This is a joke compared to the original. Howard's voice makes Doc Dart (of the Crucifucks) sound like a song bird. It is weird, but the so is the original, as-well as being creepy and beautiful all at once. Only Lydia"s voice saves this from total failure . I don't think i'll be listening to this version again. Just my opinion.
@PorkyPants mate i actually think nick cave is a serious southern gothic artist and rowland s howard an unsung genius, but thank you for expressing your opinion. may people refrain from flaming you
Thank ye gods that this is still here. Lydia and Rowland. I do have the vinyl but not many people still know of this duo. Bit like Lydia and Jim Thirlwell. Mind you they were a bit rude to me in London when I asked for a chat.
Dave here. I need no instructon on musical taste. Where I've been in a position to select the music in a public arena, I've almost always been complimented on my good taste. He still sounds drunk to me and she sounds slightly off key. I know the mythological origin of the lyrics. Nancey Sinatra and Lee Hazelwood did a great job with this song, as they did with other songs, such as "Ladybird." I'm with baddogg62 on this one.
@Myrtle791 It was recorded and perfromed in atonality. That is a motif of Lydia Lunch, everything and anything she does is atonal. Her and RS Howard completely deconstructed the tonal melody of the original. RS Howard set a precedent for the Zero Wave of music, No Future.
@Myrtle791 No Myrtle - no accounting for your bad taste. Now you have heard of artistic interpretation haven't you...!? Do I need to explain the whole song and the (Greek) myth on which it's based?
really like her voice in this remake. the guy's voice doesn't capture any of the essence of hazelwood, though. it's hard to do. one of the better covers of the song, though.
Some songs are sacrosanct, and this is one of them, the Nancy and Lee original is just so perfect that everyone else should leave it alone and bathe in it's sonic wonder.
This absolutely sucks!!!! Neither of these fools can sing a note! The guy sounds like a half-brained idiot with a sponge in his mouth and she sounds like a reclusive mental ward psycho!
@Titan752 lol most the ppl who commented love it....i think its so good...they made a great sound and atmosphere......i didn't know who these artists were the first time i herd it.
@angryone Sure, but they're [The Beatless] such a safe, conventional choice; That's why I used them in the above context... I guess it would've been MUCH better to say "Lady Gaga," or something current/conventional/crappy like that!
Amazing, I didn't hear the original. Just Slowdive's version and Lydia's. And I think I will prefer this since the Cocteaux are the only proofs to produce Dream sounds.
What can I say but so many have borrowed from this multidimensional artist. You can view Right Side of My Brain with my cuz Henry Rollins. WARNING: Right Side of My Brain video clip is not for those who see in absolutes.
he was a great part of my formative years. The one with the real sensitive soul in the birthday party and all the stuff with lydia on the honeymoon in red album later but of course all these 12" singles. So talented.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Ive heard alot of music in 33 years. Very open minded and eccentric and absoulutely swim in music. I must say however this sounds like shit. Sounds like when I used to drink a lot and sing to myself late at night. Yea, this sounds like crap.
So much better than any of the other covers- actually covers the sinister atmosphere and lyrics of the song and works with them really well- love Lydia and Rowland also!
Fantastic Awesome, historic version of this song!! - not just Lydia, that's Rowland S. Howard singing, arranging, & playing guitar - if ya' like this, check his stuff out - the band 'These Immortal Souls', 'Birthday Party'(Nick Cave origins!), and 'early' 'Crime and the City Solution'
This is an awesome cover! - that's Rowland S. Howard singing (not nick)& playing guitar w/lydia. Re: shifts in tone in their duet, check out the original duet vrsn. by Nancy Sinatra & Lee Hazelwood!
I like both versions,the original was so ahead of it's time and lydia and roland's cover was perfect for the times.I had a band called "headband' in albuquerque, and it was funny that we covered it at the same time that lydia and roland did. i still play all 3 versions.
Many in the music area played that game, in `95 around Kurts disappearing and Polly was singing and Nick was mad like a hornet I tryed the game and called myself the new Syd Barrett and of course I was back in Shit Factory. Before the game I was spiritually strong as a poet, now thirteen years later I am almost back where i was before the game in `95.
This is a joke compared to the original. Howard's voice makes Doc Dart (of the Crucifucks) sound like a song bird. It is weird, but the so is the original, as-well as being creepy and beautiful all at once. Only Lydia"s voice saves this from total failure . I don't think i'll be listening to this version again. Just my opinion.
wcarloswilliams 2 weeks ago
Best cover,almost outweirds the original!
Oldbmwr100rs 1 month ago
Phaedra is my name
TheMimifur 3 months ago
I think Boy George and Celine Dion's cover is the best version of this song.
hwAbdiel 3 months ago
@hwAbdiel :P
LadyBright777 3 months ago
@hwAbdiel ahhh no! this is definitely the best :)
unknownpleasures4 2 months ago
But I still have the vinyl.
TheMimifur 3 months ago
Comment removed
djbat3 4 months ago
@djbat3 He died in 2009!
TheSharpeThorn 4 months ago
Comment removed
djbat3 4 months ago
I love this song tooo much.......
Best cover from Lydia and Rowland
Thanks for posting.......
mrsjanina68 5 months ago
Kind of a Punk'd out version of the original?
holzg01 6 months ago
sexy beast of a song. thanks.
antjuanoden 6 months ago
Lydia has pics of her with a .357 to my head. I'd love copies. . . .
rexeverything2323 6 months ago
Like it. Excellent remake. It's a little like...no...kind of sounds like the...oh! what? It's over! Must listen again and see if I'm right.
davidickify 6 months ago
what is the name of this cd?
MrP953 7 months ago
@MrP953 Honeymoon in Red.
lycia69 5 months ago
Terrible. She is IN those stockings though.
TheWizardOfSmog 7 months ago
A singer is a genius? If he were he'd have cured cancer and would have avoided this terrible wall of puke.
PorkyPants 7 months ago
@PorkyPants seek xpert help you bloodclaat half wit!
pzgdr 7 months ago
@pzgdr he's fat, fat people are bitter. i'd pity him but i'm too busy grooving to this brilliantly crazy song.
worldbones 7 months ago
@PorkyPants mate i actually think nick cave is a serious southern gothic artist and rowland s howard an unsung genius, but thank you for expressing your opinion. may people refrain from flaming you
geoffhead111 6 months ago
One of my fave duets ever!
Nesihonsu 8 months ago
Thank ye gods that this is still here. Lydia and Rowland. I do have the vinyl but not many people still know of this duo. Bit like Lydia and Jim Thirlwell. Mind you they were a bit rude to me in London when I asked for a chat.
TheMimifur 8 months ago
@TheMimifur i live this version. She was really nice to me when I met her in North Hampton Mass.
MegaP1972 7 months ago
@TheMimifur die welt mourns with you......what did you expect?....hugs & kisses?...bumbahole!
pzgdr 7 months ago
Lee Hazlewood + Nancy Sinatra DESTROYS this terrible version.
daddystabz 8 months ago
Dave here. I need no instructon on musical taste. Where I've been in a position to select the music in a public arena, I've almost always been complimented on my good taste. He still sounds drunk to me and she sounds slightly off key. I know the mythological origin of the lyrics. Nancey Sinatra and Lee Hazelwood did a great job with this song, as they did with other songs, such as "Ladybird." I'm with baddogg62 on this one.
Myrtle791 9 months ago
@Myrtle791 It was recorded and perfromed in atonality. That is a motif of Lydia Lunch, everything and anything she does is atonal. Her and RS Howard completely deconstructed the tonal melody of the original. RS Howard set a precedent for the Zero Wave of music, No Future.
Johnnystrychnine 9 months ago 2
Seeing this and hearing this makes me cry. A lot.
TheMimifur 9 months ago 2
This is the greatest!!
AidanJeans 9 months ago
Oooo horrible singing ! Thought it was a joke !?
baddogg62 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hey check out my channel for amazing music videos...
HongwareeChannel 9 months ago
Saw them perform @ The Greyhound Hotel St Kilda when Neil Wedd was booking the bands. It was packed, great show!!!!
poodiful 9 months ago
The morally pure married to the ethically sure leaves but a philosophical hard core to ponder.
Lieu3C4 10 months ago 4
da miedo la musica jajajaja
ponyupkiss 10 months ago
meh
HalcyonDazeBand 11 months ago
god this is so perfect
vickieickyicky 11 months ago
He sounds like he's drunk. No accounting for tastes.
Myrtle791 11 months ago
@Myrtle791 what are you saying?
sihooyin1 10 months ago
@Myrtle791 No Myrtle - no accounting for your bad taste. Now you have heard of artistic interpretation haven't you...!? Do I need to explain the whole song and the (Greek) myth on which it's based?
diamondjimlegend 9 months ago
She looks better upside down.
pessia61 11 months ago
Rowland Howard sounds like ptrick star from sponge bob, just saying
milkspam23 1 year ago 8
@milkspam23 hahahahahahahahhahaha.-
heretheflowersunfold 2 months ago
30 justin bieber fans missed the like button
planetraptor420 1 year ago
@planetraptor420 I think this just as annoying as that.
Mrdavid839 10 months ago
the b side of the original 12" i fell in love with a ghost is stunning, still got it :-) brilliant, R.I.P. Rs Howard
keeef67 1 year ago
God this is shit
xz4q18 1 year ago
Nearly one year on since Rowland left and the world is a lesser place!
AuntPearlsGlorybox 1 year ago
Comment removed
AuntPearlsGlorybox 1 year ago
Comment removed
jackkoffin1 1 year ago
What's with the photo of some girl learning how not to fall off the couch?
Lieu3C4 1 year ago
been looking for this song for ages Fantastic love it from the first time I heard it 20 odd yrs ago
savvyshiela 1 year ago
omg, this is so sad...r u kidding me....sucks big time...
canrsiegrl 1 year ago
@canrsiegrl I agree. It's an abomination.
FairAtBest 1 year ago 2
@FairAtBest Your an abomination
KatDOgzz 1 year ago
@FairAtBest Your an abomination
KatDOgzz 1 year ago
@KatDOgzz True!
FairAtBest 1 year ago
@KatDOgzz You're not your
zevon1964 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@FairAtBest Your an abomination!
KatDOgzz 1 year ago
@canrsiegrl you are so sad
sihooyin1 10 months ago
Love it
katinasvenska 1 year ago
I love this song!! I'm pretty much addicted to it! :)
MermaidAntihero1988 1 year ago
really like her voice in this remake. the guy's voice doesn't capture any of the essence of hazelwood, though. it's hard to do. one of the better covers of the song, though.
icallmybabystp 1 year ago
Love it! RIP Rowland
MrMino66 1 year ago
love it! RIP Rowland
MrMino66 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this cover is a deep, deep atmospheric pile of crap.
jere119 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
jeez this sucks! they take a classic song and destroy it
poptopia1 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Crap.
russianfantastico 1 year ago
nice-mad-beautiful xxx
murkishbub 1 year ago
yeah, some velvet morning when i´m straight
trancentralovertone 1 year ago
This is just appalling !!!!
Some songs are sacrosanct, and this is one of them, the Nancy and Lee original is just so perfect that everyone else should leave it alone and bathe in it's sonic wonder.
vmax4steve 1 year ago
best version!
thanks
Plasmobe 1 year ago
lydia and rowland rock together.
karenchristine9 1 year ago 3
Didn't like it much at all. Seems like they tried to do a 'different' version and got it
wazlo 1 year ago
Didn't like ur m
wazlo 1 year ago
Trrrrippy.
simonebelle 1 year ago
so fucking cool!
ShivaChaosRitsuka 1 year ago
not great
Dirlandarlan 1 year ago
This absolutely sucks!!!! Neither of these fools can sing a note! The guy sounds like a half-brained idiot with a sponge in his mouth and she sounds like a reclusive mental ward psycho!
Titan752 1 year ago
@Titan752 lol most the ppl who commented love it....i think its so good...they made a great sound and atmosphere......i didn't know who these artists were the first time i herd it.
mrpattrike 1 year ago
@Titan752 - What do YOU like, the fucking Beatles or something?!!
LeshaAnn 1 year ago
@LeshaAnn You can like both. I love the beatles and this too.
angryone 1 year ago
@angryone Sure, but they're [The Beatless] such a safe, conventional choice; That's why I used them in the above context... I guess it would've been MUCH better to say "Lady Gaga," or something current/conventional/crappy like that!
LeshaAnn 1 year ago
This is excellent.
esquibelle 1 year ago
Man, this sucks!
MrErdner 1 year ago
Amazing, I didn't hear the original. Just Slowdive's version and Lydia's. And I think I will prefer this since the Cocteaux are the only proofs to produce Dream sounds.
lazord1991 1 year ago
Why am i touching myself like this?
JizumChrust 1 year ago
Well done..!
tomk773 1 year ago
What can I say but so many have borrowed from this multidimensional artist. You can view Right Side of My Brain with my cuz Henry Rollins. WARNING: Right Side of My Brain video clip is not for those who see in absolutes.
PragRad 1 year ago
@PragRad: Yet this was borrowed from Lee Hazlewood and Nancy Sinatra
NickB1967 1 year ago
she sing with nick cave?
i love her voice
TheMocofeo 1 year ago 2
the guy singing is Rowland S. Howard. An absolute genius!
bazza44ify 1 year ago 28
@bazza44ify the singer is nick cave
psaychadiliyus 6 months ago
@psaychadiliyus No, the singer is Rowland S Howard.
lycia69 5 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I don't really care for the guy singing. The rest is ok.
PsychLion 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
What a bloody awful version!
moisiemo 1 year ago
what do you mean? she's still alive, wacko
stephenpaultaylor 1 year ago
*buuuuurrp*
fluffhead347 1 year ago
Comment removed
ShootToLuna 2 years ago
Comment removed
ShootToLuna 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
god this is awful. No wonder Joe Rogan destroyed her.
gorkysire 2 years ago
You will be sadly missed Rowland
AuntPearlsGlorybox 2 years ago 29
@AuntPearlsGlorybox
he was a great part of my formative years. The one with the real sensitive soul in the birthday party and all the stuff with lydia on the honeymoon in red album later but of course all these 12" singles. So talented.
twact 1 year ago
Lyia wow I havent seen her in years...
KashmiriRose 2 years ago
RIP, dark romeo...
granderuga 2 years ago 2
rip
aletons 2 years ago 3
Rest In Peace Rowland S. Howard.
eric1012wi 2 years ago 6
RIP, Rowland.
Velocilex 2 years ago 8
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Ive heard alot of music in 33 years. Very open minded and eccentric and absoulutely swim in music. I must say however this sounds like shit. Sounds like when I used to drink a lot and sing to myself late at night. Yea, this sounds like crap.
waninghope 2 years ago
@waninghope Stick to "Final Fantasy" and Olivia Newton John
u5chi1 2 years ago 3
Good -but I still like the original Nancy Sinatra/Lee Hazlewood version better..
tomk773 2 years ago 4
Nothing is trippier than a Nancy/Hazlewood collaboration.
asy4 2 years ago 4
i like both versions
genericusername337 1 year ago 7
This track is actually credited to:
Lydia Lunch & Rowland S. Howard (Ex-Birthday Party)
nightwatch01 2 years ago
They try way too hard sounding ''weird'' for the sake of it. Somehow they even failed at that since the original sounds much weirder.
SwedxSimon02 2 years ago
True dat.
Knorg 2 years ago
que freak!!
JoseBerry 2 years ago 2
Good!
MartaBtrp 2 years ago
最高
joinus777 2 years ago
Mmmm... i wanna ravish her.
Natokowsky 2 years ago
EXELENT
lordtarace123 2 years ago 2
Been looking for this for 3 years!
marksiwel 2 years ago
why did it take 3 years? thats insane
lloplop 2 years ago
amazing... listened for decades to sonic youth, but never had a real chance to listen to Lydia.. What a mistake..
leonardofra80 2 years ago 2
Lydia hot
Korusaki15hime 2 years ago
thin white rope did a pretty rad distortion and reverb drenched version in the 80's
ricv64 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
which is a hell of a lot better than this.
mikebott 2 years ago
I love Lydia's voice!
genericusername337 2 years ago 7
Ma version préférée.
paxandroses 2 years ago 3
This version certainly takes this epic song to new heights....or is that depths(!)
Thnx for posting, absolutely STELLAR
LIFEONPLANETBECK 2 years ago 5
pure art
shreivox 2 years ago 6
So much better than any of the other covers- actually covers the sinister atmosphere and lyrics of the song and works with them really well- love Lydia and Rowland also!
chaileywatts 2 years ago 17
i agree, and Lydia's voice is perfect for the whole Phaedra concept. i think this is my fave track on the album
denisaxw 2 years ago 10
@denisaxw For the last 27 years this has remained firmly as one of my favourite songs. the stuff of wonderment
pmss68 1 year ago
@chaileywatts You don't know this cover: watch?v=-lGau9uJiPE
isthattrue 1 year ago
@chaileywatts comparing to Herb Diamante cover, this one is not very good, really
GoodChineezeCheeze 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Bad (not good)........
Sounds like bored teenagers singing during school lunchbreak.
hilhorst234 2 years ago
sounds like disturbed teenagers popping pills in the school parking lot, it's amazing
denisaxw 2 years ago 33
gosh u ve a big imagination :P
polienfermo 2 years ago
heheheee :P
nikolaspearce 2 years ago
oh. why am i aroused now?
julietavalon 2 years ago
Fantastic Awesome, historic version of this song!! - not just Lydia, that's Rowland S. Howard singing, arranging, & playing guitar - if ya' like this, check his stuff out - the band 'These Immortal Souls', 'Birthday Party'(Nick Cave origins!), and 'early' 'Crime and the City Solution'
sirdoug3 2 years ago 10
a great version....
tsetao 2 years ago 3
Time to go the original.
irrationalluv08 2 years ago
a great song differebt its needed now
pikachops 2 years ago
Lydia Lunch rapes all of music a new asshole
07102592 2 years ago 4
WOW
I love this version
AbbeyDoor 2 years ago
nick cave is very cool
SvetlanaDhampir 3 years ago
And thanks denisaxw for posting !
christophe76382 3 years ago
This is an awesome cover! - that's Rowland S. Howard singing (not nick)& playing guitar w/lydia. Re: shifts in tone in their duet, check out the original duet vrsn. by Nancy Sinatra & Lee Hazelwood!
sirdoug3 3 years ago 10
yes it's very good sirdoug3, thanks for your sending
christophe76382 3 years ago
This song is sexy as hell, but it gets kind of disjointed at around 2:30, the cut out to each others part of the duet seems forced.
Besides that I love it. And no, thst is not Nick Cave. Now if I could only find Scarbourough Fair cover they did. That one is amazing also.
Steeplerot 3 years ago
wow this song is way awesome. lydia is gorgeous inside and out. really. nick is just cool. thats without saying.
replikant0101 3 years ago
I like both versions,the original was so ahead of it's time and lydia and roland's cover was perfect for the times.I had a band called "headband' in albuquerque, and it was funny that we covered it at the same time that lydia and roland did. i still play all 3 versions.
neoboy1957 3 years ago 4
Many in the music area played that game, in `95 around Kurts disappearing and Polly was singing and Nick was mad like a hornet I tryed the game and called myself the new Syd Barrett and of course I was back in Shit Factory. Before the game I was spiritually strong as a poet, now thirteen years later I am almost back where i was before the game in `95.
BengtIsaksen 3 years ago
Thanks!
So you know Rowland. I like the music they make,and i listen to Lydia some times because she have these feelings
BengtIsaksen 3 years ago
A scary song but better and more natural and scary than the version of Nancy Sinatra and Lee Hazlewood. Lydia and Roland is better.
BengtIsaksen 3 years ago
Só falta dizer que o senhor é o Nick Cave!!
EXCELENTE
PauloJCGFranco 3 years ago
no es Nick Cave, es Rowland S Howard
denisaxw 3 years ago
she makes me claustrophobic
kuj4z 3 years ago 3
Thanks for posting this version, I'm in LOVE with this song. *_*
sbeck1887 3 years ago 3
Classic, best version ever.
flawedplan 3 years ago 5
DEFINITELY, her voice is hipnotic ♥
denisaxw 3 years ago