fat jews could get rich off the interest
demonlore1234 1 year ago
@demonlore1234 have you nothing intelligent to tell?
Infernalicon 1 year ago
@demonlore1234 where the hell did this come from? the first world war had
-NOTHING- to do with jewish people or their faith. this war was mostly about the end of imperialism and old european rivalries. serbians and austria. germany and russia. this war ended the stupidity of anceant battle tactics and pointless slaughter of thousands of soldies. if we had THAT many losses today, america would impeach and or hang the president. it was later that the jews were scapegoated. go back to school.
RPGfanatic100 1 year ago
super video
michalpinterer 1 year ago
who is who in the video?
MarsImperator2 1 year ago
I didn't like the movie except for the battle scene, and with Sabaton that battle is just awsome!
crusader1096 1 year ago
Comment removed
ACSfuhrer 1 year ago
The movie sucks! But SABATON are great once again! \m/
MarkCicerone 2 years ago
Beautiful video. Paschendaelle is dark card in history of human. So many lives losted for a handful of mud
brugge216 2 years ago 2
for what has ww1 actually been fought.
as its just more then a million soldiers died becouse the elites (government) want that part?
pagman95 2 years ago
@pagman95 of mud*
pagman95 2 years ago
profits
hunbalam 2 years ago
Movie?
kreejumss 2 years ago
It's written in the info : movie Passchendaele
Drendagon 2 years ago 4
@Drendagon
great movie
laurencedeer9 1 year ago
@kreejumss Don't watch it. 110 minutes, 10-15 minutes war, the rest romance. Pearl Harbour is a serious war movie compared to this POS.
Murmelmann 1 year ago
@kreejumss In the description thats says "2008 movie Passchendaele", thumbs up if you think guy didnt even look at the info
minja714 1 year ago
If the British and Germans still have that kind of power The world would be different from today. Nice Vid 9999999999/1 LONG LIVE THE EMPIRE
TheFerkala 2 years ago
5/5
POLAND
Lyfczarka 2 years ago 2
Long Live Sabaton , they teach history better than any teacher could ! ATTERO DOMINATUS
davesykes1966 2 years ago 3
There's no Honor, in war. Only fear.
Mikita12131323213 2 years ago 2
The price of a mile,140000 dead to capture 5 miles,28000 dead to capture a mile,one dead to capture two inches,260000 German dead,300000 British Empire troops dead,36500 Australian dead,16000 Canadian dead,3596 New Zealand dead,for what...a few miles of mud.
Kayakspearo1 2 years ago 5
awesome vid !!!!
MAMEMAN1975 2 years ago 4
Nice credits and once again great video
From Poland
Sabaton RULE
kapral009 2 years ago
Great Video For a Great Song
5/5
From Poland
kapral009 2 years ago 7
super..super !!!!!!!!!!
extra video Drendagon 5/5
darmy34 2 years ago 19
Great video :-) Keep 'em coming!
Volkos 2 years ago 8
Well done, bro ;)
Skyforger8787 2 years ago 8
Nice one! Keep up the good work!
Sabaton 2 years ago 37