Added: 5 years ago
From: shellymn
Views: 54,886
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (141)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Realy Bad!

  • I can make out the lyrics now.

    I hate that.

  • i find the older version more.. powerful, but this one isn't bad either

  • this versions higher than the new, both are good

  • Is there seriously someone who prefers this version over the older?

  • @DoomSparrow me for example ...

  • 2:10 death knight face :)

  • Marco fits the viking role in the video=)

  • Marco fits the viking role in the video=)

  • anette

  • anette olzon

  • I prefer the old version, when she sang the way she knows,not the way the media told her to do so...

  • Hey, where did my comment go? :D

  • I don't have anything against Anette..

    But this song is better suited for Tarja.

    One of my favorite slow songs of Nightwish by far! <3

  • la verdad siempre he dicho que la musica de nightwish es como para esenas de combate entre caballeros y todo eso pero estas esenas se me hacen como para ghost love score

    aun asi me gusta mas este video que el viejo

  • i like the new vocals to be honest, Her Voice is more epic lol

  • nice

  • Magnificent Song, VOICE and BAND, Tária is AWESOME, I prefer the other version, the other video clip, but anyway Ty for posting. They ARE DA BEST, well till A net :(( sorry people, but the Band doesn't have that misterious "side" Tária added.

  • Great Song, Great vioce, Great Band, I agree with soundlikeblue, Tária sings this song in different ways, I prefer the other video clip and the other "side" of her Magnificent VOICE. But this song is AWESOME.

  • Comment removed

  • slashes22, I reckon there were recorded some time apart, as Tarja's vocals are totally different on this version, somewhat more relaxed, and less "classical".

  • Gah, this is so horrible x.x

  • You're not right

  • Ok, you can call me stupid, but only if you explain to me what's the difference of the new version to the old one...

  • @slashes22 different singer, appart from that nothing has changed

  • Ona ma zupełnie inny głos, niż w wersji z 1999 roku O,o'

    Ale nie wydaje mi się, by to śpiewała Anette, jak wielu ludzi sądzi, mnie się wydaje, że to jest 2ga wersja piosenki, bardziejhm, operowa, chodź Tarja sama wsobi ma operowy głos, w 1 ver był bardziej.. głęboki? ten jest bardziej piskliwy? nie wiem jak to napisac^^'' Ale lubię je obydwie, nie wiem co macie do Anette x_x'

  • What?

  • aaaw, Emppu looks so sad :( :( at least he and Tuomas live lol

  • Well, Tária, you are not singing in the same key as the old version :(((, you are AMAZING, but here well just not so good as you usualy are, you look a bit sad. Anyway I love your voice ^-^

  • Last song Tarja recorded with Nightwish. Such clean vocals from her, too. Beautiful and this video is haunting as hell.

  • Tarja is the onlyone ho is the best

  • i prefer the old version but this is beautiful too ;) and the video is better then the old one, but music... only old Sleeping sun!

  • Best video (yay, and song :D) ever.. <3

  • Thanks for video !!

    Serena

  • she's my god!!!! :D hohooh

  • Elle est bien cette nouvelle version ^^

  • je je

  • i dont like anettes voices but tarjas voices is better beautiful

  • yeah... it has a different sound, but it is 100% tarja

  • this is tarja

  • This isn't recorded very well...

  • this is not tarja at all x) first verse it's anette. cause it's thin. its flat. its simply tarja^^

  • it sounds like anette singing

  • That's what I thought.

  • Tarja can make her voice sound in diferent ways, and it prooves that she controls her instrument and also that she has got creativity when doing different arrangements with different voice textures. You can notice that, not only in this version, when she does soft ligher vocals, and then operatic vocals again in some parts, But you can also notice this fact in other songs like: The Siren, or Bless the Child, among others.

    I really like Both versions of the song!

  • I made the same mistake.. Nightwish made a re-recording of this song.. But this is Tarja, because its to operetic to be Anette, not saying she sucks, but her vocals arent anyway near as high as Tarja's, they both rock.. not trying to start a war/argument, so dont go replying to my comment with Anette/Tarja wars please, that goes to all of you! thanks

  • Tarja sings this song in 2 diferent ways, being this one more soft and lighter, also a bit slower, and the other one more heavy on the vocals and a bit faster.

    I think Tuomas wanted to give something new to the song and a new video too, and Tarja made it giving multiple textures to her voice, notice that Operatic timbre is still there when she wants!

    She sings Live both ways (in my videos she sings like in the first version. After 2005 she usualy sings like in this version - see End of an Era)

  • i´ m cold on my back!!how beautyful

  • Absolutly beautiful:D

  • Is it me or is Tarja's voice sound different in this one than the older version or is thay just my ears

  • Jep, she sounds different.

  • it;s in a higher pitch that the older version, she always did say it was low.

  • Oh my God!!!It's so different!!!too high!!

  • yeah, marco is the viking

  • lol he does look like a viking!

  • If you go to Wikipedia, you'll see the reason behind this new version. It had to do with the letting go of Tarja.

  • this version feels kinda slow....

  • it should be^^

  • Tarja <3

  • Ay que bonitos

    jejejej

    pero la voz de Anette está de más

    XD!

  • me gusta mas la version viejita! pero tarja siempre sera la reina de el metal :D tarja eres la mjor!

  • tarja's voice is better for this song.

  • eww...anette really sucks

    seriously anette..this is just not your range

    i dont hate you, but i think u better stop singing tarja's song..really..its getting on my nerve

  • You do know this is Tarja singing, right?

  • just to make one thing clear:

    they are not tarjas songs, but tuomas'

    and he only lets Annete sing those songs, which he thinks, that match anettes voice (sry for my english, i bet you understand what i mean)

  • Why does her voice sound so ''thin'' compared to the other version?

  • She´s been practising, an opera singer is never done! There´s like 8 years between the versions and maybe she wanted to do it more like a pop song... I think she sounds perfect.

  • I love this video.

  • I just love this song. i heard its dedicated to the 1999 total eclipse of the sun. I missed it and its my lifetime abition to make the next one in 2090, this song means so much to me and is so beautiful. Tarja u are missed in nightwish!

  • I like this music to sing by Annette

  • this is a very pretty song.

    i like it

  • a sense of lord of the ring...

  • YES

  • I like the old version better, but they're both fantastic :D

  • If you ask me, the first version is better;)

    But Mamuza, you take the dress i want the lady :)

  • Gimmie the dress! D:

    I love it!

  • I love this song and the video was awsome!

  • i like this version. in this version her voice is better

  • like both but prefer the original version to this one. altough there aren't much differences...

  • the older version of this song is good, but i like this version much better.

  • When I heard this song is like it teletransports my spirit to the Cold mountains of norway... hahaha

    I love it

  • Wow!She's like a goddess!Love the song!Love Tarja!Love the video!

  • Tarja die schönste und geilste Frau der Welt mit der schönsten Oper-Stimme.auch wenn sie es hier eher mit normaler weicher stimme singt *Gg

    aber Oper ist ihr ding.. mach weiter so süsse Tarja. Ich liebe Dich!!!!!!

  • tarja`s voice is amazing and oviusly unic

  • Nightwish and medieval battles... how much better can it get!

  • So not, it is Tarjas voice

    How stupid are you? Every one can hear it's Tarja

  • Don't compare Tarja with Annette. It's not worth it... Tarja is way better.

  • Tarja!!!

    Anette makes for a pitiful singer. It's like having a ring with a diamond on it [old Nightwish], taking out the Diamond [Tarja] and putting in a piece of trash[Anette].

    It's just not the same.

  • I think it's tarja's voice.. just pay attention to the accent..

  • I agree. Especially at the key change - her voice is surprisingly restrained in this video, and that gives the song a much nicer sound overall.

  • that should be anettes voice?? xD OMFG XD AHHHHAAAHAHA XD

    nice joke xD

    anette cant hold a note !^^ she makes : ejajajajajajajaja!^^

  • no it's not, that was Tarja's voice in the new video, the old was more powerful

  • In old version her voice was more powerful. And the finnish accent was not so straight. So I like the old one more

  • EPIC

  • Guess who`s gonna eat VIP- dinner with Tarja on 26 May 800:pm in Malmo =)

    ME! ME! ME! ME! ME! ME! ME! ME!ME! ME! ME!

    Millan69

  • whoah i never saw this video before!

  • To me she seemed like she was a godess of death and she was sing to make the war stop.

  • Guys and girls don`t fight we all know that Tarja is the best singer on the symphonic metal ``market``. So what the heak her voice is divine. It`s my seeping song

  • tarjas voice sounds better than in the old vesion because it was a bit too overwhelming.

    but her voice in this version is absolutely beautiful

  • tarja looks adorable with that giant flag.. hehe

  • This version is a little boring...

  • i like this version better

  • like this version better.

    sounds better than her opera voice.

  • haven't checked this version before..the video is quite good but the song is so crappy,so fucked up.Tarja sounds soooo weak.what she brings in my mind is complete lack of talent,which is a shame for such an ethereal voice.

  • this isn't Tarja singing this, just to let everyone know.

  • I think you are right , and I do love Tária's voice.

  • i dont why but she just looks so much fucking hoter in this video for some reason

  • the old one is way better but this is still good

  • i love this version! ... emppu looks so hot, jeje!!

  • I love Nightwish but sincerely I was expecting something way better

  • I love the original so much!

  • I want her dress.

  • so soothing =)

  • I hate this version it sounds like shes trying to make it all 'poppy' sounding now ._. Her voice is so weak....

  • Why did they do this version? Its worse than the house remix! The original is far better.

  • Tarja's voice is weak... the old version i prefer is better. still good =D

  • yay..now more then just 1 person saved to fav :P

  • =P i still rate this 5/5 and its second song on my fav list...the first is the original sleeping sun =) but still messed up how they made this to try to kill the old version..but i still like her voice...both videos.. =D

  • Tarja's voice is so weak and crap on this, the old version was so much better.

  • i love both videos...

  • wtf is this?!?! new version sucks, old version rulez!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more