skip to 3:18... probably designed like that, but the little flair that she puts on the end of her solo to as an exclamation and it syncs perfectly with the pick ups from the guitar. absolutely brilliant!
the only reason i listen to new nightwish is that Thoumas write great songs...and Emppu ...is still the best guitarist !!! i love Emppu!!!...But now i`m a real fan of TARJA <3...she write great songs 2 ...but imagine how would be if Thoumas would write songs and Tarja would sing them ^^...ahhh sweet dreams ! T.T
Me encanta este tema,por mucho que Anette lo intente...y es ahí donde realmente reside la grandeza de los antiguos temas de Nightwish,por que solo Tarja,y solamente ella,los puede interpretar.
wmg sucks theyre such jerks. i've met tuomas on numorous occasions i should so record him saying "i give everybody on youtube permission to use our songs in any way to promote our band and make their own videos featuring one of our songs as long as theyre not trying to make a prophet" and they dont own nightwish anyways. nuclear blast, and roadrunner own them. and lord knows tuomas would do it cus hes the man, then i could rub that in stupid youtube and wmg's face.
Annette's doing good with Nightwish. I have nothing against Annette's voice. I just like Tarja's better because she's more opera-metal, and that's more my style.
Great song, btw. This has to be my second-favorite. :]
They're both great singers, but Tarja has a sound that sticks out more in the modern metal landscape. Her voice also suited Tuomas' compositions much more than Anette. That said, they work well with her and it sounds great.
I think the best combination woul dbe nightwish,evanescence, and within temptation. If they did a song together hat sound somewhat like this that would be amazing!! Sharon, Tarja, and Amy lee would be great together bt sadly Anette makes the band a little suckish now. :(
and if you think that now anette sings this song..and i don't like it anymore...i love this one with tarja as many other songs.. tarja rocks..nw rocks
sorry don't know english hay un video de zlatan ibrahimovic(futbolista) en ares y dale esta cancion y luego sale otra parecida quiero saber si alguien la a escuchado que mediga que se llama la cancion el video dura aproximadamente 29 minutes
taaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaarrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrjjjjjjjjjjjjjjaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa help nightwish anette is horrible!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I miss her somehow. I don't know what she was really like offstage, nor will I claim to... but here she is so haunting and enchanting. I only know her dismissal marks the end of a combination that will be sorely missed. I wish Tarja and the new Nightwish all the best.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
As much as I miss the tone Tarja's operatic voice brought to Nightwish, I am very glad she is gone... she wasn't very nice to the fans, and Nightwish is still Nightwish; still symphonic metal, as we see in Poet and the Pendulum... for everyone who says that it's not, just remember: Tuomas started out with the idea of 'Acoustic Campfire music', not metal.
"I am very glad she is gone... she wasn't very nice to the fans, and Nightwish is still Nightwish"
Uh huh. Perhaps you can fill us in on how "she wasn't very nice to the fans". Or perhaps you're just another one of Anette's family members making shit up on YouTube.
Are you? Tarja has always been sweet and extremely friendly with the fans, anybody that says differently is being dishonest and is just trying to justify her dismissal by making shit up about her.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I hate how they got rid of Tarja...I wish she was still with Nightwish, but we all know that Tumas strives for the media...how he wants attention from the public...he doesn't want to be underground anymore, the child in him hungers for popularity. And with annette...thats what he gets. Tarja, is doing very well on her own, I'm pleased to say. =]
Anette will destroy Nightwish, weather people who love her believe it or not.
"you clearly have never read the open letter to tarja. Or else you wouldn't have said that (and she never denied a word of that letter)"
You clearly have never tried to read Tarja's rebuttal to that "open letter", the device used to fire her from the band as soon as they walked off the stage of this very concert.
You should never believe everything you read on the Internet, especially a vindictive letter designed to hurt its target as much as possible.
I have read them, analyzed them both, read Marcelos version of the events. And after analizing other sources as well, I came to the conclusion that Tuomases version of the events seems much more realistic and accurate.
Out of interest, why did they get rid of Tarja?? And what's Anette like then? I've only heard a couple of songs by Nightwish (all still with Tarja, presumably the girl singing in the vid!) and I've liked most of them so far. This one is really haunting and lovely!
Ok then why then did Tarja cancel shows because they're too small then the after shes gone decide to play at Slims in San Fran a place where you would be hard pressed to fit 300 people inside? Yeah he really wants public attention.
OMG!! Their Music With Tarja Was So Amazing!Especially Her Voice Made Tuomas Music Even More Fantastic..Now Anette (i Do NOT Dislike Her) Made Nightwish Sound Like A Simple Common Band..Only Tuomas mUSIC is still Good...Tarja Can Save Nightwish Not Anette,Make Her Sing Nemo,Ever Dream,Wishmaster Or Whatever She Cannot Sing THem Like Tarja.Tarja Is THe Icon And Flesh Of Nightwish Toumas Is THe Soul....
bloody brilliant. nightwish = legendary :D i dont dislike annette, but personally, when one of their older songs like this is put up against amaranth...well, there just is no comparision :)
Amaranth is not the symbol for the album. That was The Poet and the Pendulum (widley regarded as their best song). Amaranth was supposed to be a light single and was added to the main album because band prefference, not a "lets stick it to the fans" ideal. But to do the other side... Anette CANNOT sing Tarja's songs, nor will she. Anette sings NIGHTWISH's songs, not My Winter Storm's songs. Tarja had no part in the composition whatsoever, so how can people call then Tarja's songs?
yeah! I AGREE 100%! They ought to change their name. I mean, just watching them on stage LIVE now, it's just ridiculous. With Tarja they had CLASS!! Now it's freaking karaoke!
I Love Tarja:* <3
darkqart 1 year ago
skip to 3:18... probably designed like that, but the little flair that she puts on the end of her solo to as an exclamation and it syncs perfectly with the pick ups from the guitar. absolutely brilliant!
headslo 1 year ago 2
the only reason i listen to new nightwish is that Thoumas write great songs...and Emppu ...is still the best guitarist !!! i love Emppu!!!...But now i`m a real fan of TARJA <3...she write great songs 2 ...but imagine how would be if Thoumas would write songs and Tarja would sing them ^^...ahhh sweet dreams ! T.T
fantasyfair2009 1 year ago
Me encanta este tema,por mucho que Anette lo intente...y es ahí donde realmente reside la grandeza de los antiguos temas de Nightwish,por que solo Tarja,y solamente ella,los puede interpretar.
Arkangel290884 1 year ago
Comment removed
Arkangel290884 2 years ago
que el mar tiemble bajo la voz de tarja con esta cancion
cristian15fonseca 2 years ago
wmg sucks theyre such jerks. i've met tuomas on numorous occasions i should so record him saying "i give everybody on youtube permission to use our songs in any way to promote our band and make their own videos featuring one of our songs as long as theyre not trying to make a prophet" and they dont own nightwish anyways. nuclear blast, and roadrunner own them. and lord knows tuomas would do it cus hes the man, then i could rub that in stupid youtube and wmg's face.
unitard08 2 years ago
Shut it!
OceanbornOceansoul 2 years ago
*bends over* kiss it and have a blessed day :)
unitard08 2 years ago
How come nobody ever mentions Emppu? Hes the fuckin man.
CryPTiC889 2 years ago 4
Tarja > Anette Simple mathmatics.
Kyomaaa 2 years ago 3
A Nightwish video with a Tarja vs Anette debate going on in the comments? That's something you don't see everyday.
... Unless you watch at least one Nightwish video everyday.
nikkiduv 2 years ago 5
Annette's doing good with Nightwish. I have nothing against Annette's voice. I just like Tarja's better because she's more opera-metal, and that's more my style.
Great song, btw. This has to be my second-favorite. :]
kirel8913 2 years ago 2
They're both great singers, but Tarja has a sound that sticks out more in the modern metal landscape. Her voice also suited Tuomas' compositions much more than Anette. That said, they work well with her and it sounds great.
VastFarFlung 2 years ago 2
I think the best combination woul dbe nightwish,evanescence, and within temptation. If they did a song together hat sound somewhat like this that would be amazing!! Sharon, Tarja, and Amy lee would be great together bt sadly Anette makes the band a little suckish now. :(
kewlemogirl 2 years ago 4
Lol, I don't agree on the Amy Lee part. No offense to her.
UihaAkiko12 2 years ago
Now... Nightwish is not a metal band... Anette made them pop music. -.-"
HealerLaundri 2 years ago
nightwish will always be symphonic metal. after all there are plenty of symphonic metal bands without operatic singers.
unitard08 2 years ago
i see what people mean about Annette and Tarja both are good but i think Tarja is some-what better.
EmilieAutumnGal18 2 years ago
annette just needs to stay away from the original nightwish songs and stick with the songs that are more to her genre of singing, like pop lmfao
Lichbane1 2 years ago
i think she's doing very well with the older songs recently o.o
Nelli915 2 years ago
is this song on an album ?
DisturbedHurrican 2 years ago
yes
ADOBARD90 2 years ago
Once.
VastFarFlung 2 years ago
3:03 - 3:19 my favorite part
DaRkSymphoniCa 2 years ago 3
then you have to be gay
waterfallman92 2 years ago
huh??
DaRkSymphoniCa 2 years ago
I agree!! That's like the best part of the song!!
kewlemogirl 2 years ago
and if you think that now anette sings this song..and i don't like it anymore...i love this one with tarja as many other songs.. tarja rocks..nw rocks
diana17rock 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
She is the one who wanted to leave them..
my oponion is that she has a nice voice but she is acting like an idiot on stage....
anathema999 2 years ago
how could they let tarja go..ILL MISS HER 4VER
arachanox01 2 years ago 2
Tarja rules! awesome song!
darklyzard 2 years ago 4
its kinda scaryy!!
qaisarkhanqaisarkhan 2 years ago
Most definitely my favoritest Nightwish song ever.
I love his face in 0:42
<3 <3
hiddenxleafxninja 2 years ago 5
Tarja - you are the woman of my life but you don't know that yet:)
pticanagrani 2 years ago 8
sorry don't know english hay un video de zlatan ibrahimovic(futbolista) en ares y dale esta cancion y luego sale otra parecida quiero saber si alguien la a escuchado que mediga que se llama la cancion el video dura aproximadamente 29 minutes
gunsnrosesftorres 2 years ago
u mean the pianist tuomas let tarja go.
mozzarvice1995 2 years ago 4
deff one of my favorite songs
they are one of the few bands who are pretty much just as good live
hiddenxleafxninja 2 years ago 3
i love this song i haven't heard it in so long omg just luv everything about them
KirBii143 2 years ago 2
Simply amazing. Probably my favourite song by Nightwish.
SoulOfFrozenFire 2 years ago 3
super!
depechehim 3 years ago 3
Suuuuuuuuuuch a perfect song! And a perfect voice! Love them!
Nightwisher1980 3 years ago
this is the most amazing song i cant believe that marco let tarja go she is bewitching
puregraceprincess 3 years ago
what do you mean marco let tarja go
dnanything 3 years ago
sorry i got confused with names
puregraceprincess 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
marco sucks
MasterStelik 3 years ago
She is really haunting and enchanting, but she has beautifull voice.
Lucy187677 3 years ago 3
This is such a great song.
good band members.
hot singer.
and most of all kick ass songs.
gannandork0 3 years ago 5
taaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaarrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrjjjjjjjjjjjjjjaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa help nightwish anette is horrible!!!!!!!!!!!!!
guerreiroinfante2001 3 years ago 5
I miss her somehow. I don't know what she was really like offstage, nor will I claim to... but here she is so haunting and enchanting. I only know her dismissal marks the end of a combination that will be sorely missed. I wish Tarja and the new Nightwish all the best.
KeikaStrife 3 years ago 6
Tarja is one amazing woman. She's beautiful, has an amazing voice, and most of all, she's humble. That's about as perfect as you can get.
ironhardt 3 years ago
i love this song <3
LichKingJh 3 years ago 6
Marco = God
olliethefisherman 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
As much as I miss the tone Tarja's operatic voice brought to Nightwish, I am very glad she is gone... she wasn't very nice to the fans, and Nightwish is still Nightwish; still symphonic metal, as we see in Poet and the Pendulum... for everyone who says that it's not, just remember: Tuomas started out with the idea of 'Acoustic Campfire music', not metal.
TrespasserChic 3 years ago
"I am very glad she is gone... she wasn't very nice to the fans, and Nightwish is still Nightwish"
Uh huh. Perhaps you can fill us in on how "she wasn't very nice to the fans". Or perhaps you're just another one of Anette's family members making shit up on YouTube.
justanamehere 3 years ago 7
Paranoia much?
Lilpep1221 3 years ago
Are you? Tarja has always been sweet and extremely friendly with the fans, anybody that says differently is being dishonest and is just trying to justify her dismissal by making shit up about her.
justanamehere 3 years ago 3
Tarja era genial!!!!
es la mejor...
Pero Anette tambien canta
super bien
lMayral 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I hate how they got rid of Tarja...I wish she was still with Nightwish, but we all know that Tumas strives for the media...how he wants attention from the public...he doesn't want to be underground anymore, the child in him hungers for popularity. And with annette...thats what he gets. Tarja, is doing very well on her own, I'm pleased to say. =]
Anette will destroy Nightwish, weather people who love her believe it or not.
GloomDoll 4 years ago
errmm firstly... nightwish has always been really famous and has sold lots of platinum discs on many countries.
Secondly you clearly have never read the open letter to tarja. Or else you wouldn't have said that (and she never denied a word of that letter)
thirdly, nightwish is now on the top of charts in many countries
Felinestance 4 years ago 3
"you clearly have never read the open letter to tarja. Or else you wouldn't have said that (and she never denied a word of that letter)"
You clearly have never tried to read Tarja's rebuttal to that "open letter", the device used to fire her from the band as soon as they walked off the stage of this very concert.
You should never believe everything you read on the Internet, especially a vindictive letter designed to hurt its target as much as possible.
justanamehere 4 years ago
I have read them, analyzed them both, read Marcelos version of the events. And after analizing other sources as well, I came to the conclusion that Tuomases version of the events seems much more realistic and accurate.
Felinestance 4 years ago 3
Out of interest, why did they get rid of Tarja?? And what's Anette like then? I've only heard a couple of songs by Nightwish (all still with Tarja, presumably the girl singing in the vid!) and I've liked most of them so far. This one is really haunting and lovely!
cccrsc 3 years ago 2
Ok then why then did Tarja cancel shows because they're too small then the after shes gone decide to play at Slims in San Fran a place where you would be hard pressed to fit 300 people inside? Yeah he really wants public attention.
Oceansoul343 3 years ago
OMG!! Their Music With Tarja Was So Amazing!Especially Her Voice Made Tuomas Music Even More Fantastic..Now Anette (i Do NOT Dislike Her) Made Nightwish Sound Like A Simple Common Band..Only Tuomas mUSIC is still Good...Tarja Can Save Nightwish Not Anette,Make Her Sing Nemo,Ever Dream,Wishmaster Or Whatever She Cannot Sing THem Like Tarja.Tarja Is THe Icon And Flesh Of Nightwish Toumas Is THe Soul....
DarkLady131415 4 years ago 4
I get triple goosebumps listening to this!
niamaztor 4 years ago 2
I love this song..
AngelOfTranquil 4 years ago 10
bloody brilliant. nightwish = legendary :D i dont dislike annette, but personally, when one of their older songs like this is put up against amaranth...well, there just is no comparision :)
RideEmCowgirl123 4 years ago 17
Amaranth is not the symbol for the album. That was The Poet and the Pendulum (widley regarded as their best song). Amaranth was supposed to be a light single and was added to the main album because band prefference, not a "lets stick it to the fans" ideal. But to do the other side... Anette CANNOT sing Tarja's songs, nor will she. Anette sings NIGHTWISH's songs, not My Winter Storm's songs. Tarja had no part in the composition whatsoever, so how can people call then Tarja's songs?
shadoworacle44 3 years ago 4
"Tarja had no part in the composition whatsoever, so how can people call then Tarja's songs? "
Tarja made the songs what they became by deciding how they would be sung. Her voice made them unique, and very hard to mimic by another singer.
She may not have written the sheet music or the lyrics, but she certainly had a role in what the songs evolved into.
justanamehere 3 years ago 4
la voz de tarja luce tanto o mas que la de los aneles
kngrejito 4 years ago
I LOVE this song. It's so epic. It makes my imagination fly.
Rafoliv 4 years ago 6
After hearing "Nightwish 2007" crap videos, then listening to this, this is like a breath of fresh air.
It's like listening to a lame half-assed cover band, then seeing the real thing, and this IS the real thing.
Nightwish with Tarja was an EXCELLENT band, and had powerful music that touched the soul.
Nightwish with Anette sounds like a cheap nightclub act at best, that hurts the ears and bores the mind.
justanamehere 4 years ago 6
They used to be Nightwish, but now they are Nightmare....
gojyo666 4 years ago 5
shut up all of you!!! you make me sick .....
nibelungaia 4 years ago 6
Please... explain why, nibelungaia...
theverybestfan 4 years ago
yeah! I AGREE 100%! They ought to change their name. I mean, just watching them on stage LIVE now, it's just ridiculous. With Tarja they had CLASS!! Now it's freaking karaoke!
niamaztor 4 years ago 7
Nightwish is Tuomas' band, not Tarja's.
He's a f***ing GENIUS, Tarja is just a hell of a interpreter. I still wish she comes back.
Rafoliv 3 years ago 3
There is no other voice as Tarja's!!! She Rules, Anette won't sing not even close to how Tarja does.
gemitalandaverde 4 years ago 3
indeed
azrael5022006 4 years ago
I love this song!
lumierenocturne 4 years ago 6