Its like the piece cannot be played by a human... I just keep hearing mis-notes over and over, and it ruins the feeling of the music. someone should use a digital audio program to complete his music.
@looney1023 good thing you didn't just make an all-encompassing black and white statement about what will be the future of music creation and playing... Kinda... simple minded.
Awesome. I`m learning this version of this piece right now, and I`m so happy to finally find a recording that ISN`T from Trois Movements de Petrouchka.
Great performance, thanks for putting this up. c:
this piece is SOOOOOOOOO HARD you cant imagine how hard it is!!!!!!! this guy does a really good job but its still too fast for him because he cant control the dynamics, which is very important for this piece. it must be played "easier" and more soft. only few pianists can do that and play this terribly difficult piece very well.
this is a re-arranged version of the original.. it is a highly technical piece meant to show off skill, it would be nonsense if THIS version is meant to express the w,e, dance-like feeling, yes, it should sound like a race, as fast as possible, as accurate as possible...
Hey look, another youtube commentator who has no idea what they're talking about, what a surprise.
This piece, Trois Movements Petrushka, is a seperate composition by Stravinsky dedicated to Artur Rubinstein. It is different from the original Petrushka in many, many ways and cannot be called an arrangement or a transcription. Check around before you post a comment strongly claiming things. This is not a re-arrangement, oh, and the pianist here plays only the 1st of three movements.
@POPYLOLY8 i would have to dissagree, Yuja is technically better, but this performance conveys the mood and the initial intention of the piece in much more vivid colours
Yes, this is Stravinsky's own arrangement of the ballet out of three movements. The young pianist is playing it to fast and it is supposed to be a dance not a race to the finish and notice it is all the same dynamic. He has to learn through experience the musicality of Stravinsky.
Tell me about it. Stravinsky meant for the first line to be dance-like, but he's interpreting it as too fast and technical. The technicality of Stravinsky is implied, not to be shown off.
VERY nice! Excelante! but boy he couldn't get off the stage fast enough! haha oh well. It's NOT total chaos, it's amazing if you listen to the orchestration before this, you will hear the themes being played underneath themes, it's quite magical. Bravo, chap!
BRAVO!!! How long do you think he learned how to play this? i'm starting on it but i'm stuck on the first 2 pages T_T but i have 6 more months to learn it for a graduation concert =D
Messed up just a little bit in the FCG# key change, but recovered really well!
Another great piece by Stravinsky. Haven't heard the actual orchestrated ballet though.
Nobodyknowsme021 1 week ago
@TamirylAuvahn. Me. Sorry.
JohnRSamples 4 weeks ago
Who is the asshole who coughed in the middle of it
TamirylAuvahn 4 months ago 6
wrong
monktrane325 5 months ago
Been reading about McCartney playing a tune called "Petrushka" during his sound checks in Chicago recently, anyone know of this tune?
Tunz909 5 months ago
וואווו !!!
סחטיין עלייך !!
aviramskate 7 months ago
Excellent!
sweetpeariot 7 months ago
Its like the piece cannot be played by a human... I just keep hearing mis-notes over and over, and it ruins the feeling of the music. someone should use a digital audio program to complete his music.
SOSTacoJohnson 10 months ago
@SOSTacoJohnson
Digital Audio Programs have no musicality.
looney1023 6 months ago
@looney1023 good thing you didn't just make an all-encompassing black and white statement about what will be the future of music creation and playing... Kinda... simple minded.
SOSTacoJohnson 6 months ago
Brilliant
SOSTacoJohnson 10 months ago
Too fast? Shut up and read the score, this is the tempo at which this movement is to be played.
CptSchmidt 1 year ago
Wonderful oh yes
deanfergy9933 1 year ago
too bad... i cannot enjoy what he's playing... >.<
poetry4jc 1 year ago
!brilliant
mirisaadon 1 year ago
People love to accuse players performing Stravinsky of playing too slow or too fast. :) The tempo here seems right to me!
meowkie 1 year ago
This is the best rendition by the pianist I've ever heard! :) And in the right tempo, too. That's not easy. ;-)
UrbanPoet 1 year ago
Awesome. I`m learning this version of this piece right now, and I`m so happy to finally find a recording that ISN`T from Trois Movements de Petrouchka.
Great performance, thanks for putting this up. c:
bennidiot 1 year ago
shreddin!
TheMiasickness 1 year ago
this piece is SOOOOOOOOO HARD you cant imagine how hard it is!!!!!!! this guy does a really good job but its still too fast for him because he cant control the dynamics, which is very important for this piece. it must be played "easier" and more soft. only few pianists can do that and play this terribly difficult piece very well.
hotbebimauz 1 year ago 4
this is a re-arranged version of the original.. it is a highly technical piece meant to show off skill, it would be nonsense if THIS version is meant to express the w,e, dance-like feeling, yes, it should sound like a race, as fast as possible, as accurate as possible...
justinneversleep 1 year ago
Hey look, another youtube commentator who has no idea what they're talking about, what a surprise.
This piece, Trois Movements Petrushka, is a seperate composition by Stravinsky dedicated to Artur Rubinstein. It is different from the original Petrushka in many, many ways and cannot be called an arrangement or a transcription. Check around before you post a comment strongly claiming things. This is not a re-arrangement, oh, and the pianist here plays only the 1st of three movements.
JohnEBPiano 1 year ago
looks like either the piano guy is a total egocentric asshole running of stage like that, or he had to take a shit really fast.
drv30 1 year ago
Comment removed
sa1ku2ra3 2 years ago
•• Almost There!!
•• But YUJA WANG Is The Best!!
POPYLOLY8 2 years ago 14
right!
sal50811 2 years ago
as good as Yuja ! But for the recording sound...thats it...
utki17 2 years ago
@POPYLOLY8 i would have to dissagree, Yuja is technically better, but this performance conveys the mood and the initial intention of the piece in much more vivid colours
vspecs 6 months ago
Yes, this is Stravinsky's own arrangement of the ballet out of three movements. The young pianist is playing it to fast and it is supposed to be a dance not a race to the finish and notice it is all the same dynamic. He has to learn through experience the musicality of Stravinsky.
selaromyar 2 years ago 2
Tell me about it. Stravinsky meant for the first line to be dance-like, but he's interpreting it as too fast and technical. The technicality of Stravinsky is implied, not to be shown off.
ClarinetistJuan 2 years ago
Straweenie
Neongrapes 2 years ago
I agree, the tempo is perfect. Is this Stravinsky's own arrangement/reduction? It originally for piano and orchestra, correct?
Sounds amazing, regardless! Great work!
VladekMeyer83 2 years ago
*it was originally.
VladekMeyer83 2 years ago
It's originally for just orchestra (it's a ballet)
I'm not sure if this is Stravinsky's own arrangement...that'd be good to know though :)
Great job too, piano guy!
therabbitsfoot 2 years ago
Too fast? No, this is the proper tempo for this movement. Excellent playing, too!
ProTwoAm 2 years ago 17
damn ... too fast ... i can't play like that =P
momochot 2 years ago
ei the music really is fast.....
and the hands REALLY is fast :O
WhyNne0w 2 years ago
Comment removed
WhyNne0w 2 years ago
Comment removed
WhyNne0w 2 years ago
bravissimo
pablocreate 2 years ago
what hands !!!
PLASTERM66 2 years ago
This is waaay too fast. But still a good performance,
Hervinbalfour 2 years ago 2
Bravo!
jink9127 2 years ago
this is such an amazing piece of music. Played very well, but a little fast for my taste.
Someone said it was total chaos. It has those elements, but that's a good thing. Stravinsky - what a composer.
X factor! You hear this tune then it's in your head for weeks. That's the test
hungrydave1977 2 years ago 2
VERY nice! Excelante! but boy he couldn't get off the stage fast enough! haha oh well. It's NOT total chaos, it's amazing if you listen to the orchestration before this, you will hear the themes being played underneath themes, it's quite magical. Bravo, chap!
TheAfterPipe 2 years ago 2
Total Chaos...(that's not to diminish your playing (which is splendid I'm sure) but I think Stravinsky is bloody overrated.
firebreathone2 3 years ago
이거 실제로 보면 졸라뻑가여!!!!!!!!
내 칭구가 쳐줫는데 ㅜㅜ 우메
O3Ob2 3 years ago
Beast.
Ooftyman 3 years ago
BRAVO!!! How long do you think he learned how to play this? i'm starting on it but i'm stuck on the first 2 pages T_T but i have 6 more months to learn it for a graduation concert =D
Messed up just a little bit in the FCG# key change, but recovered really well!
dodger997 3 years ago
wow!!!
he plays it very fast!
actually too fast.
but great performance!
nahyun1992 3 years ago
he's too fast. he should have slowed it a little bit down to make it sound better but other than that it's great.
Minnischnucki 3 years ago
Bravo!
leedogdog 3 years ago
i love this music
Dimacartoons 3 years ago 3
Bravo!
darkangleda 3 years ago
thanks for this video.. ;)
andigalguitarmansg 3 years ago
VERY Impressive!
Gretchluver1 4 years ago
impressive. good job
fuzzitiger 4 years ago
bravo lahav!! :-)
uvcruv 4 years ago