Added: 4 years ago
From: ZamzarBob
Views: 25,821
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (232)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Laughs, but you have to get stuff even tighter than this if you want it to really be funny.

  • Very funny ...

  • People can't take a joke? What's wrong? I'll bet Coltrane would have laughed his ass off. This is the jazz musicians rick roll.

  • Jerk

  • Raw BS

  • Hey man it's quite clever but you've gotta be careful. John Coltrane was no ordinary cat. He was from a different dimension and his music was and still is like religion to many people. I'm not gonna insult you, but I will ask you to please remove this video.

    Thanks

  • fuck

    

  • TROLOLOLOLOLOL

  • And my favorite part is STILL Elvin Jones' shoes.

  • What The Fuck??? This Is the worst shit ever, you should kill yourself right now. Put a shotgun in your mouth and right before you pull the trigger sneeze causing the shotgun to jerk blowing half of your face off not killing you but leaving a grotesquely deformed face that nobody will recognize then try again when you leave the hospital to finish the job.

  • @fineyoungspecimen I like ur style

    

  • F. U.

  • fuck you

  • lol, I kind of feel Rick Rolled :D

  • I flagged it. If the title was blunt and said that it was a joke that would have been fine and I wouldn't have been disgusted by it.

  • hahahaaa!, I like it though, made me laugh when he goes back and forth with the saxophone, eyes closed and all that feeling... funny, like your sense of humor!

  • You are the guy in High School who I beat up.

  • Ja ja ja ja .. what a fuck animal !

  • This so funny thank you uploader for posting..Coltrane was a man its not like he was God or anything .He wasnt a genius. Niether was Bird. He was a VERY highly practised human being. He wasnt born with the amazing virtuousity he his praised for today . listen to his 40's recordings he made in the navy playing standards like hothouse ect. i dont understand why people have elivated him to saint hood. People have done shred vids on here of Miles Bird and Dizzy ...Why not Trane ?? come one peeps!!!

  • @indaplace2b Both Trane and Bird were highly practiced, but their genius is rooted in the fact that they found new innovative combinations using raw material that was available to everyone else. A genius is someone that looks at what everyone else is looking at, yet develops something new and fresh from it. Genius evolves with time and continued experimentation. Trane's concepts are taught in all of the universities. You are just expressing your ignorance of genius, and the process it requires.

  • @KABRIS1 "I can't see where there's anything fantastic about it all. I put quite a bit of study into the horn, that's true. In fact the neighbors threatened to ask my mother to move once when we were living out West. She said I was driving them crazy with the horn. I used to put in at least 11 to 15 hours a day." <== Birds own words ...Now reguarding Trane who do you know who came up the same time as him (apart from maybe Sonny) who put that much time into the horn for the rest of his life ???

  • @indaplace2b The quality that distinguished Trane and Bird from the others greatly trancended their technical ability on the horn itself, The long arduous hours they put into their instrument was fueled by the improvisational ideas that they were hearing in their head. The way in which they both combined, intervals, scales, and rhythms, was innovative. Achieving technical proficiency on an instrument, through practice, and creating a new musical language,

    are different accomplishments.

  • @indaplace2b bird was being characteristically modest! Mastery of the technical ability to improvise - yes it's practice, but where Coltrane is concerned there's something extra (compare him with bop conservativism of the great Hank Mobley). I've studied Trane for years (I play sax) and keep finding amazing stuff nested in his solos, I think: how the hell did this stuff occur to him? it's easy in retrospect to put it down to "techne"! Idolizing him is one thing but give him the credit he's due.

  • @jazzmunky My Post has nothing to with not giving him credit or him having only good techinque. The points im making is, In my view Coltrane was and amazing Saxophone and probably the best player to have walked the earth ... But he was no genius. He wasnt a saint, a god, and he wasnt above riducule. I too play Sax. I've studied Trane and still do. You wonder how certain things occured to him? He worked harder than any of his peers to find things that handnt been played before on the horn!

  • @indaplace2b Why not concede that Trane was a genius? In your view are there any geniuses in jazz? If so, why not Trane? Perhaps our definition of it differs. As far as I understand it's someone who's extraordinarily creative in a particular field. Part of this is hard work, part is intelligence (though this isn't sufficient for genius, I know plenty of clever people - we judge by results, not the cognitive potential of an individual). For the contribution of Trane I recognise him as a genius.

  • this is about as juvenile, vile and insulting as kenny G playing over top of Satchmo for the Clinton Innauguration. More so really in its content, less so in that its intent is being silly. But if I come to your house and take a dump on your living room carpet, then in your bed, after a day of drinking olive oil, i think that would be equally good taste as this

  • This makes me sad...

  • this is not respectful

  • just too silly.

  • this is utterly disgraceful, whom ever did this in my opinion should be serving prison sentence.....a long sentence

  • lolz. whats even funnier than the video are the people who take this seriously.

  • whomever did this bullshit dubb whith John William Coltrane, may your armpits have the fleas of a Billion Camels

  • Enchilada supreme!

  • More respect to the master please!!!You can do this with everybody else, but his music is to deep for this cheap joke I think...

  • Comment removed

  • this keeps getting funnier and funnier. and i am a HUGE coltrane fan. i've seen this like 5 times over the past year. good job!

  • ,,,,two words: "bullshit"....and "1984" but....I "feel yah" in terms of your contemporary translation"..... just do more work...stop riding..get technically "correct" and study.... listen to the critiques that follow...and with that effort 'understand' PLEASE

  • ,,,,two words: "bullshit"....and "1984"  but....I "feel yah in terms of your translation"..... just do more work...stop riding..get technically "correct" and study.... PLEASE

  • ,,,,two words: "bullshit"....and "1984" but....I "feel yah in terms of your translation"..... just do more work...stop riding..and study.... PLEASE

  • ,,,,two words: "bullshit"....and "1984"

  • this is not a joke , this comes from someone who doesnt know music at all!!!

    and smokes alot of crack!!!

  • Worst video ever!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!

  • This is funny loooooooooooooooool

  • Hahahahaha this made my laugh my ass off HAHAHAHAHA

    lol but naw seriously this is bad

  • Its too bad cas zamzar bob does have a few good videos. But please bob, you are doing a disservice to jazz. And forgive my barbarism, I won't hunt you down or do harm to you. but I will flag your video. good day sir.

  • Its too bad cas zamzar bob does have a few good videos. But please bob, you are doing a disservice to jazz. And forgive my barbarism, I won't hunt you down or do harm to you. but I will flag your video. good day sir.

  • ZamzarBob, I will hunt you down and kill you if you don't take this down. Thanks.

  • The clown who posted this has done IT before. He dubbed some obnoxious dreck to clips of Bird And Dizzy and posted it pawning it off as authentic. STAY AWAY.

  • LOL its in black and white!

  • Please take this video off. It insults all jazz fans of Coltrane. I bet Sanborn would be mad! BTY, is the guy who posted this video dead yet?

  • I don't know why you've done this but you insulted me and you insulted Coltrane. I have made note of your login and will ignore anything else you upload.

  • asshole.

  • Ain't Trane, but it's cool.

  • hardy har har

  • una merda pazzesca

    vergognati

  • Stoopid Fuck.

  • Fuckin' Idiot.

  • please....dont do this anymore. what we are listening here to is david sanborn on alto sax....nothing to do with Jonh Coltrane. Come on man!

  • fool

  • This a fucking disgrace. Period.

  • hahaha nice one, this is rickrolling to the extreme

  • me likey :0)

  • i like it it's funny =P

  • this is just a video and sound its no insult....its looks funny

  • haha

  • what the heck haha. get out of here.

  • this is sacrilegious.

  • The music on this video is obviously bullshit because this is not what he played. You should be horsewhipped.  An insult to all true jazz fans everywhere.

  • @leecool1956 - Insult to everyone who's heard one note played by Coltrane.

  • i'm going to find you and you will die.

  • Hahahahahahahahaha

    Trane is the best, but i have to admit that this is funny

  • lame

  • this is hilarious.

  • You should be banned from youtube for this!!

  • @Peabosvibe420 Agreed . Trane was the man. It's not funny. Fuck this crap

  • @Peabosvibe420 Make that banned from the planet...

  • The cats that actually played this jam would like the credit MF'ka!! Big up 2 the real trane not this imposterized propaganda!!

  • This is desecration to the extreme.

  • even my dead dog knows that this is not trane.

  • time less than well spent...

  • hahaha good joke

  • Wow! I heard that John Coltrane was good, but I had no idea he was that cool. Thank you man this is great!

  • Comment removed

  • nice! i love herb alpert!

  • o man....david sanborn, really?

  • This is a sick joke...

  • LOL...Now all the jazz cats get bent out of shape...

    Good thing you didnt directly compare Trane to Kenny G, you may have gotten hanged hahaha

  • idiots!! hahahahahahaha

  • i gotta admit thats a pretty hip version of tequila

  • nice dave sanborn, but REALLY!

  • hahahahah

  • This is bogus...blaspheme...Coltrane plays tequila?...Get the f**k out of here!

  • what the fuck is this shit?

  • Whoever 'dubbed' this shit music with this vintage video of the master playing, should die a violent and slow death and then, buried deep in an ant hole to have their skin slowly peeled off by millions of ants.

  • @peppersax you mean Masters, and I agree, they should be punished by body guillotine in several non-vital spots before being burned slowly to their death.

    [B^J

  • @peppersax Can't take a joke?

  • @ZackPomerleau seriously lol. This is pretty much a rick roll (might even be worse) xD

  • @saxoman1 Yeah, ahhaha. This isn't sacrilege, sorry, this is just in plain fun.

  • his not coltrane guys his a david sanborn in the album timeagain....theme tequila....its a alto sax sound not tenor lol

  • Do you really think you need to clarify that for everyone?

  • ((: ok, im very serious into jazz music... but i dont see that as offence. i actually had to laugh the first moment i saw this. ^^nice. come on people, dont take this to serious!! (man, is this SANBORN playing tequila? ((; thats so damn funny!!

    great.

    (coltrane OR sanborn thats like eating lubster OR fish sticks (think about that.^^ there can more be interpreted on that than you may think for the first time)

  • u FUCKING ASS WIPE!~

  • whoever posted this is an expleted deleted

  • "Expletive"

  • shiit u re shit!!!!

  • i wasted 1 minute of my life looking at the beginning of this blasphemy and writing this message.. thanx dumbass

  • This is such slandourous BULLSHIT it is not even funny!! - How dare you be-little Coltrane in this fashion!!

  • why?

  • This video fails on so many scales.

  • ?? what do u mean this video is awesome !

  • SO nice!! especially the note to the video "sorry.. its out of sync sometimes" ((: thats hilarious!!! thanks man

  • this video OWNS!!! what are u talkin about!!?!?!

  • if i find you i will bleed you real slow..you will pay the ultimate price for such blasphemy

  • im going to go kill myself now, goodbye.

  • dumbass!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Go fuck around with some of your home movies, or some animal bloopers or something. This kind of footage is beyond you

  • Dave Sandborn

  • wow. I would have never thought someone would disgrace Coltrane like that.

  • fuck

  • No way....

  • Wow, this is Sweet ! Usually I listen to like Coldplay and John Mayer so I don't know much about jazz but this is awesome. Who is this Coltrane guy. Is he still making albums ?

  • lol

  • wikipedia

  • ...Coltrane passed away 42 years ago

  • TOO SOON!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    (lol)

  • holy shit,this is funny shit

  • Comment removed

  • very funny.

  • Wow!! Elvin sounds terrific here! lmfao

  • I was irritated at first, but now I'm doubled over with laughter! Reading the comments makes me laugh even harder! This is hilarious!

  • I hear an alto but see a tenor

  • Not Trane.

  • Horrible but hilarious. You have way too much time on your hands! (How about Jimi doing 'Room 335??')

  • or Room 222

  • Come on! down-right sinful...Trane would never stoop to this level. We all sensed this. did we not? Let Trane be Trane and learn to appreciate his work...if you can Sincerely, Fred

  • Dett Ding iss geil,echt PSIchiatrisch!

  • This ain't Trane for sure.

  • no possiblility. not john coltrane by any means. this is some fucked up shit.

  • I know what's wrong with ZamzarBob. He hates jazz!

  • I think its funny! but  I agree with

    thereagauze that perhaps "Coltrane shreds" would be a better title

  • Isn't this Dave Sanborn? No mistaking that sound. And no mistaking this video as a fraud. You'd do better telling people that a Chipmunks Album was Etta James.

  • My wife is still over here jammin' to it, though. With our 11 mo. old son. Lil dude's gonna be a sax player like daddy!

  • That is, without a doubt, Trane.. there's no mistaking that sound! And also, that's the former bass player for Celine Dion.. This is some priceless footage!!

  • he usually played this for an encore...

  • this is a sacrilege. you should be chopped up into tiny pieces starting with the toes while still alive. you deserve the worst possible suffering not yet imagined. this is not a joke.

  • how do you make a tenor sound like an alto? only the trane could do that!

  • Come on guys its funny...have a sense of humor. Coltrane was the master, Sanborn is talented as well though. Its a joke. Come on

  • Asshole

  • shit post this as "Coltrane Shreds" or something, don't get people's hopes up

  • Please, guys... Have some sense of humour.. Haha

  • Fuck you zamzar

  • What a bunch of tripe! More suitable for Sponge

    Bob!

  • Oh, I didn't know this was a joke. You need to be locked up in a max-security institution off the coast of New Zealand.

  • WTF!!!! This isn't Coltrane...this is David Sanborn playing Tequila from his album Time Again...loser...

  • this is bullshit. not Coltrane. take it off. what the fuck!

  • OMG now this is what im talking about! I knew coltrane could play some real stuff and instead of that stale bullshit he was playing before. Thank You ZamzarBob for bringing the REAL JAZZ to the masses!!! we need more like it!!!

  • delete this video, now

  • lame... fuck david sanborn or whomever that is... that "Vigil" footage is what you guys are looking for.. oh my god that shit is from another planet. or deep within the spirit of this one, sometimes i cant tell

  • Wow THis is some funny shit !! you's a fool

  • i pray for you whom ever uploaded this crap !!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • kenny g much vid poster?

  • OMG thats soo cool! I never thought Trane could play like that! I can totally see the Johhny Griffin influence, and how Brecker was influenced from that!

  • prick that is an insult to any jazz musician as john coltrane was one of the best man its not even funny its sick

  • ok people yes joke on this persons behalf...........but it totally got most of us come on admitt it hahaha

    oh and at least they posted the music of David Sanborn Michael Breckers #1 sax bud both great fans of Coltrane

  • Sanborn is a cheeseball, and this isn't funny, its just annoying

  • A rick-roll would have been a more appropriate approach. To do something like this with Trane is not cool at all.

  • you're a complete idiot

  • fucking lame, dude.

  • what a dumb ass post and an insult to John...

  • musics good thow.

  • try a difrent aproach ok!!!!

  • I don't know what you were trying to do here, but I don't see any humor in it. And I'm trying to, believe me!!!

  • hahahahaha...very funny. this isn't coltrane..this is the smooth jazz crap...sounds like the kenny g's stuff...horrible music to my taste....if you wanna hear smooth jazz at its best get any jeff lorber album.Peace

  • This made my day.

  • laaaaaaaaaaaammmmmmeeeeee

  • HAHAHAHA THATS HEAPS FUNNY

  • Acknowledgement

    Resolution

    Pursuance

    Psalm...

    TEEEEQUILA!

  • i was mad at first then i began to laugh my ass off!! lol!!! maybe because im high but this shit is funny as hell when you just have a sence of humor.

  • Bullshit

  • Sanborn is great let me say that first, but to dub him over Coltrane and mislead us is comical and ireverant, well done you got me, but a horrid overdub!