Added: 5 years ago
From: grunzy
Views: 138,798
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (395)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Comment removed

  • I love her

  • Are you kidding me...

  • goddess!!!

  • Put that whining cat out of its misery.

  • not bad but yep not as good ans Bianca tbh

  • She rocks

  • Good but too loud on the low nuts and too soft on the high notes.

  • Not bad. Better if you don't watch her. She's cute, but it looks as if she's reaching too hard.

  • great fucking job.so close to the original

  • hooooooo por dios que interpretacion :))))

  • Clare Torry...the one and only.

  • ach....no....no....sorry...str­ong voice but no for Floydian's song.....

  • where is the "echo" ? what happened to the sound man?

  • ya gotta give the lady her props !... it's no easy task ... but i would to hear Liv Kristine cover this ...

  • Wow, that was as close as you can get to the real thing. Awesome job !

  • Beautiful and totally meant to sing this song. How dare anyone say she is unfit; this chick rocks it.

  • so wonderful!!! thank you

  • Clare Torry is the one and only greatest gig in the universe FULL STOP

  • SHe has a nice voice, but she is no substitute for Clare Torry, but neither is Bianca! Bianca is good, but even she is no comparison to Clare.

  • And FYI, regardless of what anyone's opinion is of her voice not being as strong in some parts as someone elses voice, or that she smiles too much or whatever... the one thing that watching this confirms is that the ladies singing this live are doing it about 95% note for note to the original recording which is totally INSANE to pull off. BTW, I think this vocalist sounds absolutely beautiful on the softer notes towards the last few minutes of this song.

  • Comment removed

  • just to have the balls to do this is serious enough, she does a good job, but I think what she lacked was the ability to evoke emotion, in the same respect as Claire Torrey or Bianca do

  • flawless n beautiful

  • This is a good performance but to much smiling, this song is about dying.

  • My favorite is Natalie Azared.  Actually Bianca too. This girl can sing certainly better than me. Chilling, all of them.

  • she has a great voice, but she's not singing it as toppy as it should be... she needs more practice and more artistic and musical...

    nice try :)

  • She has a great voice, but not meant for this song!

  • Agree

  • Agree...

  • Bianca kicked her ass.

  • @FroggyOne2 Bianca was better but she didn't kick her ass or anything. My god...this is a piece of music not a football game. This girl did a respectable cover of Great Gig - as opposed to the over the top '"screamers" I've heard in the past. Having said that - Bianca's version is the most awesome

  • No way this was better -__- it was ok but listen closely she doesn't even hit the right key at times... I still think it was good though.

  • good but not even close

  • Godo voice, for sure but missed those important middle - high notes imo. But fuck me, she can sing. No doubt about that... this song is hard to replicate due to it being nailed in two takes. "This song is about death, sing it" how can you replicate raw emotion?

  • Superb Job, no denying the woman has talent, one of the better if not best covers I ve

    heard. 

  • a great effort like but not the best ..in my view.....but much credit to the lass......

  • Sam Brown Earls court Pulse dvd division bell tour superb . but this girl is quality make no mistake

  • speachless

    

  • @azax22attica even speechless?? lol

  • speachless

  • wtf are some of you smoking? that was fucking fantastic!

  • this is the only song in which no one can sing without making ridiculous faces

  • Fantastic  exaccly like Clare Torry

  • Shortly - Great Gig n the sky , Beautiful girl but ... what a lot of average singing, Sorry ...

  • you are fantastic, incredible sound and voice...

  • The most faithful vocal performance I've heard of this song yet. Keep up the good work, Sharon. And to the rest of the band - simply great.

  • Some Floyd songs should never be redone

  • bunch a sorry people on here got negative stuff to say about a group of people that love to play floyd and pay homage to them.

  • WOW! Any of the nay sayers just wish they could sing like that. The best rendition of the song I've heard. Seen and heard some live Pink Floyd and you did better. Note for note. Most of the singers try to add a little or alot of their own vibe. You hit it Note For Note. Those that say you missed, post someone that hit it better.

  • @llaaragon Are you on drugs? Better than Pink Floyd? Better than Clare Torry? Not a bad rendition - respect an all but "Better" You need to get out more dude!!!

    And i post Clare Torry dude (BEAT HER)!!

  • there is something missing? ! no timber

  • I think it's pretty amazing. i know i certainly can't sing any of this and she does a pretty darn good job of it. we didn't all see Pink Floyd perform this so this tribute band must continue the live legacy. if they ever come to the east coast, i'll be sure to see em. keep singing, lady.

  • She really tried well and succeeded in most of the places.., but I will agree with the NO,,, cuz she missed the most critical notes... her laryx would break if she even tried to reach those nodes. I am pretty sure she knows and working on improving those notes.

  • Intenso

  • If nothing else, proof that the little ads on the right side of Facebook do work for some odd reason I've been seeing ads for this cover band. As for the song itself, some recordings should just never be done live. This song in same category as "A Day In the Life," if McCartney sucks doing his own song, how could you expect a cover band to do anything from Dark Side of the Moon any justice. lower case fail :)

  • By far, the best cover of Great Gig In The Sky by PF, I´ve seen... what a vocal performance.... Greets from Denmark

  • Women are so Sexy :)

  • I doubt even the fair Claire Torry could have nailed it this close a second time.

  • well, what can an old polite hippie say..ma'am,,that was a nice try.

  • @OldHippieMatt

    Lol, you're right :)

  • damn girl you can sing

  • A pretty Lady and gotten some neat tune ablibbed OK and done fine for me.

    Reminds me of another famous singer named Gracie Slick wonder if they're related?

  • @thanksyounow ..she does kinda remind ya of Gracie..just a lil...physically anyway.

  • the original was a white girl in the 1972......

  • When you can hit 99.8% of someone else's gut improvisation in a vocal range as wide as the one demanded by this song, you're nailin' it... This girl rocks.

  • I havent seen a white girl yet his the proper range at the highest part... The original was a black girl in 1972...

  • Ela poderia me acordar todos os dias, cantando assim ao meu ouvido!

  • Great range, your great!

  • she is so SEXY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • 107,190 I'm good fer 20 or so views!!!!

  • You guys are crazy !!! Do you know exactly how hard that song is to do !?! I have been in or around bands for 27 years and yes she nailed it ! Critics...well jealous if you ask me !

  • How is this a no? Shes amazing!

  • Great voice!!!...apologies for saying so, but doesnt fit this song :(

  • Un F'n believable!!!!! GREAT Job!!!!...Nice voice!!..leave the band and go get signed somewhere!

  • teeth on that !

  • Great job, wow, never heard of these guys. 

  • not to bad sounding sharon did a good copy in this version - a good remake of this song by Bianka Antoinette is a good remake as well - i do agree that Clare Torrie did it the very best but in all the other version's i have herd these are the best and the pink floyd pulse version is good as well but not as good as the original

  • One of the better covers of this extremely difficult song.

  • very good! with the very difficult song to sing 9.8

    loved it!

  • Hey guys, I found Sharon's current original band online it's called Savant. I actually like the tunes. It's not Pink Floyd, but it's pretty sweet!

  • what a angel

  • very impressive cover

  • I can't help it... I cry every single time I hear this song!

  • to all the people who cant seem to comment positively. Let me enlighten you to this womans talent. Clare Torry rarely sang this song completely through live. They girls didnt switch during live setting just to give eachother turns in the limelight. So major props to Sharon for being able to carry her very beautiful voice completely through the entire piece so strongly. Now of course she's not Clare. but this is probably the the best it is done other wise.

  • well i got goose pimples :-)

  • a mi me gusto mucho este cover, canta muy bien y aun le queda tiempo para sonreír, excelente

  • i saw them live at the o.c fair, and all ican say is " fricking amazing" so what if they arent original? they did an amazing job covering the greatest songs on earth

  • brill...you are awesome...

  • just saw them t0day at the 0C Fair XD

    it was g0dly and s0 musik m0ving and during one 0f the s0ngs i swear i smelt weed XD

  • at minute 3:10 you decide if is she really a good performer, because of the change of tune to loud aun more sweet, definitely sh'e beatifula and she made it well at the beginiing, but she disapointed me in that part.

  • Great vocals, but the high notes need to be a little more robust.

  • ביצוע מצויין!!!

  • Not as good as the lady who sings this for TAPFS.

    Ouch!

  • 1st: As a lifelong lover of "soul music," I have to say this is the deepest piece of utter and absolute soul music that I know of.

    2nd: This is definately a White woman's song. I've only heard one Black woman who could pull it off.

    3rd: I'd love for Chaka Khan to give her best to save the reputation of Black women as soul singers.

    4th: To hear Karen Carpenter "getting throaty" between going high on this. I've never heard any singer who could really dig into deep tones for this.

  • More acid.

  • Not bad. Some of the high notes are flat.

    Bianca Antionette is still the best (after Clare Torry).

  • EX-CEL-LENT!

  • flat flat flat...sorry sharon. more range needed.

  • لقد وحقوق ما بعد أنها ☺

  • La mejor version de esta cancion

  • shes awesome  an ofc pink floyd is too

  • she shines

  • Well done. Sharon needs to detach herself from the experience and really feel the music. She has a tremendous voice that is well capable of hitting all the notes accurately (she demonstrated that for sure) and with the intensity and emotion needed to really get it over. She has it within her

  • falta volume, mas ela faz o trabalho de 3, ela é fantastica, da proxima vez grita mais...

  • very good

  • absolutely brill went to c australian pink floyd in manchester last night was facinated the lighting was out of this world keep it up u lot well worth £35 MIZZY XXX

  • desafina en un par de notas y llega sin aire...

  • I would not call it talent when it is the ability to trash and desecrate a masterpiece of Pink Floyd without shame while someone with zero talent as a music critic is bewitched enough to call it immeasurable talent.

  • Listening to her poor singing is bad enough.

    Seeing her whorish smile and demeanor that desecrate this Pink Floyd masterpiece is an absolute eyesore.(0:50-0:57, 1:10-1:12 , 2:33-2:39, 3:44-3:48, 4:12-4:13).

    I need to watch the soulful rendition by the ladies of TAPFS as an antidote after watching this trashy performance.

  • awesome...just awesome...what a voice

  • when I looked at the girl that it was going to sing i tough that she wouldn't have voice for this song but WOAH

  • Im 58 and listened to the great gig in the sky many many times but this girl is unbelievable, a voice to send the angels to singing lessons, a talent that has bought a tear to my eyes, also  very nice looking

  • damn pretty fuckin sick man ill be playin with those guys in june cant wait to see the guys live

  • hmmm not for me.the best one ive seen is from the australian pink floyd TAPFS go check that out

  • Which One's Pink is the best PF tribute band on YouTube. Period. Don't waste your time watching other posts...

  • @PetPiv no mate go look at TAPFS them two girls nail it!! trust me

  • @PetPiv no mate go look at TAPFS them two girls nail it!! trust me

  • :S no. try again.

  • very nice

  • Hello

  • the best cover from all that i have seen,.

  • Nice try... but in the end... its a No.

  • Not bad, but she lacks the intensity of the original.

  • Ugh, a bit weak on the high intense one s.

  • I love her!

  • Damn man

    I think i just fell in love.. :D

  • i loved it!!!!

  • good cover shes pretty too

  • Pink Floyd would be proud. And to do it live? Whew! go on with your bad selfs!lol! i enjoyed !

  • sounds like shes having a long orgasm

  • well I dont know why is your comment rated so bad but it is fact that in original vesion on The dark side of the moon, Clare Torry was told that she must sing like having long and strong ORGASM!!

  • lol yea i dont know how people dont get that, its the first thing that i think of with this song

  • @MySmegma ...... Little correction: Torry was said to sing without words...to pretend she a musical instrument. At least that's what Rick Wright said in his interview here on YouTube... Torry did it on 2nd try, apologized to Wright, left the studio and never sang it again....

  • Nice teeth!

  • she is nowhere near being in tune

  • Then you, sir, must have a tin ear. She is completely in tune.

  • she is in TUNE!! great performance!!!

  • Nada como el original

  • So what? They are not the originals.

  • @grunzy  When you watch covers, there's no idea to compear with originals. Of course originals are better : there's no competition with them, that's stupid !!! By the time, this one is not at the level of TAPFS. Far away...!!!

  • @grunzy exactly, that's why, nada como el orginal

  • @betojon Dude... of course it's not the original. HOWEVER, if you ever see this band live you will be freaked out! I've never heard such a great floyd performance. They are the real deal!

  • @betojon Cualquier version bien interpretada merece respeto, y no la critica de alguien que solo critica y no actua.

  • David Gilmar should see this... Amazing cover!!! the best

  • muy copado el tema, muy grosa cantando la loca...

  • One of the best vocals ive heard for this song

  • Great Job... Loved It...

  • Stupid joke. Sharon- no Rachel.

  • Pink Floyd wrote "Dogs".

  • OMG, I just crapped my pants haha, this cover is fucking amazing....I fell in love with her voice...

  • fuckin great

  • sorry....not rellay

  • muy buena identica al original

  • Amazing cover!

  • What I like about her is that she doesn't try to put her own spin on it like most of the other covers.

  • que grande! impresionante la voz de esta chica y la version mas que correcta.

  • It will never cease to amaze me that people with zero talent critique those with talent. All who try this cover have immeasurable talent when comparerd to their critics

  • @vfwilson

    because as human beings we have the ability to judge the fuck out of people.. and yes we can't do it... and since we can't do it, we sure as hell can point out someone else who can't. which is the case here.

  • Pretty good. But not better than the original.

  • She's not bad, just the original is naturally better. She's even one of the best at singing this, for most of the cover of the Great Gig are pure shit. Don't be too harsh, consider it is just a cover.

  • true

  • Close but no cigar, theres no one like Clare Torry, think about it, she was asked to improvise a vocal to music and to just think about death, life and love. Clare pulled it off like no one else can because every one else has what she did to go by. But all and all a good performance by Sharon Fatoorechi.

  • I agree in the fact that Clare Torry really was in touch with "The Great Gig in the Sky"!

  • not as bad as i thot, but still not even close, though i do think great gig is probly one of the most hardest songs to sing ever recorded

  • mich021188 20 years old baby whith no hair on his balls

  • the day this song does not raise the hairs on my balls ,I will be dead

  • @andiman45 HAHAHA.

  • @andiman45

    well said! This is a song i'd like to listen to as i lay there.. ready to be up there with the spirits in the sky..

  • @andiman45 HAHA! dude...SAME

  • @andiman45  LMAO!

  • @andiman45 or the day you decide to shave your balls and it ends up raising something else. Great tune til eternity! Never get sick of it.

  • Pretty damn good if you ask me!

  • Not that bad. You should check out that fuckin horrible aussie floyd SHITE. Its fucking dreadful, especially so concidering that most of it is on track...

    F.U.C.K.I.N.G. W.A.N.K!!!