Added: 5 years ago
From: pjvenner
Views: 149,402
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (215)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Strange how these days every country (xept north korea) is into peace making

    yet we can laugh at a man being cut open by savages and have his abdomen cut to peices and have his organs removed while he screams and writhes in agony o_O,

    Ah who cares, its funny

  • i love this song so much...i`d never seen meaning of life from beginnin to end untill my dad got the boxset for his birthday...bloody hilliarious

  • can anyone tell me what th emoral/meaning is of this scene?

  • One of the greatest Monty Python scenes of all time, right up there with Mr. Creosote. I remember people walking out during both of these scenes when the movie first aired in the theaters.

  • i love Eric Idle

  • how the fuck did they get away with this back then....

    this is truly brilliant.....

    even in today's standard......

  • I can only imagine this in surround sound, or in theaters.... especially when he starts screaming... oh god, it must have been ghastly.... but bloody hilarious.

  • gah, every time I hear about someone needing a liver transplant, I think of this video and I want to laugh. Monty Python, you've damaged my sensitivity!

  • amazing sketch movie.

  • So I guess this is the movie Repo Men in 5 minuites.

  • lol at 2:00 and 2:35 he's reaching out like "gimme back my liver!! AHHHH!!!!!"

  • If you like the monty python/galaxy song check out this Uke cover. search flukulele galaxy song........enjoy!

  • Please someone else please tell me they recognized the photograph of Haile Selassie I in the beginning of the bit and noticed the donors dreadlocks and added 2 and 2 together to realized the Python fellas knew a thing or two.

  • "pray the day we find intelligent life out there cause theres bugger all down here on earth"

    rofl

  • @reddwarf135 its 'pray that theirs intelligent life somewhere up in space coz theres bugger all down here on earth'

  • @XDLJX : Ain't that the truth!

  • I'm using it :))))))))))))

  • I forgot how freakin' gory some of these Monty Python skits could be. Sick bloody bastards......I love it ^_^

  • Is this John Cleese in this clip??

    It sounds like him but isn't the same height and doesn't look like him LOL... thought it might be the video quality :S

  • Holy hell. I love Monty Python!

  • "were here for your liver'

  • I would be interested to know who wrote this sketch. I can't make up my mind whether it was Cleese and Chapman or perhaps a Terry Gilliam cartoon idea?

  • The song, however, is undeniably brilliant, and almost redeems the bit that didn't work before it. This film goes back and forth from brilliant to lame to brilliant again. Glad they stopped before they made a 100% lame film.

  • I like the sketch.  No, not subtle, but enjoyable, and of course the song, awesome. In general, I think the film is better than people give it credit for. And death at dinner is quite great. The biggest problem with the film was identified by the Pythons themselves. It's a bit underdeveloped, but love it nonetheless.

  • This segment actually sums up the film perfectly. The first sketch is an indication that the creative bubble is beginning to wear thin, resorting to shock tactics that, in its execution, comes off as more disturbing than funny (to me). A lot of comics who are going off a bit do this, it's a fairly common trend.

  • Couldn't agree more. In fact at the time of its release in an interview, Terry Jones said they were actually ashamed of a lot of what they did on the film and that they had filmed some sequences which they had expected to be cut.

    However Universal refused and released the film unedited.

     Like quite a few of their other sketches in the film the idea is a funny one but beyond the point where it becomes clear what the joke is, the rest is gratuitous.

    Terry Gilliam's screaming is just too real.

  • Salad Days and the Black Knight sequence in Holy Grail are violent and bloody, but you know that the violence is purely cartoon from the characters' reactions.

    Here we have two thugs essentially breaking into a person's house and disembowelling them. There is nothing remotely hilarious, comic etc. in the execution. It is totally inhuman and brutal.

    This is pretty much their lowest point.

  • Right on. I love Monty Python. They were (are) comedic geniuses with few equals, but in this instance, they simply went too far. I'm all for outrageousness if it has a point, but this is simply sick for sick's sake, which not only isn't funny, but can lead to some pretty backward artistic territory, as the comment on here about "socialized medicine" and "Obamacare" illustrate.

  • "But other sequences really do go right over the top into totally yucky juvenile humour, like a load of little boys trying to shock and just being boring." A review from the time of its release.

    The idea here IS funny but the way its done isn't. It would have made a great quickie. As it stands it remains the only track on the CD I skip.

  • Thanks for that. I knew that John Cleese wasn't entirely impressed with the film afterwards, even though he was the one who refused the final re-write that everyone else wanted.

    The organ transplant scene doesn't work for me because the comedy is in the background and the horror is in the foreground, which is back-to-front when it comes to gore humour. Background comedy, foreground straightness can work of course, but not with this subject matter.

  • Indeed, see "Airplane" for example.

    I think if they had simply slammed the door on the actual disembowelling and lame dialogue and just cut to the next sketch, it would have been a great one line quickie.

    I think Chris Morris "Jam" is far more interesting and sophisticated in the use of horror in comedy. Because it plays with the audience rather than simply going for the throat as this sketch does.

  • I really disagree. The shocking horror and violence of that scene is really necessary to get the Galaxy Song to hit home. You have to juxtapose this over the top moment of injustice and violence with this profound and humbling expression of the universe. It made this the second greatest segment of the film.

  • But you don't need to show the horror, suggestion is far more powerful. I get the impression that this is a scene they were hoping would be cut but wasn't.

    It adds little to the song which stands on its own.

  • @feloniousbutterfly I'm guessing the greatest is Mr. Creosote.

  • cool

  • i love Monty Python songs! i really do

  • Likewise! I have the 'Monty Python Sings' CD & every track's a classic... there's even a few I'd never heard before.

  • Makes you think twice about getting a liver donors card!!

  • ............and pray that theres intelligent life some where up in space, cause theres bugger all down here on earth!!

  • wtf! waaah

  • Has anyone relised that we are currently all travelling at the speed of light Einstein's theory of relativity two objects travelling alongside one another at the speed of light would appear motionless.If you suddenly stopped I wouldn't even have time to wish you...........................­..........

  • two objects travelling alongside each other at ANY speed that is the same appear motionless. We indeed are traveling but not on lightspeed. Only light travels on lightspeed

  • I suggested we are revolving around the centre of the galaxy at the equivalent to speed of light 300,000 km/s not travelling on the speed of light

  • Actually, we're all traveling at the speed of light through both space and time. When you increase your speed in the spacial dimension, you decrease your speed in the time dimension, as given by the formula To=T/ Root(1-v^2/C^2), where To is the proper time, T is the dilated time, V is the velocity in the spacial dimensions, and C is the speed of light. So in a sense, it is correct to say that we are traveling at the speed of light, but not in the typical spacial sense. Think planet of the apes

  • Actually we are travelling through TIME at the speed of light, not space. Even our passage through time is slightly slowed due to astronomical motion.

  • Basically what I just said..? It's a combination of the two. Yes, it is usually moving through time more than space due to the tendency of most objects to not move close to the speed of light relative to each other, but if one increases when the other increases, isn't it fair to say it's a combination of the two in which we're moving? And remember, how fast we're moving through time is only relative to other objects.

  • Where are you making this stuff up from?

  • I can never watch the transplant bit, it freaks me out too much.

    but I love the song :)

  • bloody hell that screaming is nerve shattering... the song makes up for it though :)

  • I love the way Eric is so cheeky and campy in this scene. His gestures are spot-on funny!

  • ahahahaha one of my favorite scenes!

  • Woah.. People take these Python sketches far too serious :x

    How is that possible?

    Eric came out of the fridge...

    Need i say more?

  • What, are you saying you don't have Eric Idle in your fridge?

  • I have him in a dress :D In amongst the iced halibuts.

  • The song is funny

  • Seems like theyve erased all the bloodsquirting in this edition of the scene. On the Dvd, its three times as terrifying...

  • a movie for the ages;

  • I love the way he says 'expanding'.

  • Just watched this, great movie.

  • Kinda makes you feel insignificant dosen't it?

    Yea, yea. Can we have your liver then?

    Ok, you talked me into it.

    ROTFLMAO!!

  • It would have been better as a quicky. Just have the guy being forced onto the table and have the door closed on it. Then cut to next scene. The rest is just simply gratuitously nasty.

  • PMSL, that would be too funny! Isn't it ironic that the 'pro-life' movement would probably end lives by firebombing any theatre that dared to show it...

  • You are a sick, disgusting person for suggesting something like that.

  • Yet I'm sure you found this video hilarious.

    GREAT HYPOCRISY.

  • Nobody's forcing you or anyone else to have an abortion. What right is it of yours to force your fundamentalist ideas upon others?

    What's next, taking away women's right to vote? Misogynist bastard!

  • It's a skit. No one's forcing you to give your liver away.

  • "can we have yo liva"

    lol

  • Actually, it's 'Can we have YOUR LIVER'. No chavs or gangstas in Monty Python. :P

  • the transplant part was gruesome.. even its fake. im disgusted by it somehow?!

    i just dont think i like things taken out of people.

    love the song tho!

  • If you look in the background when the're tlking in the kitchen, the guys still getting killed. Great Song

  • "Can we have your liver?"

    "I'm using it!"

    LMAO.

  • In history class we were watching a film about mummification and it showed them taking out the organs from the body, and everyone in my class was cringing at how nasty it was, but I was laughing so hard because it reminded me of this.

  • does anyone know the name of the tune at the very start of the live organ donors scene?

  • hava nagila

  • I had nightmares when I was little about the poor guy getting killed, disemboweled to be more precise.

  • makes me feel insignificant.

  • i loved this song, until i had to sing it in front of my year, ah! still like it though!

  • Love this scene from the movie, esp. the picture of Haile Selassi hanging in the hall at the beginning. Can't believe all the dialogue this video generated.

  • If only this kind of stuff didn't really happen...

  • "Can we have your liver?" LMAO.

  • terry jones KILLS me in this.

  • *sigh* You would never know how long i stand in front of my fridge... openening and closing the door... trying to coax a white haired man in a pink suit to come out... all those days wasted... all for nothing...

    lmao, thanks for posting

  • Lol monster. It's good to know I'm not the only one who does that. Maybe we need to spend a bit of money & get one of those fancy retro styled fridges?

  • @monstermaskus Eric idle only comes out on Tuesday.

  • lol

    *Husband being killed on table*

    "Would you fancy a cup of tea?"

  • FUCK OFF AND DIE SPAMMER

  • what did i do! all i did was one of those bulletin like things that are on myspace. it's not spam you idiot. it's a freaking comment. and i was an idiot for doing it bc none of those ever work!

  • Sorry about the FO&D, it was a lil OTT, I didn't realise at the time that you're just a kid - and I was pretty pissed to start with.

    Still, I can't believe you seriously thought it would work =D

  • It's okay. I guess I am a kid in a way. How old are you? I can understand the whole ticked off thing. I kinda take things out on other random people when I get mad, also. Lol.

    Yeah, I can be pretty stupid sometimes with these comments. Lol. I have a wild imagination sometimes.

  • Prolly about as old as your mom & dad :-s

    I still don't like irrelevant comments on my vids but I way over-reacted to yours, I just had other issues going on that particular day. Glad there's no hard feelings :)

  • ah. okay!

    Well I hope you have happier days than about a week ago! Lol. Yep. I can get over things pretty quickly.

  • Surreal genius!! I love all the Python films, have been a fan for years!

  • Same here.  XD X3 ^3^

  • I love them. especially Palin!

  • i didn't get film v werid lol but got all movies anyways lov like that bit and fish bit lol

  • I'm a nihilist, but this scene gives me a warm fuzzy feeling inside

  • Why the hell do people think Meaning of Life is inferior to Brian or Holy Grail? Let's see: Birth sketch, Every Sperm is Sacred, Sex Ed, Find the fish, Organ Donation with The Galaxy Song to boot, Mr. Creosote... I mean come on...

  • I love all the films :D

  • Wow, you could tell by John Cleese's face that he was really getting sick. His face was completely pale when Terry Jones was talking to him.

  • super super genial!!!!!!!!

  • Why the Hell does Eric Idle come out of a fridge at that moment. Monty Python has random humor too. Take that Fanily Guy!

  • Man, some people need to relax! No one will be as funny as these guys were! Stop posting lame comments, get a life and laugh a little!

  • AGREED!

  • fantastic!

  • Let me guess... a student right..? You could learn from the pythons - at least 3 of them studied at Oxford or Cambridge, one is a qualified medical practicioner - but they studied in the days when universities taught knowledge, as opposed to teaching politically correct opinions.

  • have u ever tried laughing when ur friends suck

  • It was made in 1983, actually.

  • sociopath...

  • I am just what the world made me.

  • you are just plain werid ! but each to their own! if you see satian tell him i said hello !

  • Oh, hold your horses; I am not exactly in the Devil's guestbook, and please:

    Everyone gets a little evil from time to time, and please do not make me send you some proofs of what I mean.

  • mwuhahaha peanutbutter..

  • wtf..? he's a nice guy who agreed to donate his organs, that's part of what makes it funny.

  • I know, but I felt evil, and trust me, I nearly grow horns when I get evil.

    -Rhanar

  • fuck you thats solid gold you wanker

  • Monty Python isn't a person, it's the team's collective name. As for the "sick bastard" that's your [minority] opinion which you're perfectly entitled to.

  • prick

    stupid stupid prick

  • what if guys come to cut out a man's liver, ....u offer them a cup of tea offcourse xP

  • best comedy movie ever!!!

  • ooooo, what about the life of Brian? Can we have your liver? classic

  • Too good for YouTube! Excellent stuff!

  • Yeah, I'm not a fan of horror stuff myself - just checked the rating when it came out: USA: R. I can stand humans gutting orcs, but people really against each other I can't stand. I've always been sensitive about it; I don't even like the part with Mr. Creosote (I hate throwing up). Still, the Pythons remain my favorite comedy troupe. The song was funny, though.

  • The reason that this is not disturbig, but unny, is that no- one really seems to notice that the guy is getting cut open, she even offers him a cup of Tea for his service of murdering her Husband! I love Monty Python, I hav so many of their DVDs!

  • and now for something completely different

  • that was random!

  • Brilliant!!!

  • he a good singer for a comedian lol lv monty python watched em all

  • o.O wth :D monty python are great.. but that was just random

  • Monty Python is kings! :D

  • moty python OWNES

  • Love this music!

  • best ever monty python scene!

  • "Do you think its all for the good of the country" LOL

  • "We're just doing our job, Ma'am"

  • Stop being a bunch of wussies!

    "Oh momma I couldn't bear the screams! please breast feed me!"

    The skit was brilliant, so was the song, and so was the brutal murder.

  • May I call you "SIR"? You are a fucking gentleman! If this was some kinda snuff movie I'd understand all the whimpering wussies, but it aint... it's blatant comedy so put your fake-ass sick bags away! Respect to the majority of viewers who've realised this already ;)

  • I'm 101% with you... but this isn't gory disembowelment. it's enactment... parody.. pretend.... call it what you like... IT'S NOT REAL SO GET OVER IT!

    and if you've enjoyed one single horror movie, you're such a hypocrite.

  • Well, I'm not the biggest horror fan in the world either. But even in horror, you're *supposed* to be revulsed. I think what most people find disturbing about this is that it goes too far for comedy. I mean, compare Lancelot's charge on Swamp Castle or the killer bunny in Holy Grail. That was outlandish and preposterous enough to be hilarious. Just my opinion, I don't mean to offend. (Unlike they did with this skit.)

  • Jackass....why don't you go smoke some of your stupid weed till ya die, I loath people like you PalaceOfExile.

    BUT MAN I LOOOOVE THIS SKIT!!!! ^__^

  • And pray that there's intelligent life somewhere out in space, 'cos there's buger all down here on Earth!

  • How very true!

  • LOL

  • omg.. I love brittish english.. there's no english way but the brittish way

  • i've see every movie, every episode, hugeeeeeee monty python fan!! :D

  • What's the meaning of it all though?

  • dude this is culture...classic culture.... you need a life and a scence of humour

  • This is funny, but what does being small have to do with the meaning of life? Say for example that we were all enormous, in the order of size of galaxies, or bigger, we still wouldnt know the meaning of life. It doesnt matter how small, or big, we are.

  • I think they meant small in a non literal sense. Small as in unimportant and insignificant.

    ...although come to think of it your point would still be very valid.

  • That's a good point. Perhaps emphasizing the size is a bit of a backlash against the historical/religious perspective of seeing ourselves as the center of the universe (with God speaking to us and failing to account for life elsewhere, which we now presume should exist).

    I had something interesting to say.. but, 500chars max.

  • Above was a a reply to

    fredschick1. I had to shorten my comment so many times to stay within limits.. I guess something got screwed up.

  • they cant tell you the meaning of life because nobody knows the meaning of life... its just another monty python film what do you expect it just talks alot about nothing lol but it is a great film

  • i love monty python! i totally wanna walk up to somebodys door and just be like "hello can we have you liver?" lol! so good! just to see what they'd say!

  • The screams scare the shit out of me, but this is still hilarious xD

  • Hell yeah man, It's beautiful.

  • galaxy song is one of thier most brilliant ideas ever.

  • I disagree. The Galaxy Song is one of the most brilliant ideas ever, not just exclusively to MP. ;P

  • Hm, must say, this isn't exactly the funnyest python I've seen, though I normally like Monty Python. The songs brilliant though. ^_^

    What does she say just after he says "Can we have your liver then"? Never understand that.

  • Sounds like "well no, it's... scary" - probably a reference to their removal methods?

  • I agree, they have made better things, all and all meaning of life wasn't really their best work.

    John Clease - "can we 'av ur liver then" Old woman - "Yeah, alright then, You've talked me into it"

  • And the first time he asked she says, "hmmm, no, i'd be, scared"

  • LOL!

    "Yeah, I know what it is, but I'm using it!"

  • I'm never gonna think the same way when I listen to that song again. XD

    Still great though, in normal Python, random-filled awesomeness.

  • I saw that movie in theater as a little kid. I'll always blame my parents for not letting someone keep me that night instead of dragging me to the theater, this movie scared the **** out of me.

    I love the Pythons but I don't even like that sketch as an adult. One of the worst times of my childhood.

  • come to think of it this scene frightened me too the first time I saw it. the screams somehow got to me...

  • How old were u? I'm sure it was X or at least '14' rated on release.