Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (298)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Yari Cav's charges look amazing

  • "oh look just some guys"

    loads of huys come over hill

    "OH NO!"

  • the last samurai anybody?

  • Your voice always give me headache especially when I watch your videos at late night. Good commentary though

  • I can see his general on his chair with his jaw hanging past his mask because his army fell like a monopod

  • dude, how long did it take you to learn all that shit

  • @z4ravager

    You must love Poopie so much since you say it every time you comment,

  • Truthfully idk who is better PrinceofMacedon or HeirofCarthage they would both beat me so I can't criticize either player.

  • I rate this poopie video 1000000 points down here I show u 000000000000000000000000000000­00000000000 I would do more but I'm tired

  • U ppl have poopie for brains ,heir of Carthage already went against prince of macedon and horribly failed.

  • That montage at the end was awesome...

    Truly displays what the graphical preformance can do in this game.

  • I am going to buy this ...this coming weekend.....epic music

  • Hey HeirOfCarthage, just wondering, have you ever faced the PrinceOfMacedon, in either S2TW, or RTW? and if so, what did you think of him as an opponent?

  • How good are hero units in Shogun 2? The Kensei/sword saint in old Shogun could potentially stand up against a unit of low- to mid-grade melee troops. They were independent units, but I prefered using them in support of other assault formations.

  • getting a total war game which should i get/better this or empire anyone

  • @rossglennie shogun 2 is better all around empire sucks

  • Very Nice! Esspecially THE last part!

  • very good cinematic view. It kinds reminds me of the one scene from "We Were Soldiers". when the photographer Galloway drops his gun takes his camera and started shooting pictures. well done indeed.

    maybe its a good idea to make short cinematics like this before each battle.

  • @Ukkepuk123 and maybe makes, if done right, 2 seperate points of views over eacgh other a great effect

  • next time ur doing a cinematic u can put the black movie bars at the top and bottom of the screen so no one sees your steam messages and cursor moving at the game speed bar.

  • whats the name of the cinematic music ?

  • Commentaries are for people who can't figure stuff out. This is why the people who don't make it to the Top 100 1v1 Page will always complain. I know, it sucks to be the bottom 99,900 out of 100,000 players.

  • Music is better for cinematic videos.

  • really nice video heir. i loved the cinematics you should do those more often

  • Heir 1 thing i think you should mention is the morale shock when your OWN matchlocks are shooting near your men. Loan swords especially will rout near the general but samurai suffer too. All that missle fire at the rear demorlizes them.

  • Heir do you believe it is possible/playable to have naginata monks as a core for your army because ever since the nerf on them I have found its very hard to win with a nag monk core and i just dont see nag monks used as a core anymore its more often what you use which is a samurai nag core. So do you believe that monk nag cores are dead?

  • Awesome highlights!

  • Heir, another great video! Please do not stop posting them. By the way, love the ending. Out of curiosity, who is the artist and the name of the song at the end. Thank you!

  • Great battle, great cinematics, great commentary and a great commentator :) Oh, and the music was epic! What's the song called? :)

  • just a tip for the sony vegas cinematic thing. you can shrink the edges of the screen in editing ever so slightly which gets rid of the time bar and the some of the other stuff in the left hand corner. It makes it look really professional and nice. Still great cinematic.

  • 17:02 That charge into enemy fire make me think about "The last Samurai"... Very nice videos ever since I happened to bump into one of your Rome videos. Good fortune to you ^_^

  • I was a long-time youtube friend and subscribers to PoM, last night I unsubbbed and unfriended him. His videos aren't as good as Heir's, his jokes are really bad, and he's been acting like an asshole to his viewers lately.

  • patchys toothpicks

    

  • i like poms videos and i watch all of his uploads, i thinks hes a very good player, but hes an asswhole with people, unlike heir,

    pdt: heir time for some napoleon and rome total war

  • @HeirOfCarthage The view count bug is somthing that is affecting everyone. Most videos view counts stay at around 300. Belive me, more then that number of people are watching, don't get discouraged.

  • Pom doesnt like be bothered lol he's awesome

  • Comment removed

  • HoC vs PoM ! :D

  • @komedicentralen I'd love to see that. HoC FTW!

  • @banditblade4 YEAH ! :D

  • @komedicentralen Id be cheering for HoC he is a much better guy and commentator, plus HoC has alot more experience on shogun 2 than PoM does. So i think HoC would easily win

  • @xTakenotesx16 Yeah, I like HoC better, but PoM would be a good opponent as well, but it would be really fun to watch that :)

    Or maybe HoC vs DiplexHeatedHD ? :)

  • @komedicentralen PoM already fought HoC. It was a slaughter.

  • @SolarKnight88 can you link the video ?

  • @SolarKnight88 where can i see the video? Did heir upload it?

  • Your opponent's army is very scary =()

  • wait, i thought Patchy was Polish?

  • shogun 2 is beautiful....

  • great cinematics just showcases how beautiful the style and graphics of this game are. cant praise this game enough.

  • What is up with the view count on this video? It stayed on 302 for a day or more and then it says only 2,569 now? This video has more comments and likes than my last few videos, so I would think it has more views? Anyone have any insight into this? Or did I just make a video no one wants to watch? :)

  • @HeirofCarthage its just a youtube glitch for some reason the number of viewers is precise atm saw a video of one of my favorite commentators(other than you) that had 5000 likes and only 206 views it was weird and the comments were full of "wait what?" it takes a while before a video actully shows the amount of views it actually has so its not you making bad videos it youtube fault. And name the naginata Nagy Pathcys

  • @Commentor1010 is is suppose to be isnt

  • @HeirofCarthage

    Youtube automatically updates the views until about 300 views, then due to keep lag down and processing speed up the views only get updated, every hour, or day.

  • @HeirofCarthage well you showed epicness in this vid like all your other ones

  • @HeirofCarthage

    youtube has had a bug that it freezes at around 300 but will go back to what views you got after a bit

    love you vids keep at it

  • @HeirofCarthage I think the view counts don't update in real time. This is why sometimes you have more likes than views (They update more often).

  • heir i think you should leave the sound effects in the cinematics. having the melee sounds and the music at the same time would be excellent.

    thanks!!

  • Heir of carthage for the win : )

  • I just sent prince of macedon a message saying, i enjoy your new video's but i think you would be better off bringing more total war commenterys out. He took this to offence so i apologised this is how he replied.... Prince of macedon

    Furthermore, I STILL SHOW TOTAL WAR VIDEOS. Are you this fucking hard-headed that you can't see that???

    Your head is SO FAR UP YOUR OWN ASS that you can't see that I'm doing this for my viewers. You fucking conceited asshole

  • @xTakenotesx16 PoM has issues for sure. He can't take the slightest critisicm or questioning. He's a hypocrite through and through. A real phony. HoC is the real deal, nice guy and not afraid to admit his losses :)

  • @NearDark87 Thank you for the support, PoM needs to know that people are upset with him

  • @xTakenotesx16 I second the motion

  • @xTakenotesx16 I'm not upset with PoM. I like PoM's style, and also HoC's style. I think they both have their reasons to making TW videos and they both make videos about other games too. The only reason I see people getting upset is that PoM refuses to adhere to demands of people who don't pay him to do so. As long as he doesn't get paid, he has every right to do videos about playing Ping Pong if he wishes it. And he hasn't even stopped to make TW videos. So what's the problem?

  • @GeminiK , anyone with decent person. would be able to take advice and constructive critsism on the chin, but not PoM. For example if you comment on PoM when he makes a tactical mistake he will ban you for critisism. Tell me without critisism how can you get better. Heir Of Carthage on the otherhand can take constructive critisism and use this to become a better player. That is the difference Heir Of Carthage is a well mannered good peson, while Prince is a douche.

  • @xTakenotesx16 I don't recall PoM getting mad about constructive criticism. He does get mad if he thinks your criticisms are erroneous, which for what I've seen he is right about, or if you make an ignorant comment.

    HoC is very well mannered, and I like his even tone :). It doesn't mean he has to tolerate ignorant comments or rude ones, but from what I've seen he does. Aside from that, the videos is what I'm subscribed to both of them for.

  • @GeminiKI don't mean critisism as insults, i mean useful critsism what can help you improve your channel. I do not agree with insulting or being ignorant but i do believe that some critisism can help you. But heair of carthage is a great man, and he listens to advice and uses it to become a better player

  • @xTakenotesx16 Listening to reasoned criticisms is good, but anyone has the right to disagree. It's not right to get mad over what one does on their channel, despite how wrong someone may think they are. One should simply unsubscribe if they dislike the content. Additionally, it just may be that the criticism, although well intentioned, are invalid or counter to the interests of the content provider.

    PoM may not be right all the time, but he does have logic, and expects you to have it too.

  • @GeminiK My logic is perfectly fine in this scenario, and i agree with you if you don't like it unsubscribe, But more people who unsubscribe the less views PoM has. I was just giving him advice on what video's to put up because i care about his channel. If PoM won't take my advice well thats fine, but when he outright insults me then that is unreasonable

  • @xTakenotesx16 Well, I don't know what the whole dialogue between you two was, so I can't make a judgment on your logic or PoM's (Generally PoM seems sound to me). Also, it does seem like PoM doesn't care too much about the number of views he gets. He seems to take the stance that there will mostly always be people watching his videos, disregarding their wishes. Of course, it's adversarial to those who wish him to do a particular thing.

    It's ok to suggest, it just can't sound like a demand.

  • @GeminiK Well it was a suggestion, i never demand. The fact is PoM probaly was in a bad mood and i got on the wrong side of him. Thankyou for your calm and well written response

  • @xTakenotesx16 You're full of shit. You're the guy who said he should upload Total War videos to garner more viewers. Correct me if I'm wrong, but he already uploads Total War videos.

  • @SolarKnight88 Hold on i said the majority of his audience enjoy total war videos, and i was just worried about the lack of total war videos lately. I didn't say he had no total war videos. Plus what he sent me is true i apoligised to him and he sent me this.

  • @xTakenotesx16 I didn't make the insults up that is really what he sent me, i was just concerned about his channel, fuck so now a subscriber cant even do that?. I didn't force him to do anything i was just giving advice. I apoligise if you took this the wrong way

  • @xTakenotesx16 It's unfortunate if he took your suggestion as rude. I guess you are right about him being in a bad mood; the ton of guys who were rudely demanding could have made him suspicious of your intentions.

  • @GeminiK Yeh i think people have been giving him a hard time and when i came along he just flipped and took it out on me

  • @xTakenotesx16 Basically that same thing happened to me a couple days ago with him.

    I've literally never seen such a persnickitey faggot. Honestly.

  • @SOLANUM992 PoM is egostic just take no notice of him, if he wants to lose subs well thats his loss. We have HeirOfCarthage : )

  • Comment removed

  • @xTakenotesx16

    says who?

  • @xTakenotesx16 i doubt he responded that way but he gets alot of people asking if he still does total war videos even though he keeps broadcasting it on his videos..i assume that would get very irratating just like when people tell Heir he is a noob and all that trolling going on

  • @xTakenotesx16 WOAH. Unsubbed!

  • @xTakenotesx16 Lol yea, he raged like a retard at me for asking him if some1 ever beat him and if he could put it on youtube. I really like his vids but he is a douch and i had to unsub.

  • 19:08 was prolly my favorite part but I feel like you have potential for even greater extrapolation of battle footage... good lick Heir, your expectations have just been raised.

  • Do spear retainers count for naginata troops? Always been curious about that.

  • Heir: If you want your cinematic clips look really amazing, try the "cropping" function on Sony Vegas to cut out the rest of the battle interface, so that it looks like a real movie.

  • You are now my favourite total war commentator. Also i just wanted to add i think you deserve alot more views, I hope you get more subscriptions : ) I don't know what has happend to prince of macedon, he is now making chess video's??? at least you are staying true to the total war franchise. Thank you!!!!

  • @xTakenotesx16 soo true

  • @xTakenotesx16 not to mention POM has kinda turned into a dick, like when ppl ask questions, etc.

  • @Kelplings yea he is. i just said something about flanking to him one day and he came on my channle and cussed me out and blocked me

  • @Kelplings a big dick! hes an idiot... when i first started watching pom him he was awesome :) but now heirofcarthage is my fav :) i mean really he was a different person but now... i also liked him because hes names is prince of macedon ( and i am from Macedonia ) but now that doesnt matter any more!

  • @Kelplings In all of PoM's video comments that I have seen he's always been like that. He didn't turn like anything.

  • @xTakenotesx16 well, at one point PoM was one one of the best commentators, before HoC, peul230688 and synoptic became well known. seeing this may have natured his arogance and ignorance, which made him believe that he can put unbreakalbe laws and rules, undoubtable facts, and prevented him from accepting any other point of views but his own.

    its unplesant to see this happenning to once a great commentator.

  • name front line ashigaru throw-away units japanese interns

  • Name a Vet Bi-Winning! haha :P

  • you should name them, "whitty veteran name" haha

  • really good cinematics, need to crop out that mouse and menu buttons though, i love using sony vegas =)

  • Slice & Dice

  • Call them Patchy's Chosen

  • The Patchinators

  • Naginata name:

    Sticks and knives

    "ours" have blades

    We have blades on "them"

    "ours" and "them" -> you know what I mean ;)

  • amazing cinematic :D great job

  • Dont think the cinematics are worth the time heir

  • Absolutely fantastic cinematic at the end i want to see more of those! Loved when the cavalry charged your opponents troops and you see the loans swords rout past the camera..one holding his wounds.

  • naginata samurai is a very cost effective unit. I focus mainly on their defence and moral just so they stay longer. and they are superb at most melee units they hold very long specialy with support from matchlocks. used them for over 2 month.

    anyway heir use guard mode on all units. as you get more mobility and the chance to inflict more dmg to other untis with the same unit :)

    with it on a freash matchlock unit can beat any 1cav unit in melee as all not in melee uses there matchlocks hhehe

  • OMG IF I DONT GET A DAILY DOSE OF HEIROFCARTHAGE VIDEOS I WILL DIE. HEIR DONT LET ME DIE PLS I KNOW YOU LOVE US AND WE LOVE YOU :DDDDDD

  • That cinematic was amazing, I'd love to see more of it!

  • Hey heir when you would use nuns here is a good name.we are the EX from patchy!.Lol

  • naginata samurai name: rock and a pointy place

  • Your cinematic shows how chaotic a real life battle can be

  • imagine if you had a fair amount of katana cav heir

  • i think heir's opponent did a poor micro on his army.great cinematic though

  • My idea for the naginata unit is "Stonwall Patchies" because of their armor. Not sure if it's all that great, but there's my two cents.

  • Extremely cool cinematic and match. You should name your naginata veterans something that alludes to how they are an in between unit. Not quite swords or spears. "Swings both ways", "Arthur or Martha", "bi-sexual", "class confused"?

    I'm sure someone creative can think of a good one.

  • @MrLusciousmeat swing both ways is great lol. 

  • great work on the cinematic

  • use some other heroes pls:)

  • Name them Patches Pals! thumbs up so he sees it

  • this is one of heir's best vid's so far (only second to the battle of many frances in my opinion), such great vid deserves more than 10000 views, such pitty to see its number of views so far.

    great vids as allways, honored and proud to be one of your subscribers.

    Viva heir of carthage.

  • I prefer the replay commentaries. Looks way cooler and it gives you more time to explain whats happening since you aren't concentrating on controlling the army.

  • Wow one of the nicest vids iv seen from you

  • dude your getting really good at editing.

  • Heartshaped Snowflake at 16:19 thumbs up for Heir!

  • Pause at 17:30. The enemy katana infantry are peeing.

  • incredible cinematic video at the end...good luck ...it was beautiful

  • Two simple tips for generals.

    Keep a cool head at all times.

    Embrace and Unleash Chaos.

  • Great cinematic at the end

  • sweeeeeeet

  • Don't mind the cinematics, but would hate to see them used as filler for shorter battles or lack of anything to say.

  • god I hate stand and fight. Every opponent tht does it I either have to out slug him or try a braindead suicide charge with my melee general. Chances of sucess usually 50/50.

    Can anyone give me some ideas on how to kill them? (that dont involve mass volleys of matchlock fire)

  • part at the end was gud wiv the shots and the music and can u do 1st person more often as well

  • The cinematic highlights at the end are a really great addition, well done heir!

  • that was epic, i totally forgot that this was a game and not a movie

  • Damn You're good at using your army And you fought an army that is bigger by your army by twice the size!!

  • what happened to campaign still good vid

  • Comment removed

  • I'm digging the cinematic highlight reel. That would make an excellent regular feature. Thanks for making these videos!

  • Yay Hero units thank you heir! Great video.

  • Your such a nice guy. Thanks for the videos! They're always awesome!

  • Great Video! Keep Them Coming! :D

    Heir, have you ever watched "Deadliest Warrior"? Just wondering.

  • What was the song used i do shogun 2 vids and starcraft and i would like to use this kind of music

  • love your vid heir of carthage so good !

  • Hey guys, i am an up and coming video game commentator specializing in pc games. Check out my channel for shogun 2 total war commentaries! thank you

  • That was amazing!

  • classic pike and guns tactics.

  • cinematic highlight real was so epic. definitely enjoying you experimentation with Vegas 11 heir!

  • I never take too many loan swords now, they're good as middle line units but you want some nice vet sami on either flank and be sure your gen is always near them.

  • @corpral13 I never pack too many as well. All it takes is for your enemy to have either some matchlocks or warrior monks and with one good volley or battle cry, your morale drops. On the flip side, if you are a leadership general and rally and get into stand and fight, a loan sword army is a good idea. Fantastic attack stats, cheap and with the morale bonuses, you can actually stand and fight against better troops.

  • love the lone Man at 18:50 when he couter charges the green yari dudes

  • highlight reel made my day that much better. I'm starving but I had to finish appreciating this all the way to the end. Well played and well edited good sir.

  • Didn't know you had some ballet warrior monks in your army heir :P. 19:40 on the right side, two monks.

  • ure awesome, heir

  • *applauds*

  • epic as always Heir. Keep it up!

  • Wow. This is the best video yet. I just love the "war correspondent film" piece at the end of the video. It felt like a documentary with re-enacters. Very well done.

  • great vid you should use hero units more there great!!!

  • Hey Heir I have a better graphics card that you but when ever i put it on max graphics it lags more than it does for you...some one help me!!!!!1111

  • I hope you do more high reels like this in your future videos Heir. I love the graphics of this game, and your highlight reel, really show it off greatly

  • Awsome cinema! You got some very nice shots in there, like the one where the monks get charged from behind :). Keep it up!

  • Heir, Bow cav with one speed upgrade have the same speed regular yari cav if you dont know.

  • awesome video again man, love the cinematic thing, you should do that more often!

  • well the cinematic seems pretty awesome as it looks like as if you would be in a real battle with some views great job!

  • holy living crap heir, that was amazing! I felt like I was watching an actual battle! vids like this are why I started playing total war!

  • excellent vid heir as always. more cinemas in battles like this would be cool

  • the cav charge into the rear of the matchlock warrior monks was my fav part :P

  • What happened to youre Katana Hero?

  • Not to be negative, but I think the music choice for the cinema could have been better. For such a truly epic batter against overwhelming odds, I feel like a triumphant feel to it would have truly been better. I'm in no way saying this isn't a good video, because it really is amazing, but that's just my opinion on it. :)

  • That cinematic highlight clip was INCREDIBLE! You are amazing.

  • wow heir we got sony vegas at almost the same time i just got it yeseday

  • awesome video