Comfortably Numb - David Gilmour - MeltDown Concert 2002 - with Bob Geldof - HD

[longdisturb]

I see Bob Geldof eye brows grow again! lol .. I can't get enough of this song.. 

[Flavorcore96]

Waters is better than Bob Geldof...

[luischarlos]

Jesús "Chucho" Merchan - Contrabass

[julrueda]

Que viva Colombia y Floyd por siempre!!!

[wdobni]

this performance is perfection....Bob Geldof does an exceptionally good job of reprising his role as Pink from the movie The Wall and sings perfectly as the voice of the quintessential addict just trying to keep it going 4 more hours....and whenever Bob Geldof performs with David Gilmour on this song it inspires Mr. Gilmour to new heights of performing ecstasy, as seen in this video where his voice and playing are absolutely perfect. Together they create absolute authenticity.

[Kezzabingo007]

Billy Connolly also gives a fine display on Piano.

[memoideus]

Mr. Kamen RIP

[abbas838]

IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII­IIIIIIIIII have become,  . . . comfortably numb.

[XRePete]

Every time Mr. Gilmour starts singing I get goosebumps- just unbelievable live vocals.

[Noanns]

bob geldof gets a great welcome and delivers a shitty performance

[ChrizzSudaka]

Wtf? Why he needs a paper to sing this piece of art? I can't bealive it...

[mcelo09]

Nice! reading and singing!

[TheGaeta63]

semplicemente fantastico...lo penso da quando sentii per la prima volta i Pink Floyd... sono passati molti anni da allora e il mio sentimento non è cambiato...

[Netthuno]

Hello Bob!!

[1ralton1]

What the hell's wrong with Bob!!! I can't believe he's forgotten the words to this. He looks and acts here like a spare part. Shame he didn't put more passion into it. Can't help thinking he wasn't too well.....Nonetheless must agree this is one of the best versions I've heard of this. Thanks for uploading. Would never have heard it otherwise.

[volandy]

6:43 drummer:"Fuck yeah")))

[TheNoTrump]

When your sword is guitar.. 

[leesmartin]

3;18. That fist slide up the neck.Chills when played loud

[radiodead74]

@leesmartin I totally agree , I've watched 6 times and every time he slides that note I get the chills all over my back... that's what music is supposed to do," I cannot put my finger on it" but I know what it feels like!

[loverocknow]

half pink floyd , half dire straits = full music.

[Joey15215rjd]

I teleprompt every song I do for lack of memory and a desire for perfection. But I'm also doing the guitar rhythm as well. It would have been good for Mr. Geldof to pull up a chair and put the lyrics on an easel. There's no shame in it. It's a whole lot different when you're up there with everyone's eyes upon you ... under the audience-size-microscope. -rjd

[curicaveri1968]

I just love at 4:30

[douchecock427]

haha the chick on the cello is freaking out and u cant even hear her

[douchecock427]

haha he needs a lyrics sheet. is he the guy who played pink in the movie?

[woutervincentbff]

Today in 1968 is the day that david gilmour joined pink floyd official

Pink Floyd's fa

[SPOREthomas]

live on pink floyd, live on

[rafacm52]

Bob doesn't get it, does he?

[woutervincentbff]

Will you people just please shut the fuck up

If you were old

and you didn't know the lyrics in your head

i think you also needed a paper with the lyrics on it

so please stop saying he didn't needed the paper

Written by a floydian.

PS; Poster; Thanks for uploading this vid

[alwaysdreamingable]

he doesn't know the lyrics because he didn't write the song.....it was a movie that he was in a long time ago........Gilmour, one of the best guitarists in the world.... the Floyd, we loved them because they felt the same way we did.........excellent and thank you for uploading!!!!!

[zickpadrote]

todo es perfecto eres un grande , gilmour te admiro mucho un parte de Pink Floyd corre aun por tus venas xD

[CRAUSish]

THERE IS RICK WRIGHT TOO!!!!!!!!!!

[woutervincentbff]

@CRAUSish holy crap

You're right

Pause the vid

and watch 3:07

Then you'll see rick

[SoarerUZZ31]

How does he not know the lyrics?? Shame on you Bob.

[lacerdaer]

magic

[arrobarodolfog777]

Bob's papper... ¬¬

[kathleen1966]

ummm....he was in the movie....

[EscapeMCP]

I didn't know Craig David played double bass.

[MrRODAS666]

it`s riiculous going on stage and not knowing the songgs lyrics!|!

[NathanielKHVids]

Two little gems hidden in this video: David drinking his tea at 1:40 and Bob's awesome dance at 5:55. :D

[rlcflymusic]

And so the other page opened to order this DVD. What else can one say. :) Thanks

[Jpmusic96]

Bob geldof has a very similar voice to mark knopfler.

[jkinder1969]

Hmmm... I thought this sounded really good. Bob sounds much better than when Roger Waters sings it. Bob, should have memorized the words, though. haha

[Jvvanda]

que mierda. como asi que bob no se sabe esas partes tan faciles, hasta yo que no se ingles seria capaza de cantarlas, fucking bobo

[miguemam]

@Jvvanda ni dos dedos de frente, aprecia la musica! y aprende de ella, te falta mucho antes de criticar algo asi!

[meterripig]

bob is an absolute waste of fucking time david should of sang it all

[MRGR082391]

Gilmour is God!



[floridaskater07]

OMG Caroline Dale is just so incredibly talented and beautiful!

[zaproud]

@floridaskater07 She's is Behaving like a ROBOT :D lol

[SippinonMickeys]

@floridaskater07 Yes Gilmour + Dale is and was pure fucking win.

[Barkonetwothree]

I personally loved Geldof's performance. Sure he didn't have the lyrics memorized, but for all we know he was invited to sing at this concert day of and didn't have time to memorize it.

Either way, fantastic performance!

[MrsFloydArtemisa]

♥_♥

[islimming]

Dumb Bob...

[powerjonibrabo]

La parte de waters es un desastre, no se save ni la letra

[rjfloreschong]

@powerjonibrabo parece que tu tampoco saVes mucho de letras

[powerjonibrabo]

@rjfloreschong

no lo digo por que haiga dicho la cansion mal, si no por que la va leyendo y la tonada se ve diferente aparte se quiere pareser a Bob Dylan

[CamiiiBlack]

@powerjonibrabo Che boludo, no es Waters, pero si, cualquiera su parte, no se saBe ni la letra u.u

[powerjonibrabo]

@CamiiiBlack

lOSE QUE NO ES WATERS, pero no me gusta como interpreta la parte de el.

[Fatihstratocaster]

is he fucking with us. he is really reading the lyrics. here is turkey.. even here everybody knows this song :/

[Silvergoldstarfish]

Just gotta hav a strat for that solo

[HiOctane62]

wow that was awesome and to see the guy who played Pinky from The Wall sing it was sweet.

[vmackey11]

I would love to have this on MP3, great sounding...

[Forgottenimpuls]

@vmackey11 Just use youtube to mp3 converter on this video. ;)

[ryk84]

hello, BOB!

[fabiancito14xD]

hasta yo que no se ingles, me se la cancion :| XD

[Tfrne]

God dammit Bob

[Kapowieee1]

Caroline Dale is so incredibly beautiful.

[TheBatugan77]

@Kapowieee1 if that's the cellist...yes!

[AVIGTI]

This Bob Geldof is not doing good to such a song. Maybe that's all the idea

[kadu777777]

FALA O QUE SEM PALAVRAS!!!!!!!!!!!!



[1540nelson]

comentar o que dessa fera. occcccccccccccccctimo

[armandodark95]

CHUCHO MERCHAN RULES !!!!

[CRZ38L]

Dislikes? They must hate real music!

[2011NorcoRyde]

love it

[HadezNox]

Chucho Merchan.... Colombia presente,,

[william3636]

i guess i'm dense...i just don't get how someone could dislike this live performance. it seems sublime to me.

[jtlampsu]

Yes, shame on him not knowing the words, and he was in the film too,,,, big TUTS !! Also when he was on TV the other week about Floyd he said they were AWESOME at Live 8.... I Prefer the david bowie version with Gilmour (apart from the original) & he KNEW the words !!!!!

[acx10s]

se agradece



[ytdfinke23]

Geldof will look 15 when he's 80

[cucomaiden]

Michael Kamen (RIP) on piano...great verson....

[stellaP96]

that's what i call magic!!! see it exists !!!

[VelvetRope1992]

How can you not know the lyrics to this song?!?

[staffys4142]

the lady playing the cello gives me the horn!

[EricDavidFloyd]

Bob - take a word of advise from Bob Dylan - know your song well before you sing it

[novembrine1]

@EricDavidFloyd

What was wrong with him?

[mwibob]

shame on you ... bob geldorf ... you dont know the lyrics

[Johannore]

Pink Floyd seems to be a father/son thing for many. So it is for me!

[nootaramus]

I would eat ( her pussy) that gal playing the cello !

[areebbanjumm]

is mr. gilmour playing a gibson? i've never seen him playing a gibson

[hinicstevan]

@areebbanjumm No It is not a Gibson, It is a Gretch guitar i think. Cheers

[LMilleniumT]

@areebbanjumm But he certainly has played gibson guitars! the solo in another brick in the wall pt. 2 is played on a gibson!

[TopVersnelling]

Wait a minute, is that Bob Geldof guy Pink from the The Wall movie? It sure sounds like him!

[marilyano]

now he can do a led zeppelin movie , as jimmy page!!

[madhatt3r111]

Born in '84. Grown up with Floyd and love to watch live performances. Though this is a Gilmour channel, I was fortunate to see Waters' tour "THE WALL" at HP Pavilion December 2010.  Differences aside, they both embody the soul of this music and do these performances justice. Love them and their individual projects equally. Thank you for the upload :)

[superstratman14]

gildof scares the living shit out of me :)

[YManCyberDude]

Man... How awesome is this !!!

[juliperga672]

Twelve people do't know what the music..

[CallSignRaven]

even with a very simple Stage and gear this song sounds awesome.

David Gilmour's the best, period!!!!!

[aggusstinn]

no podes no saber la letra de esta cancion!!!!

[SupaMikael1]

David gilmour rules forever, he's The King!!!!!!!!

[blackened667]

NNNNNNNNNOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOOOOOOO, NOT GELDOF, THE WANKER. BUT I GUESS PEOPLE WEREN'T AWARE THAT HE HELPED KILL AROUND 150,000 AFRICANS WITH HIS FARCE THAT WAS LIVE AID. IF YOU DOUBT IT WATCH THE DOCUMENTARY "STARSUCKERS" BY CRISS ATKINS. IT WILL OPEN YOU EYES AND MIND

[555rest]

bob sounds like roger a little

[undersquirl]

goose-bumps.

[esepasae]

caroline dale you re beautiful

[abig1403]

The cellist is fab. Beautiful instrument, beautiful woman.

[ycicle]

David Gilmour is awesome in this show, but Caroline Dale (the cellist) makes the show for me.

[121nicholas]

weak solo

[vstarblackie]

@121nicholas What are you, a 20 year old Justin fan ??? Get a life and get the fuck of this comments page you fuckin pussy !!!!!

[Fetcha200]

The guy singing the rogers' parts in comfortably numb remind me of that guy who played in the wall-the movie.. The one with the suit on.. :)

[8P1NK15FloyD90]

@Fetcha200 it is him :)))

[pshphx]

SO BEAUTIFUL !!!!!....ACOUSTICALLY.....OR RAW LIVE.....NO MATTER THE WAY SIR GILMOUR PLAYS IT ..... . I BOW TO SIR DAVID GILMOUR

[fonvass]

Legent

[purpledude603]

Majestic yet refined. Gilmour is th legend !!

[Whatever2012Arthur]

Bob Geldof barely speaks in the movie The Wall because he can not memorize the text ... The guy is reading the lyrics of a song so famous! If I was David Gilmour would not let him sing without knowing the lyrics!

[ACfloydDC]

@Whatever2012Arthur but bob sang in the movie.

[Whatever2012Arthur]

@ACfloydDC yes, i know... and sang very well...

[ACfloydDC]

@Whatever2012Arthur but bob sang in the movie. well, on some songs.

[sebasredspecialfan]

@Whatever2012Arthur But he IS the original Pinky from The Wall, so that makes his presence justified in my opinion

[Blackshamrock1974]

@Whatever2012Arthur ...for gods sake man chill out and just enjoy the music stop nit picking...keep on rocking yuuuuuuuuuuup!!



[julio66able]

meraviglioso.

[julio66able]

meraviglioso

[Cheximus]

lol holding a piece of paper with the lyrics. LOL. Bob Geldof - prize cunt.

[tteu123]

Fuck you Bob. You could've at least had the decorum to memorise the lyrics. Fuck you

[Louren9]

I think that we all know that this is a prove that Gilmour is GOD

[aznhxor]

Watching that beautiful cellist smile and then David's emotional solo come in just made my day.

[edazdogma90]

is Bob fucking sick?! WTF?!

[Darndez]

that cellist is amazing!

[mitchskater]

Ello Bob

[samguy175]

Gretch you say? Gilmour you say? No! Fantastic regardless.

[mitchskater]

God Bless Michael Kamen, one of the greatest

[gingerbean2k7]

Is the dvd just called David Gilmour in concert?

[GilmourTrueHD]

@gingerbean2k7 Yes it is. Thanks, I should have had the dvd title in the description, now I get to go back through all the David Gilmour in concert vids and correct that...lol

[froibaad1]

How can you go on stage and don't know words for such a song??

[GlobeMullensk8]

@froibaad1 Specially seeing as how you were the MAIN CHARACTER in the movie -___-..totally kills the aura of the song :/



[floydiansdoank]

great posting !!!!

[Verboholiker]

best decision

[papan1990]

Who is the cellist ? She's so beautiful?

[largekinder]

@papan1990  Caroline Dale

[thedeadliest]

i think he pretends not to know the words...it would be shameful!

[jorgealbertobaron]

GRAN TEMA

[leardc]

LOL he was in the movie but doesn't know the words to the song?

[GuitarMasterizer]

@leardc never understood that. Doesn't make any sense at all. :l

[MaximilianPs]

tonight i've made a gift to my father, this DVD made him.. and me .. happy :)

[GilmourTrueHD]

Great gift, I love this dvd!

[hogwarts09]

Loving the shirt bob

[robdotcom71]

Hahahahah Bob the knob doesn't even know the words to one of the greatest songs ever...

Better than any dogshit that he could ever had written...

What a fucking wanker!!Get him off the stage now!

[kyu64]

Magico!!! Genial Monsieur Gilmour!!!

[secretworld1]

MAGICAL ,,!!!!!

[jmm1233]

awesome