Added: 2 years ago
From: ParasRajput
Views: 27,463
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (112)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • old one was much better than this.....!!

  • @arjun13031968 much much....................

  • salo tumhari maaki choot jis bhi laudae ko nahi acha laga, nahi acha laga to apni gand daboch ke baith ja na , kamsae kam ganda haag to maath ,tere maa ki choot

  • ARE MAAA KE LOONDOOON TUM KIS DEEESH KI CHAAAKI KA ATAAA KAHTE HOOO ,,, SAAALOON APNE HI GANE KOOO DISLIKE KAR KE KYOOON GADAAAR BAN RAHE H0OOOO SALLOOON KISINE NE TO IS GAANE OON REVIVE KIYA HIA SALOOON AGAR TUM CHUTOYOON KOOO PASAND NAHI AYA TO KYA HUAAA SOOAAALOON INDIA IS MY MOTHER MY COUNTRY TUM JESE HIZDOON NE MERI MAAA MERE INDIA KI IZAAAT KHRAAAB KAR DI HAI SALOON JAAAG JAOOO APNE DESH SEEE PYARRR KARO IS PAR MAR JAOOO , I LOVE MY COUNTRY INDIA MY MOTHER

  • I am quite disappointed with the video.The song has a rich impact on every mind.

    But it is well known, our nation is known for our villages which is completely omitted.I don't know why?Focus is to capture the monuments to show the identity of various states or region but I can say, that would be quite better if common scenes of our villages were given priority.The gap between India and Bharat is already widening and it is clearly shown in this video.

  • Old is gold

  • I PROUD TO B I M INDIAN THANX PARAS FOR UPLOADING THIS VIDEO

  • Sonu Nigam needs to get over himself .

  • After watching this song, I have realized that India is becoming more fake. Back in 80s, even though I was only a kid at that time, people were still proud of what they were. Being in armed forces was a matter of pride. In today's India, people are obsessed with just doing MBAs and getting jobs in american companies. Its more about glamour and money and this is what this video shows too.

  • @ZooniIndian what do you do??

  • so overall: the video was utter nonsense, made only for the sake of showing all stars and not to foster the feeling of oneness. there was more of hindi in the video ...while the older one had lots mroe. even if this one had all of the languages, it was obvious that there was more importance given to hindi

    PS: i am a hugge fan of bollywood, all the khans, shahid and also though hindi is not my mother tongue, its my most fav lang ...so these comments are not passed because i dont like them

  • further ranbir comes so that later he does not say he was not called

    then comes shahrukh fine nice ...and why that ohohoho humara???

    karan johar comes for same reason as ranbir

    then goes on nice till the end ...and lovely music

    (continued in enxt comment)

  • ....then concept is nice but just reveals the concept of 'no controversy' ...it is the basic concept looks like or is not to get cought in controversy but not to show that india is one

    then sonu comes ....fine to give a little western pinch (that was given in the start of his entry) ...then comes shahid ...and spoilt the entire video that was already kinda miserable

    (continued in next comment)

  • a complete analysis

    nice bgining ...goes well till 1.10

    then comes stupid deepika just to reveal her skin

    then comes priyanka in salwar ...that was nice

    next goes nice t....nice music in between

    then malayalam and tamil ....nice till 3.50 (music nice ...but too much to pause)

    fine bharatnatyam is needed ....but why are the group dancers dressed that way in the beginning (revealing stomach)

    goes nice till 4.51 ....(continued in next comment)

  • this is such a fail !!! why is shahid, and deepika here??? nothing can compare to the original version and this is a very bad attempt

  • and there are not north-east states

    only muslims are there

  • Gay-est shit ever...

  • Disappointing.....EPIC FAIL!!!

  • Previous1 was lot better.....I hate this stupid bollywood biased vid....

    shame ...shame ..shame...

  • dis one is very nice too - but for - deepika and her short dress, not sure why - we indians - like to accept certain values of the western culture, in the western country - people wear short dresses as the weather is such, anyway - there are many other western values that we should learn - like tolerating indifferences, accepting others for what they are - these values i have seen only in dis western world .......

  • this a video every indian must watch & must know their duty towards our motherland

  • Comment removed

  • kon hei iye pagal composer aur usko kaam dene walal murkh producer kaun hei?very poor .disrespecting mile sur this time i think

  • This video isnt complete without Sachin in it!!

  • @robiniyer83

    wht about saurav ganguly?? wht abt Gavaskar n Kapil??

    and no Beng?? lol.... whoevr made this noob vid..get a life...

  • This was a really sickening video...what has national integration got to do with video...?It has bollywood in every shape and size...looking totally incoherent. In some parts, it was showing representation from the states, but it dissipated no sooner than it came. They should stop making such caricatures of something as serious as National Integration, and try and making Ad-Film videos instead...it will suit them more!!!

  • As for Hijab commentary - nowhere in Pak and Bangladesh do women "have" to wear hijab. They can if they want to. Or not. And in the so-called "Arya" tradition in India, higher castes women were veiled. So? Based on ur argument u urself hardly have a "shining" history. War might destroy culture - religion doesn't.

    I was about to say how gr8 it is to see someone celebrating their culture and diversity. Sadly, ur love for ur own culture is based on hatred and ignorance about others', what a shame!

  • islamic cultures dont have diversity... they r based on an arab culture. Thats one of the most ignorant statements ever. Sindhi culture is as intact as it was - oncoming of a new religion changes or adds to the existing culture, it doesnt destroy it. Else u shud go back to ur roots before the Vedas, cuz Hinduism must have "destroyed" ur culture a lot too.

  • How come the shitheads like Karan Johar and Priyanka Chopra appear in this video when people like Sachin, APJ Abdul Kalam and Manmohan Singh are left out? They killed the song!!

  • old is gold,

    thats not our feel like us....

    its like only filmy fashion show....

  • old is gold,

    thats not our feel like us....

    its like only filmy fashion show....

  • still old is gold...

    thats not our culture, our music ..

    its not feel like us....

  • Comment removed

  • Our Indian music culture is greatest in the world... and Old Mile Sur was one of the example...

    But this sur only spoils mood........

    Tooooooooooo Badddddddddddd

  • Comment removed

  • @pkkulkarni14 NO WAY MAN...Our people still work with music like our old music? That's brilliant as it is. What's even greater is that classical musicians support this too. Every piece has its own quality. Appreciate it man. Jai Hind, Jai Bhaarat. Take care pkkilkarni14

  • this is more like a commercial..no sur between the old and this one...i love the old one the most...

  • wtf?? what kinda crap is this??

  • jai hind..................vande mataram

  • The original version was much more touching & had a sense of patriotisim to it. This video just has a sense of Bollywood to it. I myself enjoy Bollywood movies, but having all those actors was such a waste & looked so articifical/fake. The only touching part was Salman Khan with the deaf & dumb children. The old version was MUCH better...

  • I watched the original and then this new version right after. No comparision. The original goes straight to your heart. The new version felt like a new movie commercial.

  • Totally with Sam.Nobody would watch this video to watch Deepikas' legs and Ranbir's silly pose and Shahid's show off.What have they acheived for the country?What eligibility do they have to stand on this platform?What is Sonu trying to do in that video?This looks like a Bollywood song rather than a patriotic song in the second half.The sportsmen,the business tycoons,the literaries,and most imp, the defence forces are like totally ruled out.

    Who's the video director?? What a shame!!

  • Disappointed watching this video!!! Why there is only bollywood's singers/actors/composers/direc­tors/choregoraphers showing in the video, rather than Sachin, TATA, Ambanis, Gurdaas Maan, Lata ji, Hockey players, Army,Navy etc fighting on borders, farmers, no punjabi people??

    OMG!! Im not very happy!! stil prefer the old version!!!

  • We all are fan of Indian actor and actress, but many of actors not eligible for this songs. We have Sachin Tendulkar, Saurav Ganguly, Lata Mangeshkar, businessman like TATA, and good political people too. India not famous only because of actor and actress.

  • was it a bollywood movie trialor?

  • video is not that bad as had been reviewed, but too much bollywood here.atleast some great poet, scientists or from politics could have taken place in place of Ranbir , Deepika,Shahid.they can do it the next version.

    I feel people are more expressive about their creativity than showing passion for integrity.atleast for countries sake shahrukh,aamir,salman could share a single screen.Whatever,good thought,well try, but if you cant take it to that level of Mile Sur,it is better not to touch it.

  • the most immature thing ever made.

    who made this?? n for whom?? bollywood is a part of India and India is not bollywood!!!

    mile sur.....is an iconic song dedicated to some stalwarts in respective fields and represents India as a whole.....PHIR MILE SUR is just for bollywood....nothing else...IT misses out on a hell lot of things....the original showed unity in diversity but THIS ONE shows only diversity  no unity...sur taal everything is missin.......

  • I believe I missed one more point how could u people miss the real heros , our NSG commandos how risked their lives to save hundreds of other men in Mumbai? Go for real heros people and not reel heroes... I m seriously so upset with this video

  • thanx god v dont have dodgy politicians and cricketers are not here

  • 1. This new version missed some national heroes like sachin,lata,Sir Abdul kalam,should have included some defence personnels those are in border,ISRO team,hockey team,cricket team,Ambani,ofcorse mammohan singh.

    2. Advance of the nation in terms of technology and economically is not portrayed

    3. so many bollywood stars, whats the need?

    4. Salman showing up his body is of no use when national integrity is being portrayed.

  • seriously erase it 4m every possible place available..... utterly dissapointing, v really dont want our kids 2 grow up remembering this 'mile sur mera tumhara' it totally dejecting to c ppl comin up wid such pathetic work!!!

  • If u really wanted to show true Indianian s u could have gone for people like Kalpana Chawala, A.P.J Abdul Kalam, Rakesh Sharma, or other really gr8 people. The older version's video is 100 times better than this. Once again I would like to say India is not Bollywood people.

  • i m completly agree wit ur statement

  • I am a great fan of SRK and Amir but what the hell r they doing in this video, India is not Bollywood, Bollywood is a part of India hope u understand this u could have shown them just for a while like u have done the sports persons

  • err Kalpana Chawla is no more. RIP Kalpana.

  • It sucks seriously sucks, who the hell made this video. It started wonderfully with Drums Shivamani,but when I saw Deepika Padkone, I was like what is this female doing in this video... from then it went bad to worse to worst.. I hate this video.

  • Comment removed

  • sabse wahiyat video hai ye .jisne bhi banaya hai usne humari sanskruti k saath bhadda mazak kiya hai......................

  • No cricketers in video. Amazing !!! In a cricket crazy nation.

  • Indian media have all but ignored a murder allegedly committed by three of the country's own citizens, in marked contrast to the hysterical coverage of allegedly racist attacks on Indian nationals in Australia. Fruit-picker Ranjodh Singh was believed to be alive when he was allegedly set on fire near the NSW Riverina town of Griffith on December 29. Three Indian nationals faced court yesterday charged over Singh's murder after police arrested the third suspect, a 25-year-old man, in Wagga Wagga.

  • fuck lards these guys have wasted my time and such a beautiful feeling abt my country. It is not more then an advertisement. They have not showcased the feeling of one india.

  • WTF

  • I want the last 16 minutes of my life back :(. What a waste!

  • A total crap!! More of an insult actually....

    the older one was sheer finesse and so mesmerizing.........

    I could have made a better one I guess :)

  • why the old song ? can't find good song ?

  • duniya ka sabse faltu vedio..... not eastern states.... why deepika -only to show her dresss... issse accha rakhi sawant ko laga dete...jo bhi isi banya hai .... he/she must be a bollywood dog..... kyu baya isse accha nahi banate... its proves dats we r not better dan our senoirs

  • No Cricketersss shameee

  • this is shit

    the old version was really nice. this is becoming just another platform for the filmstars to show their stupity. bull crap

  • has anyone noticed what they have done with the national anthem part at the end? when i was a kid i remember reading it in my civil science book that any alteration/adulteration of national anthem is a violence.

  • sorry sorry sorry...but its a real disgrace...did they do it intentionally?????coz i cant figure out how on earth they came up with this thing...plzz plzz plzz re edit this one...

  • Iam happy to see Iam not alone, who feels a song that represents the nations sentiment of Unity and Progress, should have acheivers like Dr.APJ,NSG Commando's, and not "mere entertainers"...

  • its a let down.. hope they at least reedit this stuff if they really intend to show national integrity... such a disappointment.. and wats so grt abt the Bachans.. oh wat ever.. i'l still vote for the older original version...

  • Crap..crap..INDIA IS NOT BOLLYWOOD...and a bunch of regional film actors

    Where are the likes of sachin tendulkar , narayan murthy ,kiran bedi et al?

    wat so great of ashiyara rai, deepika padukone and gang....BS !

    growing up children will be forced to believe..india is filimi......

  • Hugely diappointing would even say its total crap, is Bollywood India????

    Wht F Aholes!!!!!!!!

  • it sucks all these ppl r very true it seems it is not dedicate to nation but dedicate to bolly wood who the hell has made this iconic video, like this hang him till death

  • poor man, poor thinking......here people should be from every field. very bad video

  • this new version is real disgrace. full of filim stars. the old version was superb..i didnt feel any national integrity in the new version....the zoom should withdraw this new version..

  • Too much bollywood representation.. Not Good!!

  • Old version was good... :) but why so many film stars.. People who have really contributed in different fields should have been included like Kargil heroes, sachin, APJ, Narayan Murthy... and listening full song is a torture.. Hope they can retain the original tune.. .Jai Hind!!!

  • Hello Friends.

    here is the link of Zoom TV where we can give them feedback about this video.

    h t t p : / / w w w . z o o m t v . i n / c o n t a c t u s . p h p (please remove spaces)

    I have given my feedback twice. I hope if more and more people send them genuine feedback about this video, they may feel ashamed of themselves and pull this video back.

  • People, the only thing which we can do is "Report this video". I have done so, please give a helping hand.

  • hope*

  • SUCKS BIG TIME!!!

    shahid kapoor? priyanka? deepika? karan johar? sonu nigam????? all money hungry people in a mega distortion of an iconic song!!! The one whose concept is this, he/she is one of the biggest a**h*l*. I hole he/she reads this comment.

  • Very bad direction/production, not even a bit close to the quality of the original old video. They just tried to squeeze in all possible new faces into this video, thereby just dragging the song, did not showcase the patriotic essence.

    And look at Dipika's dressing and expression in this video, and the voice given for Priyanka, yuck... Patriotic songs and these glamour dolls just don't go together. I'd never see this video the second time.

  • gay people made a gay vid..

  • what the hell.... where is the biggest icon of India. Sachin Tendulkar? And why have all the other national/international sportsperson being given a footage of half sec each? I didnt like this version so much...

  • Am sorry to say but this 16 min video is a disgrace to our nation, especially when there was so much hype surrounding the making of this video. What the hell are Karan Johan, Deepika Padukone, Shahid kapoor, Ranbir Kapoor and even Shilpa Shetty doing in this video? Man this is not a bollywood number...this song was like an anthem. I just hate the new version. Show the people who made India proud and not the people who enjoy today's India. Wht travel across the country and spoil a great song??

  • total crap..dis video shud b renamd as FIR MILE BOLLYWOOD.....n dat deepika part is jst...YUCK!!!

  • Video is not symbolizing anything about national integration. It would have been better with personality like lata ji , Vishwanathan anand, Sania mirza, Sachin, Mani ratnam instead of showing banian ad of Sallu , tight outfits of Deepika , Romantic mood of SRK, khadala rhythm for Ghajini boy

  • not at all gr8

  • wer ar e personalities as sachin tendulkar,kamal hassan,rajini,mohanlal,manirat­nam,and a whole lot of people????...video is ok...but doesnt convey the msg..old one is better....looks very commercialised...gr8n effort,but there always a nxt time better;-)

  • the video is ok...but it looks very commercialised and doesnt convey the msg like hw the old one was...and btw...where are the legends....like kamalhassan,sachin tendulkar ,mohanlal,maniratnam,and a whole lot of personalities....this is somethin missin...??good effort...but there is always nxt time;-)

  • Not even near the original versions. Except very few moments I did not get the sense of national integration.

    On a sarcastic note, the time prestigious Indian army and sporting achievers was shown is almost equal to or lesser than what Deepika and her trendy outfit was shown.

  • well.....its a good effort, but the older one was way, way better......... there was a better depiction of the message, of the idea of INDIA.

  • its boring .old is gold

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • this video is good but the message is misplaced in remaking it..sm of the clebreties din even make sense in the video...the older one is much better and the unity in diversity message is very clear in the older

  • gud but old version was better..

  • jai hind!

  • Where is Taj Mahal????

    People making this video have no idea of what India is and how unity in diversity should be shown......!!!!

  • yes Mr Sid i also agrre with tht......

    hw ever its......i dnt knw wat to say..

    we are INDIANS...

    its a great feeling...

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more