Carly Smithson - Jesus Christ Superstar (Results show)

[bucamarie]

She was the best this show has ever had

[Ikurun]

It would've been soooo cool to see a David Cook vs. Carly Smithson finale. =/

[JarHead2435]

if they had the judges save she wouldve made it farther b/c she wouldve been saved

[Boredtimes]

I have a feeling she would have been screwed either way, I think they would have used it on Michael Johns because he went first.

[truebloodfinatict8]

what place did she come in? did she come in sixth?

[jodalita]

So sad for her when she was eliminated. One of the strongest voices that year. Well, at least she got voted off with her best performance.

[franman0916]

American Idol should be like America's Best Dance Crew, so that the deaf voters don't choose who goes, they nominate who goes and the real experienced judges choose

[Aangfan24]

she probrably got voted off cause jesus was in the song...

[osahju914]

you are probably right...

[TvMooVJunkE]

the best performance for that week. how the hell did she get kicked off with this song?

[feelthejoy]

@TvMooVJunkE probably bc she's off pitch for 50% of the song...

[greenduck1027]

:[

sad

[lunafan12]

I was so mad when she got voted off...but, I was happy she left with a smile on her face.

[Luvin2Sing4eva]

i agree

[matum0to]

i was so pisse of when carly got voted off. all the votes down the drain. i really wanted her to win since she was the last of my favorites in the competition with the exception of archie.