who started all this shit about her voice being sub par... this girl makes me wanna cry every time i hear her music, her voice is the most beautiful thing ive heard since i can remember so anyone who wants to bash on sumthing that incredible doesnt know jack shit about beauty, this girl is magic, i love you joanna newsom
What an exquisite voice; powerful in its fragility, tragically beautiful in its emotion. Joanna Newsom is a superb artist with haunting, ethereal talent and an obviously deep understanding and rich perspective of the world. Her revealing songs are both modernly relevant and eerily dated in their folk-like narrative quality and fantastic subject matter.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Please make it stop. Make it stop please. Her voice makes me want to drink cod liver oil and the lyrics make just about as much sense as Justin Bieber being straight.
@DarthBriannaWeasley Get over yourself. Just pause the video and close your browser if you want it to stop so badly. And cod liver oil is very good for you, fyi. Maybe think next time you try to bash something as incredible as this song.
Beautiful voice, beautiful lyrics, first singer that actually tells a story in her music and her lyrics are not meaningless. all i can say is very unique :) love joanna newsom
I love this because her voice isn't this picture perfect ringing bell. It's strange and somewhat unnatural.
I love that because somehow this, along with the beautiful harp and I'm just calmed by the sound. It feels like things I've known for hundreds of years and thing I've yet to discover.
Time seems to become irrelevant when listening to this song. After hearing it I'm not sure whether I've been listening for 2, 10 or a hundred minutes. In the absolutely best possible way.
There's a tremendous amount of meaning in this song when you look at it through the idea of a Deus Ex Machine. A machine used in a play that comes in as the hand of God or fate. There's a tremendous amount of imagery of stage mechanics---her as a fake bird being controlled by strings, being pulled up and down by a church bell. The real and fake, God and fate, life and death, etc.
I just discovered this song yesterday, so I'm still working through it. But, it is beautiful.
She's considering her musical existence, her physical existence and what comes at the end. You just need to let it seep into you - there's no obvious comprehension; it just happens over time.
I guess it's because I'm new to her music, but this song doesn't do anything for me. I've tried to listen to a few of her songs, and so far "No Provenance" is the only one that I even remotely enjoy.
I really want to give her a shot, but it's really hard. My ears are really sensitive to pitch, so sometimes listening to her really hurts (quite literally). But I do want to give her a fair try.
@SuperAthenaD I get that. First time I heard Peach Plum Pear I was just... shocked. I really didn't get it. What really got me to understand why she had captivated so many was actually listening to the polyrhythms in this song. When you don't focus on her voice for a while you really start to feel what she's feeling.
That didn't make any sense, but that's mostly because I'm horrid with words.
@TheyStopWar You say it doesn't make sense - but actually a great comment. My gf always listens to the words n a song and doesn't like Newsome so much - I always listen to the music and ignore the words, and I think this is great.
I had an initial sick feeling about the voice, but the music and imagination on display just seem to me to be quite unusual
@SuperAthenaD All screw all you attentions whore's if you don't like or even faintly dislike her don't even waste your time looking her up on youtube,obviously you like her and enjoy her music or else you would'nt even comment you'd just leave and forget about her! Me on the other hand i love her.
@TheKuraiAssassin Wow, wow. Is the name calling really necessary? I posted this like, seven months ago when I had just found her music. I've grown to like her a lot now. I was just born very sensitive to pitch, so it took me a while to adapt. There's really no need to be rude when I was just stating an opinion.
Okay, if there is anyone that has the ablum 'Ys' would it be possible for you to send me a message with the track listiing? I can't find it anywhere on google, and if I do, it only comes up with the first disk track list and provided that the information on this video is correct, there is clearly more tracks that I can't find the name of. Thanks in advance/anyway!
I don't know why but this thought just occurred to me..if Joni Mitchell had passed away this would certainly be her modern reincarnation.I've heard a lot of music in 44 years..but I can't begin to wrap my head around this. It's staggering on so many levels.
I thought her voice is absolutely perfect! Especially the raw crackling voice in Milk-Eyed Mender! Why imperfect at all? I absolutely adore the exuberance her voice has. But I don't like her voice as much now in Have One On Me--- too restrained.
Joanna (I'd like to be on a first-name basis) is amazing. There is not a song of hers I do not absolutely love. Her voice is divine, and her harp-skills are superb. I absolutely love her and her music.
i never cry because of a song. it's just emty words and some noise. but this single song, this girl, nade me cry all way trough, staring at thoose wonderful words and listening to that voice..
@clevery96 dude wtf me too. no other song in existence, either. some come close. but this just blows my emotions from the very beginning to the very end, it never lets up, it just takes me deeper and deeper.
You know, after listening to her for some time, I don't even care how she sounds. Anyone who can come up with lyrics so moving and full of raw emotion deserves to sing them, no matter how they sound.
Please let the music flow. A fairy will look upon you when you stop cursing this song, which resists being a poem, because it is a lot more beauty than one.
@fachefichekuriza I think when she went to arts and performance school, she was taking theatre and looking a line-reciting trick to be able to repeat long, long stories.
Joanna can be quite hard to listen to when you hear her for the first time. She's really unusual and different. But, when you make yourself listen to her for some time, you end up loving her and you can't get enough of her music. I find it hard to understand some of her lyrics because English is not my vernacular language, but either way, it's all together (the lyrics, the music, and her voice) really relaxing, peaceful, poetical and absolutely adorable. And so is she.
It's complete insanity to put Lady fucking Gaga in any type of category with Joanna Newsom. Whoever managed to dribble that nonsense out of their mouth...may god have mercy on their soul.
@job87meh That's ignorant and cruel. No artist who loves music would ever condone such useless banter. Joanna and Gaga are totally different, and should not be compared like meaningless trinkets to be sold. Mind yourself before you assume such disdain.
I dislike how she pronounces her R's within her singing. Besides that and the lack of her vocal accuracy she's not half bad. The lyrics are really good. I think I may write a cover to fit a more "indie rock" style.
@Jonisapsuedonym That's the thing though, she's creating something new. That's great if you want to fit it into a certain style for your interest, but I don't think any real musicians should create music purely to fit a genre. A stylistic choice is a means, not the end; and I'm glad Joanna is willing to go beyond any constraints to make her music what it is.
Oh man, if she isn't the most magnificent lyricist I've ever known. I wish one day she'd collect all her lyrics, like poems really, into a book ... I'd buy it in a heartbeat. I hardly care how she sings, when she can write like that, and play the harp like she can.
but...do you all know why is it???...cause while other musicians and composers just write about big butts and shook hips, this princess bizarre pops up with somethign hiden in the soul of a man, she doesnt perspire money nor industry....she is just her.
I imagine Lady Gaga getting revenge on Newsom for being right about her being talentless by covering this song with glitzy synths and a disco beat-- and then it becomes a top-40 hit and all that was good in music continues to dig a grave for itself.
This is a beautiful song.I can not begin to explain how this song made me feel.I was hypnotized by the beautiful poetry.One day i hope to be able to write half as good as her.Someday i hope to comprehend this song completely,even though i am only 13 years old i have never heard a song with so much emotion before.
Its hard to not to want to say that this is the perfectly written song i have encountered. By far the most lyrical genius of our time. flawless poetry.
two years ago if i had heard this song i would have shot it down in less then a second but now i hear her voice stress the right notes deeping the story man how my music taste have changed though that is not really the right word they are not even a former shadow of what they were
her voice sounds impeccable to my punk rock ears
maosaytounge49 1 week ago
Comment removed
maosaytounge49 1 week ago
best rapper alive!
kate8771 2 months ago 2
The feeble minded don't understand her.
kate8771 2 months ago 3
who started all this shit about her voice being sub par... this girl makes me wanna cry every time i hear her music, her voice is the most beautiful thing ive heard since i can remember so anyone who wants to bash on sumthing that incredible doesnt know jack shit about beauty, this girl is magic, i love you joanna newsom
NolanDrag0n 2 months ago 6
<3
DeniseInChains 4 months ago
she's just so amazing. I love this song
AshleyTH94 5 months ago
What an exquisite voice; powerful in its fragility, tragically beautiful in its emotion. Joanna Newsom is a superb artist with haunting, ethereal talent and an obviously deep understanding and rich perspective of the world. Her revealing songs are both modernly relevant and eerily dated in their folk-like narrative quality and fantastic subject matter.
morganbrannon 6 months ago 8
I love this one....I think it's her best. The lyrics are amazing, the harp is amazing, and her manner of delivery is perfect.
frankied00m 6 months ago
i was all horns and thorns
noradosmith 6 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Please make it stop. Make it stop please. Her voice makes me want to drink cod liver oil and the lyrics make just about as much sense as Justin Bieber being straight.
DarthBriannaWeasley 6 months ago
@DarthBriannaWeasley Tacking an overused Justin Bieber joke on the end there just proved how little your opinion matters.
sickofwaitingtables 6 months ago 5
@DarthBriannaWeasley Get over yourself. Just pause the video and close your browser if you want it to stop so badly. And cod liver oil is very good for you, fyi. Maybe think next time you try to bash something as incredible as this song.
darkthunderz13 5 months ago
Beautiful voice, beautiful lyrics, first singer that actually tells a story in her music and her lyrics are not meaningless. all i can say is very unique :) love joanna newsom
Gumbiiii 7 months ago
I love this because her voice isn't this picture perfect ringing bell. It's strange and somewhat unnatural.
I love that because somehow this, along with the beautiful harp and I'm just calmed by the sound. It feels like things I've known for hundreds of years and thing I've yet to discover.
blondenarwhal 7 months ago
Who can compare nowadays? Such imagination. This isn't your average tune, its a musical poem!
bendabledoll 7 months ago 4
and the little white dove made with love, made with love, made with glue, and a glove, and some pliers
alreadytakenthe3rd 7 months ago
Time seems to become irrelevant when listening to this song. After hearing it I'm not sure whether I've been listening for 2, 10 or a hundred minutes. In the absolutely best possible way.
lukebrinkworth 7 months ago
Comment removed
chelseamuse72 9 months ago
this is wonderful music, truly exultant and tragically beautiful, something to watch the snow fall by yourself to.
chelseamuse72 9 months ago
7 people are oblivious
cellularsoul 9 months ago 2
There's a tremendous amount of meaning in this song when you look at it through the idea of a Deus Ex Machine. A machine used in a play that comes in as the hand of God or fate. There's a tremendous amount of imagery of stage mechanics---her as a fake bird being controlled by strings, being pulled up and down by a church bell. The real and fake, God and fate, life and death, etc.
I just discovered this song yesterday, so I'm still working through it. But, it is beautiful.
seamouse007 9 months ago 5
This song is profound.
robfisher1 9 months ago
this is the single most poetic thing i have heard in my entire life. She plays on my heartstrings.
Shmoofles 10 months ago
She's considering her musical existence, her physical existence and what comes at the end. You just need to let it seep into you - there's no obvious comprehension; it just happens over time.
shelingEB 10 months ago 3
her voice is trurly magicial. just now... i could't move through the whole song, and it's not my first time listening to it.
Tenmirel 10 months ago
yes, yes, this song is very beautiful. but can anyone explain the meaning of the lyrics to me please?
vxmit 10 months ago
heroine please
adaymify 11 months ago
Can't even find the right words to describe how lovely this is....
CheezyPoof09 11 months ago
she's painting a story with her music. it's insane and beautiful.
WebsOfTheLies 1 year ago
Does anyone know where the image at the very beginning of the video is from?
kaysoncashashley 1 year ago
@kaysoncashashley its from my ass
lawtrip 1 year ago 6
I guess it's because I'm new to her music, but this song doesn't do anything for me. I've tried to listen to a few of her songs, and so far "No Provenance" is the only one that I even remotely enjoy.
I really want to give her a shot, but it's really hard. My ears are really sensitive to pitch, so sometimes listening to her really hurts (quite literally). But I do want to give her a fair try.
SuperAthenaD 1 year ago
@SuperAthenaD I get that. First time I heard Peach Plum Pear I was just... shocked. I really didn't get it. What really got me to understand why she had captivated so many was actually listening to the polyrhythms in this song. When you don't focus on her voice for a while you really start to feel what she's feeling.
That didn't make any sense, but that's mostly because I'm horrid with words.
Listen to this again but listen to the harp.
Then listen to it again.
TheyStopWar 1 year ago 5
@TheyStopWar You say it doesn't make sense - but actually a great comment. My gf always listens to the words n a song and doesn't like Newsome so much - I always listen to the music and ignore the words, and I think this is great.
I had an initial sick feeling about the voice, but the music and imagination on display just seem to me to be quite unusual
mcgigglish 10 months ago
@SuperAthenaD All screw all you attentions whore's if you don't like or even faintly dislike her don't even waste your time looking her up on youtube,obviously you like her and enjoy her music or else you would'nt even comment you'd just leave and forget about her! Me on the other hand i love her.
TheKuraiAssassin 6 months ago
@TheKuraiAssassin Wow, wow. Is the name calling really necessary? I posted this like, seven months ago when I had just found her music. I've grown to like her a lot now. I was just born very sensitive to pitch, so it took me a while to adapt. There's really no need to be rude when I was just stating an opinion.
SuperAthenaD 5 months ago
Abusando.
tuculomeapasiona 1 year ago
Okay, if there is anyone that has the ablum 'Ys' would it be possible for you to send me a message with the track listiing? I can't find it anywhere on google, and if I do, it only comes up with the first disk track list and provided that the information on this video is correct, there is clearly more tracks that I can't find the name of. Thanks in advance/anyway!
missygreendaychimp 1 year ago
@missygreendaychimp
Emily
Monkey & Bear
Sawdust & Diamonds
Only Skin
Cosmia
phils010 1 year ago
I don't know why but this thought just occurred to me..if Joni Mitchell had passed away this would certainly be her modern reincarnation.I've heard a lot of music in 44 years..but I can't begin to wrap my head around this. It's staggering on so many levels.
cranie4 1 year ago 5
I thought her voice is absolutely perfect! Especially the raw crackling voice in Milk-Eyed Mender! Why imperfect at all? I absolutely adore the exuberance her voice has. But I don't like her voice as much now in Have One On Me--- too restrained.
ranice 1 year ago 2
Joanna (I'd like to be on a first-name basis) is amazing. There is not a song of hers I do not absolutely love. Her voice is divine, and her harp-skills are superb. I absolutely love her and her music.
thatsabigmanatee 1 year ago 3
i never cry because of a song. it's just emty words and some noise. but this single song, this girl, nade me cry all way trough, staring at thoose wonderful words and listening to that voice..
clevery96 1 year ago
@clevery96 dude wtf me too. no other song in existence, either. some come close. but this just blows my emotions from the very beginning to the very end, it never lets up, it just takes me deeper and deeper.
theoogabear 1 year ago
10 minutes of enthralling bliss
Ivan1burnf4ces 1 year ago 2
beautiful....
DJChainSmoker 1 year ago
You know, after listening to her for some time, I don't even care how she sounds. Anyone who can come up with lyrics so moving and full of raw emotion deserves to sing them, no matter how they sound.
ScribTheTreeHugger 1 year ago 15
@MonoxideKing - I tried not to lol, but I lol'ed.
ProperOnest 1 year ago
@MonoxideKing That's probably not anything special.
JessieMeteor 1 year ago
do you know what makes her songs perfect? is that her voice is imperfect in the most beautiful way
hellonearth069 1 year ago 18
@MonoxideKing such an interesting thing to say >.>
thetomatoelement 1 year ago 5
i like rap/hip hop and i even rap myself but i love this shit
phatmattd03 1 year ago 8
@akadenis47
it does not sound even close to a guitar you little dumbass. it's a harp ;)
9458283 1 year ago
lol how would that ever sound like a guitar to someone. shes awesome at what she does
smoketimer 1 year ago
@akadenis47
O.o guitar? That's not a guitar honey. That's a harp. You suck at identifying instruments.
mrshanson2010 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this girl fucking sucks at guitar but great lyrics
akadenis47 1 year ago
@akadenis47 But she's great at the harp :p
Adamanger3011 1 year ago
@akadenis47
Please let the music flow. A fairy will look upon you when you stop cursing this song, which resists being a poem, because it is a lot more beauty than one.
Atlein 1 year ago
@akadenis47 That's a harp she is playing. Not a guitar. Lmao.
MyChemicalRomance824 1 year ago 5
This song just makes me want to lock it up somewhere safe so that nobody who cannot appreciate it can belittle it. It's just so beautiful.
pookiejo34 1 year ago 2
4:33 - 4:45 always gives me goosebumps
Adamanger3011 1 year ago
This is such a beautiful song and the lyrics are amazing, how does she remember them all when she's performing?
fachefichekuriza 1 year ago
@fachefichekuriza I think when she went to arts and performance school, she was taking theatre and looking a line-reciting trick to be able to repeat long, long stories.
BloodyCatastrophee 1 year ago
@fachefichekuriza she (rarely) forgets them and it's super endearing when that happens
hewhosayszonk 1 year ago
She has a very interesting, different voice. C:
ceilingotaku 1 year ago
One of my favorite's by Joanna. She's simply an amazing Musician.
raklaf 1 year ago
when i listen to this i feel like im on a journey into another world
bigpimpdaddy69 1 year ago
Joanna can be quite hard to listen to when you hear her for the first time. She's really unusual and different. But, when you make yourself listen to her for some time, you end up loving her and you can't get enough of her music. I find it hard to understand some of her lyrics because English is not my vernacular language, but either way, it's all together (the lyrics, the music, and her voice) really relaxing, peaceful, poetical and absolutely adorable. And so is she.
BonesYouCannotBreak 1 year ago 2
A perfect example of Joanna's vocal range.
iOpposum 1 year ago
magical song
LeVitrail 1 year ago 2
It's complete insanity to put Lady fucking Gaga in any type of category with Joanna Newsom. Whoever managed to dribble that nonsense out of their mouth...may god have mercy on their soul.
id3nt1tyCr1siS 1 year ago 4
@id3nt1tyCr1siS Joanna isn't above a bit of fashion and glam, is she. Just use google.
dachhh 1 year ago
One of my favorites!! So peaceful!
musicismyhomegirl1 1 year ago
STOP COMPARING EVERY SINGLE FEMALE NEW ARTIST WITH GAGA! FOR GOODSAKE! GET OVER IT.
Joanna ROCKS!
TheAtreyustar 1 year ago
I love how this song seems to convey all of the sorrow I've ever felt while still bringing me to a place of pure jubilation.
MoonAndAntarctica3 1 year ago
I love how so many peeps are here slagging off Lady Gaga. Joanna would be so proud!
job87meh 1 year ago
@job87meh That's ignorant and cruel. No artist who loves music would ever condone such useless banter. Joanna and Gaga are totally different, and should not be compared like meaningless trinkets to be sold. Mind yourself before you assume such disdain.
Miyaatan 1 year ago
@Miyaatan Sorry Mom.
And I meant it in reference to the fact that Joanna herself has slagged off Gaga....
job87meh 1 year ago
@job87meh omg u even compare it with Gaga? get over Gaga, for chirstsake.
TheAtreyustar 1 year ago
I don't know why, but every time she starts the part at 5:00, my heart breaks. There's something so sad about it.
"just to lift your long face"
madkaye 1 year ago
I dislike how she pronounces her R's within her singing. Besides that and the lack of her vocal accuracy she's not half bad. The lyrics are really good. I think I may write a cover to fit a more "indie rock" style.
Jonisapsuedonym 1 year ago
@Jonisapsuedonym That's the thing though, she's creating something new. That's great if you want to fit it into a certain style for your interest, but I don't think any real musicians should create music purely to fit a genre. A stylistic choice is a means, not the end; and I'm glad Joanna is willing to go beyond any constraints to make her music what it is.
saratomavernus 1 year ago
Oh man, if she isn't the most magnificent lyricist I've ever known. I wish one day she'd collect all her lyrics, like poems really, into a book ... I'd buy it in a heartbeat. I hardly care how she sings, when she can write like that, and play the harp like she can.
susannacole 1 year ago
but...do you all know why is it???...cause while other musicians and composers just write about big butts and shook hips, this princess bizarre pops up with somethign hiden in the soul of a man, she doesnt perspire money nor industry....she is just her.
kalhumi 1 year ago 2
I imagine Lady Gaga getting revenge on Newsom for being right about her being talentless by covering this song with glitzy synths and a disco beat-- and then it becomes a top-40 hit and all that was good in music continues to dig a grave for itself.
FidelioRoo 1 year ago
man... I'm not your typical romantic person, but this song is just magical. God bless you Joanna.
alexakarpov 1 year ago
This is a beautiful song.I can not begin to explain how this song made me feel.I was hypnotized by the beautiful poetry.One day i hope to be able to write half as good as her.Someday i hope to comprehend this song completely,even though i am only 13 years old i have never heard a song with so much emotion before.
choklitozz 1 year ago 3
Its hard to not to want to say that this is the perfectly written song i have encountered. By far the most lyrical genius of our time. flawless poetry.
bunnylooker 1 year ago
This is what beautiful music is about.
NedsMissingTeeth 1 year ago
This song makes me cry
mramywinehouse 1 year ago 4
two years ago if i had heard this song i would have shot it down in less then a second but now i hear her voice stress the right notes deeping the story man how my music taste have changed though that is not really the right word they are not even a former shadow of what they were
e08man 1 year ago 48
This is the single most beautiful song that I have ever heard..
TheFallenCanRise 2 years ago 98