John Petrucci Missed Up - Fatal Tragedy

[baaaarnsey]

@talkingbullet not sad, dumping labrie would mean a complete change of sound. mangini is different, but it only comes across subtly in the album.

[TheRiffCalendar]

There can be no pizza pie! (?)

[fatdydnkn]

Tell me who could be DTs singer if not Labrie??

I guess anyone

[joa97killer]

This video is fake. GODS NEVER FAIL.

[anthonymm777]

the only mess up was L'abrie's awful vocals

[digitalfreak123]

@anthonymm777 not trying to say your wrong here (actually i am) but why does everybody thik hes a bad vocalist? hes got a great range and voice

im not trying to be offensive, just curious

[anthonymm777]

@digitalfreak123 Not sure how I would take offense to it, but I just believe that an incredibly talented band like Dream Theater deserves a better lead singer. In the end you have your opinion on him and I'll have my opinion on him, I feel that this may turn into some dumb argument, so we'll just leave it at that.

[digitalfreak123]

@anthonymm777 i wasnt trying to argue, just curious

[talkingbullet]

@anthonymm777 yet they dumped MP instead of Labrie, sad

[RaidZeroh]

@talkingbullet They didn't dump MP, MP chose to leave.

[ZachValkyrie]

Silly Johnny; still trying to convince us that he's really human after all!

[OmgItsGaryBusey]

how the hell can you even tell what's wrong

[metallicguns95]

Where did he mess up?

[ThatCheapDrummer]

You "missed" up to.

[nandinho1334]

@ThatCheapDrummer You "missed" up "to".

[chrisx8x23x95]

labrie looks like a fag without the beard...just saying. Maybe when he shaves it off we can call him RONALDO LABRIE cause he doesnt look like a james or a kevin with out that thing

[Michielvdwerff]

I think Labrie's vocals are a bigger fail to be honest

[triviumfan35]

I was expecting a screamer.

[ytsebam]

I'll stop listening to DT for this mistake...

[Explosive184]

To those who think this is fake....

/watch?v=QhWobIUwfcE

2:07

[alexeevic]

lolwut?

[Desfrable]

I dont even wanna know what would happen to the crowd if he didnt change the song on purpose, he saved lives.

[marHAVIK]

You messed up the spelling on a video that's criticizing someone for messing up -__- #Fail

[daniju93]

omg what a fatal tragedy

[SpaceDyeDream]

@TheeOutlaw @gimli1980 @Macckos

Hahaha really?



[TheeOutlaw]

I am not sure where you're even talking about :s it sounds fine to me.

[reyeror]

I thought he wasn't human....... but he is.

[gimli1980]

..I really didn't see any "mess ups"

[Macckos]

Where is the problem in this?

[DustinShaneYounce]

It looks like you "missed" up on your title.

[Guitardreams182]

I was there, Chile.

[Sun2ni]

God isnt perfect~

[matt2eadgbe]

You're title failed more than he did

[xaqshana]

humans screw up, im sorry to say it.

but petrucci isnt human, his level awesome just became so intense that out minds failed to comprehend it for a moment

[laurendaly2010]

he didn't mess up, acording to the tittle he missed up

[thisiswebbmaster]

i actually think his wee little fail sounded pretty cool

[Darkflameszide]

Eso fue en chile :D del 2005 en la gira del octavarium

[D3m0nhunter719]

Definitely doctored...... the better sound quality of the "mess up" proves it.

[Dopefish1990]

He is human okay, their music isnt exactly easy to play either.

[theunitedspeed]

he messed up??

[Randyolsson]

its hard to play that while singing. if u think about something else for 1 second this is what happens

[MrStorm1337]

He plays faster than the speed of sound, the noise can't keep up.

[metalmasta]

dont know the song so didnt hear any messing up? People mess up all the time on stage anyway. Its part of the performance

[Crazy3189]

rare

[acerpalamtum]

Its funny to see you pointing out a trivial mistake of an accomplished, brilliant musician when you cant even spell 'messed up' properly.

[henkiewessel]

robots cant make mistakes this vid is fake ;)

[KyleJPie10]

Sound waves just don't know how to react to his playing, thats all.

[YtseJam16]

patch change fail

[TheFacilidade]

I cannot see mistake,maybe on backing vocals!

[m0nNickneim]

He didn't mess up. The sound disobeyed his order.

[9000Ryan]

I don't get how this would be fake or he didn't mess up. Anyone with any musical knowledge should accept that the chords he hits after the "piece of mind" part are all messed up and garbled, like he forgot where he was going. Sometimes people just mess up, you can't help it.

[godlikecharacta]

he didn't mess up, everyone else's hearing is messed up.

[Ragash91]

If I got it right I wouldn't call that a mistake, it is barely audible, he just lost the timing a little bit. Besides, the poor quality of this video may make it sound worse than it actually was.

Anyway, the first line LaBrie sings is way worse. I didn't know he sang so bad live, guess it's his vocal cord problem. Man, that was bad luck.

[JDrobertson91]

@Ragash91 I've seen DT twice (sytematic chaos and black clouds) and Labrie nailed his performances. I think he's getting better as time progresses, but so many of these videos from older performances are a little painful

[tjrocks209]

he actually hit like 200 notes impossible to see to the naked eye.

[zacdenison]

That sounded good though? It was likely intentional. It was in key. And you ended it too soon.

[mariusel666]

Nah thats probably how they play guitar on his home planet

[SmokeAndMirrors2]

hahahah eso es en chile!!!!!!!

[slashbullet]

@SmokeAndMirrors2 }

más encima xDD

[ibanezxiphos700]

i dont get it....

[G3LEBEL]

This is not Petrucci, this is Chuck Norris trying to imitate him and failed

[INNERVOICExx36]

Nice try but it was fake

[DiabolusEnGuitar]

FFFFAAAAAAKKKKEE

[nekezajebancije]

Hehehe, nope, it's not Petrucci, I think Rudess screwed up.

And, no, I'm not saying Petrucci is not human... He's just... like a demigod or something.

[TheConnord12]

wheres the mistake?

[Riffeater]

fake

[gabiruman]

@Riffeater nop i actually have that concert and the same happens

[guano70menos1]

yo no pude ir a ese, yo fui al 2008 y 2010, q igual estuvieron la rajaaa!!!!!!

[metalandi]

he didn't mess up, the time-space continuum got out of order because of his awesome playing, so it seemed like he was off.

[TheeOutlaw]

I still can't find the mistake. I seriously don't know where you're talking about.

[ESP4thaWin]

fake

[fixxxer602]

fake

[antiWMGchannel]

How could petrucci make a mistake??? It is impossible

[gnryeah]

He didn't miss a note, the note was too scared to come out from the guitar under his wrathful fingers.

[destruction143]

Petrucci doesn't make mistakes, he meant to play that.

[Schneiderrst]

live CHILE 2005 :)

[0oIronMaideno0]

This whole show was terrible for Petrucci, he fluffed his solo in this and other songs too and i think this is the show were they completed fucked the ending of Metropolis as well, but hey its a rare occurence, they have a different setlist every nite so there is alot to remember.

[shipuuga]

yea, it must be a NIGHTMARE to remember, OH!

[KazeReload]

Maybe he did it on purpose? it's not really bad after all lol

[SjPedro]

you don't get it...he missed the note so the mine under the audience wouldn't go off and kill everyone in the process...he showed those mortals in the audience some pity by not killing them!!

[ChromeXk]

Petrucci doesnt need mines to kill anyone. All he needs to do is enter KILLZONE mode! And you better pray to your gods if that happens, but even they wont be able to help you! :P

[dreambrew]

So he is human after all. Hard to tell from all his GREATNESS!

[D3m0nhunter719]

Pffft he isn't human, he missed that note so that us mortals could have at least a tiny shred of dignity.

[dreambrew]

@D3m0nhunter719 LOL! His mistakes sound better than my correctly played efforts!

[D3m0nhunter719]

@dreambrew They sound better than all our correctly played efforts......

[drumari0]

one major fuck up and he still destroys all you morons that criticies him, im sure he's crying in his mansion into his silk sheets that he payed for by being a guitar and music god

[xPurpleDrinkx9001]

@drumari0 Your a fanboy for thinking that people care if he misses a single note. This video is strictly for lawls.

[LHondrums]

man i thought like the last tone in this vid could be the real fuckup.. that one was simply wrong!

[ryujisan]

oh come on. admit it.. john petrucci is still a human after all beyond his godliness

[GLP68]

he actually diddnt mess up. he just time warpped and when he came back he was a little bit ahead of the song.

[Vibratissimo]

lol.

to the millionth power :)

[0Mifel0]

Santiago / Chile / 2005

[ahmedsolist]

hahaha

[joshherbert1]

nah, this video is fake, probably doctored :)

[TukiOpeth]

nopes

[joshherbert1]

I was joking :)

[Dimerah]

he didnt mess up

[dyinghorse7]

@joshherbert1 he mess up in a couple parts on fatal tragedy...live in chile 2005 check out the bootleg....i was there

el mejor recital de la vida!

[joshherbert1]

@dyinghorse7 Who are you really, to critique John Petrucci?! and point out his mistakes?!

[dyinghorse7]

@joshherbert1 i think it was probably by the 20000 peoples in the crowd....love the music and work of petrucci....you can also check the tackle of myung with petrucci in the root of all evil at the same concert... it was a crazy night!

[yarzunecro]

@joshherbert1

Is true my friend, i was there in that show...but is Mister Jhonn Petrucci... is a human!!! :P

[CristianTejadaU]

@joshherbert1 nope is the DVD chilean skies

[fellipebarnabe]

@joshherbert1 no no!! its not a fake, I remembered this part!! john is simple human with mistakes like all of us!! but his so good!! LoL

[chaveznieves]

lol if we all didn't already know the song it works

[Kynitt]

He got distracted by MP saying "you can eat my ass and balls"

[shipuuga]

hahahaha

[6rosebudX]

yeah. he wanted to makes us think hes human! jajajajaja

nice try, but we're not fooled mr. petrucci

[XGLDF]

He probably just lost himself just because he had to sing at the same time (Yes, he does a lot of back vocals, but shit happens)

[WeRemaincf]

around 0:08

[wcr4]

A real mess-up by John Petrucci would be a Fatal Tragedy indeed.....Fatal because he would slay the world with a barrage of shredding in a fit of rage afterwards. Except they couldn't get into hell because it would be frozen. Also all the flying pigs would block the way to heaven.

[metALLIca15091993]

hahaha

[CrimsonDrift16]

buhahah...

[fcatrin]

this was in Chile. I was there.

Three hours of musical hallucination for 25.000 people!!!

[maviddicic]

You can hear some wrong notes on guitar... but still you can hear the right ones.... So... it's fake!!!

[psychostew911]

did he mess up on the words or something? Who cares anyways he is amazing, he's only human

[rodrigozamo]

no he´s not.... he is our god

[wcr4]

Explain to me how he messed up?

[Sproeikoei]

This is posted by a DT hater (has to be) he just didn't pinch the note it's still the same note so no mistakes there ;)

[wcr4]

A hater who went to a concert?

[Sproeikoei]

Well if he carried 4 cameras on his back and knows how to control and switch them within 15 seconds sure yes...

Sorry but that was the dumbest thing you could have said.

[SomethinWild]

Btw he said this was POSTED by a DT hater and not FILMED by him... but sure, this is some official footage.

[metALLIca15091993]

HAHA!

[FlashCE]

Interesting. This looks professionally filmed?