I have to admit when I first heard that Ellen was gonna be an idol judge I was pretty excited and was sure she would be perfect for it. But after her appearnce on idol last year I felt that maybe I was wrong. As much as I love Ellen and think she's hilarious, she really didn't add anything at all to the show or make it more interesting (ironic I know). I think she made the right decision to quit the show.
excuse me its NOT about being ABLE TO SING a song just because you cant sing doesnt mean you have ears for music, stop dissing ellen im 100% sure if your favorite celebrity couldnt sing youd be totally happy about it shes not stupid she just cant sing
Time will tell. Never mind, she can't sing or do anything musical. Neither can Simon. Plus he can't read music, write music, or play an instrument. I personally prefer Paula, but, oh well, what can you do. The AI producers wanted Paula out & set things up so she had no choice but to decline the contract as presented to her. A shame, but it happens all too often in show biz.
I live in England so its not really my position to comment but I WILL. as much as I liked what i saw from Paula Abdul yeah its a shame to see her leave but the fact that the decision was already made that she was not returning so we cant do anything to bring her back we have to move on. So i think Ellen has become the best decision that could have been made i dont know who else would have been good like Ellen..perhaps it will be better than some people think, wait until we SEE Ellen on there XD
I've been thinking about why ellen was chosen for the show and I've been trying to think of good reasons for her... I think she knows a lot about stage presence and performance (since she's worked in front of people since.... practically forever...) so she is able to judge that. It's not 100% about the voice - you can have a great voice but be totally awkward on stage and you're not going to win with that. It's about finding someone who can appeal to people and know how to work a crowd too.
Why did they say in this report that Simon will welcome Ellen (or IS welcoming Ellen) to American Idol this year? Ellen was announced two months ago as the new judge and Simon is the only personality from Idol that has not issued a statement or said ONE WORD about Ellen being hired. People need to get their reporting straight. I don't think Simon's happy about Ellen at all. Simon told Fox he wanted PAULA on the show.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
ellen will be terrible.......she cant dance, sing or do anything musical..........plus she is looking more like a man every day............I heard she is going to have a sex change
Ellen is going to be terrible. American Idol is done for. I watched it since it started and i loved Paula. She was fun. Ellen is going to try to hard to be funny but she is not going to be. GOODBYE AMERICAN IDOL. My prediction is that this is the final season of idol.
I have to admit when I first heard that Ellen was gonna be an idol judge I was pretty excited and was sure she would be perfect for it. But after her appearnce on idol last year I felt that maybe I was wrong. As much as I love Ellen and think she's hilarious, she really didn't add anything at all to the show or make it more interesting (ironic I know). I think she made the right decision to quit the show.
aku192 10 months ago
excuse me its NOT about being ABLE TO SING a song just because you cant sing doesnt mean you have ears for music, stop dissing ellen im 100% sure if your favorite celebrity couldnt sing youd be totally happy about it shes not stupid she just cant sing
excuse her for not having THAT gift
she is a good judge
shes honest
she has fun too
and she doesnt go beyond what she knows so
just chill
and stop with the negativivty
Hannanball13 1 year ago 2
Phew!! Thank God it's not Jonas!!
But it'll be hilarious with Ellen on Idol! :D
Hahaha!
cca211 2 years ago
Time will tell. Never mind, she can't sing or do anything musical. Neither can Simon. Plus he can't read music, write music, or play an instrument. I personally prefer Paula, but, oh well, what can you do. The AI producers wanted Paula out & set things up so she had no choice but to decline the contract as presented to her. A shame, but it happens all too often in show biz.
SpaghettiGirl1982 2 years ago
I live in England so its not really my position to comment but I WILL. as much as I liked what i saw from Paula Abdul yeah its a shame to see her leave but the fact that the decision was already made that she was not returning so we cant do anything to bring her back we have to move on. So i think Ellen has become the best decision that could have been made i dont know who else would have been good like Ellen..perhaps it will be better than some people think, wait until we SEE Ellen on there XD
ShyGuy19898 2 years ago
i dont think ellen can read music either. or write it, or play an instrument. she probably thinks that Do is a deer.
grantr456 2 years ago
a Female deer.
grantr456 2 years ago
I've been thinking about why ellen was chosen for the show and I've been trying to think of good reasons for her... I think she knows a lot about stage presence and performance (since she's worked in front of people since.... practically forever...) so she is able to judge that. It's not 100% about the voice - you can have a great voice but be totally awkward on stage and you're not going to win with that. It's about finding someone who can appeal to people and know how to work a crowd too.
darkaardvark720 2 years ago
GO ELLEEEEEN!
to1be1me 2 years ago 2
Go Ellen!
unfoldingart 2 years ago
Why did they say in this report that Simon will welcome Ellen (or IS welcoming Ellen) to American Idol this year? Ellen was announced two months ago as the new judge and Simon is the only personality from Idol that has not issued a statement or said ONE WORD about Ellen being hired. People need to get their reporting straight. I don't think Simon's happy about Ellen at all. Simon told Fox he wanted PAULA on the show.
chillindillon5790 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
ellen will be terrible.......she cant dance, sing or do anything musical..........plus she is looking more like a man every day............I heard she is going to have a sex change
darkfur35 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
ELLEN SUCKS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
piffSD 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
ELLEN SUCKS!
piffSD 2 years ago
Joe Jonas?
Jeez... What the heck did the producers think? T__T
Kingtown 2 years ago 2
The ads are annoying!
aku192 2 years ago 13
@aku192 If there werent ads we would have to pay for youtube
MultiMonkeyss 10 months ago
i think they should get someone with musical experience, hell i would rather see cyndi lauper
peasent1287 2 years ago
BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOo
stupid ads
hurbaga 2 years ago 8
I think it's a very smart pic for AI. I'm gonna miss Paula, but it coudln't happen to a nicer person. I'm actually gonna tune into the show now!
DesperatelyKind 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
does anyone know what song ellen's dancing to at 0:57
googlerankingexpert 2 years ago
Comment removed
googlerankingexpert 2 years ago
Nostalgic sons of bitches.. Ellen will be fine and the show will be better than ever withou paula's non sense coments.
juckadings 2 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
Ellen is going to be terrible. American Idol is done for. I watched it since it started and i loved Paula. She was fun. Ellen is going to try to hard to be funny but she is not going to be. GOODBYE AMERICAN IDOL. My prediction is that this is the final season of idol.
videoreviewer99 2 years ago
u fucken suck "videoreviewer99" Ellen is going to make the show more funny and entertaining...GO ELLEN!!
keenasafrog 2 years ago 7
I wish she was replacing Kara instead of Paula
wonbinlover 2 years ago 5
i think ellen will bring a whole new chapter to american idol...she's going to be amazing!!!!
Steven123789 2 years ago 7
i love that ellen is now on AI
uste25 2 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
HALF THE FANS GONE!! JUST LIKE THAT!!!! ellen SUCKS!!!
piffSD 2 years ago
The real test will come when she's mixing with the other judges.
snoops71 2 years ago
the only bad thing is that she won't be in the auditions rounds, she'll start as judge in the hollywood rounds... : (
sacd25 2 years ago
BLM A much better person...Like Who?? Ellen will be awesome and funny and will bring new life to A.I.'s routine
xoolkam 2 years ago
I think that ellen is the GREATEST =D she is funny and she can really bring life to amercian idol
kohhy 2 years ago
Bradley jacobs, well said.
genelee16 2 years ago
UGG, this probably will be last year for AI. THey could have found a much better person to replace.
BLMichaletz 2 years ago
HEY!!!!!!!!!!!! what the feathers is ur problem?! Ellen will make an AWESOME JUDGE!!!
nanaobsessiveHSM3 2 years ago 5
yeah...pretty much anyone at julliard would have been enough, but forbid someone who is am outsider from the BS pop culture
sebastal 2 years ago