Huh... this whole magic truth and false talking is getting me a HEADACHE!! And especially the SPOILING PARTS that people say! But thats okay... im very stupid at getting clues and jokes and whatnot... >.>
Beato isn't an alternative at all, because she can't win. It was proclaimed with absolute certainty. And you misread the ??? if you think there is any kind of alliance or scheme between Bern and 34.
And Witch's Tanabata is only an ad hominem attack. Just because Bern is a huge jerk there doesn't mean that she's evil or that her goals are evil.
Also, I've seen no evidence that Bern plans to leave Battler alone with no family. She guaranteed Ange the opposite, actually.
You don't know things very well. Were Beato's chances declared in either red or gold? No. She can still win, just in a weird way.
Bern is a being higher than humans. She regards the people as playthings. The only reason she did that was to get a piece on the board and give Battler another chance. She really doesn't care about anyone but herself.
Episode 5, Erika is her piece. And Erika's a sadistic bitch. Erika seems to be the opponent for now, but we really don't know what's going on.
'But we really don't know what's going on'? You sound very sure of yourself there, right?
And I know a couple Episode 5 spoilers myself, thanks to bloody stupid YouTube spoilers in the comments, and I don't think you're right on Beato's chances.
And you've proven Bern is self-centered, something I do not disagree with, but not evil. Someone can be self-centered without deliberately setting out to benefit from the suffering of others.
We don't. The only one who understands everything about the Witch's Game is Battler. That's how he was able to use Gold Truth. Everything else is still shrouded in mystery, such as who Beato really is in this situation, and the true motives of Lambda and Bern.
And going through episode 5 (can't read it) it seems incredibly obvious that Bern is doing everything possible to make Battler go through hell.
Beato will not stay dead. That's just bad writing.
Not that I disagree, but then we'd have to enter in a discussion of what's evil. Sure Bernkastel is having a blast in this game (or so I would suppose), but does that make her evil? Then again she IS helping Battler, but does that make her good?
As for Bernkastels benefit, it is fun. Fun she gains from watching their battle and/or interfering (playing) with it.
With the sole Knox rules the possibility of Beatrice is reduced to almost nothingness.
But is very clear that the Theme of Umineko no Naku koro ni Chiru is not so much about denying or not the magic, but ruling out the false truths.
In Episode 5 Erika just try to continue the role of Battler denying the witch, but in reality she is not interested in the truth, she just create false logics and with that false truths.
The theme of Umineko is love. Battler's trying to find out the truth no matter what, but isn't willing to accept the Witch and Magic as truth. Erika's a bitch who took on an extreme even Battler wouldn't touch.
Battler would be willing to accept magic if there's no other choice and if magic actually happens to be the truth.
In EP5 the knox commandments almost automatically destroy the possibility for any supernatural occurrence in the game, at least if it is related with the murders.
Also the role of Batter in Umineko no naku koro ni Chiru is greatly reversed, and as of now it seems that the game is no longer about Battler denying or accepting magic, because even at the end of EP5 Battler understood the mystery and became a sorcerer.
Battler wouldn't accept magic at all during the first 4 arcs. He's figured out how magic works, so he's willing to accept it if it is the truth. Erika won't accept magic no matter what, she's too far on the Mystery side.
Battler's main goal is to figure out why this stuff is happening, not how. He already knows how, but now it's just about him trying to uncover what his "sin" was that drove his entire family to their deaths.
I shall deny that in red... Or I would if Youtube had that option.
Bernkastel didn't guaranteed Ange the survival of her family. She only gave her the possibility of revenge and the hope of a small miracle.
Beato was fighting a lost battle since the beginning. There are no witches in Rokkenjima. She probably said that herself in red to deny EVA-Beatrice in EP3
Well, that's not true. Since pretty much the entire episode was an act, nothing she supposedly would say in red, but didn't (i.e. we didnt see), is worthy of any credit. This reasoning is useful not only in this episode, though, but mainly.
Please note that I'm not disagreeing that she might be able to say it in red, I'm challenging the statement that she did do that then - such conclusion would be a false positive which, as discussed, therefore, might be intentionally induced.
Beatrice is the best alternative, since she states(or at least thinks) in red that she wants to die. Bern doesn't care how she wins, even if that means Battler is all alone with no family
. And since she's allied with Lambda, who also doesn't think Beatrice can win, it seems to me that they plan to leave Battler in pieces while they go screw each other after screwing up his life.
Eva was willing, heck, BEGGING Ange for her to accept her as her mother after Episode 3, and Bernkastel flat-out lied about the possibility of her family coming home, just for her own amusement.
I downloaded it from a torrent a long time ago, so I don't know if it's dead or not, so you can try looking for it if you want. Or use a YouTube to mp3 program/website and convert this video...
Actually, I think I might still have the mp3 on one of my hard drives, I'll go check later and upload it for you.
Am I the only one who wants Bern to win O_O
khfanmuffin 8 months ago
@khfanmuffin I hope so.
EphidelDarkheart 6 months ago
出題編で一番好きなEDです!
うpありがとうございます。
katouke4 9 months ago
basically, umineko is the definition of getting trolled.
enough said. thumbs up ?
CanadianNazi 1 year ago 10
Why cant Bern get bitchslapped?
;_;
DOES SHEEE?
Well, I havent read past the Gaap making a mark in George's head, so yeah.
DOES SHEEE?
Darkever84 2 years ago 5
I'll do it myself if I have to.
nyuurocks 2 years ago
Huh... this whole magic truth and false talking is getting me a HEADACHE!! And especially the SPOILING PARTS that people say! But thats okay... im very stupid at getting clues and jokes and whatnot... >.>
HanakoFujita 2 years ago
Comment removed
harumatsuterumi 2 years ago
Beato isn't an alternative at all, because she can't win. It was proclaimed with absolute certainty. And you misread the ??? if you think there is any kind of alliance or scheme between Bern and 34.
And Witch's Tanabata is only an ad hominem attack. Just because Bern is a huge jerk there doesn't mean that she's evil or that her goals are evil.
Also, I've seen no evidence that Bern plans to leave Battler alone with no family. She guaranteed Ange the opposite, actually.
Vaxidd0 2 years ago
You don't know things very well. Were Beato's chances declared in either red or gold? No. She can still win, just in a weird way.
Bern is a being higher than humans. She regards the people as playthings. The only reason she did that was to get a piece on the board and give Battler another chance. She really doesn't care about anyone but herself.
Episode 5, Erika is her piece. And Erika's a sadistic bitch. Erika seems to be the opponent for now, but we really don't know what's going on.
shunkwugga 2 years ago 2
'But we really don't know what's going on'? You sound very sure of yourself there, right?
And I know a couple Episode 5 spoilers myself, thanks to bloody stupid YouTube spoilers in the comments, and I don't think you're right on Beato's chances.
And you've proven Bern is self-centered, something I do not disagree with, but not evil. Someone can be self-centered without deliberately setting out to benefit from the suffering of others.
Vaxidd0 2 years ago 3
We don't. The only one who understands everything about the Witch's Game is Battler. That's how he was able to use Gold Truth. Everything else is still shrouded in mystery, such as who Beato really is in this situation, and the true motives of Lambda and Bern.
And going through episode 5 (can't read it) it seems incredibly obvious that Bern is doing everything possible to make Battler go through hell.
Beato will not stay dead. That's just bad writing.
shunkwugga 2 years ago
No, she's evil. Pure goddamn evil. She recreates Ange's death just so she and Lambda can have a good laugh at Battler's rage.
Of course, she tried avoiding for the most part provoking him into using his true power. Which failed to stop it in the hidden tea party, obviously.
I could go on.
KawaiiDesuNekoBCSK 2 years ago
Not that I disagree, but then we'd have to enter in a discussion of what's evil. Sure Bernkastel is having a blast in this game (or so I would suppose), but does that make her evil? Then again she IS helping Battler, but does that make her good?
As for Bernkastels benefit, it is fun. Fun she gains from watching their battle and/or interfering (playing) with it.
RafaelEnvoy 2 years ago 2
But I just can see how Beatrice can win.
With the sole Knox rules the possibility of Beatrice is reduced to almost nothingness.
But is very clear that the Theme of Umineko no Naku koro ni Chiru is not so much about denying or not the magic, but ruling out the false truths.
In Episode 5 Erika just try to continue the role of Battler denying the witch, but in reality she is not interested in the truth, she just create false logics and with that false truths.
Yetanotherytuser 2 years ago
The theme of Umineko is love. Battler's trying to find out the truth no matter what, but isn't willing to accept the Witch and Magic as truth. Erika's a bitch who took on an extreme even Battler wouldn't touch.
Battler would be willing to accept magic if there's no other choice and if magic actually happens to be the truth.
shunkwugga 2 years ago 2
Well, that was truth until EP4.
In EP5 the knox commandments almost automatically destroy the possibility for any supernatural occurrence in the game, at least if it is related with the murders.
Also the role of Batter in Umineko no naku koro ni Chiru is greatly reversed, and as of now it seems that the game is no longer about Battler denying or accepting magic, because even at the end of EP5 Battler understood the mystery and became a sorcerer.
Yetanotherytuser 2 years ago
Battler wouldn't accept magic at all during the first 4 arcs. He's figured out how magic works, so he's willing to accept it if it is the truth. Erika won't accept magic no matter what, she's too far on the Mystery side.
Battler's main goal is to figure out why this stuff is happening, not how. He already knows how, but now it's just about him trying to uncover what his "sin" was that drove his entire family to their deaths.
shunkwugga 2 years ago
" with out love, the truth can't be seen"
right?
vaan123456789 2 years ago 5
@shunkwugga battler actually has already accepted magic, he's only fighting for denining magic on those two days on rokkenjiima
rambo171993 1 year ago
I shall deny that in red... Or I would if Youtube had that option.
Bernkastel didn't guaranteed Ange the survival of her family. She only gave her the possibility of revenge and the hope of a small miracle.
Beato was fighting a lost battle since the beginning. There are no witches in Rokkenjima. She probably said that herself in red to deny EVA-Beatrice in EP3
neh1234 2 years ago 25
Well, that's not true. Since pretty much the entire episode was an act, nothing she supposedly would say in red, but didn't (i.e. we didnt see), is worthy of any credit. This reasoning is useful not only in this episode, though, but mainly.
Please note that I'm not disagreeing that she might be able to say it in red, I'm challenging the statement that she did do that then - such conclusion would be a false positive which, as discussed, therefore, might be intentionally induced.
RafaelEnvoy 2 years ago
bern dat ungrateful son of a .....
i will hope battler totally kick those witches asses for all the abuse and sadness they have done to his family.
But a least in ep 4 they show that he cannot lose
MrBernkastel 2 years ago 19
Actually, they specifically said "Beato cannot win" . Not meaning Battler can win.
However, with Episode 5's opening, it makes me think Battler has caught on to their scheme, and is putting a stop to it.
KawaiiDesuNekoBCSK 2 years ago
you right that playing the game forever part.
Don"t get hope up the next episode is battler" s counterattack but like kai there will a bad end until the last arc.
I think bern is gonna to be scratch free at the end
MrBernkastel 2 years ago
Nah, I think Bern's going to lose. Well, I guess I should say I hope so. >:((
KawaiiDesuNekoBCSK 2 years ago 3
Battler's played Platinum Angel.
shunkwugga 2 years ago
@MrBernkastel don't know if you have read yet the other episode, but prepare for a major change :D
rambo171993 1 year ago
Don't be so harsh on Bern. She's better than the alternatives.
Vaxidd0 2 years ago
Better?
Hah, I don't think so.
Beatrice is the best alternative, since she states(or at least thinks) in red that she wants to die. Bern doesn't care how she wins, even if that means Battler is all alone with no family
. And since she's allied with Lambda, who also doesn't think Beatrice can win, it seems to me that they plan to leave Battler in pieces while they go screw each other after screwing up his life.
KawaiiDesuNekoBCSK 2 years ago 2
Gah, I moved the period.
KawaiiDesuNekoBCSK 2 years ago
Dude, have you READ Witches' Tanabata? Bern is even worse than Beato!
shunkwugga 2 years ago 6
Hey look, it's Ange and the bitch that made her life end up that way.
KawaiiDesuNekoBCSK 2 years ago 7
inorite?
lolwhatsthat 2 years ago
Meh. Atleast she's fixing it? I'm not even sure it's her doing anyway, not this time.
Suchaku 2 years ago
Did you read The Witches' Tanabata?
Eva was willing, heck, BEGGING Ange for her to accept her as her mother after Episode 3, and Bernkastel flat-out lied about the possibility of her family coming home, just for her own amusement.
KawaiiDesuNekoBCSK 2 years ago
I just finished episode 1 (demo version, though) last night, so I'm really interested in who all these characters are...
/waits for the full version I ordered to arrive. DX
Twila27 2 years ago
Do you know where I can download this song? XD
tokyorabbiit 2 years ago
I downloaded it from a torrent a long time ago, so I don't know if it's dead or not, so you can try looking for it if you want. Or use a YouTube to mp3 program/website and convert this video...
Actually, I think I might still have the mp3 on one of my hard drives, I'll go check later and upload it for you.
Berilyn 2 years ago
wow! :DD if you could, that would be great! thanks so much!
tokyorabbiit 2 years ago
この曲大好きです!
いい歌ですよね+。゚φ(ゝω・`○)+。゚
alicehime1212 2 years ago
Love this song! <3
XDZ 3 years ago
?の罪は捨てて
その指に絡みつく希望の糸もそう
もう辿ることはできないから
絶望を楽しみなさい
ただ受け止めればいい真実
だけどゆるやかな罠に潜む
おぼろげな記憶が蝕む前に
comedieaaa 3 years ago 4
?の罪は=淡く薄い望みは、かと。
harumatsuterumi 2 years ago 3
あなたの命の火を燃やしなさい
諦めた時点ですべてが終わりを迎える
もう離さない掴んだ幻のあなたを
この眼に見えるものが真実ならば
もう迷わない答えは移ろいの中に
この激しい痛みと共にあるのならば
孤独光希望は捨てて
その瞳に映るこの不安の糸もそう
もう戻ることはできないから
快楽を楽しみなさい
comedieaaa 3 years ago 4
Comment removed
harumatsuterumi 2 years ago
ただ諦めばいいこの先
なんて穏やかな罠に紛れ
素敵な世界が崩れる前に
わたしの命の火を奪いなさい
諦める時点ですべてを捨て去るならば
もう離れない抱き寄せた幻のあなたを
この眼にみえるものが偽りならば
もう迷わない答えは揺らめきの中に
この激しい痛みと共にあるのだから
comedieaaa 3 years ago 4
この切なさは砕けた幻のあなたを
この手に触れることが叶わないから
もう探さない答えは真実の中に
この激しい痛みと共にあるのだから
もう離さない掴んだ幻のあなたを
この眼に見えるものが真実ならば
もう迷わない答えは移ろいの中に
この激しい痛みと共にあるのならば
comedieaaa 3 years ago 4
うpありです!
raia1992 3 years ago 2
Cant stop listening to this song... *o*
Aurorita 3 years ago 3