Added: 4 years ago
From: holodeckwaitinglist
Views: 240,605
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (683)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • My Choice is none other than "Mary Ann" (Dawn Wells)

  • Mary Ann is a very superior version of the "girl-next-door" type; good wife material.

    Ginger would make an excellent mistress.

  • It's always been MaryAnn

  • OBAMA II IS A USURPER

    FACT, NOT ALLEGATION

    READ BELOW:

  • Mary Ann, but only because she showed more skin (always in shorts and heels)......still a good choice BTW. Ginger was stuck in those long dresses.....never any skin....unless you like to look at backs and shoulders.

  • Fuck, youtube. I really wanted to see this one.

  • Mary Ann. She had a hot little body. Still does and she's 73. Mary Ann...Call me!

  • "Ginger was hot, but Mary Ann made me cream!" - Alan Hale, Jr.

  • Ginger

  • They'd both be swinging from my penis.

  • Mary Ann hands down! Uh, hands on!

  • i would lay MARY ANN ! she has a nice ass and legs !

  • Mary Ann is the one I could love the most and taking nothing away from Ginger.Mary Ann also is a pretty girl.So is Ginger,and she refused to do nude scenes and speak profanity when she discovered the vast changes that took place after being rescued,I could take Ginger over today's stars.I really love them both.Mary Ann and her innocence by a slight margin.

  • The professor could have had them both. He was actually a really handsome guy, and both MA and G wanted him BAD. But he was too busy trying to make telephones out of coconuts and junk like that.

  • What's REALLY lame is the era we live in, populated with people who would rather snivel and piss and moan than click "More about copyright" and learn how to get their post restored in less time than it took for me to type this comment. It's true. Click it and see!

  • Betty or Veronica?

  • It's a tough choice. I mean, sweet-natured Mary Ann is wholesome and clean-cut, and cultured Ginger, who has a body us dudes would kill for. Perhaps I'd prefer the former, seeing Ginger is hard to nail.

  • marry ann is the one and only. down home healthy country girl. i would pick her in a heart beat!

  • Apples and oranges, folks. They were both smoking hot.

  • Apples & oranges, folks. They were both smoking hot.

  • They are on a deserted island yet both always wear makeup how much do people take with them on a three hour tour? Maybe the Millionare was a drug dealer and the Professor his chemist and Marryann grew the stuff and Ginger was his hooker. His wife made contacts to sell the stuff.They were in a hurry and excaping the cops so they hired the quickest ride they could find because regular route cut off. Skipper and Gilligan to stupid to check weather report so that's why they were stuck in a storm.

  • I like Ginger but Mary Anne and Mrs Howe were nice too.

  • Dawn Wells was Miss Nevada 1960

  • With my luck Mary-Anne would be gay and Ginger would be a trans-sexual guy.

  • think about this alone on an island ...NO make up!!!... I rest my case!!

  • 6:03 we have bush outline!...lol!

  • mary anne all day!... and night!!!

  • I'll have some Maryann, please!

  • Short guys who want girls -maryann

    big guys ( like me and the skipper )who want women ! - ginger

  • @fidfel1062 I was thinking just that also but i saw ginger looking somewhat different in these photos, rethinking about it now

  • @fidfel1062 The Professor prefered Maryann so smart people perfered Maryann.

  • Both ! Repeatedly ! In every imaginable position !

  • Mary Ann > Ginger, Janet >Chrissy(she was an airhead on the show), Lonnie Anderson < Jan Smithers (Lonnie was Just hotter looking, but portrayed an airhead). Actress that played Wilma in live action version of Flinstones was hotter than Rosie O'Donnel who played Betty. Why was thin Betty portrayed by Rosie O'Donnel?

  • booo!!!!! but maryann !!!!

  • BOTH!...Question answered.

  • WHERES THU FREEKIN SOUND ? ? ?

  • @jlj025151 It was copywrited and removed because didn't have permision to use. Should have just spoke to talk and redid without music.

  • Dawn Wells was a very beautiful girl it would take a LOT to out do her, but Tina Louise was more than beautiful, she was glamorous! When she walked in to a scene, she OWNED it.

  • mary ann

    no contest

  • On the british sci fi comedy Red Dwarf, there is an episode where Cat and Lister (lost in deep space) are watching Flintstones and discussing who is hotter, Betty or Wilma. Cat says "I would do Betty, but I would be thinking of Wilma". Then he says "this is nuts, grown men lusting over Wilma Flintstone". To which Lister replied "yeah, this crazy.....she would never leave Fred"

  • TOUGH CHOICE,,,THIS QUESTION HAS BEEN ON MEN'S MINDS SINCE THE BEGINNING OF TIME ITSELF...TINA IS ALL THAT BUT SHE'S TOO PERFECT,SHE DOES'NT SEEM REAL....DAWN ISJUST AS HOT BUT IN A SMALLER CUTER MORE BELIEVABLE PACKAGE...I REMEMBER DROOLING WATCHING DAWN ON THIS SHOW...SERIOUSLY...

  • Always Mary ann, but I will swallow my pride and do a threesome with both whoo hoo !!!

  • Ginger, hands down!

    

  • Mary Ann. Ginger was beautiful but had a coldness about her. JMO

  • O polo ci bagumba, I guess it will have to be Mary Ann for me

  • Fucking legal assholes!

  • I think ginger had all the experience in dealing with men , and would be a better lover

    maryann would say what are you doing no !!! not there !

  • For me, it was about who looked more like a woman and who looked more like a girl, not the 'wholesome/slutty' angle that most people seem to assume. Obviously, Ginger was it from that perspective. OTOH, Dawn Wells would have been about equally appealing to me IF she had been dressed/made up like a grown woman instead of being made to look like a dewy-eyed teenager with the ponytails and all that crap. Dawn Wells was beautiful to the eye, but so was Tina Louise. 'Mary Ann' is just the PC answer.

  • oh well, it's still worth watching for the pics of the lovely Island Ladies. Ginger is undeniably gorgeous, but as a country boy myself, I have to go with Maryann...her fresh smile, those innocent eyes, her down to earth attitude, and it must be said her awesome body make her my (dream) #1 lady!

  • I vote for Mary Ann, and I think most guys would. My contribution here is called: russell johnson book signing. The iconic star is interviewed, and although I didn't tape the look alike contest, you'll be happy to know the winner was....Mary Ann (I interviewed her). The series holds up, sure wish it would have ran longer than 3 seasons, but, Matt Dillon is a tough guy to beat. Love the costumes Mary Ann wore, Ginger not so much.

  • MaryAnn would bend over backwards to please her guy...Ginger would withhold sex and would never be happy with everything you gave her. she was to material. MaryAnn was wholesome and HOT !

  • Mary Ann had the look guys like. Ginger had the look that women wanted guys to like. Deal with it, women. Mary Ann was good looking. Ginger was a plain every day girl who tried to look good, which is why women wanted us to like her.

  • Both :)

  • Man if I was on that island!! 40 kids and counting.

  • fuck off cry baby

  • What was the song that got cut? Was there an audio track that went with it? as for the question...idk. If I'm stuck on an island with these people? I think I'd be pretty happy.

  • what was the song that got cut?

  • Geez, can't we get a few votes for Mrs Howell?

  • @huskyjerk The original question was between Mary Anne and Ginger. Mrs. Howell (Natalie Schaefer) has since pasted on, also Jim Baccus (Mr. Howell and voice of Mr. McGoo), Alan Hale (Skipper) and Bob Denver(Gilligan) have died also.

  • She turned out to be a real crack head. Men don't admit it but they like women who play hard to get. Ginger may have looked easy but she wasn't. Tell you the truth both of them are not who they portray. And as is the other woman, Susan Summers was no dummy. They all try to portray Marilyn Monro. MaryAnn wore fake eyelashes with loads of mascara, lipstick. There was nothing natural about her. Even her tan was sprayed on. They both have there own beauty.

  • The Professor was a pimp daddy, and he didn't even know it.

  • Mary Anne, by a million miles. Coffee cream skin, sweet, honest, pig tails, incredible legs and hips, a woman you can trust and marry.

    Ginger, constantly trying to manipulate the three guys into something. She probably blew her way to the top in Hollywood.

  • MARY ANNE.

  • Just curious - I know Jan Smithers and James Brolin were once married, but is she Josh Brolin's mom? Again, just curious.

  • Always was always will be Mary Ann. There will always be a place in my heart for Dawn.

  • BOTH

  • I wanted to do things to Mary Ann that are still illegal in 17 states

  • MARY ANN ALL THE WAY

  • Who cares! If I would have been stuck on a desert island with 3 women, even Mrs. Howell would have been pregnant with my baby!

  • @kalimaganeshshivan LMAO!! Funny

  • @kalimaganeshshivan - *LMAO*

  • For me it was Mary Ann. She was the country , who was down to earth yet had a great body to look at.

  • IMHO, to sum it up, Ginger is a girl you take home to your apartment. Mary Anne, you take home to meet your mother!

  • Ginger!

  • Mary Ann !

  • MARY ANN with some Ginger on the side (I'm not stupid, ha,ha,ha.)

  • ginger, she's sort of an idol to me at 15 years old, p.s. wear did you find the pics?, they're really cool.

  • Mary Ann hands down

  • Sorry, but I gotta go w/ Tina Louise- fair skin, gorgeous red hair, darling smile. Sigh...

  • @RomneyGack Go to the internet and type in tina louise photo gallery. She was Miss November in the 1963 Playboy calender and that's the 5th picture on the third page.

  • MaryAnne was cute, but Ginger was hot. (But, I'd rather have Thelma from Good Times - she was BANGIN')

  • Mary Ann. Thus I have spoken and thus it shall be written. Amen.

  • If I had to choose to be alone on an island, and if it were between Ginger and Mary Ann, I would have to get with Mary Ann.

  • I'd have to say Mary Ann too. She was untouched. Who knows where Ginger has been? Of course, when answering the question "what if you were on stranded on a deserted island with her?" Well, 4 men were. And they barely touched either of them.

  • Maryanee- Long ternm girlfriend and wife

    Ginger- Short term girlfriend NOT a wife

    Ginger is a hot DIME, impress other people with, better in bed and sexier.

    BUT, she started to look like the crypt keeper as Maryane became a MILF/GILF.

    Maryanne- cooks, cleans and takes care of her man and family, she is more respectable and wont cheat on you . She is also hot around an 8 or so and sexy.

    BUT, not too many buts with maryane.

    In Short- Ginger for fucking, Maryane for Merriage.

  • mary anne hands down

  • when I asked my brother this, the eternal question, Ginger or Mary Anne, his answer:

    JEANNIE!

    man, he's smarter than I thought!

  • Sorry Tina, but there's alot of Mary Anne in Dawn, and alot of Ginger in you. Ginger had to be THE center of attention or be pissed off. Refusing to participate in the movie where the castaways got of the island was worse than Bill Wyman leaving the Stones. unforgivable. Mary Anne rules.

  • I'd bang Ginger, make MaryAnn my girlfriend and Marry Mrs. Howell so I wouldn't have to work anymore.

  • @4ureyesonlee HAHAHAH

  • if i was marooned on gilligans island, not only mary ann and ginger but, i'd be bangin mrs howe also!!

  • Tina Louise is a bitch and she looks like the Crypt Keeper.

    She was the asshole of Gilligan's Island.

  • Mary Anne ALL THE WAY!!!! Ginger would be too high maintenance!!!!!

  • I'd take a one night stand with Ginger but she's too high maintenance for anything longer. I'd marry Mary-Ann in a minute. Bailey vs Jennifer? Definitely Bailey even though she tended to hide her light under a bushel. As for Janet & Chrissy, definitely Janet - I like my women to have brains. Besides if you look at some of those first season outfits Janet wore, she was definitely looking for action.

  • OK, here we go: Joyce DeWitt vs Suzanne Somers? Suzanne had the sexier body, but Joyce was prettier (though Joyce had a real nice ass). Jan Smithers by a mile over Loni Anderson. Loni had big fake boobs; Jan was stunning and every inch a real woman. Ginger or Mary Ann? To quote pro wrestler Tommy Dreamer, "I'll take 'em both, I'm hard core!"

  • Fake

  • Both! Heh heh, I'm a greedy bastard.

  • WTF?! Why can't I see this vid? My fucking life is RUINED!

  • @Donkwoon you can still see it, you just can't hear it. Jump ahead a little. 

  • mary ann is sooo wonderful and still is a dream girl. she will always be one of the best

    .

  • MARY ANN PLEASE. I think most of the time, guys are going to go for the big brown-eyed brunette. Perhaps it's the contrasty dark hair and eyes against their white skin and or the plump cheeks. Perhaps it's just the cuttie-pie look and sweet smile. Although every brunette loving guy has a blonde bombshell, mine would be Loni Anderson. My favorite brunette, Linda Ronstadt in her prime was HOT, like naughty & nice. Also Ann Wilson from Heart in her prime & Sally field, from Smokey and the Bandit.

  • @Seaclam67 Oh hell yeah! Ann Wilson before she got heavy was AMAZING looking. And what a voice! Linda Ronstadt suffered the same fate as Ann did - got fat as she got older. Supposedly in 1978 Playboy offered Ronstadt $1,000,000 to do a nude spread but she turned them down because she didn't want to hurt her then-boyfriend Jerry Brown's chances of running for the Senate, and also because she didn't feel comfortable about posing nude.

  • Mary Ann gets my vote hands down.

  • Comment removed

  • I think Mary Ann was the best looking what a Hottie!

  • Mary ann- it's not even close!

  • Mrs. Howell is waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa­aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay better than both of those whores!

  • Mary Ann

  • Mary Ann did wear booty shorts and probably never had sex and could be great. But Ginger you can tell she knows how to bone.

  • OLD NEWS.I could have went to church and commence a nuclear megafart decimating the whole congregation.............would have been more entertaining also than watching this.

  • Everybody knows that the one with the biggest rack wins.

  • As far as this video shows, there is no clear choice as both girls are very pretty in their own way... So what it boils down to is the personality... I sort of favor the Ginger types as I like a woman that is an exotic seductress and likes to be extremely womanlike, not so tomboyish.. I do like them taller than average as well.. And that fits more the Ginger experience. But that's just my preference as I think most girls in the world are the Mary Anns but only so many are Ginger...

  • Ginger by far. Tall, redhead pale skin, all uncommon but beautiful traits.

  • Ginger by far. Tall, redhead pale skin, all uncommon but beautiful traits.

  • If you on an island with little food it would be better to be marooned with Maryann as she grew up on a farm and new more about identifying and growing food. What good is knowing how to act in movies going to do on a deserted island? Janet or Chrissy? Janet was way smarter. I think the brunette on wkrp was made out to be smarter also why are blondes and redheads portrayed as being stupid. OKay maybe wilma wasn't the guys were the dumb ones on the Flinstones.

  • When I was in my 20's and 30's I was definately a Mary Ann fan, At 50, I now appreciate the statuesque beauty of Ginger. Mary Anne could be Tinkerbell, while Ginger is more like a real woman.

  • To be honest, I always thought Mrs. Howell was better looking than both of them. If I age half as gracefully as her I'll be a lucky lucky lady.

  • Oh ya, its Mary Ann baby

  • mary ann all the way!!!

  • Comment removed

  • Don't know how I made it thru 10 min. w/o audio, but science is a harsh mistress. The evidence is absolutely irrefutable. Although Ginger is pretty hot at 5:51, MARY ANN is the essence of feminine perfection!!! Thank you!

  • just make a nailer sandwich!

  • Ginger was more or less a high maintenance, egotistical department store mannequin. Mary Ann was a real woman. IMHO.

    U.W.

  • Fuck those bitches. I always wanted to put the stones to the professor, myself.

  • You take Ginger on a night on the town.

    You take Mary Ann home to meet Mom.

  • Mary Ann.

  • Mary Ann. Ginger was beautiful but Mary Ann...oh my God. Not only beautiful but someone a guy would love to live with the rest of his life.

  • Well, I 've always been an "ass man"! (People are always saying to me "You know.. You're an ass man!" So I must be?) Tina Louise got scary looking fast! (of course she is 3 years older). However, Dawn Wells got even hotter and turn into a MILF and even a GILF! I met her in the 80's and got her autograph. Super nice and super hot! By the way, I bought the coffee table among other things when "Mary Ann" sold her beach house in Treasure Island a few years back!

  • I wish I could have heard an audio track like Mitch Miller's "Ain't She Sweet", but it was very good. Holodeck, it must have taken you forever to do this. You really put in a lot of time and effort. Kudos to you. I'm still waiting for my Mary Ann to marry one day.

  • oh god yes.....mary Anne for sure......I don't like that slut tramp ginger

  • who cares, i'd eat both their ass's out

  • Tall Amazon Blondes OUT! Short Cute Brunets with sexy legs IN!!!!

  • Both are beautiful, but I would take Ginger no contest

  • Comment removed

  • Mary Ann would be my main squeeze, Mrs. Howell would be my backup (I'd make HER howl, all right), and in distant third would be Ginger.

  • Mary Ann. no doubt about it. i always had a thing in the early 70's for her and Barbara Feldon, agent 99 on Get Smart. btw i heard Dawn is like half Hispanic or half American Indian. is this true?

  • Mary Ann

  • There's no question...Mary-Ann.

  • Joyce dewitt was no maryann. I never had a single sperm want to go in Janet on 3's company direction. Suzanne Sommers, well thats a different story. Maryanne/dawn wells seems like the only one of all these women you could actually stand to have around. The others are all CA crazy bitches, and I mean that literally. TIna Louise just can't deal with the fact she got old. Is she dead yet?

  • Mary Ann. She gets STONED!!!

  • I think if they dressed Ginger like Mary Ann (Daisy Dukes and belly shirts) on Gilligans, it would be easier to judge.

    They always had too many clothes on Tina. Dawn on the other hand got to show her tight body and therefore was the subject of many a pubescent fantasy. Its still a very close call. But you know what red on the head means...

  • maryann for sure

  • Ginger on the weekends, Mary Ann Monday thru Friday. The Skipper on leather and rubber Tuesdays.

  • TankBanana FTW!

  • Mary Anne all the way. I'm fortunate enough to Marry a Girl that closely resembles her. She has the same caring attitude. Unfortunately, she can't cook. LOL

  • try daily motion and post it there

  • I would go will Maryanne, she was hot , her frame was perfect for hitting, she was thick in the thighs had a nice round ass, short that is the way should be. She had the girl next door look, that is why I prefer Mary ann, any time she also had that latina look you know. Giner was to damn wack period , to stuck up, mary anne looked like she was down for all nasty shit. any way mary ann wins this one, I wish I was stuck with her I would stick that daily!!!!!!!!!

  • She didn't have a latina look. She just had dark hair.

  • it would have to be Mary Ann for me it"s aiways been Mary Ann

  • I've never seen the TV Show, but I'd have to go with Mary Ann (Dawn Wells) - btw, nice job on the video!

  • OK, crazy time....

    The Q. Who would you rather be stranded w/?

    A. BOTH. Come on, your on the island w/ a old married couple, an A sexual Prof., a Fat guy (don't speak ill of the dead, sorry Mr. Hale) and a nervous clutz. Your going to be tapping both (or THEY are going to be tapping you, i mean me). Hell after a while "Lovey" will want some. ...that was fun.

    Thanks for the post. Good work

  • Mary Ann wore "Daisy Dukes" before Daisy Duke did

  • I'll translate. He has a boner for little buddy:-)

  • Let me add this. Tina Louise was far, far, and far away more talented than Dawn Wells. Tina Louise was a truly wonderful singer and a major league actress. Tina has stated that Gilligan's Island was a mistake for her career. I won't choose between them but only say that getting stuck on a Desert Island with a young Tina Louise and Dawn Wells would be a major step closer to Heaven.

  • I would have to toss the coin between them both.

  • Hands down, Mary Ann (Dawn Wells). I had a huge crush on her in my teens. She was waaaay hotter than Tina Louise.

  • What! no Elly Mae Clampet ! this poll is rigged

  • Maryann the wife, Ginger the mistress, thats the way it's been for over 30 years with me and my friends.

  • Ginger would have been the perfect one-night stand type, but Mary Ann was the happily-ever after pick, you know what I mean?? Definitely Mary Ann!!

  • yes we all would pick mary ann, but would definately cheat on her with ginger

  • Mary Ann!

  • i'll never chose,how can I?  bob denver got all the breaks!

  • Mary Ann

  • Mary Ann of course!!

  • Both at once. But if I have to choose: Ginger if it was just a fling. Mary Ann if I got to live with the bitch.

  • Mary Ann.

    No hesitation.

  • not even close, i would not mind being shipwrecked with Mary Ann any time, she has that ah shucks, holesome, country girl look, and is sooooooooo hot. what a bod also, Dawn Wells was great then, and even today she looks great

  • I agree. Dawn's 70, but you could never tell by looking at her.

    Dawn and Raquel Welch, in her upper 60's, look great for their age. They're ageless.

  • mary ann

  • Mary Ann

  • I'd pick Mary Ann. She has an adorable, flawless, and fresh face. Ginger looks older in comparison and has a more boring face. I'm a face person. :p Not that that is relevant in this case, both of them have fine figures and likable personalities.

  • The copyright lobby can eat shit and die.

  • MARY ANN !!!!!!!!

  • Mary Ann, no doubt

  • Fuck, is the compete video anywhere?