Too many children are being labled!! Every child or person is different!!!! Maybe they don't want to communicate because they know were to dumb to listen or understand!!!!!!Autism is a wonderful gift. It's just not understood yet. We are entering a new world cant you see it comming. We better step up and take notice!!!!!!!
There are actually some good reasons for labeling. My eldest has shown several autistic traits since she was very small. She has outgrown some and learned to suppress/exploit others, but as she entered high school she started showing signs of her dad's bipolar. When we took her in for evaluation the doc noticed some of the old anxiety traits and immediately concluded she was schizophrenic! If she'd been diagnosed as AS earlier he would have known it was just her way.
However, the comments about being "drained by people" could simply mean that he's an introvert. Look up Meyer's Briggs. In reality we all have elements of introversion and extroversion. But about one in four people is primarily an introvert and the vast majority of them do not have Asperger's or autism. Also people with trouble developing social skills due to CAPD-like myself-can be extroverts who enjoy people but often don't understand them.
Your video is very interesting to me. My son (10) does it with water, sand, etc. too. He's pretty verbal and has HF autism. The interesting part is that when they do cognitive tests on him, he scores highest on the pattern portion. In 2nd grade his ability in patterns was as high as a 19-21 year old. I always knew he was extremely visually perceptive. Occassionally, I see an artistic side to him and it will be interesting to see if it develops over time. Great video for thought!
Standing Ovatation for that one : ) Awesome video and I so wish the public school teachers and educators would get this. It seems I am constantly fighting the school to stop squelching my child's learning ability and squashing their spirit by demanding they conform to their one size fits all way.
to never know what a skill was. When I found out, I realized it was my ability to see patterns everywhere. No wonder I sometimes can't stay calm unless I am doodling. No wonder
I could never understand the patterns in sand throwing that Braden, my son and other autistics have. After watching this, I have a new perspective, Andy Goldsworthy is an amazing artist and clearly demonstrates it. They can see patterns we can't.
Outstanding video, Phil! Thanks for addressing this in a direct and straightforward manner. I have always had difficulty expressing this to others. In the future, I will ask them to watch this video. You have helped me and I am sure others a lot with this video.
First, I think it has always been known that true genius - art, math, science, music - usually comes with a price. They are seldom "normal" so maybe the AS community has a point.
My guess is that Goldsworthy has some form of AS and I agree with you that he is abled, not disabled. However, I also happen to believe that it is inappropriate to consider AS a disability.
Everyone has strengthens and weaknesses. Viva la difference.
I think it's a really cool fact that Albert Einstein proved the existence of the Atom after looking at the way dust grains moves in water even though the water is still - a pehonomenon most scientists thought was strange but uninteresting, while Einstein found it highly fascinating.
Too many children are being labled!! Every child or person is different!!!! Maybe they don't want to communicate because they know were to dumb to listen or understand!!!!!!Autism is a wonderful gift. It's just not understood yet. We are entering a new world cant you see it comming. We better step up and take notice!!!!!!!
Motherkuen 2 years ago
There are actually some good reasons for labeling. My eldest has shown several autistic traits since she was very small. She has outgrown some and learned to suppress/exploit others, but as she entered high school she started showing signs of her dad's bipolar. When we took her in for evaluation the doc noticed some of the old anxiety traits and immediately concluded she was schizophrenic! If she'd been diagnosed as AS earlier he would have known it was just her way.
baqaqi 2 years ago
I love Andy Goldsworthy!!
However, the comments about being "drained by people" could simply mean that he's an introvert. Look up Meyer's Briggs. In reality we all have elements of introversion and extroversion. But about one in four people is primarily an introvert and the vast majority of them do not have Asperger's or autism. Also people with trouble developing social skills due to CAPD-like myself-can be extroverts who enjoy people but often don't understand them.
Scanlonam 3 years ago
If it was a case that the NT's and people with autism were swapped around then the NT's would actually need help to cope in our society.
You really are taking opinions of quite a few of the autistic community phil and I appreciate it.
When I was younger I used to have an obsession with pinecones, never knew why but now I think it was the paterns as I loved the way they looked
BenedictC 3 years ago
Your video is very interesting to me. My son (10) does it with water, sand, etc. too. He's pretty verbal and has HF autism. The interesting part is that when they do cognitive tests on him, he scores highest on the pattern portion. In 2nd grade his ability in patterns was as high as a 19-21 year old. I always knew he was extremely visually perceptive. Occassionally, I see an artistic side to him and it will be interesting to see if it develops over time. Great video for thought!
Carla
gabrielknight11 3 years ago
I really enjoyed this perspective. I have heard of Andy Goldsworth and I love his work, we should be encouraging childrens skills and work with them.
Thanks
MarSuk 3 years ago
Good video! I like that guys artwork.
jon2xu 3 years ago
Standing Ovatation for that one : ) Awesome video and I so wish the public school teachers and educators would get this. It seems I am constantly fighting the school to stop squelching my child's learning ability and squashing their spirit by demanding they conform to their one size fits all way.
FriscoF7 3 years ago 5
Definitely a very well researched and produced case study :)
djfmitv 3 years ago
Thanks for this excellent video. I used
to never know what a skill was. When I found out, I realized it was my ability to see patterns everywhere. No wonder I sometimes can't stay calm unless I am doodling. No wonder
colors "dance".
limeslimey 3 years ago
Excellent video!!
I could never understand the patterns in sand throwing that Braden, my son and other autistics have. After watching this, I have a new perspective, Andy Goldsworthy is an amazing artist and clearly demonstrates it. They can see patterns we can't.
Nice work.
Go Leaf's Go!!!
leoleponge 3 years ago 3
Oh sand is just the begining, Try ripples and lights dancing about...Ah, the experience, I will someday share poems about it when I get a new webcam
Serge165 3 years ago
Outstanding video, Phil! Thanks for addressing this in a direct and straightforward manner. I have always had difficulty expressing this to others. In the future, I will ask them to watch this video. You have helped me and I am sure others a lot with this video.
Nena
Aragonpr 3 years ago
First, I think it has always been known that true genius - art, math, science, music - usually comes with a price. They are seldom "normal" so maybe the AS community has a point.
My guess is that Goldsworthy has some form of AS and I agree with you that he is abled, not disabled. However, I also happen to believe that it is inappropriate to consider AS a disability.
Everyone has strengthens and weaknesses. Viva la difference.
666sigma 3 years ago 3
Great vid!
I think it's a really cool fact that Albert Einstein proved the existence of the Atom after looking at the way dust grains moves in water even though the water is still - a pehonomenon most scientists thought was strange but uninteresting, while Einstein found it highly fascinating.
ischlopischlo 3 years ago 3
If he is in his own world, then how is he Manifesting physically in this one?. Yes, the child is watching the patterns of sand, I've done it before
Serge165 3 years ago 3