Poor Victoria..But the end of Julian is the saddest. He was an alcoholic and addicted to the casino, his wife was cheating on him and then saw Victoria's death. But they were together at the end.. So it's an amazing story.
@Psykko911 Yes, this is both the CD Live Scenes From New York and the DVD Metropolis 2000: Scenes From New York, hate how not all the songs from the CD are on the DVD.
all respect James Labrie,I couldn't even think of anyone who's able to peform this ridiculously hard song live,with all the poisining shit u been through,of course i wasn't expecting u covering all the notes u hit in the studio,but u were mindblowing,Long live DT from Syria
@zonic26 dude the full album is like that, the intro piano solo in one last time is a guitar solo in finally free, the dance of eternity part that comes just before rudess's ragtime solo is there in overture 1928, labries last part in metropolis pt 1 is played as a guitar solo in it too, home has so many parts of metropolis in it, there are millions of repetitions which makes the album so interesting
@abhimuscat Regession contains a part from The Spirit Carries On, One Last Time also contains a part from Overture 1928 and Strange Deja Vu, Through My Words and Through Her Eyes also contain repetitive parts, those are all the songs I've noticed using same parts, but never noticed any Metropolis pt 1 parts in Home, I heard it was Regression which also has parts of that song from IAW, this was even before the Twelve-step Suite from the albums SDOIT to BCSL.
@zonic26 lets see home.....first verse on high hats portnoy plays the ostinato pattern that metropolis pt 1 first verse riff has, then the rest of the verse has the same drum beat, the chorus contains subtles parts which individually is hard to point out but as a whole is noticeable, second verse the jungle groove...same as the one where labrie sings i was told a new love was born......and tons more references, theres a video somewhere of portnoy showing those parts
@zonic26 You can hear parts from Metropolis in Overture, and that part is in Home too but i guess in Home is slower :S
When they say "Metropolis watches and thoughtfully smiles
She's taken you to your home " that part is the same that Home but in Home it's: "Victoria watches and thoughtfully smiles, she's taking me to my home".. is the same in rythm and lyrics.
@universalmind38 I saw a comment saying that (the first line) on The Spirit Carries On from this DVD and I had only been a fan of DT a while after BCSL came out and before Mike left and I stopped listening for a few days and then Another Day brought me back into listening to them, I got back to listening a few days after and when I listen, it doesn't feel like there's no more Mike, I don't know why
Scenes remains as one of the greatest (progressive) metal albums of the last decade. It's one of the most melodically coherent as well as technically brilliant albums I've ever heard.
@Professsor OK. I like it :-) Esp.: 9:36-9:38 Just that little "run", or whatever it is called. But you're right, the drum solo is pretty epic. It is Dream Theater, almost every note of all songs are epic! I mean, DT is putting 4 gods together in one band ;-)
that is my favorite part of the entire dvd ( with a change of seassons and learning to live ) .. I mean, if you pit in the context of the album, it was just unespected after that massive drum solo and minor scale to come up with that. It gives me goose bumps everytime
@Professsor Actually, it is a variation on "One Last Time", the song After "The Dance Of Eternity" and after "The Spirit Carries On". So, it shouldn't annoy you if you understand what the notes mean.
cuando escuche este tema en santiago no la podia kreer que estubiera ai or la csm ademas cuasndo espezaron los gritos de la mina gritaba mas yo que la wna grande deram ctm !!
@swantonbomberx It sounds like he's actually playing in a different time signature.
Musicians will sometimes do that if they're really good at it. I've heard things like that before, but not so drastically like Portnoy doing it there.
I'd take my own life before losing you....I know I've already lost you...but I'm hoping for a change....wishing you will come back....that's why I'm not dead yet....I LOVE YOU.....and ALWAYS WILL......:(:(:(
That's one of the things I like better about this version. He's not sounding so great in this song (guessing that's cause he'd been singing for a while at that point), but that's one of the things that makes this version better. The very end of the song is beautiful, I wish it was on the album version.
Lacks the technicality of most well known Dream Theater songs, but easily one of the best. Has a lot of depth and originality to it; I wish DT would stop wanking Constant motion songs and come back and make a great concept album like SFAM!
James tried so hard to destroy the song..Couldn't do it...But those high parts he sang...THES FEELEN ENSAID OF MEEEEE FANALE FAUND MA LAV A FANALE FREEEE ... Damn it :D
This song is definitely one of my favorites, up their with Voices, and Learning to Live. The vocals are powerful enough to make an entire nunnery instantaneously orgasm with exploding hymens causing many nuns to drown in a see of vagoo blood.
Portnoy:[God mode cheat on]
abyildirim35 1 day ago
Open your legs Nicholas
StreamlessSilence 3 weeks ago 3
[ . . . ] Open your eyes Nicholas ! .
25245638 3 weeks ago
8:28 - 8:37 Portnoy GOD
Drumsmadness 1 month ago 2
I'm so happy that I own this on vinyl now :D
abstract37 1 month ago
mike portnoy and drummer most creative of all time
OPUSPICA 1 month ago
Poor Victoria..But the end of Julian is the saddest. He was an alcoholic and addicted to the casino, his wife was cheating on him and then saw Victoria's death. But they were together at the end.. So it's an amazing story.
anqipiqi 1 month ago
Victoria's such a slut.
engraveddrummer 3 months ago 7
ესეც ხომ რათქმაუნდა !!!
davitdavit87 3 months ago
EPIC
tidealagain1 4 months ago
Holy mother of God!!!!!!!!!!! I just had 10 eargasms in a row.
Callidus2009 4 months ago
9:09 = fainting on account of most epic fill ever!
Sage80 5 months ago
Oh god I love the cheesyness of the scenes
yaedrex 6 months ago
@yaedrex i hate it. it's too bad music so good has to be ruined with such horrible lyrics.
Sage80 5 months ago
@Sage80 Lyrics are amazing!! The whole story is just awesome and wonderful:
anqipiqi 1 month ago
John Myung makes bass playing looks easy as move forward
TheAaronKiddo 6 months ago
Best song ever!
ermac210 7 months ago
10 persons won't finally be free ^^
Tigrousauteur 7 months ago 2
my fav part at 4:08 :D
csarvids 7 months ago
@csarvids xDD
anqipiqi 1 month ago
Ten people lives are a Fatal Tragedy.
daks46 7 months ago 6
is this from a movie or what? i really want to know please!!
viktordiaz 7 months ago
@viktordiaz It's a conceptual album.
anqipiqi 1 month ago
@TheDjentinator Yeah, I checked it. Seems different
bezowashere 7 months ago
The keyboardist is not Jordan Rudess , right ?
bezowashere 7 months ago
@bezowashere of course its jordan^^ with hair! :D
Feal9123 7 months ago 2
I think this song is 100% perfect <3 the replay button broke :P
Plelute 8 months ago
5:03 DEEEOOOWWWWNNN LOL
larztallica316 8 months ago 2
God would have a hard time trying to play that drum solo.
homsiz 9 months ago
lol...saw an nissan at the begining and victoria time is 1930's
MrIdontknowanyname 9 months ago
@MrIdontknowanyname the Nissan belongs to Nicholas, the person who's eyes the story is told from in the present.
TantrumFTW 9 months ago 2
oh God ,tht was a fine summer !!!! i luv it !!
malenamax 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
james at 6:52
ChrisGuitarbeast 9 months ago
Comment removed
ChrisGuitarbeast 9 months ago
Comment removed
ChrisGuitarbeast 9 months ago
ruddess with hair
wow!!
TheRocker0619 9 months ago 3
04:10 lol
preppychrisbou 9 months ago
@preppychrisbou Those guys are really bad at acting xD
anqipiqi 1 month ago
best drum solo ever!i love how he is just raping the song...no need to make a special spot for the solo...it flows so easily
jf506 10 months ago
it's such a good solo, nothing really exiting JAJJAJAJAJA MIKE=GOD
TheRockerman17 10 months ago
labrie....the man who can make any band awesome
abhimuscat 10 months ago
is this from live scenes from new york
Psykko911 10 months ago
@Psykko911 Yes, this is both the CD Live Scenes From New York and the DVD Metropolis 2000: Scenes From New York, hate how not all the songs from the CD are on the DVD.
zonic26 9 months ago
i love the video.... is fantastic
mddy1987ED 10 months ago
man those crappy sound effects that are used in like every tv show really ruin the part with the shooting
niabwerd 10 months ago
all respect James Labrie,I couldn't even think of anyone who's able to peform this ridiculously hard song live,with all the poisining shit u been through,of course i wasn't expecting u covering all the notes u hit in the studio,but u were mindblowing,Long live DT from Syria
reslanreslan 1 year ago 4
look at myung shoes.. awesome!
viktordiaz 1 year ago
Comment removed
viktordiaz 1 year ago
The fill at 08:45 - when he doubles over the octobans should technically blow your head clean from your body it is so good.
Rhys96 1 year ago
4:48 is a re-used part from One Last Time
zonic26 1 year ago
@zonic26 dude the full album is like that, the intro piano solo in one last time is a guitar solo in finally free, the dance of eternity part that comes just before rudess's ragtime solo is there in overture 1928, labries last part in metropolis pt 1 is played as a guitar solo in it too, home has so many parts of metropolis in it, there are millions of repetitions which makes the album so interesting
abhimuscat 1 year ago
@abhimuscat Regession contains a part from The Spirit Carries On, One Last Time also contains a part from Overture 1928 and Strange Deja Vu, Through My Words and Through Her Eyes also contain repetitive parts, those are all the songs I've noticed using same parts, but never noticed any Metropolis pt 1 parts in Home, I heard it was Regression which also has parts of that song from IAW, this was even before the Twelve-step Suite from the albums SDOIT to BCSL.
zonic26 1 year ago
@zonic26 lets see home.....first verse on high hats portnoy plays the ostinato pattern that metropolis pt 1 first verse riff has, then the rest of the verse has the same drum beat, the chorus contains subtles parts which individually is hard to point out but as a whole is noticeable, second verse the jungle groove...same as the one where labrie sings i was told a new love was born......and tons more references, theres a video somewhere of portnoy showing those parts
abhimuscat 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@zonic26 You can hear parts from Metropolis in Overture, and that part is in Home too but i guess in Home is slower :S
When they say "Metropolis watches and thoughtfully smiles
She's taken you to your home " that part is the same that Home but in Home it's: "Victoria watches and thoughtfully smiles, she's taking me to my home".. is the same in rythm and lyrics.
anqipiqi 1 month ago
Since MPs departure, I haven't been listening to Dream Theater's album ever since...
Dream Theater is the best prog-metal band around. I hope they can still create great music even w/o MP.
universalmind38 1 year ago
@universalmind38 I saw a comment saying that (the first line) on The Spirit Carries On from this DVD and I had only been a fan of DT a while after BCSL came out and before Mike left and I stopped listening for a few days and then Another Day brought me back into listening to them, I got back to listening a few days after and when I listen, it doesn't feel like there's no more Mike, I don't know why
zonic26 1 year ago
Scenes remains as one of the greatest (progressive) metal albums of the last decade. It's one of the most melodically coherent as well as technically brilliant albums I've ever heard.
jsnake01 1 year ago
TRAGICO !!!
anamgify 1 year ago
look at the pants James is wearing
zonic26 1 year ago 2
@zonic26 I can't see his pants, but I can see his trousers...
Professsor 1 year ago 34
@Professsor same thing, they don't differ but they look like something a woman would wear
zonic26 1 year ago
@Professsor hahahahahah XD
Baustelle11 8 months ago
the best progressive band ever.
MrMadSnukky 1 year ago 17
@MrMadSnukky No. Best BAND ever. Get it right :P
Professsor 1 year ago 46
@MrMadSnukky I disagree. I think the best was Genesis. But it's just my opinion. ;)
Btw, I love DT.
rogerzn 11 months ago
@rogerzn Genesis? Pffffffffffff. Rush too much better than Genesis. But, Dream Theater is untouchble!!! The best of the best!!
AleshRock 10 months ago
@AleshRock That's your opinion.
In MY OPINION, Genesis is the best progressive band ever. END.
rogerzn 10 months ago
6:54 Labrie fail!!!!!!
JcDrummer28 1 year ago
wtf ?!?! why was the end cut of like that?!?!?
GangstaPoliceman 1 year ago 11
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@GangstaPoliceman It bores me
Professsor 1 year ago
Comment removed
JamieandhisIbanez 6 months ago
@Professsor just because it bores you doesnt mean it bores other people ¬_¬
hanzabean91 5 months ago 14
@hanzabean91 My channel, my upload. Feel free to upload it yourself.
Professsor 5 months ago
The hypnotist sounds hilarious.
firelegendmushroom 1 year ago
i love the song
mddy1987ED 1 year ago
i love his hair :D
TheZutaraKataang 1 year ago
What is the song from 9.27 onwards? o.0
jakeling 1 year ago
@jakeling
It's a mix between the final part of "Metropolis Part I: The Miracle and The Sleeper" and the final part of "One Last Time".
masterofpuppets1985 1 year ago
Anyone else think at 07:06 James is checking his breath? :P
Professsor 1 year ago
nice spray-on trousers james! ;-)
brings back memories this does. possibly the best band of all time.
blahfox 1 year ago
The whole concert "Live scenes from New York" is a story about the relationship of a couple and so on...
So the songs are connected with each other
cescfabregas411 1 year ago
wait so he killed them OUTSIDE????
nmillwater33 1 year ago
Metropolis Pt.2 is one of the best songs from dt. From the beautiful opening to the epic ending
TheMureena 1 year ago
@TheMureena You mean one of the best albums didn't you?
zonic26 1 year ago
7 people didn't return to the present feeling peaceful and refreshed
elmocheesecake1174 1 year ago 72
Comment removed
joselavi11 1 year ago
dios santo
danielorbis666 1 year ago
many ppl not enjoying their freedom as Palestines all my greeting to them
viva palistina
manguiwalid 1 year ago
The acting wasn't supposed to be amazing, it was just for it live, D:
It isn't meant to be a professional video, it's meant to be a story.
TheeOutlaw 1 year ago
the acting sucks pretty hard
TheThim51 1 year ago 2
finally free mike.....>.<
liquidemonds 1 year ago 6
Jordan Rudess is similar to Peter Barden with long hair
OLord2 1 year ago
The best drum and guitar solo I've ever heard.
icacous 1 year ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
¤ø„¸¸„ø¤º°¨¸„ø¤º°¨ post to 9 other vids
¨°º¤ø„¸ Copy „ø¤º°¨ press F5 twice
¸„ø¤º°¨Paste ``°º¤ø„¸ OK
¸„ø¤º°¨¸„ø¤º°¨¨°º look at ur background
XboxGamerification 1 year ago
(((_{-_-}_))) one of the most invincible and prestigious bands that ever formed in the face of the planet...and thank you for liquid tension.
lastfanstanding999 1 year ago
2:18 a moment of lol but great song nonetheless
kalsikum 1 year ago
9:27 beautiful!
steitisch 1 year ago 25
@steitisch I really dont like this bit, annoys me after such an epic drum solo thingy.
Professsor 1 year ago 9
@Professsor OK. I like it :-) Esp.: 9:36-9:38 Just that little "run", or whatever it is called. But you're right, the drum solo is pretty epic. It is Dream Theater, almost every note of all songs are epic! I mean, DT is putting 4 gods together in one band ;-)
steitisch 1 year ago
@steitisch 5 xD
TheThim51 1 year ago
@TheThim51 No 4, LaBrie is just an archangel, no god!
steitisch 1 year ago
@Professsor
that is my favorite part of the entire dvd ( with a change of seassons and learning to live ) .. I mean, if you pit in the context of the album, it was just unespected after that massive drum solo and minor scale to come up with that. It gives me goose bumps everytime
joshuanaconda 1 year ago
@Professsor Actually, it is a variation on "One Last Time", the song After "The Dance Of Eternity" and after "The Spirit Carries On". So, it shouldn't annoy you if you understand what the notes mean.
whoareyou134 1 year ago
@Professsor its could be awesome without it, but with it, its even awesom-er!
hatooli 1 year ago
@Professsor Really? I wish it was on the album version, I think it's beautiful, oh well.
jmrocker 1 year ago
@Professsor
1505maia 1 year ago
@1505maia Erm, thanks?
Professsor 1 year ago
oh, there's 7 people who have no sense for great music
ChriKy99 1 year ago
cuando escuche este tema en santiago no la podia kreer que estubiera ai or la csm ademas cuasndo espezaron los gritos de la mina gritaba mas yo que la wna grande deram ctm !!
maimaiu 1 year ago
that riff starting at 4:00 just sends chills down my spine, along with the scene
lhc89 1 year ago
IMPRESIONANTE !!!! QUE BUEN TEMA
apokpo 1 year ago
Mike Portnoy is the best and this, is everything! :)
chuckgobbo 1 year ago
Don't get me wrong, dream theater is one of my favorite bands, and LaBrie is awesome, but he just can't pull off these vocals live.
belbers9715 1 year ago
@belbers9715 Im guessing you have never seen him do learning to live live, have you?
JulianBaynez 1 year ago
@JulianBaynez not that particular song, no. I saw them in concert, though.
belbers9715 1 year ago
Just fucked up xD
LinkinPark198902 1 year ago
EPIC ENDING!
zynex 1 year ago
one of the many reasons I like DT (:
SellyJr 1 year ago
what a drummer.....
koentje2104 1 year ago 5
@koentje2104
what a band...
betvarin 1 year ago 2
musical orgasm! damn i love DT
zHawk32 1 year ago
i wish they make the movie for the whole album. It would be a masterpiece.
mike portnoy throwed out after this concert huh
blake123zz 1 year ago 2
the first time i heard this song i was trippen because my name is Nicholas and i thought dream theater was talking to me
Mr00NiCk00 1 year ago 4
@Mr00NiCk00 and u were liek OH FUCVK HOW did they now myu eyes were closed
pappabear2010 1 year ago
@Mr00NiCk00 dont trip man lol !
orland0 1 year ago
i think John could crush a mans head with his picking hand
Mr00NiCk00 1 year ago
apri gli okki nicolas:)
simo90msn 1 year ago
kerend,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
rizaherdiantodarmawa 1 year ago
@rizaherdiantodarmawa
mantep yaa....
kagum banget sama mereka
jambrongification 1 year ago
holy shit im 111,111 viewer XDDDDD!!
maxza209 1 year ago
is any1 so kind to ell me who is miracle, victori, nicholas and sleeper
rakislon 1 year ago
Can any drummer explain to me what Portnoy is doing from 8:29 to 8:37?? I can't quite understand it...
swantonbomberx 1 year ago
@swantonbomberx odd beat?
rexpinsel 1 year ago
@rexpinsel It seems to be hitting every three 16th notes on toms and snare during a couple of bars while keeping straight 16ths on the ride...
swantonbomberx 1 year ago
@swantonbomberx what do you mean what is he doing?
CallOfDutyWerido13 1 year ago
@swantonbomberx Polyrhythms
DDDekost 1 year ago
@swantonbomberx It sounds like he's actually playing in a different time signature.
Musicians will sometimes do that if they're really good at it. I've heard things like that before, but not so drastically like Portnoy doing it there.
Ceptor5665 1 year ago
Wow, Derren Brown just shot someone!
Equipe3v 1 year ago
God created the Earth on 6 days and on the 7th....................He created Dream Theater!! :)
nunosdinis 1 year ago 8
6:55 sacalo amigo asi como lo hace mike xd
oscarskate1 1 year ago
2:45 <3
MilanWraith 1 year ago
I'd take my own life before losing you....I know I've already lost you...but I'm hoping for a change....wishing you will come back....that's why I'm not dead yet....I LOVE YOU.....and ALWAYS WILL......:(:(:(
4everBritney4ever 1 year ago 6
It don't know why, but always in my head this awesome acted "fight" has taken place inside a house.
BananaWarrior1993 1 year ago 2
@BananaWarrior1993 Thats kinda wierd, i have always thought the same xD
HYPERDISTORTED 1 year ago
@BananaWarrior1993 The lyrics say 'they'd rendezvous, in a pathway out of view' so i always imagined it outside.
Equipe3v 1 year ago
It don't know why, but always in my head this awesome acted "fight" has taken place inside a house.
BananaWarrior1993 1 year ago
greatest song ever created !!!!!!!!!!
SCHneeWill 1 year ago 4
9:20 -9:25 EPIC!!!!!!!!!!!!
KeenanCl 1 year ago
Victoria is pretty ugly XD
Canigoripelushtappo 2 years ago 58
@Canigoripelushtappo keep in mind she's in the 1920's, I bet they thought she was hot back then
guysullavin 2 years ago 6
TrueXDDD
tomcld 2 years ago
@Canigoripelushtappo agree xD
LinkinPark198902 1 year ago
@Canigoripelushtappo lol yeah... I certainly wouldn't kill my brother for HER xD
gangsterthomas1000 1 year ago 2
love song
Classic2009Rock 2 years ago
buenisimo mike! :)
romerovan21 2 years ago 3
QUIERO PONERLE 10 PUTAS ESTRELLAS!!! no 5!
I WANT TO PUT 10 FUCKING STARS!!! NOT ONLY 5!!!
DT the best album ever made
grayback87 2 years ago 5
6:57 The way Labrie sang the word "friend" was SO EPIC!
trtlpowr 2 years ago 6
That's one of the things I like better about this version. He's not sounding so great in this song (guessing that's cause he'd been singing for a while at that point), but that's one of the things that makes this version better. The very end of the song is beautiful, I wish it was on the album version.
jmrocker 2 years ago
The best drum solo I have ever seen..... by far...
teapee37 2 years ago 8
one of the best drums solo ever
this song aways give me shivers to =P
dscarmo 2 years ago 5
The scream at 4:27 gives me shivers down my spine every time.
IronMikeDT 2 years ago 3
Lacks the technicality of most well known Dream Theater songs, but easily one of the best. Has a lot of depth and originality to it; I wish DT would stop wanking Constant motion songs and come back and make a great concept album like SFAM!
cjgone2 2 years ago 9
i may lack technicality in terms of playing,but it is amazing at songwriting techinc
Podarias 2 years ago
Fuck, why the hell they didnt added the part where Hypnotist kills Nicholas? They ruined a flawless performance D:
XRasenX 2 years ago
amazing. one of my favorite songs. so meaningful and deep. dream theater ftw.
morky8 2 years ago 3
ojala canten esto en el concierto de venezuela
mrVejete 2 years ago
No wonder Mike Portnoy passed out after the concert. More than three hours of such awesome energy
JimiPain 2 years ago 5
actually it was 4
aadishjaj 2 years ago
Poor Jordan looks a litle bored without his stand! hahah
You know! it would be great they redo this concert again!
I mean really! with all the experience they have gain they would defintly do a pure awesome thing!
mulanovich 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
James tried so hard to destroy the song..Couldn't do it...But those high parts he sang...THES FEELEN ENSAID OF MEEEEE FANALE FAUND MA LAV A FANALE FREEEE ... Damn it :D
ToshiGilmour 2 years ago
This song is definitely one of my favorites, up their with Voices, and Learning to Live. The vocals are powerful enough to make an entire nunnery instantaneously orgasm with exploding hymens causing many nuns to drown in a see of vagoo blood.
abortionsrock 2 years ago 7
Drum solo? Where?
The ending is awesome btw!
WhiteDeath 2 years ago