La dame de Monsoreau 2008 fleur-de-lis forumei ru

[RustineEduc]

Ouh, la musique et les bruits lourds.

[RustineEduc]

Mais...mais, elle n'est même pas blonde !

[nevanovna]

The French got rid of the Protestants, then they had the Revolution, and killed all the Nobles,what then is left.

[bardond]

@nevanovna Of all those that died under the guillotine during the Terror period, only 5% were Nobles. The other 95% were mainly war profiteers. During the Terror, France was defending itself against a coalition of all the main European Kingdoms with an armies that had lost all its officers (mainly nobles) to emigration (and ended up winning)..

[bardond]

@nevanovna The religious wars or the 16th century were not a French phenomenon, it was European. Protestants were usually members of the educated gentry (you had to be able to read) and their dependents (tenant farmers, clients, servants) followed them. Protestants and Catholics engaged in a deathly struggle for political power. Results were different across Europe, but always bloody.

[Martyrdurock]

Mais le pire, ce sont les costumes, totalement anachroniques : aux collants masculins de la prestigieuse version de 1971, se substituent des sortes de pyjamas ou de vareuses flottantes - dont le seul but semble être de dissimuler les jambes de ces messieurs (là où l'actrice principale, travestie en homme, exhibe au contraire de grosses cuisses bien moulées) ! Michel Hassan a réussi là le film le plus creux et le plus ringard de toute l'histoire de la télé !!!

[Martyrdurock]

Ce film est un sommet de grotesque ! Réalisation approximative, que tentent vainement de dynamiser les acrobaties de la caméra ; absence totale de direction des acteurs et des figurants, livrés à eux-mêmes et qui semblent sortis de "Plus belle la vie", bien davantage que du roman de Dumas... La palme de l'insignifiance revient à l'interprète de la dame de Monsoreau ; celle de la vulgarité, au duc d'Alençon.

[befreebeyourself]

Je n'aime pas cette adaptation qui ne respecte pas le roman de Dumas. Ce n'est pas la meme histoire d'amour.