she has invented a new religion in the name of islam. good on you girl. you have made your own explanation which is of course not permitted in islam but you did it anyway.
She specks loud with no Knowledge and claim Islam , but don't follow the teaches of Muhammad and the wives ( whom were schorlars of the deen ) look how they laugh about the past , when Imam Malik said we will be correct until we follow what Muhammad and his Sabahs were upon .
you can say crazy to her, and whatever you want to her, the islam you talk about in the middle east is dead, and the muslim leaders are hypocrites, and thats why the muslims left to europe for a good life. Now, God is up, and we are down, if he wants the muslim to progress, God should wipe out the garbage in the middle east, because many arabs believe we are acting like GODS, and love to step on others, what goes around will come around.People left islam due to this and osama bin laden
I am entitled to express my opinion which is my democratic right and you like many others may agree or disagree and that is also your right but you don't have any rights to ARSE-UME anything about me. How the fuck did you get this idea that "you know morethan I" about Islam? Did you ever com[pete with myself about the knowledge of Islaam? NO ...Than shut the fuck up. It is you is Ignorant and Arrogant self confessed "Mr. Know It All"
I am entitled to express my opinion which is my democratic right and you like many others may agree or disagree and that is also your right but you don't have any rights to ARSE-UME anything about me. How the fuck did you get this idea that "you know morethan I" about Islam? Did you ever com[pete with myself about the knowledge of Islaam? NO ...Than shut the fuck up.
I ADMIRE THIS LADY. SHE'S VERY EDUCATED BUT AFTER READING THE QURAN AND MANY OF THE HADITHS I WOULDN'T IDOLIZE MUHAMMED. THE QURAN IS A BOOK THAT DEMONIZES THE INFIDEL, TELLS MUSLIMS TO FIGHT UNTIL THE WHOLE WORLD BECOMES MUSLIM, 8:39, 9:29 AND HUMILIATES WOMEN. THE HAIDTHS ARE EVEN WORSE? THEY TELL US HOW MUHAMMED KILLED, LOOTED, TOOK ONE FIFTH OF THE BOOTY. I'M SORRY, BREAK THE MYTH THAT REDUCES YOU TO POVERTY. I'M NOT WHITE. BUT YOU'LL HAVE PROBLEMS UNTIL YOU SEEK INTO YOUR HEART RATIONALLY
@pundada SO "DEATH WOULD BE TOO GOOD FOR HER"? WHAT HORRIBLE WORDS! THAT IS WHY MUSLIMS HAVE SUCH A HORRIBLE REPUTATION. THEY BRUTALLY THREATEN TO DEATH THOSE WHO SPEAK THEIR MINDS OPENLY. YOU SHOULD BE A SHAME TO KILL IN THE NAME OF GOD. KILLING IS THE MOST HORRIBLE OF ALL THE SINS AND THAT IS WHAT I DISLIKE ABOUT ISLAM, IT KILLS IN THE NAME OF GOOD. READ THE HADITHS AND YOU'LL SEE THAT MUHAMMED USED TO KILL, WAS ALWAYS INVOLVED IN WARS. ISLAM DESERVES THE REPUTATION IT HAS. YOUR WORDS PROVE IT
Listen you pathetic piece retard Imbacille....Don't ARSE-Ume Anything.....What makes you think that I am a muslim? Don't ever judge a person purely on the comments he makes. I am NOT a muslim, hindu, christian, budhist or even a jew. And you are on sad SOB...Why do you have to write your vile comments in Capitals? WTF are you trying to prove? ...Get a life BoZo..
@punda YOU'RE PROBABLY NOT MUSLIM BUT ONE THING IS SURE, YOU ARE AN IGNORANT. YOUR AGGRESSIVE,VULGAR WAY OF TALKING PROVES IT. I DIDN'T INSULT YOU.I HAVE DONE MORE RESEARCH THAN YOU ON ISLAM, CHRISTIANITY AND BUDDHISM. PEOPLE WHO THINK THAT "DEATH WOULD BE TOO GOOD FOR HER" AS YOU WROTE ONLY SHOW THAT THEY ARE BRUTAL AND IGNORANT. WHAT RIGHT DO YOU HAVE TO WISH DEATH TO ANYBODY?WHATEVER YOUR RELIGION IS KILLING IS THE WORST OF ALL TRANSGRESSION. I CONDEM ISLAM BECAUSE IT KILLS IN THE NAME OF GOD
zee and .x1treme-let's guess what gender and religion you are? Irshad is a scholar and is bringing understanding to chaos.
You too can have faith without fear. There is really nothing about women or change to be affraid of. Your faith is strong. Your personaal connection to Allah is strong-no fear.By the way men in the West are often very disrespectful of woman, and many woman have used their freedom to degrade thenselves.
Manji shit is not even a perfect follower of the Islam's ISMAILI SECT( who follows Aga Khan,a debauched drunkard,.and famous gambler(horse racer)ISMAILIS like all other Muslims believe in ONE God,in Islam's Prophet ,and in Koran in complete totality. This Manji SHE MALE had a troubled up-bringing.Her father left her mother for a younger woman, hence her anger towards the Muslims.
after surah 6 :46 this is the right surah n ayat to discribe a person like that, [45:23] Then seest thou such a one as takes as his god his own vain desire? Allah has, knowing (him as such), left him astray, and sealed his hearing and his heart (and understanding), and put a cover on his sight. Who, then, will guide him after Allah (has withdrawn Guidance)? Will ye not then receive admonition?
Most Muslims who left their countries & sought shelters in the West are from those arenas where their talents were not recognized or they were financially at a disadvantage. In the UK, majority of Muslims are the children of immigrant who were at the bottom rung. They knew nothing of Islam. Mullas in the villages Knew nothing of Islam either. They are not carrying Islamic tradition but ignorant village tradition with Islamic names. All these Pirs, Imams, Murshads are non Islamic.
I am a Muslim and I like how she says it's a time for reasoning and using intellect. Many Muslims nowadays take everything so literally and mistake culture vs religion. I don't think people should judge her because she is homosexual or because she doesn't wear a veil. Although I give her credit for trying to speak out, I think she should use a more traditional approach. And I disagree with Irshad, most immigrants are persecuted. Look at the puritans & the Irish. Muslims don't have ALL the fault.
Shame on you that is not the problam ,,we slected a women prime ministre(beynaziir bhutoo) 3 times,,and its world record about youngest women head of country,,even canadian and american women hasnt get this title,,Irshad manji i will say shutt up,i saw many of your interviwes where you always critisize muslims,,
She's not a Muslim! She keeps referring to herself as a Muslim. She is a selfish, feminist who wants to change Islam so it fits her. As people say that terrorists pick and choose and interpret certain verses in the Qur'an to suite themselves, she is doing the same, but in a different way.
She always says "God is most forgiving, most merciful"...she thinks that God will then excuse all her selfish ways.
@artistdigital Yeah,I agree with you, she has no right to speak on behalf of Muslim women. She's a feminist, lesbian who is really spreading hate about Islam... She is making the REAL Muslims look bad. She wants modern Islam, what does that mean? She can't change Islam... Islam will never change, it's her that should change or shut up.
@artistdigital Yeah I don't know about "Modern Islam" too lol... but I've heard her mention that before..."Modern Islam" would mean changing Islam. I think she is in media so she makes the real Muslims look bad. oh well.. Let's just watch her make a fool of herself and laugh at her lol
@claudelebel55 There is no ISO certified standard for this. Its a diverse subject that vary from culture to culture. Depends on the perspective you are looking at it.
@artistdigital to some extent you are right but not to all extent. Even in Afghanistan, some women have the courage to escape from their abusive husbands and their families. Culturaly, we often desensitize ourselves to certain forms of abuse but if we stop to feel deeply, we know when we have been hurt. As humans, our needs do not vary all that much if at all. Do we not all want to be loved and respected ?
@claudelebel55 Again its how you define "Loved and Respected". Have you ever seen people loving pornstars and the respect they get at different celebrity shows? Women were considered oppressed in Afghanistan before foreign intervention, and even now you won't see any women dressed up in skirts, and even if there is a woman wearing skirts, the women of Afghanistan would condemn her... I'm not justifying abusive husbands.. Nobody would!
@artistdigital As I said earlier, I agree that conditionning has something to do with it but no one (except the totally screwed up) truly enjoys being beaten or demeaned. You may get used to it but deep down you know it is not right. It all depends on your level of consciousness. Much violence comes from unconscious behaviour.
@claudelebel55 Being beaten up is against Islam. Sharia law punishes anyone who beats his wife. in fact, the word "beat" is used in wrong context by many. The symbolic beating is the maximum extent to which a husband may go, and it must not leave a mark n must not be intended to inflict pain. Its symbolic to show extreme displeasure, as a final stage before separation. Come on, a lot happens in families, but husband and wife should stay together as one unit, at least for their children.
@artistdigital you obviously don't want to recognize the point I have been trying to make. No - families should not stay together no matter what. There are limits. Why do you refuse to acknowledge the point I am making ? justify, justify, justify, not even bothering to respond to what I have written. How about women beating men in sharia law. Is that allowed ? Why is it one-sided ? huh ?
@claudelebel55 Look around you! How many family splits? What are the effects on children? and society?
Now, why one sided, hmm.. Well, man is the leader of the house. Sharia is an entirely different system. Man is responsible for providing for and protecting the family. Wife isn't responsible for providing for and protecting the family, even if she is richer and stronger.
@claudelebel55 :) Thats not the case! I'm from a society where Sharia law rules the family life, even if not formally. My father has never hit my mother. They have often made compromises. We have strong family ties, and I'm thankful to them for it. I love my mother and my father, so do all my cousins etc. We are very much satisfied. If parents play their roles, everything is fine. If they can't, they shouldn't marry, to bring more lives into torment. Plain n simple! ?
@claudelebel55 Two leader and house in chaos. There are rules and regulation in Sharia for this. Sharia intends to keep families together for their mutual good. I can go into details, but I think enough info is there online. As far as domestic violence is concerned, its everywhere. There should be strict laws dealing with it. Sharia law also has laws dealing with it.
@artistdigital hurrah for sharia. What are you going to talk about next. You are an expert at evading the point I first made. You so want to be right that you just go around whatever I say so take care. There is obviously no violence in the islamic world. No women ever get hurt by their husbands and they should stay no matter what. Hurray for sharia law.
@claudelebel55 Its easy for you to say such things because in western societies, children suffer, and when they grow up, they forget everything because they are lost in the same society. They real problem is that children can't stand for their rights to have a normal family, some that they can call father and someone to love like mother. I know, its harsh but its a reality. Isn't it?
@artistdigital you are so bent on proving your point that you refuse to acknowledge anything I say. You seem to be as pig-headed as that Koran burning minister from Florida. He also seems to know what is best for everyone and there is no talking to him either. He's right and he knows it .... or so he thinks. Have a good conversation with yourself.
@claudelebel55 Now you are getting way too personal bro. :) Its just a discussion, chill out! You have your say and I have mine. I don't impose my way on you, and so shouldn't you. Simple? You may be right from where you come, and I may be right from where I come. Lets appreciate each others views, and move on. Peace!
@claudelebel55@claudelebel55 What do you expect? Should I say, "OK! You are right" or "Yes, husband and wife should both beat each other to death" or "Yes, equality, pregnancy should be turn by turn" lol! Can you be kind enough to type your points for me? :) If you need any references to domestic violence in Montreal, I can ... ?
:) Domestic violence should end, but it isn't the monopoly of any particular race or color!! Cultural awareness and understand may clear a lot of things!
Islam is a cult created by a psychopath. It cannot be reformed. It must be eradicated. Islam must be eradicated not because the Quran says Earth is flat or the shooting stars are missiles that Allah fires at the Jinns who climb the heaven to eavesdrop on the conversation of the exalted assembly. These stupid tales could even amuse us. Islam must go because it teaches hate, it orders killing of non-Muslims, it denigrates women and it violates the human rights.
@GameOvai5 Brother, why dont you stand up and do something about the way Muslims are being treated due to the misconceptions spread by the media about Islam. If you cant, then atleast appreciate the guts this woman is showing in trying to remove the misconception. AS far as her personal characteristics are concerned, well, first we dont know to what extent its true and secondly she will be answering in her grave not you.
IRA (Irish republic Army) was terrorizing quite sometime in UK, and no one ever blamed for the catholics. The Nazi killed 6 million Jews, again I never heard pple. saying "Germans" killed 6 miilion Jews. Catholic church in the US paid over 600 million dollars compensations (Child molestations) and no one ever said all the catholics are child molesters. Am I missing something here?
@MrShahee23 there are many like her being "FINANCED" and "ENCOURAGED" in the west trying to have ONE last chance at changing the very fabric of Islam.
@sisenor68@sisenor68 I found a reference to her lesbian status > fgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2004/01/19/DDG424BVAN1.DTL A Muslim calls for reform] by Matthew Kalman, The San Francisco Chronicle.
Common Muslim women aren't lesbian. She doesn't pass the criteria of leading Muslim women. She doesn't qualify!
says the retard, a muslim must cover her head, muslim women dont lick pussy of anther women..(as she does)..so take your bullshit elsewhere....this person is a filthy jew (zionist) or something else
Irshad Manji (Arabic: إرشاد منجي) (born 1968) is a gay Canadian author, journalist and an advocate of "reform and progressive" interpretation of Islam. Manji is director of the Moral Courage Project at the Robert F. Wagner Graduate School of Public Service at New York University, which aims to teach young leaders to "challenge political correctness, intellectual conformity and self-censorship."[1]
This is a fraudulent interview where both host and interviewer are indian setup pretending to be Pakistanis. Irshad manji can be jailed for doing this fraud and blemishing another country.
This interviewer does not seem to be a Pakistani. I think the cheap dirty indians are at their dirty games again. Setting up an interview as if Pakistani were intervieweing. A Pakistani would never interview irshad manji as we know how much knowledge she has of islam.
She has memorized few words of arabic and became an expert on islam lol. As an indian she is bound to target Pakistan since it is in indians innate nature. How can a Pakistani threaten her because of she being a woman as one of Pakistans prime minster was woman. Benazir bhutto. The speaker in Pak assembly is a woman and there are lot of women in Pakistan assembly. : )
the genocidal oppression hindus endured down the centuries under islamic rule entitles them 2be wary of pakistan.
i'm glad as an englishman, that in spite of the indignity and various wrongs of the colonialial rule of the british, that our presence in the region crushed islamic rule, and paved the way for hindus to reclaim their land & culture from the muslim usurpers,who labled them dhimmi & kuffar in their own country
good2see india now going from strength to strength.
@catveezle With the population and size 10 times bigger then Pakistan, Indian still afraid of Pakistan. seems funny. I highly doubt u are british, deception and back stabbing is also indians innate behaviour and a brit would never come on internet praising another country. They are not shameless like indians. India developing is the biggest joke of the century.
I'll admit that I don't really agree about the whole homosexuality thing being accepted in islam but I think we're being a over-board and hypocritical her main goal is to stop all this radical extreme violence : stoning women to death in third world countries oppression ,abuse all these unjust extreme acts are the main reason why Islam and muslims have this hate image portrayed by everyone and how to know that Manji is wrong? heck how do we know that we are right? at the end Allah decides that
@mrghanaboy17: Not all religious pple are homosexuals all you pple who are criticizing her act as if homosexuals wake up one day and choose to be the way they are its not like you wake up one morning and decide "Oh I'm going to be gay today" just out of sheer boredom its just something that happens either your born that way or it takes you a while to realize that you are. And how do you all know that she isn't a devout muslim?
I still think Irshad is great. She's got guts. And these limp dick men calling her names and insulting her gender expression and sexuality further prove her point.
Peope like irshad manji are called Shemale in somesites. As appeared from appearance, speech, talking, hair style. Irshad can be a wife and husband of a same time. Can be called a sister, brother, father, mother, daughter, son, nephew, niece, uncle and aunt the same time. so this is called shemale both male and female charaterestics. criticizing other people beliefs do not make one a scholar. they are filthy, they just need money and citizenship in a western country like cananda an england or so
this woman is a fraud. she comes from a khoja shi'ite background and pretends like she's a mainstream sunni. she wants ijtihad which already exists among her people who share neither belief nor history with the middle eastern world. all you xenophoic rightwingers who think islam is a monolithic faith probably wont understand what that means.
@Suhayb17 You ignorant illiterate fucktard. Go and suck your father's dick and then have him ram it up your ignorant ass. Motherfucker! Get an education!
So you are telling me that you follow this lesbian woman who does not pray salah and not wear a hijab?
If you are a true believer you would understand that all muslims will be questioned on the day of judgment. I wonder what her answers will be, as well as yours. This bitch is clueless.
You are sooo tough talking like that behind a computer screen, ahaha pussy
You are passing ill judgment on this intelligent woman Irshad Manji. You must be thankful and proud that Irshad Manhi has given a voice of moderation and intellect to Islam. You do not need to follow her, but you can examine your faith against her and decide on your own. If you do not agree with her, it is your right to do so but you do not denigrate her and her call bad names....because doing so exhibits your lack of or respect for women.
First of all that btich talk about Quran what Quran says but i am asking that bitch
does not Quran said to Mohammad tell to your wives and the beleive wives for hijaab
do you know without covering head you be cursed by Allah so you think Quran is reveaaled by you what you like to use and what you don't like don't mention.
@strangerlover11 You are just an angry fool and CANT be Muslims. Muslims are guided by a God that will punish them for so much hatred. A true Muslim would never INSULT someone by calling them a BITCH!
NEVER! So, no wonder Islam looks bad. Its not the media...........its the MUSLIMS themselves that prove its bad!
Its true she is a big bitch because she cashing and bashing when she talk about
quran , Quran says that Quran says this ....than its not says by Quran a women should cover her head...even Bible says if women does not cover her head shave
Here is another point I want to bring up, i live in Canada, I can do what ever I want here, if I want to be Muslim Christian Atheist gay what ever, I can do it. No one will stop me, my entire family is non Muslim and would love to see me apostate which is never going to happen. If I fear god why would I want to disbelieve in him. In order for me to want to apostate first I have to disbelieve and by doing so my fear of God would be non existent, this is all very logical to understand.
@KilluminatiMujahad if I want to be Muslim Christian Atheist gay what ever, I can do it."
No you CANT! IDIOT! You will get punished if you do, by your very own God. Go read your book, just once. Just one time is all I am asking. Specifically you need to read Surat an-Nisa and tell me the TERRIBLE punishment you will get for beleiving me.
Does this punishment or praise keep you from believing me? come on, dont be shy. STOP being scared of me!
@KilluminatiMujahad Brother, you still RUN from my questions? WHY?? WHO are you scared of?
Does your God punish or praise for disbelieving in him???? So, when I prove the Quran is wrong, is punishment or praise, the reason you CANT beleive me. HUH???
Since you continue to run from my questions that PROVIDE you with proof that you CANT beleive me................PROVES you are just too damn scared to answer! WHAHAHAHAHAHAH
@srexob715 Why would a person who disbelieves in god care what God thinks, you need to explain this flaw in your argument in order to have a valid point. this is the fact you cant get through your think headed skull!!
@KilluminatiMujahad Why would a person who disbelieves in god care what God thinks"
Brother, there is a BIG difference. Let me show you.
A disbeliever does not care about what God thinks. Since he does not, then he will NEVER try to appease a God that he does not believe in.
But, the BELIEVER does care about what their God thinks. They will do anything to appease him. Even believe in him, despite being proven wrong. They are SCARED of his punishment or his praise........which one????
@KilluminatiMujahad you need to explain this flaw in your argument in order to have a valid point."
Well, I explained that it is not a FLAW in the first place. Get it? Nah, you CANT for some strange reason. Prove my explanation is wrong.
WHO said that the disbeleivers care about what God thinks? Not ME brother. I have always said that the BELIEVERS are the ones that are too scared of their God and you could SEE this too, if you would stop TWISTING what I say just so you don't have to SEE it
@srexob715 Your speaking to yourself here, Your counting on people being a dumb as you are, people are smarter then you think, dont delete your comments and leave them here for all to see. Any person Muslim or not with an objective mind can see clearly how you are the one who is scared and insecure about his own convictions to the point your looking for consolation from people online. Its really sad and pathetic but I dont owe you anything, much less an explanation.
if your so certain of what you believe then why are you so desperate to prove it lol Your a joke of a debater, you turn a theological discussion into a personal one, you use one point that is illogical throughout your whole debate, one point lol You then claim victory in a intellectual debate lol Did you graduate high school? honestly what level education did you get lol You have no scholarly points to make nor are you capable of making them if someone was to tell you what to say.
Brother, its a BELIEF and as long as I have evidence of my belief, I can maintain that belief...............UNTIL YOU PROVE ME WRONG!
Prove Surat an-Nisa 56 is wrong, brother. You need to PROVE that you are not scared of your God, for if you CANT,then surat an-nisa 56 is MY reason for believing you are SCARED. GET IT? Nah, you CANT for some strange reason! LMAO!
I am desperate for you to DISprove what I say, for if you CANT, then tell me WHY you can't believe what you can't disprove?? WHAT reason do you have? FEAR or STUPIDITY? huh? LMAO!
WHAHAHAHAH! But you guys CAN never show me where I am joke! You keep reducing the debate to ONLY what you can say, since you have NO proof of me being wrong. Just classic brother.
I can say things about you to, but does that mean I am right when I can't PROVE what I say???????????? HUH???? NOPE! WHHAHAHAHAHAH
Again, brother, your ONLY reason for not believing what you CANT disprove is stupidity or FEAR. I believe it is fear, but you will not admit it, which leads me to believe you are stupid.
SEE how I provide EVIDENCE of why I believe in what I believe?? WHY can't the Muslims do the same. Ahhhhh, I bet they have no evidence, so they just RANT and RAVE! LMAO! Classic lies brother, just classic!
When you CANT believe me, but yet CANT disprove what I say................then I have no reason to discard my beliefs. I COULD beleive you if you were right. You CANT believe me no matter how right I am.
SEE, you have no evidence that my points are NOT scholarly.............for if you did, you would have copied and pasted them and THEN proved them wrong.
SADLY, No Muslim has the balls to do so! And the wonder why we laugh at them! WAHAHAHAHAHAH
@srexob715 Look at the content in your own posts, read the yourself as if you were a third party and see what would they think lol you would be ashamed!!!
@KilluminatiMujahad Brother, WHO is going to punish you if you believe me??????
How many more times are you going to run from this question. Is it because you know that the answer will solve the mystery as to WHY you cant????????? HUH????
@srexob715 Your so ashamed your spamming the page with your own comments so that people only see what your dumb ass recently said, I ask anyone interested in knowing wtf your talking about to read the whole debate, go back about 5 pages and read what this clown wrote. I have nothing to hide and I am not ashamed of anything, your so ignorant you claim to have a PhD, saying blunt lies like this really takes away from your credibility, just look at the content in your posts and ask yourself wtf?
@KilluminatiMujahad When you guys refuse to believe what you can't disprove, you will start to focus on different things to twist the discussion away from what you KNOW you have no reason to not believe. Just classic!
This FOOL will not answer any questions, of which the answers proves him wrong. NO WONDER he runs from these questions, then has the nerve to try and poke fun at me. What a COWARD!
@srexob715 I'm not going to run around in circles with you anymore you clown. I'm not here to help you with your own insecurities, go see a Psychologist for that. you've made your point loud and clear about how you assume believers only believe out of ear, i disagree with you and I'm not going to change your mind nor you mine. Call it what ever you like but I believe on the day of judgment you and i will meet and I am patient to have the last laugh.
@KilluminatiMujahad you've made your point loud and clear about how you assume believers only believe out of fear"
You IDIOT............that's not what I said, nor was it my point. But tell me brother, do you LIE on purpose or just because you don't know any better? What a RETARD! And you do it in front of your God and the public. You should be ashamed, but I am sure this is completely normal and acceptable, huh? LMAO!
@srexob715 You dont get it do you, I am done with you, I got your point, I agree to disagree with your dumb ass even if you cant do the same. I simply ask any reader who comes on her to read the whole debate you and i and see in a objective way wtf is going on here cus you obviously have insecurities about your beliefs and I dont. Also your way too immature and emotional to get involved in these kind of debates which require objective people that know how to not get personal.
@KilluminatiMujahad I know brohter, that is what COWARDS do when they realize that they have no reason to not beleive what they cannot disprove. You RUN away before you have to ADMIT that you cant.
You RUN away to keep from having to admit that you CANT! COWARD! Just like all the other Muslims! Run, RUN, RUN, RUN!!!
@srexob715 No one is running away, you made your points, dont you get it, your not going to convince me with one argument that is illogical and beyond weak, for days you've been holding on to this one argument about fear based belief, its not working, why dont you change to a new point, either do that or go find a new freind to play with. You just simply want the last word, you want the top comment to be your condescending reply to me to make yourself look good, your only fooling yourself!!
@KilluminatiMujahad So, RUN away before you have to ADMIT that you twisted my point. Run away so you don't have to show the world how the Muslim mind works.
You twist my point around, just so you dont have to believe it. You make my point sound ridiculous, then claim my point is ridiculous. NO FOOL! It is your twist that makes my point sound ridiculous and you do it because you are either too scared or too dumb to believe me. Which is it COWARD?
Of course brother....................YOU WILL GET PUNISHED IF YOU BELEIVE ME. No wonder you cant see it working. No wonder.
You could prove the sky is blue, but if someone was threatening to punish me, there is NOTHING you could ever do to prove. I would NEVER be able to, since punishment awaited me if I did!
@srexob715 Note how you always make more then one comment at at time so a to make my comments go down and give yourself the top spots, your simply making your intentions much to obvious here. Your playing by yourself now, I'm not going to entertain your illogical ideas anymore. Say I'm running away all you want, just stop spamming the page for Gods sake.
@KilluminatiMujahad Note how you always make more then one comment at at time so a to make my comments go down.'
Notice how you NEVER address my statements, but that I copy and paste EACH one of yours............1 by 1..........to keep the Muslims from saying that I don't respond to their points.
In other words brother, it is proof that you RUN from each of my comments, but that I address EACH one of yours. But TWIST, TWIST, TWIST! It makes you look right!
@KilluminatiMujahad Your playing by yourself now, I'm not going to entertain your illogical ideas anymore."
Yep and like I said. Cowards will run from what they cannot disprove........especially when they will get punished for changing their beliefs. PERIOD!
@KilluminatiMujahad Yeah, I have insecurities about my beliefs.........but YOU are the one that runs away. Its pretty interesting when reality of you running away proves YOU are the one with insecurities, not me.
@srexob715 If it makes you feel better then yea I am running away from you, far far away, cus your a waste of time, I could be doing better things then helping you with your insecurities, I am certain of my convictions to the point of death. I dont need to prove them to you or have anyone prove theirs to me.
@KilluminatiMujahad Brother, you are NOTHING but a waste of oxygen and flesh! So keep running away from what you are scared of. It is funny and entertaining.
Man, all you STUPID Muslims are just too DAMN scared. Insecure in your beliefs, but yet you claim to be guided by a God. LIARS will never stick around to admit it. They will get punished if they do.
@KilluminatiMujahad You will always RUN AWAY from what you are scared of. So, tell me, since it is the truth that people run from what they are scared of.............are you scared of your God's punishment or his praise.
SOMETHING must be keeping you from believing me. WHAT is it???? FEAR of punishment or praise........or STUPIDITY. Which is it? Man, I hope you prove you are scared, then at least you would still look smart! WHAHAHAHAHHAHA
@KilluminatiMujahad Any person Muslim or not with an objective mind can see clearly how you are the one who is scared"
Hmm, you did not prove it. Try again. This time, TRY EXPLAINING how I am scared. I am starting to wonder whether you CAN, since you keep failing to do so.
Or I can just resort to your same tactics. Everyone here can see how YOU are the one who is scared. SEE, I don't have to mention surat an-nisa 56 as my PROOF, since you provide no proof of what you say. SAD, huh? LMAO!
I am not a Muslim because I am afraid of hellfire which i am, I am a Muslim cus Islam makes sense and is logical and the world situation and fools like you behaving the way you do also prove to me Islam's authenticity. Yes I certainly fear god but the primary reason I became a Muslim is cus I love God and want to serve him, not cus I am afraid of him. Do you respect your father cus you are scared of him or cus you love him, I'm sure if your dad is strict you would fear him, but still love him!!
You also proved your not interested in discussing anything with me but rather to slander me so as to slander what i say, it is obvious you care more about what others read hereon the posts then what I personally think, its as if your here ti spread propaganda, you know for culture creation reasons, this is exactly how you go about things, your not fooling anyone.
i don't understand why it's so hard for muslims to understand what she's saying.
bellijklh 2 months ago
she has invented a new religion in the name of islam. good on you girl. you have made your own explanation which is of course not permitted in islam but you did it anyway.
taniahurley 3 months ago
She specks loud with no Knowledge and claim Islam , but don't follow the teaches of Muhammad and the wives ( whom were schorlars of the deen ) look how they laugh about the past , when Imam Malik said we will be correct until we follow what Muhammad and his Sabahs were upon .
AbuKhalilah 3 months ago
you can say crazy to her, and whatever you want to her, the islam you talk about in the middle east is dead, and the muslim leaders are hypocrites, and thats why the muslims left to europe for a good life. Now, God is up, and we are down, if he wants the muslim to progress, God should wipe out the garbage in the middle east, because many arabs believe we are acting like GODS, and love to step on others, what goes around will come around.People left islam due to this and osama bin laden
Ammo150 4 months ago
@MrNaryal And you are a disgusting dirty biggot
EarlRegent 5 months ago
@DictaduraNo123
I am entitled to express my opinion which is my democratic right and you like many others may agree or disagree and that is also your right but you don't have any rights to ARSE-UME anything about me. How the fuck did you get this idea that "you know morethan I" about Islam? Did you ever com[pete with myself about the knowledge of Islaam? NO ...Than shut the fuck up. It is you is Ignorant and Arrogant self confessed "Mr. Know It All"
pundadah 6 months ago
@ DictaduraNo123 You have a SICKNESS of writing in Capitol letters
WTF are you trying to proove? It is you is Ignorant and Arrogant self confessed "Mr. Know It All"
pundadah 6 months ago
I am entitled to express my opinion which is my democratic right and you like many others may agree or disagree and that is also your right but you don't have any rights to ARSE-UME anything about me. How the fuck did you get this idea that "you know morethan I" about Islam? Did you ever com[pete with myself about the knowledge of Islaam? NO ...Than shut the fuck up.
pundadah 6 months ago
I ADMIRE THIS LADY. SHE'S VERY EDUCATED BUT AFTER READING THE QURAN AND MANY OF THE HADITHS I WOULDN'T IDOLIZE MUHAMMED. THE QURAN IS A BOOK THAT DEMONIZES THE INFIDEL, TELLS MUSLIMS TO FIGHT UNTIL THE WHOLE WORLD BECOMES MUSLIM, 8:39, 9:29 AND HUMILIATES WOMEN. THE HAIDTHS ARE EVEN WORSE? THEY TELL US HOW MUHAMMED KILLED, LOOTED, TOOK ONE FIFTH OF THE BOOTY. I'M SORRY, BREAK THE MYTH THAT REDUCES YOU TO POVERTY. I'M NOT WHITE. BUT YOU'LL HAVE PROBLEMS UNTIL YOU SEEK INTO YOUR HEART RATIONALLY
DictaduraNo123 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
FAILED PAKI LESBO...BITCH....is "JEWMERIKKKANIZED"......"CANADIZED"
Would she have spoken like this if she was in Her Country of Pakistan........
I DON'T THINK SO.....
pundadah 7 months ago
FAILED PAKI LESBO...BITCH....is "JEWMERIKKKANIZED"......
Would she have spoken like this if she was in Her Coutry of Pakistan........
I DON'T THINK SO.....
pundadah 7 months ago
@pundadah No because she would probably be killed
droitnow 6 months ago
@droitnow
Death would be too goodfor her.
pundadah 6 months ago
@pundada SO "DEATH WOULD BE TOO GOOD FOR HER"? WHAT HORRIBLE WORDS! THAT IS WHY MUSLIMS HAVE SUCH A HORRIBLE REPUTATION. THEY BRUTALLY THREATEN TO DEATH THOSE WHO SPEAK THEIR MINDS OPENLY. YOU SHOULD BE A SHAME TO KILL IN THE NAME OF GOD. KILLING IS THE MOST HORRIBLE OF ALL THE SINS AND THAT IS WHAT I DISLIKE ABOUT ISLAM, IT KILLS IN THE NAME OF GOOD. READ THE HADITHS AND YOU'LL SEE THAT MUHAMMED USED TO KILL, WAS ALWAYS INVOLVED IN WARS. ISLAM DESERVES THE REPUTATION IT HAS. YOUR WORDS PROVE IT
DictaduraNo123 6 months ago
@DictaduraNo123
F.U.2 and I don't respond to WANKERS who write in Capital letters.
pundadah 6 months ago
@DictaduraNo123
Listen you pathetic piece retard Imbacille....Don't ARSE-Ume Anything.....What makes you think that I am a muslim? Don't ever judge a person purely on the comments he makes. I am NOT a muslim, hindu, christian, budhist or even a jew. And you are on sad SOB...Why do you have to write your vile comments in Capitals? WTF are you trying to prove? ...Get a life BoZo..
pundadah 6 months ago
@punda YOU'RE PROBABLY NOT MUSLIM BUT ONE THING IS SURE, YOU ARE AN IGNORANT. YOUR AGGRESSIVE,VULGAR WAY OF TALKING PROVES IT. I DIDN'T INSULT YOU.I HAVE DONE MORE RESEARCH THAN YOU ON ISLAM, CHRISTIANITY AND BUDDHISM. PEOPLE WHO THINK THAT "DEATH WOULD BE TOO GOOD FOR HER" AS YOU WROTE ONLY SHOW THAT THEY ARE BRUTAL AND IGNORANT. WHAT RIGHT DO YOU HAVE TO WISH DEATH TO ANYBODY?WHATEVER YOUR RELIGION IS KILLING IS THE WORST OF ALL TRANSGRESSION. I CONDEM ISLAM BECAUSE IT KILLS IN THE NAME OF GOD
DictaduraNo123 6 months ago
zee and .x1treme-let's guess what gender and religion you are? Irshad is a scholar and is bringing understanding to chaos.
You too can have faith without fear. There is really nothing about women or change to be affraid of. Your faith is strong. Your personaal connection to Allah is strong-no fear.By the way men in the West are often very disrespectful of woman, and many woman have used their freedom to degrade thenselves.
Freedom is flawed but beautiful, like Irshad.
holyland08 8 months ago
she is a shameless bigot liar, profiteering by bashing islam, UGLY AS HELL!!
zee687 8 months ago
Comment removed
claudelebel55 8 months ago
Manji shit is not even a perfect follower of the Islam's ISMAILI SECT( who follows Aga Khan,a debauched drunkard,.and famous gambler(horse racer)ISMAILIS like all other Muslims believe in ONE God,in Islam's Prophet ,and in Koran in complete totality. This Manji SHE MALE had a troubled up-bringing.Her father left her mother for a younger woman, hence her anger towards the Muslims.
krishnamurthy241 8 months ago
why is he asking her questions relating to Islam she is neither an Islamic scholar nor an intellectual person
MyCheaky 9 months ago
quran also talks about modesty, prayers, keeping hijab and all that why is she not practicing them?she is funny shit
MyCheaky 9 months ago
after surah 6 :46 this is the right surah n ayat to discribe a person like that, [45:23] Then seest thou such a one as takes as his god his own vain desire? Allah has, knowing (him as such), left him astray, and sealed his hearing and his heart (and understanding), and put a cover on his sight. Who, then, will guide him after Allah (has withdrawn Guidance)? Will ye not then receive admonition?
preetybaby6 9 months ago
Most Muslims who left their countries & sought shelters in the West are from those arenas where their talents were not recognized or they were financially at a disadvantage. In the UK, majority of Muslims are the children of immigrant who were at the bottom rung. They knew nothing of Islam. Mullas in the villages Knew nothing of Islam either. They are not carrying Islamic tradition but ignorant village tradition with Islamic names. All these Pirs, Imams, Murshads are non Islamic.
amoralis123 10 months ago
I am a Muslim and I like how she says it's a time for reasoning and using intellect. Many Muslims nowadays take everything so literally and mistake culture vs religion. I don't think people should judge her because she is homosexual or because she doesn't wear a veil. Although I give her credit for trying to speak out, I think she should use a more traditional approach. And I disagree with Irshad, most immigrants are persecuted. Look at the puritans & the Irish. Muslims don't have ALL the fault.
1990marcela1411 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Does she has any conscience ?
azamjaved 11 months ago
There is nothing as "Islamic civilization!". We only have Islamic time which is full of shit.
toofan123 11 months ago
Shame on you that is not the problam ,,we slected a women prime ministre(beynaziir bhutoo) 3 times,,and its world record about youngest women head of country,,even canadian and american women hasnt get this title,,Irshad manji i will say shutt up,i saw many of your interviwes where you always critisize muslims,,
amirzubairmughal 1 year ago
I'm sure that to her, there is no such thing as Jihad... or her only Jihad is being a lesbian and striving to cause as much controversy as she can.
99N92 1 year ago
She's not a Muslim! She keeps referring to herself as a Muslim. She is a selfish, feminist who wants to change Islam so it fits her. As people say that terrorists pick and choose and interpret certain verses in the Qur'an to suite themselves, she is doing the same, but in a different way.
She always says "God is most forgiving, most merciful"...she thinks that God will then excuse all her selfish ways.
Fact is, she is not a Muslim!
99N92 1 year ago
She doesn't have the right of speaking on the behalf of Muslim women, because she isn't a common muslim women!
artistdigital 1 year ago 5
@artistdigital Yeah,I agree with you, she has no right to speak on behalf of Muslim women. She's a feminist, lesbian who is really spreading hate about Islam... She is making the REAL Muslims look bad. She wants modern Islam, what does that mean? She can't change Islam... Islam will never change, it's her that should change or shut up.
Peace :)
99N92 1 year ago
@99N92 I really don't know about "Modern Islam" lol
Another thing I don't understand is "Why is she on the media?"
artistdigital 1 year ago
@artistdigital Yeah I don't know about "Modern Islam" too lol... but I've heard her mention that before..."Modern Islam" would mean changing Islam. I think she is in media so she makes the real Muslims look bad. oh well.. Let's just watch her make a fool of herself and laugh at her lol
99N92 1 year ago
@99N92 The reason this project began is stop people who exactly think like you.
sisenor68 9 months ago
Comment removed
sisenor68 9 months ago
@artistdigital it is people like you who will destroy islam. allah bless irshad.
sisenor68 9 months ago
@sisenor68 Yeah! She would take it to peak, like religion in the US! lol
She isn't a Muslim women! Looks to me like she is working for fame, n I have read somewhere that she is a lesbian, God knows best! :)
artistdigital 9 months ago
@sisenor68 muslims can be destroyed but no one can destroy Islam
MyCheaky 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I am a Muslim, and I am very proud of you. You are brave, and inspire people like me.
However, I think that you have mistitled your book, I now understand that you meant to title your book "the trouble with Muslims today".
sisenor68 9 months ago
@artistdigital you don't have to be a 'common muslim woman' to know that every living person deserves respect.
claudelebel55 8 months ago
@claudelebel55 There is no ISO certified standard for this. Its a diverse subject that vary from culture to culture. Depends on the perspective you are looking at it.
artistdigital 8 months ago
@artistdigital to some extent you are right but not to all extent. Even in Afghanistan, some women have the courage to escape from their abusive husbands and their families. Culturaly, we often desensitize ourselves to certain forms of abuse but if we stop to feel deeply, we know when we have been hurt. As humans, our needs do not vary all that much if at all. Do we not all want to be loved and respected ?
claudelebel55 8 months ago
@claudelebel55 Again its how you define "Loved and Respected". Have you ever seen people loving pornstars and the respect they get at different celebrity shows? Women were considered oppressed in Afghanistan before foreign intervention, and even now you won't see any women dressed up in skirts, and even if there is a woman wearing skirts, the women of Afghanistan would condemn her... I'm not justifying abusive husbands.. Nobody would!
artistdigital 8 months ago
@artistdigital As I said earlier, I agree that conditionning has something to do with it but no one (except the totally screwed up) truly enjoys being beaten or demeaned. You may get used to it but deep down you know it is not right. It all depends on your level of consciousness. Much violence comes from unconscious behaviour.
claudelebel55 8 months ago
@claudelebel55 Being beaten up is against Islam. Sharia law punishes anyone who beats his wife. in fact, the word "beat" is used in wrong context by many. The symbolic beating is the maximum extent to which a husband may go, and it must not leave a mark n must not be intended to inflict pain. Its symbolic to show extreme displeasure, as a final stage before separation. Come on, a lot happens in families, but husband and wife should stay together as one unit, at least for their children.
artistdigital 8 months ago
@artistdigital you obviously don't want to recognize the point I have been trying to make. No - families should not stay together no matter what. There are limits. Why do you refuse to acknowledge the point I am making ? justify, justify, justify, not even bothering to respond to what I have written. How about women beating men in sharia law. Is that allowed ? Why is it one-sided ? huh ?
claudelebel55 8 months ago
@claudelebel55 Look around you! How many family splits? What are the effects on children? and society?
Now, why one sided, hmm.. Well, man is the leader of the house. Sharia is an entirely different system. Man is responsible for providing for and protecting the family. Wife isn't responsible for providing for and protecting the family, even if she is richer and stronger.
artistdigital 8 months ago
@artistdigital everything is black and white for you I see.
claudelebel55 8 months ago
@claudelebel55 :) Thats not the case! I'm from a society where Sharia law rules the family life, even if not formally. My father has never hit my mother. They have often made compromises. We have strong family ties, and I'm thankful to them for it. I love my mother and my father, so do all my cousins etc. We are very much satisfied. If parents play their roles, everything is fine. If they can't, they shouldn't marry, to bring more lives into torment. Plain n simple! ?
artistdigital 8 months ago
@claudelebel55 Two leader and house in chaos. There are rules and regulation in Sharia for this. Sharia intends to keep families together for their mutual good. I can go into details, but I think enough info is there online. As far as domestic violence is concerned, its everywhere. There should be strict laws dealing with it. Sharia law also has laws dealing with it.
artistdigital 8 months ago
@artistdigital hurrah for sharia. What are you going to talk about next. You are an expert at evading the point I first made. You so want to be right that you just go around whatever I say so take care. There is obviously no violence in the islamic world. No women ever get hurt by their husbands and they should stay no matter what. Hurray for sharia law.
claudelebel55 8 months ago
@claudelebel55 Its easy for you to say such things because in western societies, children suffer, and when they grow up, they forget everything because they are lost in the same society. They real problem is that children can't stand for their rights to have a normal family, some that they can call father and someone to love like mother. I know, its harsh but its a reality. Isn't it?
artistdigital 8 months ago
@artistdigital you are so bent on proving your point that you refuse to acknowledge anything I say. You seem to be as pig-headed as that Koran burning minister from Florida. He also seems to know what is best for everyone and there is no talking to him either. He's right and he knows it .... or so he thinks. Have a good conversation with yourself.
claudelebel55 8 months ago
@claudelebel55 Now you are getting way too personal bro. :) Its just a discussion, chill out! You have your say and I have mine. I don't impose my way on you, and so shouldn't you. Simple? You may be right from where you come, and I may be right from where I come. Lets appreciate each others views, and move on. Peace!
artistdigital 8 months ago
@artistdigital it's not a discussion when you constantly ignore what the other person just wrote.
claudelebel55 8 months ago
@claudelebel55 @claudelebel55 What do you expect? Should I say, "OK! You are right" or "Yes, husband and wife should both beat each other to death" or "Yes, equality, pregnancy should be turn by turn" lol! Can you be kind enough to type your points for me? :) If you need any references to domestic violence in Montreal, I can ... ?
:) Domestic violence should end, but it isn't the monopoly of any particular race or color!! Cultural awareness and understand may clear a lot of things!
artistdigital 8 months ago
She keeps quoting the same verse of the Quran! LOL
Muslimah454ify 1 year ago
you can't call yourself a FAITHFUL MUSLIM unless you pray or act like a Muslim.
aatayyab 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Islam is a cult created by a psychopath. It cannot be reformed. It must be eradicated. Islam must be eradicated not because the Quran says Earth is flat or the shooting stars are missiles that Allah fires at the Jinns who climb the heaven to eavesdrop on the conversation of the exalted assembly. These stupid tales could even amuse us. Islam must go because it teaches hate, it orders killing of non-Muslims, it denigrates women and it violates the human rights.
IslamISsick1 1 year ago
She keeps saying "We Muslims", how the heck can she sit there as a lesbian calling herself Muslim?
Does this shameless being not know she will stand before Allah on the day of resurrection for the numerous sins she is committing.
1. Claiming the Quran is incorrect, by saying she is a lesbian Muslim.
2. Coming on TV without her head covered.
3. Having a hairstyle which Australian male surfers do.
4. Claiming to know more than the educated Ulama?
Shame on this shameless woman.
GameOvai5 1 year ago
@GameOvai5 Brother, why dont you stand up and do something about the way Muslims are being treated due to the misconceptions spread by the media about Islam. If you cant, then atleast appreciate the guts this woman is showing in trying to remove the misconception. AS far as her personal characteristics are concerned, well, first we dont know to what extent its true and secondly she will be answering in her grave not you.
humanitypeace 11 months ago
@GameOvai5 you are a nut. she is a much better muslim than u are.
sisenor68 9 months ago
@sisenor68 Do you deny that homosexuality in Islam is haraam? Is this woman your hero? A woman who defies the teachings of the Ulama?
GameOvai5 9 months ago
"a faithful muslim myself" this being said by a lesbian????
u cant be gay and be a muslim
akuma4u 1 year ago
IRA (Irish republic Army) was terrorizing quite sometime in UK, and no one ever blamed for the catholics. The Nazi killed 6 million Jews, again I never heard pple. saying "Germans" killed 6 miilion Jews. Catholic church in the US paid over 600 million dollars compensations (Child molestations) and no one ever said all the catholics are child molesters. Am I missing something here?
amareto35 1 year ago
idiot woman, why people giving her so importance .
MrShahee23 1 year ago
@MrShahee23 there are many like her being "FINANCED" and "ENCOURAGED" in the west trying to have ONE last chance at changing the very fabric of Islam.
aatayyab 1 year ago
wot a hypocrate, in another lesson she is telling that Quran is not perfect. howshecan define the standard,
Samojahandad 1 year ago
Kafir....................
pakifighter 1 year ago
we muslims hate her bcoz she slanders islam under a islam name...note how often she says " my fellow muslims" andd "we muslims" its just a facade
X1REME 1 year ago
@X1REME she does not slander islam. she slanders muslims of today. she is a better muslim than u are.
sisenor68 9 months ago
@sisenor68 @sisenor68 I found a reference to her lesbian status > fgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2004/01/19/DDG424BVAN1.DTL A Muslim calls for reform] by Matthew Kalman, The San Francisco Chronicle.
Common Muslim women aren't lesbian. She doesn't pass the criteria of leading Muslim women. She doesn't qualify!
artistdigital 9 months ago
@sisenor68
says the retard, a muslim must cover her head, muslim women dont lick pussy of anther women..(as she does)..so take your bullshit elsewhere....this person is a filthy jew (zionist) or something else
X1REME 8 months ago
Irshad Manji
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Irshad Manji (Arabic: إرشاد منجي) (born 1968) is a gay Canadian author, journalist and an advocate of "reform and progressive" interpretation of Islam. Manji is director of the Moral Courage Project at the Robert F. Wagner Graduate School of Public Service at New York University, which aims to teach young leaders to "challenge political correctness, intellectual conformity and self-censorship."[1]
karim1950 1 year ago
She's a Lesbian, enough said.
6713545 1 year ago
god bless inrshad.She is just exposing the fanatic sick ideology of islam.
ayeesakhan1 1 year ago
This is a fraudulent interview where both host and interviewer are indian setup pretending to be Pakistanis. Irshad manji can be jailed for doing this fraud and blemishing another country.
paksurzameen 1 year ago
@paksurzameen
What is wrong with what she said ?
batura1 1 year ago
This interviewer does not seem to be a Pakistani. I think the cheap dirty indians are at their dirty games again. Setting up an interview as if Pakistani were intervieweing. A Pakistani would never interview irshad manji as we know how much knowledge she has of islam.
paksurzameen 1 year ago
@paksurzameen yes u right i think
4200Mohsin 1 year ago
She has memorized few words of arabic and became an expert on islam lol. As an indian she is bound to target Pakistan since it is in indians innate nature. How can a Pakistani threaten her because of she being a woman as one of Pakistans prime minster was woman. Benazir bhutto. The speaker in Pak assembly is a woman and there are lot of women in Pakistan assembly. : )
paksurzameen 1 year ago
@paksurzameen
the genocidal oppression hindus endured down the centuries under islamic rule entitles them 2be wary of pakistan.
i'm glad as an englishman, that in spite of the indignity and various wrongs of the colonialial rule of the british, that our presence in the region crushed islamic rule, and paved the way for hindus to reclaim their land & culture from the muslim usurpers,who labled them dhimmi & kuffar in their own country
good2see india now going from strength to strength.
catveezle 1 year ago
@catveezle With the population and size 10 times bigger then Pakistan, Indian still afraid of Pakistan. seems funny. I highly doubt u are british, deception and back stabbing is also indians innate behaviour and a brit would never come on internet praising another country. They are not shameless like indians. India developing is the biggest joke of the century.
paksurzameen 1 year ago
@catveezle either u are an indian or a zionist jew hiding behind Britiain. These two categories of ppl seem to be without shame and dignity. : )
paksurzameen 1 year ago
@paksurzameen your mother is shameless as she got fucked 4 times in war and still kill innocent people in the name of jizzlam
TheHinduzionist 1 year ago
I'll admit that I don't really agree about the whole homosexuality thing being accepted in islam but I think we're being a over-board and hypocritical her main goal is to stop all this radical extreme violence : stoning women to death in third world countries oppression ,abuse all these unjust extreme acts are the main reason why Islam and muslims have this hate image portrayed by everyone and how to know that Manji is wrong? heck how do we know that we are right? at the end Allah decides that
Jokerchic411 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@mrghanaboy17: Not all religious pple are homosexuals all you pple who are criticizing her act as if homosexuals wake up one day and choose to be the way they are its not like you wake up one morning and decide "Oh I'm going to be gay today" just out of sheer boredom its just something that happens either your born that way or it takes you a while to realize that you are. And how do you all know that she isn't a devout muslim?
Jokerchic411 1 year ago
Comment removed
Jokerchic411 1 year ago
Loud mouth & arrogant modernist. Following own whims and desires instead of what is commanded by Allah.
A warning for those who praise her and/or have similar thoughts:
watch?v=t5dofhepGx8
May Allah guide us all. Ameen
Yahya1Khan 1 year ago
you pigy women, fasiq, lil bitch
alghoraba 1 year ago
you pigy women, fasiq
alghoraba 1 year ago
Irshad is a dirty lesbo!!!!!!!!!!
pyromania76 1 year ago
I still think Irshad is great. She's got guts. And these limp dick men calling her names and insulting her gender expression and sexuality further prove her point.
TamirasEx 1 year ago 9
Peope like irshad manji are called Shemale in somesites. As appeared from appearance, speech, talking, hair style. Irshad can be a wife and husband of a same time. Can be called a sister, brother, father, mother, daughter, son, nephew, niece, uncle and aunt the same time. so this is called shemale both male and female charaterestics. criticizing other people beliefs do not make one a scholar. they are filthy, they just need money and citizenship in a western country like cananda an england or so
Shahid8904 1 year ago
she is a fucking big mouth..not really committed to Islam. Nothing important to say.
hunzai000 1 year ago
There are Muslims from Pakistan ...so she is zeroing in the Pakistani men...
AIMANALI 1 year ago
this woman is a fraud. she comes from a khoja shi'ite background and pretends like she's a mainstream sunni. she wants ijtihad which already exists among her people who share neither belief nor history with the middle eastern world. all you xenophoic rightwingers who think islam is a monolithic faith probably wont understand what that means.
maulpreylion 1 year ago
Is she a Lesbien
I di not understand y religious people are homosexual.
mrghanaboy17 1 year ago
I have no respect for a lesbian who does not pray.
Then she tries to represent islam?
Study the Quran and hadith, then you will understand.
Suhayb17 1 year ago
this bitch is lost.
She does not follow the sunnah
الله يلعنها, قحبه
Suhayb17 1 year ago
@Suhayb17 You ignorant illiterate fucktard. Go and suck your father's dick and then have him ram it up your ignorant ass. Motherfucker! Get an education!
ahmedhusseinny 1 year ago
@ahmedhusseinny
So you are telling me that you follow this lesbian woman who does not pray salah and not wear a hijab?
If you are a true believer you would understand that all muslims will be questioned on the day of judgment. I wonder what her answers will be, as well as yours. This bitch is clueless.
You are sooo tough talking like that behind a computer screen, ahaha pussy
Suhayb17 1 year ago
@Suhayb17 Well, your language in your comment deserved my comment.
What do you mean "true believer". I gave up on Islam sometime back. Not a believer anymore.
The only person who is brainwashed and clueless is you!
ahmedhusseinny 1 year ago
@ahmedhusseinny
What city are you from?
Suhayb17 1 year ago
@Suhayb17 New York Ciry
ahmedhusseinny 1 year ago
@ahmedhusseinny Ok, nvm
Suhayb17 1 year ago
@Suhayb17
You are passing ill judgment on this intelligent woman Irshad Manji. You must be thankful and proud that Irshad Manhi has given a voice of moderation and intellect to Islam. You do not need to follow her, but you can examine your faith against her and decide on your own. If you do not agree with her, it is your right to do so but you do not denigrate her and her call bad names....because doing so exhibits your lack of or respect for women.
samlarsenwrites 1 year ago
@ahmedhusseinny
she is not ignorant..she is intelligent muslim woman and I admire her. Obviously you have no respect for muslim women.
samlarsenwrites 1 year ago
@samlarsenwrites You mixed up my comment with someone else's. I never said ANYthing bad about Irshad! I respect her a lot.
ahmedhusseinny 1 year ago
@ahmedhusseinny My apologies for misunderstanding you.
samlarsenwrites 1 year ago
First of all that btich talk about Quran what Quran says but i am asking that bitch
does not Quran said to Mohammad tell to your wives and the beleive wives for hijaab
do you know without covering head you be cursed by Allah so you think Quran is reveaaled by you what you like to use and what you don't like don't mention.
strangerlover11 1 year ago
@strangerlover11 You are just an angry fool and CANT be Muslims. Muslims are guided by a God that will punish them for so much hatred. A true Muslim would never INSULT someone by calling them a BITCH!
NEVER! So, no wonder Islam looks bad. Its not the media...........its the MUSLIMS themselves that prove its bad!
srexob715 1 year ago
@srexob715
Its true she is a big bitch because she cashing and bashing when she talk about
quran , Quran says that Quran says this ....than its not says by Quran a women should cover her head...even Bible says if women does not cover her head shave
it alll..............hahahhahahahahhaha
strangerlover11 1 year ago
@strangerlover11 When FEAR guides you, it will make you do all kinds of crazy things. LMAO! WHAHAHAH
Since she can disprove what the Quran says, why should she stopping proving its wrong. WHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHA
srexob715 1 year ago
@srexob715
what she disproving in Quran do you know Quran what she said read by yourself
not just choose some and leave other.......you have to follow every things ....when
you talk about islam think to your self how much you follows.....she just cashing
and bashing........
strangerlover11 1 year ago
@strangerlover11 WAHAHAH! When you can disprove what someone says, why should you stop proving what you can disprove? HUH?? WHAHAHAHAHAH
when FEAR guides you, it will make you do some VERY crazy things........like believe in Gods!
srexob715 1 year ago
@srexob715
And when fear or scare guide you than what you dod..........mom , mom , mom
hahhahahah
strangerlover11 1 year ago
@strangerlover11 You are the biggest loser of them all. Keep trying brother, keep trying!
WAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
srexob715 1 year ago
@srexob715
you are exactly same jackass now i know.......hahahahhah
strangerlover11 1 year ago
@strangerlover11 Keep running away from what you can't believe because you just too damn scared!
WHAT A FOOL! WAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAA
srexob715 1 year ago
@srexob715
now i know you , you are the same jackass........hahahahha
strangerlover11 1 year ago
Here is another point I want to bring up, i live in Canada, I can do what ever I want here, if I want to be Muslim Christian Atheist gay what ever, I can do it. No one will stop me, my entire family is non Muslim and would love to see me apostate which is never going to happen. If I fear god why would I want to disbelieve in him. In order for me to want to apostate first I have to disbelieve and by doing so my fear of God would be non existent, this is all very logical to understand.
KilluminatiMujahad 1 year ago
@KilluminatiMujahad if I want to be Muslim Christian Atheist gay what ever, I can do it."
No you CANT! IDIOT! You will get punished if you do, by your very own God. Go read your book, just once. Just one time is all I am asking. Specifically you need to read Surat an-Nisa and tell me the TERRIBLE punishment you will get for beleiving me.
Does this punishment or praise keep you from believing me? come on, dont be shy. STOP being scared of me!
srexob715 1 year ago
@KilluminatiMujahad Brother, you still RUN from my questions? WHY?? WHO are you scared of?
Does your God punish or praise for disbelieving in him???? So, when I prove the Quran is wrong, is punishment or praise, the reason you CANT beleive me. HUH???
Since you continue to run from my questions that PROVIDE you with proof that you CANT beleive me................PROVES you are just too damn scared to answer! WHAHAHAHAHAHAH
srexob715 1 year ago
@srexob715 Why would a person who disbelieves in god care what God thinks, you need to explain this flaw in your argument in order to have a valid point. this is the fact you cant get through your think headed skull!!
KilluminatiMujahad 1 year ago
@KilluminatiMujahad You idiot. WHAHAH! Instead of answering my questions, you TWIST what I say to mean something else. WHY do you do it brother????
Do you do it on purpose or because you don't know any better? HUH?
srexob715 1 year ago
@KilluminatiMujahad Why would a person who disbelieves in god care what God thinks"
Brother, there is a BIG difference. Let me show you.
A disbeliever does not care about what God thinks. Since he does not, then he will NEVER try to appease a God that he does not believe in.
But, the BELIEVER does care about what their God thinks. They will do anything to appease him. Even believe in him, despite being proven wrong. They are SCARED of his punishment or his praise........which one????
srexob715 1 year ago
@srexob715
KilluminatiMujahad 1 year ago
@KilluminatiMujahad you need to explain this flaw in your argument in order to have a valid point."
Well, I explained that it is not a FLAW in the first place. Get it? Nah, you CANT for some strange reason. Prove my explanation is wrong.
WHO said that the disbeleivers care about what God thinks? Not ME brother. I have always said that the BELIEVERS are the ones that are too scared of their God and you could SEE this too, if you would stop TWISTING what I say just so you don't have to SEE it
srexob715 1 year ago
@srexob715 Your speaking to yourself here, Your counting on people being a dumb as you are, people are smarter then you think, dont delete your comments and leave them here for all to see. Any person Muslim or not with an objective mind can see clearly how you are the one who is scared and insecure about his own convictions to the point your looking for consolation from people online. Its really sad and pathetic but I dont owe you anything, much less an explanation.
KilluminatiMujahad 1 year ago
if your so certain of what you believe then why are you so desperate to prove it lol Your a joke of a debater, you turn a theological discussion into a personal one, you use one point that is illogical throughout your whole debate, one point lol You then claim victory in a intellectual debate lol Did you graduate high school? honestly what level education did you get lol You have no scholarly points to make nor are you capable of making them if someone was to tell you what to say.
KilluminatiMujahad 1 year ago
@KilluminatiMujahad if your so certain of what you believe"
Brother, its a BELIEF and as long as I have evidence of my belief, I can maintain that belief...............UNTIL YOU PROVE ME WRONG!
Prove Surat an-Nisa 56 is wrong, brother. You need to PROVE that you are not scared of your God, for if you CANT,then surat an-nisa 56 is MY reason for believing you are SCARED. GET IT? Nah, you CANT for some strange reason! LMAO!
srexob715 1 year ago
@KilluminatiMujahad then why are you so desperate to prove it"
I am desperate for you to DISprove what I say, for if you CANT, then tell me WHY you can't believe what you can't disprove?? WHAT reason do you have? FEAR or STUPIDITY? huh? LMAO!
srexob715 1 year ago
@KilluminatiMujahad Your a joke of a debater"
WHAHAHAHAH! But you guys CAN never show me where I am joke! You keep reducing the debate to ONLY what you can say, since you have NO proof of me being wrong. Just classic brother.
I can say things about you to, but does that mean I am right when I can't PROVE what I say???????????? HUH???? NOPE! WHHAHAHAHAHAH
srexob715 1 year ago
@KilluminatiMujahad ou turn a theological discussion into a personal one"
Again, brother, your ONLY reason for not believing what you CANT disprove is stupidity or FEAR. I believe it is fear, but you will not admit it, which leads me to believe you are stupid.
SEE how I provide EVIDENCE of why I believe in what I believe?? WHY can't the Muslims do the same. Ahhhhh, I bet they have no evidence, so they just RANT and RAVE! LMAO! Classic lies brother, just classic!
srexob715 1 year ago
@KilluminatiMujahad You then claim victory in a intellectual debate"
When you CANT believe me, but yet CANT disprove what I say................then I have no reason to discard my beliefs. I COULD beleive you if you were right. You CANT believe me no matter how right I am.
I win, you CANT change your beliefs. I COULD!
srexob715 1 year ago
@KilluminatiMujahad honestly what level education did you get lol "
Doctorate! How about you? Oh, the dumbfounded look on your face must be astounding! LMAO!
srexob715 1 year ago
@KilluminatiMujahad You have no scholarly points"
SEE, you have no evidence that my points are NOT scholarly.............for if you did, you would have copied and pasted them and THEN proved them wrong.
SADLY, No Muslim has the balls to do so! And the wonder why we laugh at them! WAHAHAHAHAHAH
srexob715 1 year ago
@srexob715 Look at the content in your own posts, read the yourself as if you were a third party and see what would they think lol you would be ashamed!!!
KilluminatiMujahad 1 year ago
@KilluminatiMujahad WHAHAHA! Brother, that is the biggest COP out I have ever seen.
IF, IF, IF, IF YOU are the one that can't believe me, then YOU should be able to show me where I am wrong.
Try again, or you can RUN from trying. It is up to you. CHICKEN SHIT! WHAHAHAHAHAHAH
srexob715 1 year ago
@KilluminatiMujahad Brother, WHO is going to punish you if you believe me??????
How many more times are you going to run from this question. Is it because you know that the answer will solve the mystery as to WHY you cant????????? HUH????
Run CHICKEN SHIT!
srexob715 1 year ago
@srexob715 Your so ashamed your spamming the page with your own comments so that people only see what your dumb ass recently said, I ask anyone interested in knowing wtf your talking about to read the whole debate, go back about 5 pages and read what this clown wrote. I have nothing to hide and I am not ashamed of anything, your so ignorant you claim to have a PhD, saying blunt lies like this really takes away from your credibility, just look at the content in your posts and ask yourself wtf?
KilluminatiMujahad 1 year ago
@KilluminatiMujahad When you guys refuse to believe what you can't disprove, you will start to focus on different things to twist the discussion away from what you KNOW you have no reason to not believe. Just classic!
This FOOL will not answer any questions, of which the answers proves him wrong. NO WONDER he runs from these questions, then has the nerve to try and poke fun at me. What a COWARD!
srexob715 1 year ago
@srexob715 I'm not going to run around in circles with you anymore you clown. I'm not here to help you with your own insecurities, go see a Psychologist for that. you've made your point loud and clear about how you assume believers only believe out of ear, i disagree with you and I'm not going to change your mind nor you mine. Call it what ever you like but I believe on the day of judgment you and i will meet and I am patient to have the last laugh.
KilluminatiMujahad 1 year ago
@KilluminatiMujahad I'm not going to run around in circles with you anymore you clown"
SEE, call me a clown, but YET you cant show me where I am wrong. WHY DO YOU LIE, CLOWN?????????????????
srexob715 1 year ago
@KilluminatiMujahad Cowards always RUN from what they can't disprove and from what they are just too damn scared to believe.
You're right. You're a waste of time, your heart and mind is already locked!
srexob715 1 year ago
@KilluminatiMujahad you've made your point loud and clear about how you assume believers only believe out of fear"
You IDIOT............that's not what I said, nor was it my point. But tell me brother, do you LIE on purpose or just because you don't know any better? What a RETARD! And you do it in front of your God and the public. You should be ashamed, but I am sure this is completely normal and acceptable, huh? LMAO!
RUN you coward!
srexob715 1 year ago
@srexob715 You dont get it do you, I am done with you, I got your point, I agree to disagree with your dumb ass even if you cant do the same. I simply ask any reader who comes on her to read the whole debate you and i and see in a objective way wtf is going on here cus you obviously have insecurities about your beliefs and I dont. Also your way too immature and emotional to get involved in these kind of debates which require objective people that know how to not get personal.
KilluminatiMujahad 1 year ago
@KilluminatiMujahad I know brohter, that is what COWARDS do when they realize that they have no reason to not beleive what they cannot disprove. You RUN away before you have to ADMIT that you cant.
You RUN away to keep from having to admit that you CANT! COWARD! Just like all the other Muslims! Run, RUN, RUN, RUN!!!
srexob715 1 year ago
@KilluminatiMujahad you obviously have insecurities about your beliefs and I dont."
Then DON"T run away then. If you don't have any insecurities, then WHY in the hell are you running from what you are not scared of?? HUH??
srexob715 1 year ago
@srexob715 No one is running away, you made your points, dont you get it, your not going to convince me with one argument that is illogical and beyond weak, for days you've been holding on to this one argument about fear based belief, its not working, why dont you change to a new point, either do that or go find a new freind to play with. You just simply want the last word, you want the top comment to be your condescending reply to me to make yourself look good, your only fooling yourself!!
KilluminatiMujahad 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@KilluminatiMujahad No one is running away, "
But yet you JUST SAID;
I'm not going to run around in circles with you anymore you clown"
Is this RUNNING away or sticking around? CLOWN? SEE how you guys are. Even will LIE! LMAO!
srexob715 1 year ago
@KilluminatiMujahad you've made your point loud and clear about how you assume believers only believe out of ear"
THAT WAS NOT MY POINT FOOL!!! SEE, no wonder we get emotional with you guys. YOU LIE, LIE, LIE!
That was NOT my point and you know it, you just will not admit it. You just CANT be honest! FOOL!
srexob715 1 year ago
@KilluminatiMujahad So, RUN away before you have to ADMIT that you twisted my point. Run away so you don't have to show the world how the Muslim mind works.
You twist my point around, just so you dont have to believe it. You make my point sound ridiculous, then claim my point is ridiculous. NO FOOL! It is your twist that makes my point sound ridiculous and you do it because you are either too scared or too dumb to believe me. Which is it COWARD?
srexob715 1 year ago
@KilluminatiMujahad one argument about fear based belief, its not working,"
Of course brother....................YOU WILL GET PUNISHED IF YOU BELEIVE ME. No wonder you cant see it working. No wonder.
You could prove the sky is blue, but if someone was threatening to punish me, there is NOTHING you could ever do to prove. I would NEVER be able to, since punishment awaited me if I did!
srexob715 1 year ago
@srexob715 Note how you always make more then one comment at at time so a to make my comments go down and give yourself the top spots, your simply making your intentions much to obvious here. Your playing by yourself now, I'm not going to entertain your illogical ideas anymore. Say I'm running away all you want, just stop spamming the page for Gods sake.
KilluminatiMujahad 1 year ago
@KilluminatiMujahad Note how you always make more then one comment at at time so a to make my comments go down.'
Notice how you NEVER address my statements, but that I copy and paste EACH one of yours............1 by 1..........to keep the Muslims from saying that I don't respond to their points.
In other words brother, it is proof that you RUN from each of my comments, but that I address EACH one of yours. But TWIST, TWIST, TWIST! It makes you look right!
srexob715 1 year ago
@KilluminatiMujahad Your playing by yourself now, I'm not going to entertain your illogical ideas anymore."
Yep and like I said. Cowards will run from what they cannot disprove........especially when they will get punished for changing their beliefs. PERIOD!
srexob715 1 year ago
@KilluminatiMujahad Keep running away brother. You CANT learn that way. Doh, I bet that is the reason why you run! LMAO!
Show the world you are too scared!
srexob715 1 year ago
@KilluminatiMujahad Yeah, I have insecurities about my beliefs.........but YOU are the one that runs away. Its pretty interesting when reality of you running away proves YOU are the one with insecurities, not me.
Get a brain!
srexob715 1 year ago
@srexob715 If it makes you feel better then yea I am running away from you, far far away, cus your a waste of time, I could be doing better things then helping you with your insecurities, I am certain of my convictions to the point of death. I dont need to prove them to you or have anyone prove theirs to me.
KilluminatiMujahad 1 year ago
@KilluminatiMujahad running away from you, far far away, cus your a waste of time"
I COULD believe you if you were right...........but since you are not right and you CANT admit it............you run away before you have to.
SAD that you can't stand up for Islam! SHAME ON YOU! WHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
srexob715 1 year ago
@KilluminatiMujahad Brother, you are NOTHING but a waste of oxygen and flesh! So keep running away from what you are scared of. It is funny and entertaining.
Man, all you STUPID Muslims are just too DAMN scared. Insecure in your beliefs, but yet you claim to be guided by a God. LIARS will never stick around to admit it. They will get punished if they do.
RUN YOU LITTLE GIRL!
srexob715 1 year ago
@KilluminatiMujahad You will always RUN AWAY from what you are scared of. So, tell me, since it is the truth that people run from what they are scared of.............are you scared of your God's punishment or his praise.
SOMETHING must be keeping you from believing me. WHAT is it???? FEAR of punishment or praise........or STUPIDITY. Which is it? Man, I hope you prove you are scared, then at least you would still look smart! WHAHAHAHAHHAHA
srexob715 1 year ago
@KilluminatiMujahad Any person Muslim or not with an objective mind can see clearly how you are the one who is scared"
Hmm, you did not prove it. Try again. This time, TRY EXPLAINING how I am scared. I am starting to wonder whether you CAN, since you keep failing to do so.
Or I can just resort to your same tactics. Everyone here can see how YOU are the one who is scared. SEE, I don't have to mention surat an-nisa 56 as my PROOF, since you provide no proof of what you say. SAD, huh? LMAO!
srexob715 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@KilluminatiMujahad I can do what ever I want here,"
SEE, twist, twist, twist! Brother I am not discussing whether you WANT to leave Islam, murder, rape, steal. My point is whether you CAN or not.
WHO will punish you if you rape, steal, leave Islam? The Tooth fairy or your very own God???? HUH?
Now, when I prove the Quran is filled with errors and you CANT believe me, is it because of punishment or praise? HUH?
srexob715 1 year ago
I am not a Muslim because I am afraid of hellfire which i am, I am a Muslim cus Islam makes sense and is logical and the world situation and fools like you behaving the way you do also prove to me Islam's authenticity. Yes I certainly fear god but the primary reason I became a Muslim is cus I love God and want to serve him, not cus I am afraid of him. Do you respect your father cus you are scared of him or cus you love him, I'm sure if your dad is strict you would fear him, but still love him!!
KilluminatiMujahad 1 year ago
You also proved your not interested in discussing anything with me but rather to slander me so as to slander what i say, it is obvious you care more about what others read hereon the posts then what I personally think, its as if your here ti spread propaganda, you know for culture creation reasons, this is exactly how you go about things, your not fooling anyone.
KilluminatiMujahad 1 year ago