Great song, very interesting lyrics. Wow, Black is a genius.
Basically, he's shooting down the idea that reading some words can provide true comfort. This is very similar to his mocking in "Mr Grieves". The point is that if you've tasted the flesh and body fluids of another, mere words pale in comparison.
Prisons connote different things. Is he in a physical prison? Brilliant song. Awesome.
Jesus, the Pixies even sound like what was eventually the White Stripes, it's uncanny...is there any major alt rock group that doesn't owe some gratitude to the Pixies??
No one should ever cover Pixies songs. Not saying that in a dick way, it's just no one can ever come close to touching their versions. They are too unique. One of the greatest bands of all time.
@guanjon yes, you're right, nobody can touch her versions, but when they take a pixies song and change it? Do you know the Mr.Grieves Cover by TV on the radio. I think it's really good...
@vanboaconstrictor No, I'll check it out, thanks. And I agree with you that covers are better when they are changed up/reworked. But listen to Bowie's version of this, it's exactly the same (in terms of following the original musically). I've heard some good covers of Hey also.
Man I love both versions of this song. They both offer a completely different experience. This one is much more desperate with the vocals and really just draws an image of complete desolation, while Bowies is more of a romping flowing rock song.
I'd subscribe, but You Tube said, 'You have too many subscriptions compared to the number of subscribers'. Like, what? I don't KEEP UP with them? YT should get their facts straight!!!
I heard the Bowie cover first but didn't twig at all that it wasn't original, and was pleasantly surprised that the Pixies released it first. The two are crafted from the same clay maybe.
But what about Manta Ray, Crackity Jones, Motorway to Roswell, Ana, Into the White, Tame, Caribou, All over the world, Hey, Wave of Mutilation, Where is my mind, I Bleed, Isla de Encanta, Vamos, Space (I believe in), hell any song! I couldn't make a top 5 if I wanted to. It's all too brilliant!
I find it very hard to name my favourite Pixies album. They are all very different and choosing one is almost impossible. It's like saying you love one of your kids (who happens to be a superhero named Tony) more than the others. You may like one a bit more than the other, but you could never say it out loud because you don't want to hurt their feelings. And naming my favourite Pixies album would hurt the other albums' feelings. And than they would have to kill me in my sleep.
The Pixies were many things but never were they grunge. But I will admit a lot of the grunge bands stole from them. But why wouldn't they? Pixies are artistic gold.
No. Pixies started in Boston. Grunge was mostly a Seattle/West Coast thing: Mother Lovebone, Alice In Chains, Mudhoney, Nirvana, Pearl Jam, et al. Different vibe, attitude & look. Pixies were more artful than grunge IMO & were closer to punk but weren't quite that either. They weren't anything you could categorize easily & were alternative before the term was coined - they called it "Progressive Rock" back then. I love my Nirvana & I love that they admired Pixies but Pixies were not grunge.
good job clearing that up - the whole Subpop thing was cool but nobody was in the same league as the Pixies except maybe Nirvana and well, we know how that turned out
one: pixies were not grunge. Sachapp464 just clear that up 4 u. great.
two: why will you be surprised that Bowie knows grunge, or Pixies for that matter? ge is an incredible curious artist always on the look for new sounds. reciently performed with artist such as Arcade Fire just to name one.
Three: Reality is not an almost totally unknown album!!!
"Cactus" is a song by the American alternative rock band Pixies, and is the eighth track on their 1988 album Surfer Rosa. It was written and sung by the band's frontman Black Francis ... So next time, think before you speak!
yay! Cactus! this was the song that made me fall in love with the pixies. If you dont mind another suggestion...upload hangwire..theres only a live version and a cover :)
The lyrics remind me of a Robert Browning poem.
PrivateAckbar 2 weeks ago in playlist music 6
beautiful 2:17
SRQguy1 4 weeks ago
feat Grandma from Squidbillies
wizardneedsbeer 2 months ago
Dat bass. Amirite?
Jackimole 2 months ago 2
I fucking love this song so much. Probably my favorite by them.
curry136 3 months ago
I wish this song was longer!
cotupina187 4 months ago
All the years I've listened to this song and I never even noticed the "P-I-X-I-E-S!" part until I read about it on wikipedia.
FerenswayRecords 4 months ago
@FerenswayRecords wats the P-I-X-I-E-S part?
cotupina187 4 months ago
@cotupina187 listen to 1.10 to 1.15 :-)
FerenswayRecords 4 months ago
holy shit my pee pee just went back inside of me
lolercannon 4 months ago
the pixies just kick you straight in the balls,
perthheat111 5 months ago
I wish it was louder =O
kargath101 6 months ago 13
So fucking sexy!
xandermonkey1 6 months ago
Will you take off that dress, and send it to me?
PilotGina 6 months ago
whats the picture? Its prettty cool
HOSHAM12345 7 months ago
Does anyone know of any Pixies songs that are particularly heavy metal sounding. That would be right up my ally.
Thanos700 7 months ago
@Thanos700 try Tame! My fave track.
pixilixy 7 months ago
Un bon rif^^
daiidalos 7 months ago
make this song longer sonic youth
MrJessesmokeS1 8 months ago
to cool
0TheStorage0 8 months ago
this song is awesome but it's def not long enough.
baufuckinghaus 8 months ago
David Bowie really likes The Pixies.
DaBoulDick 8 months ago 4
P-I-X-I-E-S!!!!
MasTriste 9 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
why do these faggots think they're orginal when they're clearly copying Bowie
7waystowin 10 months ago
@7waystowin You're an idiot! Bowie covered this song! Go kill yourself!
AkiZivina344 9 months ago
@AkiZivina344 He's trolling, faggot. gb2 basement.
thoughtcrimer 8 months ago
@thoughtcrimer Go fuck ur mom.
AkiZivina344 8 months ago
@7waystowin what a lame guy... go get fill up with info and then argue about it.. you dummy
suhijo 9 months ago
@7waystowin Wikipedia would've saved you from humiliation.
NorthStarAritharo 9 months ago
Mescaline!!
Fabiosouza420 10 months ago
Great song, very interesting lyrics. Wow, Black is a genius.
Basically, he's shooting down the idea that reading some words can provide true comfort. This is very similar to his mocking in "Mr Grieves". The point is that if you've tasted the flesh and body fluids of another, mere words pale in comparison.
Prisons connote different things. Is he in a physical prison? Brilliant song. Awesome.
ChuckyTheGoat 10 months ago
Jesus, the Pixies even sound like what was eventually the White Stripes, it's uncanny...is there any major alt rock group that doesn't owe some gratitude to the Pixies??
sammyh1982 10 months ago 4
No one should ever cover Pixies songs. Not saying that in a dick way, it's just no one can ever come close to touching their versions. They are too unique. One of the greatest bands of all time.
guanjon 11 months ago
@guanjon yes, you're right, nobody can touch her versions, but when they take a pixies song and change it? Do you know the Mr.Grieves Cover by TV on the radio. I think it's really good...
vanboaconstrictor 10 months ago
@vanboaconstrictor No, I'll check it out, thanks. And I agree with you that covers are better when they are changed up/reworked. But listen to Bowie's version of this, it's exactly the same (in terms of following the original musically). I've heard some good covers of Hey also.
guanjon 10 months ago
I think this song influenced Cobain to write Frances Farmer Will Have Revenge On Seattle
Tybangy 11 months ago
@Tybangy Check out Foo fighters tired of you is almost the same song jajajaj... you bet who influence /copy who
suhijo 9 months ago
ROCK AND FUCKING ROLL!!!!!!!!!!
purpleryder 11 months ago
Man I love both versions of this song. They both offer a completely different experience. This one is much more desperate with the vocals and really just draws an image of complete desolation, while Bowies is more of a romping flowing rock song.
Antichrist2000 1 year ago
I love both the bowie version and the Pixies version.
thepersona100 1 year ago 3
Amazing song. I have an acoustic version on my channel. :-)
thebandcoca 1 year ago
lol
1marksr 1 year ago
wow it's amazing how hard it is to find the official video of a song
ASwollenProstate 1 year ago
the most demented and awesome love song ever recorded....
97bruin 1 year ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
but the letter in your writing doesn't mean your not dead -bloody your hands hands on a cactus tree wipe it on your dress and send it to me---!
marcdeb 1 year ago
but the lettter in your writtin doesnt mean your not dead -bloody your hands hands on a cactus tree wipe it on your dress and send it to me---!
marcdeb 1 year ago
I'd subscribe, but You Tube said, 'You have too many subscriptions compared to the number of subscribers'. Like, what? I don't KEEP UP with them? YT should get their facts straight!!!
louiseduvee 1 year ago
this has absolutely nothing to do with mescaline! why dont you listen instead of spouting pseudo psychotropic nonsense?
19stuart73 1 year ago
It's called mescaline, it's the only way to fly.
merkabah2 1 year ago
aint no 'The' homie. they just Pixies.
BigMeatSpecial 1 year ago
Great song!!!
mondrago77 1 year ago
fr4nk bl4ck r00ls
jellobefore 1 year ago
I heard the Bowie cover first but didn't twig at all that it wasn't original, and was pleasantly surprised that the Pixies released it first. The two are crafted from the same clay maybe.
p1nkAcid 1 year ago
@p1nkAcid Bowie has praised the Pixies in many an interview and they are fans of his. Yes, they are cut from the same cloth
Nedzorz1 1 year ago
he kinda sounds like jack white
hunggar2000 1 year ago
@hunggar2000 you mean jack white sounds like frank black
downthespiral666 1 year ago 7
@hunggar2000 dude jack white sounds like him ;)
elwoop 1 year ago
The best song by them is every song recorded from Caribou to The Navajo Know.
0987cheez 1 year ago
where did you get the skull image from?
vapordistilled 2 years ago
wow he is desperate
1800iamevil 2 years ago
Top 5 Pixies songs:
5.Debaser
4.Where is my Mind
3.Velouria
2.Gouge Away
1.Cactus
0987cheez 2 years ago 2
But what about Manta Ray, Crackity Jones, Motorway to Roswell, Ana, Into the White, Tame, Caribou, All over the world, Hey, Wave of Mutilation, Where is my mind, I Bleed, Isla de Encanta, Vamos, Space (I believe in), hell any song! I couldn't make a top 5 if I wanted to. It's all too brilliant!
Jefrey with one F!!!
AllRiseForDrEvil 2 years ago 7
we'll just say surfer rosa is the best album then.
brrnay 2 years ago
I find it very hard to name my favourite Pixies album. They are all very different and choosing one is almost impossible. It's like saying you love one of your kids (who happens to be a superhero named Tony) more than the others. You may like one a bit more than the other, but you could never say it out loud because you don't want to hurt their feelings. And naming my favourite Pixies album would hurt the other albums' feelings. And than they would have to kill me in my sleep.
AllRiseForDrEvil 2 years ago 18
@AllRiseForDrEvil Lmao, i love you!!
XstonerXXL 1 year ago
@AllRiseForDrEvil
dUUUUUDE YOU SMOKE HARD SHIT
WHERE DO YOU GET THAT-'?
tukitronic 2 months ago
dUUUUUUUDE
YOU SMOKE HARD SHIT....... WHERE DO YOU GET THAT?
tukitronic 2 months ago
@tukitronic
Actually I ate a desert cactus. The same one Frank had for dinner when he wrote this song.
AllRiseForDrEvil 2 months ago
@AllRiseForDrEvil doolittle its there beest
iancurtisfanatic 1 week ago in playlist surfer rosa
Comment removed
MrVanFamily 1 year ago
@0987cheez personally i think letter to memphis is their best.but i would put this at #2
drumsofthunder32 1 year ago
This is by far the best song of longing ever written - I'd drop my panties in a second for shit like that
lilcoffey13 2 years ago 3
wow that's an awesome background pic
nitarbell 2 years ago
wow, the studio version seems a lot more haunting and disturbed
BalloonAway 2 years ago
<3 Love Pixies so hard.
2write2sing2dance 2 years ago
Do you have more information on that poster? Pixies playing UC Davis? What's the date? Love the way it looks.
kleinsound 2 years ago
Awesome song!!
Lisaleesa13 2 years ago
She is sooooooooo beautiful!!!
draktar666 2 years ago
I cant stop listening to this song. Greatest band ever!!!
andrew12494 2 years ago
Yep. Dont forget David Bowie, though :-)
rrumcajsz 2 years ago
I'm surprised Bowie knows Grunge.
He covered this song on his almost-totally-unknown 2002 album.
That's how I know this song existed.
stupidpablo1 2 years ago
The Pixies were many things but never were they grunge. But I will admit a lot of the grunge bands stole from them. But why wouldn't they? Pixies are artistic gold.
sachapp464 2 years ago
The pixies aren't grunge?
stupidpablo1 2 years ago
No. Pixies started in Boston. Grunge was mostly a Seattle/West Coast thing: Mother Lovebone, Alice In Chains, Mudhoney, Nirvana, Pearl Jam, et al. Different vibe, attitude & look. Pixies were more artful than grunge IMO & were closer to punk but weren't quite that either. They weren't anything you could categorize easily & were alternative before the term was coined - they called it "Progressive Rock" back then. I love my Nirvana & I love that they admired Pixies but Pixies were not grunge.
sachapp464 2 years ago 2
Woah thanks for clearing that up. I was apparently taught wrong.
stupidpablo1 2 years ago
good job clearing that up - the whole Subpop thing was cool but nobody was in the same league as the Pixies except maybe Nirvana and well, we know how that turned out
lilcoffey13 2 years ago
one: pixies were not grunge. Sachapp464 just clear that up 4 u. great.
two: why will you be surprised that Bowie knows grunge, or Pixies for that matter? ge is an incredible curious artist always on the look for new sounds. reciently performed with artist such as Arcade Fire just to name one.
Three: Reality is not an almost totally unknown album!!!
ziggyplayguitar 2 years ago 2
I was surprised he knew grunge because I never really related his musical style to that of grunge at all.
Reality? I thought this song was on Bowie's "Heathen" album. That's how I got to know this song.
stupidpablo1 2 years ago
you are right is heathen.
and yes, his musical style is different but he is one curious guy!
cheers!
ziggyplayguitar 2 years ago
get lives
curdlemon 2 years ago
we have an awesome ones: all day listening music and smoking shit yeaaahhhh what more could a girl want in life? :D
ziggyplayguitar 2 years ago 3
Some blues in this song.... like it :D
And pixies rule... :o FTW
Flemse911 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I had no idea this was a cover of david bowie till today..haha
antiXincorporated 3 years ago
in fact, david bowie covered this song....this song isn't a bowie cover
Crackerdamus101 3 years ago 61
Bowie knows good music. Pixies are damn good music.
DZMOR 3 years ago 3
@Crackerdamus101 who the fuck is David Bowie lol
manchesteralex4 11 months ago
"Cactus" is a song by the American alternative rock band Pixies, and is the eighth track on their 1988 album Surfer Rosa. It was written and sung by the band's frontman Black Francis ... So next time, think before you speak!
Flemse911 2 years ago
Wow calm down. It's a simple mistake.
lightbulbs67 2 years ago
@antiXincorporated GET AIDS.
BrendanIsCool 1 year ago
@antiXincorporated fuck your dumb
bman462 1 year ago
@bman462 *you're*
If you're going to call people dumb make sure you do it correctly.
Sigma9870 1 year ago
@Sigma9870 cry
bman462 1 year ago
@antiXincorporated um....david bowie covered this song... this is the original version...
RandomVideos7818 1 year ago
meest romantische liedje aller tijde
cnarl 3 years ago 3
bla
cnarl 3 years ago
yay! Cactus! this was the song that made me fall in love with the pixies. If you dont mind another suggestion...upload hangwire..theres only a live version and a cover :)
hojitasvioletas 3 years ago 20
alrighty, hangwire will be up very soon...
Crackerdamus101 3 years ago
hang wire is now up!
Crackerdamus101 3 years ago 4