Doesn't touch Amy's vocals, but I give her props for trying? I think she's just a little choppy for the smooth lyric style of the song. But that's just me maybe.
i have no idea why she is not a super rock star now whit a kik ass band...really...why! but we have Jonas brothers...justin beber...what happens to the word...
She did a great job on this song and was my fav of the season along with Magni. Watching Zayra's PO'd face was just a big plus for me. She sucked big time and ruined everything she sang.
This show was my favourite reality show ever made.Ugh i wish it would come back!Btw jill! Love her! Bets bottom 3 performance of the season right there
This isn't a bad cover I just think she's missing a bit of the bass that I personally like when someone sings this song. It gives it more umpth in my opinion.
I have to laugh.... They would have never chosen a female vocalist...... It wouldn't have mattered how talented she was. This whole cast needed more work.
The original is obviously the best but this done very well in my opinion. She should of captured the tenderness of the song more but even still she did great. BTW Zayra was terrible imo she ruined every song she sang, i remember lmao watch how pissed she was watching Jill tear down the house.
I don't think they were ever seriously considering picking a female lead singer. Gilby probably would have, but I think Tommy and Jason wanted a male lead singer from the start. However, all male contestants would've made for boring TV.
If they were going to choose a female, Jill >>>Dilana.
Yeah, you could tell that she wasn't happy to see Jill singing this the week after she did. She looks pissed everytime they show her, and they show her alot. lol. I liked them both really well though.
yup, she hated not only that Jill is singing it a week after she did, but she is also making her version look terrible, which it was...Jill sang this great
@frdaharlynna No one sings this like Amy Lee. period. It needs that unique tone that only Lee can do. Jill's to classic rocker with her vocals for this song.
Toby was in the version WITH Storm, as the back-up vocals. I don't agree, I actually prefer this version over Storm & Toby's, and Zayra's. Honestly, I think Zayra's really.. just.. killed the song.
i didnt like zayra. but i did like storms version better. jill is a finesse singer, if u ever really listen to her voice u can hear that she never hits the note directly. she always slurs here voice into the note which is good for country. storm was the one who has the most trouble wit the song but her effort and her talent helped her change a good song into an excellent song
because when jill did bring me to life at elmination zayra picked bring me to life to perform a a week befor or the same week, and jill did way better
At least Zayra could entertain. Some of the people on that show just didn't have much stage presence and were pretty boring actually. You could never say Zayra was boring.
Well hell out of the 3 chicks that did this song, this was the only bitch who nailed it. She's no Amy Lee, but I could see Amy approving of this cover. No "creative covers", just pure Evanesense.
JIll is one of my favorite singers . She has an incredible voice ...much larger than others. A great personality, a great sense of humor and great passion for what she does. I miss seeing her live around New York. I wish her the best in all she does.
lol at 1:12!! she did the cross sign there!! i will say that she did a pretty good job on this song. you don't have to sound like Amy lee if you are going to sing one of her songs on this ya' know!! some people sound different when they sing. so, at LEAST give her some props on this song!!
duh of course people can cover this song and give it their own twist, thats what makes a real musician. not just mere copying the original. but jill gave the song justice and it was a good song for her voice
zayra does NOT look amused. lol. whatever, Jill was better and that's that. Zayra just sang this song too... weird, for lack of a better word at the moment.
and Storm is great but this song wasn't good for her.
she sucks sucks sucks it's soooo crap...no one can cover this song well not one person amy lee's voice is oo invidual and anyone who tries sounds like a tube...sorry bu i's rue she completely killed it
i saw Evanescence in concert and this is nothing compared to Amy Lee
traysia113 2 weeks ago
I miss this show it was awesome wish they would bring this back
JCRIBBSANDMCCOY 3 weeks ago
Doesn't touch Amy's vocals, but I give her props for trying? I think she's just a little choppy for the smooth lyric style of the song. But that's just me maybe.
arikay123 1 month ago 2
lol, Jill was a cheater. She is a pro singer.
jimaymay 6 months ago
@TheCrimsonStrawberry Zayra was horrible.
GJARRS 6 months ago
@TheCrimsonStrawberry in case you were confused I was stating that Jill was good Amy is better Storm is good and Zayra is worse than shit
GJARRS 6 months ago
i have no idea why she is not a super rock star now whit a kik ass band...really...why! but we have Jonas brothers...justin beber...what happens to the word...
PsiqueLogos 6 months ago
@PsiqueLogos They are aimed at all the young girlies who go for the face & a catchy song... forget about a great voice & song!
MsFerris21 2 months ago
Zena peva pa razbija. Kakav glas. Neverovatno :)
racyclebin 6 months ago
who really loves evanescence and know them can't say that this song is good..
elgordito911 6 months ago
..this is too goooooooood.! I Luuuuuu
u it!
rodmrivera 6 months ago
That little sign of the Cross she makes...paying homage to her Catholic school roots...she was the best!
NYcgrguy 7 months ago
where can i watch this show?
Vitiare23 7 months ago
Amy>Jill>Storm>Shit>Zayra
GJARRS 7 months ago
She did a great job on this song and was my fav of the season along with Magni. Watching Zayra's PO'd face was just a big plus for me. She sucked big time and ruined everything she sang.
pmcdl 10 months ago 2
ehh she's off beat and doesn't seem to feel it. not finishing this video.
ginnysays1 10 months ago
In the end, Jill was voted out before Zayra. So Zayra laughed at last.
tvEdo 11 months ago
I miss this show three
alvie2 1 year ago
She's my distant cousin, no joke.
PrinceofDarkness9585 1 year ago
I totally miss this show too!!!
iprincesswhale138 1 year ago
does any1 know a link to see the old episodes of the week to week life of the stars?
ians2cool2 1 year ago
This show was my favourite reality show ever made.Ugh i wish it would come back!Btw jill! Love her! Bets bottom 3 performance of the season right there
tiggercat500 1 year ago
This isn't a bad cover I just think she's missing a bit of the bass that I personally like when someone sings this song. It gives it more umpth in my opinion.
bldydrkangl 1 year ago
the woman had Pipes, no doubt.....not a lotta personal style though..
AlexMackinum 1 year ago
I have to laugh.... They would have never chosen a female vocalist...... It wouldn't have mattered how talented she was. This whole cast needed more work.
DIVINATORY 1 year ago
superb
gerardrodrigo14 1 year ago
yeah she said screaming lol what a noob
italgino21 1 year ago
"without a soul my screaming is sleepng somewhere cold"???
Did she say that??!!
It's "Without a soul, my spirit 's sleeping somewhere cold".
adr14ntr 1 year ago
@adr14ntr Sounds like 'spirits' to me. I think she's just mumbling a bit.
danno700 1 year ago
She did very good
BateYasho 1 year ago
The original is obviously the best but this done very well in my opinion. She should of captured the tenderness of the song more but even still she did great. BTW Zayra was terrible imo she ruined every song she sang, i remember lmao watch how pissed she was watching Jill tear down the house.
XBLKOUT420X 1 year ago
In this show knew from the beggining the were planing on pickig a guy.
ernesto6103 1 year ago
she doesn't capture the tenderness of the song! It's pitchy and shouty and not controlled. I love the original.
Qdiazissipom 1 year ago 2
terribleee
galadeas 1 year ago
the best version done on this show, right here,
JIHOSOCR 1 year ago
I miss this show...........
tramca 2 years ago 51
@tramca Me too! I loved it. It's one of the few things on TV I had to be home to see.
RockysMom89 7 months ago
i remember this zayra was very pissed
saulski90 2 years ago 2
It was this performance that made me a fan of Jill's. Some of her other songs were hit-and-miss, but this performance was mind-blowing.
UnluckyAssassin 2 years ago
Jill has a VERY powerful voice live. See her if you can she does live shows every now and then.
prr1361 2 years ago
I don't think they were ever seriously considering picking a female lead singer. Gilby probably would have, but I think Tommy and Jason wanted a male lead singer from the start. However, all male contestants would've made for boring TV.
If they were going to choose a female, Jill >>>Dilana.
UnluckyAssassin 2 years ago 3
@UnluckyAssassin : I agree totally. I like Dilana also. Her LITHIUM was totally out of control...BRILLIANT !!!
prr1361 2 years ago
She's got a great voice, but she comes across like a housewife from New Jersey.
SternSuperManiac 2 years ago 2
i was never a jill fan but this performance was amazing, she did a killier killer job.
morrisonlover44 2 years ago
This version is A LOT better than Storm's, but in her defense, her voice just didn't suit the song.
sweetsolitude99 2 years ago 3
Awesome voice, she did a good job here! (Amy Lee wishes she could sing like THAT live), I liked this
arturesteve 2 years ago
amy is amazing live what are you talking about
eclipeser 2 years ago
but Zahita didnt like it _lol
phatgonk 2 years ago
Yeah, you could tell that she wasn't happy to see Jill singing this the week after she did. She looks pissed everytime they show her, and they show her alot. lol. I liked them both really well though.
0reos64 2 years ago
yup, she hated not only that Jill is singing it a week after she did, but she is also making her version look terrible, which it was...Jill sang this great
wjs1710 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i like to punk that short thang
phatgonk 2 years ago
No one can do what Amy Lee of Evanescence can.
Kir13ear 2 years ago 3
She owns the stage and kick major a**es!
SuperstarX 2 years ago 2
This was better than Zayra's but the original by Evanesence is Best.
frdaharlynna 2 years ago 24
anything was better then zayra..lol sorry but I dont know what the hell she was doing on that show
sens2good 2 years ago
@frdaharlynna No one sings this like Amy Lee. period. It needs that unique tone that only Lee can do. Jill's to classic rocker with her vocals for this song.
PhantoMPhreeK92 1 year ago
@frdaharlynna totally agree with you.. I loved it how she was shown with that sour puss look on her face. hahaha.. Jill rocked it..
charley1999 1 year ago
im not religious or anything, but shut the fuck up gothtaco.. ur full of it.
i prefer toby and storms version, mainly since toby brought a raw element to the backup vocals
JuicedBoi 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
she should kill her self for prating while singing this song wat a bitch
GothTaco 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
praying*
GothTaco 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
you suk u know?
darckzamurai 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
that sucked
hollyberrytree 2 years ago
I prefer Storm & Toby's version of this.
ashraym 2 years ago
i dont remember toby ever doing this version. it was storm and zayra
adunn225 2 years ago
Toby was in the version WITH Storm, as the back-up vocals. I don't agree, I actually prefer this version over Storm & Toby's, and Zayra's. Honestly, I think Zayra's really.. just.. killed the song.
xMrsMeganLetox 2 years ago 4
i didnt like zayra. but i did like storms version better. jill is a finesse singer, if u ever really listen to her voice u can hear that she never hits the note directly. she always slurs here voice into the note which is good for country. storm was the one who has the most trouble wit the song but her effort and her talent helped her change a good song into an excellent song
adunn225 2 years ago 3
God you couldn't be more right Zayra's is just wow.
souloftwilight 2 years ago
Glad to know someone agrees ^_^
xMrsMeganLetox 2 years ago
@adunn225 Storm sang it with toby (he was backing vocals) i know your comment was 10 months old but what the heck ;)
emilyyam 1 year ago
@emilyyam haha its cool :)
adunn225 1 year ago
why did the camera keep showing zayra? did they hv some kind of feud?
mel3120 2 years ago
because when jill did bring me to life at elmination zayra picked bring me to life to perform a a week befor or the same week, and jill did way better
cadvo 2 years ago
she has a good voice...but I want to punch her pretentious face in.
evilwillow19 2 years ago
she was okay...
frdaharlynna 2 years ago
She blew this song out of the water!
BamaCrueChick 2 years ago
the video seriously gave me goosebumps. lol.
jldavies87 3 years ago 2
fantastic voice , fantastic girl
djzacky 3 years ago
love it when the camera pans on zayra looks likes she's a little pissy that she can't do that lol
canadiangirl20 3 years ago
Zayra couldnt do much of anything...
prr1361 3 years ago
At least Zayra could entertain. Some of the people on that show just didn't have much stage presence and were pretty boring actually. You could never say Zayra was boring.
zeecee1 3 years ago 4
Anyone that shakes her boobies on stage is considered entertaining.
happypunklove 2 years ago
awesome!!
ALMOST as good as the original!
♥ it
BeXy170893 3 years ago
Zayra at 0:46..." WTF, I cant sing like that"
prr1361 3 years ago
AMAZING
BEST ONEEEE.
Otehr hten amys hahaha
but best one on the show
Africanlionsafari 3 years ago
Wow!!! What a awesome voice!!!
telinah 3 years ago
jill's my aunt...shes my moms sister so its really cool singing on a show because she is really good and never really got credited for it
JoeJonasMyLove4Ever 3 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
She has great voice but she didn't sing the song in the dark way,she must sing pop or rnb songs not rock!!
LynetteImmortalle 3 years ago
she did an amazing job with this song. I couldn't help but sing along with her lol x]
bwanana095 3 years ago 2
shes one of the best on the youtube site, at least better than the other people that trys to sing, KEEP IT UP JILL !
Flipkid81 3 years ago 4
better than the other two like everyone says but still not good enough. i don't think anyone can do better than amy to be honest but its a good try.
bad2wolf2mcgee 3 years ago
the other two boutchered it SO badly. tis is pretty okay
eeveeoverlord 3 years ago 2
god this chick ruined it too! no one can do ev NO ONE the only people tht can do it is the band themselves this is fucking shit
xXxlette4lyfexXx 3 years ago
Well hell out of the 3 chicks that did this song, this was the only bitch who nailed it. She's no Amy Lee, but I could see Amy approving of this cover. No "creative covers", just pure Evanesense.
job1181 3 years ago 5
she was way better then the other two who sung this song
runescapeDailycr3lf 3 years ago 4
agreed.... x5
phoenix2o1 3 years ago 2
shes great!!!!!!!!!
MemoryOfTheHeart 3 years ago
Awesome!! A wicked female rocker, I would love to see/hear her singing in a good metal band!
Zeliziouz 3 years ago 4
JIll is one of my favorite singers . She has an incredible voice ...much larger than others. A great personality, a great sense of humor and great passion for what she does. I miss seeing her live around New York. I wish her the best in all she does.
prr1361 3 years ago
lol at 1:12!! she did the cross sign there!! i will say that she did a pretty good job on this song. you don't have to sound like Amy lee if you are going to sing one of her songs on this ya' know!! some people sound different when they sing. so, at LEAST give her some props on this song!!
Aralei13 3 years ago
Holy crap, she is WAYYYY better than the Storm and Zyita...
Anything716anything 3 years ago 2
shi is better than others
real98 3 years ago
duh of course people can cover this song and give it their own twist, thats what makes a real musician. not just mere copying the original. but jill gave the song justice and it was a good song for her voice
kenanjairus07 4 years ago
okay people should just stop trying to pull that song off because only amy lee can do it any justice, i will admit that storm large did okay though
lobo20043ca 4 years ago
zayra does NOT look amused. lol. whatever, Jill was better and that's that. Zayra just sang this song too... weird, for lack of a better word at the moment.
and Storm is great but this song wasn't good for her.
0fayelynn0 4 years ago
Jill rocks on this one better than Storm and Zyita but Storm did better than Zyita. Jill's is the one that is richer and stronger.
charley1999 4 years ago
of all the people who sang this song that season, i liked her the best...
and i saw amy le live, on her cds you may be right about the computer, but she is fantastic live...better than i expected her to be
LadyRaederle 4 years ago
she sucks sucks sucks it's soooo crap...no one can cover this song well not one person amy lee's voice is oo invidual and anyone who tries sounds like a tube...sorry bu i's rue she completely killed it
crissielvzgee 4 years ago
well u are stupid, this is clean, amy lee´s voice is cheat... it´s computer all over the place, Jill Gioia has more natural talent than Amy Lee.
Hrafnin 4 years ago
Actually, Ame Lee's voice sounds as pretty as a violin at times.
Wospwosp 4 years ago
personally,
I thought Dilana should have done that song.
stargirl1492 4 years ago
wow she did good with this song...i like it lol
thevampirelestat26 4 years ago
BITCH!!! i love her version but she would of never song that if Zayra sung it and Killed it (GO ZAYRA!!!)
Icycheetah01 4 years ago
um wow. zayra did sing it...and she sounded horrible. ur done.
driftingspirit 4 years ago
btw this was one of my favorite performances of this sho :D
driftingspirit 4 years ago
amazing she should be on american idol !!!!!!!!!!!!
jkleppe 4 years ago
not bad
jorpike 4 years ago
Zyaras like, "What a bitch!"
puissse 5 years ago