Andrew Garcia * Sugar Were Going Down * - Top 24 American Idol 2010 Performance

[SynysterKezia]

Also, he said "gun"...

[SynysterKezia]

Not a fan of his style, but  I guess he's okay

[jimbaway]

he was a lot better than they gave him credit for

[erichw23]

They lost the rock part

[KrakenSkullz]

OMG NIGAHIGA!!!!!! his buddy!!

[Stealthkill117]

He got voted off because he didnt sing country or some other gay shit

[Bynbyn101]

Not really a American Idol fan but I found Andrew through Ryan Higa and Chester See and I think he killed this song. They made a mistake back in 2010 by voting him off.

[Leodachef1]

FOB best on da world. !!!

[shander29]

I liked this a lot... not sure its been done better

[kouyokato]

3:52 he's like..shut up bitch....

[matthewteabag]

the background band fucked it up

[BebePieGreen234]

Best Is For Last<3

[KBetts21]

SWOG

[rpdizzy09]

its fall out boy

[TeeshJay]

Same season as Casey James? I love his song "Let's Don't Call It A Night". This season was crazy good.

[fobgurly]

Not hating, I love this guy, but I didn't like this cover :/

[videogirlsk]

inspired to watch him again after watching ryan's (nigahiga) new video <3 YTF!!!

[missmeryll]

he's now part of ytf! :)

[Ang62198]

SIMON NEEDS TO GET THAT TAMPON OUT OF HIS ASS! HE SHOULD OF WON!!!!!

[xoxochayanne]

AMERICAN IDOL crushes your dream,

and this guy goes on waaaaaay better than Justin Bieber and his puberty voice.

[itzclaudiaa]

and who knew he would be a part of YTF

[luvXhateXsolo]

YTF ♥

[psychotsunade]

I am a diehard Overcast Kid, and I approve this message.

[reeooww]

@elm1456 seriously? lol did you watch the beginning of the video? it shows his wife and child..

[luvXhateXsolo]

@elm1456 no idiot.

[SANDROSCHULZE]

Po como alguem não gosta do som desse cara, ele é ótimo muito bom mesmo...

[jimbaway]

i actually thought this was really good, better than most of the other people who sang

[AndroidXShadow]

niga higa

[fraserelliottguitar]

Lol "Fall Out Boys" in description. Fail.

[contadaisabela]

Did he win?

[theann111]

I loved how he sang this. I think its kind of an annoying song when fall out boy sings it. But Andrew turned it into a softer song. It's sounds better that way

[EmilyRR99]

@theann111 You can't say that the original song is annoying, it doesn't make sense and it's dissing Fall Out Boy, which is stupid because without them he wouldn't have been able to sing this.

Just say you think he did a better job.

[slipknotowns23]

i rather have this guy then justin bieber

[headong909]

bbbbbbbooooooooooooorrrrrrrrrr­rrriiiiiiiiiiiiiinnnnnnnnnnnng­gggggggggg!!!

[amyclark68]

YTF!

[ScoobyBaseball]

You can tell that the dude at 1:14 was jammin silently to this in his head, lol.

[00alejandravzz]

BORING

[kithboy123]

A LIL Bit Higher Pitch And He well Sounded Like Patrick

[RILEYisFLY]

yah fuck simon

[MrMichaeljudd]

that songs not meant to be played acousticly? tell the people who wrote the song it wasnt and they will send you the video where they did it themselves, you dumb bitch

[RmNaNtCbScRrn]

IF SIMON COWELL SAYS IT WASN'T GOOD ENOUGH. ITS BECAUSE IT WASNT GOOD ENOUGH! he's the best judge ever.. and you need to trust in his judgments

[marquesgoncalves]

@RmNaNtCbScRrn Yes, Cowell is our master and we should always respond to his commands

[exTstorm]

it's not that he's bad it's just the song don't suit his voice

[InDira11394]

i love this performance.. what's so wrong?

[naomi13jf]

whenever i hear bruno mars it reminds me of andrew garcia's awsomeness

[RSBLACKVEIL]

WTH did he do to the song? the song isn't meant to be played that slow, as if it were a love song. He really did screw that up. A little faster tempo would have made that performance amazing.

[tacotom39]

i love how he makes it his own aqnd stfu it isent ment to be played acoustically, pat stump originally write the song on an acoustic guitar

[tacotom39]

i love how he makes it his own

[piratesvsninjas666]

lol 0:30

[edunavia182]

Im not an asshole but i kinda agree with the judges... He sings really good and i love the song but i personally think that his voice doesnt fit the song

[Snowinhell09]

@edunavia182 His voice would never have fit the song if he kept it as the original version. but he didnt he made it HIS OWN and made the SONG SUIT HIS VOICE. The judges said that the song isnt meant to be original but the band themselves made an acoustic version of the song. And honestly that was the best version of the song i have ever heard and i want to hear a full recording of it.

[edunavia182]

@Snowinhell09 Well that's why i said it was my personal opinion

[jfp5646]

I guess American Idol producers purposely filter out Asian competitors. How sad, because I support the show. When will American Idol stop being Caucasian/Black Idol, I'll never know.

[senho130111]

@jfp5646 andrew garcia is mexican.

[Ticimonster]

@jfp5646 Lol. His last name is Garcia. Do you really think hes asian?

[LadyBUGG1213]

@Ticimonster So many of my Asian friends actually have the last name Garcia

[ajaykeer23939]

not a good song for his voice type...... OUCH

[tacioii]

que mierda es esto... frases vacias y sin sentido las del jurado

[alltimelowfan21]

Patrick should judge! 

[lllIIllIIllIIIlIIlII]

I just think there will never be an ASIAN especially Filipino American Idol. All those Pinoys they had are GREAT and TALENTED. I just don't know what's the problem.

[SquishyTaira]

Bless C: 

[RyanTheAdvocate]

Not original? Has Simon heard the original song? He killed that shit!

[240cookie]

that was amazing, shut up simon he was good. i'm being true i though he kind of sounded like patrick stump from FOB just alittle.

[SuperBigmodder]

hes a bitch he got my cuz eliminated

[iluvgerardway99]

Eh. He has an AMAZING and UNIQUE voice... But this song... it wasn't for him...

[eightyyeightkeys]

best cover of this song, cudve gone without the background music though

[giggshenrik]

12 people went down in an earlier round...

[Paulsasleepwalker]

I think he's in Wiz Khalifa's "Black & Yellow" music video at 2:37? :3

[zECA02468]

omg! WTF!! He was freakin amazing xD

he made a slower version and it was beautiful!

he did a great cover, FINE! they have to get over it..

if he did that cover everytime, that would b REALLY boring and would shown any development

[191147cali]

this guy could sing keep it up bro.

[Kazekuiga]

Yea, i know they were wrong for not picking him but if you hear the original song and his song , you can tell alot of difference. Not because of the acoustic , the way he played the song is "weird". Just listen to it alot of times then you'll hear it. Anyway it was a nice acoustic cover. XD

[jennelovesjames]

I can see why this isn't the song for him. This song makes him sound mediocre when he has quite a unique and amazing voice.

[jingrl89]

FOB bassist Pete Wentz tweeted at Idol host Ryan Seacrest, saying, "I think he killed it. Team Andrew Garcia."

'Nuff said.

[xhead246]

@jingrl89 It'd be better if Patrick had said that because he's the one who actually sings it.

[imbeat]

@jingrl89 he also tweeted his penis, so take what you want from that

[michaelyonyon]

they were right, this isnt the song for him.

[chanceloves]

i am the only person that i know that loved this performance and the song i have saved everywhere. i totally loved it i listen to it all the time. and this song was meant to played exactly the way he sang it.

[chanceloves]

i am the only person that i know that loved this performance and the song i have saved everywhere. i totally loved it i listen to it all the time. and this song was meant to played exactly the way he sang it.

[jellofast]

simon has eyeliner on

[freakypanda8bacon]

this is definitely not forgettable. i sing this to myself all the time, the exact way he sang it lol

[MacChink]

not gonne lie, this cover is wack

[ak123456p]

Judges have issues, this was way better than the speed up, over produced "original

It sounds very singer song writery and I love that.

[GerardWayJr]

Frankly, I agree that it wasn't that great. It wasn't bad, but it wasn't REALLY GREAT or anything. I certainly wouldn't pay to see him.

[ISkellerI]

Loaded GOD complex, GOD complex not gun. Gah :(

[biddykins]

@ISkellerI 'Loaded GOD complex', really? Fuck right off, it's obviously 'gun', every single lyric in the song points to it being gun, and not god. God makes no sense in any way.

[ISkellerI]

@biddykins Pete confirmed it was god.

And God Complex does make sense actually.

A god complex is a non-clinical term generally used to describe an individual who consistently believes he or she can accomplish more than is humanly possible.

So before you start trolling,g et your facts right kid.

[LobsomOverlord]

okay. how is the arrangement strange? i mean, i loved it, but all other critisisms aside, i was completely like, blown away at the awesomeness of an acoustic version of this song, i thought it was freakin' brilliant.

[NarwhalsWinAtLife]

This used to be my favorite song when I was youunger, so it will forever have a special place in my heart, and I love this cover, maybe as much as the original.

Andrew should've won, America is stupid.

[MysteryPisser]

this is such a good arrangment. The judges really got it wrong that time

[MarissaH22]

AMAZING! I love how he flips songs like this!!!

[rspkingdude]

The only problem with this song is he said we are going down town. It's down, down.

[xXxRunningstarxXx]

andrew rocks. he shoulda won or at least got too top two. screw the judges

[ilyxb00]

(: it's cool how he's from youtube, too. & it's cool how I met him <3 I even have a video for it to remember and keep with me :]

[Alltimemaineblg]

some of the judges dont even know or arent familiar with this song .. Andrew Garcia made a great rendition with this song . Wtf are the judges talking about

[dchou168899]

man i really like this rendition.. its smooth and different

i dont really get how ALL the judges hate this.

i mean simon hates almost everything, and randy thinks everything is pitchy, just a bit flat

but still HOW IS THIS NOT ORGINIAL!!!!!!

[domdom87]

i dont think the judges really 'got' his whole style. personally i love his covers and this rendition as well. coolest guy with the coolest girlfriend sporting the coolest hair doing the coolest fall out boy cover.

[xhead246]

eh.

[mgcustado06]

IDK but I liked this. It's weird why the judges didn't like it.

[beezneez911]

I love you sooooooo much dude!!!!!

[mxauger]

This was great !!! I wish he would make a full version

[onefineeagle]

I loved this from the first moment I heard it. I must admit I had never heard the original version of this song. I went and found the original version, and I thought it was crap. I would have never liked this song without Andrew.

[leeeshalicious]

i like how he skipped the verse that says "wishing to be the friction in your jeans"

[Queela54321]

i like ur voice but i dont like how u massacred the song... u have a uniqu voice (i like patricks better srry im crushing). im with simon!!!!!!

[99andredoria99]

i agree great great version

[Kyder]

Eh. Not the best song choice. Had he chosen something more "wow", I think he would have done better in the competition. Though he did sing this well.

[BabyStandByMe]

Before I start, you should know I am a huge FOB fan.

1. The arrangment was kind of weird, but I respect him for taking a risk.

2. At the same time, however, the cover was not that great. His voice really does not match the song.

3. There are some GREAT acoustic versions of this song!

[Pattynakazone]

@BabyStandByMe The guy of FOB loved that version! he said on twitter that andrew killed the song in the good way! and pu teamandrewgarcia so shhhh

[hbmonster52392]

@BabyStandByMe you saying you're a huge FOB fan discredits you from making any musical statement

[minutes2midnite]

@hbmonster52392 HahhAHAH gottt emmmm.

[bobnos]

is everyone on the judging panel a lil dummy... this was one of his best! I liked this better then strait up!

i think it was from here where he didnt pick it up as much... except he did pull it back a lil with another song i cant remember.

but seriously they saying that this wasnt original enough? he put a complete switch on the song "like strait up".shouldn't be played acoustically? well then argue with simon about being original.what shouldn't he done sing the exact song?!

bleh AI sucks

[joeysab123]

Did that skinny crack whore next to Simon just say that this sone is never meant to be played acousticly?? I think that proves my point on why I just can't watch this show. Seriously, that sounded nowhere close to a rational thought. Five stars for the sone though!

[LXISMOMMY]

i think its great

[TheFifthTake]

I like his first few songs but this..was not his brightest idea..

[26PlayDoh16]

Shut up Simon! I Dig your tunes AG!!!

[TheWizarddufreak]

Allen (I think that's her name) Shouldn't insult on the song because she SUNG with Fall Out Boy

[Kiljan137]

they need to stop slapping the table it messes up the audio.

[zaboomafoo323]

HE GOT THAT EARING AT H&MMMM

[rachelvwalker22]

this is my favorite performance of his, the judge had some issues!!!

he is really good

[pengu2099]

Thats 6 more people that accidentally pressed the dislike button!

Get it together people!

[tepperrocksthis16]

i love andrew garcia! i just love the way he remakes songs with his guitar! forget what simon said

[levantos]

This guy isn't a Karaoke singer like everyone else you see on here, he has genuine talent. He'll blow up with real publicity, I'd listen to his music.

[tyjsell]

AG is incredible. He didn't win for reasons that are not relative to talent. No worries. Support him by showing up at the tour. BTW; the judges are just 4 people that are by no means perfect or the final say.

[nathancourt]

This Fall Out Boy song was one of my favorites but I’ve got to say I actually like Andrew’s version better. That being said, I think the judges this year were all over the place. When Andrew stuck to his unique style and sound, he was criticized for being safe and boring: When he took the judges advice and tried to sing out of his comfort zone, he got ripped on. I'm disappointed he didn't make the top 3 but he's still extremely gifted and I hope he has a long and prosperous career!

[mahir100]

what kind of drugs do the judges take?

[3dgflames]

i hate how when the first judge to talk is always backed up by the other ones. if simon said it was amazing then the others would

[ispankmymonkey555]

i want to hear simon sing im pretty sure he sounds like shit

[xelizabethdang]

What are the judges talking about ? Andrews rendition was amazingg !

[selenna1995]

He should've totally made it farther than he did... but no, freaking Casie What's his face made it D<

[babblan981]

omg, i was about to shit myself out of anger when the judges underestimated this as much as they did! I mean, the guy's freakin awesome!

[NguyenGiGi]

dude, xcept for Straight up, every single time, the freaking judges would splash sumthing at hiim. HE IS AWESOMEEE

[NeverShoutSellOut]

I personally blame the background singers and extra instruments. It doesn't fit. I don't know, if it all doesn't fit, it can kill you. They just need to kill the backgorund stuff a bit more. (Does that make sense?)

[johnstark9]

peter wentz of fall out boy tweeted that andrew "killed it" . american idol is rigged the judges read scripts look at andrews audition and look at simon hes reading.

[madden09guy]

I loved This Version I also liked his version Of You Give ME Something

[taylorluckeroth]

andrews amazing but it was a poor choice of a song but he's still amazing

[noesis121]

In retrospect, probably the most under-rated performance of the entire season.

[teacherHATER031]

judges, wtf? i thought it was awesome!

[horseygirljane]

i loved his impersonation of him trying not to cry after he made the top 24! ha he's so funny

[lfcfan1231]

my second favourite live performance by him after Forever

[PreVaylMusic]

these judge are freaking weird he twisted the song and it fit they never heard the damn song its a rock song and can easily be song as an acoustic, freaking idiots these judges sometimes

[wombocomboftw]

damn hes good! i think its either gonna be him or casey

[littlebuster2323]

holy shit. im holding that same ibanez electric acoustic in my hand.

[skyblue471]

How could they be dissapointed?? It was amazing :) arggg the judges

[Hello2Mzalladatish]

it sucked that he got elimiated he was brilliant....he is gonna turn out like Clay(minus the gay) and get a deal even though he didnt win

[jasminemanak]

GOD HES AMAZINNNGG

[Teaxas13]

i luv his voice hate how he ruined my favorite song

[xXShaYnXx]

how the fxck is this forgettable? It's the only song I actually remember hearing from that week. I don't remember what anyone else sang.

[GerardWayJr]

@xXShaYnXx That's because you like the song. XD

[GerardWayJr]

I don't think it's accurate to say the song isn't meant to be played acoustically. It's fine acoustic, it just isn't meant to be competed with like that.

[CyreckX]

@GerardWayJr Ture ture but i would pay to see him ^^

[GerardWayJr]

@CyreckX What is "ture?"

[CyreckX]

@GerardWayJr Lmao u wud b trolling over a smiple spelling mistake..

[GerardWayJr]

@CyreckX Go back to 3rd Grade English, honey pie.

[CyreckX]

@GerardWayJr 1st i was just saying i would pay to see him when i madea mistake of spelling "true" wrong and u troll me over than and now ur telling me to go to 3rd grade? lmao Sorry but i dont and wont feed trolls, they are already fat and ugly... no use ^^

[GerardWayJr]

@CyreckX I'm not a troll, I just think you're an idiot.

[CyreckX]

@GerardWayJr Im a idiot for supporting one talented youtuber? lol looks who's the dumb one now

[GerardWayJr]

@CyreckX Sorry, I don't speak imbecile.

[CyreckX]

@GerardWayJr You dont speak that but u speak troll now stfu ^^

[cuakevinlex]

@GerardWayJr your an ass...

[korea0626]

@xXShaYnXx you have to remember that most of the time this whole shit is arranged...:/

[TheSirlagalot]

@xXShaYnXx Honestly, I would agree with the judges. Sorry to say this man. I mean the real song was more upbeat. To bring it slower, He had to add more powerful vocals but he didn't. Also, the fact that they said that meant that they were actually complementing him. They expected more cause the know he's just that awesome. Just my 2 cents.

[hakutheicedemon]

he isnt the best singer any ways not even close in fact he was one of the worst but what he does is change a song this song forever cant buy me love was fantastic and hound dog was good 2 but other contestants were getting to good like lee and crystal after staright up he was a condtender then he became a under dog though he shouldnt have been eliminated all because of that boring as shit micheal lynche i really hate that guy waste of the save

[bobnos]

THIS IS TEN TIMES BETTER THEN STRAIT UP!.. judges dont know nothing..

they think he went downhill since strait up in hyollywood week... this song in acoustic version is amazing..

the judges really need to wake up

[livelearnlaughandluv]

i was sooo mad when he got voted off..hes amazing! like the best one this season... DD: team andrew. :]

[nellzmpinay49]

i cant believe he's gone.... he deserved to win. this show is bullshit

[adgjmptw4]

lol @ simons facepalm

[lhenmanalo1]

crazy judges how can you let someone as talented as ANDREW ... omg you lost one great talent ...

[THEEBIqqESTNerd18]

FUCK PEOPLEzz andrew garcia freakinqq rox nd deserved to win..

[coverbydesign]

Umm fob has played that song acoustic god knows how many times